Chapter Text
For the first day after Kili was arrested, everything for Fili seemed to be held both motionless and spinning, like a child's mobile. Kili was being held somewhere in a cell under the palace, but the praetorians seemed to have taken charge from the regular City Guard and no one was able to tell Fili much about where or how long he would be held. On the second day, they let Dis visit Kili, while Fili sat and waited for her on the street outside the palace. She was there for almost two hours, and came back looking as pale and old as he had ever seen his mother. She had been crying, though her cheeks were dry now. Fili held out his elbow and she linked her arm through it and clung tight.
"He's alright," she told Fili as they walked away. "They're treating him coldly but not unkindly. He's just frustrated and alone. They've told him nothing about why he's been accused. He asked to see Tauriel's body, but of course he doesn't want to tell them why, and even if he did, nobody will even consider it. I asked one of the guards if I could go and pay my respects, for myself - for whatever that's worth, I'd like to say sorry for my part - but the praetorian said she's already been buried in a small ceremony. She didn't have a lot of family, from what Kili said."
Fili glanced around before he spoke. "What do you mean, 'for your part'? Ma, tell me the truth, you didn't have something to do with this?"
"Of course I didn't!" Dis' voice regained a little of its usual brashness. "Fili, don't be stupid. Even if I'd wanted to... even when I was most angry at her for, for... for seducing my boy... I would never have been so silly. I would have guessed that Kili would be their first suspect. Exactly as it's played out."
"But then who?" Fili whispered. "She was... well, she seemed quiet, and inoffensive. And she's so close to Prince Legolas. Who would dare...?"
Dis' mouth was hard and thin. "She had an impulsiveness in her, that I think she would have claimed was her heart speaking. Reckless girl. Do you think she'd have chased Kili if she was a good elf? She was a rule-breaker, too. No wonder he liked her so much."
"How do you know? You barely knew her."
"She was helping me with something, something Thorin asked for," Dis said very softly. "And I told her to be careful. I think she didn't listen. But it’s my fault for meddling, for getting her involved." She added, almost to herself. "Mahal, when we get him out of this mess, he'll never be the same."
Fili tried to find out everything he could about what was going to happen next. A crime of this magnitude was simply so rare in the Woodland that it was hard to know what precedent would be followed and what would have to be invented by the clerks and magistrates of the law. Normally, if it was safe, anyone accused of a crime in the City which they denied would be released to their home until trial, with the assurance that their family would watch them and keep them confined. But Fili was not surprised to be told that such a thing was not permitted for murder. Eventually, unable to get much out of the officials in the halls of the palace, he spoke to Telion, Kili's archery trainer and the oldest elf he knew. Telion did have a memory of another contentious murder trial long ago, where the suspect was found to be wrongly accused; centuries and centuries he said, well before Tauriel was even born. But it had been a different time, when the Woodland realm could fit all of its populace into the king's palaces when danger threatened, and everybody was cousin or third-cousin of everybody else.
"Is there anything we can do?" Fili pleaded with Telion. "They won't tell us anything. We don't even know how she died."
Telion shook his head. "I fear these dark days are not some unlucky strike of lightning, but the bud of something poisonous growing across the whole City. Watch your step, Master Fili. Your mother has lost her father, her brothers and now one of her sons. I know you will give anything to help your brother, but think of her as well."
"She hasn't lost him," Fili said firmly. "Kili is innocent. That will be obvious at the trial."
Telion did not scoff at him, though he did not say he believed him, either.
–
Bilbo had left the City the night Dis and Tauriel had had their final conversation, carrying Thrain's key and nmap with no idea of everything that had happened afterwards. He had reached Laketown the next afternoon, after a long walk along the banks of the Forest River with the ring on his finger. Once he was past the gates of the Woodland realm, he was able to secretly hitch a ride on one of the many barges taking goods to and from Esgaroth.
Now he sat in the rented room of the Black Arrow inn. When he’d walked through the door an hour earlier, Inga greeted him as if he’d just come back from a trip to market, and not as if he’d been away for more than a week. She told him Thorin was still paying for the room, although she wasn’t sure exactly when he came and went. Still making trips to the mountain to scout out other possible ways in, Bilbo suspected.
He had accepted a meal from Inga and a chance to rest his feet in the room. Thorin’s bed was neatly made, his bag with most of his belongings tidily packed on the floor. Bilbo realised that after today, he would have completed everything Thorin had asked him. But unless Thorin returned from his latest trip to the Mountain with a few stolen treasures from the dragon’s hoard, Thorin had no way to pay him for the job.
