Chapter Text
The dragon pursued Thranduil towards the gate, smashing through the elegant, stone archway that had welcomed travellers for over a century, flinging wide the wrought-iron gates of the Woodland City to crash apart on twisted, broken hinges. Thranduil’s horse made a valiant effort to escape, but even the legendary horses of ancient myth could never have outrun a fully grown dragon for long. Smaug gained four yards for every five that Thranduil fled. But that was enough. He only needed to draw the dragon just outside the City, to the great, open cathedral of trees and bare-packed earth that formed the road right in front of the main gate.
When he got to the end of the huge colonnade of trees, he leaped off the horse and let her gallop into the forest. He spun and snatched the long-necked bottle from his belt. Cracking off the top with the edge of his spear, he tipped the dark, viscous liquid along the length of the blade until it dripped like treacle and hissed upon the grass at his feet.
As Smaug tensed his neck to strike, a thin, silvery rope shot across his eyeline, carried by an arrow from high in one of the columnar trees, which buried itself in a trunk on the far side. Smaug’s keen sight spotted it and drew back a little, like a rambler encountering a single spiderweb across the path and recoiling from the discomfort. Then another rope flew from one side of the trees to the other, and then half a dozen, and then twenty, as the praetorians fired arrow after arrow of anchored cords. They made a net of threads above and below Smaug’s body. He writhed to shake them off, but despite their lightness they were stronger than steel cables, and all that broke was some of the arrows that anchored them into the far trees, the ropes tensing and then pinging through the air to whip or wrap themselves around his wings and tail.
“Pathetic little spiders! You cannot hope to trap me!” Smaug roared.
There was the bright, high peal of a horn and the gaps between the trees were full of the Forest Guard, a mass of grey-green moving in sync to harry the dragon from both sides with arrows and spears. A handful of the bravest and most swift-footed ran across and even between the dragon’s legs, spooling out more of the strong rope from one side of the trees to the other to entangle his ankles.
Smaug began to flail with more frenzy. He could not fully spread his wings between the columns of trees, though he slammed his shoulder from one side to the other, trying to topple them. But their roots went down as deep as their canopies, fifty or even seventy feet into the black, rich soil and stones of the woodland, and only one or two began to lean under the barrage of blows. Even if he had had room to spread his wings, it would have taken an enormous leap with every ounce of his strength to get upwards high enough to clear the top branches, and so get enough clear air beneath himself for a single downstroke, which was the bare minimum he would need to get airborne. Such a leap was not possible until he could get himself untangled from the cursed ropes. On their own they were thin enough to snap when he put his weight against him, or to cut with his teeth when he reached back to bite at them, but there were too many to break at once and he could not turn in the enclosed space to reach them all.
That was when the praetorians high in the branches leaped from their perches, their long spears dripping with black poison. They landed like cats on the dragon’s back, clutching for handholds on his shining scales. The tips of their spears dug in between the scales, stabbing for weak points or trying to lever them up to expose the wiry flesh beneath. But they could not pierce his armour.
Smaug roared, a wail of pure, vainglorious, almost offended rage. He turned, looking over his own shoulder. He opened his mouth and fire poured out, scalding his own back and tail but obliterating several of the filthy fleas that were trying to bite him. He swept the trail of fire around in a great arc, filling the forest on his right flank with fire until his head was facing the elf king again. He drew in a few long, outraged breaths as he stared at the tiny figure of Thranduil, who was brandishing a spear that was to Smaug no larger than a pencil.
“Some of your people I might have spared, as my chattel,” he hissed. “But now - none!”
The rumble of his voice did not seem to fade. It was replaced by the thudding of bootsteps, as a hundred, two hundred, three hundred dwarves poured out the broken gates and through the shattered holes in the walls. They were armed with hatchets, hooks, pick-axes, even large, hand-sized bolts or nails, and they broke over the dragon and began to climb him like termites swarming from a mound; they were young dwarves, born under the trees, and they could climb as well as elves. They went for the wings first, using their weight to pin the thin phalanges down and puncture the membranes between, then some reached his neck and like the praetorians they used the scales and ridges to clamber up. Smaug squirmed, trying to throw them off, but they were sure-footed and strong-gripped and not weighed down by armour, and even when he shook the damned things off some would fall and get up again, limping at worst, and claw their way up again. The sheer weight of dozens of them was enough that his neck bent lower and lower, closer to the ground, as if in supplication before Thranduil.
Smaug opened his mouth and the air rippled as his hot breath boiled in his stomach, but before he could exhale, Thranduil moved swift as a darting swallow and leaped up, into Smaug’s mouth, bracing his feet on the lower row of teeth and stabbing the poison-dripped spear up, into the dragon’s soft palate, deep into his head.
