Chapter Text
Thorin is unable to think straight as his company scrambles out of the Goblin tunnels. Moments ago, he was certain that they’d met their ends. He was afraid, terrified, paralyzed with fear at the thought of watching his sister-sons die. After that, Thorin figured, his own demise would be welcome. He does not think that he could go on, knowing that he’d caused harm to Fíli and Kíli. But then the Wizard arrived, and the company fought like Durin himself, reclaiming their weapons and taking advantage of the confusion caused by Tharkûn’s magic light.
It took you long enough, Thorin growled to the Wizard sometime during their escape. The twinkly-eyed smile he received in response was neither welcome nor appreciated.
They got past the goblins through some precarious blend of ingenuity and luck, and now they are clear of the Misty Mountains. No more thunder battles, no more odd caves, no more Hobbits dangling over ledges. Thorin does not know what to make of the conversation that he overheard between Master Baggins and Bofur, but he does know that he disapproves. Bofur has no business joking about receiving a favor from a Hobbit who obviously has no idea what connotations such a gift might carry in Dwarven culture. Thorin is not jealous. There is nothing for him to envy. The tightness in his chest at the thought of Master Baggins’s handkerchiefs in the pockets of his fellows must be some other breed of irritation.
It matters not. Everything Thorin does is the act of a king, and everything he says is effectively a royal decree. He is not only Thorin Oakenshield, but Thorin II, Son of Thráin, Son of Thrór, King Under the Mountain, as well. If he wishes to court, he must choose wisely, for his intended will, in effect, be courting the entire Kingdom of Erebor. Which feels foolish when at present there is no kingdom to speak of, only a distant mountain infested by a vile wyrm. And even were he not king, Thorin would not bother with such nonsense. He cannot handle another loss. Was he not resolved to avoid getting close to Master Baggins at all costs? He should not think of the Burglar as anything more than a mercenary. Courtship is entirely out of the question.
They reach a clearing, slowing to a stop. Plainly, they have not been followed. The goblins must be mourning their king, or worse, selecting a new one. Perhaps they are sounding the alarm for whatever allies they might have in these parts, sending out a signal that Thorin Oakenshield and his company have escaped their grasp.
The Wizard knows all sorts of odd passages in all sorts of odd places, and he has led them through one of these now. How he came by the details of this route, Thorin does not know and does not want to. Tharkûn-Gandalf-Mithrandir, is a strange creature bearing many names and many simultaneous errands. No doubt the Wizard was slinking around in the goblin tunnels as part of some scheme and only happened upon their company again out of chance. He was content to abandon them to the thunder battle, after all! There is no way that one so ancient and powerful could be oblivious to the hazards of the pass he sent them on.
Tharkûn conducts a head count, his finger twitching and his lips moving as he settles his gaze on each member of the company in turn. “Where’s Bilbo?” He murmurs, and suddenly, Thorin forgets his musings altogether. Louder, the Wizard demands, “Where is our Hobbit? Where is our Hobbit?”
Thorin cannot explain the feelings this question brings up. His head snaps to and fro as he glances frantically around for any sign of the Burglar. His chest tightens, his stomach sinks, and his boots, all of a sudden, seem to be filled with lead. Master Baggins is not with them.
“He’s a little fellow,” Glóin announces, as though he is an expert on the subject. “Easy enough to lose track of if you’re not careful. We should’ve had our eyes on him from the moment we fell. I thought he was with Dori!”
“Don’t blame me!” Dori yelps.
“Well, where did you last see him?” The Wizard attempts to steer the conversation in a more productive direction.
“I think I saw him slip away when they f—“ Nori begins, but Thorin cuts him off.
“He is still inside the Goblin tunnels.”
If he is alive. If he is even still alive. The thought that the Hobbit may not yet live makes Thorin’s chest constrict further. Oh, Mahal’s anvil! That hapless little creature would not have survived a confrontation with a single goblin, let alone an entire horde of them. And even if he hasn’t been confronted, he has been separated from his ridiculous pack. The Hobbit has no food, and he requires sustenance more frequently and in greater quantities than any creature that Thorin has ever known. If Master Baggins is still alive, he won’t be for much longer. He will starve to death in those tunnels. “We must return for him.”
“No, we mustn’t, laddie,” Glóin argues. “He’ll find his way out. We did.”
“There are thirteen of us,” Thorin reports, “Fourteen, counting the wizard, and we barely escaped. For our sake, he abandoned his soft bed and his warm hearth. No. We will not be leaving our Hobbit behind. He cannot be far!”
“Not we,” Dwalin protests, hand heavy on Thorin’s shoulder, offering comfort which is entirely undeserved. Thorin has failed yet again. There is more blood on his hands. Always more blood on his hands, no matter what he does. “You and the lads should stay behind with the rest of the company. The Wizard and I will go.”
Ah, yes. Thorin remembers this part well. His father, too, told him to stay behind and far from the worst of the fighting, to look after Frerin and keep him safe. Little Frerin, barely more than a child. But Thorin was proud, then, so certain of his own indestructibility. So certain that his brother would stay put when asked to do so, though Thorin refused to heed those same instructions. And how had that turned out? Thorin had been too late to save Thrór, and in his mad dash to avenge his grandfather, he’d lost track of Frerin and Thráin. One had died and the other had gone missing, and Thorin found himself, all of a sudden, the head of a bereaved family and of a people displaced. He will not make the same mistake again. He will not lose track of one of his own.
“That’s ridiculous!” Kíli protests, “Fíli and I have the best eyes here, and you all know we’re the fastest.” He speaks true.
“We’ll find Master Baggins quicker than you can, Dwalin,” Fíli agrees, “And if Thorin is staying, you should be the one to defend him. Anyway, no point keeping all the heirs in the same place. It’s better if we split up.” This, too, is true enough.
