Chapter Text
Dis was not alone for long. She became aware, without noticing him arrive, that Bilbo was sitting next to her on the fountain balustrade. She glanced at him.
“You were too late,” she said bitterly.
“Yes,” Bilbo replied, his arms loosely folded across his lap. “It seems I was.”
There was none of his feigned nerves or sharp tongue from their last few conversations. Bilbo looked as if he’d just survived a shipwreck. His shoulders were slumped low and his eyes were hollow in their sockets.
“You look hungry,” Dis said. “We should go home to get some rest. Perhaps we’ll know more by the morning.”
“Thank you, that’s very kind,” Bilbo gave her a weak smile.
They did not speak further as they walked back to the house. Despite the late hour they found there was a crowd around the door, as there had been earlier, but the mood was measurably different. The dwarves and elves closest to the house, mostly friends or neighbours she knew by name, were silent or speaking in whispers. Many were in their dressing gowns or night clothes as if they’d been just woken up. The rest of the crowd was a clustered group of at least a hundred young dwarves, almost all dwarrows but a few dams in trousers, all dressed for ease of movement as if they’d been awake and waiting for orders for some time. Many were carrying what were clearly improvised weapons; clubs, kitchen cleavers, axes for firewood. As they took notice of Dis, they parted for her like the crowd parting for a condemned woman walking to her hanging.
“What’s happened? Did they bring them back?” Dis grabbed the first dwarf she trusted close to the door, which was Balin. “Is it my boys?”
Balin shook his head, and she saw tears in his eyes. “No. You should go in.”
Dis picked up her skirts and strode to the open door. Somebody must have called in to Dwalin, because he met her in the front hall with arms wide to catch her before she could go farther. “Dis, give me a moment to prepare you before you see him.”
“Which one? Which one?” Dis begged. “Tell me, Dwalin!”
“It’s not one of the lads,” Dwalin said quietly. “It’s Thorin.”
Dis stared at him. Bilbo had come at a jog to join her, and she felt him tense beside her at the sound of Thorin’s name. Dwalin frowned at Bilbo. “This little creature’s been chasing around the city looking for you. Who is he?”
“A friend. He can know anything I need to know,” Dis said. “Is Thorin dead?”
Dwalin swallowed. “Not yet. One of our young dwarves saw the praetorians coming in the north gate carrying a dwarf’s body on a stretcher. Like pallbearers. It was Thorin. The boy raised the alarm, and along came that pack of angry young hotheads out there - they’re Fili’s friends from his combat school.”
“His what?” Dis frowned.
“We’ve been training them, Fili and I, since Thorin left. We should have told you before now. You still have an army loyal to you, Dis, ready to call you queen if you want - a small army, but they’re fit and keen. They’ve been champing at the bit for something to do since the trial this morning, so we rallied them to block the praetorian’s way as they tried to take Thorin’s body to the palace. There was a standoff but no blood. The praetorians gave us the body rather than risk a riot.”
“Body,” Dis echoed. “Why do you keep saying ‘body’? You said he wasn’t dead.”
“He’s alive, but he won’t be for long. You must come and say goodbye.”
“What did they do to him?” Dis snarled, tearing herself out of Dwalin’s arms and finally striding into the house.
She and Bilbo entered the parlour. The furniture had been pushed to the sides and rearranged, with two low tables shoved together to make a knee-high sickbed. It looked like the bier where the coffin would lie at a wake. Thorin had been laid out with his arms by his side, a blanket pulled up to his chest. Apart from the pallour of his skin, some faint, dispersed bruises and an unevenness to his breathing, he did not look badly injured. For a moment Dis could not even see any blood, but then Oin, who was kneeling by his side, gently wiped a trail from his nostril.
Oin looked up as she approached. “Cousin,” he said gravely. “I’m so sorry.”
“What happened to him?” Dis whispered, kneeling on the far side of Thorin’s body.
“I was told he fell from some height. That’s what the praetorians said,” Oin explained. “That would explain his injuries.”
“He’s strong,” Dis said firmly, laying one hand lightly on Thorin’s chest. He gave no response. “He’s alive. He’ll pull through.”
Oin reached across to put his hand over hers. “You need to be ready for the worst.”
