Chapter Text
ELEVEN: Fading
The weather got colder again, as if conspiring to keep Thorin constrained within Bag End and frustrated. His chest recovered far slower than he had imagined-but then, he had neglected himself to a degree that would normally end in death and it had only been the determined efforts of Bilbo and Tauriel than had spared him that fate. Even though Bilbo had claimed him as his friend and had admitted to being his husband, the lack of a formal reconciliation had only partly eased the gnawing pain in his chest and the exhaustion that lay on him like a heavy hand. But weak and miserable as he was, he chafed at the idleness and ended up puttering around the smial, getting under Bilbo’s feet and just making things worse.
So he retreated to the spare room he had insisted on moving into when his fever was broken-only because Bilbo would not permit him to move back to the Forge or the Inn-and brooded. Every action in his life was ruthlessly dissected and every foolish, prideful or reckless act was castigated. He had done so much wrong and had never deserved to succeed. His whole life was on litany of failure, starting from the dragon and working on. He covered his face with his hands and tried to push back the memories-but the dam was broken.
Mahal, he had been leading the guards trying to protect the Gates of Erebor that fateful day when Smaug burst in and they had been swatted aside like gnats. He had saved Thror but others of his family had been trapped in the mountain and he had ended up shepherding what remained of his people away from their home, ragged and singed and shocked. And with his grandfather’s faltering sanity and his father’s shock, he had been forced to lead. And there had been mistakes and failures. Dwarves had died from exposure or hunger or disease. Infants died before their time. the elderly and frail succumbed. It had all been on him because there was no one else who had stood forward, especially not the pompous Lords who had stolen off like thieves in the night to relatives in the Iron Hills, leaving the commoners to their fate. They had wandered, hopeless and desperate, always cheated and sneered at until the catastrophe of Azanulbizar had shrunk the remains of his family down to himself, Dis, young Fili and her unborn son. So the ragged remnants of the Longbeards had finally gone to Ered Luin and Thorin had worked himself to the bone, trying to build a life for what was left of his people. But always, he thought of Erebor, of home, of the promise he had silently made as they fled from the gates of the Lonely Mountain: one day he would bring them home.
Yet he had led a small band of neither the best nor brightest who had followed him with courage, honour and a willing heart while the other Lords had scorned him and refused. Even a Hobbit had been more willing than his own cousin and somehow, despite Thorin rather than because of him, they had succeeded. But his mind had become fogged by Dragon Sickness and madness-though it had mostly lifted to allow him to lead them in the Battle. And even after, when he had recovered from his horrific wounds, it was always there, like a nagging buzz at the back of his mind. Bilbo had seemed to ward it off-or maybe he had switched his illness to considering Bilbo as his treasure rather than gold and gemstones. But finally, it had overcome him and it had cost him everything he cared for…
He wrapped his arms across his chest, trying to ignore the burning pain. Brooding and moping made it worse but then, no one had ever accused Thorin of being wise. Reckless, brave, stubborn-those he would own-but sage? Never a word applied to the Line of Durin.
A knock on the door made him start and he looked up as Bilbo poked his head round the door, frowning as he read the King’s face.
“Are you alright?” he asked automatically.
“I am well,” Thorin lied. Bilbo moved into the room and stared at him.
“You look like you’re moping…or at least brooding,” he noted as Thorin sighed. The dwarf forced his face back into the practiced mask that he wore in Erebor.
“There is little more I can do, Bilbo,” he said awkwardly. “I am under your feet, I cannot go to the forge because I cannot breathe in the cold and I am a mere nuisance.” He sighed. “I tried to help around your home but I only anger you. Yet you will not hear of me staying anywhere else.” The Hobbit stared at him and then walked to sit by him on the bed, staring at the larger shape at his side.
“I’m not going to say I understand because I don’t, fully,” Bilbo said, his voice honest. “But I know it must be hard. You are the King and have been since you were far too young. You have always been in control of your fate…” But the dwarf gave a bitter laugh.