There was a rushing wave of fire and screaming that blew outwards in all directions. The dragon clamped his mouth shut, but Thranduil had propped the spear between his upper and lower jaws and his own strength drove the point further into the tender spaces encompassed by his skull. He flung himself back and forth between the cage of trees, crushing anyone who fell beneath his feet or body, and fire poured indiscriminately from his mouth, but the poison worked its way quickly through his blood to his brain and heart. His frantic writhing began to slow, his joints seemed to seize and then bend under his own weight, and in minutes he lay, claws twitching, eyes rolling, and then was still.
The beautiful columns of living trees were scarred and stripped of their bark, and some leaned outwards on the verge of falling. The fire was spreading in the dry autumn foliage. The air was filled with groans and cries of pain and calls for help. Anyone who could move got to their feet, and carried those who were still speaking or reaching for help. Others, unconscious or beyond survival, were left where they lay. There was no time to even count the dead, let alone retrieve their bodies.
Legolas found himself bruised but standing, calling for his Guards to run, run for the City where the stone wall might provide some shelter, however temporary. He moved as quickly as he could through the mess of torn earth, fallen branches and ruined bodies of elves and dwarves, finding clusters of dazed survivors picking each other up and trying to stem gushes of blood or splint broken limbs. He rallied them and directed them as best he could, trying to convince the most reluctant to leave off their search for their friends and brothers and to save themselves.
At last, afraid to be trapped by the growing fire, he followed them. Fili was at the gate, face streaked with ash, pointing the survivors onwards with his good arm; sending the wounded back towards the main square in front of the palace but keeping back those who looked well enough to walk. It was now the early hours of the morning, and beyond the glow of the street lamps they could see the first red light of dawn between the branches.
Legolas strode up to him, “Your dwarves need to get back on their feet if they can. I’m giving the order to evacuate the city. The fire is in the oldest trees outside the wall. There is no stopping it.”
“We can fight it,” Fili insisted. His voice was hoarse and he was swaying a little. “We contained the fire in the north market. We can slow the forest fire down when it reaches the walls, get trains of buckets from the Ruby Street canal, make another firebreak where New Town meets the palace - even if we save only half the city… even if it’s just to slow the fire…”
“The whole forest is burning.”
“We can’t just give up. This is our home. This is the only home most of us have ever known.”
“I’ve given my orders,” Legolas said firmly. “We’ll carry all the wounded we can and go street to street to get everyone out of their houses. If you can buy us time by slowing the spread of the flames, do as you will, but your dwarves have done more than their share already.”
He turned to begin sorting whoever was left into units as best he could, but Fili called, “Legolas, where’s my brother? Did you see him?” Legolas turned back to him. Fili shook his head. “Kili hasn’t come back through the gate.”
“I saw him charge the dragon with Fainthel when the horn blew, but I have not seen him since. I’m sorry,” Legolas replied, and headed back to his surviving troops.
—
Fire was dancing up the trunks of the huge, ancient trees that lined the great, wide road into the city, dripping upwards along the branches until a tongue or a spark could find purchase on the entwined leaves of the neighbouring trees and spread even further. It was closing into a ring on all sides around the dragon’s body. The rest of the survivors had run for the ruined gap where the main gate had stood, to make the most of the shelter behind the wall. But it wouldn’t be long before the fire leaped over the wall and began to seed itself on the west side of the City.
Kili had never quite lost consciousness, but at some point he must have come pretty close to being crushed, and he could not protect himself. There had been a moment when they had all charged out of the forest together, the young recruits and old veterans of the guard all shoulder to shoulder, and briefly it had seemed like they were a single unit that could not be severed from their comrades. But the chaos and the heat and blood hit them so thick and fast that Kili couldn’t quite remember how he’d ended up at the base of a half-uprooted tree, with his face in the dirt and his ribs aching. He remembered Fainthel sprinting to pull the ropes tight around Smaug’s back leg, and he remembered Haered shoving Kili down onto the ground as the spout of fire went right over their heads, but the heat had sent Haered falling with his hands on his face and Kili could not see either of them now. Now it was quieter, and one of the city constables who he didn’t recognise was shaking his shoulder, telling him to run or die. Kili raised his head and waved him off. “I’m alright. I think I can walk. Help someone else.”
By the time his vision stopped spinning and he managed to stand up, there was no one left but the bodies. Mostly dead, and a few so close to it that it would be a mercy when it came. Kili rubbed his stinging eyes. He was looking for someone in particular. He’d seen him, in that final moment, with his silver-black spear and his white hair flying behind him like a banner. Kili remembered watching him hit the ground as the dragon let out its last blast of fire, before the chaos of its death throes knocked Kili under the exposed roots of the tree. He got to his feet and began to search for Thranduil.
