Chapter Text
Thorin cannot wrap his mind around the Halfling. Never in all his years has he encountered a creature so confusing, so nonsensical, so utterly and entirely strange. Master Baggins is only a little thing, with large eyes, a narrow frame, and no shortage of roundness about his middle. He’s not bad to look at, Thorin supposes, if one has time to linger on such matters, which Thorin does not. He keeps his eyes resolutely forward, making a conscious effort at all times to stop them from wandering over to the Hobbit as the company trudges onward.
That has proven to be quite the feat over the course of their week on the road together. More than once, Thorin has caught Master Baggins with a book balanced between the ears of his pony. Does he fear nothing? There may not be many orcs in these parts, but there are plenty of other hazards deserving of one’s attention. The Hobbit always seems to know when it’s going to rain several hours in advance; twice now, he has removed his hood from his pack on a clear morning and been the only one spared the indignity of rifling through his belongings when the sky opened up. And that pack! Oh, by the Maker, that’s the worst thing of all.
Master Baggins has no weapons whatsoever in his possession, not even a knife, despite his claims about knowing his way around a sword. He does, however, carry some fifty monogrammed handkerchiefs, which he seems to have no qualms about distributing amongst the members of the company at the slightest provocation. He has no shoes to speak of, but during the first few days of their journey, Thorin watched the Halfling withdraw a glass butter dish, complete with a generous block of yellow butter, from the depths of that odd pack. Naturally, the butter was gone before they left the Shire, considering the force with which Master Baggins applied it to the crusty bread he’d also brought with him.Once, he cajoled Thorin into eating some sort of sweet bun with the excuse that Master Baggins and Bombur had already made “fine work” of the other seven rolls between them. Who in their right mind would bring eight sweet rolls on a quest?
It is evening now, and the party has made camp under the cover of a sturdy rock formation. Thorin has permitted a modest fire for cooking, though he does not like the idea of sending a smoke signal to any potential assailants. Now that they’ve had dinner, Master Baggins has produced a large bag of sweets and is in the process of showing the company how to roast the confections over an open flame.
Bofur, true to form, bypasses the careful cooking procedure demonstrated by the Halfling and sticks about six of the treats into the fire at once.“Quick, blow it out!” Master Baggins orders, laughing and clapping his hands, delighted by the performance on show as Bofur waves around the flaming stick. The Hobbit's luminous joy floats across the camp and slugs Thorin in the stomach. How can this little creature find pleasure in these unfamiliar wilds, teeming as they likely are with trolls and wolves and bandit-men?
Bofur does as instructed, then inhales the charred mess he has created. Such nonsense has no place on an errand like theirs, and all of Thorin’s companions should know as much by now. They are wasting time, and moreover,Master Baggins is wasting vital baggage space on a single evening’s entertainment. Why would he do this? “Not bad,” is Bofur’s verdict.
“I told you,” Master Baggins replies, his fond gaze shining on Bofur like the glowing sun, despite their short acquaintance. But Mahal made his children to live always underground, deep within mountains that shelter them from such brilliant light. It is not needed, and Thorin is not pleased that he’s responsible for the wellbeing of this ridiculous, easily-trusting, impractical little creature. “It’s even better if you do it properly.”
Kíli devours one of the confections and grins the way he did when he was small and Thorin showed him how to make nails in the forge. “What did you say these were called again, Mister Boggins?”
“Marshmallows,” the Hobbit replies. “They’re tricky enough to make, but worth it, don’t you think?”
Thorin watches as the Halfling catches sight of Fíli, who has been lingering behind the group, watching the proceedings unfold with palpable interest. There is not space for everyone around the fire, and Fíli has learned from Thorin’s example of self-deprivation. The lad would never rob one of their people of any joy for his own sake. He always serves others before himself, as well, though back in Erebor, such behavior from the Crown Prince would have been nothing short of scandalous. Still,selflessness is a good quality for a king to have, and Thorin is silently proud of his nephew.
“Here, Fíli, you should take this.” The Hobbit holds out the stick he’s using to roast the marshmallows. “I’m getting too old to spend so long in this position. Need to stretch my legs.”
It’s nothing more than a flimsy excuse. The Hobbit isn’t old at all. In fact, he’s probably decades younger than Fíli and Kíli, obvious maturity differences aside. Clearly, Fíli knows this. “Do Hobbits really age so quickly, Master Baggins? You can’t be over a hundred.”
“Oh,” Master Baggins begins, “Well, I suppose I’m only fifty, but don’t you know, lad, I feel old, just looking at you two young things hopping around.” Another excuse, surely. The Halfling is going to great lengths to look after Thorin’s sister-sons.
This is not right. They are Thorin’s responsibility, after all, and he does not appreciate the implicit insinuation that he is doing a poor job at it. The lads are fully grown and should not need to be entertained while undertaking a quest to claim their birthright. If he’d thought they needed to be plied with sweets and games around the fire, Thorin would have left them both at home. But Master Baggins has no shame about his blatant attempts to buy the affection of the princes. This is not the first time that Thorin has caught the Hobbit hovering around his sister-sons, checking on them or eliciting laughter with some inane comment or other. Thorin makes a mental note to think more of his own heirs.
“Hopping?” Kíli asks, apparently delighted by this odd verbiage.
“The sheer sight of your roughhousing makes my knees ache,” Master Baggins claims.
“You’re younger than I am,” Fíli declares. “But if you’re sick of roasting marshmallows, I’d be happy to take on the burden. Least I can do for such a venerable and respectable Hobbit.”
“Yes, well, that’d be much appreciated,” the Halfling says. “Come out of the shadows and have a go at it.”
Putting on an exaggerated expression of courtly duty which makes even Thorin chuckle, Fíli accepts the stick and settles onto the rock which Master Baggins has lately vacated. “If you’re really just sick of my brother, you could’ve said something.”
This earns him a well-deserved elbow to the gut. “Please,” says Kíli, “Mister Boggins loves me, and he loves spending time with me. I’ll have you know that I’m his favorite. Isn’t that right?”
“I’m just going to take a couple of these,” Master Baggins ignores the good-natured scuffle he has caused and uses some sort of biscuit (yet another useless item taking up vital space in the Halfling’s over-stuffed pack) to remove the marshmallows from the stick.
Before Thorin can pretend that he’s been doing anything other than keeping an eye on the Hobbit, Master Baggins makes his way across the camp, brandishing the roasted marshmallows in one hand and extending his other arm for balance. Thorin wills a bucket of cold water to fall over the fond forge burning in his chest. It would be much easier if he held no attachments to any members of his company, but he feels it is especially problematic to get close to the one he’s sending into the dragon’s lair. It’s best to keep his distance from the Halfling.
“Here.” Master Baggins places his burden in Thorin’s hands. “Eat up.”
Thorin only glares at him, which earns him a dramatic huff and an exasperated look from the Hobbit. Master Baggins has fine eyes, and Thorin finds that, despite himself, he enjoys teasing this strange creature, though it seems that the Hobbit prefers the company of Thorin’s sister-sons. But perhaps that is for the best.
Thorin has no right to these feelings, and he needs to do something about them before they cause him trouble. No amount of comeliness will protect the Hobbit from the sort of violent death that somebody so soft and foolish can expect out here on the road.
“I’ve had about fifty already; I’ll be sick if I eat these,” the Hobbit prattles on in response to Thorin’s silence. “And you haven’t had one yet.”
“You should not have wasted space in your pack on sweets.”
Master Baggins shrugs, establishing himself on the ground beside Thorin. “We’ll get more provisions when we stop in Rivendell, I’m sure. May as well enjoy ourselves until then. And there’s no knowing how long our packs will be with us, but I can’t imagine we’ll be lugging them all the way to the Lonely Mountain. Plenty of stops to make, even if everything goes according to plan.”
“We will not stop in Rivendell.” Thorin spits the name of the Elven city out like a curse. “Despite what the Wizard has told you. I won’t jeopardize this quest by putting any part of it in the hands of an Elf.”
“Of course not.” Master Baggins gives him a knowing smile, which perplexes Thorin to no end. What does this Burglar think that he knows? Something silly, no doubt. Thorin should not bother paying heed to the opinions of a creature who cannot even be trusted to pack prudently for a journey, no matter how fine he is of face. “Those are getting cold. They’re really better when they’ve just come out of the fire. Do you not like marshmallows?”
“I don’t know.” Why is Thorin even engaging with this? Perhaps he’s simply tired. He hasn’t had a proper night’s sleep in weeks, and that is a conservative estimate. “I’ve never had one.”