“I’ve rarely been in control of my fate,” he said gruffly. “My fate has controlled me. And yet, when the wizard brought us here before the Quest, I told him I would not guarantee your safety, nor be responsible for your fate. Yet you were responsible for our safety and ensured that our fate was not to be a footnote in history as a failed mission to reclaim the mountain.” Bilbo looked away, clearly uncomfortable at the praise.
“But you have been able to contribute and have been involved in decisions about the Kingdom…whereas here, you are a visitor,” Bilbo sighed. “But you have Dwalin, Kili, Ori and Tauriel here for you…” Thorin looked pained.
“My sister-son is in love with the Elf and they are quite nauseating,” he said. “Dwalin is a good friend but he is out working. I feel as useless as the day Smaug took Erebor. I am no help to you.” Bilbo looked at him.
“Can you peel potatoes?” the Hobbit asked him suddenly. Thorin blinked. “I need some peeling. It would be a help. If you don’t mind, that is…”
Thorin stared at him. He was being asked to do work that was the tasks of the menials in the kitchens when he was actually a King…but Bilbo was asking him and it was a relief to be asked for anything by the one he loved. He rose.
“I would be delighted,” he said honestly and waited for Bilbo to lead. The Hobbit rose and gave a small smile.
“Come on then,” he said. “Those chips aren’t going to make themselves.”
But cooking with Bilbo was a stopgap measure because he still had no idea how he could demonstrate that he trusted Bilbo. The fact that he would trust his life to the Hobbit didn’t seem to be enough because his words had shattered what they had, that intimate understanding that had grown between them since he had woken after the Battle. And while he had dreamed since that fateful day when the Dragon came of being King, his heart had pushed all that aside when he had fallen in love because his goals had changed. Being King was his duty but the only thing he wanted was his husband.
When the weather finally improved again, he headed out-though not without the Hobbit fussing. His coat had been cleaned and brushed and Ori had knitted him a ridiculously long scarf that the Hobbit wound round and around his neck before Bilbo would allow him out. The air was crisp and clear on a sparkling late winter morning and when he took a deep breath, the air caused him to cough but the spasm passed swiftly and he was no longer gasping for breath after. So he smiled at the Hobbit and walked down the path from the green door.
Yet he was unable to enjoy the Shire, no matter how gorgeous the morning. The weak sun held no warmth and the brightness was almost dazzling but he strode heavily and steadily as he walked in the direction of the Forge. There were eyes on him, watching him without sympathy and when he looked up, the Hobbits ducked back. And under his breath, he cursed Gardenia Proudfoot for whatever she had lied about this time. His newfound knowledge of the language of plants-incomplete and imperfect as it was-told him that she had been blatant in her proposal and that a Hobbit would certainly be rather scandalised by her behaviour. But as a dwarf, he wouldn’t-couldn’t-have understood. Not that he would ever find someone like Gardenia attractive. And then Bilbo’s words floated back and he frowned as he walked.
Hobbits prefer to talk things through…
A proper Hobbit would have talked to him and made their intent obvious-after checking he was available and interested. A proper Hobbit would not have mounted a vicious campaign against the outsider to isolate and ostracise him-but vanity…well, that he could understand. Not that he had much vanity for his looks, for he was not considered anything other than plan or worse by his own people. No he suffered from vanity of his Line, of his Throne, of his people and would exult in those against any competition. How many times had he sneered at the Elves, knowing that their kind-at least in ages past-had skills the equal of or maybe superior to his own people. Mahal, he carried an Elvish sword forged in Gondolin! (And it was the finest blade he had ever seen or wielded). How he had defended Erebor against criticism even when he knew that Thror’s actions had been reprehensible. And now…he had allowed his pride and vanity in his position and dignity as the King to overcome his duties as a husband.
No wonder it was hopeless.
He stopped and stared ahead, almost unseeing. How could he possibly hope to regain Bilbo’s trust when the Hobbit was pleasant and caring but had made it clear that he had hardened his heart against the dwarf? Hobbits, it seemed, faded far more easily than dwarves and the fracture in their relationship threatened Bilbo’s life as much as it did Thorin-but Bilbo had taken the steps he needed to in order to protect himself. Thorin didn’t even know if that could be reversed because there was no lore on inter-species relationships. Except what his heart told him. And Thorin’s heart told him he had probably thrown away his last chance.