It did not take long before Kili spotted the elven king beside the dragon’s head. The elf king must have been so close to the dragon as he breathed his final burst of flame that he had been able to dive beneath it, into Smaug’s shadow. He had been caught by the teeth or claws at some point: his armour had buckled on the chest and back, but had held just enough that he was not suffocated inside. Kili watched Thranduil pull his ruined breastplate off with a clatter, to shed the weight of it as he sat up labouriously. The arm that had held the poisoned spear was bloodied and bruised, the sleeve hanging in shreds. He was gasping through the miasma that had fueled the dragon’s fire and now oozed from its dead lips. He was on one knee, pausing to gather his strength, when Kili reached him.
Kili came out of the smoke, to get the element of surprise, and got his foot behind Thranduil’s leg to unbalance him and one hand around his throat before Thranduil even knew he was there. With a sweep he shoved him onto his back, one knee on Thranduil’s ribs and the other foot still rooted to the leaf-strewn ground. Thranduil’s legs kicked as Kili’s grip under his chin tightened. Despite being slight for a dwarf, he was still heavy, heavy in his bones and his muscles, and most importantly he knew how to use that weight at the right angle and the right points. He had spent two years sparring with elves.
The tip of Tauriel’s shortsword pressed into Thranduil’s breast, above his heart. Thranduil froze, staring into his eyes. Kili looked for fear there, but he couldn’t see it. He wanted it more than he had wanted anything before this moment.
“Beg me not to kill you,” he hissed through his gritted teeth.
Thranduil heaved for breath through the narrowed passage of his throat. He smiled a little. “They all told me you were so tame,” he whispered. “That you could never be a murderer. Go on, then. What will they say now?”
“Your body will be ashes by morning. No one will know. But I’ll know,” Kili rasped, his eyes widening. “And I’ll live two hundred more years happy that I did one thing right. Can you say that? About anything you’ve ever done in your long life?”
“I don’t care a speck what you think of me, boy,” Thranduil said in a faint croak. “You’re green now, and gone like dry leaves tomorrow.”
Kili raised the sword, felt himself wavering as he reached the apex of his strike. He could tell Thranduil was trying to stand up, trying to roll him off, but the king’s strength was expended. The smoke had reddened his eyes and his breath was choked from the smoke. But his face was still placid. There was no regret there, no apology. The rage at that was unbearable, and Kili tensed to strike.
In the moment of indecision, a voice cried. “Stop, please! Don’t kill him!”
Kili’s eyes slid just a little away from Thranduil’s face. What appeared to be a short, curly-haired dwarf was standing beside them, as if out of nowhere, his cloak drawn across most of his face to try and screen the worst of the smoke. Kili didn’t recognise his eyes; he had never met Bilbo, or indeed any hobbit at all. And though he could not know it, Bilbo did not recognise Kili either - he had only glimpsed him once, from a distance, many days ago in his Guard’s uniform with his hair braided - and now Kili was unrecognisable with his hair coming loose in the wild, red light, in the midst of the growing inferno and the mess in which they found themselves. They were complete strangers facing each other over Thranduil’s fate.
Bilbo’s hand was raised as if wanting to grab Kili’s wrist but afraid he would just provoke him.
“You don’t know what he’s done,” Kili spat at him.
“I do. I do,” Bilbo assured him, his voice muffled through his makeshift mask against the thickly falling ash. “But I need him. He’s the best healer in the City, and someone I love is dying. Please, let him go.”
Kili turned his head at last to stare at the small part of Bilbo’s face he could see above the cloak. Then, slowly, he lowered the sword and took his hand off Thranduil’s throat. He drew in a shallow, shuddering breath. “Fine. If he’s worth something to you, have him.”
He stood up and backed away, and then turned and ran for the relative safety of the gate, hating himself for his own cowardice, and yet weak with relief that someone had stopped him killing the king. The horror came not from what he nearly did, but how easy it had nearly been.
He saw no one left alive as he reached the ruined gate. The fire was already crawling over the grass and bushes on the banks around the walls, turning the stones black in some places. The one blessing was that there was no wind tonight. The inferno was spreading slowly, inches by inches, sending birds and a few panicked squirrels and small deer crashing out of the leaves, some to be trapped against the wall and die butting against it in their confusion. Kili climbed over the fallen stones and into the City.
