Chapter Text
Two nights after Kili was arrested, Fili was awoken by his mother before the sun was even bright enough to outshine the City lamps. "Get your coat. There was a messenger, the trial's happening today."
"Today? I thought it would be weeks away," Fili jumped up and blearily dressed and shoved a piece of yesterday's bread in his mouth as they headed outside into the lamplight. Balin and Dwalin, who lived nearby, had been roused by the messenger as well. Dis embraced them both quickly. "Will you put the word out and tell everyone to get down to the administration halls? I think it will help if we are not alone, whatever happens next."
"Of course," Balin gave a quick bow. "We'll see you there."
The community buildings that administered the City's central needs were a cluster of high-ceilinged halls and offices, their roof beams and door posts made of a pale wood polished until they shone almost white. They stood in a rough circle, as if back-to-back, surrounded by a wide ring-road of newish, dwarven paving stones. When Fili and Dis arrived, the lamps were finally flickering out and the winter sun was filtering through the distant arches of the trees that filled the City avenues. Beneath their shade, a crowd was already gathering outside the central hall of justice.
It turned out there had been no need to summon reinforcements. Somehow, despite the short notice, word had gotten out about the trial. There were two dozen dwarves, of all ages, but more coming all the time. Among them at the front, marking the clearest faction of coordinated supporters, were Kili’s friend Berior from the archery range and another three tall, elven schoolfriends, along with at least half a dozen dwarves. The strawberry-haired Ori, who had always rather idolised Kili and occasionally helped him cheat on homework, seemed to be the leader of this group. Fili was amazed to see that on presumably short notice, Ori had coordinated both the dwarves and elves so that they all wore a dark blue - a coat, vest or scarf - the old colour of the line of Durin. So their purpose here was loud and clear, for good or for ill. Fili had been so busy the last two days trying to figure out how to get his brother out of the cells he had not realised there were parallel efforts to help him.
On the far side of the steps there was a small group of young elves in uniform, who Fili recognised as some of the members of Kili's unit in the Guards. That they had worn their uniforms was notable, as it was normally not permitted unless on duty. All four of the elves who had been recruited with Kili were there, and two older ones from the same unit, and their lieutenant, who was standing back a little and looking troubled. The cause of her trouble was obvious; two of the elves in the group had started arguing with each other.
Fili grabbed his mother's arm. "Can you go to the top of the steps and look, well, you know...?"
"Majestic?" Dis raised her eyebrow.
"And a little bit fragile, if you don't mind," Fili gave her a gentle push.
"Fili, we don't want to be seen leading a riot--"
"I'm not going to start a riot, I'm going to try and stop one," Fili insisted. He gave her a gentle push, trying to make it look like he was just guiding her onwards, and the crowd parted around them. Everyone was looking at them. As Dis walked up the steps, Fili darted over to the group of young Guards. Just as he got there, the arguing rose a notch and one of them shoved the other in the chest.
"Hey!" Fili jumped in between them and they looked down at him in surprise. He pointed up the steps at Dis. "You're in your bloody uniforms! Can you please try to keep the peace, for my mother's sake?"
Lieutenant Fainthel, looking a little embarrassed, stepped in as well. "Yes, lads, we are here to observe, nothing more."
"You know this is wrong, Fainthel!" One of the two arguing guards said. Fili vaguely remember his name as Annúngil. "I passed Kili four times on patrol that night, on our route in the forest. I can give him an alibi. But the magistrate won't let me speak at the trial."
"We don't know anything," Haered, the elf who had been shoved, smoothed down his jacket. He had been recruited to the guard at the same time as Kili and, as he was Berior’s cousin and closest friend, had come out drinking with Kili and his brother many times. Now his face was cold and his tone stinging. "You have not seen the evidence. Your alibi only covers the night, but she could have been killed while he was returning to the barracks. He always acted odd when the captain was around, we all knew it. Unnatural urges, that’s what I think.”
“You’re a prejudiced, bitter fool, Haered,” Annúngil went for him again, but Fili held his ground between them like a rock and blocked him from touching Haered again. “You’ve never liked him!”
Fili raised his hands to try and get their attention. "Both of you, please, keep your heads. Tauriel would want justice to be done, and that won’t happen with you fighting each other over speculations on the front steps."
When they seemed mollified, he looked back over at the cluster of blue-clad dwarves and elves crowding around the bottom of the steps. Dis was speaking to them quietly. After a moment she hurried over to Fili and whispered in his ear. "They've been told no one will be admitted to the chamber, not even family. The clerk inside said it was too small. They're starting the trial now."
"What?" Fili gaped at her. He chewed his lip and then touched her shoulder. "Do your best to keep everyone calm. We'll sort this out." He dashed over to Lieutenant Fainthel. "Can you come with me to speak to the magistrate inside? They're trying to keep the trial behind closed doors."
Fainthel drew herself up a little, her chest and shoulders stretching the smooth lines of her uniform. "Of course, surely that cannot be right. Everything should be open to the sunlight."
Within a few minutes, Fili and Fainthel returned. The crowd of dwarves had swelled even more, now. Balin and Dwalin had made their way to the front to stand with Dis, trying to respond to questions to which they had no real answers. Dis turned to Fili as she heard him come up behind her. "Well?"
"Fainthel's convinced them they're risking serious unrest if they don't delay the trial to allow us and the prosecution to select observers. I saw Prince Legolas in there as well, he was making the same demand, even he was not happy to hear they were trying to hold the trial in secret. We've got an hour. They're moving everything to the Great Hall next door. They said they'll let us in, and as many as can sit in the gallery at the back of the room. It’s got a small bench that looked barely enough for ten dwarves, give or take the size of the dwarf," Fili looked around the crowd until he spotted an older fellow whose callused hands were folded over his chest. "Ginnar! Just who I need," Fili darted between the blue-clad faction to clap him on the shoulder. "How fast can you get wood and hammers, and how many hands would you need to build a tiered stand?"
"You planning a stick-ball tournament?" Ginnar raised his eyebrows. He grinned. "How long have we got?"
"Less than an hour," said Fili grimly. Before Ginnar could even start looking for his apprentices in the crowd, he had several of the blue-clad supporters rushing forward to volunteer for errands. Fili caught Berior and Ori, “We’ll make as much room as we can, but if you could choose five dwarves and two elves who you think can sit quietly and respectfully in the court, we’ll bring them in with us. The rest should stay out here and relay any information we can. If they don’t want people watching, we’ll make sure the crowd outside hears every word as soon as it happens,” once that was sorted, he went to Fainthel with the same offer, “Can you pick three of your recruits? A balance of opinions. And you’ll come yourself, if you would? We can’t have them saying we packed the court with intimidating partisans. I want good witnesses.”
