Actions

Work Header

Strange Alloys

Chapter 6: The Fig Garden

Notes:

I’m just gonna make this an author’s note because it’s entirely my fault for the confusion:

This chapter and the next chapter (Bilbo’s timeline, essentially) is still catching up with Kili’s timeline; this chapter occurs before Tauriel’s death.

Chapter Text

When Bilbo had put on his ring and slipped into the City, he thought he must have hit his head, got his spirit mixed up on its way out of his body, and accidentally gone straight to the undying realms.

He took off the ring and did his best to keep his hood up. In his experience, unless someone was talking right in his face, he could pass for a dwarven child. Especially if he kept moving and looked like he knew where he was going; people didn’t tend to stop you if you looked like you knew where you were going.

But it was hard to hide his face when there was so much to see. It was like something out of a story book. As he had approached the main gate of the city, the forest had opened up into a huge avenue of trees, wide enough for more than twenty elves to ride abreast. On either side, selected trees had been left standing and trimmed until their trunks were like the columns of an ancient temple rising so high that birds flying between their topmost twigs looked like tiny specks. Although Bilbo had never been into one of the ancient halls of the great dwarf lords, he’d seen drawings and read descriptions in books, and there was no doubt that this welcoming esplanade in front of the city was modelled on those ancient, underground halls, so that a traveller arriving here would have no doubt that his place was a union of elven and dwarven craft and beauty.

Once he slipped invisible through the gates, he found himself on the long, smooth streets, lit by the flameless lamps. They swept in graceful ribbons between tall, arched buildings of wood many stories high. What a marvel, to build five or even six stories all of wood and not have it fall down on your head - only dwarven mathematics could have managed it, only elven patience and understanding of the grain and strength of wood could have raised them.

The City had been built within the living forest without razing it entirely: huge trees predating the buildings still stood everywhere, the roads curving around them. Their branches supported walkways and smaller shelters, or extended right through purpose-built gaps in the buildings, so that even when walls had corners they rarely had many right-angles. The air had a pleasant warmth, and was full of changing scents as the greenery and the open-air eateries mingled in different measures. There was not the stink of the towns and cities that Bilbo was used to, the ever-present smell of waste, animals and industry. Everything distasteful was drawn away by hidden waterways; clean fountains emerged from spouts on street-corners every few dozen yards.

Elves and dwarves filled the streets, on foot or occasionally pulled in small carts by ponies, so that if Bilbo let himself get distracted by the sights he was constantly in danger of being knocked over. Everybody seemed to be smiling and dressed in fine cloth, in fashions that made Bilbo feel the urge to rush to the nearest tailor and beg to have a new wardrobe made at once before he embarrassed himself. And there were children everywhere, of all sizes, running with their school books under their arm, clustered together with heads bent in gossip, climbing across the roofs and tree-branches while governesses and grandmothers called to them from below, warning them of the consequences if they didn’t come down at once.

It was a dreamland. How could Thorin have left? Bilbo thought if he’d been in Thorin’s place, he would have risked the trial rather than walk away. Imagine trading all this for Bree.

He spent most of the first day trying to get his bearings in the large and winding neighbourhoods. He found the Palace easy enough: at the heart of the city rose a great hill of stone, surrounded by cliff-shadowed rivers and filled with natural caves that had been furnished and extended. This had once been the entire permanent abode of the wood-elves, large enough to shelter all of them in times of war, yet now it was only the smallest and oldest district in the City. Bilbo did not yet want to put the ring back on and head straight into the centre of Thorin’s proposed conspiracy, so he left the palace for now. Instead, he went looking for the address that Thorin had given him, just so he would know where it was if he needed help in a pinch.

It took him until the early evening to find Thorin’s house. It was in what seemed to be the core of the dwarven-dominated part of the city, on the nicest street, but all the same it was an unremarkable terraced cityhouse, no larger than its neighbours, with a pale blue door and many, large windows. He waited on a curb nearby with a small pastry he’d managed to swipe from a busy bakery, leaving behind a Laketown coin on the counter that he hoped would cover the cost. He didn’t want to risk any conversations with shopkeepers, so he would have to feed himself by theft after this, and he was out of money anyway.

