Chapter Text
FIVE: Hope and Rejection
Summer deepened and the days were filled with plenty to keep Bilbo busy. His garden needed tending and his tomatoes were coming along well. There were weddings every week and parties and other events to keep him busy. The Shire was in bloom and for a Hobbit, the world was at its best. There was plentiful fresh food, lots of company and gardening to keep him busy. And sometimes, when he was sitting in the shade under the oak tree by his home, he wondered how warm it was in the forge-before he schooled himself and forced himself not to complete the thought. That Thorin chose to be in the Shire, working like an itinerant blacksmith instead of home in Erebor was his choice. It wasn’t for Bilbo to worry about him.
One morning in late May, he emerged from his front door to check the morning and found a small bouquet laid on his doorstep. It was simple, tied with plain string and there was no note. But to a Hobbit, the flowers spoke eloquently enough. White Clover - Think of me; Bluebell -humility; Chamomile - patience in adversity and a purple hyacinth for sorrow. Bilbo picked the flowers up and sniffed them: they were fresh and the scents were beautiful as well. Quietly, he walked down and saw, amid the fast-evaporating dew, the marks of booted feet. And then he sighed.
Thorin had brought him the bouquet speaking in a language he clearly didn’t know but had gone to pains to learn. Hobbits were less secretive than Dwarves and it was likely he would find someone to teach him the basics. And also, thinking about it, how to recognise the flowers, since his husband hadn’t been able to recognise anything except a few trees and knew flowers only by their colours. He had worked out that red meant passion or love and when he did give Bilbo flowers, there was a preponderance of red and white. Fortunately he had never really misstepped but Bilbo had wished that Thorin had asked his husband about the flowers more. Of course, amid his anger and hurt at how things had ended, Bilbo had forced himself to remember that Thorin was affectionate, tactile and incredibly patient. He showered his husband with gifts and indulged his interests, so their rooms were littered with books on ancient languages and maps, Bilbo had a Hobbitish wardrobe and they entertained far more than Thorin would have chosen…but he played the host with good grace. There were even doilies… And he did adore his Hobbit.
Bilbo blinked and he almost flung the bouquet to the ground but something stopped him. Thorin was here, alone and isolated and he knew that Bilbo was beyond angry at him. But he had stayed and was tentatively reaching out again. This was an attempt at an apology. It wasn’t anywhere near enough but he would accept the bouquet because it was thoughtful. So he went inside and placed the flowers in a nice vase that sat on the kitchen table. And somehow, that day felt all the better for knowing that he had been given flowers by his husband.
Bofur arrived unexpectedly a week later and Bilbo greeted him eagerly. The miner was his usual cheery self and it eased something in Bilbo’s heart to see him unchanged. He regaled the Hobbit with tales of Ered Luin and how Bifur and Bombur were getting on. In return, Bilbo shared the Shire gossip and carefully brought up the subject of Thorin. Bofur was very quiet and thoughtful after he had heard the tale and considered before speaking.
“He has an ulterior motive being here,” he agreed as he stared at the window. “I am not sure why he’s here. He rejected you, didn’t he?”
Bilbo rolled the events of that day round his head: in truth, he had rerun every word a thousand times and had dissected every nuance.
“No,” he said quietly. “He banished me but he always referred to me as his Consort. He gave me the chance to return. I was the one who told him that without trust, there was no point us being together. I removed my ring and marriage braid and left the beads on the floor before leaving.”
Bofur stared at him, then exhaled.
“Ah,” he said. “That would be it.” This time, it was Bilbo’s turn to frown, even as he rose from the kitchen table and refilled the kettle for a fresh cup of tea.
“What?” he asked irritably. The last thing he needed was Bofur getting all mysterious on him. “You dwarves and your secrets…” Bofur leaned forward and drained his ale.
“What do you know of Ones?” he asked. Bilbo threw his hands up in exasperation.
“Very little considering I am a One,” he grumbled. Bofur managed a grin at that.