He made his way to the forge and found his cousin there already, the fire lit and the room already reasonably warm. It was almost certainly Bilbo’s work, ensuring that Thorin didn’t have an icy cold forge to go into when he returned to work and he smiled inwardly at the Hobbit’s concern. Dwalin looked up.
“You dragged your lazy carcass out of the house at least, did yer?” the warrior asked, his grin showing he was relieved to see his friend out at last but there was an inflection in his voice that showed he was still worried. Thorin took off his coat and the scarf and hung them up on the nail at the back of the door, starting to roll up his sleeves.
“Couldn’t let you wreck the place while I'm gone," Thorin replied, glancing around. The place was still set up as he preferred it and Dwalin was heating some metal in the fire.
“I dunno,” Dwalin grinned. “Market traders seem to have taken to me. That baker woman makes a tasty cinnamon and raisin biscuit…”
“They’ll soon realise feeding you biscuits is a straight route to bankruptcy,” Thorin retorted.
“You’re a fine one to talk about straight routes,” Dwalin taunted him, pulling the iron out of the fire and tapping it lightly with a hammer. “Did you get lost, twice?”
“Will you ever let that drop?” Thorin asked him dryly. Dwalin chuckled.
“Maybe in a century,” he replied and then his face fell slightly. “The traders have been asking about you as well.” Thorin glanced up.
“What are we making?” he asked.
“Lock,” Dwalin answered. “Simple three bar. They seem to be friendly. Asked me every day how you were doing. Not all these hobbits are prejudiced.”
“Hmm,” Thorin muttered. “But…”
“There's talk in the market as well,” his friend revealed. Thorin started hammering out another piece of metal from the fire, the strokes even and regular. He didn’t want to mention his chest felt tight with the smoke from the fire and the scent of hot metal.
“Yes?”
“There’s a new rumour that you’ve been courting another Hobbit,” Dwalin revealed. “I sent Ori round to chat to the stallholders and listen in. It’s in Hobbiton Market as well.” The King looked up and then shrugged.
“I haven’t,” he said flatly and continued hammering.
“But Bilbo…”
“Knows who and what I am,” Thorin continued, lifting the metal up with a pair of tongs and frowning, before putting it back in the fire. “He will not believe it.”
“Look, you need to tell him that you love him…” Dwalin was staring at him.
“He knows. We’ve talked.”
“Then…” The warrior was starting to look exasperated.
“The problem is not that of love but my foolishness gave him cause to think that I did not trust him,” Thorin reminded his friend. “But I have no idea how to demonstrate such.”
“Start by showing him that you love him,” Dwalin growled. “I even worked out how to do it-but of course, I’m not an emotionally-stunted son-of-a-dragon…” Thorin shook his head.
“I’ve given him flowers,” he said and then Dwalin did walk forward and glare at him.
“Imagine he was a dwarf,” he hissed.
“This wouldn’t be happening if he was a dwarf,” Thorin reminded him.
“It shouldn’t be happening anyway!” Dwalin snapped. “And wouldn’t if you weren’t such a stubborn ass that you didn’t think to ask yer Hobbit about his own side of things. He is your One but you are whatever a Hobbit calls it…”
“Heart-Mate,” Thorin murmured.
“Whatever they call it, the One you love wants to be shown it, not treated to some expert pining and grumpy looks,” Dwalin told him bluntly.
“What can I give Bilbo?” Thorin hissed. “He is home among his kind-who he doesn’t actually like that much. He wants to go back to Erebor. I’ve told him that he can return. But I am not sure that he believes me.”
“And why wouldn’t he?” Dwalin asked him. The King covered his face with his hands.
“I have let him down one time too many,” he sighed. “I fear he will never trust me. Maybe if you took him back so he could see his friends once more, he would be happy.” Dwalin stared at him.
“You talk like you aren’t coming,” he said and Thorin looked up, his eyes haunted.
“The fading has slowed but not stopped,” he said quietly. “The journey is long and at the end…there is still nothing for me. I will not be travelling again.” Dwalin froze and his eyes flooded with concern.
