Chapter Text
Smaug was not dead.
All who witnessed the horror would relive it in their nightmares for the rest of their lives.
Smaug flung about the treasury, cascading mountains of gold coins and jewels as his long neck snapped after retreating dwarves. Smoke spilled from the dragon’s throat, showing promise of the fire slowly building within his gullet. The air surrounding the dragon’s chest shimmered with such heat, they all felt it like a burning smelter of iron.
The Company divided themselves into three, each group straining their agility to the limit as they struck and then retreated from the enraged dragon’s teeth to allow the others to strike in turn. A softer creature would have eventually succumbed. But dragon scales were like stone, like iron. The dwarves’ weapons could not draw blood. It was too much. Thorin shouted, and Bilbo did not know the Khuzdul word, but he recognized its meaning: retreat.
Smaug thrust his horned head among the scattering dwarves. Bombur made not a sound as teeth closed around his middle, but he gamely battered at the dragon’s snout as the beast raised his head higher than the trees. He tossed the dwarf into the air and snapped him down with a single gulp like a dog playing with its food.
In a move perhaps even more foolhardy than running towards Azog the Defiler himself, Bilbo ran at the dragon. With a wordless shriek of rage disproportionate to his size, he flung his hands onto the dragon’s scales.
Smaug flung his head back with a startled jerk. He shuddered. His great claws dug reflexively at the gold. Smoke then spilled out his nose, black and billowing. It clouded over all but his glowing amber eyes.
“What. What are you? You tricked me.”
What would have been a bellow was a gasp. Staggering, shuddering, the dragon collapsed atop glittering gold. His wings spasmed. Smaug rolled over in his death throe and went still.
There were no cheers. A few dwarven gasping coughs. The smoke pouring from the corpse’s snout was black and oily. They stared, their weapons slowly slacking in their upraised hands.
Bilbo alone was full of movement.
“Quick! Get him out! Bombur! Get him out!” He helplessly hacked at the dead dragon’s throat, his little sword throwing a few sparks, but unable to pierce dragon hide.
He didn’t see the dwarves watching him in shock.
Bilbo clambered over sliding piles of gold and braved the billowing smoke to crawl between open teeth longer than his entire body. He coughed and gagged, but boldly tread towards the back of the beast’s throat.
Bofur tossed aside his hat and ran after him. “Wait! Bilbo! You won’t reach by yourself! Let me grab hold of your feet!”
Bifur was shook and he huffed a few staggered words of Khuzdul and followed.
Glóin’s eyes bugged at the sight of living dwarves crawling into a dead dragon’s smoking mouth. “They’ve gone mad! They’re going to suffocate or burn!”
Clutching at his chest with horror in his eyes, Balin still managed to be the most logical head among them. He opened his mouth once, shut it, and then said slowly, “We must retrieve Bombur’s body for burial. I surely do not wish to do it now nor later, but it may be preferable now before it is digested by the beast’s stomach juices.”
Thorin held his head in his hand. He heaved a great breath and choked a little on the smoke. “Balin, Dwalin, see what can be done about the ventilation before we are all smothered. Glóin, Nori, go down to the forges and fetch fire suppressant. I fear that thing will burn its own flesh like a candle if we cannot put its fire out. Kíli, Fíli, go to our packs and fetch rope before Bilbo gets himself irrevocably stuck down its throat. Dori, Ori, we will take up our sharpest weapons that have any hope of splitting that wretched beast’s hide. Óin, advise us. Where is the most likely spot to begin a dissection?”
The entire operation lasted well into the night. Clever dwarven engineering throughout the mountain allowed various vents and shutters to be opened or closed to channel the smoke from the treasury and directly out into the open air.
The dragon’s scales could not be pierced, but they could be chiseled. They were much aided by Óin’s discovery of a chink in the scales of the corpse’s breast.
“Likely a wound gained when the foul beast took Erebor. To think, an arrow could have slipped through and stilled its heart! Would’ve saved us all a fair bit of trouble, but for an arrow.”