He was counting in his head as he went, trying to estimate the size of the gallery stands Ginnar had yet to build, but Fainthel caught his eye as he tried to leave. “You speak as if the crime was still in progress. Your brother will be treated fairly, Master Dwarf. The Woodland realm cares for its people.”
“Tell me that to my face at the end,” Fili answered, and then shook his head. “I’m sorry, you don’t deserve my ire. Forgive me.”
“You are forgiven,” she waved her hand. “I will see you inside.”
Fili turned to his mother. "Do you want me to find you somewhere to sit? You don't look yourself."
"I'm perfectly well," said Dis, but her hand was shaking when Fili reached for it. "This is worse than I imagined. I thought, I thought... perhaps it was all a mistake, and they would release him once they’d properly investigated. But they are rushing this through... did you speak to the magistrate who will convene the trial? Did you catch their name?"
"Tulus," said Fili.
Dis gave a soft groan and touched her brow as if she had a sudden pain. "One of Thranduil's closest advisors. He was one of the Dragon Guards, he used to be a praetorian. He has been chosen for this purpose. Fili, we can't let this happen, we can't let them do this. There are things I haven't told you, things even Thorin didn't know until now. Tauriel, she helped us..." But there were people all around them, and she cut herself off as a few ears turned towards her voice.
“It'll be alright, Ma. I promise." Fili had never seen her so gaunt and wan. His strong, single-minded mother, who as a child had watched her home burn and her own mother with it, who had raised two boys without her husband, who had taken her brother's place as their leader with all the courage of a warrior stepping over the body of a fallen commander. He put his arm round her and eased her away from the crowd. "Dwalin, please, can you take her inside? Find her some water, perhaps?"
"Aye, you keep things smooth out here," Dwalin nodded, and despite some weak protests from Dis, he escorted her up the steps and through the doors of the great hall.
--
Kili had no idea what was going on. He'd been woken before dawn for a short breakfast and chance to wash and dress. They’d taken his uniform and given him plain clothes to wear, slightly oversized, but he managed to roll the sleeves and the hems up until they didn’t look too humiliating. Then he’d been led through tunnels and over bridges and under lower levels of the City until they came through a small door to a simple chamber with a large desk and two chairs. For some time he waited here, with guards on the doors. He assumed he was finally going to be questioned for the investigation, and was trying to remember everything that could possibly be relevant in the days leading up to Tauriel’s death, and practise the words in Sindarin because he thought that might help. Then a clerk came in and said, “The magistrate and the prosecutor will be in shortly.”
“The magistrate? For what?”
The clerk stared at him for a moment. “Your trial.”
Kili felt like he was falling through the floor. “My trial? Now? But no one’s even asked me for my side of the story.”
“You will have your chance to answer their questions, and speak in your own defence,” the clerk assured him. “Once all sides of the story have been told, the magistrate will decide the truth of the matter.”
“S-speak?” Kili balled his fists on his knees. “Can’t I… can’t someone speak for me?”
The clerk shook his head. He was short for an elf, and very slight, his clothes of a particularly fine weave with a long silk shirt beneath a tunic, his skin pale and unfreckled. He did not look like he had left the heart of the City for years. Nevertheless, he didn’t seem to have any fear of Kili, even though Kili was unbound and sitting a few feet from him. So Kili must not look like a brutal murderer. That was a good sign, wasn’t it?
“I… in dwarven courts, you usually have a friend who’s a good orator, or pay someone if you can, to present your case…” Kili said weakly.
“That’s not how it’s done by the City law,” the Clerk explained. “But you could have requested it if you’re really afraid to speak. I don’t think there’s time, now.”
“No one told me!”
The clerk looked a little irritated. “Ignorance is no excuse. You’ve lived here your whole life, haven’t you?”
“Yes, but I’ve never been arrested before!” Kili burst out, jabbing both his hands towards the magistrate’s empty desk. “Can I not have anyone with me? My brother–”
“I’m sorry, the room is too small to allow it.”
The door opened behind him, but it was just someone with a message. Kili buried his face in his hands and tried to think. He was trying to be brave, but he knew that at some point, they would surely ask him about the death. Which meant they would have to tell him about the death. Which meant he would have to hear someone describe to him how Tauriel had died. Forget speaking in his own defence: he didn’t think he could sit there listening to that and not throw himself on the floor and scream until his lungs gave out. He had spent the last two days trying not to imagine it. He had not slept very much.
The small clerk returned. “There’s been a delay. Wait here.”
He nodded and waited. He thought it would be a few minutes, but it went on and on. He wished they would just get it over with. He wanted water, but he didn’t want to ask the guards. Not out of fear, he just felt too proud to need something from them, when they were complicit in this whole ordeal.
After what must have been nearly an hour, the clerk returned and on his instruction, the guards got Kili up and took him out of the room again. Kili wondered if they’d decided to skip the trial and just declare him guilty. The clerk said as they walked a short distance to the door he’d already come through, “They’re moving the proceedings to the Great Hall nearby.”
“Why?”
“To allow family and friends.”
Before Kili could ask if the clerk meant his or Tauriel’s, they crossed a small courtyard and went in through a simple, arched wooden door. On the far side, Kili found himself in a large hall, the columns formed of what looked like the trunks of several ancient, red-barked conifers, the branches grown with patience and direction until they formed the roof beams on which planks had been laid far above. At the end where Kili had been brought in, there was a raised dais with a large desk placed on it, at an angle so that it faced an empty space that seemed to almost glow with malice. The place where the accused would stand when being questioned.
Two wings of railed seats stood on either side of the dais. On the far side sat Prince Legolas and three senior members of the Guard; all fellow captains. Kili knew them all by name and face. They all wore shades of dark, formal clothes. Mourning clothes.
There was one other figure in the far seats, a red-haired elf woman. For the briefest moment, Kili’s mind gave a desperate leap and saw Tauriel sitting beside Legolas, alive and robed in cream and sage. But it was bitterly obvious that it was another elf, who looked nothing alike in face and was narrower in the shoulders. Kili vaguely remembered meeting her once before. Tauriel was an orphan, but she had some more distant relatives; this elf was Mírior, a second cousin on Tauriel’s father’s side. She had a placid look on her face, but she did not take her eyes off Kili as he was led to his seat.