“Thorin…” he said softly. The King quietly fished the now-red metal from the fire once more.
“Without my One, without my heart, I may just arrive home to die,” he said emotionlessly. "Bilbo rejected me and though he has offered me friendship, it is not enough. It is close to two years since…I broke our marriage. Not many last this long after Rejection: I should be grateful.”
“You have to tell him,” Dwalin urged. But the dwarf King shook his head.
“To what end?” he asked. “He still loves me but he does not trust me and without that, he will not consider anything more.”
“Then court him! Show him that you care and love and trust him,” the warrior urged him. But Thorin lifted his chin and locked his fiercest gaze on his friend.
“You cannot tell him,” he said firmly. “I will not make him feel obligated to accept me out of concern for my wellbeing. He wishes to return to Erebor and see his friends. If he wishes to go, you and Ori must accompany him.”
“But…”
“Swear!” The tone was that of the King and after a long look, Dwalin slowly bowed his head.
“As you wish, Your Majesty,” he murmured. Then Thorin bowed his head.
“But I could still use your help in courting him,” he murmured he turned back to the metal.
He was more aware of the accusing eyes on him, the expressions of the Hobbits varying between shocked, disgusted and scornful. There were whispers in the market, some stallholders refusing to serve him and he wanted to yell at them that the accusations were lies-whatever they were. He was a dwarf, a creation of Mahal who was bound to his One and could no more be unfaithful to his husband that he could turn into an Elf. But Hobbits didn’t know that and it was clear they didn’t care. And while he had endured stoically before, there was a part of him that desired to defend his honour. But while he was Rejected, he had none. In the eyes of dwarves, he really was without honour for he had been Rejected by the one perfect gift Mahal had given him. And though he was a King, it meant nothing.
He took to avoiding the market except the couple of Hobbits who had always been open and welcoming. Dwalin and sometimes Kili worked with him in the forge and there were moments when he could recall teaching Fili and Kili basic forging when times were hard and he couldn’t afford the fees for any apprenticeships. Kili was deft and when he concentrated, he was reasonably skilled at fine work. Thorin had completed his Mastery and it eased his heart to teach his nephew tricks and tips he himself had learned from his Master which would stand his nephew in good stead when he needed to forge. He guessed that Kili was humouring him since why would the Prince-and first Heir to the Crown Prince-ever need to know how to deal with poor quality ores as he had learned during their wandering days? But concentrating on teaching distracted him from everything else.
As the days lengthened and the temperatures rose, snowdrops and crocuses poked through the muddy ground and buds enlarged on the branches, almost ready to burst into leaf. Thorin made and remade a number of small gifts, items for the kitchen that would make Bilbo’s life easier that he took to leaving in the kitchen when Bilbo wasn’t looking. He mended everything he could find in the smial and generally did everything he could to contribute. He helped in the kitchen and answered the few Ravens that arrived with questions from Fili, Balin or Dis but he never gave any news of himself because there was none. Bilbo remained amiable but distant and Thorin was beginning to give up hope.
Until a morning when the early blossom was starting to burst out and the yellow flowers of the forsythia bushes were glowing like drops of sun in the hedges. Bilbo burst in and stormed towards Thorin, his face flushed with anger and humiliation.
“I have been harangued in the Market and in the Green Dragon for taking up with an adulterer,” he said furiously. “Did you know there was someone alleging you had been courting them?” Thorin looked up and nodded.
“I was aware of the rumours,” he said gruffly. “Though none were spoken in my hearing.”
“I can assure you that they have been spoken in mine!” Bilbo spat. “I’m being accused of stealing another Hobbit’s betrothed. And no one credits that we are married…they don’t see a ring or braid and the Hobbit in question supposedly has a ring…” Thorin stared at his husband and bowed his head.
“I explained that it had been stolen,” he reminded Bilbo and the Hobbit stared at him, then slowly sat down.
“Dwalin found it stolen,” he amended. “And I know both of you are honest. Whatever this girl is saying, it must be a misunderstanding…” He looked up. “Or something darker.” Thorin gave a small incline of the head.
