Actions

Work Header

The Price The Gods Decree

Chapter 12: To Fight For Him

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

TWELVE: To fight for him

 

It was hard because Bilbo started waking earlier-he was never an early bird to start with-to ensure he was up when Thorin quietly made his way from his room and towards the door. But the King started to meet a tired-looking Hobbit, wrapped in his familiar dressing gown, with a brown paper-wrapped package of food for breakfast that he carefully pressed into the dwarf’s hands. The first morning, Thorin had averted his eyes and gravely thanked Bilbo. The Hobbit had quietly wished him a good day and watched him go. And he had understood what Kili had meant about the King’s appearance. Thorin was looking tired and weighed down and the streaks in his raven hair were wider. He looked older and tired and the whispers of disquiet grew louder in his heart. It solidified his resolve to stand forward and do what he should have done before.

 

So dressed in his finest and looking every inch the proper Hobbit, Bilbo set out into the fine spring morning, walking down the Hill after a hasty First Breakfast towards Tuckborough. It was quite a walk but one that needed to be done so he arrived at the Great Smials in good time. His cousin Fortinbras saw him immediately and what he heard had the Thain frowning deeply.

 

The Thain dispatched his cousins to start making enquiries because they weren’t Bagginses, they were Tooks and were working for the Thain. Bilbo was promised that he would be kept up to date but as he watched the older Hobbit walk out of the door (with a packed snack for the walk home) Fortinbras was worried. What he had heard and was hearing was starting to sound very un-Hobbitish and concerning. A proper Hobbit didn’t behave like that!

 

But Adalgrim, Flambard, Sigismund and his own son Ferumbras reported back and all of them were disappointed and reasonably angry at the tales they had heard.

 

“There’s a rumour that has been going round that the dwarf has been abusing young hobbit women,” Adalgrim reported, sitting opposite his cousin and munching on a slice of very acceptable lemon drizzle cake. Fortinbras frowned and rested his teacup down on the applewood table. 

 

“What?” he said in a distressed voice. “How many?”

 

“Uncertain,” Adalgrim said, his voice thoughtful. “It’s all rumours, light on details but heavy on innuendo. Everyone is certain that it is true.”

 

“Why?” Fortinbras asked shortly.

 

“Because it’s several people making the accusation,” Sigismund told him, refilling his teacup. “Always more powerful than one.”

 

“But no one is, are they?” Fortinbras pointed out simply. “No names, no specific instances. Just rumours. And rumours are a bad way to run a country.”

 

“Always worked in the Shire so far,” Flambard reminded them.

 

“Not for anything important,” the Thain said gravely. “Gossip is the currency of normal social interaction but most of our fellow Hobbits can discern the difference between scurrilous rumour and factual reporting of events. The gossipmongers will stir things up but we who wield the power always seek corroboration before acting on anything that we hear. Because what they are alleging does require action.”

 

“You’re right,” Ferumbras said, looking at his older cousins. “If you drill down, ‘everyone knows’ something but no one actually does. No one can give a name or a time or an instance. It’s generalised character-damaging.”

 

“Most of the Hobbitwives and the market merchants-even those in Bywater-want the dwarf locked up,” Sigismund added. “Things could get ugly.”

 

“They already are,” Flambard added. “There’s the news that he gave a ring to a younger Hobbit as well. That’s been going since a couple of weeks after Yule.”

 

“When he was seriously ill, having been turned away from the Green Dragon and left to freeze in his forge,” the Thain said grimly. “I’ve met him-and seen how prejudiced our people are against him. And I cannot see he has done anything wrong…except perhaps bruise the feelings of one Gardenia Proudfoot.” He frowned. “Find the person who alleges the dwarf gave her a ring. And bring her to me. I want to speak to her myself-without any other Hobbits interfering.”

 

It took another three days before the stern shape of Flambard escorted a pretty youngish Hobbit lass into the parlour at Tuckborough. Her light brown hair was winsomely styled into a knot at the back of her head with curls framing her pleasantly round face, her green eyes sparkling and her ruby lips offering a shy smile. She was dressed in a pretty flowery dress with a blue shawl and blue ribbons in her hair. She bobbed a tiny curtsy.

 

“Mimosa Grainfellow, at your service, your Thainship,” she said, her voice light and laughing. “I am honoured to talk to you.” Fortinbras gestured for her to take a seat and poured her a cup of tea. She accepted it prettily and sipped it gently, licking her lips as she looked up with big, innocent eyes. The Thain sat back.

 

“Why are you claiming that the dwarf, Lulkhel, gave you a ring?” he asked. Her eyes widened in hurt.