After hammering away a line of scales, they slit open the cavity that sat between neck and sternum, but it exposed to the air a thick oil that flickered into an unnaturally hot open flame. The prodigious heat drove them all out of the treasury and into the corridor. They had difficulty smothering it since every shovelful of sand and fire suppressant melted to glass at the first, but soon it was so buried, the flames finally smothered into a haze of smoke.
With the fire out, the corpse grew cool enough to hack into its stomach. Once the scales were pried or broken loose, the dragon’s hide cut like immensely thick leather.
Óin seemed the least bothered to cut through bloody muscle to uncover Smaug’s stomach, so the dwarves let him direct the final stage of recovering Bombur’s body.
“Curious fibers,” said Óin as he sawed through yet another thick cord as thick as his finger snaking through the dragon’s veins. “If I didn’t know better, I’d say a tree rooted itself in the damn dragon’s circulatory system while it slept! That is, of course, ridiculous. I suppose dragons simply must be built different than other creatures.”
Bilbo tried not to look like he knew anything was the matter. He ignored the dwarves’ side-eyed looks.
Óin said to nobody, or perhaps only to himself, “The beast must have been in a torpor for a century until we woke it. Its viscera haven’t any signs of digestion yet, thank Mahal.”
“Thank Mahal,” several in the Company echoed in grim mutters.
Bifur held Bofur tight to his breast so his cousin could not watch his brother’s body spill out onto the gold.
Reeking with dragon spit and blood and foul oily smoke, Bilbo slipped on bloody gold coins in his haste. He crawled across Bombur’s corpse and cradled his bearded face in his hands. He cried. He wrapped all the heavy emotion surrounding him into his fingers and forced together all the love and grief he possessed and could feel pressing against him from every side. He prayed Yavanna it was enough, it was not too late. He caught it all up in his hands and forced it to bloom into new life.
Bombur blinked. They all stared. He sat up. Bilbo groaned and fisted his hands against the knives of pain driving through his stomach. He slid a little way down a clinking mound of gold coins.
Bombur’s strangled voice was hard to hear, but they all heard it. “Bofur, Amad wanted me to tell you she thinks Galathâl daughter of Bakhâl would be a nice dwarrowdam to make your wife, but I told her that was a terrible idea.” He blinked again, the hoarseness of his voice now gone. “What’s the matter with Bilbo?”
Glóin cursed.
Slowly regarding the open dragon corpse above him, Bombur took a breath and held his blood-stained belly. “Did I get eaten?”
With a yelping sob, Bofur leapt upon his brother and then all was noise and commotion.
When Bilbo was next aware, he awoke to the disconcerting discovery that he was naked, freshly washed, and wrapped up in a terribly musty-smelling blanket. He was pillowed on a truly ancient eiderdown near a warm coal fire burning in a round iron stove.
“Are you awake?”
“Mmph,” said Bilbo.
“Fee! He’s awake!”
He felt strong hands hoist him to a sitting position and a mug of cool water was pressed to his lips. Under normal circumstances, he would protest such manhandling, but a great weariness leadened his limbs to the point that scratching his nose was a difficult endeavor.
“My clothes seem to be missing,” wheezed Bilbo.
Fíli’s sheepish smile lifted one side of his mustache. “We didn’t think you’d be too happy with us, but we were all so fouled by blood and gore and smoke—we couldn’t very well leave you in filth while we cleaned ourselves.”
“So we toted you down to the public baths with us and washed you along with our laundry!” said Kíli cheerfully.
Bilbo wasn’t sure how he felt about that. He shortly decided if he were to get upset, he would get upset later, because he hadn’t any strength to build up a decent head of steam right at the moment.
“Thorin said you were out for two days last time you did this.”
“How long?”
“Four days. You’ve really worried us, Bilbo. We could get you to drink a bit of broth or tea from time to time, but you’ve been completely out.”
“It was the size of that dragon, I think, and then Bombur, of course. Managing both so close together, well, it was a lot.”
“You killed the dragon. That’s astonishing. But then you—you—” He searched for the proper word and came up empty.
“You unkilled Bombur,” said Kíli. “That’s impossible.”
“Yeah,” agreed Fíli. “Impossible.”
He shrugged, and the movement did not come easily. “It’s what hobbits do.”
