Chapter Text
FOUR: Pride and Misunderstandings
The Shire hadn’t changed at all, Bilbo realised. It was as if he had walked out of his door one day and back the next for all the difference there was. There were a few new relationships and a little gossip to catch up on but honestly, he was the main gossip for the first year after his return. And it hurt, being stared at and muttered about behind his back (though not quietly enough to prevent his keen hearing from picking up the hated ‘Mad Baggins’ epithet). But Bilbo had his neighbour and friend, Hamfast Gamgee and Belle, his wife, who were down to earth and treated how they found-and they always found Bilbo polite, friendly and generous with his bakes. A number of his younger cousins also saw him as rather a hero, having gone off on an adventure. And he shared his tales with them, telling his young and eager visitors of trolls and stone giants, of goblins and orcs, of skin-changers and giant bees and Eleven Kings and one very scary dragon. And of course, he spoke of his dwarves, his friends who lived the other side of the world. And he said that he came home because he was a Hobbit among dwarves and missed the Shire too much to stay away.
His more respectable and older relatives treated him as if he had contracted some particularly unpleasant and malodorous complaints and avoided coming anywhere near him, excluding him from family gatherings and celebrations. But some questioned why he should be punished when he had come home so he was still invited to some weddings and of course, all the festivals and High Days that formed the rhythm of life in the Shire. And he was always generous and imaginative when he gave gifts. Of course, Lobelia Sackville-Baggins spent months claiming that Bilbo Baggins was dead and that some cursed changeling had returned in his place and was even now despoiling Bag End which should rightfully be hers. And while some of the more venal and petty-minded Hobbits could sympathise with her complaints, everyone soon grew weary of her unrelenting bile and her words were tuned out.
Over the cold Yule period, he was delighted to receive guests: Bofur, Bifur and Bombur and his family all came over to spend the season with their friend. Bofur had been good as his word and had written as well and it warmed Bilbo’s heart to have a Smial full of noise, bad manners and dwarvish cheer. Hamfast and Belle, his cousins Drogo, Dora and Dudo Baggins and Adalgrim, Sigismund and Flambard Took and their families all spent some time with Bilbo over the holidays and met his dwarvish friends. And though there were some raised Hobbitish eyebrows about the dwarves’ manners (and some hands over young ears at some of Bofur’s rather racier stories), the Hobbits recognised fellow beings who enjoyed good food, family, good ale and good cheer. And the presence of his few tolerable Hobbit relations and his dwarves eased the loneliness and ache in Bilbo’s chest.
He also received a steady stream of letters from Erebor, with some arriving mere days after he had returned to Bag End. Balin and the Princes were the most frequent correspondents but Dis and Tauriel wrote as well along with all of the others-all save, Thorin. Even Dwalin wrote, an unusual occurrence, explaining how sorry he was that Bilbo had left and that he would have stopped Thorin if he could.
“He’s an idiot. You know that and so do I. He and I are warriors and we don’t do long talks about feelings. But he’s also a King and the rumours had half of Erebor laughing at him. Maybe if he was told in private, he could have coped. But that orc-bait Sulgan announced it in Council and humiliated him. His pride took over and you know how well that always works out. He knows how much he has hurt you and himself. But he can’t stop being a King. He is sorry. And so am I. I know Ori misses you and so do I. Honestly, Thorin is like a warg with a hangover so I may need to come for a visit before I hit him over the head and brain him with his own crown…”
Smiling as he read the words and mentally imbuing them with Dwalin’s gruff voice and dry intonation, he allowed himself, just for once, to imagine Thorin. He had studiously avoided considering the King because the subject was too painful. But he could imagine Thorin in Erebor, his famous temper permanently bad due to shame and guilt and hurt and how unpleasant that would be. He rested the letter down. He didn’t need to imagine: he had been on the receiving end of that temper for all of the Quest until he had saved Thorin’s life from Azog and been apologised to on the Carrock. Ori had told him later that he had never heard of Thorin apologising to anyone before-at least, not publicly-so he appreciated the gesture all the more. And he knew, from loving and being married to the King, that his pride was still an issue. He had heard Gandalf warn the dwarf in Rivendell and he had seen it in Mirkwood when Thorin’s pride and still-smouldering grudge against Thranduil had condemned the dwarves to eternal captivity in the ElvenKing’s dungeons.