At the other end of the room, several dwarves seemed to be literally building a three-tiered seating structure, hammering the last nails into one end while there were dwarves and elves already filing in to sit at the other end. Kili the first flash of lightness he'd felt in days when he saw his brother, his throat closing up. Fili looked like he’d slept in his braids and dressed in a hurry, in a wrinkled shirt and an old, comfortable doublet. Fili met his eye and nodded at him, and pressed both hands to his chest before he sat down. Their mother came to sit beside him, holding onto Dwalin’s arm, with Balin close behind.
As the guards led Kili to the enclosed seats below the dais, on the opposite side of the room from Legolas, Kili leaned around them to catch Balin’s eye. He mouthed Balin’s name, and gave a small beckoning motion.
Balin glanced around. He hitched up his belt and strode across the hall to where the guards had sat Kili down. He leaned over the rail in front of Kili. “Are you alright, laddie?”
“Balin, they said I have to speak in my own defence,” Kili hissed. “But I can’t, I’ll mess it up, I’m rubbish. Can you…?”
Balin looked at where the gallery at the back was growing increasingly full. Kili could see many of his friends, wearing blue like the colour of his house, and several of his fellow recruits in their uniforms, and even his lieutenant. They didn’t all meet his eye, but they were here. They wanted to see the truth. He had been very glad to see Ma and Fili, and even Dwalin, who he was sure would have defended him even if he’d been caught with a bloodied knife in his hand standing over the body. But the rest of them… they were about to witness possibly the worst day of his life. He wasn’t sure how he felt about them spectating.
“Of course, Kili,” Balin patted his hand. “Let me take care of it.”
The small clerk had appeared beside Balin. “Master Dwarf, you’ll have to return to the gallery.”
“Ah, no, I will not,” Balin raised his bushy eyebrows at him. “I’m the lad’s representative for these proceedings. I’ll be making our case to the magistrate.”
The clerk made a pained face. . He looked like he wanted to protest, but at last decided it was not worth the trouble. “Very well. I’ll note it in the records.”
Balin came around the side of the rail and sat down in the seat beside Kili. He patted Kili’s knee, which Kili realised too late was shaking and tried to make it still. “Right. We’ve got a few seconds. Can you tell me, honestly, is there anything I need to know before this starts?”
Kili had been pressing his chin into his knotted fingers. He glanced sharply at Balin. “Like what? Do you think it was me?”
“I don’t think anything. But it’ll help to have the truth. It sounds like the two of you had your secrets.”
“Balin, no. I would have rather died than hurt her,” Kili shook his head and looked back across the hall at Prince Legolas, who was staring at him with a stony expression. “And if I find out who did it, I’ll kill–”
Just at that moment, the entire court went quiet as a tall, gaunt elf in a long, grey robe emerged through the side door at the back of the hall and walked up to the dais. The last two words out of Kili’s mouth hung in the air, and the clerk who was still standing nearby shot him a sharp glance. Kili buried his face in his hands and tried not to groan out loud, but no one else reacted. However, he was sure that Prince Legolas’ keen ears would have made out his words. He’d watched the commander react to a spider’s web tremble from a hundred yards away. Kili was sure that even if this entire farce cleared his name, Legolas would never see him unstained by the crime. He would never be readmitted to the Guard. Everything he’d worked for was gone.
But at least if he was found innocent he would not be banished. He had always felt like such a worldly adventurer, traipsing around Mirkwood with his fellow young recruits, showing off to his cloistered school friends at home. Few dwarves his age had even completed the relatively safe trip to the Iron Hills to visit family or expand their trade. But Kili had never even gone that far, never even left the boundaries of the forest. He had never needed to. Everyone he cared for was here, in the Woodland City. This was the only home he’d ever known. To be thrown out and never return, to be alone out there trying to make his way without any idea of how anything worked, to never see Fili or Ma or any of his friends again - it was more terrifying than facing a nest of spiders in the dark.
The magistrate, Tulus, called over the clerk for some quiet conversation, pointing at the crowd who were now crammed into the newly-expanded gallery. The clerk winced but shook his head. Kili could only make out the words, “…as many as could sit, you said, I didn’t know they’re make more seats…” Tulus’ face was stormy, but after a moment he collected himself. He intoned some formal introduction of the proceedings. Then, to Kili’s shock, it was Mírior who stood up and was introduced next. She would be speaking for the dead, to make the case against the accused. Kili had not imagined the horror of this. He didn’t know if it was traditional to have a relative present the prosecution case, but he was absolutely sure that it was no accident they had chosen someone who vaguely resembled Tauriel. His knee began to shake again.
The magistrate finally raised his head and pinned Kili with his gaze. “I will give you a final chance here, to confess and receive some clemency in return.”
Kili had not expected a question directed at him so soon. He felt frozen in place, until Balin patted his back. Kili glanced at him and shook his head. Balin spoke up instead, “Your grace, he will not lie. He has no confession to give.”
“I was not asking you,” Magistrate Tulus said.
“I speak on his behalf,” Balin insisted. “You’ll get no other answer.”
“Very well. Then we will continue.”
“My Lord Legolas, we request that you approach,” the clerk called. Legolas stood to his full height and made his way to the dais to stand in front of the magistrate, his hands folded neatly in front.
Mírior stalked across the width of the hall between them, her cream robes flowing behind her, until she could stand and address Legolas while still half turned towards the magistrate. When she spoke, her voice was clear and perfect, and loud enough to be heard around the entire hall. At least she sounded nothing like Tauriel.
“My lord, will you describe what you found, three mornings prior to today?”
Legolas’s jaw grew stiff, and his neat hands clenched around each other. “The body of my friend, Captain Tauriel of the City Guard.”
Kili couldn’t have reacted even if he’d wanted to. His body had become as cold and unyielding as stone, except for his twisting stomach. Everything he’d been afraid to hear was about to come out.
“Will you describe what you saw, in detail?” Mírior asked, as lightly as if requesting he bring her a cup of tea.
Legolas looked down and nodded. His voice croaked when he finally answered. “She was in a narrow, quiet street behind the headquarters of the Guard. She was unarmed. She had been stabbed, here, above the left breast, with her own shortsword,” he pressed his hand above his heart. “There were bruises on her throat. I tried to lift her but she was already heavy.”
The imagining of it filled Kili’s mind, washed over him in beating waves. He closed his eyes and it was worse. He wanted to pluck his own eyes out. Tauriel, all that life inside her, those thousands of years ahead of her, her laugh, her silent tread, her fanciful musings on the world when everything around was quiet, all draining out with the blood. He could not stop himself thinking how much it would have hurt, and wondering whether it had been hard for her to breathe, if she’d known what was happening, or if it had all been too quick.
“How did you know she was there?” Mírior asked.