The familiar streets were turned to a nightmarish maze. Smaug had smashed or scarred many buildings as he’d charged along the street from the palace to the outer promenade. Kili knew he had to head east, away from the fire, but if he went in a straight line he’d end up with the great rocky hill of the palace between him and safety. He tried to choose a side street he thought he knew and followed it until he reached a canal. There was no destruction here, but still some eerie, frozen chaos. Doors hung open and belongings were scattered across the streets. The inhabitants of the houses had gotten outside and abandoned them when they saw the streams of fire or heard the battle against the dragon. A horse galloped past in terror, its bridles only half-buckled. All the shops were still shut tight for the night, so that familiar places looked like blank faces. Kili kept going as best he could, but then as all the Woodland streets did, the path under his feet curled inexorably around the trees and natural hillocks until Kili found he was facing the palace again instead of going around it. The smoke was getting thicker and he began to cough with every breath.
He tried to turn at the next intersection and soon found to his horror that the bridges of the next canal had all been broken to prevent the fire spreading over them. White, raw wood shone in sharp splinters. He followed the canal as far as he could until he found a stone bridge and was able to make his way across. Here, there were less signs of a panicked flight. The fire was further away and the inhabitants must have had more time to gather themselves, with doors shut up and the carts and animals all missing, a good sign that there had been time for an orderly evacuation. But this was an elvish district and Kili didn’t know the streets well. In the pre-dawn light with the smoke making a haze over the rooftops, he couldn’t even figure out which direction the palace was to get his bearings. He cursed. He could navigate a pitch-black forest while tracking a silent giant spider, but now he was lost in the city he’d lived in his entire life?
Somewhere, the fire either reached the central wires or the control building for the City’s Mithril lamps and all the street lights went out in a long tide of spreading darkness. Very distantly, Kili heard a few weak screams, so everything in the city must have gone out at once. At least he knew there were people over there. He tried to judge which direction the voices had come from and started running.
But, Durin’s beard he was back at the palace again. Somehow he’d gotten turned around and was still on its west flank, in the open courtyard out front. It loomed above him, a dark and bulbous shape with the dawn rising behind it. Kili was actually beginning to panic now. The smoke was so thick he could only see the palace and surrounding buildings in snatches. He felt dizzy, but when he tried to suck in a deep breath, it was foul and full of ash and he went into a fit of coughing so hard he ended up on his hands and knees. His eyes were streaming so much he couldn’t see clearly, and as he crawled he found himself putting his hand on another hand. He jerked his arm back. Through his stinging eyes he looked down at the cooling, unmoving body of Lieutenant Fainthel. He realised there were bodies scattered all around him in the courtyard, mainly dressed in the grey-green uniforms of the Guard but some young dwarves as well. They were laid out on blankets or cloaks or with bundled jackets as pillows under their heads. He had stumbled upon the triage area for those wounded by the dragon, and all that was left were the bodies of those who had been carried away from the front gate but had died within minutes. The corpses in this outdoor morgue had been left for the fire by the friends and comrades who had fled as the smoke grew too much to bear.
The air was a little clearer closer to the ground and he got his breath back enough to keep moving. He crawled towards the pale, circular shape of the public fountain in front of the palace, gripping the edge for support. He managed to lean over the rim and splashed some cold, clean water on his face to get the worst of the ash out of his eyes. He crumpled against the wall of the fountain, pulling for breath.
He didn’t know where to go. He couldn’t crawl the length of the city, or at least, not fast enough to outrun the fire. He hoped the smoke would put him to sleep before the flames got to him.
He thought of his mother. He hadn’t even had a chance to say goodbye at the trial. He just had to hope that Fili had made it to safety, or Ma would not be able to live with the grief, he was sure of it. And Thorin. Thorin had given his life to save them both. And Kili had thrown that gift away on a rash, callow chance at a revenge that he couldn’t even follow through with.
He wondered if Tauriel would be waiting for him on the far side of death. He wondered if she’d be as angry with him for dying stupidly as he was angry with himself. Probably she would. Well, if he did see her, at least they’d have the rest of forever to sort it out.
He closed his eyes against the smoke and when he opened them there was a figure, crouched low but moving at a jog towards him, wearing a cloth as a makeshift mask over his nose and mouth. The top half of his face was somewhat protected by a smithy’s eye-mask with polished quartz lenses, presumably pinched from one of the surrounding workshops. Even if Kili couldn’t see his face, he knew him by the familiar sling, now filthy with dust and ash, that Fainthel had made only a few hours earlier.
His brother had come for him.
Fili reached Kili and slapped a wet cloth over his mouth. Kili pressed it close with his own hands, trying to breathe through it. Fili grabbed his shoulder and got him up into a crouch, pulling him wordlessly across the paved courtyard, around the bodies and the broken wreck of a house where Smaug had perched. The pain in his eyes was so bad Kili had to keep them closed almost the entire time, but Fili kept his hand on his shoulder and guided him onwards in steady, staggering steps.
