Actions

Work Header

The Gift of Hobbits

Chapter 4

Notes:

With the time jump here, it kinda looks like I forgot to post a chapter. I decided the story didn’t need a whole chapter on the gold-sickness/Arkenstone betrayal since I decided not to vary much from the events in canon. These final two chapters allude enough to those events that I’m confident y’all will be able to pick up on the bits of narrative that did vary from canon without it being narrated.

One difference I don’t explicitly explain anywhere last chapter (I don’t know where that info could naturally fit) is that Thorin is still himself four days after Smaug’s death, but in canon, he’s affected by dragon sickness almost immediately upon entering the Mountain. I figure he was so focused on/worried about Bilbo’s well-being, he was able to unconsciously resist the gold without any trouble, but the moment everything seemed OK, he let his guard down and got himself sucked into the gold lust and didn’t surface again until the Battle of Five Armies already started.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

It wasn’t many days after everything fell apart when Bilbo held his hand tight across Fíli’s mouth and called him back. He felt the heat, the burning sensation of ruptured organs, pierced flesh, shattered bones all rejoining themselves to be whole. Fíli’s body jolted in his arms, and he felt a sudden surge of panic when the dwarf instinctively gasped for breath and found he could not.

“Shh, Fíli, quiet!” he murmured in his ear, unable to keep his voice from shaking. “Please for the love of Eru, keep quiet!”

Fíli’s head bobbed up and down in a shaky nod. Bilbo lowered his hand. The young dwarf breathed heavily, silent tears striping the grime on his cheeks.

From the all-too-shallow hollow in the rock and screened by low scrubby trees naked of autumn leaves, Bilbo and Fíli sat and watched the orcs. There were dozens upon dozens of them milling about the watchtower ruin on Ravenhill.

Fíli clung closer and Bilbo didn’t begrudge him. Others in the Company had thought themselves merely lucky. They believed they had a near-miss, a brief black out, and some lingering aches. But Fíli knew—he felt the blade run him through, he felt the ground rush towards him when Azog dropped him from the top of the watchtower—he knew what it meant to wake in Bilbo’s arms. He held the trauma of dying in his hands. Of course, the young dwarf would quake and tears roll down his face to disappear into his beard.

“Easy there, Fíli.” Something was drawing the orcs away. The closest of them were now too far away to hear the murmur of a frightened hobbit. “Azog didn’t see me. He thinks you are dead. He won’t come back here to capture you again.”

“Bilbo… how could you?”

Feeling bewildered and a little dismayed, he pulled back to look Fíli in the face.

“We cast you out,” frowned Fíli. There was blood in his beard. “We banished you. We let Thorin descend into the worst of the dragon sickness and did nothing to protect you from him. We were jealous of our gold, and some wretched corner of our hearts were glad he did it. I… I do not deserve your friendship. How could you come here into danger to rescue me?”

Bilbo clucked his tongue like a mother chiding her child. “Of all the ridiculous—! I am angry. Upset. Hurt. But what makes you think I would ever abandon you? Of course, I would come!”

A cautious joy lit his eyes. “It is a battle. You are not a warrior.”

“Lucky for us, I am not,” he sniffed. “You didn’t need a warrior just now.”

They both shrank down into the meager shadows. A pair of shambling orcs passed far too close, but by a miracle, Bilbo and Fíli remained unseen or were perhaps mistaken as a pair of corpses tangled up in the embrace of their death throes.

Grimed fingers explored the bent armor where Azog’s blade had pierced him through. “Is… is that what it was like for the others?” Fíli asked in a small voice.

“What was?”

“Dying.”

“You’ll have to ask them. I’ve never died before.”

“Really?”

“Is that so hard to believe?”

A wry smile lifted a corner of his mustache, “The way you hobbits can simply unkill a fellow! Well, if I’d been born a hobbit, me and Kíli would’ve died a half dozen times each before arriving at our majority.”

He scoffed with a little shake of his head. “Calling someone back… it does not come so easily.”

“You are too modest. You unkilled over half the Company! Other than Bombur, it’s not been any great hardship for you.”

The look Bilbo gave him was so exasperated and cross that Fíli instantly understood he had said something at best ignorant, and at worst cruel.

“I don’t know what it’s like to die, but I know what it is to call the dead back to life. It hurts, Fíli. Life is not cheap.”