After a short while, he watched a dark-haired, regal-clothed dwarrowdam returning. She had a younger dwarf walking beside her, also dark-haired and wearing the grey-green uniform of the guard; although Bilbo only saw their faces briefly before they turned away, they seemed to be laughing about something. The two of them fitted the description Thorin had given of his sister and his younger nephew, Kili. All seemed well between them, so after they’d gone inside and he’d finished his pastry, Bilbo loitered in front of a nearby front garden, admiring the flowers he had no names for, and some time after another young dwarf came out, yellow-haired and with a long blue cloak: evidently this was Fili. He seemed to have a furtive look about him, and Bilbo was too intrigued by that to leave well enough alone.

Bilbo followed Fili through the quiet, residential streets until they reached what seemed to be a busy district of smithies and carpenter’s workshops. Bilbo watched him pull up his hood and take several corners in quick succession and seemingly at random. Bilbo was sure Fili didn’t know he was there, but he was clearly worried about being followed. At the edge of the workshops, the streets merged into an area of warehouses, and Bilbo had to drop back a little as the crowds disappeared. He nearly lost Fili around the side of one of the warehouses, but he heard a distant murmur of conversation and then the thud of a heavy door. Bilbo hurried around the corner and found only a single, dwarf-sized wooden door in the side of one of the smaller warehouses, which overlooked a canal.

Bilbo put on the ring and carefully tried the door, which seemed to be bolted from the inside. He circled the building until he was blocked by a wall, which he managed to scale, thankfully still wearing the ring as he was far from graceful. On the far side was a small, exclosed courtyard extending to a dock over the water. There were loading doors facing the canal but also a small, grimy, narrow window low down, looking into what seemed to be a large basement. Bilbo pressed his face to it and could just make out a gathering of many dwarves, more than three dozen at a glance. They seemed to be standing and listening to a voice somewhere out of Bilbo’s sight, but he couldn’t make out the words or many details.

He was getting distracted by it all. He was here to do a job, and he wouldn’t find the answers here. He needed to get into the palace and hope that he had sharper ears than the elves.

—

Dis was just sitting down in the comfortable chair in the living room. She had been up since dawn in her official royal reception room, which was a small parlour with a few chairs and a desk, attached to the side of the Tinkerer’s academy. She could be found there most waking hours of most days. There she had meetings with dwarves and elves from across the City, ordinary people with ordinary lives, bringing her small complaints and grievances that for them were enormous and world-altering disasters. The parlour was leased from the academy for a peppercorn rent, and almost everything inside it was donated by merchants and trade-dwarves who considered her royal status to still have any meaning. Who still, quietly, greeted her as ‘your highness’ and gave her the traditional bows when they said farewell.

She’d had a small business before Thorin had disappeared, in gem appraisals and mineral studies for the mines. But she’d sold everything to cover the missing money and smooth things over with the dwarven families who donated it for the Khuzdul school. This was the school that Thorin had said he was going to build, but no stone of which ever materialized. Thorin had constantly said there were delays; every building he tried to lease pulled out of the contract, or suddenly had permission denied by its neighbours, or no carpenter would provide a quote to renovate it to their needs. Finally he’d found one rundown old hall in the warehouse district of the City and gathered the coin needed to purchase it outright; Dis had seen the chest when he brought it home. The same day, there had been a banging on the door and a forced search of their house by the Guard, looking for contraband weapons, which Thorin had raged and roared was a charge beyond offensive in its ridiculousness. At the time, he’d warned the constables he would raise the issue directly with Thranduil, as they were walking out empty-handed without any sign of the reported weapons. Hours later he’d come to Dis looking greyer and older than she’d ever seen him, and sat down on the same old chair where she now sat, with his hands shaking.