“Aye…unfortunately, it seems being one doesn’t gift yer with the knowledge,” he said philosophically. “Dwarf relationships don’t really break down. Only very rarely because when you meet your Soul-Mate, nothing could make you doubt them.” Then he winced. “Not if you’re sane, anyway…”
“Well, we know Thorin has had issues in that department…” the Hobbit sniped and as he said the words, a pang of guilt hit him. What if it was true? What if Thorin wasn’t well, if the Dragon Sickness had left a lasting legacy? According to Oin and Ori, no one had ever recovered from the affliction so Thorin’s case was unique. No one knew what the long-term effects would be.
“Aye, well in the few cases where the bond is broken by rejection, it can cause pain for the rejected partner,” Bofur said. Bilbo frowned.
“That’s not me,” he realised, grimacing. “I rejected Thorin when I walked away, didn’t I?”
“Maybe,” Bofur said. “I can go speak to him, ask him what he’s doing…” But Bilbo shook his head.
“No,” he said quietly. “I will deal with it. In my own time. I don’t want any unpleasantness marring your visit.” then he grinned. “So what shall we have for dinner?”
Bofur stayed a week and accompanied Bilbo to a wedding where he danced and sang and generally acted like the sociable being he was. Bilbo actually saw Thorin at the back, his tall shape unmistakeable, but the dwarf ducked his head when he saw Bilbo staring at him and retreated. A flash of insight told him that Thorin had maybe hoped to speak with him but had stood down at the sight of Bofur and part of Bilbo was pleased at that…but a small part was disappointed that his former husband hadn’t the courage to proceed anyway. Though he knew that he was liable to be sent away and maybe his pride didn’t invite the certain public humiliation…
Life got busy and Bilbo pushed the concerns to the back of his mind. The bouquets resumed, always proclaiming love, regret, longing and sorrow and the Hobbit secretly enjoyed the gifts though he knew that the tentative approach could not come to anything because their issue had not been love but trust. And nothing had done had shown Thorin trusted him any more: in fact, now he came to think of it, wasn’t Thorin’s presence a huge red flag? He was literally here in the Shire, watching Bilbo and making sure he wasn’t getting on with his life! Angry and spiteful, he tossed the latest bouquet onto the compost heap and bustled around his day, feeling just a little unsettled. It wasn’t his fault that Thorin couldn’t take ‘no’ for an answer!
But sometimes, he still shopped in Bywater Market because Mistress Salvia Dunhaven made the most exquisite cheeses and Bilbo did have a very soft spot for a sharp, well-matured hard white cheese. Especially the ones she made with cranberries, walnuts or seeds incorporated. And if he happened to look over to the Forge-well, it was natural to see how the newcomer was doing. Certainly, the Forge always seemed to be busy and there was a steady stream of Hobbits going to the hatch to bring new items for repair or replacement, collect their repaired items or enquire about work. And Thorin always dealt with them politely and reasonably. The market traders never had a bad word to say about him.
“Say what you will, that dwarf has always been most decent,” Salvia said to Bilbo apropos of nothing. Probably because she had noted his eyes always drifted to the Forge whenever he visited for cheeses (which he had four times in the last two weeks). “Helps all of us set up our stalls and always runs out to help us take ‘em down quick if the weather turns inclement. Never a rude word and keeps himself to himself.”
“I am pleased to hear it,” Bilbo forced himself to say. He didn’t want to hear about Thorin’s life in the Shire because he was not interested. Not at all. Salvia gave a wide grin.
“You always check on him as if he’s about to run out of there waving a battle axe,” she noted smugly. “And I defer to your expertise since you ran away with a hoard of ‘em a few years back.”
“Thirteen. And one wizard,” Bilbo said absently, watching Thorin carefully bend forward to be eye level with a faunt sent by his Da to purchase a bag of nails.
“I’m not sure what you sense about him but he doesn’t seem dangerous to me. Is he?”
“No. He’s entirely honourable,” Bilbo told her, turning away. “He just reminds me of someone I once knew.”