“I’m sorry.”

He sighed and scruffed a hand through his sweaty curls. “You didn’t know any better. I’m sorry I snapped. It’s been a tiring day.”

He fixed Fíli with a considering look. Fíli patiently returned his gaze without saying anything.

“In the Shire, we have death. But if circumstances are right and the right hobbit is found in good time, well, we have a little less death.” He shook his head, “You don’t understand how extraordinarily lucky you’ve all been! By rights, I shouldn’t have been able to do it at all.”

“Why not?”

“It’s just not done. It’s not able to be done. It—it belongs within family, you see. With kin.” He felt a blush creeping up his neck.

It wasn’t hard. After seven months together, they were all his dwarves. He’d shivered, starved, complained, fought, sung, teased, and worried with the whole Company. He dared to hope that, by now, he was their hobbit, because they were certainly all his dwarves. It was easy to love them.

He cleared his throat and said, “One must have… a certain regard for the other, otherwise they won’t hear you call.”

By the warm grin slowly dawning on Fíli’s face, he obviously understood more than he let on. He teased, “Maybe dwarves are simply very good listeners.”

Bilbo grumbled, “Dwarves are not very good listeners in life. What makes you think death would ever change that?”

His smile vanished. Bilbo sensed the shift, too.

Fíli tilted his head. “I think they’ve gone.”

“I don’t hear anyone, either.”

They crawled to the edge of their hiding spot. Not a single bat flew in the sky. Emboldened by the distinct lack of orc in what was once Azog’s center of command, they rose to their feet. Fíli staggered. Bilbo wordlessly served as his crutch. Treading through footprints left by orcs not even an hour past felt eerie, dangerous, like walking across cursed ground. They left the ruins behind.

There they spotted Dwalin below on the ancient stairs. Warhammer in hand, he gave chase to a pair of clearly demoralized orcs, and he disappeared behind a turn in the stones. Further below the ridge in the opposite direction, on the flat of a small frozen lake, Thorin fought Azog. Thorin was flagging. The way he limped, he was badly injured. Even from here they could see the spread of blood on the white ice.

“Thorin!”

Bilbo stopped him. “No. Fíli, no.”

“But Thorin—”

“Fíli, you shattered both legs, a hip, and part of your spine. You’re going to be wobbling around like a newborn calf for a time. It’s not a matter of desire or will—you were wounded and cannot fight anymore,” Bilbo fingers curled around the edge of Fíli’s breastplate, and he gave him an emphatic little shake. His stern words quelled the rebellious look that flashed in Fíli’s eyes. “I gave you a good gift. Don’t be ungrateful. Don’t throw it away as worth nothing.”

He breathed hard for a long moment and then the tense line of his shoulders relaxed. Humbled, Fíli asked, “What should I do? I will not hide while I’ve been given strength and breath.”

“Go to Dwalin. Maybe find Kíli while you’re at it. Get to where it’s safe. Go help Óin with the wounded—you’ll be useful there. They will need every willing hand to save the lives of the wounded.”

“Wait, aren’t you coming with me?”

“I’ll help your uncle.”

He hissed, “Azog will kill you!”

“I’m not stupid. I won’t let him touch me. I’ll—I’ll chuck a rock at his head!”

Fíli frowned at such a shallow and problematic battle plan as chucking rocks and hoping for the best.

“I’ll be careful and quick! Go on!”

Bilbo turned away, but a hand caught over his bicep and tugged him back. Fíli gently bumped his brow against his. He echoed softly, “Be careful, Bilbo. Be quick.”

“I will,” he smiled reassuringly. It was the first he had smiled in days, and it felt like a white lie.

The rock was a stupid idea. Bilbo’s aim was spot on. The first rock made an impressive thunk of stone on flesh and bone noise, but the second aimed at his skull was batted away by Azog’s bladed arm as easily as if he was swatting away a gnat.

“Perian,” he laughed, and the black words he then snarled made no sense to Bilbo, but they enraged Thorin.

Wounded, his strength spent, Thorin threw himself at the orc with abandon, screaming aloud in Khuzdul that needed no translation. Azog countered and he was brutal.

It was over so, so quickly.


The stink entered his awareness first. Then a throbbing headache. Then stiff aching muscles that did not want to move. Finally Bilbo’s eyes opened and clouded yellowed eyeballs stared back.