They fed him a few mouthfuls of bread and stew and Bilbo slept.
The next he awoke, Bombur was hovering nearby. He tried to ignore the brown bloodstains and recently mended tears bisecting the dwarf’s wool tunic.
Bilbo felt stronger. He was able to sit up under his own strength with only a bit of a wobble. Quiet and efficient, Bombur carefully propped him up with Bifur’s pack and his own bedroll. He fetched water to drink and Bilbo’s clothes, now clean and mended tidily with tiny dwarven stitches. After he allowed him some privacy to dress himself, Bombur tucked him right back under the blankets and set Bilbo up with some cold roasted meat and potatoes.
Roast rabbit and fried potatoes was likely the finest dish Bilbo had ever tasted in his life, and likely it was the tastiest he would ever eat, since he had no intention of ever again going four or five days without a proper meal and thus season his meat with hunger.
Bombur fussed over the food supplies, and then began to tidy up this chamber the Company had obviously taken for their new camp. He again fussed over the food, and then gave it up for a half-hearted attempt at sweeping the stone floor.
“Bilbo,” he finally rasped, his voice heavy with emotion. “I do not know how to speak. Because of you, my children are not fatherless. I am forever in your debt—”
“No—no, none of that, if you please,” interrupted Bilbo. “Not that I don’t value your thanks, because I do, and you are indeed very welcome. With all my heart, you’re welcome! But I am spared too much thanks for doing what any one of the Company would be perfectly willing to do, if only he could. You owe me no debt for a gift freely given to my friend.”
Bombur held the handle of his broom, his knuckles white, and shifted uneasily on his feet.
The hobbit shook his head and insisted kindly, “It is my gift to you. Not a miracle. Not dark magic. A gift.”
A slow, shy smile bloomed across the dwarf’s whiskers.
“He is awake?” Thorin stood in the arched doorway. A dwarven king standing within his ancestral halls, Thorin never looked more properly in place than in this moment, no matter that he was crownless and dressed in his travel-worn leathers and fur.
Bilbo looked away quickly and pretended he was much interested in the ceiling. He noticed for the first time the stone surrounding him was expertly carved in beautiful geometric lines crossing the arched ceiling and running along every straight line of the architecture. At every intersection of lines, little crossed battle axes or swords decorated the stones. He wondered if all dwarven motifs were so martial or if this large room had been allotted to soldiers for some purpose. Flecks of quartz (Bilbo knew it was quartz only because Bofur had repeatedly described to him the look of it in finished rock) shone in the firelight like sunlight glinting off a distant, wind-touched lake. Bofur was right—it was very pretty.
“He woke not long ago,” replied Bombur. “He has a good appetite and says he feels well.”
Bilbo gave a little wave. “I am right here, y’know.”
“You are awake,” wondered Thorin, coming closer as if to see for himself.
“Bombur just said that.”
“In Thranduil’s dungeon, I thought you had awoken several times and I was mistaken several times.”
“Oh. I feel quite well, thank you.”
Bombur bobbed a little on his toes. “Shall I go tell the others?”
Thorin gave a curt nod.
He set aside his broom and happily bustled toward the door.
“Bombur?”
He halted in the doorway and looked back.
Thorin stared steadily at the hobbit. “There is no need to hurry.”
Bombur looked from Thorin to Bilbo and back again. He fought against a knowing smile and bobbed his head in a nod. He left.
Bilbo could not withstand his stare. He wandered over to the table set near the iron stove that apparently now served as their kitchen. He vaguely thought to himself how something as simple as a flat piece of wood elevated campfire cooking into something resembling cooking in an actual kitchen.
“Hobbits are not lucky,” said Thorin.
Bilbo’s fingers skirted about the Company’s collection of battered tin cups, straightening their already tidy, straight lines. “I don’t think so, no.”
“You lied to me.”
“I am sorry for that. I should have told you the truth when we first met and then asked for a promise of secrecy in return, but I did not like the prospect of it.”
Thorin frowned and although no words accompanied it, Bilbo understood it to mean, Why not?