“I had called a meeting with my captains, inside the Guard’s hall, and Tauriel was missing. We all remarked on it, because it was so unusual for her to be late. Then an elf boy I didn't know came in the door and asked for us to come at once. It was this boy who had found her. He said he heard something and came to look, but he did not look closely before he ran for help. We were the first to see the body up close.”
“When had you last seen Tauriel?”
Legolas said, “The evening before. When she finished her patrol she came to see me at the palace, for a walk in the gardens. She seemed troubled, but wouldn’t tell me why. Some hours later, after midnight, I saw her leaving the palace. There was a dwarf with her,” Legolas said darkly. “The two of them didn’t know I had seen them. They seemed to be keeping to the shadows.”
“Can you name the dwarf she was with?”
Legolas looked directly at Kili, but at last he said, “No. He wore a long cloak and a hood. I couldn’t see his face. But from the neck down, I’m certain he did not have much of a beard.”
There was a murmur from the gallery. Kili resisted the urge to touch his chin self-consciously. Who had Tauriel been with? It couldn’t have been him. He’d been miles away, on his forest patrol. But how many beardless dwarves would Tauriel be sneaking around with after midnight? Legolas must be simply lying.
“Was there anything else of note that you found with Tauriel’s body?”
“Yes,” Legolas swallowed and waved his hand at the desk where Tulus sat, his quill poised. “I believe it was given to the magistrate for inspection. It’s on his desk.”
“Will you show the magistrate, and the court, to confirm it’s what you found?”
Legolas stepped up to the desk and took a small, silk bag that had been laid beside Tulus’ papers. From within, he lifted out a long, dark braid of hair with a glint of silver at the end and held it up, turning so that no one could miss it.
Kili thought he would throw up. He knew exactly what that was.
“A braid of hair,” Legolas said, his voice growing louder. “It was clutched in her hand so tight we had to work to unlock her fingers and retrieve it. Torn from her killer’s head as she struggled against him. It is tied at the end with a clasp, imprinted with a sigil of Durin the Deathless.”
There was at last a reaction from the crowd; many reactions, gasps of shock and anger, and Dwalin raising his voice in disbelief. Kili couldn’t look at them. He didn’t hear his mother or brother among the cacophony. He stared at the wood of the railing right in front of. He was doomed. How could he possibly pretend it wasn’t his hair? Even Fili and Mother must be questioning his innocence, now.
“And who do you think this braid belongs to?” Mírior asked.
“Him.”
Kili could sense Legolas pointing at him, like a hot beam of sunlight, but he couldn’t bring himself to raise his head. He wished he could shrink into something mindless, like a mushroom, perhaps, and just melt away under that burning beam.
“Do you know the accused?” Mírior asked Legolas. “Do you know if he knew Captain Tauriel well?”
Here it was. Of course they knew about their affair. Of course they would use it against him. Legolas said bitterly, “I know he was too familiar with her, though she vastly outranked him. I know he followed her out of the Guard's barracks sometimes, when he thought no one was looking. She was too kind and she did not report his little idolatries, but his lieutenant, Fainthel, discussed her suspicions with me. I believe he was obsessed with her.”
Kili raised his head to look at the crowd in the gallery. Across the vast space, Fainthel met his eye for a moment, and then looked away, a faint flush rising in her neck. Kili wasn’t sure, but he thought he saw her shake her head a little. Fainthel had asked Kili once, during a pause in regular training in the barracks, “The Captain’s always hanging around when our unit is sparring, isn’t she?” and Kili had said too quickly, “I don’t know what you’re talking about. I’ve barely noticed her.” Fainthel had shrugged and tossed him a towel. “I’m just saying, son, if you don’t feel you can turn her down, you let me know. I’ll have a word, tell her I don’t want you distracted and she’s to leave you be.” Kili had stammered a protestation, and she had never mentioned it again. She had clearly suspected something, but if she had really discussed it with Legolas, he was sure it would have been in regards to Kili’s welfare, not Tauriel’s. But perhaps whatever words Fainthel had used, Legolas had heard something different.
Mírior turned as she spoke next, gesturing to the magistrate and then to the crowd. “Thank you, my lord. You may go.”
Legolas started to step away from the magistrate’s desk, but before he could, a low voice called, “Excuse me, my lord Legolas. May I approach?”
Kili looked up at Balin, who had risen to his feet and raised his hand. Legolas paused and looked to Tulus for guidance. Tulus nodded, “Of course.”
Balin went around the side of the railing. Smiling, he walked towards the dais. Alone on the wide, herringbone floor, he looked too small for the shape of the room. But like Mírior, his voice carried loud and well. He said, “May I come up on the dais? My old neck can’t take the craning to look up at you.”
Tulus paused in his writing to wave his hand. “I’ll allow it.”
“Thank you, your grace,” Balin climbed up the steps and stood facing Legolas, like two players on a stage. He clasped his hand behind his back. “Could you show us one more time, where the sword was? In Captain Tauriel. Just so we are absolutely sure.”
Legolas gave him a dark look, but again he touched the spot above his heart. “Here.”
“And you say it was her sword? And she was unarmed?”
Legolas nodded.
Balin turned a little, as if considering. “This was the standard style of shortsword carried by the Guard? Usually twinned, worn on the hip or behind the shoulders?”
“Yes,” Legolas said.
“And did Tauriel usually carry these twin swords?”
“Yes,” Legolas said again.
“But there was no other sword?” Balin pressed. When Legolas finally shook his head, Balin asked, “Did you search for it?”
“The street was searched for anything unusual,” Legolas said at last. “Nothing more was found.”
“Was it common for Tauriel to forget one of her swords, on the way to a meeting with her commander and her fellow captains?”
Legolas’ face was furious, now. “Of course not. She was an exemplary warrior of my Guard. She was my best Captain.”
“So her killer must have taken the second sword? If anyone else had encountered the body, it would be a dangerous thing to steal. A thief would be liable to be arrested themselves, for carrying a weapon within the City bounds. And if it had been discarded soon after, anyone who found it would surely have reported it by now.”
“I suppose.”
“Kili was seized not five hundred yards from the Guard’s headquarters, if I have been told correctly, and perhaps half an hour after you found Tauriel’s body. He was not hiding. In fact, he claimed he was returning to the headquarters.”
“Yes.”
“Did he have the sword?”
Legolas said, though gritted teeth. “No. But we don’t know when she died. He could have had hours to hide it.”
“She lay on a public street without discovery? For hours? Even at that time of the morning?”
“We have no way to know,” Legolas insisted.