He jolted with a gasp. He scrambled backwards, away from the dead orc, but a rough living hand tipped with claws closed around his arm.

The orc eyed him closely. Dark shadows surrounded them, but the light from a nearby campfire was enough to illuminate his ragged features. The orc was very large and wore a small hoop of carved bone in his lip. The guttural words upon the large orc’s lips made no sense to Bilbo, but then he supposed it didn’t matter because the words were obviously not directed to him.

At his captor’s call, a few other orcs approached. One wearing a black-bloodied bandage over one eye looked very closely at Bilbo and he roughly seized his jaw so to slowly wag his head back and forth as he examined him. The one-eyed orc with no sense of personal space then said something—maybe he was merely clearing his throat? Whatever it was he said was apparently satisfactory because Bilbo’s captor hauled him up over his shoulder like a sack of potatoes.

A little startled gasp burst past his lips, but Bilbo strangled back any other sounds.

From his distressing vantage point on the large orc’s shoulder, he could see he was somewhere away from the battlefield, away from Ravenhill, away from the Lonely Mountain. He hadn’t any idea if it was just after sunset or the wee hours of the morning. It was difficult to tell the exact hour by the grey pall covering over both moon and stars. The only reason he could see anything at all was because there were bonfires scattered among the orcs and his sharp eyes could see shadows and the glint of firelight on pale stone and snow. It was rocky here, with great snowy pines pointing upwards, and by the size of the stone cliffs on either side, Bilbo understood they were in a canyon. He heard more than saw a narrow swift stream limned with ice hugging the canyon wall. A shelf of stone and frozen earth rose above it, and strung along that narrow shelf, lay the orc camp.

Orcs were everywhere. Bilbo had been plucked up from what he supposed served as an orcish healing camp, though it looked more like a convenient out-of-the-way spot designated for orcs to either die or lick their wounds for a while. Curious eyes rested upon him as they crossed through a hundred or more orcs resting among ratty tents and wagons and traveling weapons forges and cookfires. He saw no proper shelters, very few blankets. They built their fires high because that was all the warmth and shelter afforded them on a frozen night. Nearly all bore wounds. All stared at him with hate and some bit of curiosity.

Love was important for a hobbit’s survival, and the sensation of such bare hate roiling about him like a terrible flood nearly suffocated him. He trembled.

He was carried up a dark incline to a large sturdy tent. The large orc barked a word of command. A skinny little orc holding a lantern pulled back the tent flap, stared up at them, and disappeared back into the tent with a flick of canvas.

A brief moment later, the skinny orc reappeared and held open the tent flap. Bilbo was hauled inside and immediately dropped to the dirt. It was warm here. Warmth tingled painfully in his fingers and ears. Flames flickered in a rough round stove set in one corner. Bilbo slowly picked himself up. A wild inclination to run like hell nearly overtook him, but he knew it useless. There was no escape for Bilbo Baggins—not in the midst of an orc camp, not when he could hear a very large orc breathing nearby.

Bolg loomed over him. His smile had no joy in it, only satisfaction.

“Perian,” he said, and Bilbo felt he just might vomit. “You will revive him.”

Bilbo’s gaze followed Bolg’s outstretched claw to the massive pale bloodied corpse of Azog the Defiler laid out on the floor of the tent.

He stared at the corpse. He dared to meet Bolg’s gaze. “I do beg your pardon?”

“Revive him. My own father watched you revive that wretched dwarf king months ago, so I know the stories are true. It can be done. You will do this now.”

Bilbo’s legs shook with a refreshed desire to flee.

“I don’t know what stories you’ve been told, but it doesn’t work that way. I, uh, I can’t revive just anybody. If the deceased has been, well, dead too long, they won’t listen when I call. They’re simply too far away to hear me.”

He twisted his bloodied dirt-worn cuff. “And, er, the body needs to be whole. I can’t very well grow somebody a new head, now can I?”

He cleared his throat, feeling stares as sharp as blades. He felt himself blush and felt furious at himself that he could possibly feel embarrassed in front of an orc as if he cared what such slime thought of him. “And perhaps most important, most difficult of all, I must feel… a certain regard for the deceased.”

“You must love the dead one,” said Bolg.

“Well, yes.”