Thorin glances to Tharkûn. The Wizard shakes his head, and they come to a silent agreement. If Thorin’s sister-sons seem young to him, he cannot imagine what they must look like to Tharkûn, who has lived many lifetimes and seen many things.They are agreed, at least, that Fíli and Kíli should not be risked for this.
And Thorin can understand the logic of protecting himself, as well. He is dimly aware that were any other member of his company lost, save perhaps for his sister-sons, he would be perfectly content to send others back into the tunnels and use this time to marshal his forces and gather his wits. That is the kingly thing to do, after all.
“No. The Burglar is my responsibility,” Thorin resolves. “I must go.” This much he knows, deep in his soul.
“You must listen to Dwalin,” Balin advises, “You heard what that Great Goblin said. There’s a price on your head already. You shouldn’t go back, not now that we’ve gotten away.”
“I will go, Your Majesty,” Dori pipes in, “I should have lifted him onto my back when I had the chance. It is my fault that he isn’t with us now.”
Bifur protests vehemently against this, signing something along the lines of, Not your fault! You too were in the middle of a battle! The Hobbit did not know to look to you! As long as Thorin has known him, Bifur has struggled with the sort of quick speech necessitated by an argument such as this one. He plays to his strength, his agile crafting hands flying from word to word with practiced ease.
“We shouldn’t split the company up when we’ve just escaped,” Bombur reasons, “We know what’s behind us, and we have no clue what’s ahead of us.”
“Master Baggins is still trapped in that fell place,” Thorin growls, “I will not stand by while he suffers, alone and scared, and Mahal only knows what else!”
“No!” Comes a voice from somewhere in the trees. “No he’s not! Alone and scared, I mean.” Where just a moment ago, Thorin could have sworn there was nothing but thin air, Master Baggins materializes. He seems to flicker into existence all of a sudden, a round little Hobbit appearing from nowhere.
It must be the light and the relief playing tricks on Thorin. The Hobbit must have simply come out from behind a tree. “Mister Baggins!” Kíli yells, running up and throwing his arms around the Burglar. “We were just about to go back for you.”
“No, you weren’t,” Thorin tells his nephew sharply. “I was.”
He needs to make this clear. He does not want Fíli and Kíli thinking that they have won this argument, that they will ever win this argument. Thorin refuses to put his boys in danger when it can be avoided. Not after what happened during the thunder battle.
And furthermore, he wishes for the Hobbit to know that Thorin would be the one to take responsibility for him, to protect him. He will personally see to the safety of every member of his company. This fire in his chest cannot be envy. What concern is it of Thorin’s if Master Baggins wishes to embrace Kíli? The Hobbit slips out of Kíli’s grip and is immediately scooped up into Fíli’s arms. Thorin decides that the wisest course of action is to look away.
Besides, it is true, what Master Baggins guessed in the cave. Thorin did not mean what he said before they made their camp. He would not have the Hobbit thinking that he has no place among them, or even that the leader of their company believes as much. Master Baggins is odd, and Thorin would not accuse him of bearing any skill with that knife of his (he still insists upon calling it a sword!), but the Hobbit has proven his loyalty and devotion. If he did not believe Thorin to be a fine king, he’d never have said as much.
Or, perhaps Thorin only wishes to believe that Master Baggins approves of him. Why? He has no reason to seek the approval of one so strange. He has no reason to seek the approval of anyone at all! And yet, here he is.
“You all thought I was lost in the goblin tunnels,” Master Baggins grins. His teeth are straight and well cared-for, his lips a fine shape. His skin glows golden from time spent in the sun. “And you were bickering about who’d have the honor of saving me?”
“Yes,” Ori agrees, ever honest. “That’s exactly what happened.”
“Well, in all the time you wasted doing that,” the Burglar announces, “I managed to save myself. Though I did lose a few buttons along the way. Dreadful, really, and I didn’t even think to stop and pick them up! Such a terrible thing to happen to my favorite waistcoat! I should never have brought it. And I knew this was coming, too! Why didn’t I bring something more practical? That old brown one would’ve done just fine, no matter what I may have looked like. I’m sure I make a pretty picture now!” Yes, he does.
Thorin is pleased to learn that his Hobbit at least as some basic survival instincts, though this joy is tempered by the discussion of waistcoats. “Are you injured?”
Master Baggins blinks at him. “No,” he replies, allowing the word to trail off into silence as though he is expecting Thorin to say more. “Aren’t you going to ask me why I came back?” The Hobbit inquires when the silence becomes uncomfortable.
Thorin considers this strange question. “Why would I ask that? You have proven several times that you will not leave us, even when it’s in your best interests to do so.” It stings a little to think that his burglar doubts him so. “Though of course, we would not have abandoned you in those tunnels.”
Master Baggins scrunches up his nose as though he is working through a particularly difficult puzzle. The expression suits him. Apparently, Thorin’s words were a shock to the Hobbit, which makes little sense. Has Thorin not proven himself to be an honorable king? Has he not made it clear that he is personally responsible for every member of his company, even those fools who go rushing off to place themselves in danger? Evidently not.
Balin, thankfully, has the sense to interrupt whatever is taking place between Thorin and his Burglar. “I must say, Bilbo, you’re the first person ever to get past my lookout. How did you ever manage that?”
Before the Hobbit can begin to explain, Bofur cuts in. “He slipped past while you were busy nagging His Majesty, of course. Wouldn’t’ve gotten past you if you’d been facing the right way, there, Balin.”
“He makes a good point,” Thorin concedes.