“I cannot ask you to trust me,” he said, “but…”
“Thorin, I trust you,” Bilbo said. “I trust you to act with honour. I trust you to act like a King. I trust you to be cursed by your pride. I trust you to be a dwarf. But you are honest and faithful and you keep your word.”
The King closed his eyes and rose, turning away.
“I broke my word-and yours-and almost caused a war,” Thorin said bitterly. “Did you forget?” There was an awkward pause and then Bilbo rose to walk to him.
“No,” he said quietly. “I will never forget everything that happened then. But I also know that the dwarf speaking those words was sick. You had Dragon Sickness and were not in your right mind. How could I blame someone who was ill? The dwarf who broke his word wasn’t Thorin II Oakenshield, son of Thrain, King of Erebor. He isn’t the dwarf who faces me now.”
“He is,” Thorin said flatly. “The Sickness twisted what lies within me but I spoke those words. I am to blame.”
Bilbo looked up into his eyes.
“I forgave you,” Bilbo said. “I hold to that. You made right what you had done when your mind returned. You ruled Erebor with honour and honesty. You always acted in the best interests of your people…even to your own detriment.”
“You were the only thing I ever did for myself, the only thing I did that was against the will of my people…well, some of them…” Thorin revealed slowly, his voice reluctant. “But know that I would give everything up for you. If, as it seems, I cannot be both your husband and the King, then Erebor can have a new ruler.”
“But it needs you, Thorin,” Bilbo told him bluntly. “You are the King. You reclaimed it. You ruled Ered Luin. Fili is just young and needs your experience to guide him.”
“He has Dis and he has Balin,” the King told his Hobbit. “Erebor no longer needs me.”
“And the Lords on the Council?” Bilbo asked him.
“I banished most of them after you left,” the dwarf said without shame. “It was all that they deserved.” Bilbo looked unimpressed and planted his hands on his hips.
“I can see why Dwalin wanted to hit you with your Crown,” he admitted as the King bowed his head.
“There really is no hope then, is there?” Thorin said quietly. “I just cannot meet your expectations, Bilbo. I am no longer able to be the husband that you expect or deserve. I cannot rule without you. And I seem incapable of winning your trust. All I do is disappoint you.” Then he turned away and went to his room.
But he could not sleep, the effects of Fading robbing him of the peace of sleep and any rest he could achieve. So he lay, staring at the curved ceiling of his room and allowing his mind to spin where it would. And he found himself taken back to the discussion he had endured with the StoneSeers before he had married his hobbit.
“You defy Mahal’s Will and insult our race,” DeepSeer Haunor growled, looked through the slits in his hood. The StoneSeers traditionally covered their faces, symbolising their loss of identity to the honoured spiritual role among their folk and the DeepSeer was the most senior of their number. The King had stiffened, knowing that there would be opposition but hearing it so bluntly was like a blow to the gut.
“Yet he is my One and thus to not accept this gift is a graver insult to the Maker,” he had replied.
“Arrogance to presume you understand the complexities of…” StoneSeer Agulal cut in.
“Yet he is my One and I will marry him,” the King told him, talking over the developing diatribe. “So you can do your duty and inform me of my duties as Mahal requires or you can allow your prejudices to overcome your duty and fail Mahal and your King.”
There had been a palpable wave of hostility at the words and Thorin had lifted his chin, staring them down.
“As you wish, we will explain the duties and perils of bonding to your One, bearing in mind your chosen partner is not Khuzd and is not blessed by Mahal,” Haunor conceded. “But he is not Khuzd and cannot know our ways. We will not speak with him and there will be no preparation, no purification before the Union. And if you break this prohibition, we will ensure that all know your reign is not supported by Mahal, is not backed by the will of our Maker.”
Thorin had stared anthem, aching to roar at them that they had crossed Arda, facing stone giants and goblins and trolls and orcs and elves and one very live dragon and had reclaimed the mountain. If that was not a sure sign they were blessed by Mahal, then nothing was.