“I did not wish to become the Company’s hobbit. I wished to be your friend. How could I ever be certain if any of you liked me rather than merely valued what I could do for you?” He shook his head with a mutter to himself, “Not that I had any confidence I could do enough for you all.”
Thorin was standing very close now. Bilbo turned and felt his back pressing into the table. He swallowed and bravely met the dwarf’s eyes.
“I am foolish,” said Bilbo. “I knew this whole endeavor was dangerous, ill-fated, and had a dragon at its end, and yet I still underestimated how frequently death would dog our heels. I hoped perhaps I wouldn’t need to intervene at all. But then the first few—they happened while we were chased by goblins or orcs or by spiders... well, there was hardly time to have a proper sit and explain it all.”
“You could have told me in Thranduil’s dungeon. We spoke a great deal about many things.”
“I fought so hard to win your regard, I didn’t wish you obliged to me.”
“I already knew you saved my life from the white orc.”
Bilbo scoffed. “Even I understand there is a difference between saving a life and resurrecting a dead dwarf. I didn’t want you to fear me.”
Thorin gaze suddenly faltered. He stepped back unconsciously and shifted on his feet uneasily, as if the reality of his death had not until that moment occurred to him.
The hobbit’s smile was sad. “See? It is too late. All is changed between us. It is always so between hobbits and other peoples.”
His heart was breaking even as he tried to offer a friendly smile, perhaps one of his last to offer. The dragon was dead, his contract fulfilled. Gandalf would arrive at any day now and would surely be willing to escort him back to the west and the Shire.
“I am very sorry, Thorin.”
He turned away, his sight trembling with tears standing in his eyes. Bilbo felt fingers catch his arm and he was helpless to resist surrendering to a pair of strong hands holding him close against a warm dwarven chest.
Thorin’s voice was low and carried a slight shake that was not usually present in his measured words. “I ardently wish for all to be changed between us, but not like this—not you turning away, not this ache in me.”
“How… how do you wish things to be changed, then?”
A kiss pressed against Bilbo’s lips. It was soft, tentative.
When he looked into Thorin’s eyes, he saw fear there—but not fear of Bilbo or his awful magic that straddled the divide between life and death and called for souls to stand forth. The dwarf feared his going away. He feared Bilbo would reject him.
Bilbo felt a tremendous upwelling of love that had nowhere to go. There was no life to revive, no flowerbed to make bloom, just a swelling of love for Thorin who stole his breath away.
He rose on his toes, threaded his fingers between locks of dark hair and gave proof that Thorin had nothing to fear. Their kiss was passionate, long reserved by them both since neither believed until this moment their growing emotions were mirrored in the other.
Bilbo felt a thrill of pleasure to feel large warm hands move across his back and hold him close. He felt the heat of Thorin’s body. He felt the thrilling press and movement of warm lips across his own. It was obvious neither of them had much practice in such arts, but they made up for their mutual lack with a great deal of enthusiasm. Bilbo felt shivers to hear the quiet little moan overwhelmed by bliss torn from Thorin’s throat. He gasped for air as they broke their kiss and Thorin pressed a row of small, breathy kisses along the side of Bilbo’s neck. He gently kissed away the tracks of his tears until they were no more.
They held each other for a long while, panting and allowing their racing hearts to slow, and basking in one another’s warmth.
“Does this mean you forgive me for lying to you?”
“I do not wholly understand your reasoning, but I understand it was not born from malice. I forgive you. Let us have no more secrets between us.”
“No,” agreed Bilbo, “no more secrets.”
They smiled at one another.
Then Thorin’s eyes fell downward to the stone beneath them. “Is… is that normal for hobbits?”
A large bursting halo of lichens had bloomed around Bilbo’s feet, a pretty mottle of faint greens and white and orange. It quite encompassed half the room.
He laughed in delight. “Normal, but uncommon. I was feeling a great deal of sunflowers just now, but they couldn’t possibly grow on bare stone, so it all came out as lichens instead.” With a grin, he pressed a tiny kiss to his mouth and murmured, “Next time, kiss me outside at the foot of the mountain and I will give you an entire field of tulips!”
Thorin gazed at him in adoring wonder.
They heard Bofur chortle from down the corridor, “Ooh, is our little sleeping laze-abed awake?”