“Oh Thorin,” he sighed as he folded up the letter and placed it in the drawer of his desk with the others he had received from the Company. “You are your own worst enemy. I can only hope Dis and the boys will get through to you. Erebor doesn’t deserve your wrath.” He shrugged and a Tookish surge of bitterness washed through him. “Sulgan though…well, you can do what you want to that snake.”
Spring brought a new cycle of gardening and Bilbo was determined this year to ensure his garden was in shape and see if he could coax his prize-winning tomatoes back to their former glory. The previous year he had been far too late to grow anything suitable to enter into the Hobbiton and Shire Shows but this year, he was determined that he would reclaim his legacy as Bilbo Baggins, Grower of Unmatchable Tomatoes. He would be an entirely proper Hobbit who grew wonderful vegetables, baked extremely well and was a superb host. And if he hosted dwarrow as well as Hobbits, then that was no one’s business but his own.
Spring was gently warming into Summer when he heard rumours from Bessie Bolger that there was a new blacksmith in Bywater, a dwarf who had taken up the old forge and was willingly taking any and all commissions. She was fairly vague about the details, save he was polite but taciturn and seemed to be on his own. And Bilbo listened politely and absolutely definitely told himself that he did not need to go and investigate. That it was probably some simple dwarf who was doing what Thorin had done when times were desperate in Ered Luin and was working where he could find employment. That he absolutely did not need to see if he could befriend the newcomer because he missed his dwarves fiercely. And he lasted all of two days before he found himself heading out for Bywater market ‘for a change’ as he told himself unconvincingly.
It was a short walk of only a mile or so and it was a pleasant day when Bilbo set out. The sun was brilliant in the cloudless sky but dew was still gleaming on the grass and there were a few early bluebells and pink bells in the verge was he ambled along. Up ahead, the market was in full swing and he smiled and was polite to the stallholders as he worked his way around, buying some quality produce as he slowly approached the forge.
Smoke was curling from the chimney and the hatch was open, a few hobbits coming and going to speak with the blacksmith. Bilbo watched a middle-aged Matron pause and obviously flirt with the unseen dwarf and leave with a smile on her face. Curious, he walked round so he could get a better view through the hatch.
The forge was neat enough, the space a little gloomy but the dwarf was working hard hammering a spade into shape. Bilbo stared, seeing a powerful shape hammering away. The dwarf had a long dark mane streaked with silver and was dressed in dark colours. It was only when he turned that Bilbo stared, ducking back after a moment, his heart pounding.
The dwarf was Thorin.
But how could Thorin son of Thrain, King Under the Mountain, be here in Bywater? How could he be a blacksmith when he was ruling the Kingdom of Erebor? And why?
The Matron he had seen earlier walked past Bilbo, her primrose yellow dress contrasting with her simple straw bonnet trimmed with blue and white ribbons. She was a little plump and had a ready smile.
“Master Lulkhel!” she called and he looked up. Resting his hammer down, he turned to give her his attention and nodded.
“Mistress Gardenia-how may I be of service?” he asked and Bilbo felt a shiver run down his spine.
Oh, he had missed that baritone voice and his heart ached that the dwarf King was here in the Shire and hadn’t come straight to him. What was Thorin’s plan? Was this some other revenge or some plan to entrap and punish Bilbo some more for the temerity of taking Thorin at his word? And why wasn’t Thorin still in Erebor? Had there been a coup? Was he on holiday? Had Dis finally kicked him out?
Why hadn’t he come to see Bilbo?
The Matron was fluttering her lashes at Thorin and Bilbo found an unfamiliar curl of jealousy tighten in his chest.
“Oh, I think you know, you tease!” she tittered as the dwarf gave a slight sigh.
“Mistress Gardenia, I regret that I do not understand,” he said honestly. She looked at him.
“I gave you a bouquet of daisies and asters,” she told him. He frowned and Bilbo understood his confusion because he knew dwarves far better than ‘Mistress Gardenia’ obviously did…
Thorin doesn’t understand the language of flowers. He’s a dwarf. And you won’t find a more dwarvish dwarf than Thorin. Except maybe Dwalin-though even he worked out how to court Ori without half his family haranguing him.