“Aye,” says Óin, though Mahal only knows how he heard Thorin’s mumbling. Perhaps he’s responding to Bofur’s exclamation, which would be difficult even for one with Óin’s poor hearing to miss. “If you’d not been arguing against the will of our mighty king, you’d have seen the wee Hobbit sneaking past.”
“I doubt it,” Master Baggins chirps. His left hand is poised just outside his pocket, as though he dares not slip it in but knows nothing else to do with it. So very comely, but so very strange. That much, at least, has not changed during his brief separation from the company. “I can be very sneaky when I need to be. Isn’t that what you hired me for? Now, if you don’t mind, I’d like something to eat before we start running again. Does anyone have anything on them?”
He sounds awfully sure that they’ll be on the move again in short order, but Thorin doesn’t get a chance to press any further on this matter, because the moment he opens his mouth, he is interrupted by an awful howl that chills him to the bone. Wargs. Several of them, if the responding howls are anything to go on.
“Out of the frying pan,” Thorin huffs.
“And into the fire,” the Wizard, annoyingly, takes it upon himself to finish the turn of phrase.
“So much for elevensies,” says Master Baggins. His terror is palpable despite his best efforts to conceal it. “We’d best be off.”
Thorin, at least, can agree with that sentiment. “Run!” He orders. None of his companions need to be told twice.
Bilbo knows exactly what’s about to happen, of course. He was distracted from this inevitability by his conversation with Gollum, by the active recall necessary to escape with his life. Then, he was distracted by the ring on his finger, and the oddness of the exchange with Thorin when Bilbo finally caught up to the company.
The first time, Thorin was convinced that Bilbo had abandoned them at the earliest opportunity, and he hadn’t been entirely incorrect. Bilbo’s initial plan, as expressed quite clearly to Bofur, had been to abandon the company and return to Rivendell. He’d felt scorned, and overcome with self-doubt, and Elrond had offered him solace before the company departed. It all made perfect sense. Thorin was baffled by Bilbo’s return, and, Bilbo now suspects, the lack of control engendered by his imperfect understanding of the Hobbit caused no small degree of irritation for the king.
This time, however, Thorin seemed baffled by the implication that he might question Bilbo’s motives. Which, no doubt, Bilbo would happily spend a good few hours unpacking, were he not running for his life. Cocky words aside, Bilbo understands the danger that they face better than anybody else does. He is conscious of his place within the company, who’s around him as he tries to reconcile this sensory data with his memory of who was near to him before. This proves more difficult than he would have thought. The first time, Bilbo was too distracted by the wargs on his tail to worry much about where he was relative to his friends.
Now, Bilbo is distracted by the racing of his heart. He cannot settle his thoughts. He cannot stop his limbs from trembling as he forces his tired legs to run onward, dodging wargs and the fights that engage his companions. He does not know the last time he ate, nor the last time he slept, but it does not matter now. He’ll run or die. And he can’t die, not when the fate of Middle Earth sits in his pocket and the fate of the Line of Durin rests in his hands. Bilbo must keep his wits about him. Only he feels that he may vomit, and his legs are buzzing, and his head spins at an impossible speed.
Thorin dispatches a warg with Orcrist. Gandalf swings his staff and knocks a few of their assailants aside. Bilbo knows that the orcs are only biding their time, setting their beasts on the company to tire them out before the actual challenge takes place. He does not think before joining the fray. The last time, Bilbo was unsure, unaware of how to defend himself from the wargs. Now, he slashes with Sting, fending off a few of the beasts, though it would take too much of his strength to actually kill one. He cannot help but notice the way the others leap to his defense.
Glóin steps between Bilbo and an oversized warg, and while the creature is distracted, Bifur finishes it off. Ori shoots one in the eye with a rock at close range, and though the beast does not die, it whimpers and steps back, giving Bilbo a chance to weave away. Fíli throws a knife that lands in the neck of a warg, and seems inclined to retrieve the weapon, before Balin grabs him by the arm and drags him away. Good. At least one member of the company has some sense. For his own part, Bilbo feels the sudden urge to dry-heave. Because he alone knows what is coming.
Once again, the Wizard leads them to a grove of fir trees overlooking a cliff. There is no other option. The orcs and their wargs have herded the company here on purpose. There is no escape, or, at least, none that Azog can foresee. “Up into the trees!” Gandalf orders. “All of you! Come on, climb!”
Even with his foreknowledge, Bilbo is unprepared for the warg that comes after him next. Reflexively, he stabs it with Sting, burying his sword in its brain. The creature’s end is quick, thank Yavanna, and when it falls to the ground, Bilbo is left to struggle with the blade. He has a distinct recollection of doing this the first time around, as well. “Hurry, Master Baggins!” Thorin yells. He’s already gotten himself up into a tree, as have the rest of the company. “More are coming!”
“I can see that!” Bilbo snaps, all nerves. He’s not going to stand there like a lamb in the road, the way he did the last time. And yet, seeing all those wargs coming, he doubts himself.
Bilbo really should have done something. Couldn’t he have warned the others, rather than leaning against a tree and acting all smug about his relative utility? No. He couldn’t have. Thorin may feel differently about him this time around, at least at this juncture, but no revolutionary change has taken place. If Bilbo had attempted to steer the company elsewhere, he’d surely have started an argument with the king or the Wizard or both at once. Then, they all would’ve gotten their throats ripped out by wargs. But, even so. Bilbo could have come forward earlier. He did not need to spend so long lurking in the shadows, listening to his companions’ conversation. It’s just that he was utterly mesmerized by Thorin’s insistence upon rescuing the Burglar. That certainly didn’t happen the last time.
“This way, Master Baggins.” Dori urges, ripping him from his thoughts. “You must climb!”