They seemed to be heading right for the palace, and Kili was sure that was a death trap. If they went upwards the smoke would just get thicker, and at ground level those caves were a warren that they’d never find their way out of. He was sure the palace was a dead end.
But Fili pulled him through the front doors, picking up a lantern by the entrance, and within a couple of turns they were heading down, into cool and unfamiliar tunnels where the air was clearer and they could both pull their damp masks down.
Kili was stumbling, finding it still hard to get enough air, half-blind, but Fili held his arm and led him on until they reached what looked like a huge wine cellar. There they reached a small cluster of elves and dwarves, all covered head to toe in ash, clambering down a rope ladder into a dark trap-door through which Kili could hear the sound of churning water.
Kili tried to wipe his eyes with the wet cloth Fili had put over his mouth. He knew the faces of the dwarves and recognized most of the elves. They were not from the Guard but from his own social circles, schoolmates, or various cousins or even just acquaintances from the pubs. Several of them were still in day-clothes and clad in matching blue for some reason. His friend Ori was there, and Berior from his archery lessons, both of them reaching for him and Fili, to guide them around the open mouth of the trap door.
“I can’t believe it!” Berior helped Fili clamber one-handed onto the first few rungs of the ladder. “You found him! We’d just decided to leave without you!”
“I told you we were too stubborn to die,” Fili said wearily.
The ladder led down to a long, bobbing boat, with a shallow draft barely deeper than a punt, loosely moored to an outcrop of rock. They all managed to squeeze into it, with two elves trying to steady it with long poles braced against the narrow stone walls of the tunnel through which the river ran.
Kili found an empty space on the damp floor of the boat and lay down, his head spinning. Fili sat beside him and Kili reached for his good hand. “Thank you,” Kili said. “Thank you.”
“I would never have left without you,” Fili squeezed his hand in return. “But I might stick a bit closer to you next time.”
—
Dis was torn from her memories by a frantic knocking. She raised her head. The lights had all flickered out some time earlier, as the Mithril wires of the City melted and the engineers’ workshops collapsed. The smell of smoke was very strong now, thick enough that Thorin coughed weakly beneath her hand. Dis struggled to her feet and fumbled for the little candle that, what seemed like years ago, she had put in the window to summon Bilbo. She lit it and the parlour appeared in the weak glow. She put it on the mantelpiece and turned towards the sound of knocking.
She wished she had locked the door; no doubt Balin had had a turn of regret and sent someone to drag her away to join the evacuation. Sure enough, she heard the door open as the person knocking finally tried the handle.
She turned to see the last person she could possibly imagine. King Thranduil crouched a little as he stepped through the parlour door. He was in armour and a great cloak as silver as beech-leaves, half-torn and hanging from one shoulder. There was blood on his face, on his armour, and blood soaked the sleeve that was half-covered by the torn cloak.
She stared at him, wondering if the smell of smoke had caused her to fall into some hallucinatory state.
“Princess Dis,” he nodded at her.
“Thranduil,” she acknowledged, but did not stand.
Bilbo squeezed around the elven king and ran to her side, leaning over to listen to Thorin’s breath. He stood up with a sigh. “Thank goodness, we’re not too late,” he bobbed at Thranduil. “I do apologise for dragging you here, I know you probably have a lot of other things to do today. But would you mind, just, perhaps, having a go…?”
The king looked at Dis. In shock, she nodded her permission and stepped away. There was not much space in the parlour by this stage.
Thranduil came in close to put his hand on Thorin’s chest, his ear to Thorin’s mouth. He was silent for a moment, and then he said, “His wounds are very dire. You should have let the praetorians bring him to me straight away.” He straightened up, business-like despite a note of pain in his voice. “But… I suppose the dragon would have distracted me before I could do much.” He looked at Dis. “I need clean cloth, boiled water if you have it.”
“There’ll be some in the kettle, a couple hours old,” Dis mumbled. “I’ll see if the pipes are still running and start boiling more.”
Bilbo helped her gather what they had. Through the window, Dis could see that the sky above was dark with smoke, but the air directly outside was still clear of haze. Without any high wind, the City would be burning slowly, house by house, spark by leaping spark. Somewhere nearby, she could imagine the wall of flame chewing through the beautiful arches of the taverns and markets, running along the carved rails of the bridges, flowing up the pillars of the halls. But it hadn’t reached them yet.
When she and Bilbo returned to the parlour, Thranduil had unbuttoned Thorin’s shirt and tugged it open until his chest and shoulders were exposed. By now, the blossoming, black bruises there were clear even in the dull light of the candle. Thranduil put his hand on Thorin’s belly, just below his ribs, and murmured something in an elvish tongue that Dis did not understand. She saw Thorin’s limbs twitch, and then his muscles clench. His throat made a low noise like someone rising from a fitful sleep.