“Ah.” Salvia’s grin was knowing. “I take it your friendship with that person didn’t end well?” Bilbo swallowed.
“It ended on a stupid misunderstanding worsened by pride, stubbornness and some scurrilous and unfounded rumours,” he said briskly. "Thank you, Mistress Dunhaven. I need to get back to bake some fresh poppy seed biscuits to go with these excellent cheeses. I know I will be looking forward to them at tea time.” She pressed a small package into his hand.
“Try the truffle variation,” she said kindly. “I only keep it for my best customers. And you look like you need cheering up.”
When little Ivy Underwood got herself lost in Bindbole Woods, Thorin was there with the search crews and found the tiny faunt by going closer to the racing stream than any sane Hobbit would go. Seeing him emerge damp, muddy and triumphant with the precious child in his arms caused a brief surge of pride in Bilbo’s heart, for whatever his motives, the dwarf’s presence had saved that child. The river was rising after the recent rains and she would certainly have been swept away. Hobbits treasured their children but they could not have known that dwarves treasured children even more, for so few were born: Thorin would have willingly risked his life to save a child of any race. But it was noticeable that after a few perfunctory thanks and a couple of claps on the shoulder, the dwarf was left behind as the Hobbits went off to celebrate the safe recovery of little Ivy. Because he was close to the back of the group-though still included-Bilbo saw Thorin’s shoulders slump and his head bow for a moment before he erected his practiced facade and made his way back to the forge. An unfamiliar pang of guilt shot through Bilbo then, for Thorin did seem to be very alone. Even in a Company of dwarves, Bilbo was welcomed by Bofur and Ori and Balin, who tucked him under their wings and reassured him even when Thorin was being a complete arse. But Thorin had no one and Hobbits were even more insular and slow to trust.
Watching the retreating figure, Bilbo pondered that maybe was part of the reason he had been so hurt. He had trusted Thorin-not once but twice. The first time was, of course, when their friendship developed after the Carrock and the dwarf King had opened his heart and shared with the Hobbit. It had been flattering especially to be included in every part of Thorin’s life. The boys had loved it, already jokingly calling him Uncle Bilbo to the growling disapproval of their real Uncle. And they had grown closer, especially in Mirkwood where Bilbo has spent a fair few nights sitting by Thorin’s cell, talking to the dwarf and trying to stop him sinking into depression at his own failure and stupidity. Thorin was prone to blame himself and brood-Bofur had joking referred to him as ‘his Royal Broodiness’ back in Erebor-and Bilbo had realised that a long life filled with hardships, disasters and failures had scarred the King more than he would reveal even to his own kin. Bilbo was certain that Dis knew-she had asked him to watch over her ‘idiot brother’ when they had married-but even Thorin was bad at acknowledging his own self-loathing. It was obvious that the King had relied on Bilbo’s visits to keep his spirits up enough to endure the captivity. And when they had escaped, there had been another of those warm, all-encompassing hugs and the whispered words ‘thank you’ in Bilbo’s ear. And he had felt then that he would do anything for Thorin if he could stop him falling so low again.
But then there had been Erebor and that immense treasure, infected by the bile and greed of Smaug that had afflicted all of his dwarves-but Thorin fastest and far the worst of all. And Bilbo had been conflicted because he knew and trusted that Thorin would not hurt him-but he could not get through to the dwarf he was growing to love and could see him sinking further away. And perhaps he had been foolish, trusting a mentally-ill dwarf not to lash out but he had trusted Thorin-and his violent reaction to finding out that Bilbo had taken the Arkenstone had shattered Bilbo’s trust. Hanging over the ramparts, the hatred and fury in Thorin’s eyes had been terrifying and Bilbo had been shaking as he had clambered down the rope to return to Gandalf.