“It’s gone. Every coin I took out to buy the deeds tomorrow, for the school house. The chest is missing. It was the Guard, they must have taken it, they must have… it has all been a conspiracy against me, all the delays to the school, all along, because I am a threat, any dwarf who stands out or tries to lead our people is a threat…”

She didn’t know whether to believe him or not. The story of a long trail of persecution was as convenient as it was mysterious and unprovable. It played into Dis’ prejudices so neatly that she didn’t know whether she could trust her own judgement. When their grandfather had been in the grip of madness, he had seen conspiracies everywhere, too. Before the dragon came, when gold flowing through Thror's fingers. Perhaps Thorin had finally gone the same way.

When the story of the missing money got out, the Guard wasted no time in charging Thorin with embezzlement, and he fled before the threat of exile could play out in court. Of course, her boys were completely on Thorin’s side, and believed every word their uncle said before he left. Dis supported Thorin’s story in public while paying off the missing money in private. In her heart she did not want to think that he could have robbed his own people, his own kin.

But why would he have run if he wasn’t guilty?

Dis was thinking of Thorin that evening, looking at the portrait of the three siblings on the wall above the bookcase. It was a small picture painted in thick brushstrokes by a skilled, dwarvish hand, with paints and pastel-powders from the Woodland. It had been made a few years after they arrived here, after the Mountain was lost. Dis was in the centre, so young she hadn’t a whisker on her face, in little princess braids and a dark green, silk dress that the painter had embellished with imaginary pearls; the real dress had been a re-sewn, secondhand robe gifted by one of Thorin’s elven friends. Thorin himself stood behind her left shoulder, brows heavy and brooding, hair as black as a raven’s wing, his coat a dark, royal blue. He looked so young it was hard to reconcile him with the greying, faded brother she remembered the night before he fled. Behind her right shoulder stood Frerin in a dark, burgundy robe. His pose and three-quarter profile were a perfect mirror of his older brother, but for his hair a faint shade fairer, and brushed little sleeker, and of course the smile broad on his face. His eyes were as warm as hearth-stones; he had Thorin’s nose but Kili’s smile. Frerin was just as she remembered him, of course. He had never gotten much older than his portrait.

Dis tried to find the energy to get up and make herself some supper when the knock on the door came.

She flinched at the thought of having to deal with yet another complaint, in the evening and at home. She didn’t have the patience for this princess business. She shoved herself to her feet and marched towards the door, trying to compose a politer way to say, “Go away or I’ll show you where you can stick it!”

But when she opened the door with a wrench of the handle, there was no one there. She boiled with fresh anger. How dare they, how dare someone play tricks? Her grandfather had been a king. If she’d had a sword in her hand and she’d caught the blighter who’d knocked, she’d have shown him some tricks, oh yes.

As she turned to close the door, she realised there was a piece of paper under her left foot. Dis frowned and looked at it for a moment, thinking it was something she’d dropped on the way in. Then she shut the door quietly, crouched and picked it up. The weight of the paper was cheap, the edge torn as if from a bound notebook. She unfolded it and pencilled within, it read: Please meet me at eleven tonight in the fig garden behind your street; yours, an honourable burglar in your family’s service.

Dis read it over three times. Then she went back to the kitchen stove and burned the paper before Fili got home.

Her son was very late. He would not say where he’d been, and he wanted to pick a fight with her as soon as he got in the door. Being late and secretive had not been unusual for Fili, at least recently, but starting arguments with his mother was definitely uncharacteristic. As always, the thing that had got his hackles up was his brother.

“He told me everything you said. Why would you do that?” Fili griped. “I hope you’re happy with your meddling, because he’s gone and broken it off with Tauriel, as of some time this evening.”

“Good,” said Dis. “I’m happy to hear it. That’s what I wanted.”

“It wasn’t any of your business, Ma!”

“It was all of our business. We are not common diggers. We are the elder line of Durin,” Dis hissed at him. “I can’t believe you kept it secret from me. You’re supposed to be the sensible one, Fili. Ah, Mahal hear my prayer, I wish he’d sent me daughters, since sons cannot see beyond the tips of their—”

“Ma, he’s a grown dwarf! Let him make his own mistakes!”

“It’s done. I won’t speak another word about it. If anyone else finds out what Kili and that catamount were doing, it will be the end of his commission in the Guard, you mark me. Tell no one, pretend it never happened. I’m going to bed,” Dis snapped, and shut the bedroom door in his face.