“And I am very grateful,” he said carefully. “They made the forge and my living quarters look far merrier…” Gardenia stamped her foot, her carefully pinned up mahogany curls starting to escape from the knot.
“Do you not understand what am talking about?” she asked and Thorin sighed, reluctantly shaking his head.
“I gave you some very nice treacle tarts and meat pies,” she told him. “Did you not understand that as well?” By now, Thorin was looking very uncomfortable.
“Were they not gifts?” he asked and the turned to the battered metal box under the counter. “I can pay you for them if that was what was expected? I apologise for misunderstanding the nature of our transaction…” By now Gardenia was almost bristling with fury.
“No, you stupid dwarf!” she spat. “I was asking you if you fancied walking out with me.” Thorin’s eyes widened and then he adopted the familiar practiced expression that Bilbo recognised as the one he used when dealing with Thranduil, an experience he always found distasteful.
“I apologise most humbly, Mistress Gardenia,” he said in a regal and polite tone. “I did not understand your intent. We dwarves do not give food or flowers as a mark of affection.” His voice hitched and Bilbo hoped that he was thinking back to all those times when his husband had made him special treats and was realising what he had meant. “I am flattered by your words. Yet while I am far from home, I cannot reciprocate your affections and so, I must respectfully decline.”
She stared at him.
“What?” she spat. “You are turning me down? Don’t you know who I am?” Thorin’s brow furrowed.
“I regret that I am a newcomer to the Shire and I am unfamiliar with your familial ties,” he admitted. Gardenia drew herself up in anger.
“I am a Proudfoot and am the only daughter and heir of Waldemir Proudfoot of Harbottle!” she sneered. “You’d know that if you were a proper Hobbit and not some rude and ungrateful dwarf!” Then her eyes narrowed. “The people around here won’t like that you led me on and were toying with my virtue! You can forget anyone treating you like anything other than a hired hand and outsider, Master Lulkhel!” Then she turned on her heel and marched away, leaving Thorin staring after her with resigned expression on his face. He looked up-and then he froze as his eyes fell on Bilbo. And Bilbo really hoped he hadn’t imagined the instantaneous look of relief and joy that flickered across his gaze before he blinked and then forced himself to look impassive.
“Bilbo…I mean, Master Baggins!” he said, the warmth in his voice unmistakable. Seen and suddenly filled with annoyance that he felt like he had to hide in his own homeland, the Hobbit marched forward, his expression set.
“What are you doing here?” he hissed. Thorin looked taken aback at the tone-but only for a second. He gave a small smile.
“It is good to see you,” he said warmly.
“Is it?” Bilbo snapped, every moment of hurt and outrage at the injustice rising in his throat in an inexorable tide.”That’s rich, considering the last words you said to me were ‘So be it. Accused of adultery and refusing to defend the accusation, my Consort Bilbo Baggins, is banished from Erebor. He may return when his innocence is proven.’” Thorin winced.
“What I did then I was not proud of,” he said quietly. “I know I betrayed your trust.”
“You betrayed everything!” Bilbo yelled at him. “Why didn’t you write?”
“I expected any letter to be burnt.” The words were toneless.
“Then why didn’t you come to see me?” Bilbo yelled. Thorin drew himself up.
“I expected this welcome,” the King explained. “It is richly deserved, after all. After the magnificent gift that you gave to Erebor, to me, I truly realised the depths of my failure and utter…”
“And what is this Lulkhel nonsense?” Bilbo demanded, cutting him off fiercely.
“It is a name I deserve,” Thorin said, hurt flashing in his eyes. “I would not use my own name. Some would know and it could bring distractions.” Bilbo glared at him.
“Distractions?” he snapped. “What are you doing here at all? Who is ruling Erebor?” Thorin dipped his head.
“Erebor is safe,” he assured the Hobbit. “My sister and Balin are assisting Fili…”
“So you dumped the whole thing on him and swanned off…” Bilbo began but Thorin finally lost his patience.
“It was always for him!” he snapped, his eyes flashing with anger. “I was never meant to survive the Quest. The odds were always that we would lose-or I would die. A miracle meant I survived-and that was a gift I never deserved. And I am no longer worthy of the Throne. My family have sent me here to see if anything could be salvaged.”
“They can stop wasting their time. Nothing can!” Bilbo snapped, still furious. Thorin swayed as if struck but he took a deep breath and blinked once, raising his practiced mask.