Thorin and Bilbo quickly turned away from each other, but not without a shared look of happy conspiracy. This was theirs, their secret, their pleasure. They would tell the others in time, but for now, this new fragile bloom held between them would be theirs and theirs alone while it branched and grew roots.
Like a faunt unwilling to be caught being naughty, Bilbo hopped onto his bed. He felt a little glad for the opportunity to sit down. Bofur, Bifur, Nori, Balin, Dwalin, and all the rest piled into the chamber, alerted by Bombur their burglar had finally awoke. They greeted him with happy and dwarvishly loud exclamations.
Bofur wagged a finger at him, “Lad, what would your mother say if she knew you were lazing the sunshine away here in your bed?”
He grinned at him around a mouthful of dried apple, “My mother would be quite pleased with me, under the circumstances.”
“I’m so relieved,” said Bofur with a suddenly strangled voice, and then the hobbit found himself half smothered by a fierce dwarven embrace. But Bilbo did not mind because he was accustomed to dwarvish embraces by now and he much preferred it to affectionate head butts.
Bombur then scolded his brother for handling Bilbo too roughly while the poor hobbit was just trying to eat his dinner.
Still kneeling beside Bilbo’s makeshift bed, he swept off his hat, took the hobbit’s hand and set it on his head. Every dwarf grew still and silent.
Bilbo had no hope of understanding the fervent Khuzdul tumbling from Bofur’s lips, but he understood enough. He snatched his hand away.
“No!” he said quickly. “No, thank you, all the same.”
Thorin, who had been haunting the periphery of the crowded chamber, rumbled quietly, “Hobbits do not accept life debts. It is an insult to them to do so.”
Bombur added, “Because hobbits don’t think them debts. They’re gifts.”
“Just so,” nodded Bilbo. “I expect no payment for a gift. Otherwise, it’s not a gift!”
“A life… gift?” said Bofur slowly.
He took a steadying breath. There was no use pretending anymore. They all saw Bombur swallowed by a dragon. There was no excusing that as a mere brush with calamity, which good luck had turned into an escape. Bilbo twisted a corner of his blanket in his trembling hands.
“Yes. We call it Yavanna’s Gift or the Gift of the Green Lady.”
“Can other hobbits do what you did for Bombur?”
“Of course! It’s common to all hobbits.”
Looking overwhelmed, Bofur sat on the floor. Bilbo patted his broad shoulder with an uneasy smile. He did not like the way Bofur stared. His friend was frightened.
Nori now understood what Bofur had just now realized for himself. He held himself very, very still, his gaze fixed upon Bilbo. “Bofur fell at the goblin’s back porch. I saw him. I thought I saw wrong, but I didn’t. He broke his neck.” Nori gave him a calculating, uncertain look. A little piece of Bilbo’s heart broke to feel that look upon him. “And you did something. You brought him back.”
All smiles faded. Bilbo nodded.
“Oh, by Mahal’s grace,” gasped Dori. “Bombur was not the first and Bofur was not the only other!”
Bilbo nodded again, feeling tension creeping into his spine and making his hands feel jittery. He twisted his blankets in his fingers and felt a few ancient threads snap.
“I was too late to reach you, Dori. With the spiders, I mean. I apologize. I tried, I really did, but there were just too many.”
Nori made a little choked noise in his throat. Bilbo ignored it and his eyes swept across the rest of the Company who were peculiarly solemn.
“The barrels? You were right. It was an awful idea. Terrible. I should’ve tried a different way. Balin, Ori, and Óin were all knocked about by the rapids and drowned.”
Bofur fiddled with his battered hat in his big hands. “Is that why when we reached the shore of Long Lake, you were staggering ‘round and vomiting like you’d been too hard at the cider?”
“It’s not easily done, so many in a row. I’m honestly not certain I could’ve managed a fourth.”
“You’ve no hobbit remedy for orcish poison?” asked Kíli plaintively. Fíli clutched at his arm.
“Well, yes, I do. But it’s not an herb. It’s me. The tea I gave you alleviates nausea.”
“By the very beard of Mahal!” exclaimed Óin. “How many of us didn’t die?”