She waited until he’d stopped moving around the house and seemed to have settled in his own bedroom, and then she took a dark cloak and slipped out into the street. The bells of the dwarven temples struck their last chimes at ten, so all she knew was that it was some time later than that.

The fig garden was an old piece of disused land not far from her house, between a row of narrow, wooden homes and a tall factory block. It had been one of the earliest dwarven burial plots in the City, back when this area had still been half-wild woodland, but the bodies had been moved to a newer graveyard some decades ago, and the families who’d laid their relatives down here had fought over what to do with the consecrated but now empty slice of land for so long that they themselves had mostly died or left. Wild figs, honeysuckle and fat pines had grown up through the empty graves and choked the forgotten headstones until it was unofficially reclaimed as a public garden. There was an open gateway at each end, so it was particularly popular for trysts where the lovers wanted to enter and leave without being seen together.

The handwriting on the note had been as unfamiliar as the make of the paper. Dis had no idea who she was looking for, but she was not worried. This was a dwarf neighbourhood. Who would hurt the last princess of the Longbeards? Even if some mad political assassin was plotting against her, they’d want to make a public statement, not do away with her in secret in the shadows.

There was a small, polite cough right behind her. Dis turned more quickly than was dignified.

There was someone sitting on one of the old, ivy-covered gravestones that she had just passed. It was a small person, curly-haired and beardless, but with a face that was far from childlike. Somehow in the dark she had not seen him, though she must have walked within a yard of him.

The person hopped off the headstone and bowed. She was baffled to see that his feet were bare and he was wearing a sheepskin-hemmed jacket in a Laketown fashion. His voice was polite as he straightened up and asked, “Would you be the Lady Dis?”

“I’d be the Princess Dis,” she said firmly, not bowing in return.

“My apologies. Bilbo Baggins, a hobbit lately of Bree in the West, at your service,” he pressed one hand to his chest. “I’ve been sent to speak with you as discretely as we are able.”

“By who?” Dis narrowed her eyes.

“By my employer,” Bilbo bobbed a little. “Your brother.”

Dis stared at him for several long seconds, while Bilbo gave her a smile that seemed both apologetic and impertinent. At last she said, “I think we should retire to my house, it’s very close.”

“Oh, really? This seemed like such a good spot, an abandoned graveyard at midnight; though I didn’t want to keep you up that late, so I made it eleven.”

“Anyone could come upon us, especially at this time of night,” she said, businesslike and gathering her skirts so they would not catch on the thorn bushes as she turned. “Come along, and quickly. Your shape will be memorable if we’re seen together. How did you get into the City?”

“Trade secret, I’m afraid. Is there anyone else home? Thorin said I should speak to nobody, but if I had to speak to somebody, it should be you.”

“My eldest is, but he’s well asleep,” Dis insisted.

A few minutes later, they were ensconced in Dis’ kitchen, around a tiny table with a mug each of lukewarm coffee from a pot left on the stove earlier in the night. Dis watched the hobbit. He had a nervous energy, like a rabbit, but Dis also had the sense that Bilbo wanted to appear nervous, to put her at ease and to make himself seem more harmless. Anybody who could enter the City undetected and walk straight up to the ancestral leader of the City’s dwarves was not, in her opinion, anything close to harmless.

“How long have you been watching me?” she asked.

“A couple of days. Only when you’re out and about, mind you, I’m not a spy,” he said with a roll of his eyes. “I just need answers to a few questions, and this place is shut up tighter than a dowager’s coin-purse. Everybody talks in riddles, even when they don’t know I’m listening.”

“What questions?”

Bilbo gave her a pained smile. “Thorin said you have kept journals, all your life, or at least, all your life here in the forest. He needs to know about certain dates, some very long ago.”

“Why?”

“I’m afraid I’m only being paid to answer Thorin’s questions,” Bilbo set his mug quietly on the table and rested his fingers around the rim, turning it slowly. “And some of the answers may be very dangerous.”

“Is my brother safe?” Dis said quietly.