But he had still cared for Thorin and when the Battle came upon them-a Battle Bilbo’s treason had failed to prevent, though he had stopped the forces of Men, Elves and Dwarves from destroying each other before the orcs arrived-he had plunged in to try to protect his friends. And racing up to Ravenhill, feeling as if his heart would burst, he had found them fighting. Fili and Kili were badly wounded, possibly dying and Dwalin was fighting half an army of goblin mercenaries on his own as Thorin battled Azog. And as Bilbo watched, he saw his dwarf go down, injured and exhausted. And his heart had almost stopped as he watched Thorin pull his sword away and allow Azog to strike a lethal blow to allow him his own chance to finally kill the murderer of his grandfather, brother and father-and possibly his nephews and himself. Azog had died and Bilbo had been almost too late, saying his farewell but flagging down the eagles. And when Thorin had been saved, Bilbo had stayed. He had accepted Thorin’s heartfelt apologies and assurances that the Dragon Sickness was gone. And Thorin had never given him any reason to doubt…until the day that he had confronted Bilbo into front of the Council. And then, hurt and angry, Bilbo had realised his trust had been misplaced and he had walked away.
He glanced in the direction that Thorin had vanished. The hurt was still bubbling there, anger at being betrayed once more. Yet Thorin had never renounced his love and had intended his banishment to be temporary. And before, he had allowed his friendship and concern for his dwarf to take him to Thorin’s side in the Battle. This time, he had allowed anger to rule because he had not perceived any danger to the King and he had walked away. And in doing so, he had given up on their friendship as well as their marriage.
Then Bilbo shook himself. Thorin’s lack of trust had shattered everything and this time, Bilbo could not expose himself once more. He would have to harden his heart to the dwarf and realise that any solitude and isolation was Thorin’s choice. He would not be so unhappy himself if he had been a proper Hobbit and had not trusted the King a second time.
But there was that little pang of guilt that jabbed him every time he saw Thorin either in Bywater Market or at any of the many gatherings and events that took place that summer. Thorin attended many of them, always at the back, usually alone and always gazing at Bilbo with undisguised longing and sorrow in his eyes. It began to irritate the Hobbit because he was worried that some of his more astute relatives would realise that there was something between Bilbo and ‘Master Lulkhel’ the dwarf blacksmith. Honestly, Bilbo wanted to go and yell at him sometimes but Hobbits were generous hosts and it wasn’t done for guests to argue. Even if one of them was largely unwanted and isolated.
Gardenia Proudfoot made sure she continued to spread rumours about Thorin which didn’t help him either. Whenever word got round that he was helpful or generous or that he had performed some useful local service, she would launch a fresh set of rumours about his dishonourable conduct and that would scupper any chances of acceptance. The fact that she was now walking out with Jumbo Freshfield didn’t seem to dampen her vindictiveness against the dwarf who had rejected her and Bilbo found himself feeling sorry for Thorin. He had been the subject of enough rumours in Erebor to know how unpleasant it was to have everyone gossiping about you but at least he had his friends there to comfort him. Thorin endured alone.
So against his better judgement, he had travelled down to the forge one evening, knowing that Thorin didn’t rent a smial or room in the Green Dragon Inn. Almost turning round three times, he had finally made it to the door and had rapped on the wood firmly.
There had been nothing for a long moment and Bilbo had almost turned away before he heard the bolt slide back and the door open. Thorin had looked out for a blank moment before he tried to control his surprise. He had unconsciously smiled as well.
“Bilbo…I mean, Master Baggins…” he said, his deep voice betraying his shock. “To what do I owe this honour?” Bilbo shuffled his feet. Thorin had shed his tunic and was only in a loose shirt and his leather trousers, his heavy boots of course ever-present. He looked tired and worn to Bilbo’s eyes.
“I brought you…” He gestured to his basket. Thorin gave a small smile.
“Food?” he checked. Bilbo rolled his eyes.
“This is just food. No ulterior motive or meaning. It is not a proposal or offer or anything. Are we clear?” he said firmly. Thorin nodded.
“Perfectly,” he said and accepted the basket. “Thank you. I…”
“Enjoy,” Bilbo said and turned away. He heard Thorin’s sharp intake of breath.