Bilbo put the bowl of clean water down on the floor nearby. Dis piled the towels and clean linen beside them. She was not clear why they were even needed. She had the growing sense both that Thranduil had used them as an excuse to take command and get them out of the room, and also that she could not leave Thorin alone again. Not with this monstrous snake who had taken so much from their family.
“This will take time,” Thranduil said, “I suggest you both go and get ready to flee the fire.”
“No, I’ll stay,” Dis said.
“So be it,” Thranduil didn’t even look over at her.
She heard the kettle boiling on the fuel stove, one of the few things in the house that was still working. She went to take it off and refill it. When she returned, the first thing she noticed was Bilbo standing in the doorway, heedlessly blocking her way, covering his mouth. The hobbit gave a strange, half-wild little sob and looked at Dis.
Thorin’s eyes were open. His hand clutched Thranduil’s upper arm. His lips were parted and his eyes were wide. Thranduil was leaning over him, neck extended and face lowered almost like a dragon leaning over some prey, his face bare inches from Thorin’s.
Thorin rasped, groggy but alive, “What are you doing to me?”
“Saving your life,” Thranduil’s hand shifted to the centre of Thorin’s chest and he pushed. There was a series of sticky, muffled crunches and Thorin groaned, lifting his head, his brow pressing against Thranduil’s. Dis felt faint at the sound, and the horrific intimacy of it, and the shame that she couldn’t bring herself to interrupt in case she broke whatever ritual Thranduil was weaving. Thranduil’s hand slipped across Thorin’s skin and up his neck, over his face, fingers digging into his hair around his temple, and whispered something too low to hear. Thorin gave another cry of what sounded like pain and something like the relief of an animal being released from a cage. His eyes rolled back for a moment and then opened, blinking, staring at Thranduil, their faces pressed close together.
“What did you do?” He growled. His eyes were sharp and his voice more lucid.
Dis felt tears on her cheeks and didn’t have the strength to wipe them away. She leaned against the doorframe and found herself praying, not to any god but to Frerin, not yet, not yet, go back to your rest. He won’t join you yet.
“What I had to,” Thranduil drawled. His voice dropped to a whisper, but the room was small and they all heard it. “You’re the only other one who knows how it was all built, how it can be done again. I need you to live. I give them all to your charge, our people, our future.”
He helped Thorin lie back, and then stood swiftly. “I’ve done what I can with the time we have. You all need to leave this place.”
—
Thorin lay back and felt the rush of hot, bloody life pulsing through him and then breaking like a wave, fading into his fingertips and his prickling scalp. He stared up at Thranduil. The air smelled of smoke and the only light was a fat candle burning almost to nothing on the mantelpiece. He felt beyond confused. He remembered falling, but he couldn’t be dead, because he’d have to be cursed beyond measure to find Thranduil was the one welcoming him in the next life. He blinked and looked around as far as he could without moving his head too much; the slightest shift shot white-hot headaches behind his eyes.
He was in his own parlour; or, he supposed, it was Dis’ parlour since he had left. His sister stood half-collapsed in the doorway, beaming at him and weeping as he hadn’t seen her cry for decades. Tucked behind her, of all people, was Bilbo. How had he ended up here?
They were all moving with some unnamed urgency. That smell of smoke was stinging his nose. Dis brought over Thorin’s coat and boots, and she and Bilbo helped him swing his legs around and sit up. Every movement hurt, and he was weak as a newborn kitten. Dis heaved him to his feet and put his arm around her shoulders. He leaned heavily into her. Bilbo tucked himself under Thorin’s other arm, a simple comfort of closeness, although frankly he was not doing much work given his height and size.
With slow, careful steps they made their way outside into a muted, grey light. There was no one in sight and no sound but a faint, constant roar and the panicked wings of birds overhead. From the angle of the blotted sunlight, it was dawn, yet the sky was as dark as the heaviest storm. In the distance, Thorin could see the flicker of flames in the tree-tops. Tiny flakes of ash drifted around them. The city was burning.
Thorin knew at once what had happened. He had broken the dragon’s bargain.
Thranduil stood a little way away, facing towards the fire. He looked at them with a derisive glance. “I suggest you move faster.”
“Aren’t you coming, your majesty?” Bilbo asked.
Thranduil turned away. “I will search the City for any other survivors.”
Thorin stared at the back of his head. Thranduil was a ruin, his armour half-discarded, the blood a great stain down the side with the missing arm, trailing his torn cloak as if it was doing him any good beyond adding to his air of despoiled majesty. Yet somehow, he’d kept his hair perfect. Thranduil wanted this to be how he was remembered, he wanted them to take the story back to the survivors and say, oh, but didn’t the elf king die glorious and beautiful.