Perhaps, he thought, he could use that as an excuse to stick around until Thorin could cover the debt. He tried to be rational. He needed to go back to Bree and close up the treasure hunting business at last. He was supposed to be retiring. If he didn’t return by the date he’d given the Sackville-Bagginses to move out of Bag End, and supervise their exit himself, his cousins would absolutely use it as an excuse to dig their heels in. He tried to remember how much he had missed his childhood home, how desperately these last few years he had wanted to return and replant the garden, spend his days decorating the house and reading all the books his mother had put in storage. He’d had a vague plan to write down his memoirs, all the wildest jobs he’d taken on, perhaps even make copies as a serialised publication if he could get the book-binders down in Bywater to collaborate. ‘The adventures of Bilbo Baggins, Professional Burglar’, that had been the plan. If he could invite Gandalf over for a visit, he might even be able to get more details about Bella’s life before her marriage and write a biography of her as well.
He’d been looking forward to retirement. And now he was staring at the empty bed in this grubby downtown inn, and he thought, I’m not ready to go home.
Perhaps what he’d found could clear Thorin’s name and allow him to return to the City in triumph. If he did, perhaps Bilbo could follow him - with the intention of chasing payment for his fee, of course. And then, if Thorin was restored to a place of respect among the dwarves of the City, he’d probably be willing to recommend Bilbo to others. There must be lots of need for a burglar in a place as rich and full of industry as the City, lots of backroom dealings that needed someone to listen in, lots of runaway husbands who needed catching under their assumed names, and plenty of stolen gems in need of investigating and recovery. Bilbo could probably start a very successful career in the City. And of course, he’d always have time in the schedule book for when the uncrowned King of the Dwarves came by with a new quest—
He was lost in this daydream when he heard heavy footsteps on the stairs. He sat up quickly as the real Thorin walked in, looking rather greyer and more tired than the glorious image in Bilbo’s mind. His face lit up with a broad smile as he saw Bilbo.
“Inga didn’t mention that you were back!”
Bilbo climbed off the bed. He remembered the news he had for Thorin and he couldn’t bring himself to smile in return. Thorin’s expression soured a little. “Was it not a successful trip?”
“It was more than successful,” said Bilbo, and waved him over to the table. “I think you should sit down.”
A few minutes later, he watched as Thorin turned the key over and over in his hand, examining it from all angles as if he hoped it was a forgery. The map lay in front of them. Beside it, Bilbo had placed the rest of the papers from the archives, laid out like fortune-telling cards.
“I’m sorry you were right,” Bilbo said quietly.
Thorin touched the card with his father’s name. “Twelve ounces,” he murmured. “The life of my father, for twelve ounces of Mithril. Some would say that is a fair ransom for a king, but I would not have sold him for the whole hoard of Thror.” He shook his head and put the key down on top of the map. “And all those others, walked to their fate without knowing until far too late…”
At last, Thorin looked up at Bilbo. “Thank you, Mr Baggins. You have performed more than admirably. Gandalf did well to recommend you.”
“You’re very welcome,” said Bilbo. “Now, I realise that since the mountain did not turn out to be unguarded, you may have some trouble covering my fee, but I’m happy to defer payment for as long as you need—”
“It’s alright, I’ve found a solution. After you left for the City I sent a raven from the Laketown roost to my cousin Dain, in the Iron Hills. He’s already replied to say he’ll loan me the money to settle things with you. His house does plenty of trade here, so he has accounts with the Esgaroth moneylenders. It took a day to arrange, but here. Dain has lent me enough to pay your expenses back to Bree as well, so you shouldn’t be out of pocket.”
Thorin reached into his coat and took out a small bag that sagged with the weight of coin inside. He put it down on the table in front of Bilbo.
“Here. Count it, and let me know if you think I’ve cut you short.”
He sat back in the chair and folded his arms, still staring at the map and the key.
“Oh,” Bilbo said. His stomach sank. Just like that, the adventure was over. It had just been another professional job, after all. Why had he expected anything else? “Well, what are you going to do next? With this information? ”
“Go to the Iron Hills and get Dain fully on my side,” Thorin said morosely. “From there, we shall have to see. Dain can get messages to my friends and family in the City. We need to be careful before we reveal this, or no one will believe it. It will take time.”
“To what end?” Bilbo asked. “What is all this for? You can try to start a revolution against Thranduil, revenge your father’s death, perhaps clear your own name, and likely get a lot of dwarves and elves killed in the process. But the City will still need Mithril.”
He felt puffed-up and annoyed at Thorin for so casually discarding him. He knew this was both completely unfair - Thorin had never promised him anything other than the fulfillment of a contract - and unkind - Thorin had just had his worst fears confirmed about his father’s disappearance. But he couldn’t help it. He had really imagined that Thorin thought of him as more than just a contract.