“You aren’t going to stay?” he asked, the hope in his voice painful.
“I think not,” Bilbo said firmly. “Think of this as a thanks for the flowers.”
Thorin’s face closed and he lifted his chin regally.
“They required no repayment,” he said stiffly. “It was the only way I could talk to you.” He swallowed. “I assume this is not a reply.” Bilbo shook his head.
“Enjoy the food,” he said quietly and turned and walked away.
That night, he found himself unable to sleep, the expression on Thorin’s face haunting him. There had been an instant when he had made clear that he wasn’t making any time to spend with the dwarf that the hope in Thorin’s eyes had vanished and a flash of pain had replaced it-before the mask was back up. He knew that Thorin was isolated and even letters delivered by raven were poor substitute for time spent in the company of someone agreeable. And memories surfaced, of nights spent by the fire, Thorin exhausted after a day of meetings and dealing with the complaints of his people but able to relax in the company of the one he loved. And there had been times spent with the Company or with Thorin’s family, the Princes goofing around and Dis smiling at their antics…and even Tauriel smiling serenely as she watched her love banter with his brother. It was relaxed and warm and homely…and Bilbo still missed it. But Thorin didn’t even have the comfort of family as Bilbo did and he could not tell anyone who he was or why he was in the Shire. For whatever reason he had deemed that the penance of isolation, worsened by seeing the One he loved who had rejected him over and again, was the correct one for his transgression. And Bilbo’s private anger at his perceived wrongs had him maintaining the distance, even when his heart was screaming for him to offer an olive branch to the lonely King. So he tossed and turned and sleep eluded him until the dawn was already warming the sky.
In the morning, the basket was waiting on his doorstep, the plates scrubbed clean and neatly stacked within. A small bunch of rosemary, sweet woodruff and willow and a single deep crimson rose was resting by it. Bilbo rubbed his aching head and snatched the basket, resting the bunch on the table and wondered what he could do. He could ask the Thain, his cousin Fortinbras, to ask Thorin to leave the Shire but there was something that was stopping him. His presence made Bilbo uncomfortable because Bilbo was feeling guilty, not because he was going anything threatening. Though a bouquet saying ‘remembrance, humility, sadness and mourning’ was a good way to make the Hobbit feel worse. After all, Thorin had banished Bilbo when all Bilbo had done was plot and plan to recover his lost ancestor to bring honour to his Kingdom. And he had listened to scurrilous gossip that had impugned Bilbo’s character when he would never betray his husband…
But Thorin had never renounced his marriage. He had remained married to Bilbo despite the rumours, despite the facts that-apparently-half of the mountain was laughing at him for being cuckolded. It had been Bilbo who had rejected Thorin and stormed off, leaving the mountain without a further word to his husband, despite the pleas of the Princes. Bofur had seemed concerned that it was Bilbo who had done the rejecting and Bilbo muttered a generic curse against all things dwarvish for their ridiculous secrecy. The only dwarf in more than two hundred miles was the subject of Bilbo’s ire and there was precisely no chance that the Hobbit could walk up to his former husband and ask what it was that he was missing.
‘Remembrance, humility, sadness, mourning.’
Thorin wasn’t known to be eloquent but the bunch of vegetation spoke of a wounded heart, mourning his marriage and begging for another chance. The fact he was remaining as a poor smith in the Shire, alone and isolated, spoke volumes of his resolve. He was the most stubborn dwarf Bilbo had met-but the Hobbit knew that he was Thorin’s equal and he would not surrender so weakly. And what had Thorin shown him that could persuade Bilbo to trust him again? What had he shown Bilbo at all, except his willingness to step back from the trappings of royalty, by leaving the Kingdom he had dreamed of regaining for 170 years and all his family behind? He had not spoken of their shared past, not even used his own name and he was isolated and clearly finding it hard. So why didn’t he just go home? Why did he insist in tormenting himself?