“Of course. Thank you, those are my questions. I apologise if I’ve caused you distress,” Balin turned and went back down the steps of the dais. His footsteps seemed very loud as he crossed back to sit down with Kili.
The magistrate finished writing something down and then said dryly, “You may go, Legolas.”
“Ah, yes, of course,” Legolas hurried down the dais.
“Do you wish to speak to anyone else, Mírior?”
“I would like to speak to the accused,” Mírior said.
“The accused should approach the dais,” the clerk called. Balin stood up to let Kili past, and Kili walked what seemed like miles, the hall so silent he could hear his own heart pounding. He stood in the open space where he was told, where Legolas had been standing a minute before. He felt dizzy with the number of faces turned towards him, the myriad of different expressions, hostility and hope and uncertainty. He tried to focus on Fili and Ma. They were completely blank, like wooden models of themselves carved and painted to look like real dwarves.
Mírior stood a few feet from the dais, her hands clasped in front of her. "You are the son of Vili, son of Vali, is that correct?"
Kili shrugged. "Yes."
"Your father was also convicted of a violent act, is this true? He beat his elven neighbour half to death, not so long ago?"
Kili frowned. "That was decades ago. I haven't seen my father in years. He left the family when I was barely in trousers. He lives in an alms house somewhere, with a head injury, unable to speak more than a word at a time. My mother pays for his upkeep."
“Who raised you, then?”
“My uncle, for the most part.”
"Ah yes - would this be the uncle who was accused of a serious theft and disappeared before his trial, true?"
There was an audible ripple of grumbles from the dwarves at the back of the room.
"My uncle was the grandson of the King Under the Mountain," Kili said, feeling heat rise around his collar. "He was wrongly accused because he was too well-liked in this City and somebody wished to bring him low. He was building a new school with donations from rich dwarves, and he was accused of training child soldiers. But it was not true, it was a Khuzdul language school. The money was taken when the authorities searched his house, probably by some corrupt minor official. My uncle stole nothing."
Mírior nodded. "And you thought yourself special as well, did you? The first dwarf to be admitted to the Guard, to be permitted to carry a weapon in the City since the law was made. Did you think yourself apart from others, deserving of more than your fellows? Did you think yourself so big and brave that Captain Tauriel might even love you, if you pursued her long enough?"
"How we felt about each other is none of your business," Kili spat. "You'll just twist anything I say."
There was a noise of someone loudly and dramatically clearing their throat, and Balin stood up. "Excuse me, your grace. May we pause so that I can have a word with my charge?"
Tulus folded his hands in front of him, his face neutral. After a moment he said. "You have a minute," he waved his hand at Kili. "Master Dwarf, please go down to your representative."
Kili hurried down the steps. Balin had come out onto the floor and met him halfway, but took his shoulder and bent him down close so they could not easily be overheard. "Kili, do you understand that this is a show trial? And that means you have to put on a show?"
"Why? Everyone's already decided on my guilt," Kili said bitterly.
"For your mother's sake, please collect yourself and listen to me. Think about what you've just given them; that your father is a destitute criminal, that your disreputable uncle fled justice rather than obey the law, and that you are hiding some secret to do with Tauriel. Is that what you meant to say, or were you briefly possessed by some dark spirit?"
Kili hissed. "It's not fair. It's all a sham."
"You have to convince them," Balin said patiently. "Forget about Mírior and forget about the Magistrate. Think about your friends and your people in that crowd. Convince them. Even think about defending yourself to Prince Legolas, your commander. He wants the truth to come out as much as you do," Balin pointed at the gallery. "They have not yet made up their minds. They want to believe in you. When Mírior asks a question, tell the truth, but don't give her more information than you need to. She is trying to get you to run ahead of her into a trap. Think about what you say before you say it; channel a little of Thorin's patience. And look humble, for Mahal's sake. I know that's difficult for you."
Kili nodded. "I'll try."
"Please return to your place, Master Dwarf," the magistrate said in a bored voice.
Balin gripped his arm and nodded at him. "When she's finished with you, it will be my turn."
Kili went back up to stand on the dais. Mírior paced in front of him, apparently for the effect of it, and then stopped and looked at him. "Legolas has already said that you were too familiar with Captain Tauriel. What did he mean by that?"
Kili swallowed. He tried to think about how Legolas had managed to stand here and look dignified. He folded his arms in front and dropped the hunch out of his shoulders. Thinking of what Balin had said, he tried to make his voice sound humble as he answered. "We were in love."
He'd taken caution too far and spoken too quietly. Mírior had heard him, and Tulus paused in his writing to focus on him, but Mírior glanced at the gallery to confirm they were leaning forward to listen. "Could you say that again?"
"I said, we were in love," Kili repeated, louder this time. There were whispers from the gallery, a few nods between people who had clearly heard some gossip and were pleased to have it confirmed.
"Was that what you believed? Think to yourself. Does it really seem likely, in the light of day, that Captain Tauriel was interested in a... low-ranking recruit?"
Kili let out a long, slow breath until all the curses he wanted to spit at her faded. "We kept our relationship secret. We met at least once a week for the past six months. After our shifts, never on duty. We talked about marriage, about petitioning for an exception to the age laws. But she wanted to wait until I could request reassignment under a different captain."
"And can anyone confirm these meetings took place?"
"No. I just said it was a secret relationship," Kili said. To his relief, this earned a few, small laughs from the gallery at the back.
"But no one else can back up your claim that Tauriel loved you as you loved her? No one knew?" Mírior insisted.
"Oh, as it turns out, everyone knew," Kili said. More laughs, some a little louder. For just a moment, he actually wanted to smile, but he caught himself. He didn't think Magistrate Tulus would take that well.
Mírior looked a little annoyed now. "And did you meet her the night she died?"
Kili shook his head. He said, "We had stopped our trysts, two weeks before Tauriel… before all this happened. I told her I was ending it. My mother had figured out what we were doing together, and she said I was risking my position in the Guard. She didn't want me to ruin my future."
He glimpsed a movement in the gallery, and looked over to see Dis with her face in her hands, leaning into Dwalin's side. After a moment she raised her head, pushing her hair back into place. Kili looked back at Mírior.
"You ended the relationship?" Mírior pressed.
"Yes. I told my brother right away. You can ask him."
"Your brother is not a neutral witness."
Mírior went close enough to the dais that she could reach out to take the braid of dark hair that Legolas had put back on the corner of Tulus' desk. She held it up again. "Is this yours?"