“Then we must take him to the healer’s hall. If they arrest him afterwards, so be it, as long as they wait until he’s recovered.”
“He’s not going to recover, Dis,” Oin didn’t move his hand. “And I don’t think we should move him any further. He hasn’t woken, but if any part of his mind is still in there, it’ll cause him more pain for nothing.”
“So we bring the healers here!”
Behind her, she could hear Dwalin’s bootsteps at the threshold of the room. “This is the elven king’s doing. Every blow against your family is an act of subjection against the dwarves of this City. We’re ready, Dis. If you want your revenge, we are ready to follow you.”
Dis thought of the elven prince, who had come to her in desperate hope that she could help him keep the peace, trying to bridge the growing chasm between them. It would be so easy to start tearing their own home to shreds just to make the elves suffer as she was suffering. She yearned for it. But it wouldn’t bring any of them back. It would just end with more dams, like her, weeping over the bodies of their sons and brothers.
“Make those children outside go away, Dwalin,” she said quietly. “Make them put down their toy weapons and go home to their mothers.”
“I don’t know if they will,” Dwalin admitted. When she didn’t reply, he backed out of the room.
Oin squeezed her hand and let it go. “I’ll give you some time alone with him. I think it will be hours, at most, before he passes to the halls of his fathers.”
He got up and started to leave, gesturing to Bilbo with a squint of confusion. “Come along, lad. Leave the princess.”
“Can… can I have just a moment?” Bilbo asked.
“She doesn’t have time for your questions right now.”
“I mean with Thorin,” Bilbo said sharply.
Dis looked over at them, anger flashing at their presence and then subsiding. She twitched a finger at Bilbo. “Come here, Bilbo. Let him stay, Oin, I’m in his debt. And he’s a friend of Thorin’s.”
Oin raised an eyebrow but left, shutting the door quietly behind him. Bilbo didn’t intrude on her closeness, but sat in the big armchair that had been shoved to one side to make room for the makeshift sickbed. It had been Thorin’s favourite chair, and then Fili’s, though Kili would always try and get to it before him in the rare evenings when they were both home at the same time. She would never see them play-fighting over that chair again. Bilbo sat perched on the edge of the seat, his hands on his knees, his face like a death-mask himself. Dis turned back to her brother, smoothing down Thorin’s tangled hair with her hand.
“You’re the only one here who’s known Thorin since he left the City,” Dis said quietly. “What was his life like?”
“I only knew him the past couple of months,” Bilbo said after a moment. “We travelled together from Bree.”
“Just the two of you?”
“For some of the journey.”
“It’s a long journey. You must have talked about something.”
Bilbo didn’t answer for a moment, and then he said, “I’m not sure what you want me to say. He wasn’t unhappy in exile, but only because he was driven, always moving with a purpose. He wanted to get back here, to fix what he believed was broken in this City. I know he missed you all very much. You could hear it in the slightest word he said about you.”
“Do you know how the praetorians caught him?”
“He was going to find your boys,” Bilbo said softly. “He was going to try and save them.”
Dis nodded without looking away from Thorin’s face. She’d guessed, somehow, when he hadn’t appeared with Bilbo. “Thorin went to save them, and was nearly killed. The praetorians brought him back, but not my sons. So Thranduil was right: it was too late, and the dragon has taken them. Thorin was too late. I was too late. They’re gone.”
“They might have–”
“Please, don’t feed me hope,” Dis whispered, folding her arm beside Thorin’s head and laying her cheek down on it, so that she could look at his sharp, pointed profile in the light of the hearth. She thought of another dwarf who had worn that same nose, the same brow, but without the lines and cracks carved by a long life. She hoped Frerin was in those far halls too, waiting at the door to welcome Thorin when he arrived.
She could not imagine her boys in the halls of their ancestors, not out of hope, but out of the dreadful fear that the dragon now had them in its keeping, the fear that it may not have killed them yet but soon would in ways too terrible to imagine. Either way, they were far beyond her reach. In the old stories, the ones about heroes, the mighty princess would have taken up arms and gone to the mountain herself, opened the secret door with her father’s key, killed the dragon and rescued her sons in a blaze of glory. But she was a diminished princess of a captured people, and she had no way to get to Erebor. No dwarf had left that mountain once the dragon had passed the front hall; there was no chance she could save them.