“If he stays where he is,” Bilbo shrugged.

Dis felt the corner of her eyes sting. “I didn’t know if he was alive,” she whispered. “He disappeared, like our father. Our cousin Balin insisted he would be safe, but what did he know of what happens beyond the borders of this forest? We know nothing of the world, cloistered here in our mansion of wonders and tranquility.”

Bilbo was quiet for sometime, looking at her with some deeper pity than she thought the rant had warranted. At last he said, “I can’t promise you that he can ever come back to the City, but it’s clear that since he left he’s done nothing but think of you all and scheme about how to change the fortune of all the dwarves. If you help me, it will help him.”

“Of course I will,” Dis said, slumping back in her chair. “What dates does Thorin want to know about?”

Bilbo pushed his mug aside and from his coat, he produced a small book wrapped in amber-coloured leather, full of scribbled notes. He flipped it open to a marked page and began to read them out to her.

Dis went to the box at the end of her bed and found the stacks upon stacks of journals she had kept since she was a child. They were in fairly good order, and after asking him twice to repeat the list, she managed to find the corresponding book for each one. She set the empty mugs by the sink and piled the books on the table between herself and Bilbo.

“I don’t know if they’ll be of that much use,” she said. “It’s mostly pretty dry and sparse, a few words or lines for each day, unless something particularly interesting happened to me personally.”

“We’ll see,” Bilbo said, and read her the first date on the list. “Can you tell me what happened then, and perhaps a couple of days either side–”

That was an old journal, the pages yellow and sticking together from being long squashed at the bottom of the box. Dis flicked through the dates and shrugged. “Nothing in particular. Apparently I was still doing my apprenticeship as a rock-surveyor. I complained about my master.”

“Check a few days on either side,” Bilbo said.

Dis scanned the pages. “Let’s see… I was planning a trip to the Mirkwood Mountains, for my education. Before that… hmm, some personal thoughts I had about another dwarf,” she blushed slightly. “No need to read those. Ah, and some gossip. A dwarf had gone into a rage and killed his wife and her sister, a week or so before. He confessed, and was exiled. I write some youthful opinions opposing marriage traditions. Not very original.”

Bilbo’s expression was more careful and controlled than at any time since he’d appeared to her in the fig garden. He said, very casually, “Interesting. Well, what about this date?”

It was a few years later. Dis found the next book she’d selected from her archives and turned to the relevant page. She read a handful of days worth of entries. “I am working for Thorin. I say it’s very boring,” she turned back a page. “I’m still complaining about Thorin being boring. And…” she stopped, looking back in time through the dense, precise lines of her own handwriting as if peering through a spy-glass. “...and a dwarf is caught trying to light fires in the autumn trees. He’s declared mad, but still exiled.”

She looked up at Bilbo, who was now very clearly keeping his face utterly blank. He said after a moment. “And was that common, back then? Such a harsh punishment? Maybe if we picked a date at random, we’d find the same?”

“No,” said Dis. “Very rare, or I would not have mentioned it.”

They went on to the next date and the next book. “I’m courting my future husband. I think he’s the most delightful thing Mahal ever made. This occupies most of my journal entries for the whole week,” she flicked back through the days. “Here. A dam is accused of trying to blackmail her lover into murdering her husband. Her lover reports her to the Guard. She is exiled.”

She retrieved the next book. She saw now that Bilbo was writing in Westron next to each date: dwarf exiled.

“This week: I’m heavy with child and writing about all the miseries and how hard he kicks. Right into my ribs. The midwife says that means it’s a boy,” she turned the page. “A smith is found forging weapons against the prohibition, though he insists they are only for decorative purposes. He is exiled.”

The next book. “I am pregnant again, I’m not as sick this time. The kicks seem much gentler. The midwives are sure it’s a girl,” Dis glanced wryly at Bilbo. “It wasn’t.” She ran her finger over the faded, ink dates that she had laid down so many decades ago. “A dwarrow’s young babe dies in suspicious circumstances. Horrible rumours. A trial, the magistrate declares her guilty of deliberately smothering him, she is exiled.”