Bilbo must look horrible. He must be shaking. Azog the Defiler is coming this way. The monster from Bilbo’s nightmares is coming this way. “Up you go,” Bofur encourages him with a false smile, which Bilbo cannot even bring himself to return as he scrambles over the branches. He has no choice.
It is the same tree again, because once more, Bilbo is the last of the company to make it to this place. He might be faster, were he in better condition, but as it stands, he can barely stand. His stomach is a pit which threatens to implode or overflow with bile. His hands are useless, jittering. His mind is a mess. Bilbo can barely sort out where he is right now, can only gag on air as the orcs approach.
Yes, they’ve fallen out of the frying pan and into the fire, but at least Bilbo can expect the metaphorical fork of an Eagle’s talons to scoop him up with minimal burning. Still, the writhing in his guts intensifies at the thought that he’s just led Thorin to a serious injury. Because last time, Bilbo could be excused for allowing this to happen. This time, however, Bilbo knows. He knows that Thorin will challenge Azog, that there is nothing he can do to stop it. He knows what the warg will do to their king. He knows the expression on the pale orc’s face, smug and gloating. Bilbo knows all of it, but can do nothing to prevent it from happening a second time
And, as the small rational voice clinging on for dear life inside his mind is only too happy to remind him, it would not be wise for Bilbo to alter the sequence of events by intervening earlier. Azog might kill him, and then where would he be? Or, even worse, Azog could see him coming and….
As expected, Azog makes his presence known, leading his warg mount forward at a leisurely place. “Azog,” Thorin breathes, shocked.
Right. Until this moment, he believed Azog to be long dead. The pale orc delivers what is sure to be a very threatening little speech in his own tongue, which seems a bit counterintuitive to Bilbo. After all, none of the company could possibly understand it, save, perhaps Gandalf. Though if Bilbo put the ring on… he would know everything that Azog was saying, wouldn’t he? Just as he could understand the spiders, just as Frodo could understand the orcs in Mordor, Bilbo could understand the words of Azog the Defiler. He could use this knowledge to protect his friends.
“It cannot be,” says Thorin. And who is Bilbo, to have kept this information from him? To have led him here? To have allowed him to face this threat once again?
Azog shouts, something unseemly, no doubt, and the wargs charge forwards, pawing at the trunks of the trees and snapping their jaws at the members of the company. Nobody does anything. Why does nobody do anything? Bilbo shakes with rage. A few extra moments would not have helped them. They’d only end up cornered here on this ridiculous cliff once again. The trees tip, one by one, forcing Bilbo’s friends to leap to the one fir that remains standing, right on the edge of the cliff. Just like last time. Exactly like last time.
Azog cackles. Bilbo hates him. Never in all his life has he felt such disgust, such anger, such terror. Never in all his life has he wanted so badly to harm another living creature. Hobbits are a gentle and peaceful folk, but perhaps that’s because they do not, as a rule, have their loved ones murdered by orc lords. All Bilbo can see is Thorin’s eyes, blank, staring at nothing. All he can feel is a cold hand clutched in his own. And Azog has the nerve to laugh.
A flaming fir cone falls into Bilbo’s hands. Right. Bilbo doesn’t have time to waste on the horrific images that he’s repressed for eighty years. He’s got to stay present in this fight, because he’s got to win it, for Thorin’s sake and the sake of the company. Bilbo has to do everything exactly as he did it before, which didn’t seem like such a major challenge at all when he was making his to-do list in Bag End. He wrote about this, after all.
He thought he’d been reliving his adventure over and over again for eight decades, but he was wrong. He did not mention this part. He implied that they just sat in the trees waiting for rescue, listening to a scary song. He did not write about the feeling of plunging his sword into the body of another being, of taking a life. He did not write about standing in front of Thorin, motionless on the ground, fearing that the king was dead. Now, he forces himself to stay aware of Thorin’s every movement, even as Bilbo throws down flaming cones at the orcs and wargs.
At first, the orcs hiss and grumble amongst themselves; the wargs howl and yelp. It looks as though the company is winning. But Bilbo cannot join in the cheer. He can do nothing but force air into and out of his lungs as the tree begins to fall, until it is nothing more than an extension of the cliff. Ori loses his grip on the branch he’s been perched upon and falls, clinging for dear life to his eldest brother’s legs. Then, the orcs seem to cheer up a bit. More of that horrible laughter, more of that horrible speech.
Nothing they are saying is anything like the little tune Bilbo composed for his book about fifteen birds in five fir trees. It makes him sick to his stomach, which he’s certain is the intended effect. Or perhaps the illness comes from watching Thorin set his shoulders as he makes his inevitable decision: he will go out and face the Defiler. Bilbo is going to vomit. He’s going to combust. He throws his last fir cone and it hits a warg, but that means nothing, nothing at all. One orc incapacitated for a moment will not change what is to come.
Bilbo knows by now that Thorin has never taken anything laying down. If there’s an opportunity for a fight, Thorin will leap to it, even if wiser folk might deem the odds insurmountable. There was never any chance of Thorin hanging back and letting the orcs taunt the company. This time, Bilbo is ready, prepared to spring into action when he’s needed. He forces himself to wait, though his limbs are twitching with the need to leap down and rush to Thorin’s aid.
The king steps forward, walking across the broken trunk of the tree with determination. Bilbo focuses on his hair, long and lovely, even after the storm and the fall and the trip through the goblin tunnels. He focuses on the way that Thorin grips his sword, the tight hold he keeps on the shield that gave him his name. They got through this before. Thorin lived through this before. Bilbo cannot prevent this. He must allow Thorin to act. He cannot steal this moment from him. He cannot become a distraction for Thorin, not here, not now.