“Oh, you have to try them,” Master Baggins urges, “You may as well, since I’ve already wasted the pack space.” He looks very pleased with himself for this ridiculous logic.
To shut him up (and not because Thorin is at all curious about the confection that’s been placed in front of him. Certainly not because he has any interest in wasting his time this way) Thorin takes a bite. And… oh, Mahal below. That is good. He’s not going to say anything about it, of course. It would not be wise to encourage such behavior from the Burglar. If Thorin had his way, the marshmallows and the butter dish and the book would be left behind at the campsite and never seen again. Ridiculous wastes of space.
“Good, isn’t it?” Master Baggins sounds very smug, which Thorin does not appreciate.
It is a delicate business, eating the marshmallows without getting the gooey mess stuck in one’s beard. The faces of his sister-sons are evidence enough of that. “You would have been better served by packing a weapon,” he says, after finishing the morsel as neatly as possible.
The Hobbit has the audacity to wave him off. “I’ll find one eventually.” He gives Thorin a long look, which makes the king uncomfortable. He does not like the feeling of being sized up, especially not when it comes from the most confusing creature that he has ever laid eyes upon. “Well. I’ll leave you to your brooding, then.” And he bounces off, back towards the fire and the remainder of the company.
He is greeted with wide grins and excited chatter. Already, he’s endeared himself to the company with his foolishness. They do not seem to find it even remotely troubling that Master Baggins has no idea how to survive out in the wild. It’s strange. The Halfling clearly knows the basic skills that come with travel: he can build a fire with no trouble, he lays out his bedroll with expert precision, and he takes only a few moments to dig a latrine, which is better than can be said of the younger members of the company. And, yet, as far as the Wizard knows, Master Baggins has barely left his home in the past half-century. Where would he have learned such skills, and why could he not have also garnered a little bit of sense somehow in the process?
After only a moment or so, Balin comes to take the Hobbit’s place. Thorin is comforted by the presence of his old advisor. He allows himself to breathe a sigh of relief, though he has no idea what he’s so relieved about. “Do you remember,” Balin begins, “That stall in the market that sold those meringues?”
“Yes.” Thorin does remember. He and Frerin used to sneak away from their lessons to visit that stall, before the dragon came to Erebor. Dís was too little to liberate from the care of her minders at that time, but they often brought her something as well, if they could muster the funds and if they could remember. Balin usually caught them before they actually made it to the stall, although he tended to look the other way until the princes had their hands and pockets full of sweets. “But this is nothing like that.”
The flavor is different, and the meringues were served cold, not hot. Not to mention the fact that Thorin was a child then, a spoiled prince with all the time in the world to waste on the procurement and devouring of sweets. He glances reflexively toward his sister-sons, who have, naturally, discovered the value of flaming marshmallows as projectile weapons. Thorin watches as his lads take to bedeviling Bombur who, after one shocked intake of breath, opens his mouth to catch the confections being flung at him.
“No,” Balin exhales a heavy fog of smoke, his trusty pipe held loosely in his hand. He, too, has his eye on the chaos at the fireside. “I don’t suppose it would be.”
Bilbo seriously considers steering the company away from the trolls. It’ll be a terrible hassle to deal with them again, and now that he knows what’s coming, Bilbo isn’t particularly looking forward to the encounter. He also isn’t entirely certain that everything will pan out exactly the same way. What if Bilbo forgets some vital detail, does something a little bit differently, and sends the entire ordeal careening out into disaster? What if somebody has a different opinion of him this time around and decides not to help him, or to help him too early on in the proceedings, and the trolls are spurred by these changed actions into changed reactions? What if Thorin is too busy brooding about the contents of Bilbo’s pack to pick up on the Hobbit’s stalling strategy in the heat of the moment?
But the structural integrity of the entire adventure begins to crumble when Bilbo considers avoiding the incident with the trolls. If they never find the troll hoard, he won’t pick up Sting, and Thorin will never find Orcrist. Who knows what could happen to Thorin in the goblin tunnels if he isn’t armed the same way? And Bilbo is not confident that he’ll be able to fight the spiders off with any weapon other than Sting. It might handle differently, more slowly, perhaps, and he might not be quick enough to prevent the beasts from feasting upon any of his friends.
Better not to risk it, then. Bilbo huffs and puffs a little on his way over to Fíli and Kíli. The last thing he needs right now is to be coated head-to-toe in troll snot. Before the lads can begin to explain the situation, Bilbo sets down the bowls he was asked to bring them and holds up his hands. They’re in for a battle, so he can at least save the poor princes a few minutes of wheedling.
“Obviously, our ponies have been snatched up by trolls,” Bilbo decrees. “I can’t imagine what else could be lurking around here that might be stupid enough to try and pull of a heist like that, though I’m still baffled as to how you two managed to miss a fully-grown troll lumbering over and making off with two of our beasts. For the life of me, I cannot think what could possibly have been more important than keeping an eye on them, and I’ve had—“ He cuts himself off before he can say eighty years to mull this over.
“Still?” Fíli demands. Bilbo winces. How careless he has been, throwing words around as though they mean nothing. His nerves are no excuse when he might inadvertently reveal his secret with a careless phrase. “You’ve only known about it for half a minute!”
“You shouldn’t make fun of how Mister Boggins talks,” Kíli advises, “It’s not his fault he’s from a strange place with strange ways of speaking.” Oh, lovely. Now the entire company is going to think that the word still is used differently in the Shire than in every other Westron-speaking corner of the world.
“Will you two please focus?” Bilbo forces himself to abandon his linguistic fretting. He can set the record straight once Erebor is reclaimed. For now, he’ll allow Kíli’s (admittedly very charitable) explanation to stand.
“Right,” Fíli drawls. “Focusing.” He pats his breast pocket, which no doubt contains at least one weapon. Not that it’ll be much use against the trolls.
“Yes, okay.” Kíli makes a big show of straightening his back and standing at attention, though his grin gives him away.
They’re not taking this seriously. But then, why would they? For all they know, Bilbo is simply going to pop over, liberate the ponies, and lead them back with the trolls none the wiser. The boys have no reason to suspect that their Burglar is about to lead them into a trap.
He ignores the gnawing feeling in his stomach and presses forward. “No doubt that glow over there is coming from their fire,” Bilbo says, as though only just noticing the faint light in the distance. “I’m going to go over there and see what’s going on. If I don’t come back in, say, ten minutes, please come and help me.”
It occurs to him, as he’s creeping over to the fire around which the trolls are bickering, that this may not have been the wisest idea. Bilbo, in his exasperation, has already changed things. He really should have just let the lads tell him to screech like an owl and have it be their idea to send him off. Perhaps they won’t be so willing to intervene now that Bilbo was the one to propose the entire venture.
But he need not have worried. Just like last time, the entire company comes rushing forward, slashing at the trolls’ legs and feet, giving Bilbo the chance to slip away and begin untying the ponies. Then, of course, Bilbo is snatched up again, and stretched uncomfortably by the trolls. This time, Bilbo notes, Thorin curses under his breath in Khuzdul before dropping his weapon, though the life-and-death stakes of the moment prevent Bilbo from ruminating too much about that particular difference. Does this mean that Thorin is especially fond of him this time around, or especially infuriated? Maybe his opinion of his Burglar has been lowered by the Hobbit’s changed behavior.
Perhaps it wasn’t so wise of Bilbo to bring a book along. It’s just that he’s had that volume on his shelf forever, and he knows for a fact that he wasn’t going to read it otherwise, not in eighty years! Considering the relative monotony of the first few weeks of their journey, Bilbo felt it wouldn’t be such a bad idea to take his book with him, to distract him from the unpleasant thoughts that have been plaguing him since he landed in the garden at Bag End. But he can easily see how, to Thorin, it might look as though he does not understand the dangers present on the road. Bilbo understands them perfectly well; he just knows when to expect them and when he’d be better served by keeping himself out of his own mind.
Still, vanquishing the trolls proves just as simple the second time as it did the first. Easier, actually, now that he’s confident in the results. Bilbo employs the exact same stalling method, and contrary to his wildest fears, Thorin picks up on his tactics right away and discourages his company from arguing against Bilbo’s claims, just as he did the last time. Everything unfolds the same way, nearly verbatim. The trolls bicker for several minutes about the best way to kill and eat their captives, and then, of course, they turn to stone when Gandalf arrives and reveals the morning sun. It’s as cut and dry as it was when Bilbo put it in his book, though he will admit to downplaying his own role in the entire debacle. It felt cheap, then, to boast about his cleverness when his friends were nearly killed after fighting to defend him.