But he held his tongue because he needed this. He needed to hear the words of the Seers because he wanted to do right by Bilbo, to honour him as he should when all he had offered to the other half of his heart on the Quest was doubt, mistrust, danger and betrayal. How his Hobbit could have possibly offered forgiveness and accepted Thorin’s proposal still bewildered the dwarf, for his own people would have never forgiven such a transgression. Deep in his heart, Thorin knew that he did not deserve such forgiveness but he was greedy and desperate so he accepted the undeserved chance.
And Erebor needed it as well. The Kingdom was newly won and Thorin’s hold on the throne precarious. He was supported by Dain and dwarves from the Iron Hills but the rest of the Longbeards from Ered Luin were months away and there would be little he could do if the StoneSeers, who had arrived one morning from the Iron Hills. declared his rule invalid. He suspected Dain would rubbish the decree but how many of the Iron Hills dwarrow would listen? How many would insist that Dain took the throne instead of a King who had been disowned by their Maker? And having won the Kingdom for his own people and his sister-sons, how could he put his own happiness and desire ahead of their needs?
So he bowed his head and accepted the edict. And then he had listened to the words they spoke to every prospective couple-except there was only one there, for his partner was forbidden to hear. And Thorin understood the risk he took, the dangers of betrayal and rejection as well as the benefits of being in love and loved in return. And he knew in his partner, he had a unique bond, for there had never been a pairing of dwarf and hobbit before. But he asked the question anyway, because Thorin knew his life was one litany of failures.
“If he rejects me?” The words were as hesitant as he had ever heard and for a moment, Haunor was silent.
“If you are rejected, King Thorin, you will wither and die. Every benefit of the bond will leave you and instead, you will experience pain in your broken heart, weakness and despair. Slowly, you will fade. Eventually you will not be able to concentrate, nor sleep nor do anything. Your body will break down and you will succumb. Maybe madness will take you first, maybe not. But the condition is irrevocable.”
“There is no stop, no reversal if I could win back his love?” The words were desperate and the silence that greeted his plea telling.
“There is no reversal, my King,” Haunor repeated coldly. “You may manage to patch up your friendship but once a bond is broken by rejection, there is nothing that can be done. Friendship may slow the progression but you will be wracked by doubt and jealousy and fear. Despair will dog you. You will consider ending your life. Maybe that would be kindest. Because if you manage to repair your differences, you will still fade. Your One will watch you fade, watch you slip away, falling into a coma and eventually surrendering your life, no matter what he feels. And he will know that the death you suffer is his fault due to his actions. So even if there seems to be hope, there is none. And maybe, pushing him away and sparing him the grief and guilt would be best. Because if you are rejected, you will die. Within two years, your life will end. And there is nothing that you can do about it.”
And it was then that he finally realised what he had done. His desperate need to be near Bilbo had been a pure act of selfishness. It eased his pain-the pain he had earned by his own actions-but he had slowly wormed his way back into Bilbo’s generous heart. Maybe only as a friend and not as a lover but he had risked Bilbo-he knew that now. What the Hobbit had revealed about his own race's response to rejection was chilling and he thanked Mahal that he had not formally rejected Bilbo: he had never deserved it. But the StoneSeers had been unequivocal: no matter how they patched up their relationship, what was happening to Thorin was irrevocable. And if he and Bilbo grew closer, then it would be far, far worse for his husband when the dwarf died. And he would be responsible for the pain, grief and guilt that Bilbo felt. So, even though it went against everything his heart yearned for, he knew what he had to do. He just hoped that Bilbo-kind, generous, decent Bilbo-would understand.
Somehow, he managed to avoid Bilbo for the next couple of weeks, leaving before even First Breakfast and arriving back after Dinner. He bought food in the markets when he could and Dwalin brought him snacks but he once more needed reminding to eat and he became more and more reclusive. He still left gifts for Bilbo but never waited to see what the Hobbit thought. If he sometimes took the odd bread roll or meat pie, then he always made sure it wasn’t the last. But he tried to keep away from Bilbo-at least from his conscious presence, since all he seemed to do was cause the Hobbit upset and tear away the last shreds of his own hope. Dwalin seemed at a loss what to say to him and even Kili was unsure how to rouse his Uncle from despair. To his eye, Thorin’s hair held more grey and his eyes were sunken and dulled. So the Prince pulled Bilbo aside with Tauriel and sat in the garden, staring at the daffodils that were just opening their white and gold flowers in the early spring sun.