Azog has not taken his eyes off of Thorin. Oh, but it would be so easy! Bilbo knows now what the ring can do. He could slip out of this tree, entirely unseen. He could go up to Azog and stab him in the gut with Sting. No, worse. Bilbo could do worse. He wears a Ring of Power, does he not? Could he not use that power to destroy the orc, slowly and painfully? It is all that the bastard deserves. Better than he deserves, actually.
Bilbo would take his time. He would draw it out. He’d go as slowly as possible, and the power of the ring could help him. Could keep the other orcs at bay. Bilbo would make them watch, would make them see what happens to meddling creatures who dare to lay their hands on his beloved. He’ll make Azog beg him for death. The ring has the power to do all of this, and it is at Bilbo’s command, and that would solve his problem, wouldn’t it? There would be no Ravenhill to speak of if only Bilbo could put a stop to it now.
No. No. No, absolutely not. Bilbo cannot take that risk. He has not only his friends to think of but Middle Earth as well. He’s got to destroy the ring, and if he tries to do it that way, who knows the kind of grip that it could get on him? Thorin survived this last time because Bilbo defended him. Would he still survive whatever awful power Bilbo might release upon the orcs? Would Bilbo himself survive? Thorin is so close to Azog now. Bilbo is losing time. He must go. He must help. He must do something.
Thorin breaks into a run, and Azog spurs his warg on in turn. The beast knocks the king to the ground easily, so easily. The pale orc draws back, circling, giving Thorin time to sit up. Because how could a single sword and a wooden shield defend anyone against the wrath of an entire pack of wargs, led by a contingent of warrior orcs? Thorin is alone down there. Time will not help him.
Not yet. Not yet. Not yet. Bilbo must do exactly what he did before. He cannot stop thinking about that icy day on Ravenhill, cannot stop remembering over and over again a scene he did not witness. He has no idea how Azog killed Thorin, let alone how Thorin killed Azog. For the first few days, all he could do was torture himself, trying to imagine the logistics of it all. The sword tearing through all that armor into the tender flesh of his beloved. Bilbo gags. He can’t help it. It’s just as bad as it has been every night at camp, only worse, because now Bilbo knows that the danger is real. Azog’s mace strikes a mighty blow to Thorin’s chest, and Bilbo feels himself moving into the fray before he realizes what is happening.
He forgets his plan to wait, to hesitate just as he did when he was still unsure of whether he might be prepared to die for Thorin. He forgets all about the ring and his mission and his list of five tasks. Now, Bilbo knows that he would give his life for Thorin in a heartbeat. That he will give his life for Thorin right this minute, if he has to. Bilbo can see nothing but Thorin, bleeding, picked up and shaken between the jaws of a warg, and nothing else matters.
“Almost there, my love,” Bilbo snarls. Such sweet words he has never allowed himself to speak, said now in such a foul tone. Thorin will live. Thorin must live.
Bilbo is vaguely aware of shouting behind him, but he can’t make out what anyone is saying, can’t even parse what language they’re speaking. It may as well all be Khuzdul, for how little he comprehends. He’s unaware of the ground beneath his feet; it feels as though he’s floating on air, carried by a vengeful wind, faster than before, desperate. His body becomes the weapon, an extension of Sting, a projectile. Bilbo does not need to push himself because every fiber of his being is in perfect, harmonious agreement: protect Thorin at all costs.
He keeps seeing Thorin dead, laying on that ice. The great blood stain beneath him, all over his clothes, and all over Bilbo, too. His hands, his coat, his face. Because he refused to believe that Thorin was gone until he confirmed that he could not hear a heartbeat, and even then, he kept talking to him, kept begging him to stay, as though he might hear and turn around, deferring his journey to the halls of his Maker. Bilbo kissed him, only on the forehead, in the manner of Hobbits, as was perfectly appropriate following a death. The skin was cold. Thorin’s hand had carried the imprints of Bilbo’s tight grip even at the funeral. Nobody said a word.
Still, Bilbo begged. Begged as he had never done before and has never done since. He pleaded with the Valar. He offered his own life in exchange for Thorin’s, any service he could possibly give, so senseless was he with grief. All that blood. What a stupid, useless waste, and there was nothing Bilbo could do to fix it. Nothing anyone could do but throw together the funeral arrangements and go home to the safety of the Shire, where there was never any battlefield to get slaughtered upon.
Azog delivers an order, and another orc dismounts, steps toward Thorin with blade raised. But the Hobbit is already there. Bilbo wails, cries, screams, releases the sound of grief and rage that has been living in his body since Ravenhill. He drives Sting into the neck of the orc meters away from Thorin, who is laying on the ground, covered in blood. Dead.
Dead again, and Bilbo was too late. Dead, as he always was; this must only be a dream, because Bilbo watched Thorin die, and how could anyone come back to life after having bled out? Dead on the ice, dead on the grass, dead on a stone slab. Bilbo stabs the orc again, spattering its blood all over his face. The stuff tastes foul, but he repeats the motion once more and pulls back, panting. Bilbo rises, Sting twitching to and fro in his vibrating hands.
Azog has the nerve to laugh. He says something else in that awful tongue of his. The other orcs seem to find this uproariously funny. How funny will it be for them when their leader has Sting buried in his neck? An order is delivered.
The Hobbit has no clue why he is not dead yet, why he has been permitted to carry out his little production. And he does not care. If the orcs wish to underestimate him, they will do so at their peril. Next, he will kill Azog the Defiler. Slowly, painfully, brutally. He will have vengeance. If he cannot have Thorin, if he cannot keep his king safe, cannot keep the lads safe, then at the very least he will have this.