Naturally, Bilbo’s first act when the Wizard cuts him free of his sack is to go and assist those members of the company who were tied to a log rotating over the fire. Bilbo has always wondered about what compelled the trolls to do this; it seems like an awful lot of work. If they hadn’t wasted so much time divesting everybody of their weapons and then securing so many of the company to the pole, perhaps they would have come to a decision about what to do with their captives before the break of day. Still, everything worked out in the company’s favor, so Bilbo supposes that he shouldn’t borrow trouble.
“Could you help me out, lad?” Óin flags Bilbo down, clearly looking for an extra set of hands. “I’ve got to see to Bifur.”
Bilbo follows Óin’s gesture to see Bifur sitting on a rock with a very conspicuous hand clamped over what appears to be a cut on his arm. “How bad is it?” He asks, worried. He knows that some members of the company were wounded during their first fight with the trolls, but he can’t recall if Bifur took any damage to his arm.
Óin calls to Bifur in Khuzdul, and his interlocutor responds in kind. “Nothing so terrible, don’t you worry,” Óin assures Bilbo, “No bone showing at least, but there’s stitches needed and I don’t trust any hand but my own for that.”
“Of course,” Bilbo replies, raising his voice a touch to ensure that the healer can hear his next question. “What do you need?”
“Nori’s got a nasty burn,” Óin reports, “Just rub some of this on it and he’ll heal in no time. Not too much, now, or it’ll be more trouble than it’s worth. Then roll the bandage around, tight enough to stay but not enough to stop the blood flowing.”
“I’d be glad to,” Bilbo assures the healer, accepting the jar of salve and roll of bandages.
If Óin hears him, he doesn’t reply. Bilbo brings his newly-acquired medical supplies over to Nori, who is seated on a rock, attempting to lace his boots up one-handed. As promised, his left hand sports a truly nasty burn. Much worse than a sunburn, Bilbo would say, with blisters and all, but with the help of the salve, Nori will probably recover within a few days. Though it is a bit odd, considering nothing like this happened the first time around. Bilbo may not have been paying much attention back then, but he would’ve noticed if one of the company were trying to do everything one-handed. He would have helped.
“Óin sent me,” Bilbo reports.
Nori snorts at him. “Could’ve done it myself, you know.” He clearly resents the suspicion that the others harbor towards him, even if he does understand where it comes from. Nori has a reputation as a thief, after all.
Bilbo shrugs. “You’re welcome to, if you’d like, but for what it’s worth, I think I’m here more to help you wind the bandage than because Óin thinks you’re going to steal his salve.” Not that he knows this for certain, but it’s a nice thought, isn’t it?
“Go ahead, then,” Nori instructs, still fiddling with his laces.
Bilbo has never tied any kind of shoe before in his life. He’s never worn any kind of shoe before in his life. Rather than embarrassing himself by trying to fiddle with the laces, he waves Bofur over. “Can you help him?” He asks. “He’s wounded.”
“Aye, of course I’ll help,” Bofur says, settling down on the ground beside Nori and reaching for the boot laces. Bilbo probably could have done it, of course. He’s tied a bow before, after all. He just doesn’t want to be responsible for anybody’s laces coming undone during an inopportune moment, and he needs to be extra careful about this sudden departure from the events of his original adventure. “Shouldn’t we tell Dori?”
“Oh, Mahal’s anvil, no,” Nori groans. “He’ll lose his mind.”
“I don’t think there’s any reason to,” Bilbo decides, “He’ll find out soon enough, anyway. Let’s let Nori enjoy a few minutes of freedom at least before he starts getting smothered.” He opens the jar and begins spreading the salve on Nori’s wounded hand. “Do you want to tell me what happened?”
“I was roasting a marshmallow,” Nori reports.
Bilbo suddenly has about a million questions. He’s not even remotely surprised that Nori apparently secreted a marshmallow or two away when Bilbo was showing the company how to roast them. But that is the least of the Hobbit’s concerns right now. “In your hand?”
“Well, I didn’t have a stick on me, did I?”
“I’d have thrown you one, if my hands were free,” Bofur muses.
“So….” Bilbo shakes his head. “You managed to get your hand out of your bindings and to get ahold of the marshmallow that you already had… somewhere on your person… and… you stuck your hand into the fire… to roast it?”
Nori shrugs. “I figured if I was going to die, I may as well go out happy.”
Bilbo can’t begrudge him this at all. “That was downright Hobbit-y of you,” he decrees. That is to say that neither Bilbo himself nor any of his neighbors would turn down something sweet even in a time of crisis. He remembers with sudden clarity the vinegar pies his mother made during the Fell Winter to keep the family’s spirits up. That’s the same logic as Nori’s last-minute marshmallow roasting, all things considered.
“I think I roasted my hand more than the marshmallow,” Nori confides.
Before Bilbo can think of something to say, Thorin is stomping over to their huddle. “Master Baggins!” He calls. “Bofur, Nori, Glóin! Come and look at this.”
“Why us?” Bofur asks, apparently not intimidated at all by his visibly irritated king.
It does not escape Bilbo that Thorin did not invite him to participate in the inspection of the troll hoard on their first adventure. Obviously, something has changed to induce the King to include Bilbo instead of Dwalin. But it does make perfect sense, now that Bilbo thinks about it. He’s the resident Burglar, allegedly an expert in treasure. Glóin is an actual treasure expert, and it was wise of Thorin to include him as well. Nori, a professional thief, would no doubt be familiar with the tactics of other thieves and may be able to shed some light on unexpected hiding places. Bofur, on the other hand, has lots of mining experience, and would be instantly aware of any structural issues with the underground hoard. And now that Bilbo thinks about it, it really does make more sense to leave Dwalin to guard the rest of the group. They’ll have the Wizard with them in the cave, after all. Thorin clearly knows his people, and he knows how to deploy them for best results.
He does not, however, know a thing about diplomacy. He doesn’t even answer Bofur’s question, just storms off with a vague gesture over his shoulder. “Come along!” He barks.
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “I suppose we’d better go before he starts getting impatient.” This burst of sarcasm earns him a couple of appreciative snorts.
“I suppose we should,” Bofur agrees, patting Nori’s recently-tied boot with exaggerated affection. It earns him a kick in the hand that might’ve broken Bilbo’s bones, had it been aimed in his direction.
By far, the worst aspect of the troll hoard is the overpowering smell. Bilbo did not get close enough last time to experience it, and some part of him wishes that Thorin had not invited him to join their little party this time. Based on the odor alone, Bilbo has to imagine that the trolls have been using this place to store their garbage as well as their treasure. He would not be surprised to learn that it has also served them as an outhouse.
“Oh, what’s that stench?” Nori demands, making a futile attempt to waft it away from him.
“It’s a troll hoard,” Gandalf replies imperiously, as if every member of the company should be familiar with the particulars of such locations. Sometimes, it feels as though the Wizard forgets that not everyone has lived a thousand lifetimes and seen every sight that Middle Earth has to offer. “Be careful what you touch.”
Thorin walks behind the Wizard, sword raised, as though he thinks a fourth troll might be lurking somewhere in this cave. If that is the case, Bilbo isn’t sure what a single broadsword could do against such a foe, but he appreciates the sight nevertheless. It’s embarrassing, to say the least, but Bilbo could stare at Thorin for hours, especially when he’s got his sword raised and that warlike expression on his handsome face. It’s almost enough to make up for the assault on the Hobbit’s poor nose.
“You’d think the trolls could do a little tidying up from time to time,” Bilbo grumbles. He doesn’t know why he’s surprised. Like the goblins, Smaug, and Gollum, the trolls do not seem to take much pride in their home. Even knowing all that he does about the world, it makes Bilbo sniff distastefully. And then, of course, he is assaulted once more by the terrible smell.
“They are trolls,” Thorin reasons. “They do not care whether they live in splendor or in filth.”
“There’s no ventilation system,” Glóin observes, studying the walls as though he expects to find a grate which might free them from their peril upon being turned.
“Why would there be?” Gandalf, apparently, sees the obvious segue into a conversation on Dwarven architecture, and clearly, he is not interested. “As I said, this is a troll hoard.”
Bilbo might laugh, were he not too busy coughing and gagging. The smell is truly terrible, but knowing what waits for them here, Bilbo forges ahead. He’s got to have Sting, and Thorin has got to have Orcrist. Who knows what Glamdring will do for Gandalf in the many long years that he bears it? And besides, this is hardly the worst smell that they’ll encounter on this journey. The Goblin tunnels come to mind again, and Gollum’s little pool, and the place where the spiders dump the remains of their victims. The battlefield might not be as bad as the troll hoard, but that’s only because the fighting won’t take place in an enclosed space. And all that dragon dung in Erebor…
Bofur has already discovered a mid-sized wooden chest overflowing with golden coins. “Seems a shame just to leave it lying around,” he muses, examining his find with interest. “Anyone could take it.”