“Have you no love for my father?”

The hobbit’s curled lip to survey the pale body lying between them was reply enough.

Bolg laughed. It was a terrifying sound. “I hold no love for my father, either, but I wish him alive. We have stories, perian. I know these things.”

He barked a word of command in black speech. The large orc left, but almost immediately returned with another dragging a dead body between them.

“Kíli,” gasped Bilbo.

Bolg’s blade swung to halt between his eyes. Bilbo’s outstretched hands dropped to his sides. He shut his eyes tight in self-recrimination.

The orc chuckled like a man winning an uncertain gamble at cards.

An indescribable dread curled in Bilbo’s stomach. Bolg hadn’t known. Bolg hadn’t known for certain until this moment that Kíli meant anything to him.

It was just like the stories of the last age, the dreadful stories of kings of old who kept hobbits as their pets—their slaves. The old selfish kings, as well as this blasted orc, knew exactly how their unloved dead could be revived by a hobbit’s love. They knew how that bloom of life could be stolen. Bilbo’s breath shuddered in his lungs. This was why hobbits stayed in the Shire. He dearly wished he had stayed, too.

The orcs dumped Kíli’s corpse next to Azog’s dead body. They looked like a bloody parody of bedmates curled into one another in repose.

“Our stories say you can do this. Let it be done, perian.”

His heart beating in his ears, Bilbo looked at one body and then the other and stubbornly thought this was a horrific scenario he could not have possibly anticipated when he signed his contract back at Bag End, though perhaps he should have known it was inevitable. And how many hours had it been since their lives had fled? Had it been over a day? How long had he laid unconscious?

Bolg’s small scoff was impatient. “If you are useless to me—”

“No. No, I understand,” Bilbo said quickly. “Just. I need a moment to gather myself.”

Warily eyeing the orc’s outstretched blade still rusted with red blood, he circled round the corpses and fell to his knees next to the mortal remains of Kíli.

He would try.

Kíli did not look well in death. There was no peace in his face, just unnatural slackness covered with dried blood and grime. He gently straightened his limbs. They felt so heavy without any life in them. His muscles were stiff. Dried blood flaked onto Bilbo’s pale hands. He stretched himself across the dwarf. He had been dead so long, no warmth remained in his chest. He shut his eyes.

He flailed with a squawk when a strong hand plucked him up by the back of his coat and dumped him sprawling on top both dwarf and orc.

“No trickery. I will kill the dwarf again and again until you get it right.”

Bilbo raised his head and stared at Azog’s clouded eye. His stomach recoiled to be so close, his imagination expecting fetid breath and a snarling curse between sharpened teeth. Bilbo lay so close, his breath melted frost from its eyelashes. He hadn’t any idea orcs had eyelashes.

Trembling, he wriggled until he rested one hand on the orc’s bare neck, and he turned away and pillowed his head on Kíli’s empty chest. That apparently satisfied Bolg since he did not rearrange them again.

Bilbo wasn’t sure he could do it. He desperately wanted Kíli alive, but he didn’t want Azog to be dragged alongside to share this breath, this life, with him. Kíli would surely hate him. He would likely rather stay dead if it meant the cursed creature who murdered his uncle, his grandfather, his great-grandfather remained dead in whatever pit of hell orcs were resigned to in the hereafter.

Tears sprung to Bilbo’s eyes. He let Thorin die. He couldn’t bring him back. He tried. He failed. His hurt was too much, too big, too impossible for love to dissolve and allow life to return. Kíli will be so sad to live without his uncle who had been to him as a father. Bilbo’s regret and shame felt like blades.

“I’m sorry,” he whispered into Kíli’s tunic. “I’m sorry I’m not enough.”

He seized this emotion muddled with grief and shame and made it grow. He heard a cold heart thud beneath his pointed ear. Beside him, new black blood swelled in a sword-pierced heart. Flesh knit under his fingers. Lungs rose and fell under him.

Then a roar.

His sight briefly blacked out, but he held onto enough of his consciousness to be aware of being thrown aside and hearing the clash of weaponry. He woozily opened his eyes. He felt nearly crushed. A strong arm held him tight. He was shaking—no, the arm holding him was shaking. Kíli held him and the dwarf’s muscles shook and shuddered. His other hand was upraised with a blood-blackened stone in his fist.