“I’m worried about Uncle,” the Prince said without preamble. “He won’t leave Bag End because you asked him to stay-but he’s like a ghost. He’s given up.”
“Your Uncle never gives up,” Bilbo told him plainly. “He believed you could retake Erebor despite there being a dragon ensconced inside. He believed he could get there with thirteen dwarves only. He believed he could hold the mountain against two armies with just the Company. And he led that insane charge into the fray against thousands of orcs when Dain’s hundreds of men were getting overwhelmed. And he turned the tide with that move…even though it was clearly futile and insane. He would never give up.”
Tauriel pursed her lips and arched an eyebrow. "I have to agree with Kili,” she said slowly. “His behaviour speaks of shame and resignation. He is avoiding you but it is only hastening the fading.” Bilbo stared at her.
“He’s what?” he demanded. “I told him we were friends! He said that would help and…”
The pity in Kili and Tauriel’s eyes had Bilbo’s hackles rising and he stared at them.
“He wouldn’t…” he growled and looked at them. Kili’s face fell.
“You know my Uncle better than most,” he sighed, “and you know that he is an absolute sucker for ridiculous self-sacrificing moves. He is Rejected by his One and Balin told me that only a reversal of that Rejection could alter his fate. And he would not want you to feel you had to accept him back. He wanted you to have a free choice.”
“Instead, would I only find out when he was dead?” Bilbo snapped. “And why didn’t he trust me by telling me?”
“Because he loves you,” Tauriel said sadly. “He would rather you were happy and free to make an honest choice than felt you were being blackmailed by his inevitable deterioration to take him back.”
“You said without trust that you had nothing,” Kili pointed out. “But you still won’t trust him. So he believes you have nothing and there is no hope. He is just going through the motions for the last months of his life.”
“What?” Bilbo’s expression was distraught now.
“Dwarrow rarely last more than a couple of years after being Rejected-and Thorin wasted much of his first year in Erebor and then travelling here. He is already weakened and soon, it will have passed the point of no return.” Kili glanced over at Tauriel. “We were supposed to go back after a few months but I can’t leave him now. We will stay…until the end.” Bilbo blinked and then glanced at Tauriel. Her serene expression was wavering with sorrow in her calm green eyes.
“That idiot!” the Hobbit snapped. "Why didn't he tell me everything? You dwarves and your damned secrecy! It's hints here and the odd word here and not one of you tells me what I need to know and everything there is to know about this Rejection thing! I thought he was supposed to show he trusted me!” Kili rose then, his face uncharacteristically angry.
“Yet you don’t trust him either!” he accused the Hobbit. There was a moment when the angry Hobbit rounded on the Prince but Kili wasn’t backing down. “Trusting someone doesn’t mean you get to know every secret of their heart, you know. My Uncle has spent his life hugging many secrets tight and concealing them in his heart because people couldn’t be allowed to know. Who would follow a King who was mad? Or fight a battle with so little chance of success? Who would follow a Prince who betrayed his King by revealing these things to his people, even though it would be fairer if they knew? He has known when food is short, when times were desperate and his people were on the brink of starvation. And he had to project a good face, always being positive. He has spent his entire life concealing secrets because that has been his lot. You have to acknowledge that he is an old dwarf and after a life fighting to survive, dedicating himself to protecting his people and always suppressing anything he wanted, you have to allow him some agency.”
“No chance of that not happening,” Bilbo grumbled.
“And yet you seem now to be equating trust with knowing everything,” Tauriel pointed out.
“Thorin decided that he did not want you to feel you had to accept him and renew your vows out of a sense of obligation,” Kili continued. “He would rather you had your choice of your fate rather than you married him merely out of duty. Trapping you like that in a union that he knew you did not want would destroy him. He would rather die with dignity, knowing that you had a free choice.”
“But if I don’t know what the risk is, how can I have a free choice?” Bilbo argued. “I have to know that one of my choices will condemn him to death in a couple of months.” He looked up. “If that is the case…” Kili nodded.