“Agreed,” says Glóin. “Nori, get a shovel.”
Naturally, Nori seems very glad indeed of the excuse to leave the troll hoard for a moment, and he bounds off, injured hand forgotten. Bilbo watches him go with no small degree of envy, but nobody would’ve asked the Hobbit to fetch any of their heavy metal shovels. Even if he could carry it, he’d be slow in bringing it over. Still, he wouldn’t mind the fresh air.
“These swords were not made by any troll.” Thorin’s low voice carries across the cave, and Bilbo shudders despite himself.
This is a propitious moment. It’s important. And Bilbo should feel grateful that he gets to witness it this time, that Thorin has, for whatever reason, chosen him to participate in this excursion. Instead, he feels his heart drop into his stomach at the thought of Orcrist buried by Thorin’s side beneath the Mountain. The king now holds the blade that he will take with him to the halls of his Maker.
Gandalf approaches and accepts the second sword, which Thorin holds out to him. “Nor were they made by any smith among men,” the Wizard breathes. “These were worked in Gondolin by the High Elves of the First Age.” Bilbo must stifle his laughter as Thorin makes to put the sword back where he found it. Does he truly hate Elves that much? What a silly question. Of course he does. “You could not wish for a finer blade,” Gandalf adds.
But something else has caught Thorin’s eye. He keeps Orcrist close, but peers into the cache whence it came. “What’s this?”
Sting. It is Sting. Bilbo would know his little sword anywhere, even just by its dusty hilt. “An Elven dagger, I suspect,” Gandalf states the obvious.
Thorin studies the small, sleek weapon, which has saved Bilbo’s life on countless occasions. Its scabbard must still be somewhere in the crate. The blade is in alright condition, considering, but it wants cleaning and polishing. Maybe a little sharpening as well, though Bilbo certainly would not have made such considerations on his first adventure.
“I shall give this to my sister-son,” Thorin decides, “Fíli is fond of knives and will enjoy fighting with one so well-made.”
Well, that’s unexpected. “Or,” Bilbo suggests, before he can think better of it, “Instead of giving it to the most heavily-armed creature between here and the Gap of Rohan,” he pauses to accommodate Bofur’s chuckle and Glóin’s knowing snort, “You could give it to the only member of your company without a sword to speak of.”
“This is not a sword,” Thorin argues.
“Perhaps not for a giant such as yourself,” Bilbo concedes, plucking the short sword out of the king’s hands. It is not lost on Bilbo that Thorin is significantly stronger than he is; he would not have been able to take the blade if the king did not will it, but take it he has. He tries a few stilted jabs at the air off to his side, relishing the familiar feeling of having Sting in hand. “But it will suit me just fine. I shall call it Sting, I think.” The last time, Bilbo didn’t name his sword until the debacle with the spiders, but why wait?
“The blade is sharp,” Thorin counsels, “Do not hurt yourself.”
“Yes, I’m aware that swords can cut people. Thank you for pointing that out.” Bilbo is really pressing his luck, but honestly!
“Must you test my patience every time the opportunity presents itself?” Thorin murmurs in a tone of voice that confuses Bilbo to no end.
He reminds himself that he’s supposed to be annoyed with the king for attempting to give away Bilbo’s sword. “Funny. I could ask you the same thing.” The verbal sparring is almost enough to melt the icy ache that has lately settled deep within Bilbo’s chest. Almost.
“Take your knife, then,” Thorin decides eventually, as though Bilbo has not already taken it. “Perhaps you can use it for peeling potatoes.” This is an insult, Bilbo knows. In any Dwarven kingdom, the insinuation that someone might use a tool for anything other than its intended purpose would be grounds for a physical confrontation.
But Bilbo is a Hobbit of the Shire, and his people have their own way of handling such slights. “Oh, please tell me you don’t actually think this would work for that,” Bilbo protests. “Surely you must know that I know my way around a kitchen. Unlike a certain monarch I might mention.”
“That may be,” Thorin replies coolly, “But I fail to see what other use you might find for any blade.”
Bilbo sputters for a moment before collecting himself enough to speak. He should be infuriated, he knows, but instead, he is perplexed. Is Thorin actually trying to hurt him or are they merely bickering for the sport of it? The insults he’s been offered are pointed enough, but he’s been giving quite as good as he gets, and neither one of them has backed down as of yet. “In case you hadn’t noticed, I’m on the same dangerous quest as all the rest of you. Don’t you think I should be armed?”
Thorin blinks at Bilbo, Orcrist hanging forgotten in a limp grip by his side. “You should have been armed when you left your… Hobbit den.”
“The word you’re looking for is smial.” He just can’t stop pressing his luck. He doesn’t know what he’s expecting. It’s as though the moment he starts arguing with Thorin, the rest of the world melts away, a feeling Bilbo can’t stop chasing, despite his better judgment.
“Very well,” says Thorin. He looks as though there might be more than this on his mind, but if there is, he does not give it voice.
“I hope it is,” Bilbo replies, more to fill the sudden permeating silence than for any other reason.
Apparently, His Majesty has had enough of this conversation. It certainly is awkward, what with their audience staring on and the smell of the troll hoard hanging over their heads. “Let’s get out of this foul place,” Thorin declares, turning on his heel and storming out of the cave. Typical. “Come on, let’s go.” Everyone follows him out of the cave, leaving Bilbo alone with Sting and the buried treasure in the stinking hoard.
A few harrowing hours later, the company is welcomed in the House of Elrond. They are all exhausted after being chased so far by the band of orcs, and many of them are somewhat disgruntled at what they view as underhanded machination on Gandalf’s part. But from Bilbo’s perspective, there was nowhere else they could have gone. They’ll need Elrond’s help with the moon runes, after all, and it will be good to restock their provisions, not to mention all that they’re about to learn regarding their new weapons. They enjoy a very hectic meal, during which every member of the company manages to cause his own particular kind of chaos. Bilbo will admit that it takes all of his restraint to keep from spoiling the future for everyone when they tease Kíli about his alleged romantic interest in Elves. Oh, if only they knew!
After dinner, of course, Gandalf manages to talk Thorin into allowing Elrond to look at the map, a process only slightly more perilous than pulling teeth from a live warg. Bilbo lingers in the room, trying to look surprised at each unfolding development and paying more attention to the rhapsodized expression on Thorin’s face than to the glowing runes which have monopolized the king’s attention. After all of that excitement, Bilbo is more than ready for a good night’s sleep.
Last time, he accepted the bedroom that the Elves offered to him, but now, he joins the rest of the company at their camp in the corridor. None of them seem to trust the Elves very much, but Thorin’s brusqueness stands out even among the less-than-polite reactions of his companions. It strikes Bilbo as more than a little unfair, considering that Elrond is not by any means in league with Thranduil, but Thorin has no way of knowing that. Bilbo understands that the king probably would not trust anybody offering his people any kind of shelter after the horrors that he has endured. He doesn’t even trust Bilbo, of all people, and it does seem a bit too good to be true for Elrond to happily shell out fifteen bedrooms for the shelter of a company that led a band of orcs into his lands, intentionally or otherwise.
“Where did you get those?” Thorin demands when Bilbo returns to the hallway that the company has taken over.
If Bilbo didn’t have three plump pillows under each arm, which is no small feat for somebody of his size, he might shrug. “From one of the bedrooms,” he explains, “I did ask Lord Elrond first.” Bilbo doesn’t know why it matters to him, but for some reason, he doesn’t want his friends to think that he’s the sort to just pilfer somebody’s belongings without asking.
Which feels a little ridiculous, because he has been hired as an expert Burglar. They’re expecting him to have experience with pilfering things, and strictly speaking, he does. Actually, Bilbo has wondered many times over the years why Thorin didn’t just ask Nori to be his Burglar and have done with it. Perhaps, it was because Gandalf thought that Smaug’s lack of knowledge of Hobbits would protect Bilbo from the dragon in some way, though he can’t see why. The dragon wouldn’t need to be familiar with Bilbo’s scent to set him on fire or gobble him up.
“I thought you’d produced them from that magic pack of yours,” Thorin says. It takes Bilbo a moment to realize that he’s making a joke.This is certainly a new development. It never would have happened the first time around, that’s for certain, not this early on. Maybe in Beorn’s hall, or after they washed up in Lake-town, but never in Rivendell.