Bilbo twitched. He shook his head. “I’m going to do something,” he stood up, straightening the lapels of his coat. “I don’t know what, but I can’t just sit here. I’m going, and I’ll figure something out and come back.”
Dis did not answer or look at him as the door quietly shut behind him.
—
When he went back into the main room of the outpost, Kili found his brother sitting up and starting to recover some of his colour. Legolas gave Fainthel about half an hour to get him ready to travel, and Kili helped him find a fresh shirt from the supply boxes tucked under the benches, which fit alright across the chest once they’d cut the ends of the sleeves off. Fainthel set Fili’s right arm in a tight sling to stop him pulling his stitches with any sudden movements.
While Haered boiled a little soup for them all, Kili cracked open the door to listen to Commander Legolas. He had gone outside to speak to the half-dozen Guards he had brought with him. Kili could see the distrust in their eyes even in the dim light from the windows of the outpost. All of them were breaking the law by helping an exiled murderer, convicted by the high powers of their City. But Legolas explained nothing other than his commands. Kili heard him recite a simple story; the praetorians had not released the exiles as expected and in the confusion, an unarmed prisoner had been shot; since the praetorians could not be trusted with the job, the forest Guards would carry out the sentence for them and send them on their way to Esgaroth. The route would take them back past the city, along the north side of the wall until they reached the east-west road that ran through the centre of the Woodland realm.
They made their way back along the path without a lamp, as it would have ruined the night vision of most of the party and run the risk of attracting the more dangerous inhabitants of the forest. The elves could see well enough to navigate with only the faintest trace of starlight, and Kili had his own ways of travelling in the darkness of the forest, by a mix of memory and his other senses. One of his first memories of meeting Tauriel had been a few months into the new recruits’ training, after their first solo patrols; Captain Tauriel had asked Fainthel afterwards, “And how does the dwarf manage in the dark?” and Fainthel had said, with obvious pride, “He keeps up. It’s even darker in the deep places underground, Captain, so I suppose it’s in their blood.” Kili had taken it as praise and had grinned so much Haered had kicked him in the ankle because he wasn’t standing to attention properly. Still, they could not travel with the haste that the elves were used to, because Fili had to walk at practically a snail’s pace, his good hand always on his brother’s shoulder.
The wall was in sight and the path took them along a slightly raised, natural dyke crumbling towards a deep ditch, so that between the trees they could sometimes see right over the top of the parapets. They were just about to turn east when the few night-birds calling to each other went suddenly and utterly silent. Kili saw Fainthel, who was in the lead, stiffen and glance upwards. Then the gale of the dragon’s wings hit them all like a wall. Fallen leaves caught in the onslaught stung their faces and forced them to brace wherever they stood. In a moment it had passed over them, and the great, heavy shadow of the dragon with it.
For a moment there was only the silence again.
Then came the roar and a sound like billowing sails as fire poured out of the night and over the north-west corner of the City, slicing it off from the rest like a red-hot blade through wax. The glow of it lit up the world like a fragment of the sun had fallen on the town, every twig, every detail of their faces. Instantly, the inferno roared up the wooden houses and the trees that lined the curling avenues.
“No!” Fili was the only one to react out loud, and without hesitation he broke away from the group and began to run towards the nearest gate.
The rest of them stayed silent, as if this was just a cluster of spiders coming at them through the night and their voices would attract attention. Some of the Guards glanced at Legolas. Kili realised he, too, was instinctively waiting for orders that he didn’t need to obey and decided he was done with doing what they told him. He sprinted after his brother. Behind him, he heard Fainthel follow swiftly, crying to Haered and the other young recruits, “Hurry - the city Guard will need every pair of hands.”
The gate led through to an ordinary street. A few faces were appearing at windows or in open doorways, faintly lit up by the glow of the fire reflecting off the underside of the leaves above them. From down here, surrounded by houses, no one could see the danger, but the stink of smoke and dragon-vapours was spreading through the air. Anyone who had lived to escape the burning of Erebor knew what that smell meant. And the distraction meant nobody was looking at Kili, which was a relief after several days of being constantly scrutinised.