Kili hesitated. It felt like the worst thing he could admit to, after how Legolas had described it. It would be like admitting that a pile of bloodied clothes were his. He glanced quickly at Balin, who shook his head: don't give them this. Mírior waited only a moment longer before she answered for him. "It has the crest of your family. Who else would wear such a trinket? It's clearly not your brother's. If it's not yours, then who did it come from? Your mother?"
"It's mine," Kili said in a rush. He wanted to explain more, but Balin had told him to do no more than answer her questions. But he needed to make them see it differently.
Mírior put the braid back on the desk. "Thank you. The story seems clear to me. Perhaps there was a mutual relationship, perhaps there was not. But it had ended. I think you shirked your patrol duties to meet Tauriel at the palace the night before her death; perhaps that’s when she told you to stay away. But you couldn’t control yourself. You had to see Tauriel one last time. You knew her schedule, you knew she would be at the headquarters that day. You waited for her, lured her into the quiet back-street. She refused your advances, whatever your intentions were. In a rage you throttled her and killed her with her sword, so that there would be no blood on your own weapons. But as she died she managed to rip the braid from your head. You fled with the second sword and disposed of it somewhere, perhaps some waterway, and pretended you had just returned from your patrol outside the city when Prince Legolas caught you."
Kili felt his spirit growing smaller and smaller inside his body, like it was being compressed into a cold, dead, seed of whatever he had been before. It was a horror story worse than he could have believed. He could see it in his own mind, Mírior painted such a convincing picture; his hand around Tauriel’s neck, the blade gripped in an awkward stabbing position, her ripping at his hair in desperation. He wished he could at least sit down, instead of standing here as all those eyes held him, crushing into his place.
"I have no more questions," said Mírior. She started to walk back towards the benches where Legolas and the captains were sitting, but again there was a noise from Balin for attention.
"My gentle lady, would you mind remaining for a moment?" He took a few steps towards her.
Mírior frowned at him, and then at Tulus. At last she said. "Of course."
"Thank you. If you could stand here, just as you are," Balin cleared his throat. "Your grace, would you permit Kili to come and stand with us? Then he may return for further questions."
Tulus narrowed his eyes a little. "You may not intimidate the counsel for the dead, Master Dwarf."
"I won't, your grace, I intend to do quite the opposite," Balin raised his hands. At last, Tulus nodded, and Balin beckoned for Kili to come and stand beside him. Tulus had to lean forward slightly to see them all over the rim of the desk, and there was a growing series of whispers from the gallery of observers. Legolas had leaned forward as well, though he looked poised as if ready to leap up and defend Mírior if this was somehow a way of threatening her.
Balin stood Kili as close to Mírior as seemed comfortable, so they were both facing Tulus at his desk. Then Balin took hold of Kili's right arm as if he was a marionette and raised it up. "There we go lad, can you raise it any higher?" He asked loudly.
Kili shook his head. He was not sure what Balin was doing. He hand was just barely high enough that he could have grabbed Mírior’s neck if he’d wanted to. This seemed to prove nothing.
"Thank you. Now," Balin began to pace between the two of them and Tulus' desk. Kili wasn’t sure what he was supposed to do with his hand so he left it hanging in the air. "Prince Legolas was very clear that Tauriel was struck once in the heart, from above. It is a long time since I've held a sword, even a short one, but the principle should be clear even to our younger friends who've never seen battle. In order to achieve such a motion, her killer would have to generate the strength and range to pierce deep enough to reach her heart. To do that, they would direct the sword in an arc from above the point of contact. Perhaps beginning their strike even higher than Tauriel's head, certainly higher than her left breast. Kili, can you reach that high, even standing fully upright?"
Kili mumbled, "No, sir."
"No, not even close. It would be impossible for a dwarf to execute such a motion. If a dwarf wanted to strike an elf in the heart, especially a dwarf who knew how to use a sword, as Kili does, they would strike from below, under the ribs and through the liver."
Kili felt himself flinch and dropped his arm. Mírior opened her mouth to say something, but it was Tulus who spoke. "Perhaps he forced her to her knees. There is the bruising on her throat."
Balin looked at him sharply. There was a yell from someone in the gallery - Kili thought it sounded like Ori - "You're not supposed to take sides!" The heckler was hurriedly hushed by someone else.
Balin raised his hands, indicating that he was done with Mírior and that Kili should return to his place on the dais. While they both went back to their places, Balin continued to speak. "Perhaps, yes. Perhaps this strong Captain, an exemplary warrior of the Guard, who had defended these woods from orcs and spiders for over a thousand years, perhaps she was overcome and disarmed by one young recruit only two years into his probationary duties. Or perhaps he stood on a chair? Or hung from a rope ladder? Which I'm sure he disposed of in a canal somewhere with the second sword."
Tulus straightened up, and for the first time he had a flicker of emotion on his face. "Do not mock these proceedings, Master Dwarf, or I will have you removed from the hall and the accused can speak for himself."
"My apologies," Balin put his hand on his heart and bowed quickly. "I only mean to show you the ridiculousness of Mírior’s story, and draw you all to the conclusion that seems undeniable to me. Tauriel was not murdered by a dwarf. She was killed by someone at least as tall as her."
His gaze swept around the room, lingering nowhere but touching all the watching elves in particular. He waited to see if Mírior or Tulus had anything else to counter him, and when they didn't speak, he began to pace again. “Legolas says he saw Tauriel with a beardless dwarf in the palace, at midnight. Where were you around midnight, Kili?”
Kili swallowed. “On patrol somewhere north of the Stargazer Hill, I believe.”
“How far is that from the palace?”
“About five miles.”
“Did any of your comrades see you, during your patrol?”
Kili shrugged. “Maybe not precisely at midnight, but our patrol routes did cross a few times.”
Balin turned to Tulus. “May I call additional witnesses, your grace?”
Tulus glowered. “No. You should have requested that before we began.”
Balin let that answer sit tensely in the air for a moment, and gave the gallery a knowing glance. At last he continued. “Very well. Let us view this from the other perspective: if Kili had shirked his duties, his captain Fainthel and his fellow guards would surely be able to tell us, and it would lay great suspicion on the accused. Mírior would surely have called them herself, if it was the case. I would conclude, therefore, that Kili was on patrol that night, and whoever Tauriel was meeting at the palace was someone else. This sighting by Lord Legolas - of someone glimpsed at night from a distance, with their hood up - is therefore entirely irrelevant to the question at hand.”
“That’s quite a conclusion,” Mírior said loudly from where she sat.
“I don’t believe it’s your turn to speak,” Balin replied calmly. He went closer to the desk. "Would you let me look at this famous braid, your Grace?"