Still, here they are at the Last Homely House, and here is Thorin, ostensibly trying to make Bilbo laugh. Maybe Thorin takes him less seriously than he did on the original adventure, on account of the reading and the snack distribution. Or maybe, now that Bilbo is far less fussy and somewhat more prepared for travel through the wilderness, Thorin has decided that he likes his Hobbit much earlier in the proceedings. Of course, it may also have something to do with the fact that Bilbo is not actively avoiding him this time around. On the first adventure, he’d all but hidden from Thorin, refusing to meet his eyes and speaking to him only when forced to do so by the situation. All that time he wasted! All those nights when they were both awake and could have spoken but did not! All those hours of silence which Bilbo could never get back, in the end, which haunted him until the end of his days.
“No,” Bilbo smiles. Sometimes it’s like a knife in his side, being around Thorin, but he still smiles. He’s on a quest much more momentous than the one he left for eighty years ago, with much more responsibility, but he can’t help but grin at the stubborn old king. He will not fail Thorin this time. “There wouldn’t have been much space, what with all those cinnamon buns. Thank you again for helping me take care of them.”
“I still have no idea why you felt it was necessary to drag those along. You could have brought a sword instead, if you’re so skilled with one.”
Unfortunately, Bilbo did not have much of a chance to prove himself on that score during their latest confrontation with the orcs. In truth, he never came to blows with any of them, preoccupied as he was with running away and trying to continue breathing while his friends were in such serious danger. Try as he might, he could not stop remembering the Battle of the Five Armies. He was so distracted by the foes of his memory that, on one occasion, Dwalin was forced to physically carry him away from the foes presently hunting them. All in all, it was not Bilbo’s best moment.
But Thorin does not say more about it. He leaves the little teasing barb hanging in the air, eying Bilbo as he waits for a response. Very well, then. If he’d like to engage in a little bit of back and forth rather than flaying Bilbo from crown to toe for his uselessness in battle, the Hobbit isn’t going to complain.
“I have a sword,” Bilbo points out, patting Sting’s handle. He’d missed the little dagger very much when it was with Frodo, glad as he may have been at the knowledge that his nephew bore an Elven blade. “Despite your best efforts to the contrary.”
“You did not have it when we set out,” Thorin recounts. “You could not have expected to stumble upon a troll-hoard as we did.”
Bilbo can’t help but tease him a little bit. “Ah, but if I’d packed a sword, I would never have had room for the cinnamon rolls. Or the bread, or the butter, let alone the butter knives.” In all honesty, Bilbo had only brought those along because he is quite fond of them, and would rather not have them going to Lobelia and Otho any time soon. He’d prefer to see them in the goblin tunnels.
“Or your book.” Thorin is clearly amused, though he is also clearly trying very hard to hide this fact. So he does like Bilbo then, or at least, he finds him funny. But Bilbo already knows that this changes nothing, not for Thorin Oakenshield. Whether he likes the Hobbit or not, he won’t get close to anyone if he can help it.
“Or my book,” Bilbo agrees, “I’m almost done with it now.”
In truth, the novel has proved to be something of a disappointment. Prior to his travels, Bilbo often indulged in adventure stories, and this one was no exception. A brave knight slaying a dragon to protect a princess, classic stuff. Only the dragon wasn’t written very well and the princess had no personality, and the knight was just as boring but exceptionally long-winded, always yapping at every character cursed to share a scene with him. If he could do this all over again (which Bilbo sincerely hopes he won’t have to) he would probably bring an old standby, a volume of poetry or a story he knew he would enjoy. Although, his irritation at the characters in his book and the way it was written has been a welcome distraction from the more troubling reminders he’s been given on this journey.
“Master Baggins!” Kíli calls to him from the floor, as though summoned by Bilbo’s wandering thoughts. It is physically painful for Bilbo to see the lad reclining on the ground like that. It reminds him far too much of Ravenhill, even if Kíli is grinning from ear to ear, even with no Elf maiden weeping over him this time. “Throw me one of those?”
Ah, the pillows. “I’ll not be throwing anything in Lord Elrond’s hall,” Bilbo protests, walking over to Kíli and handing him a pillow. “And neither will you.” He knows the prince well enough, after all, to know what the next words out of his mouth will be. True to form, Kíli pouts at him with perfectly-polished puppy-dog eyes.
“Good luck with that,” Nori snorts.
“Is that a candelabra in your pocket?” Bilbo demands of the thief. Honestly, what’s he even planning to do with that? Perhaps he only wants to prove that he can steal the light fixtures from right under Elrond’s nose if he so chooses.
“I think he’s just happy to see you,” says Bofur, never one to miss an opening for a joke.
For a moment, Bilbo attempts to restrain his laughter. But why bother? These are his friends, and he has missed him very much, and there is no point in hiding his amusement from them. Not when he’s already doing so very much to protect them from his grief. So he laughs out loud, and continues distributing pillows, and successfully prevents three separate pillow fights from breaking out in his presence. They’ll be on again as soon as he turns his back, but at least there’ll be peace when he’s around.
“I’m going back for more of these,” Bilbo announces, gesturing at the pillow he’s just handed to Dori. Mother hen that he is, Dori has already started fluffing it and seems to be eying the space between his youngest brother’s back and the cool stone wall as a potential place to slide the pillow. “Six won’t be enough for all of us, and believe me, these Elves have no shortage.”
Thorin mutters something under his breath about how that doesn’t surprise him, an utterance which Bilbo pointedly ignores as he retreats back down the corridor.
It doesn’t take long for Bilbo to rediscover his long-standing love of Rivendell. This place is truly beautiful: every corner is perfectly clean, scrubbed and shined and dusted by unseen hands or magical forces on a daily basis. Nearly every comfort imaginable is available to the company, from books to cakes to scenery, although meat seems to be in short supply. Unlike last time, Fíli and Kíli stick to Bilbo’s sides, though he has no clue why. Perhaps they think they’ll be getting more marshmallows, or perhaps they’re simply more comfortable with him now that he’s indulged them by going along with a few of their antics. Of course, there is also the possibility that Thorin has ordered his nephews to keep an eye on the Hobbit. If so, Bilbo is impressed by Kíli’s ability to obscure that particular secret, though such comportment is no surprise coming from Fíli. Bilbo always knew there was much more to that lad than meets the eye.
“This harp music isn’t bad,” Kíli observes as they pass a huddle of Elven musicians. “Though I think Uncle Thorin is more skilled.”
“He brought his harp, you know,” Fíli points out, “I’ve been lugging it along with my fiddle.”
“And all forty-thousand of your weapons,” Bilbo grumbles. Truly, Fíli’s poor pony has been bearing an arsenal that would outfit the entire company twice over in a pinch. Actually, Bilbo wouldn’t be surprised if the prince had enough knives for everybody strapped to his person at this moment. And Thorin wanted to give him Sting as well?
“Well, yes,” Fíli admits. “But I had to pack extra to share with the people who didn’t bring any.”
“That was exactly my logic with the food,” Bilbo quips. Honestly, none of his companions seemed to even consider, when they set out from the Blue Mountains, that they would need to eat something on the journey. None of their foodstuffs were very nutritious the first time around, and all were severely lacking in the flavor department, despite Bombur’s best efforts.
“Maybe we can talk him into playing something with us at dinner tonight,” Kíli is as single-minded as his uncle, though evidently he’s much more optimistic. “He’s very pleased with Bofur for all that ruckus he caused yesterday evening, though of course he can’t say anything. It wouldn’t be very kingly of him.”
Bilbo shakes his head. “When I taught Bofur that little song, I didn’t think he was going to start belting it at the top of his lungs on Elrond’s table.” At least, he didn’t expect that turn of events when first he lived it. This time, however, Bilbo knew exactly what he was doing when he traded songs with Bofur.
“You’re part of the company now.” Fíli pats Bilbo on the shoulder with surprising restraint, a fine approximation of the sorts of gestures they saw exchanged between Hobbits as they traversed the Shire. The prince will make a fine diplomat when he’s older. If he’s ever older. “He was trying to include you.”
Bilbo shakes his head. He needs to stop thinking this way. Rumination will change nothing. He always will have lived through the deaths of his friends, but if he can make a solid plan, he’ll at least be able to help them on this timeline. He should focus on what he can do to put things right, and not what happened because he was too slow scrambling up Ravenhill. And speaking of…
“Well,” he says, fighting irrational tears. “I’m off to the library, then. Care to join me?”