It had always been about the glamour for him. Beauty at any cost, more precious that gold, more than life itself. Thorin remembered a warm night under coloured lights, a smiling king offering a young dwarf a cup of wine, the whisper to come closer, into the mottled shadows beneath the trees. A temptation, a seduction that had unfolded so slowly over Thorin’s entire adult life. But who had been chasing whom? He had been young but he had never been naïve. He had known how to play coy, and tempting from a distance, and learned fast to use his novelty and exoticism to his advantage in this realm obsessed with beauty and eternal youth. He had been the invader of the elven king’s bountiful hospitality and he had gotten everything he wanted from Thranduil. In a single generation he had turned the Woodland into a place that was dwarven and industrious and fecund. He had made the wood elves love the dwarves, and need them and all their wonderful devices and philosophies. Try to undo it and you would ruin the elves, with their slow lives and reluctance to adapt, but the dwarves would survive and repopulate from any disaster, as they had from the loss of Erebor. It might look from the outside as if the creeping grape vine had encased the stone and smothered it, but rip them apart and see who stood upright, the vine or the stone.
In the process they had both been changed by each other, and of the two, Thorin had at least been the more honest about it. Thranduil had believed he was setting a trap to tame dwarves. If he had realised too late that he was being lured into Thorin’s artifices in turn, well, that had been the game from the beginning, from that first moment that he held out a cup of dark, red wine to a wide-eyed young prince and said, “Come, drink with me.” It was not Thorin’s fault that Thranduil hated losing.
“Thranduil,” Thorin bellowed. “Come with us, you fool. You have thousands of years to atone for what you’ve done, to make yourself anew. I won’t spend my few years left on this earth as your mouthpiece. I’m not going to tell it the way you want it told.”
Thranduil glanced back at them, but looked only at him. A small smile twitched the corner of his mouth. “Goodbye, Thorin, son of Thrain.”
“We have to go,” Dis said firmly. “I understand him; he can’t leave his City to die alone.”
The ash was falling thick enough now that they had to stop and pull up collars or tie handkerchiefs over their mouths and noses. After that they tried to run, Thorin stumbling between them as best he could. They reached a path down to the east gate, joining a few other stragglers hurrying onwards. No one looked twice at them, faces covered by cloth, except a couple of elven Guards directing the last of the evacuees who asked if they needed any help. Dis waved them away. She seemed to know where they were going.
The narrow forest paths grew crowded as they went onwards. They followed the stumbling mass of elves and dwarves. Once they passed the river gate and the rapids, the river was thick with boats carrying the elderly, the children and the infirm. Many were weeping, especially the very young, but most of the people they passed walked onwards in a state of numb determination. They reached the flat, cleared steps of rock where the new port had been built. All the covered docks were empty, every boat launched.
“I have to rest,” Thorin gasped. His muscles were trembling as if they’d been pushed past exhaustion into collapse. They sat him down at the edge of the clustered refugees.
“I’ll find Balin or Dwalin and they’ll get you on a boat,” Dis stood up, searching the crowd for a familiar face.
“No,” Thorin grasped her sleeve. “We must see that everyone else is safe before then. I’ll take the last boat.”
They couldn’t dissuade him, despite Bilbo’s muttering about it and frequent glances back towards the distant smoke. Bilbo was smeared with grey and beneath it, there were deep shadows under his eyes. Thorin remembered he had already looked tired when they had parted outside the walls of the City. Was that only yesterday, or had Thorin been unconscious even longer? How long since either Bilbo or Dis had slept? And where were the lads, had they escaped the dragon?
“And where is the dragon?” Thorin said, out loud but to himself.
“He’s dead,” Bilbo said at once, as if announcing that tea was ready. “I saw him lying dead. Else he’d have destroyed the whole city, I suppose.”
Dis found a train of dwarves bringing water up from the river and went to fetch some. Unable to keep his eyes open, Thorin put his head on Bilbo’s lap. Only a few minutes later, he was woken by Bilbo shaking his shoulder. Dis was leaning over him, holding out a cup of water, and some bread. Thorin tried to break off a piece and hand it to her, and then to Bilbo, but they both refused in turn.
“You eat it. You need it,” Bilbo insisted, which was so unlike him that Thorin could not think how to argue.
Dis held out her arm to help Thorin get to his feet again. “The Guards are saying anyone who can walk should get on the paths east and try to reach the beaches of the Long Lake. The fire is getting closer and they want the port cleared of anyone except the most in need.”
She was right. The smoke was visible in the air, trailing in ribbons above them and oozing from between the trunks of the trees. Thorin felt a little stronger after the food, and was able to walk without their aid, although he was not too proud to take Dis’ arm during a few hilly parts. They followed the trails of elves and dwarves through the trees, making slow progress on the many uneven paths. The mirk was well controlled on this side of the forest and the trees did not loom or crowd together as they did in the deep parts of the wood.