Tulus sighed and reached over to pick it up in two fingers and drop it into Balin's gloved hands. Balin took a moment to examine it. The untied end was beginning to come apart, but he tried to hold it together as he held it up. "I do not mean to quibble," he said, looking over at Mírior, who was now sitting next to Legolas again. "But this braid has been repeatedly described as 'torn' and 'ripped'. That is not how it appears to me. The end is not frayed or ragged, the strands are all of even length. It appears, to me, to have been cut."
He brought the braid close to Mírior, as if showing it to her for the first time. "Can you tell me otherwise?" When she didn’t answer, he went to hold it towards Tulus as well to make the point. Finally, he turned to Kili. "Did you cut this from your own head?"
Kili nodded. "Yes."
"Why?"
Kili tried to speak loudly and clearly, as Balin was doing, but all he could manage was a hoarse whisper. "I gave it to her, two weeks ago, when I asked that we end the affair. As a promise that what I felt for her wouldn’t change." He tilted his head and drew back his hair over one shoulder to show the place at the base of his neck where the small patch of hair was shorn. “Here.”
Balin stretched his neck, but from down below and several feet away he probably couldn’t see much. Kili turned a little to show Tulus. “Can you see it, your grace?”
Tulus leaned forward a little too, squinting. He said neutrally. “Perhaps. It’s not clear.”
Balin nodded and jumped in before the confusion could disrupt the flow of his story. "But you admit the braid was yours. And she had it with her when she died - was holding it so tight they could not easily wrest it from her hand," Balin carefully curled the braid into a circle and went to put it down in front of Mírior. "Prince Legolas believed it was her dying message to identify her killer - but I don't think so. I think this was a treasure that she was holding for comfort, in her last moments. Perhaps she wanted to show that she, too, had kept her promise. Not the behaviour of an elf who had tried to escape the unwanted affections of her former lover."
Balin met Kili’s eye, and then looked away quickly. Kili realised his vision was blurring and wiped his eyes quickly, hanging his head to try and hide it.
Balin continued, addressing the magistrate directly. "What seems more likely, your grace? That one of the finest warriors in this city was careless with both her swords, was disarmed and brought low, and defeated by one young recruit? Or that she was the one wielding the second sword, against not a dwarf but a fellow elf, and someone skilled and experienced in battle, who took one of her weapons and turned it against her? Does the braid show her final attempt to hurt her attacker, or is it a last token of love that she clutched as she realised her life had been cut short?" Balin spread his arms wide and turned from Tulus to the rest of the room, first to Legolas and his captains, then the watching dwarves and elves in the gallery, and finally around to Kili standing on the dais. "The answer seems clear. Kili was an easy scapegoat, but he is not a murderer. He is telling the truth."
Kili could see several people nodding in the crowd in the gallery, and some thudding of hands on knees in agreement. Legolas was sitting back in his seat, his arms folded, but his face looked drawn and tired rather than angry, now. Someone in the crowd called, "Here, here!"
Tulus slapped his hand down on the surface of the desk. "I will have quiet. The proceedings are not over. Mírior, do you have any answer to this?”
Mírior paused for a moment. She stood up from her seat but did not approach the dais. "I have no more questions, your grace, because none more are needed. There is only one suspect. Master Balin weaves an absurd tale full of strange coincidences. A beardless dwarf skulking in the shadows of the palace, who cannot be named or found. A mystery assassin who appears in Master Balin's story and then disappears without leaving any trace behind. All of this to explain away details that point to the obvious murderer. No elf would have reason to harm Tauriel, who was beloved by many and hated by none. This was a crime of youthful, base passions by a lovestruck boy--"
Again, a voice from the crowd, and this time Kili thought he recognised Fainthel. "He's not a child, Mírior, he's a grown dwarf!"
Mírior raised her voice to drown out the heckling, "--from a violent, criminal lineage of dwarves--"
Now the outrage came from multiple voices, Dwalin's loudest among them, "How dare you insult the royal line of our people--"
"--and his refusal to admit to his proclivities only speaks further of his danger to this City--"
“—you lying, point-eared hypocrites—!”
"Enough!" Tulus stood up and roared at last. The growing noise of the rabble went silent. He leaned forward and rested his fingertips on the desk, scowling at the gallery. "If counsel has no further case to make, I will retire to consider what I have heard. I will not be disturbed until that time."
He gathered up his papers and stormed towards the door. As he went, he crooked two fingers at Mírior and she hastily climbed down from her seat and followed at a slightly undignified jog. Kili was left standing on the dais until the small clerk said. "You can sit down, if you want."
Balin followed him back to the seat and settled beside him. He patted his knee again. "We did the best we could, laddie. And I think there are many who believe you."
"Many? How could anyone think otherwise?" Kili said, finding himself cracking his knuckles to loosen the tension in his hands. Every muscle in his body felt like he'd been standing rigid to attention in a cold storm for hours. "You proved it. You did so much, Balin. I'd never have seen all those holes in their claims. I didn't have a clue what happened until you laid it all out."
"Aye, of course you didn't," Balin said. "You wouldn't know how she was killed if you weren't there, would you?"
“And you’re right. It had to be an elf, someone skilled. Someone from the Guard. Not Legolas, I’m sure of it, his hatred of me when he arrested me couldn’t have been an act. And now we’ll have a chance to find the real killer.”
“We?” Balin asked.
“Fili and I, we’ll get them.” Kili said confidently. “I’m going to hunt them down and reveal them, no matter who they are. They’re not going to get away with it.”
“Yes. Of course.” Balin said quietly.
Kili looked over at the gallery. Dis and Fili were the only ones sitting silent and watchful, both looking about as exhausted as Kili felt. The rest of the spectators were in excitable discussions with each other. Fainthel and Berior had their heads together, and although Haered seemed to be twisting around in his seat to argue with them, they both dismissed him quickly. Kili could see some of the dwarves at the back of the stands hurrying out and others returning, despite what looked like some feeble protests from the guards that they should remain seated. They must be going out to spread the news about what had just happened. He felt a growing glow of hope in his chest. That meant there were people outside waiting to hear his fate. He wasn't alone. He'd never been as alone as he'd felt in that cell.
They did not have to wait long. The guards at the back door announced the return of the Magistrate. There was hushing and then utter silence as Tulus and Mírior returned. Mírior went back to sit beside Legolas, who appeared too lost in thought to greet her. Tulus stood on the dais, in the same place Legolas and Kili had stood, and folded his hands in front of him.
"The accused will come forward," he said.
Balin stayed at Kili's side as they went forward to the centre of the hall, looking up at Tulus. Balin had been right; you had to really crane your neck back from down here, and it made you feel smaller and weaker than ever. Just another part of the City that had, unspoken, been designed to put dwarves at a disadvantage.