“Absolutely not.” Kíli claps him on the shoulder with no small amount of force. Unlike his brother, he does not seem to have picked up yet on the fact that Hobbits are smaller and more fragile than the Dwarven warriors with whom he is accustomed to roughhousing. “Have fun with your books, though, Mister Boggins. See you at supper!”
“That you will,” Bilbo mutters, darting into the library before the lad can tempt him away from his quest with the promise of food.
Bilbo has a job to do, after all. He won’t get much outside help when it comes to altering the fates of his friends; rerouting the outcome of the Battle of the Five Armies is entirely Bilbo’s affair. Thankfully, he’s sure it can be done if only he changes a few things, if he’s faster, if he thinks on his feet, if he takes advantage of his foreknowledge and, most difficult of all, convinces Thorin, Dwalin, and the lads to listen to him. But the fifth step of his quest poses a much greater challenge.
Bilbo was present at the council here in Rivendell a few years ago. Or, he will be present at the council, several decades from now. Or, he was present at it, several decades in the future, but he will not be there again, because it will not take place, because, hopefully, by that point on this timeline Bilbo will have already destroyed the ring. Goodness, but this time-travel business is confusing!
Regardless, Bilbo has never been daunted by the prospect of a bit of research. Elrond’s library is grand: extensive, tidy, and well-organized. The shelves are labeled by subject and the books are alphabetized within their subheadings. Bilbo catches sight of three librarians, all of whom are hard at work. This is one of Bilbo’s favorite places to visit in Rivendell, and where he spent much of his time while waiting for Frodo to return from his own quest.
Unfortunately, the last time Bilbo was here, he did not think to do any serious research on the Rings of Power. He saw no point in it, considering that Frodo was already off and away. Bilbo was bogged down by his guilt, which still affects him, and his shame, and his anger, and his fear. Since he’d been told in no uncertain terms that he could do nothing to help Frodo but give up his mithril shirt and Elven blade, Bilbo had turned to escapism, reading novels and poetry and memoirs about happy people who had lived in better times.
He does not even know where to look. Bilbo scans the shelves, searching amongst the jewelry craft guides and the histories of Middle Earth, but after more than an hour of this, he is unsuccessful. He checks a few less-intuitive locations, but finds nothing there, either. There is nothing, not a single volume in this entire library, that appears to be about the Rings of Power. Of course, just because a book is not explicitly about the Rings of Power does not mean that it will not make any mention of them.
So Bilbo spends another several hours paging through histories of Middle Earth, searching in vain for anything that might help. He finds mentions of the Rings, yes, but nothing that will actually be useful to his errand. He knows already how many Rings were made, how they functioned and what happened to their bearers. He knows more than the historians seem to about where the Rings all ended up, and none of this information is remotely helpful to him, anyway.
Bilbo needs to know how to destroy a Ring of Power. He needs to know how to destroy the One Ring. He needs to know if there is any way to do that, other than by taking it to Mount Doom, but of course, he has forgotten the details given by Lord Elrond at the council. He didn’t bother to memorize the details, his logic at the time being that it was Frodo’s tale to tell, and that the lad would tell it much better than Bilbo ever could.
He is shaken from his perusal of yet another useless history by the clearing of a throat. “Oh!” Bilbo exclaims. “Hello, Dori.”
“Have you seen my brother by any chance, Master Baggins?” Dori inquires, polite as usually.
Bilbo grits his teeth. “Which one?” The thought of Ori loose in the library is much less concerning to the Hobbit than the idea that Nori might be wandering around unattended. He’s the type to make mischief when bored, as Bilbo knows very well.
“Ori came to look at books some hours ago.” Well, that’s a relief, then.
“It seems I didn’t even notice,” Bilbo chuckles nervously. He was so caught up in his research that he would not have noticed if the Valar themselves all filed in and formed a circle around his table.
“I wouldn’t be surprised if he didn’t notice you, either,” Dori replies, and he’s probably correct. Ori is a scholar, after all, and would not be able to resist the pull of the library any more than Bilbo has.
“I’ll help you look for him,” Bilbo decides, shutting his latest volume. His eyes are beginning to get tired, and it’s clear that he’s not going to find much of anything here. Wherever Elrond keeps his literature on the Rings of Power, there’s nothing to be discovered on that score in his public library. “And then we can all have supper. It’s about that time, isn’t it?”
The Elves, naturally, do not serve dinner, let alone tea, elevensies, or second breakfast, so the meal that they call supper comes several hours earlier than its equivalent in the Shire. But Bilbo has gotten used to that, after two decades living in Rivendell.
“Mmm,” Dori agrees, and once more, Bilbo is distracted by a secondary task.
After they find Ori, they head to the dining hall, passing the entrance to a corridor which Bilbo has walked many times before. Out the corner of his eye, he sees Elrond, bent in concentration over a broken blade on a dais. He is speaking, his voice too low for Bilbo to hear at this distance. Here is yet another scene that Bilbo was shown by Lady Galadriel.
He watches, rapt, as a small, dark-haired creature steps into view, getting closer to the sword that is his birthright, his face a comical mirror of Elrond’s stern expression. Bilbo finds himself moving forward, though he does not know what he might say to young Aragorn. This child is decades away from becoming the Man that Bilbo once knew, the reluctant monarch who shocked his people by bowing publicly to four perplexed Hobbits.
“Come on, Bilbo, I’m starving.” Ori steers him bodily away from the corridor, and a good thing, too. Who knows how the future could change if Bilbo interfered with the destiny of the long-lost King of Gondor? “Maybe they’ll have some real food on offer today.”
Bilbo winces. In his twenty years staying with Elrond, he was never served anything very different from the meal that they received last night. Breakfast and luncheon weren’t too different, either, but perhaps Ori was holding out hope for suppertime. “I’m afraid you may need to get used to greens as long as we’re here, Ori. I doubt the fare will change any time soon.”
Bilbo waits for Lord Elrond at the same overlook where they had their discussion last time, around what he thinks is the same time. He underestimated, when he made his (admittedly very loose) plan, how difficult it would be to place himself in the exact same location he once occupied at the exact same moment. The more circumstances and relationships depart from the way they were on his first adventure, the more trouble it is to try and figure out what should be happening and to drag himself away from what is happening in order to endure it.
But this is easy. The Elf Lord must be hoping to speak to Bilbo. He knows, of course, what quest the company embarks upon, and though he may have been willing to help with the moon runes, he is certainly opposed to the undertaking. And he wants to talk the Hobbit out of it, because he is a kind Elf who takes no joy in sending any creatures off to their deaths. Elrond knows, of course, that Thorin and his company would never listen to him, but he must think that Bilbo, by virtue of his being a Hobbit, is disconnected enough from the rest of them that he might be swayed.
Unfortunately for Elrond, that is not the case this time. “You won’t talk me out of this, Lord Elrond. I’m going on the quest.”
Elrond sidles up beside him, tall and ethereal. Bilbo must remind himself that at the moment, they are not old friends but complete strangers. “You are certain, then.”
“I’ve just said that I am.” Bilbo does not appreciate this prodding. Elrond is only trying to puzzle out what to make of him, he knows. There haven’t been Hobbits in Rivendell in many an age, if there ever were any, and Elrond’s limited dealings with Shire folk won’t have prepared him for Bilbo Baggins. That brings a smile to the Hobbit’s face, if nothing else. “But I did have… another question.”
Bilbo really wanted to avoid doing this. He knows that it’s going to raise suspicion, that Elrond will be clued into things that he should not know for many years. But then, if all goes according to plan, it won’t matter whether Elrond knows or not. And in order for Bilbo to formulate a plot, he’ll need more information than he has at present. If only the Lady of Lorien had allowed him to take his book back with him! Then he could simply have consulted Frodo’s notes on the council and had done with it.
But nothing is ever that easy. If it were, Bilbo would simply have invited all of his friends to come live with him in Hobbiton, Lonely Mountain be damned. This is a risk that he is willing to take.
“What kind of question?” Elrond sounds amused. Perhaps he thinks he knows what Bilbo is going to ask.
“I was wondering,” Bilbo begins, “About the Rings of Power. I did look in your library, but I’m afraid I didn’t find anything. Perhaps I was searching in the wrong place.”
“Some knowledge is better left away from prying eyes and wandering hands,” Elrond intones, ever cryptic. Oh, honestly. Bilbo never should have taken any counsel from Elves, let alone repeated his adventure at the behest of one! “But what is it that you want to know?”
“I was wondering how one might… destroy one.” Better to just say it flat out. “A Ring of Power, that is.”