 

“Because he did,” she said and gave a little giggle, covering her mouth with her hand. She was wearing little lace gloves, crisp and white and elegant. The Thain blinked and focussed on her.

 

“When? How?” he asked. She gave a little giggle. 

 

“Well, you know what they say about dwarves…” she began.

 

“No,” the Thain said flatly. “I don’t listen to rumours and lies. So answer the question, Mimosa.” She pouted, her eyes flashing with a swift and brief blaze of annoyance that she quickly hid. Then the simpering mask was back up-and Fortinbras was certain now it was a mask. 

 

“Well, it was in the lead up to Yule,” she said. “He began to court me. Ohh, he was very passionate. Kissing my hand, murmuring sweet nothings in that lovely deep voice of his, promising to marry me and sweep me away to one of those dwarvish settlements…” The Thain tilted his head and watched her. He was certain now that she was lying and that everything was an act. The real question was…why?

 

“Did your parents know?” he asked. She looked up, her eyes wide and innocent.

 

“You know how protective Hobbit parents get,” she reminded him. “They wouldn’t hear of me stepping out with a dwarf. So we’re going to elope-but he gave me this ring as a promise.”

 

“Just a ring?” Fortinbras asked, his voice deepening.

 

“Of course-what else would he give me? A cake?” she laughed lightly.

 

“And what else did he do?” the Thain asked. 

 

“He promised me gold and gemstones-not that I care for that sort of thing,” she giggled. “He said he wants to spend the rest of his life with me and have lots of faunts.” The Thain nodded gravely.

 

“So who else knows about this, Mimosa?” he asked her sympathetically. "I take it your mother doesn’t know-and your sister, Monbretia, wouldn’t approve. Maybe…a cousin?” She fluttered her eyelashes and flapped her hands.

 

“They would be so judgemental, when dear Lucky and I are so happy,” she simpered. Fortinbras was caught between the desire to shout at her for her lies and slap her for being so obvious. Instead, he hooked his thumbs under his braces and thought for a moment, allowing her to stew. As expected, she filled the silence. “I told my cousin and she may have told some other people.”

 

“Most of the Shire,” the Thain noted. “And did you not speak to Lulkhel to ask if he wanted his name dragged through the gossipmongers…?”

 

“Well, if he wants to live among Hobbits, what does he expect?” she retorted slightly tartly. 

 

Aha-the mask slips, the Thain thought. “May I see the ring?” he asked and she giggled, then fished it out of her pocket, handing it over.

 

“It’s beautiful,” she said happily. “Look he’s even carved our initials, L and M, inside…”

 

Fortinbras looked up.

 

“Is this it?” he asked aloud as a shape appeared from behind the door. Bilbo had been wearing the Ring just to make sure but he had it slipped in his pocket as he walked forward and accepted the little gold band, carved with dwarvish runes inside and out. He nodded.

 

“The runes read ‘A dwarf that takes a husband must guard him as his greatest treasure’,” Bilbo said. “That symbol is an intertwined rune reading B and T-Lulkhel’s true name and mine. This is the ring that was stolen from the forge while Lulkhel was fighting for his life against pneumonia. The writing inside reads ‘Amrâlimê’.” Mimosa glared at him.

 

“That’s utter fantasy,” she said irritably. “How can anyone know what that means and even if he is telling the truth?” 

 

The door opened and Kili walked in-but he looked totally unlike his normal appearance. He was cleaned up and dressed in fine and clean clothes, his hair actually neat and his Promise Braid obvious. He looked at the Thain and offered a small bow. 

 

“May I present Prince Kili, one of the Heirs to the Throne of Erebor,” Bilbo said. “You know of Erebor, don’t you?” Mimosa pouted and shook her head.

 

“I don’t care for foreign lands,” she spat.

 

“And yet your ‘Lucky’ comes from Erebor,” Bilbo told her shortly and handed the ring to Kili. The Prince accepted it reverently. “Highness, could you please read the runes on this.” Kili looked up.

 

“Are you sure, Bilbo?” he asked. “These were carved by Uncle for you and you alone. He…”

 

“Please,” Bilbo said, an edge of impatience entering his voice. Sighing, he peered at the Ring though he had the keenest sight of all the dwarves of Erebor.

 

“This is beautiful work,” he murmured. “Superb precision on the runes. ‘A dwarf that takes a husband must guard him as his greatest treasure’. That’s terribly romantic. The rune is an entwined B and T-your joint rune. I know Uncle has it tattooed over his heart.” 

 

“I saw,” Bilbo grumbled. Kili peered inside then smiled.