Thorin nodded. “My eyes are not swayed from the Mountain, but now I have the means to win the dwarves of the City back to my side. If the Iron Hills are with us, we may have a chance to finally kill the dragon at the heart of this foul arrangement. Destroy the rot, and both the City and Erebor may be renewed.”
“You have one dwarf on your side. Your sister,” Bilbo assured him.
Thorin sighed. “And therefore in the most danger if Thranduil realises his secret is out. But nevermind,” he rubbed his beard. “We have time. Thranduil took lessons from us; but from him, I have learned patience.”
“So we have one last night together,” Bilbo said, trying to sound cheerful instead of melancholy.
Thorin put his hand on Bilbo’s shoulder and squeezed it. Bilbo found himself leaning into Thorin’s grip, tipping his head so that it brushed the back of Thorin’s warm hand. “Shall we go out and make the most of it? Let me buy you a drink, to thank you. Perhaps even dinner.”
“Yes,” Bilbo smiled at last. “I think we can finally relax.”
The sun was low by the time they left the Inn. They had found a warm pub in a part of the town with a breeze flowing through the open windows, which blew the smoke and smell of the town away to the east. There was a large bay window overlooking the water where they sat and ate. From here, on the west side of the town, their view of the mountain was blocked by the rambling buildings and towers, but still Thorin’s eyes seemed to drift towards it in moments of quiet.
“Bilbo,” Thorin said, as they were finishing their meal. “You seem a little morose, if you don’t mind me saying. Have I done something to offend?”
Bilbo thought about smiling and assuring him no, everything was perfectly fine. But then, he was not beholden to politeness anymore - if he ever had been. He might be able to get a ferry tomorrow and simply leave, and make it back over the mountains before winter hit and the passes were blocked. The risk of making things awkward had dropped considerably.
“I will admit, I was a little put out,” he huffed, pushing his tankard to the side and knotting his fingers on the table in front of him. “That now that you got what you needed, you would cut me loose so easily, after our journey all this way.”
Thorin’s eyebrows rose and he leaned forward, one elbow on the table. “Cut you loose?”
“Yes,” Bilbo said primly. “Paid and sent on my way.”
“Send you on your way?” Thorin echoed.
Bilbo felt himself getting a little hot under the collar. “Am I talking to myself? Yes. Expenses back to Bree. All done, Mr Baggins, thank you very much.” He swept his hand through the air to illustrate the dismissal.
A small smile tugged at the corner of Thorin’s mouth. “I didn’t say you had to be on your way,” he said quietly, leaning forward even further until a few locks of his hair fell loose around his face. “I just wanted to clear all debts between us, so that you were no longer in my employ.”
Bilbo frowned at him. “Well, I appreciate it very much, but that’s not the point.”
“It is entirely that point,” Thorin said. “I paid you so that you are free to go or stay, as you like.”
Bilbo opened his mouth and then closed it again before he could dig himself in any deeper. His frown deepened, and then relaxed, and he glanced out the window at the reddening sky and then back to Thorin as he tried to think. At last he asked, “Do you want me to stay?”
“Yes,” Thorin said with a small laugh. “Very much.”
As if he’d stepped backwards and tumbled out the window into the lake, Bilbo’s mind rushed to reorient himself. Thorin held his eye and waited for him. Bilbo gulped and said. “Well, in that case. Have we, er, have we paid the bill?” He waved a finger at the nearly empty plates strewn around the table.
“I paid at the bar,” Thorin nodded.
“Then shall we go?” Bilbo glanced at Thorin’s hands and then back to his face. “Somewhere more private, perhaps?”
“Certainly, Mr Baggins,” Thorin stood up with no more encouragement. Bilbo linked arms with him and they sauntered through the dining room of the pub and out the front doors. Through the streets, their heads bent together, they hurried back through the crowded and ramshackle streets. The paths and canals were still full of traders and workmen, mingling now with drunks and youths dressed up for the night.
When they reached the Inn, there were several patrons stumbling out the front door and they could hear loud singing and the roars of drunk revellers inside. Thorin grabbed Bilbo’s hand and tugged him around the back, onto a thin path over the canal that ran behind the building and ended in a dead-end corner leading to a back door, and only a couple of small windows high above their heads. A few small, wooden buoys painted in cheerful colours bobbed merrily in the water below the path. The lights of the houses on the far side winked and rippled in the water of the canal.
“If it wasn’t for the smell of this town, it’d be almost lovely,” Thorin said, looking up at a few white stars above them.
“It’s very romantic. Now let’s get inside,” the back door led directly through to the Inn’s guest rooms, so Bilbo reached for the handle of the door. Before he could turn it, he felt Thorin’s hand on his shoulder and found himself backed against the wall as Thorin took his face and kissed him.