Ideally, Bilbo would like to ask about the One Ring in particular, but that would raise too many questions. Elrond might want to know what Bilbo knows already, at which point, Bilbo would be forced to hedge around the fact that he knows far too much. Also, it is possible that Elrond might leap to the wrong conclusions. He already does not trust Thorin, after all, and to be completely honest, the thought of the One Ring in the hands of Thrain’s son is a harrowing one, even for Bilbo. He might be forced to tell the truth, which would not do at all. Elrond would want to interfere, and who knows who else he might inform? And if all this knowledge is truly meant to be kept secret, it is possible that Elrond might simply refuse to answer Bilbo’s questions at all.
“Ah.” Elrond stares out at his city, eyes unreadable. “Have you come into possession of a Ring of Power, Mister Baggins?”
“Me?” Bilbo forces a laugh. He’s very good at this. He’s been dealing with nosy relations all his life. He can put on a fine show if he sets his mind to it, and Elrond doesn’t even know him yet! “No, no, of course not. It’s just intellectual curiosity! I’m interested in artifacts. Like Thorin’s sword.” Bilbo finds himself stepping back a little from the edge as the blood rushes to his face. Oh, yes, Bilbo Baggins, you are interested in that, aren’t you? “Not… well, but…“
Elrond laughs. “You wish to impress your new friends with your knowledge of treasure? Of the history of their people?”
Oh, thank the Valar for the Elven tendency to underestimate all other peoples. Bilbo is saved. Elrond does not yet see the full picture, though, when things begin to change, he almost certainly shall. Hopefully he won’t be too upset about Bilbo’s mild deception. As wise as he is, the Elf Lord will surely understand that this was for the best. “Yes, yes exactly. That’s exactly it.”
“It is not easy to unmake a Ring of Power,” Elrond informs him, “The best way is to throw the ring back into the fires whence it was forged.” He does not elaborate on the location of these fires. He likely does not want to scare Bilbo, and since the Elf Lord believes that he is only satisfying an intellectual curiosity, it’s not as though Bilbo can press further. If it is all hypothetical, it should not matter that Mount Doom is deep inside Mordor. “Though you must be most interested in the Dwarven rings.”
“Yes,” Bilbo manages. No. But he cannot ask about the One Ring. He wonders, with a rising sense of dread, if the ring holds influence over him even now, if it is stopping him from speaking up in an attempt at self-preservation. But no, he assures himself, that is ridiculous. Bilbo would know it if the ring were working on him. He would recognize its presence in his head, would he not? And he does not even bear the thing! He has never even seen it yet! Even such a powerful object as the One Ring surely cannot have such reach. “Yes, I am. Most interested in those.”
Elrond chuckles. “I have watched you with the princes. They are very fond of you.” For all of Thorin’s grumbling about disrespectful Elves, Elrond clearly acknowledges the status of Erebor’s deposed royal family.
“And I am fond of them,” Bilbo replies. He does not know what Elrond is implying here, or how his friendships with Fíli and Kíli are at all relevant to the Rings of Power. “Lord Elrond, the company… well, they are fond of telling stories, around the fire. I’d like some of my own to contribute.”
“Do your own people not have stories?” Elrond studies him with ancient eyes and a mind as sharp as steel.
“Not stories that would impress warriors such as… the ones I travel with,” Bilbo replies carefully. If he did not know Elrond so well, Bilbo would imagine that he was being tested. But the Elf Lord is only trying to make friends.
“You mean that you do not believe your stories are fit to impress a king.” Ah. Well. That’s out in the open, then.
Bilbo blushes. He knows he was not this obvious the last time around. But then, Bilbo is the one who cannot take his eyes off of Thorin, cannot stop looking to make certain that his king is safe. Perhaps Elrond has picked up on Bilbo’s grief and misinterpreted it in a way that makes sense in context. Bilbo supposes he would do the same, in the Elf Lord’s position.
“I suppose that is what I mean, yes.” At least his blushing and fidgeting are advantageous in the present conversation.
“There were seven rings made for the Dwarven Lords,” Elrond explains, “Most are missing.” Yes, because the enemy probably has them already. Bilbo vaguely remembers something about this being said at the council here in Rivendell, all those years ago. “But at least two were destroyed by dragon fire long ago.”
“Dragon fire,” Bilbo echoes. He hadn’t thought of it before. “Dragon fire is effective against the Rings of Power?” Of course it is! Of course it would be! And it explains perfectly why the Valar would trouble themselves with Bilbo and his adventure, why he’d be sent back to do it again. He’s already going to stumble across the One Ring, and he’ll be taking it directly to the stronghold of an ancient and powerful dragon. It feels almost preordained, and Bilbo wonders if he isn’t very foolish for not thinking of it before.
“Oh, yes,” Elrond assures him, “Though it is a dangerous method.”
“Not more dangerous than hunting down some fire-mountain in a far away land and climbing to the top of it,” Bilbo reasons. He cannot keep the bitterness from his tone. Frodo should not have had to endure that. If only Bilbo had been wiser, if only he had been less easily swayed by the malice of the ring. “Let alone actually going inside.”
Bilbo is here to put things right, and he cannot stand around feeling sorry for himself. He does not wish to travel to Mordor and will do everything in his power to avoid it, but if he had to, then he would. Still, if this dragon fire method pans out, Bilbo will not need to be diverted from his adventure at all. He’ll have to rearrange things, of course, and come up with a few new plans after the ring is gone, but he was counting on that, anyway.
“No, no more dangerous than that.” Thankfully, Elrond misinterprets Bilbo’s utterance as sarcasm. Which is quite fair, considering Bilbo’s typical modes of interaction. Much of what he says is quite sarcastic, and Elrond does not know him well enough to tell the difference.
“Thank you, Lord Elrond. This will be a great help.” It’s true enough, isn’t it? At least Bilbo knows the sort of legs he stands on. He’ll leave Rivendell with the seed of a plan, and that seed will sprout and flower by the time he arrives at the Mountain to carry it out. Very convenient, and another sign that Bilbo’s characteristic luck is perhaps something more than he had thought.
Elrond only laughs once more. “I have not even told you the stories yet, Master Hobbit.”
Ah, yes, the stories. Bilbo tries to be grudging about this. He really should get back to the company, should he not? Elrond is actively trying to prevent their adventure. It will not put Thorin in a pleasant mood to see Bilbo fraternizing with Elves; he knows this from experience. And, yet, he cannot help himself. Not only would it be incredibly rude for Bilbo to simply walk off now that he’s gotten what he wanted from Elrond, but, despite himself, he longs to hear the tale of the Rings of Power and how they were forged and destroyed. Bilbo loves stories, especially old stories, even the ones that have no bearing whatsoever on his own life. Especially those ones, actually.
“So silly of me.” He has to laugh at himself. “Please, tell me all you know.”
“All I know?” Elrond raises an eyebrow. Apparently, Bilbo has succeeded once again in endearing himself to the Lord of Rivendell.
Bilbo shrugs. “As much as you’re willing to share.” That should be a pleasant way to spend a few hours.
Bilbo stands on a landing, overlooking yet another part of Rivendell.He initially planned to avoid this interaction. After all, he’s had it once before, and once was quite enough. He did not know then what he knows now, and the memory has been colored for him by subsequent events. But then he thinks of Thorin enduring the encounter alone, and as irritated as Bilbo might be with the leader of their company, he cannot allow that to happen.
“Of course I was going to tell you; I was waiting for this very chance,” Gandalf is saying, as he and Elrond traverse the path below. “And really, I think you can trust that I know what I’m doing.”
“Do you?” Elrond demands. When Bilbo sat down to write his book, he could not remember this dialogue, but he has an odd sense of familiarity, hearing it again. He may not know for certain the next words that the Elf Lord will say, but he certainly recalls the gist. “That dragon has slept for sixty years. What will happen if your plan should fail? If you wake that beast?”
“What if we succeed?” Gandalf counters. This time around, Bilbo hears Thorin’s footsteps behind him. He’d been so busy eavesdropping before that he hadn’t noticed the king’s approach at all. He wonders, now, why Thorin would even bother coming over. Is he trying to listen in on Gandalf and Elrond, or is he curious about what Bilbo is doing away from the rest of the company? "If the Dwarves take back the mountain, our defenses in the East will be strengthened.”
That much is certainly true. Bilbo remembers hearing about the Ringwraith’s arrival at Erebor, and he cannot imagine how the War of the Ring would have gone without a friendly presence there. If only Bilbo knew more about what actually happened! But unfortunately, anything said to him about the fate of Erebor after Frodo’s return went in one ear and out the other as he devoted his limited energy to looking after his nephew.