 

“Amrâlimê. My love,” he read and handed the ring back to Bilbo. “Uncle will be relieved that you have found it.”

 

“What’s this ‘Uncle’ nonsense?” Mimosa spat as Bilbo closed his hand around the ring. 

 

“Maybe you don’t know your ‘Lucky’ as much as you think,” Fortinbras told her in an impatient voice.

 

“Notwithstanding that Lulkhel means ‘idiot of idiots’,” Kili added, staring at the Hobbitess flatly.

 

“It’s the name my husband took when he left home to come after me to try to make amends,” Bilbo added.

 

“Well, he won’t be because he’s engaged to me now!” Mimosa spat. Kili stared at her and then walked across the room then back. He loomed over her and gave a Thorin-worthy glare.

 

“I am not sure why you imagine this lie will gain you anything but you should know that Bilbo Baggins and the dwarf you malign and dishonour both have defenders who will protect their reputations against callow lies and pathetic imaginings,” he said in a very unfamiliar, hard tone. Mimosa squeaked. “Who asked you to carry on this lie, Mistress Mimosa? If you tell the truth now, you will not face any severe consequences.” 

 

Looking up at him, she laughed in his face.

 

“You think you can do anything to me, your Highness?” she taunted him. “There are no Kings-or Princes-in the Shire.”

 

“Actually, there are currently both here,” Bilbo muttered.

 

“In fact, the Shire is bound by a number of Treaties and Contracts with other peoples and kingdoms,” Fortinbras told the young Hobbit, seeing the defiance in her eyes falter as he spoke. “And we have close ties with Erebor-isn’t that true, your Highness?”

 

“Yes,” said Bilbo as Mimosa gaped. “And my dear, you don’t know your ‘Lucky’ at all. Because his name isn’t Lulkhel-it is Thorin, son of Thrain, son of Thror, King of Erebor and my husband.” He listen to her gasp with a small sense of triumph before continuing. “That makes me the Prince Consort Under The Mountain. Kili is Thorin’s nephew-and my nephew by marriage and by heart.” The Prince gave a broad grin.

 

“Irak’Adad,” he murmured and bowed his head, a hand pressed over his heart.

 

“Namad’Inùdoy,” Bilbo replied. Then he smiled at Mimosa with utterly cold eyes. “Now who told you to lie about and dishonour my husband?” he demanded.

 

“He isn’t…” she began feebly.

 

“Thorin is a dwarf-and I am his One,” Bilbo told her angrily. “That is a Heart-Mate. He can no more betray me with you than breathe solid stone. He avoids gold and gems because he once suffered from Dragon Sickness. He is not attracted to females and he knows enough of Hobbits that the way to our hearts is through food and plants. He would never offer you gold and gems. He would never offer you anything. Your tale is a lie from first to last. So unless you tell me right now who put you up to his, I will ask Kili to have you extradited to Erebor and then you can see some real dwarves, as opposed to the imaginary one you have been supposedly courting!” 

 

“And I will permit it,” Fortinbras told her. She paled finally and her hands trembled. 

 

“Cousin Gardenia,” she said quietly. “I don’t want to leave the Shire. Please don’t make me go anywhere else and have to deal with any nasty foreign creatures!” She took a quick breath and licked her lips. “She asked me to tell the story and gave me the ring-a couple of weeks after Yule, once the storms had settled. So I have been. I mean, he’s only a dwarf and…”

 

“And what?” Bilbo asked her furiously. “He has feelings like anyone. You are lying about him, painting him to be a sort of faithless lover, when nothing could be further from the truth. He has left his home and his people to be with me because he loves me. And seeing your lies hurt him and turn people against him is cruel.” He lifted his chin. “So your lies will be exposed. You can be called Mad and Deranged and a Liar. You can have people look at you as if you have a disease. You can have people cross the road to avoid you and refuse to speak to you or serve you or even look at you in the Market. And you will deserve every moment for the pain you have caused my husband.”

 

She burst into tears, sobbing loudly and piteously. But not one of those there moved to comfort her. Finally, Flambard, who had remained quietly in the corner, came over and escorted her out, having seen her shrink from the overconfident coquette to a miserable and scared young woman, fearing the consequences of her actions.

 

“You can’t ruin her life,” Fortinbras told his cousin and then frowned at Bilbo’s flat glare. “But I will publicise the fact that she is a liar and a fantasist. That she made it up and stole the ring. That Lulkhel is already attached and devoted to his spouse.” 

 

“And an apology?” Bilbo asked. The Thain sighed.