“It is likely to be,” he sighed. “I’m sorry, Bilbo. I know he wanted it kept a secret but he trusted you with his heart when you married. He gave you the power to kill him by simply leaving him. My Uncle never does anything by halves and when he committed to you, he committed totally and irrevocably. He trusts you to keep his secrets here-which you have done.”
“But in Erebor…”
“He was ill!” Kili snapped. “He still suffered from Dragon Sickness!” Bilbo stared and sank back into his seat, aghast. “I’m sorry-I didn’t mean to say but I overheard Balin and Amad talking. He’s suffered ever since the Battle-nowhere near as severe as before or disabling but he still hears the whispers of the gold and feels the possessiveness. It was why he overreacted when he heard the accusation. It was wrong and stupid and very Thorin but he couldn’t help himself. And I think now that he feels as possessive of you as he did of the gold-maybe more. And admitting that to anyone was a terrible shame-because you know how his actions haunt him.”
Bilbo glanced towards the pulled curtains in the window of Thorin’s room and recalled the dwarf’s words when he was ill, which Bilbo had listened to carefully but perhaps not understood as deeply as he should. Kili’s words raised the suspicion to much worse levels, confirming that his husband had truly been suffering alone ever since the Battle without feeling able to tell his husband for fear of losing him irrevocably in falling once more into the ailment that had him threatening to kill his beloved Hobbit. And when Thorin had spoken, there was an edge of self-loathing in his voice, along with terrible shame…
“I know,” he murmured. “He told me he had been suffering when he overreacted but to known he had been fighting it ever since the Battle…” And then a few fragmented moments reared in his memory: Thorin staring into the fire, his hand absently stroking the hilt of Orcrist; his refusal to ever enter the Treasury and his reluctance to ever wear gold and the New Crown he had commissioned from mithril and silver. The occasional possessive look in those expressive eyes.
The words at the Council, the reaction the exact mirror of the reaction to the loss of the Arkenstone…
“I should have seen,” he added. “He should have told me, the idiot, but I should have known. I trusted him that he was cured. To know he felt he could not speak to me…” He rose and paced backwards and forwards, careful not to damage the daffodils. He felt ill. The illness that had gripped Thorin and had him threatening to kill the Hobbit had been there all along…yet he had never felt unsafe with his dwarf. He had trusted his husband…now Thorin needed that trust more than ever.
He looked up at the oak tree. A symmetry between the pair that remained unspoken: Bag End existed in the shadow of the oak tree and Thorin’s life had been saved by that oaken branch long before Bilbo’s birth and that act had coloured his identity ever since. But Thorin was strong and steady as the oak, never bowing, no matter what storms battered it…
…until this one, final storm that threatened to break him. A storm Bilbo could avert…if he wanted to. And losing Thorin was unthinkable.
“What can I do?” he asked. Kili and Tauriel shared a look.
“Spend time with him,” the Prince said. Tauriel nodded.
“He is dying of a broken heart,” she confirmed. “You are the owner of his heart. Only you can mend it.” Then she looked up. “But his pride and his shame are the obstacles. If you care for him, you have them to contend with.”
“And my own,” Bilbo murmured with honesty. “But I stole the Arkenstone to save his life. And yours, of course. But Balin said that giving him the Arkenstone would make him worse, maybe lose him forever. So I risked my life to get it away.” He sighed. “He forgave me for taking what he valued most because he understood my reasons. He should have understood I would not betray him like that. But maybe…I should forgive him as well.” He sighed again. “You think I would not risk everything for him?”
“But your trust issues?” Kili asked. Bilbo pressed his lips together and looked serious. Then he looked sternly at the couple, noting their hands twined together. If such ancient rivals as a dwarf and an elf could fall in love, there was still hope. Though how he could communicate that to Thorin in such a way that the prideful King would accept the reassurance was another matter…
“I think it’s time I took some steps to reassure myself and then I need to work out how to learn to trust this infuriating, stubborn, stupid, self-sacrificing idiot of a dwarf,” he murmured.