In the distance at the end of the street, two young dwarves had encountered Fili and were half throwing themselves on him as Kili reached them, one of them asked, “What do you mean, the dragon?”
“Who else is awake?” Fili said. “From the underground school, I mean.”
“Everyone! We’ve been roughing up the praetorians!” the dwarf said cheerfully. “We were going to come looking for you and Kili next, but Dwalin said no, we had to wait for morning at least.”
“Get them all out here, get them to the square in front of the palace. And tell them to bring heavy tools and ropes. If we start pulling down the shops along Vine Street as a firebreak, we may keep the blaze contained to the north markets,” Fili pointed with his good hand. As the two of them shot off with all the thrill of a quest, Legolas arrived beside Kili.
“We can help. What do we do?” Fili looked up at Legolas, sounding much less optimistic than the two youngsters. “We can fight the fire but it doesn’t matter. Smaug is going to kill everyone within the walls.”
“We have to find my father,” Legolas said grimly. “He’s probably the only one who could have seen this coming.”
“Alright. I’ll rally every dwarf I can to join you,” Fili said, his face pale even in the red light, and sweat beginning to bead on his forehead. They could feel the heat rising in the air. “Kili, come on.”
Kili looked between them. Fili reached for his hand, tangling their fingers together. “Come on, Kili!”
“I should stay with the Guard,” Kili said numbly. He had tucked Tauriel’s shortsword into his belt, still wrapped in the silk cloth, but now he pulled it free and let the cloth fall away. “I don’t know how to fight like a dwarf. I only know how to fight like a Woodland Guard. I’ll be more help to them.”
He could see the flash of pain and fear across Fili’s face. His older brother had always encouraged him to go his own way, had always defended any old and crotchety dwarf who said that prancing around the forest wasn’t natural, any jealous young bully who said Kili looked more like an elf these days than a dwarf. It had been Fili’s idea in the first place, it was Fili who had made them all believe that the only way for both peoples to survive was to break down the walls that remained between them, the unseen and unspoken boundaries they walked inside their minds. Fili was following Thorin’s example, but he had pushed Kili even further into that no-man’s-land. It seemed he had not envisioned that despite all their efforts, those gaps would continue to widen, and instead of bringing them together Kili had ended up further and further away.
Fili nodded and dropped his hand. “Alright,” he said. “We’ll see you soon.”
–-
Dis could smell smoke. It was as faint and distant as the horns blowing far away across the city, horns that usually only signified an enemy had been sighted and the City was under attack. The smell of smoke was somewhat foreign in this place built of wood and lit by lamps as clever as magic. At first she wondered if it was in her imagination, if her mind had become so lost that it was slipping back to that childhood day, an age ago, when the mountain had burned around her. She didn’t know how long it had been since Bilbo left. But then Balin, Dwalin and Oin burst in and told her the smoke was no memory; the dragon had been seen and glimpsed through the trees above the City, and the market district in the north was burning.
“We’re waking everyone up and clearing the streets, sending everyone to shelter,” Balin said. “The dragon could return at any moment.”
“Shelter?” Dis raised her head. She stood up slowly, thinking of the families who had tried to shelter in hidden holes in the mountain. None of them had ever come out again. “No, there is no shelter if Smaug has come for us. We need to evacuate.”
“What, the entire city?” Dwalin growled. “It’s impossible, Dis. The roads will be choked before a tenth of our folk have escaped.”
Dis tried to think through what felt like drowning mud. “Take them out the east gates, towards the river. There’s docks and clearings there, even some shelters that the shipyards use for their goods. Those that can walk or ride in the dark keep going, head for the lake. For the rest, we’ll launch every barge in the City’s port, and send fast messengers to Laketown. Get them to send every boat they have up the river to the old barrel-sorting wharf. That’s our only route out.”
Balin and Dwalin looked at each other. Balin said. “Very well. I’ll go out now, pack a bag and you and Dwalin follow when you can.”
“There’s no need,” Dis tried to give him a reassuring smile. “I’ll stay here.”
Dwalin stepped forward. “You will not.”
“I need to stay with Thorin, and if we move him, he’ll die for sure.”
“Dis, we need you too. Thorin is gone. You are the closest thing we have to a queen, now.”