 

“She isn’t sorry,” he sighed. “She’s only sorry for herself that she’s been caught and has to face the consequences. Because she knew that eventually, the dwarf would be driven from the Shire and the rumours would die down. And she could just go on as usual, having ruined another being’s life.”

 

“And the rumours won’t die down any time soon-because Hobbits believe there is no smoke without fire somewhere,” Bilbo sighed.

 

“And you used Uncle’s name,” Kili muttered. 

 

“Gardenia is getting beyond vindictive,” Bilbo continued, turning to his cousin. “And she’s dangerous. If this was a dwarf settlement, someone would come after her. You can’t allow her to do this to others.” The Thain suddenly looked tired and all of his sixty-eight years.

 

“I know,” he murmured. “I’ll speak to the Heads of Families and the Mayor of Michel Delving,” he added wearily. “We will stop her. I think Odo Proudfoot will not be happy that she’s dragging the family name down.”

 

“You have the vote of the Head of the Baggins Family,” Bilbo murmured, still idly moving the wedding ring in his palm.

 

“And the Tooks,” the Thain added. He offered Bilbo his hand. “I’m sorry, Bilbo. It never should have got this far.”

 

“I know-but that goes for most of this,” the former burglar said softly. “I knew I could trust him. I knew he would never betray me.” Then he looked at Kili. “I just need to know that he trusts me as well.”

 

“He trusts you with his life, his secrets, his heart,” Kili murmured. 

 

“I know,” Bilbo murmured. “But I don’t know why but that hasn’t been enough.” He sighed. “Somehow, I will have to find enough…and what I am missing…because I do love him and I will not lose him. Not again.”

 

-o0o-

 

Spring warmed and Bilbo split his time between his dwarves and his garden. Thorin remained elusive though he smiled at Bilbo in the mornings and accepted his food parcels with a grave nod of the head. He said nothing except polite thanks but he brought home flowers that once again spoke of sorrow and love and longing. The gifts continued, small items that were useful or pretty or just thoughtful. But Thorin had built a wall that Bilbo despaired of ever breaching, stepping back from the husband he clearly thought he no longer deserved. And Kili’s revelations had caused Bilbo to stop and consider Thorin’s actions.

 

So he sat in his garden, tired but satisfied with grubby hands and knees from where he had been weeding and looked over his beds of vegetables, the shoots poking bravely through the soil. The early greens and radishes were already up and his carrots were looking strong. His garden was looking much better than it had the previous year, a spell of love and care all that was needed to bring he neglected space back to health and beauty. He smiled and glanced over at the early perennials, little white and pink flowers dotting the bed. It had been his mother’s bed, the plants exotics that she had collected on her travels-but then, she had been very adventurous for a Hobbit. Almost every other Hobbit had scorned her, for they hated anything that was not traditionally of the Shire. Hobbits were solid and steady and predictable: it was all but unheard for a Hobbit to try anything new and it always caused a scandal. Gossip was unforgiving and never forgot. Such a faux pas could follow a Hobbit for years…

 

Which made the actions of a respectable Hobbit like Gardenia Proudfoot even more incomprehensible. And the reaction of his neighbours. For why would they tolerate her apparent courting of a wandering dwarf and his supposed rejection without a peep also confused him. There was something going on that he was missing-and Fortinbras as well. The Thain was as perplexed as Bilbo at the aberrant reactions of his fellow Hobbits but he still had his son and cousins digging into her business. Tooks didn’t like mysteries-especially when it caused the Hobbits to not behave like Hobbits.

 

Bilbo frowned. Belladonna would have had plenty to say about the way her neighbours and kin were treating the isolated dwarf and her son. Though she would have been proud at how adventurous her son had become-even with the unusual choice of partner and how turbulent and fractured his marriage had become. 

 

“A marriage is like a garden, Bilbo,” she had said as she had weeded and trimmed her beloved bed. Even fading, she had still tended the bed, almost the only thing that brought smiles to her pallid features. “It always needs work. A little weeding here, some dead-heading there. Don’t allow problems to fester. Shed light on dark areas. Refresh old or worn-out areas. Sometimes try something new. If you neglect it, the roots will die from lack of water and the soil will become depleted so the plants will grow weaker and eventually they will fade. Neglecting even the smallest things can eventually allow the whole thing to deteriorate and one morning, you will awaken to chaos and find it is ruined.”

 

“Plants or marriages?” he had asked naively. Belladonna had smiled then, one of the last that he could recall her offering.

 

“Both, my dear Bilbo,” she had said.