But after that morning, here were no more bouquets.
Summer peaked with a run of weddings and Thorin lurked at the back, nursing an ale and being perfectly polite to anyone who approached. A few daring Hobbit lasses asked him to dance and he gravely obliged, attempting not to tread on any feet and being quietly laughed at by the watching Hobbits for his ignorance of their customs, dances and celebrations. Bilbo watched, feeling guilty but not enough walk forward to rescue Thorin’s dignity. But the dwarf was useful for breaking up any scuffles between drunken Hobbits and Bilbo guessed he was asked to come along for that reason alone. But he never approached Bilbo, seeming content to watch the Hobbit as he laughed with his relatives and danced when the music started.
The harvest started and suddenly days were long and the population were all occupied in getting food in for the winter. Bilbo’s garden was productive and he began to harvest his own produce, setting to work baking and drying but also pickling and preserving where he could. He got up early and picked blackberries by the basketful, for he loved the fruit and knew it was one of Thorin’s favourites…and then he shook himself. It was foolish to waste free bounty because it reminded him of his former husband. So he harvested to keep busy and restocked his pantry once more.
The West Farthing Harvest Show was a grand affair and almost everyone entered something in one of the categories. Bilbo’s tomatoes won as he had hoped and he got an honourable mention for his squash and cucumbers, though he was delighted that Hamfast won both categories. Bilbo’s lemon and thyme cake was also a winner as expected and he felt a surge of pride at the congratulations of the many Hobbits who approached him as the champion. Thorin hung back, though he bowed his head when Bilbo looked up and the Hobbit favoured him with a happy smile. Looking around, Bilbo saw that Thorin had also won a prize for a beautiful set of garden tools he had made and looked around for his dwarf to offer his congratulations but he seemed to have vanished. He only saw him again when the winning exhibits were being auctioned off to fund the Benevolent Fund for Elderly Hobbits, a group who visited elderly and lonely Hobbits in the winter. Thorin bought both of Bilbo’s winning lots, paying well over the odds. That had Bilbo thinking, for Thorin had worked hard and had few expenses-not that he was short of money. He was the King of Erebor, the richest Kingdom on Arda. But the thought that Thorin had been determined to own his produce had him confused. Thorin didn't even like vegetables and would discreetly push tomatoes to the side of his plate in Erebor. It made little sense.
Harvest was over and the last days of summer started to fade into the warm days of early autumn when a letter arrived from Fili. Bilbo had been shocked at the sleek raven tapping its beak patiently at his kitchen window but he was well-enough versed in raven post to let it in, thank it for its efforts and feed it a bowl of meat and sausage pieces before collecting his letters. Then he sat in the parlour with nice cup of tea, a warmed cheese scone and read his letter.
Dear Bilbo,
It was good to hear from you once more. I am so glad your tomatoes won their class as you expected. I had every faith that you would succeed again (Kili bet against you! But Tauriel was on your side.).
I know that you mentioned Thorin was in the Shire. Have you spoken to him yet? You haven’t mentioned anything since that first letter and that gives me cause for concern. We know how stubborn and stupid Uncle can be but none of us doubts his love for you. Your rejection is incredibly painful for him and in the end, he had to come after you. I hope you have patched things up because he is not a young dwarf and his time is limited.
Erebor prospers. Kili and Tauriel are still planning their wedding and Amad is interfering as usual. It will be a long time before she feels able to step back but at least Kili and Tauriel talk so of there is any point of contention, they decide between themselves and provide a unified front to Amad. Ori sends his love-he and Dwalin are still courting but everyone is starting to bet when Dwalin will make his proposal gift. If it’s not soon, I fear Dori may threaten Dwalin!
Please come back and visit us. All the Lords have been shut up-Uncle banished half of them in the months after you left and was like a warg with a sore paw. I hope he’s calmed down now he’s closer to you.
Please be kind to Uncle. It’s hard to give your whole heart to someone and have them then reject it.
Your friend,
Fili.