Bilbo frowned, and his eyes flicked across the Company who looked as grim faced as he’d ever seen them. He willed his voice to be brave. He replied quietly, “Bifur, Dwalin, Glóin, Nori, Fíli—and me, of course.”
He could not understand the burst of low mutters in Khuzdul, but he recognized distress, astonishment, fear in the voices of his once friends who obviously could not hold him in friendship anymore. He wore the face of a harmless little hobbit, and it was a deception to them, now. His magic was too foreign, too unknown, too frightening.
“Harkulul!” Thorin’s sharp word of retort immediately silenced them. “The wizard insisted our fourteenth—our lucky member—should be a hobbit. I disagreed. But I now freely admit my error in judgment. We needed a hobbit. Our need is as obvious as the fact we live and Smaug is dead. Bilbo’s presence is a blessing of Mahal. You are fools if you do not see a truth so plain.”
They stood in tense silence and Bilbo felt their stares upon him. He kept his eyes fixed on the stones at his feet. The flecks of lichen there looked out of place. Lichen never grew on stones inside mountains away from the sun, he thought. Nothing grew there.
The eldest dwarf prince was first to break their silence.
“You killed the dragon, Bilbo,” said Fíli plainly. “There’s no use pretending he up and keeled over on his own. His lungs, his veins, his heart—they’re all full of some kind of vine!”
“Yes, well. I didn’t know I could do that. I’ve never heard of a hobbit doing such a thing in a living body rather than a good bit of dirt, but it just felt right in the moment.” He shrugged. “I might have panicked. Just a bit.”
“How is it possible?” wondered Ori.
“Mahal has his children. Yavanna has hers. We’re a less ancient and less storied people, but we were given her gift to use.” He gestured vaguely, “Hobbits make things live and grow. I made things live and grow.”
“Inside the damn dragon’s inner organs?” exclaimed Glóin.
The corner of his poor blanket was coming apart at the seams by his nervous fiddling. He shrugged again. “It seems so. If you plant what’s left of him before the ground freezes, you may have a very nice blackberry bramble next autumn.”
At his side, Bofur blinked in astonishment. “Blackberries… Smaug was killed with a blackberry bush?”
The dwarves looked at one another with incredulous stares.
“Blackberries?” echoed Glóin.
The entire Company bubbled into giggles and then howls of laughter.
Above them all, Bofur crowed, “Lad, your battle standard will bear the mighty blackberry! For what other shrub has ever downed so terrible a beast as the last great fire drake of our age!”
That shattered the tension. To Bilbo’s profound relief, things went back to normal after that, more or less. He was once more the Company’s burglar, and once more they were at ease in his presence. All his doubts vanished like smoke on the breeze.
Thorin, however, made them each swear by their beards they would hold hobbit secrets as carefully as they did dwarvish ones. He explained the Shirefolk would be in danger should any one of them speak carelessly, and what poor recompense would it be if the Company should bring danger upon Bilbo’s kinsmen since he had carried them out of danger himself so many times? Without hesitation, they all made their oaths.
Bilbo might have shed a few tears to be given their trust so freely.
Now that they had all their number back, they made a celebration of what remained of the day. During the past four days, in between their bloody task of cutting the dragon’s corpse to pieces and hauling the carrion outside for the ravens to eat, as well as searching the treasury, someone had explored Erebor’s cellars and found wine and brandy that had not gone to vinegar. They found fine instruments in the treasury, too, so they had wine and music and dancing and what passed as a feast for travelers accustomed to road rations.
Kíli was the first to notice, and he didn’t notice until late in the night. “Say, was the floor in here always speckled like that?” He took a pull of his tankard, “Strange how it’s so round! It’s pretty. Like a starburst!”
Bilbo caught Thorin’s glance from across the room. They shared a secret smile that the rest of the Company would tell them in later years was not half as subtle as they thought it was even if they were all mostly drunk.
The next morning, Bilbo went into the treasury and found the Arkenstone. ‘Til the end of his life, Bilbo could never decide if his discovery of the unnaturally beautiful gem was done by either luck or the dragon’s lingering curse.