Dis could not stop a brittle laugh. “Queen of what?” she turned and knelt down again. “Give him a chance. I’ll look after him until he wakes, and then we’ll join you.”
“No!” Dwalin bellowed, and seized her around the arms, trying to drag her away from the sickbed. “You mad dwarrowdam, I’ll carry you in fetters if I have to!”
Dis writhed and slammed her elbow backwards into his gut. With a wheeze Dwalin released her and she backed away from him, raising her hand towards him and trying to tidy her hair with her other hand. “Don’t touch me. If I am your queen, then you will obey me. I order you to leave me.”
She could see tears in Dwalin’s eyes as he heaved for breath, winded by her blow. Balin was reaching to her as if in supplication. At last he nodded. “We’ll go, I promise,” Balin glanced at Thorin. “Please Dis, follow us once… once Thorin wakes up.”
She nodded. She waited until they were gone, and then she shut the door and slumped on the old rug by Thorin’s side. She laid her head on his shoulder, entwined her hand with his. She felt his fingers clench a little, his head shift a half-inch away from her. But she knew it was the meaningless twitch of a broken, dying body. She closed her eyes and listened to him breathing, shallow and pained.
“I’m here, brother,” she promised. “It’s alright. I’ll be with you all the way.”
She didn’t want to die. She was as afraid of the flame as any child of Erebor would be. She would have followed Balin and Dwalin if she could. But she couldn’t leave Thorin alone, she could not live knowing he had died alone, as their mother had died alone on some broken, rocky path outside the door of Erebor, in agony with her lungs full of smoke.
Dis would stay until the end, and if by that stage it was too late to run, so be it. She had lived a full life. She had loved a dwarf and been loved by him and taken him as a husband, both the first and the last dwarf that either of them ever shared a bed with. She had taken fine gems newly cut and held them to the light for the first time, seen occlusions and colours more ancient than the woodland, hidden since they were birthed into the rocks eons before any memory on the earth. She had walked the borders of the forest in seasons of golden summer and days of soft mists blanketing the meadows. She had borne children, she had lost her children, but in between she had done her best to guide them and love them. She had seen her people flourish and change to survive. They would go on without her, without her family’s dwindling and diminished dominion over the scattered Durin’s folk. No mortal could expect any more.
She let herself dwell in her memories, and waited for Thorin to go.
–-
As the dragon bore down on the heart of the city, Thranduil willed it to look at him. He stood in the centre of the great, wide street at the entrance to the City, the largest and straightest promenade, easily visible to a dragon’s eyes. He had brought a long banner with him, bronze and sky-blue, which was unfurled and trailing from the pike in his hand. The other held tight to the reins of his horse, a roan, old beast that was the most stalwart steed in his stables. Even she was beginning to toss her head and stamp at the smoke trailing through the air and the roar of the dragon.
He knew Smaug was up there, gliding above the trees, surveilling the growing chaos, perhaps still deciding whether he would prefer to raze the City to ashes immediately or take his time picking the inhabitants off over the course of the night. Smaug would surely have seen the king, in his broad, shining armour and white hair flying in the hot wind. The fire was pulling the air towards itself as it began to rage into an earth-bound storm. It was just a question of whether the dragon would come for him or whether he would dismiss Thranduil’s vain challenge.
“Come to me,” Thranduil whispered. “Come lay your wrath on me, you ugly blight of a monster, you mistake of a bygone age.”
There was the rolling thunder of the wings beating fast and Smaug broke through the trees, slamming down on the east end of the street, crushing houses and halls with his feet and tail. He lowered his head with a long hiss, so low it shivered through the ground. “A pleasure to see you again, little king of silver boughs. I see you have grown wealthy and pompous on the potency of my gifts. Is that why you broke off our arrangement? Your thriftiness will cost you dearly.”
Thranduil ripped the banner from his pike and let the wind carry it away so that it would not impede him when he had to flee. “I broke nothing, wyrm. I have been nothing but generous. You have grown so sluggish you could not even catch your quarry tonight, and now you come to me seeking to renegotiate terms? Well, come then, let us speak somewhere a little more private!”
He spurred the increasingly panicked horse and turned her, urging her to fly as fast as she could towards the great front gate, out of the City, and towards the forest beyond.
To his terror and relief, Smaug roared and sprang to follow him.