“Then I beg your pardon, Master Baggins,” he said in a carefully neutral voice. “I will endeavour not to intrude upon your privacy.” Still fuming, Bilbo glared at him.
“Go home, Thorin,” he snapped. “There is nothing for you here.”
“Nothing remains for me in Erebor either,” the dwarf said quietly. Giving a snort of exasperation, Bilbo turned and stormed away, leaving his (former?) husband watching him with sad eyes and a clenched fist. He remained still and straight until Bilbo had rounded the corner, when he staggered and leaned heavily against the wall of the forge. The pain had tightened to an iron band around his chest and he closed his eyes and tried to breathe through it. Even though he had banished Bilbo, he had never rejected the bond-but Bilbo’s words had devastatingly confirmed that he did. And Thorin was not a young dwarf, having lived a hard and dangerous life, a life marked by privation, disappointment and hardships. Perhaps if he was younger, he could endure the rejection better but as he was…? He shook his head and straightened up. He still had time and the worst was over. Bilbo had seen him and he had reacted exactly as Thorin had expected. Now, he could concentrate upon proving he wasn’t the ogre he had shown Bilbo-and maybe salvaging something.
-o0o-
Bilbo studiously avoided Bywater after that, even diverting when he had to visit his Aunt Belba, who had married Rudigar Bolger and had been widowed a couple of years earlier. Her sons Mengo and Holgo visited the old Hobbit daily but Bilbo was a regular visitor as well. She had been his father’s favourite sister and she loved his lemon and thyme cakes so, laden with a basket of baked treats, he made his way round for tea.
When he arrived, he was a little dismayed to find his Aunt Linda also there. Belba’s younger sister had married Bodo Proudfoot and though she was also in advanced years, she was very proper and never wasted an opportunity to gossip. She had given Bilbo an especially hard time on his return and he almost retreated-but Belba saw him at the window and waved him in. By the time he had made his way to the parlour, she was up, her white-haired shape wrapping him in a tight hug.
“It’s so good to see you!” she told him, her brown eyes sparkling with enjoyment. “Linda popped round but I’m sure she can tolerate you-after all, your lemon and thyme cake is the finest in all Four Farthings!”
Linda had snorted. She shared her sister's eyes but had a pinched look about her. However, she was a guest and swallowed her objections to conform to Hobbit norms. After all, she was a Baggins and there was no victory in complaining about her nephew when she was as bad a guest. But she knew that Bilbo took after their older brother in his baking and only a fool turned down Bilbo’s bakes.
In fact, Bilbo had found himself having rather a good time. Belba was a good hostess but she had appreciated the lemon and thyme cakes, along with the strawberry tarts and the cherry-chocolate gateau. Belba had brought him up to speed on family gossip and after her third tart, Linda had loosened up and begun to spill Proudfoot gossip as well.
“Gardenia is still furious,” she continued, helping herself to another slice of the lemon thyme cake. “Being led on by that dwarf.” Belba looked up over her cup of tea.
“Oh, I hadn’t heard that,” she said, sipping away. “Word was he is a sober and polite creature.”
“Really?” Linda sneered. “Who said that? He’s a wretched creature. She gave him a bouquet which he accepted and gifts of food which he ate…but he turned her down. He even offered to pay for the food!” Belba tutted.
“Why would she even ask a dwarf?” she asked.
“He’s an ugly creature,” Linda said spitefully. “While Gardenia is rather a catch. She’s nicely plump, comes from a fertile family and she’s rather well-off. Cousin Waldemir left her very comfortable and she thought he would be exotic.” She leaned closer to her sister. “You know what they say about dwarfs.” Belba cackled and reached for her pipe, clamping it between her teeth.
“Aye,” she agreed as Bilbo felt vaguely uncomfortable. These pair were maligning an entire race he happened to be rather fond of and an individual he had loved. Still loved? Or at least had liked enough to marry…
“Insatiable!” Linda chuckled. “Always at it, strings of lovers wherever they go…they say their women have beards so you can’t tell them…”
“Was Gardenia even sure it’s a male?” Belba asked.