 

But somehow, his marriage had broken. And of course, Thorin had been at fault-because of the way he had confronted Bilbo and demonstrated that he did not trust his husband. That was Thorin all over, racing into things without thinking, without diplomacy-because to Thorin, that was just a collection of meaningless syllables-and without understanding the damage he would cause. But Thorin, the rock-headed idiot that he was, had been fighting Dragon Sickness and his mind was not thinking clearly. Not that he had told his husband, of course, because openness and sharing were also words Thorin wasn’t very good at…

 

…except much of the time, he was. He was kind and generous, affectionate and protective and would do whatever he could to ensure that his husband was happy. And maybe he didn’t do much about the rumours that had plagued Bilbo-but had Bilbo shared them with Thorin either? Bilbo’s own pride had driven him to believe that he could cope, that he could rise above the persistent whispers and looks, despite the hurt and anger and bitterness they had definitely caused. And maybe his husband had known from Nori and maybe not…but Bilbo should’ve shared his concerns and his anger as well. And Thorin always allowed Bilbo to pursue his interests, even spending some lonely evenings alone, or helping Bilbo build that huge rockery that resembled a small Erebor in his garden but which Bilbo hadn’t the heart to remove because his husband had personally moved every stone and rock to Bilbo’s command…

 

…but Thorin’s accusations had hit a nerve in the worst possible way when he had hauled Bilbo up in the Council. He had faced slights and accusations every day since he had arrived in Erebor-especially since the rest of the dwarves of Erebor had returned to the mountain. And Thorin’s intemperate demands had hit that nerve and roused the stubbornness of a score of generations of Tooks. So when Thorin had banished him, rather than getting Dis or Balin to talk him down, Bilbo had exploded and ended their marriage. And he had stormed off and been clinging to his anger ever since.

 

Thorin had come to the Shire when he had realised the extent of his stupidity-and there had been proof of what Bilbo had actually been doing. But he hadn’t written or asked for forgiveness. No, in true Thorin ultra-dramatic style, he had abandoned his kingdom and travelled to the Shire alone and incognito, using a name that was an insult. But he hadn’t come to Bilbo-no, he had hung back, suffering but knowing he would be met with bitter anger and rejection because Bilbo was still angry and hurt…as he had every right to be. Any apology would be rejected and slapped down because Bilbo wasn’t ready to hear it. But Bilbo was also stubborn and he had consciously avoided his estranged husband and left him alone among strangers. And Thorin had tried, learning to speak with flowers and trying to tell Bilbo what he felt, what his upbringing and temperament would not allow him to easily say. And Bilbo had slapped him down, again and again.

 

Until he had almost lost him. Seeing Thorin so vulnerable and sick had raised all sorts of terrible memories of the aftermath of the Battle, when Thorin, Fili and Kili had all hovered far too close to death for far too long. And this time, Thorin hadn’t been fighting to stay because he believed that he had lost Bilbo for ever. Even Elvish magic hadn’t cured him, merely slowing the deterioration down and Bilbo had become aware that there was a risk he could lose his husband anyway. And Thorin had believed, after their last stupid pointless spat that even Bilbo didn’t understand, that his last chance was gone and he was simply marking time to the end.

 

“But I don’t want to lose him,” Bilbo murmured. “He’s exasperating and hotheaded and ridiculous and overdramatic but he’s honourable and kind and generous and loving and brave and stupid but he’s my idiot.”

 

He loved Thorin. That had never been in doubt. But did having Thorin prove his trust count more than having him alive? And Thorin trusted Bilbo with his identity, his heart, his Kingdom when the King was away…

 

…and he had been ill. Was ill? Was he still ill?

 

He had seemingly given up but he still left Bilbo gifts and flowers that spoke more eloquently than Thorin himself had ever managed of his heart. And each bouquet was filled with apologies. But until now, Bilbo had just looked at the apologies and had not truly acknowledged them. Yet he had allowed Thorin to be maligned, ostracised and excluded. And now there were much more serious and unfounded allegations against him that may drive him away-and in his current state, that could prove fatal. Bilbo had finally acted and had felt a warmth in his chest at defending his husband. It seemed that dwarves were not the only protective ones…

 

“It always needs work. Don’t allow problems to fester. Shed light on dark areas…”

 

“We need a proper talk,” he decided and rose, heading into the smial to clean up. "It's time I acknowledged what my heart knows. I love him. My heart is his and only his-and he needs to understand that. No running this time-we have to work this out.”

 

It was time he found his dwarf and had a proper talk to him.

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Irak'Adad - Uncle
Namad'inùdoy- sister-son
Amrâlimê - my love