Bilbo snorted. Fili was far more sober than he had been on the Quest, the combination of surviving being impaled in Azog’s blade and a fall that should have killed or crippled him coupled with three years of observing the job of King making him grow up. He was still warm and had a wicked sense of fun but he was also more adult at times. And this seemed to be one. It implied that Thorin wasn’t writing home and Bilbo sighed. He would have to seek to the dwarf again.
A series of thunderstorms confined him to the Hill and Hobbiton for a few days and when he made his move, the autumn rains had set in. The temperature had dropped and the breezes had begun to lash the trees. The leaves were starting to look tired and everything was looking grey and washed out. In a break between the showers, Bilbo trudged along the muddy roads to Bywater and rapped on the Forge. Thorin opened the door, controlling his face and bowing slightly.
“Master Baggins,” he said formally. “How may I be of service?” Bilbo sighed and huddled in he shade of the roof, for it was beginning to spit.
“Have you written to your family since you arrived?” he demanded. Thorin’s brows dipped and he scowled.
“I have had no news to given to them,” he said flatly.
“They worry about you!” Bilbo argued, trying to hold onto his temper. This was the downside of knowing Thorin: the stubbornness and the way he stated something as if it was the end of the argument, not a starting point.
“I am aware of that.”
“And I am sure they miss you,” Bilbo said, pulling his collar up. It was drizzling now. Thorin stepped back and gestured to invite him in. Cautious, he advanced only so he was just inside the open doorway, with Thorin standing back in the gloom.
“And I miss my sister and my sister-sons,” the King said quietly. “I will miss them for the rest of my life. But they understand why I have to be here.”
“And why do you have to be here?” Bilbo demanded angrily. Thorin blinked and tried to look reasonable.
“Because you are here, of course,” he said as if it was obvious.
“But you have a home and a family in Erebor!” the Hobbit protested.
“And a One who resides in the Shire,” the dwarf told him.
“A One who you banished!” Bilbo sniped. Thorin thinned his lips and took a slow breath through his nose.
“You banishment and that of the Family Ur was rescinded,” he said impatiently. “You may return to Erebor whenever you wish.”
“And when was I supposed to learn of that?” he asked. Thorin looked exasperated.
“I would have thought you would understand when Ori wrote to you of the success of your scheme,” he said. “When I found out what you had been doing…and understood why you did not wish to share details of your meetings with Bofur…”
Bilbo saw red.
“So that is the reason why you are here?” he snarled. “Guilt because you realised you made a mistake? Nothing about realising that it was your lack of trust that would have driven me away, no matter what you decreed! And you don’t realise what you did.” Thorin gave a bitter laugh.
“Oh, I realise,” he said bluntly. “I realise that my jealousy about my husband drove you away. I realise that my stupidity led the One I love, my heart, to leave me. I realise that I was already blessed to be given a second chance after my unforgivable behaviour on the ramparts and I threw that away in my pride. And I realise that living in Erebor without you isn’t an option. If you were a dwarf, you would understand.”
“But I am not a dwarf!” Bilbo yelled. “You keep saying this. Bofur did the same thing when I spoke to him and…” Thorin froze.
“You discussed our situation with him?” he asked in a freezing voice.
“Well, no one explains anything and you dwarves never talk about your Ones or culture or anything that may make sense!” Bilbo shouted. “Bofur is my friend! Of course I asked him because he was the only dwarf I knew I could talk to about it.”
Thorin flinched and looked as if someone had just stabbed him.
“I see,” he said in a strangled voice. “I understand. I apologise. But you shouldn’t worry about me, Master Baggins. I will endeavour not to trouble you for the remainder of my time here.”
“You’re impossible!” Bilbo snapped. “Just write to your family!” Then he turned and walked out into the rain to begin the muddy walk home. Thorin leaned against the wall, his arms folded across his chest, trying to ignore the pain.
“I have no need,” he said quietly, “because when the time comes, they will learn of my fate from you.” And then he slammed the door against the storm.