“Apparently so-she checked out the merchandise,” Linda shared in a smug voice. Bilbo inspected his cake, feeling his stomach turn. This was the sort of gossip he had endured in Erebor and it was unpleasant to hear it reversed. “Maybe he thought he could mess with her and not have to bother with any niceties…”
“Well, they’re all grasping, greedy creatures. Maybe he’s after her money?” Belba suggested. Bilbo swallowed.
No, he owns enough treasure to buy the Shire, he thought.
“He is a dwarf,” he said. The two older Hobbits stared at him.
“That’s what we said,” Linda said superiorly.
“No,” he sighed. “Dwarves don’t even know there is a language of flowers. They know nothing. He will have seen a pretty piece of vegetation, not a declaration of intent to court.” The two Hobbitesses stared at him.
“What?”
“But how…”
“How can they declare intent to court…?” Linda asked in a disbelieving tone.
“They give gifts,” Bilbo told her bluntly. “Usually made of gold or gems. They are creatures of the rock, not of green fields and living things.”
“Bilbo should know-he ran off with a bunch of them!” Belba put in, puffing her pipe through clenched teeth.
“Yeah…now tying the name Baggins to the term ‘Mad’!” Linda complained.
“Let’s be honest-Belladonna would have been amused and is certainly watching and laughing her ass off in Yavanna’s Green Fields!” Belba chuckled. “Young Bilbo going off on an adventure.”
“Belbs! Keep to the point. That nasty dwarf led Gardenia on…” Linda insisted.
“And to them, food is food,” Bilbo added firmly. “He would have seen a kind gift, not a declaration of intent.”
“What kind of soulless creatures are they?” Linda sneered. “They don’t understand food and flowers? And they’re all promiscuous!” Bilbo stiffened. It echoed the accusations that had been levelled at him and he knew that Thorin was faithful. His pride and his honour would allow nothing different-a reason why his reaction to the unfounded rumours had been so extreme. He knew from Ori that his plan had been fulfilled and that Borin son of the Deathless had been returned to Erebor and interred with huge Honours into the tomb that Bilbo and Bofur had designed…but for Thorin to be so maligned roused the protective instincts he felt whenever anyone bad-mouthed his dwarves.
“Actually, they love only once,” he said quietly. “Many never find their One…what they refer to their Heart-Mate as…and not all recognise the bond. But they are faithful until death to their beloved.” Linda snorted.
“Well, that blacksmith isn’t married,” he said. “No sign of a wedding ring…”
But he was still wearing his wedding braid, Bilbo realised, rerunning his memory. It had been about the only one he had retained.
“Typical,” Belba agreed. “A rogue…” Bilbo rose suddenly.
“He is married,” he said sharply. “The braid in his hair shows that. He actually has a ring-of iron-but that is a sign of his house and his craft.”
“How would you…?”
“Because I married a dwarf!” Bilbo snapped. Both old Hobbitesses stared at him. “I married a dwarf.”
“Where is he now?” Linda sneered. Bilbo turned away.
“He showed he did not trust me,” he said angrily. “So I left him.” There was a pause and then Belba achingly rose to her feet, wrapping him in a warm hug. To his shock, Linda joined in as well.
“Oh Bilbo,” Belba sighed. “I am so sorry. It is so distressing when you find your partner isn’t what you believed.” Quietly, the younger Hobbit nodded. Linda gently stroked his curls.
“I’m sorry,” she said. “Looks like Gardenia had a lucky escape.”
“Dwarves are very secretive about their customs and culture,” he murmured. “I thought I understood him. But he didn’t understand me. He didn’t trust me…”
“Then he’s a fool,” Belba said firmly. “You are a fine Hobbit, Bilbo.”
“But I think he needed a dwarf,” Bilbo sighed. “He doesn’t understand Hobbits.”
“You said they only love once,” Linda murmured. “So you are the only love he will ever have. He’s the fool in letting you go and not learning about the one who owns his heart.” She kissed his curls. “Now did I tell you what Gurdo Proudfoot got up to at the Spring Races?”
But as he walked back towards Bag End, he glanced down at the Forge. There was still smoke curling from the chimney and he wondered why Thorin had come. He would have come straight to Bilbo if it had just been for a talk. Somehow, the ridiculous dwarf had chosen some sort of penance for himself but it was no longer Bilbo’s problem. Thorin had broken their bond by not trusting his husband.
His stupid heart would have to continue yearning for his lost love.