Bilbo peeked above the dwarf’s shoulder since Kíli had him shuffled almost completely behind himself. Azog, that hateful thing, was alive.

Bolg was laughing, his sword held between Kíli and Azog.

The orc’s father sneered, a new trickle of blood running down his temple. He growled something in hoarse black speech.

Bolg’s reply was a rough purr. But the longer he regarded his father, the darker grew his frown. His sword swung towards them.

Kíli’s grip grew firmer.

“I warned you against trickery, perian. Did you not believe me?”

“He’s been dead!” snapped Bilbo. “He’s cold! His muscles are shaking off their death stiffness! Put him to bed like a reasonable creature. If you remain unsatisfied in the morning, then you can go ahead and kill me.”

“You will not die,” said Bolg. His head inclined towards the dwarf. “He will.”

A bark of command and orcs swooped upon them. Bilbo swallowed back a choke of fear. Harsh claws attempted to separate them, but after an ineffectual fight while dwarven limbs wrapped around him so tight Bilbo swore his ribs creaked, the orc kicked Kíli in the side with a curse. They were dragged off together.

Far on the other side of camp, away from the firelights, they were flung into a narrow space within five iron grates padlocked together like a triangular coffin.

With a guttural curse and gesture of good riddance, their orc jailors disappeared into the darkness.

On his knees, Kíli rattled the grates. They were rusted, but they held.

“I’m no lockpick and neither are you,” said Bilbo with a weary sigh. “Come here. Let me warm you—best I can, anyhow.” He could not see his expression in the dark, but after a pause, he heard him crawl over the metal grates.

Bilbo tutted as he laid down and pulled a shivering dwarf to rest his head on his chest and his frozen hands in his coat. “After what you’ve been through, you should be put to a soft bed warmed with hot flannel-wrapped bricks, at least two cups of tea poured down your throat, and allowed to sleep for a week!”

“You s-smell like h-hobbit,” Kíli mumbled into his breast.

“Well, you smell of unwashed dwarf, yourself, but somehow I was polite enough not to mention it.”

A small laugh shook his shoulders, but it bubbled into sobs.

He was reminded how very young Kíli was. By rights he should not be in battles with orcs before his beard had even come in.

He murmured into his hair, “Oh, my dear. My poor lamb. I am so sorry.”

Remembering the nights in Mirkwood when he’d spied Fíli soothing his younger brother, he gently combed his fingers through his hair and rubbed at his shoulders wider than any hobbit’s until, finally exhausted, Kíli cried himself to sleep. Bilbo kept awake the long night through and watched for orcs.

Bilbo kept his arms and his coat wrapped around the young dwarf, but he knew poor Kíli could hardly feel rested sleeping here in the frozen air and the cold terror of being caged at the edge of an orc camp. A thin line of grey dawn brightened the tooth-edged top of the canyon walls. All was in shadow, but day was coming.

Kíli rubbed at his eye and with his mussed hair, Bilbo thought he must have a good idea what he looked like as a small child waking from a nap.

“How do you feel?”

“Sore. Thirsty,” he grunted.

“That’s to be expected.”

Kíli stayed reclined on Bilbo’s chest. It was warmer for them both and the confines of the cage would force him to stoop slightly if he sat up fully.

“Bilbo?”

“Hm?”

“I didn’t see anybody the first time.”

“I called for you right away the first time,” said Bilbo. He didn’t need Kíli to clarify what he meant. He stroked his hair gently and thought he felt his shoulders relax. “I watched you very closely at Beorn’s. I didn’t let you linger for fear you would be frightened. You saw someone this time, then?”

“My uncle Frerin. I didn’t realize I was dead at first, and I thought to myself, ‘just who is this dwarf hanging on me and crying?’ He died long before I was born.”

“That’s a rare thing. If anyone greets you, it’s nearly always someone you know.”

“Frerin told me Thorin was an idiot—well, it doesn’t translate right. The Khuzdul word he used is a touch crass, but he meant ‘idiot.’ And he hadn’t any idea what my mother was thinking by letting me follow him.” He breathed a great gusting sigh that momentarily warmed Bilbo’s skin. “I didn’t see any Halls,” said Kíli into his chest. “Are they real?”