Bilbo rushes forward, keeping his own small body between the orc and the king. This is the creature that killed Thorin. Bilbo will not allow the orc to survive. He drives his sword into the snout of the Warg the pale orc mounts. Azog looks shocked, for one brief moment. He must have expected Bilbo to lay down in despair and wait for the creature to gobble him up. Bilbo yanks with all his might, unable to withdraw Sting from the head of the warg as Azog raises his mace. Bilbo scrambles backwards in the nick of time as the orc slides off his falling mount.
The other wargs are closing in. Bilbo positions himself between Thorin and the orc, though now he has no weapon to speak of. He will die, then. He will fail once more. But he has failed already. He does not need to turn around to see Thorin laying on the ice behind him, dead. So close to his home, reclaimed, empty, waiting for him, but it did not matter in the end. And the poor princes, barely more than children, murdered by this evil orc and his wicked son.
“You will not touch him!” Bilbo screams, vicious. A tone that he has never used before, never needed to. He is no longer a respectable Hobbit, only a vague assemblage of grief and terror and rage. Azog advances, mace raised. Bilbo picks up a stone, prepared to make use of his prodigious throwing skills. Even if he can’t protect himself, he can at least go down protecting Thorin. “Stay back!”
And then Bilbo is on the ground with something heavy laying over him. He fights furiously, throwing his elbows, trying to reach Sting. The blade is too far away.
“Thorin lives,” A familiar voice. Kíli. But Kíli has been dead for eighty years. Bilbo saw him, dead on the ice, dead on the stone slab. And yet he can feel how warm the lad is, how vital, how utterly and completely alive as he shelters Bilbo with his body. Bilbo stills, then, breathing heavily. Kíli eases off of him with surprising grace. “We must defend him!”
The whole exchange takes only a few seconds, and Bilbo struggles to understand what has happened. Kíli hauls him to his feet, pushes Bilbo behind him. He drags the Hobbit toward the fallen warg and frees Sting with a single tug. The blade is a mess. So much blood. That is another thing Bilbo did not write about: the blood. “Master Baggins, go!” Kíli urges, passing Sting to Bilbo. Somehow, unbeknownst to the Hobbit, this has become a proper battle.
Fíli, Nori, and Dwalin have engaged Azog and driven him back, forcing him away from Bilbo. They must have mounted their attack just after Kíli knocked Bilbo out of the way, which was very good thinking, indeed. Those members of the company who have been able to get out of the trees are fighting the orcs off, keeping them far from Thorin, but Bilbo is needed as the last line of defense. Only a few moments until the Eagles arrive. But the Eagles are always too late. Bilbo is still trembling, ready to drive his blade through the eye of anyone who even dreams of touching his king.
He rushes to Thorin, and Kíli covers him, drawing his bow, firing expertly at the orcs and somehow managing to avoid shooting the other members of the company. Bilbo would be impressed if he weren’t so preoccupied. Thorin is right there, so close, his shield having rolled away from him and his sword still clutched in his hand. Bloody. Breathing. Breathing. Bilbo watches their leader’s chest rise and fall in ragged disarray. This is not Ravenhill. Or maybe it is.
Bilbo remembers doing this before, running to Thorin’s side, watching with naive hope as the king drew breath. In and out, shaky and violent, but Bilbo had taken it to mean that Thorin would survive. And he had not. He died in Bilbo’s arms. His blood stained Bilbo’s clothes and his mind and his soul. And now it is happening again; it is all happening again; Bilbo has failed once more because he is weak and unworthy. Because once again, he was not fast enough. He falls to his knees with a loud sob. Dead. Thorin Oakenshield is dead.
“On your feet!” Kíli orders, hauling Bilbo back up before loosing another arrow. This one falls short of its mark, hitting a tree instead, and Bilbo stands still, on the verge of another collapse. “We fight!” Kíli follows this with a Khuzdul phrase, vaguely familiar, a battle cry. His next arrow finds its home in the forehead of an orc.
Thorin is already dead. Thorin has been dead for eighty years. Bilbo cannot force himself to breathe. And then an Eagle swoops down from above and catches Thorin, ever so gently, in its talons. “The eagles are coming,” Bilbo whispers. “Thorin, the eagles.” Exactly what he said the last time, and what good did it do then?
“Leave him alone!” Kíli roars at the Eagle.
Bilbo sobs. He is in no position to comfort anybody, but he has no choice. He doesn’t get to fail. He doesn’t get to resign himself to despair. Kíli is still very much alive, and Thorin is breathing, and, Bilbo reminds himself this is not Ravenhill. This is not Ravenhill. This is not Ravenhill.
Bilbo looks around him and sees his friends fighting tooth and nail. Those who could get out of the trees to fight have done so, but where are Dori and Ori? Gandalf? And what can Bilbo do for any of them? What can Bilbo do but stand and watch? He may be covered in blood, but he has proven that there is nothing he can do to prevent the horrors he has endured from coming, once again, to pass. Nothing is different. Nothing has changed.
“Hush,” he says, voice creaky, torn asunder by his earlier scream. “They’re friends, Kíli. The Eagles, they’re our friends.” Seeing what’s coming, Bilbo steps away from Kíli, giving the Eagles more space to safely lift the two of them to safety. His legs nearly give out as he does so.
Bilbo goes completely slack as an Eagle grabs him, then, and drops him onto the back of one of its comrades. Kíli does not seem particularly pleased about being picked off the ground and tossed around, Bilbo notes, but at least he does not attempt to stab at the Eagle with his sword. For his part, Bilbo cannot look away from Thorin. Even as the Eagles carry them over rolling green hills, past waterfalls and splendid trees, Bilbo keeps his eyes on the king.