“It is a dangerous move, Gandalf.” But Elrond, too, is correct. Bilbo knows that first hand.
“It is also dangerous to do nothing! The throne of Erebor is Thorin’s birthright. What is it you fear?” Gandalf must be acting deliberately obtuse, though Bilbo can’t imagine why. Actually, when he thinks about it, yes, he can.
Bilbo is no longer the muddled old Hobbit who had his mind warped by the One Ring. He remembers everything that has happened to him over the course of the past eight decades with much more clarity than he’d been able to spare at the time. He knows very well that Gandalf allowed Frodo to carry the ring to Mordor, expecting that the lad would be greatly harmed by the proceedings. Believing, probably, that the lad would perish, but understanding that there was no other way. None but a Hobbit could carry the ring without becoming a monster, and Bilbo was no longer up to the task. Gandalf had made a strategic decision at the expense of one Hobbit. Here, he is making yet another strategic decision.
Bilbo will not go so far as to say that Gandalf does not care that Thorin and his nephews will die. Of course, even the Wizard has no inkling of what will come to pass, should Bilbo fail. Rather, Gandalf is willing to accept the deaths of any of the company if it means that Erebor will be reclaimed. It’s hard not to resent the Wizard for urging Bilbo and everyone close to him to embark upon terribly risky quests without sufficient preparation for the sake of Middle Earth, but then, the fate of Middle Earth is in play. Even Bilbo can admit that this outweighs the fate of any one person.
“Have you forgotten?” Lord Elrond pushes on. “A strain of madness runs deep in that family.” This time, Bilbo does not need to look to see that Thorin is still behind him. He is not surprised by what he is hearing, either. He has seen it first hand. “His grandfather lost his mind. His father succumbed to the same sickness. Can you swear Thorin Oakenshield will not also fall?” The Wizard says nothing. “Gandalf, these decisions do not rest with us alone. It’s not up to you or me to re-draw the map of Middle Earth.”
Thorin turns to leave, and Bilbo follows him. He didn’t, the last time. He only stood there, trying in vain to hear the rest of their conversation. The Elf Lord and the Wizard moved out of earshot and Bilbo stayed behind, content to let the king brood over the fruits of his eavesdropping. But Bilbo, now, knows more about dragon sickness than Thorin does. And he wants to help, even if only a little bit.
“Don’t listen to him,” Bilbo counsels, though Thorin has yet to acknowledge him in any way. “Lord Elrond has no idea what he’s talking about.”
“You seemed quite fond of him, the last time I looked,” Thorin retorts, still not looking at Bilbo. Is that envy in his tone? Surely not. Yes, toward the end, Thorin was quite possessive of Bilbo, but they are early in their journey yet. Bilbo must be hearing what he wants to hear, interpreting a jealous note in a perfectly plain statement.
“Yes, well,” Bilbo hedges, “Either way, he’s wrong.”
Now, Thorin does turn around. “What do you know of madness?” He demands. Ah, yes, lovely. Bilbo has deliberately placed himself on the receiving end of Thorin’s wrath out of… compassion? Love? Stupidity?
He has grown accustomed to Thorin as a figure from his past, a character in the stories Bilbo tells about his travels. He’s gotten used to the idea that Thorin will always respond the way Bilbo expects him to, will always follow the same pattern, over and over again. As Bilbo has lived a varied life, he has written and re-written and edited and re-told, watching Thorin take the same actions over and over again. But here, Thorin lives and breathes and has a mind of his own. He will respond to changes in Bilbo’s behavior, and not always in the way the Hobbit might predict.
“More than you might think,” Bilbo replies.
Can he judge Thorin for trying to kill him, all those years ago, several months in the future? After all, Bilbo himself attempted to lash out at his own nephew when he first saw the ring around Frodo’s neck. If he’d had the physical strength, if he hadn’t just handed over Sting and the mithril coat, Bilbo would likely have killed Frodo then. It is his greatest shame by far. “But that’s beside the point.”
“And what is the point, then?” Thorin is not pleased.
He’s so high strung, in this place. Hyper-vigilant, constantly aware of everything around him. Hovering on the outside, content neither to join in the singing, dancing, and communal baths enjoyed by his company nor to sit with Gandalf and Elrond at their high table. And now he is receiving unsolicited advice from a near-stranger. That is all that Bilbo is to him, here, in this place. They were not ever lovers, but whatever unspoken feelings once existed between them have not yet begun to bloom.
Bilbo considers lying, if only to ease Thorin’s obvious pain. He considers telling him that nothing will happen, that Thorin will be able to walk through Erebor’s vast halls of treasure and be completely fine, that there is no curse on his gold and no madness in his veins. But no. That would be wrong. Bilbo will not build a relationship, a friendship, a companionship, on a foundation of lies. Although, isn’t that what he’s already doing, considering he knows the future but keeps it to himself?
“You are not your grandfather,” Bilbo reminds Thorin, and he means it. “You have seen things that he couldn’t even imagine. Everybody out there,” he nods in the general direction of the hallway where the company resides, “Believes in you. I believe in you. Now, you have to start believing in yourself.”
“Oh, aye?” Thorin’s annoyance is plain, but he hasn’t walked away. He would be well within his rights to do so, but he stays.
“Anyway,” Bilbo continues, “You don’t even like Elves. Why are you so worried about what Lord Elrond thinks of you? You already have Gandalf’s support, and the support of your people, and of your Burglar, for that matter. We’ll just have to go out there and prove him wrong.”
Thorin only stares at him for a moment. Clearly, he’s not accustomed to being spoken to this way by anybody save Dwalin and perhaps Dís, but Bilbo could care less about that. His priority at the moment is stopping Thorin from getting himself killed, and though he knows it’s irrational, there’s some small part of Bilbo that wonders if perhaps… perhaps if Thorin has more confidence in himself this time around, the dragon sickness won’t affect him so badly. He fought it off before, didn’t he? He came around eventually, all on his own, while still in the Mountain with the treasure hoard. It was his decision to leave, wasn’t it? So maybe… maybe with a little bit of compassion, Bilbo can guide him around it. Lessen the impact. Something like that.But he knows he can’t bank on that kind of outcome. He can hope for the best, but Bilbo must plan for the worst.
“You are right,” Thorin decides eventually, “A credit to all Halflings that you should understand so well the burden of kingship.” His sneering tone is unmistakable. He probably thinks he’s being very clever.
Bilbo intends to put a stop to that. “You shouldn’t use that word,” he snaps, “Halfing, I mean. It’s very rude. I know diplomacy isn’t your strong suit, but you can at least make a little bit of effort. You don’t see me saying nasty things to you every time I lose an argument.” Not that Bilbo has lost any of their arguments hitherto, but he’s nice enough to keep that particular comment to himself.
“It was not my intention to offend you,” Thorin lies smoothly, showing off the diplomatic talent that must indeed have been ingrained upon him during his youth and abandoned sometime prior to his arrival in the Blue Mountains.
“Was it not? You’ve done a very good job of it, anyway.”
Thorin shakes his head. The ghost of a smile plays at his lips but straightens out quickly as he steadies himself on serious ground. “It was not my intention to offend you on the basis of your race. Had I known the connotation it carried, I’d never have said such a thing. I am sorry.”
Bilbo shakes his head. “Well, thank you.” He knows that Thorin is, at his core, a kind and honorable person, even if he uses brusqueness and poor manners as weapons of self-defense. He was almost certainly raised to distrust outsiders, and the events of his early life did very little to disabuse him of those notions. But the apology is genuine, and Bilbo knows that Thorin will never call him a halfling again.
An awkward pause passes between them. For quite a while, neither of them makes any move to fill it. They simply look at the city laid out below them, pretending as though they do not wish to say any more than they already have.
“You should go and get some sleep,” Thorin orders eventually. “You’ll only slow us down if you’re sluggish in the morning. We leave at first light.”
Eighty years ago, Bilbo might have asked what Thorin was talking about. He might have put up a fight, tried to argue in favor of restocking their supplies or taking a longer rest. But this time, he doesn’t bother. He knows that even without the prospect of interference from Wizards and Elves, even without Gandalf’s advice, Thorin would be resolute about pushing ahead. There are points to argue and points to let alone, and this, Bilbo decides, is very clearly one of the latter. So he only shrugs and turns on his heel. “Good night, Thorin,” he says, “You should get some rest, too.”
Though he knows that this, also, is a matter on which there is no debate to be had. Thorin is still out on the balcony when Bilbo falls asleep, and that is where he finds the leader of their company when he wakes up in the morning.