Bilbo nearly melted into him. For several minutes they simply held each other, pressed together, and then there was the clatter of the door being flung open. Thorin sprang back with a cough as light flooded their private little path and pinned them as clearly as if they were on a theatre stage. Inga and Bard’s oldest daughter, Sigrid, stepped out onto the path. She saw them and looked away quickly with a roll of her eyes, crouched to grab the mooring line for one of the buoys and hauled up a locked crate filled with bottles of sweet wine that were being kept chilled in the water. She determinedly did not make eye contact with them as she took two bottles and turned to go back into the inn, but she called over her shoulder, “Please go to your room like normal people, before you fall in the canal.”
Bilbo covered his face with his hands and groaned as the door slammed shut and the light with it, leaving them in the shadows again. “I feel like a tweenager hiding from his parents.”
Thorin stroked the hair back from Bilbo’s brow. “Being old has some advantages,” he said quietly. “Experience. Perhaps a little wisdom.” He grinned, “A sense of urgency.”
“I thought you’d learned patience?” Bilbo asked.
“I have been patient,” Thorin kissed him again. “I have been patient for weeks.”
There was a crash and once again they were lit up by the glow of the Inn. Inga was standing in the doorway, leaning out to look at them. Bilbo jumped and stepped forward. “Inga, I am so sorry, you’re absolutely right, we’ll go upstairs right away and stop blocking your back door–”
“It’s not that, Mr Underhill,” Inga said, holding something out. “It’s a letter for Mr Luznâ. It came after you both left this evening. It’s marked both private and urgent.”
Thorin pushed past Bilbo and grabbed the letter, cracking open the wax and unfolding it. His body slumped and his eyes widened. He looked at Bilbo. “It’s from my sister.”
He held out the letter for Bilbo to read. In an elegant but practical hand, with no salutation, it read simply: Kili has been arrested. No trial yet scheduled. If they find him guilty it will be exile, by now you must know what this means. I am not too proud to beg but your high friend in the palace refuses to see me. In my despair I pray he may listen to your counsel as he once did. Please come, but take great care.
Bilbo raised his head quickly as he took it in. “There’s been no exile for nine years. They’re overdue. They’ll be looking for any excuse to make the trade.”
“If he’s found guilty…” Thorin shook his head. He turned to Inga, who had been pretending to busy herself with something by the door but had left it open and was clearly listening with interest. “Can your husband take me to the mouth of the Forest River? As far as his boat will go?”
“Not before tomorrow morning,” Inga said with a frown.
“Who can ferry me at this time of night?”
“No one will brave the rocks in this darkness,” she shook her head. “Or if they did, they must be idiots and I wouldn’t recommend you trust them at the tiller.”
“Ask him to be ready as soon as he can,” Thorin pleaded.
“It’ll cost you,” Inga raised her eyebrows. “He’ll have to delay other jobs.”
Bilbo fumbled in his coat and shoved the bag of coins at Thorin. “Take it out of this. You said you overpaid me for travel expenses I don’t need, yet.”
Thorin hesitated, and then took the bag with a quiet, “Thank you.”
Inga said she’d talk to Bard as soon as he was home for the night, and then shut the door to give them their privacy back. The sparkling lights and lapping water had lost any romantic appeal. Thorin was practically vibrating with frustration at being so far from his family’s troubles.
“Thorin, let’s talk about this. You can’t just walk back into the City,” Bilbo took his elbow. “You’ll be arrested yourself, as soon as you set foot in the Woodland. They might take you straight off to the–” the glanced at Inga and lowered his voice. “The you-know-what with all the teeth and claws.”
“If I can get into the palace and speak to the king, maybe…” Thorin shook his head. “I don’t know who else knows about this bargain with the dragon, but none have challenged Thranduil in all these years, that much is clear. If I make him see what he is doing, through my eyes, through the eyes of my people, perhaps he can be reasoned with.”
“We’ll go first thing in the morning, then,” Bilbo said. “Arrested… If the City is worth anything as a civilised place, this sort of bureaucratic nonsense will take weeks. We may not be in a rush at all.”
“All the same. I would like to be there by tomorrow night,” Thorin folded his arms. Then he flinched and looked at Bilbo. “We?”
“I’ll come with you, of course. If this is a stitch-up as it was with you, your nephew will have one thing that you didn’t have on your side. A professional burglar.” Bilbo patted his arm. “Things found and found out. That was my mother’s sign on the door, remember?”
“Bilbo,” Thorin said, the hand on his arm loosened but did not release him. “You don’t have to come. Our contract is settled. If you are caught entering the City without the leave of the Guard, you will be answerable to the City’s laws. You owe me and my family nothing.”
Bilbo nodded and looked at him. “Then when it’s all done, we can talk about billable hours and overtime. But until then, I want to help.”