A few of the others call out to their leader, but the Hobbit does not bother. He knows that, just like last time, Thorin will not respond. Bilbo tries to use logic to comfort himself: yes, this fight was different from the original, yes, Bilbo’s timing was all wrong, but that should not have changed anything for Thorin, because he was already on the ground when Bilbo charged at Azog. The Eagles must have showed up at the exact same time as they did when this battle last took place. And they still have Gandalf with them; he can still heal Thorin when the time comes.
But Bilbo’s heart refuses to listen to his head. It is an active struggle to stay away from Ravenhill and the days that followed, to keep the pain at bay as Bilbo is carried to safety. He is not severely injured, but he is covered in orc blood. His breathing is rough, labored, and he is trembling something awful. When the Eagle finally sets him down on solid ground, Bilbo does not hesitate to rush toward his love.
Bilbo wants nothing more than to shove Gandalf out of the way and check that his beloved is breathing. Thorin is just laying there, his back pressed to the stone just as it was at his funeral. Bilbo can’t stop seeing him, face waxy, eyes closed, hands posed deliberately. The company carried out Dwarven funeral rites about which Bilbo had not asked, too preoccupied was he with sobbing and lamenting and blaming himself. If he’d gotten to Ravenhill faster, Fíli would have been spared and could have protected Kíli. Thorin would not have been so flippant with his own life if he’d believed that his sister-sons still lived.
That is not true. Thorin died believing that Kíli was alive. Bilbo could have saved the lads, had he been faster, yes. But that would not have helped Thorin. Nothing would have helped Thorin save sticking a sword through Azog’s heart, and Bilbo has missed his chance to do so. The next time he sees the orc, it will be too late. And that, too, is Bilbo’s fault. Just like every other horrid thing.
Bilbo forces himself to stand back and let the Wizard work. He reminds himself that this is not that part of the journey, this is too early, he did everything right. He did everything he was supposed to, and the Valar have favored him, and he was promised more time with Thorin. Galadriel showed him visions of Erebor, himself and Thorin and the lads in Erebor. So it will not end here. It isn’t happening again. Still, Bilbo cannot calm his breathing, not even as Fíli’s hand comes down on his shoulder, light and comforting. Sweaty, though, and nearly as twitchy as Bilbo’s own hands are at the moment.
Knowing that the prince is present and alive helps Bilbo nevertheless. “Steady, Master Baggins,” Fíli counsels, his voice strained. “Thorin will be alright. Gandalf knows what he’s doing.”
“He’s fine,” Kíli agrees, materializing off to the side. “He’ll be fine.” Though he sounds rattled, and he looks pale.
This certainly did not happen before. Bilbo had thought that he was close with Fíli and Kíli the first time around, but now, it’s clear to him that they were holding back. By giving them his trust and his care, by sharing his food with them, by laughing at their jokes, Bilbo has proven himself as a friend, and they both seem resolved to look after him. Oh, by the Valar! Kíli saved Bilbo’s life a moment ago, and Bilbo didn’t even say ‘thank you.’ And he must have elbowed the poor boy more than once, with all his thrashing and struggling! Where are Bilbo’s manners?
But then Gandalf finishes his ministrations, and Thorin stirs, and Bilbo forgets that the two of them are not alone together in this place.
Thorin is breathing. That simple fact makes Bilbo stagger with relief, his sore muscles catching up with him. Every fiber of his being, now, seems to be rebelling in protest against all the running and leaping and being tackled to the ground. But Thorin is alive. Bilbo watches as the king’s chest rises and falls, and then, to his immense relief, Thorin sits up. “Master Baggins?” He asks, sounding just a little bit frantic. Last time, he had asked after the Halfling. Clearly, he has learned his lesson on the score.
“It’s alright. Bilbo is here. He’s quite safe,” Gandalf assures Thorin. That seems a bit premature, considering Bilbo is covered in orc blood and trembling like a leaf, but he supposes that compared to Thorin, yes, he is fine. A few sore muscles will mend in no time, and his clothes can be washed.
Thorin pushes Gandalf aside and rises, making his way over to Bilbo in a few quick strides. That seems inadvisable, in his condition. Bilbo remembers well the last time that they had this conversation. He remembers Thorin confronting him, outright yelling at him, saying some very rude things, before contradicting himself with a smile and pulling the Hobbit into a hug.
Bilbo braces himself, but there is no yelling whatsoever. Thorin throws his arms around Bilbo far too early, and Fíli steps back, allowing the Hobbit to collapse a little into Thorin’s embrace. He smells of smoke, of blood, of earth, of battle, and under all of that, he smells of himself. Bilbo cannot help but cling to him, cannot help but breathe in their leader’s scent. He feels as though he has finally come home, more than he did in Bag End. He feels as though the story has ended, as though everything has come full circle. Oh, yes, this is worth reliving everything for. Bilbo never, in his long years of life, would have expected to be granted the opportunity to hold Thorin in his arms once again.
Of course, after a time, Thorin pulls away, and Bilbo reluctantly lets him go. “Do not do anything so foolish ever again, Master Burglar,” Thorin advises, with his typical blunt formality. Well, Bilbo can’t have expected that his kindness would produce any monumental change. Things are different, sure, but Thorin has still endured the same lifetime of hardship. “You won’t always be so lucky.”
Unfortunately, Bilbo, too, is still the same Hobbit that he always was. He’s not one to take orders, especially not ridiculous ones from monarchs who could learn to take their own advice. “I’ll do plenty more foolish things, Thorin Oakenshield,” he promises, “If it keeps you from getting yourself killed.”
Thorin looks into Bilbo’s eyes. His expression is complex, warm and cold at once, holding years of pain along with whatever affection and hope he’s managed to muster up over the course of their journey together. Bilbo must remind himself that though he has known Thorin for eight decades, Thorin has known him for only a few months. “I owe you my life,” the king murmurs. Ever so gently, he brushes his thumb across Bilbo’s cheek, wiping away the blood. Smearing it, probably.