The next date, she shook her head. “I… it was a difficult time. I didn’t record most days. There’s nothing, no entries for weeks.” They try the next one. “We are living in Thorin’s old house, before he moved here. My boys fill most of my writings, I don’t talk about anything else. Let’s go to the next one, here it is. I don’t think there’s… ah, yes. No details, but a name, a dwarrow. I knew her a little from Temple, I write that I took her for a drink to comfort her. Her brother has been exiled, it doesn’t say why.” They went to the next date. “The lads have just started at a new finishing school, the City had to build a new one because there were so many young dwarves and elves growing up at that time. I write: a professor at the engineer’s academy has been accused of seducing his students by threatening them with failure. He’s to be exiled,” the next book, “A dwarf gets into a fight, his opponent falls in a river and drowns. Many witnesses, a quick trial, he is exiled,” she grabbed the next book as Bilbo reads the date. “I’m building my new business. I think I was very busy, because I don’t write much, I can’t see anything useful. The next one? Hmm… history scholar. Accused of encouraging violence against the City Guard. A dwarven student attacked a constable, the student is fined, the professor is exiled. I write about it a lot, because no one considers it justice.” They turn to the next book. “Here, I can’t see any exiles, but there is something I mention… a dwarf vanished and was never found. I remember this, it was not so long ago. He was an old Erebor nobleman who had always opposed our settlement in the Woodland, always harping on about it. He was a conservative old boar but it was a strange case. Tell me the next one? Yes, here’s another: I write that a dwarf was found keeping his elderly, sick father imprisoned, in squalid conditions, in order to cover up years of thieving from his father’s business. Exiled. What’s the next date?”

Bilbo looked up from his notebook. “That’s the last one.”

“That was a decade ago. Weren’t they regular, before then?”

“Roughly every seven years, give or take,” Bilbo nodded, looking back down at his list, his tongue briefly sticking out the corner of his mouth as he made some quick calculation. “But yes, there’s been nothing since then. If the pattern had held, there should have been another date in my list in 2938 or 2939, though it’s not that predictable. Was there anything noteworthy, around then?”

Dis felt her fingers clench around the journal in her hand. She said hoarsely. “Perhaps. Thorin left in late 2938.”

Bilbo’s head shot up, his eyes wide. After a moment he closed his notebook, got up and went to the kitchen bench. He picked up his cup and swallowed the cold dregs of his coffee, as if his throat had grown suddenly dry, and finally turned to her with his arms folded. “How much do you know about why he left?”

“He fled before he could be tried for theft. The rumour was he would be charged as an enemy of the people, because it was supposed to be a state school, so the theft was harm to the whole City even though the money was from private donors. He thought that he would be exiled. I couldn’t believe the magistrate would do something so outrageous, not to Thror’s grandson,” Dis answered. After a moment she said, “I know he was asking questions, before the money disappeared. Questions he would only hint at. He’d never acted so secretive before. There were days I thought…” she hung her head. “He was paranoid. I thought perhaps he was going mad.”

The hobbit didn’t answer. She realised suddenly that she had been lured into giving up everything he’d asked for and had been given almost nothing in return. What a fool. She really was rubbish at this politics business, she wished she was still a gem-appraiser. She leaned forward in her chair. “Bilbo, where did my brother find these dates? You didn’t come here knowing any of this. What do these days mean to you, to Thorin? What else happened on those days?”

Bilbo tapped his pencil on his chin and then tucked it behind his ear distractedly. “It might be more than your life is worth to know the answer. I don’t think Thorin would forgive me if I put you in danger.”

“Danger from who? I’ve already helped you, I’m part of this business now.”

Bilbo shook his head. “All I can say is that I don’t think Thorin was paranoid enough.”

Dis slammed her fist into the table, making the pile of discovered journals slip over like a small rockslide. “Curse Thorin, he cannot do this alone! They are my people too, they are my responsibility! Tell me what happened on those days!”

Bilbo held her gaze. He had not flinched at her outburst. At last he said, “Dragon flights.”

“What does that mean?”