His fingers combed through long dark hair and worked down his spine. “I don’t know,” he replied quietly. “If there are Halls of Waiting, by the time a soul reaches them, they are too far to hear a hobbit call them back. All we have are glimpses. Small snatches of conversation with loved ones now dead.”

Then he sounded sadly resigned. “I’m surprised Uncle Frerin was there at all. I rather expected Fíli.”

“Oh! Fíli’s not there!”

The young dwarf looked at him. Hope lit his expression with the strength of a bonfire.

“I sent him limping after Dwalin toward the Mountain.”

Delighted, Kíli laughed, “Oh, Bilbo, I could kiss you right now!”

Aware that he was essentially pinned beneath a dwarf who outweighed him, as well as caged so neither could so much as stand, Bilbo sighed, “Please don’t.”

He did it anyway. It was a happy loud smack of scruffy lips on his cheek and Bilbo thought his ribs might give out by the way Kíli embraced him.

“Oof, yes, that’s quite enough!”

Kíli grinned, “I know you don’t like the idea of life debts—”

“A life debt is an insult to both me and the Green Lady.”

“—but you do realize you are as good as family, now! Right, Uncle Bilbo?”

All good humor instantly crumbled like burnt ash. “Please don’t call me that.”

“What’s the matter?”

Bilbo’s face crumpled. “Kíli… I couldn’t… I tried, but I couldn’t… Thorin…”

“Uncle Thorin is dead?”

He felt wretched. “I’m sorry.”

Kíli settled his head back on Bilbo’s chest. He didn’t speak for a long while.

“He treated you very badly, didn’t he,” Kíli said in a voice made hoarse with emotion. “We all did by letting him do it. It all went bad so fast.”

“All standing up for me would have accomplished is two being banished from the Mountain instead of one. No, I don’t blame any in the Company one bit. Not you. None of them. I’m sorry.”

“He shook it off, did you know?” He raised his head to look Bilbo in the eye with the most heartbreakingly earnest expression. “If he had lived, all would be made right between you, I’m sure of it! He was his old self again once he realized what he’d done to you and then that an army of orcs had arrived. The shock of it all put him back in his place. It was like watching machinery gone out of calibration, and after a good whack of a mallet, the pieces all reseated themselves back into their fittings!”

Bilbo did not understand the metaphor, but he understood enough.

“We did speak.”

“You did?”

“He was dying. He’d killed Azog, but not before he was struck through with his blade.”

Poor Kíli breathed, “Oh, Uncle!”

“He wished to take back his words and deeds at the gate. He told me he would part from me in friendship. He asked for my forgiveness.”

“Did he have it?”

Bilbo nodded, the tears welling in his eyes finally spilling over and wetting his cheeks. “He bid me farewell and said if more people valued home above gold, this world would be a merry place.”

“You made Uncle happy, Bilbo. Fee said so at Laketown.”

He sniffled and wiped his cheek against his shrugged shoulder. His father would have been appalled. “At Laketown?”

“There was always a restlessness in Thorin—just underneath, y’know? But for the first time, at Laketown, he was content. I thought it was because we were almost to the Mountain. But Fee spotted it: he was happy because he was with you.”

“I tried. I am so sorry, Kíli. I will regret it for all my life.”

As he lay dying, Thorin, that stubborn dwarf, told Bilbo he was unworthy of his gifts. With his dying breaths, he insisted if Bilbo called for his soul to return, he would refuse. Bilbo would never repeat those final words aloud—it is better Kíli believe a hobbit’s hurt to blame and not his uncle’s own self-recrimination. Desperate and grieving, Bilbo called for Thorin again and again, and then all was oblivion after a thrown stone struck him in the head. The next Bilbo knew, he was held prisoner by Bolg’s orcs.

With a sickening turn of his stomach, he wondered if the orcs had left Thorin’s body. If the corpse remained intact, even though it had now been a day, maybe two… he choked back a sob in his throat. It was too late. Too late.

“I’m sorry,” murmured Bilbo into Kíli’s hair. “I’m so sorry.” He did not know if he was apologizing to Kíli or to Thorin who was now where he could not hear.

Again, Kíli was quiet for a long while.

“I don’t blame you, Bilbo. Not one bit.”

The young dwarf was so sincere, it was all Bilbo could do to hold him and weep.

Notes:

Everything is made all better in the next chapter—I promise!