"Kili, son of Vili, I have determined that you are guilty of the murder of Captain Tauriel," Tulus said. "You will be exiled forthwith from this City--"
Whatever else he said was lost in the gale of rage and jeers from the back of the hall. Balin said nothing, but out of the corner of his eye, Kili saw him bow his head in resignation. Kili managed to keep standing, though he could no longer feel his legs. He stared at Tulus, and then looked down, and then back over his shoulder. His mother was leaning over the railing, her hand on her mouth, and though he could hear no sound from her, her face was twisted as if in a scream. Almost all the dwarves and elves in the gallery were on their feet, shouting and pointing and thumping their chests. As if it would do any good. Nothing they could have done would do any good. It had been fated from the beginning, he realised. From the moment Tauriel's body was discovered, he had been doomed.
Fili vaulted over the railing and dashed the length of the hall. He reached Kili's side and seized his hand, calling to Tulus. "I'll go with him. You can't send him alone."
"You cannot. No resident of this City may help him or give him guidance in his banishment. He is to be treated as one dead," Tulus replied. The roars from behind them quieted down a little as the crowd listened to this exchange. Kili was hearing everything but it felt like his mind was very far away, unable to react or stop Fili.
"Then I renounce this city and any claim it has on me!" Fili cried. "Make me an outlaw too if you will, but I'm not leaving his side!"
At the back of the room, Kili heard his mother scream, "Fili, no, Fili, don't do this! I can't lose you both!"
Tulus shook his head. "You do not want to share his fate, son."
"Don't bloody tell me what I want!" Fili growled. "This is my choice!"
"Very well. Then I sentence you both to exile," Tulus nodded at the guards. "Bind them and take them away."
Kili didn't fight as they tied his arms, though he heard Fili struggling a little, "This is ridiculous. I'm coming of my own free will. Give us some dignity, for Mahal's sake."
The only thing that could make him shudder was the sound of his mother continuing to scream Fili's name as they were marched away.
--
Legolas was troubled.
He waited where he sat until the rest of the hall was almost empty, though Mírior tried to call him to walk with her. He couldn't read her face. He wanted to ask her why she had been allowed to follow Tulus out of the hall for the final deliberations, while Master Balin was not so privileged. What had there been to discuss in private? But he couldn't think of how to phrase the question in a way that wasn't an accusation, so he just waved her to go.
It didn't make sense. Not anymore. He tried to think of how the fatal blow could have happened. He had sparred with Tauriel many times, had seen her in combat with many foes. She never fell. She never got off-balance. Would she really have ended up on her knees so easily, on the smooth and familiar streets of her home? And if she had been standing, how could the dwarf have struck such a blow, with such force, with such precision? Why hadn’t Legolas seen it before?
The narrative had seemed so blindingly obvious, when he'd first found the braid in her hand. He thought he had seen them in the palace together, confirming all his suspicions of their intimacy, his fears that he would never have Tauriel’s affection. The story was so clear: that what he had seen in the palace was Tauriel ending the affair, and that her lecherous, spurned lover, strong enough to knock her over and arrogant enough from his ill-gotten success in the Guard, had killed her in the street and left her there for hours like a discarded piece of clothing. And she had been dead for hours. Legolas knew death. Tauriel’s body had been cold and immobile when he'd touched her, tried desperately to rouse her, tried to hold her and give some life from his own fea. Her spirit had flown long before he found her.
The seeds of his doubt had started to grow in the days before the trial. Fainthel had taken Legolas aside and told him, "My commander, Kili was on patrol in the forest all night. His comrades saw him. I saw him. How did he get back to headquarters in time to ambush Tauriel?"
Whoever he had seen in the palace with Tauriel, it was not Kili. Nevertheless, Legolas adjusted the story in his own mind. Obviously Kili had killed her in the morning, as she was walking to meet Legolas at the headquarters. He gripped Fainthel’s shoulder and assured her, "The trial will answer everything."
He had been so sure. It wasn't the sword or the braid that had really convinced him. It was Kili's face, when Legolas and the two constables had seized him on the street outside that pub. His guilt and fear of punishment seemed as clear as the words in a book. But now, when Legolas tried to grasp that surety, it smeared in his fingers like wet ink dripping off the pages.
Had he just helped convict an innocent dwarf?
When there was only a clerk and one of the guards remaining, Legolas got up and walked towards the side door closest to him, away from where they had taken the two condemned dwarves. He could hear the distant rumbling of a crowd outside, and he had no intention of facing them. He knew a route out the back of the hall that would take him back to the palace and to quiet places to think. He wanted to go up to the rooftop gardens, walk the paths he has taken with Tauriel the night before she died. Perhaps he could bring back some sense of her, some trace of her spirit. Perhaps she would tell him what had really happened.
But it seemed his movements were too predictable. As he left the hall and tried to slip away down the corridor, he heard a cry and saw the shape of the dwarf’s mother, Princess Dis, as she threw herself on him. Her cousins, Balin and Dwalin, stood back in the shadows as if they didn't know whether to pull her away or join her. Legolas flinched, reaching for the knives he would have worn when on duty, but he was in formal robes and unarmed. But the dam was not attacking him; she fell to her knees and gripped his legs, looking up at him in supplication.
"Please, my lord, please stop this," she sobbed. "You can speak to your father. He can change the sentence to life imprisonment, put him in a cell beneath the City, never let him see daylight again, you cannot say it will not be a fitting punishment. And then his brother will stay in the City and live."
Legolas swallowed. He crouched down, forcing her to release her grip but bringing their faces almost level. "My father cannot change the law for the pity of one dwarf," he said gently. "Every family would plead for his mercy whenever justice is meted out."
"It is not justice. You were there. You have eyes, you have ears, you have a heart. Do not let your grief cloud your judgement," Dis' voice was edged with accusation now. "Please don't let them take both my children, my Lord, I will do anything. Tell your father I will take their place in exile."
"That is not how it is done," Legolas insisted. "Take heart that they will be together in their banishment."
"Together in death," Dis whispered. "Let them take me, I will be the victim of the king’s justice, if he will only spare my sons. Please, go to your father while there is still time."
"What do you mean?"
"I will swear to the king, on the lives of my children, I will keep silent even at the ruin of my own people," she said, and tears flowed down her face as she suppressed a heaving sob. "I cannot lose them both, not like this."
Legolas stood up. "Gods give you fortitude," he said quietly. "I must go."
He left her kneeling, weeping into her hands, as Dwalin tried to lift her to her feet.