At last they came to the sparsely-forested shores and beaches along the western side of the Long Lake. The late morning sun was so obscured you could look directly at it without discomfort. The sky glowed a heavy orange from one end to the other.
Here, the crowds were even thicker, and the boats out on the water barely had room to maneuver. There were lines of activity up and down the shore: dwarves and elves felling trees as fast as they could, thick trunks as straight as they could find them, trimming them with small handaxes, or even knapped stones that a few old miners still remembered how to make. The youngest dwarves were in the marshy ends of the beach cutting flax and weaving ropes, and anyone who had two working hands was tethering the logs together into makeshift rafts with roughly carved oars. Each raft was pushed out by wading Guards and young dwarves until it could be shoved into deeper water and rowed away with much splashing and not a little arguing. Some were ferried out to larger boats from Laketown that could not approach the beaches but could evacuate many survivors, while many of the bolder rafts made their own way over the lake in long, bobbing lines, shrinking towards the far shore. Shocked, ash-smeared faces on each raft turned back, looking up at the forest burning above them. At a distance, crowded on the rafts, disheveled and wrapped in whatever robes and blankets they had brought as they were roused from sleep and fled their homes, it was hard to tell elf from dwarf among the faces.
You could not see the city from the lake, even from far off, but those out on the water must have been able to see how far the fire had spread, and they must have known it was all gone. The entire City was consumed. Anyone who hadn’t escaped the walls was gone with it.
Dis’ gaze turned constantly as they walked along the beach, searching for a familiar face. “Balin! Dwalin! Has anyone seen them? Has anyone seen our cousins?”
“Over that way, your highness,” an old dwarf from the carpenter’s guild pointed along the beach. He looked at Thorin and his eyes widened, and he bowed deeply. “My lord Thorin. I had heard the worst.”
“I’m glad to prove otherwise,” Thorin nodded.
And then, just a little further along where the carpenter had pointed, there was Balin. Even in the dulled light he was visible from a distance with his red coat and great puff of white hair. And beside him, his left arm in a sling, awkwardly trying to support a scrap of paper as he scribbled something down as Balin spoke, was another familiar figure.
“Fili!” Dis shrieked. She pulled up her skirts and sprinted across the sliding stones. Thorin followed as fast as his aching body would carry him.
Did grabbed Fili’s face as if she could not believe he was real and then began to kiss him ebulliently as he looked between them and stammered. “Ma! Thorin? Durin’s beard, we thought you were lost for sure!”
“Where’s your brother?” Dis demanded.
Before Fili could answer, Kili collided with them, cursing and sobbing as he dragged all four of them into a knot and gripped them tight, as Fili cried in protest, “Ow, ow, watch my shoulder! Kili, you sod, you’ll hug my stitches open!”
Thorin was the one having to hold Dis upright now. She could not even make words as she went from one son to the other, holding them and kissing them and shaking them as if to check they were still there. Thorin maintained some dignity, but he felt the joy swell and fill him up, sharing a space in his chest beside the despair at how many others would be climbing aboard those rafts bereft of a son, a mother, a brother, lost or soon to be lost to the smoke and flames.
He stepped away from the three of them and sat down on the stones, beside Bilbo, who was staring out at the boats and rafts.
“Where are they all going to go?” Bilbo asked.
Thorin squinted his eyes against the spreading smoke to try and make out the Mountain. “To Erebor,” he said. “It’s ours again. The elves will come with us. We could not deny them a share of whatever we can reclaim, after they shared their home with us for so long. It will take a hundred years at least to regrow the Woodland realm. We’ll rebuild everything in Erebor, a new city that will be a child of the old City, and once the Woodland is restored, they can each choose where they want to dwell.”
“A century. I’m sorry I won’t see it,” Bilbo said wistfully. “These twin cities.”
“Neither will I, probably,” Thorin said. He looked at Bilbo and smiled. “But I still have some good years left to plant the seeds, I think.” He raised his brows. “It might be useful to have a professional burglar on my payroll. If you’d be willing to take a job as difficult as this one again.”
Bilbo smiled back at him. “I think I managed this difficult job.” His hand reached out and touched a lock of Thorin’s hair, by the temple. Thorin didn’t pull away. Bilbo frowned. “You had some grey, here, but it’s gone away. Maybe it just looks strange through the ash.”
Thorin nodded. He folded his arms on top of his knees, and tried not to think about the hand pressing down on his chest and the crunch of his bones sliding back into place, and the deeper flicker of a cold, old life passing from the elf into him. “Maybe,” he said. “Only time will tell.”