“The dragon was seen flying from the Mountain to the City. And perhaps… and this is only an educated guess on Thorin’s part, we haven’t found any evidence of this yet… new mithril appeared in the City’s vaults.”

In the quiet that followed, Dis heard her own heart thudding in her ears. And then they both heard something else: the sound of a door creaking in the house. Dis had only a moment to sweep the journals off the surface of the table and shove them into the shadows behind the legs of her chair, before Fili walked into the kitchen.

“Ma, what are you awake for?” He rubbed her eyes. “I heard a bang.”

Dis glanced towards where Bilbo stood, but he was gone. Like he’d been a ghost all along. The doorway to the front hall stood open and well-lit, but Dis had not seen the hobbit move nor heard the front door open.

“I’m alright. I dropped something,” she bent and picked up one of the journals off the floor. “Here. I was just writing.”

Fili looked at her, and then at the two empty coffee mugs beside the sink. “By yourself?”

Dis stood up. “Yes. Go back to bed.”

Fili would not be deterred. He put one hand on his hip. “You had a visitor? At this hour?”

“And if I did? Do I have to share names with you?” Dis said haughtily. “I’m a grown dam.”

He snorted and scrubbed his hand through his hair, yawning. “Very well. I won’t ask.” He started back towards his bedroom.

Dis said, before she could stop herself, “Fili?”

He looked back at her, one hand on the door frame. She remembered how hard he used to kick her in the ribs, before she’d ever seen his face. She should never have let her sons go, never let them run further than her arms could reach.

They were all impossible to hold onto. She’d begged Frerin and Thorin not to go to Moria with their grandfather, not to leave her all alone. Frerin had promised her he would come back; Thorin was wise enough even at that age not to make such promises. But it was Thorin who had returned, along with their father. Thrain was diminished by the losses; where he should have grown and ascended into the kingship, he had seemed to shrink away from it, using the bitter excuse that the elves didn’t recognise his authority. As if a lack of official titles had ever stopped Thorin in the years before then. But she couldn’t blame her father: he had lost his wife to Smaug, his father in the Dimrill Dale, his loud and cheerful son in the final orcish massacre. He was left with an angry daughter and his dour and distant eldest son, all of them divided by their shared anguish.

Thrain believed the dwarves of Erebor had gone soft, that if they had only gone to war in greater numbers, Moria would have been won. Dis could see that he blamed Thorin for that softness, because Thorin had forged their union with the elves, Thorin had fed their people with the elves' hospitality. He couldn’t see what Dis could: that Thorin was the only one of them whose core of obsidian dwarvishness was still holding strong in those strange and malleable days. Thorin had been able to change his face, his dress, learn Sindarin and foreign etiquette, because he had complete surety in who he was underneath. The surface was mere glamour.

When their father showed them the map and the key and had spoken of returning to Erebor, Dis threw herself into his lap and pleaded like she was a little child again, sobbed to him that she couldn’t lose her father, too. But her tears hadn’t been enough for Thrain. He vanished: their own father had abandoned them, orphaned them.

Dis was determined she would not be the last one left. “Fili, whatever you’re hiding, keep it secret,” she said quietly. “Even from me. Protect yourself.”

“I don’t know what you mean,” he smiled. “I’m the sensible one, remember?”

She nodded. “And please, please, don’t get your brother involved. I think he's truly respected in the Guard, but they're always watching. He can’t make any more missteps.”

Fili held her eye, trying to read her like a journal, but at last he seemed to give up. He shrugged, “I’ll try my best. He does whatever he wants, Ma, you know that.”

He slipped away into the darkened hall back to bed. After his door had shut in the distance, Dis thought of the trees burning, not the ancient trees of the woodland, but the young pines on the mountain, and the screams of the dwarves who escaped, half-alive, dying upon the threshold. Her mother had been among them, unnoticed in all the terror, perishing alone beneath the Mountain’s cold gaze.

In the quiet house, she swore she heard soft footsteps on the polished wood and then the click of the door outside. She went to check the door was closed, and when she returned she noticed there was a new note torn from Bilbo’s book and lying in the middle of the kitchen table: If you need me, summon me with a candle in the front window. Something colourful, please! –BB