It’s all very dramatic, but Bilbo is not interested in any form of debt. Even the first time around, he’d have jumped in front of an orc to defend any member of the company. Now, he’d do it without hesitation. “Don’t be ridiculous,” Bilbo scolds him, “You owe me absolutely nothing.”
They stay that way for a moment, studying one another, much closer together than would be considered necessary in polite society. Bilbo isn’t quite certain whether this counts as a standoff or not, but whatever it is, it is charged. He wants to kiss Thorin, or to push him away and scream at him for being so reckless, for scaring Bilbo so much. He wants to break down crying, to grab Thorin by the hand and lead him back to the Blue Mountains where he can be safe. He wants to charge toward Erebor and take it back to see the glow in Thorin’s eyes as they come home.
“Alright, that’s enough,” Óin announces with typical gusto. Apparently, their resident healer has gotten tired of watching the emotional exchange. “Both of you, go sit down so I can look at you.”
“I’m fine,” Bilbo assures him, at the same time that Thorin grits out, “That is not necessary.” Still, Thorin steps away from Bilbo, suddenly conscious of their many spectators.
“I won’t hear it,” Óin declares, and he seems to mean it, too, because his trumpet is a mangled mess. “You, laddie,” he gestures at Bilbo, “Can barely stand up, and you,” he turns his attention to Thorin, “Are lucky to be alive at all, my King. You are both in serious need of medical attention.”
Thorin grumbles about this, but Bilbo cuts him off. “He’s right, you know. I didn’t save your life so you could throw it away again for lack of care. Since you won’t look after yourself, it’s down to Óin and I.”
The King rolls his eyes. “As you wish,” he huffs, as though it is some great hardship to have his wounds seen to. “Though you are also injured.” Ah. He’s being self-sacrificing, then, and implying that Bilbo should be looked at first.
“Cheer up,” Bilbo orders. “I’m perfectly alright.” Well, aside from the ache in his side, the twinge in his shoulder, the wobble in his step, and those few minutes where all sense abandoned him and he attempted to face Azog the Defiler with only a throwing stone for a weapon. But Bilbo is no stranger to aches and pains, and though he may be covered in blood, not a drop of it is his own. Óin should see to Thorin first. “And look behind you. There’s your Erebor, waiting up ahead.”
The thing is that Bilbo is still, perhaps, not thinking straight. If he’d been in his right mind, he would’ve realized that pointing out the silhouette of Erebor on the horizon would have a profound effect on the entire company.
“Oh, bless me,” Bofur mutters, “That really is the Lonely Mountain.”
“Aye,” says Balin with palpable reverence, “That it is.”
“Erebor,” Dori breathes, gripping Ori’s hand. Shockingly, Nori joins their little huddle, taking Dori’s other hand without comment.
“Our home,” Thorin murmurs.
Bifur whispers something reverent in Khuzdul, and not for the first time, Bilbo wishes he could understand. “Strength, cousin,” Bombur counsels. “Strength.”
A bird flits by, just as it did the last time. Bilbo wonders absently if it is indeed the same bird. “A raven!” Óin exclaims, apparently having forgotten all about his wounded king. Yes this is a significant moment and all, but there are other relevant concerns as well! “The birds are returning to the mountain!”
“That, my dear Óin, is a thrush,” Gandalf observes mildly. He, too, seems to have forgotten about Thorin’s many injuries. Honestly. It’s a wonder they ever managed to get to Erebor at all, the first time around. Bilbo is the only person here with even a lick of common sense.
“But we’ll take it as a sign,” Thorin says, turning to Bilbo with a small smile. “A good omen.” Oh, the joy in those brilliant blue eyes of his! The love for his home which shines so brightly, the hope that the journey from this point will be smooth. Thorin is wrong, of course.
Putting aside the remainder of their harrowing trip, only Bilbo knows what lies inside the Lonely Mountain. Only Bilbo has any clue of all the horrible things that will happen to them there, how painful it will be for everyone to witness Thorin’s decline. Although… things are different now, aren’t they? Thorin has already been behaving differently, showing Bilbo much more warmth. Isn’t it possible that things might be different once they reach Erebor, as well? That Thorin might be better able to resist the pull of the gold with Bilbo’s support?
But that is foolish wishful thinking. Bilbo can hope for the best to his heart’s content, but he knows full well that he is also obligated to plan for the worst. “Okay, that’s plenty,” Bilbo announces, addressing an enraptured Óin, “His Majesty is wounded, remember?”
“See to Master Baggins first,” Thorin orders. Unfortunately, he is no match for an irate Hobbit, which he should know well by now.
“Don’t you dare,” Bilbo shoots a glare in Óin’s direction.
By the grace of the Green Lady, this is not Óin’s first time tending to the wounded following a battle, nor is it his first time managing a surly monarch. He is Thorin’s cousin, after all, and probably well accustomed to his moods. “Sit yourself down, now, lad, and let me get a look at you.” Given that Thorin has been demoted from my King to lad in a matter of minutes, Óin must share Bilbo’s conviction about whose injuries are most serious.
The Hobbit makes to walk away in triumph, but apparently, the healer’s reign of terror has only just begun. “And don’t you be going anywhere, now, Master Burglar. You’re next. Not another step until I’ve checked you over, understand?” And Bilbo finds that he is too tired to argue as he settles onto the warm stone of the Carrock.
The walk from the Carrock is far longer than Bilbo remembers it being. Perhaps this is because he is in no small amount of pain. Now that he’s had a chance to calm down and been seen to by Óin, he can report that his back aches, as do his legs, as does his sword-arm. His head is pounding, as well, and no wonder, when his sleeping and eating have been so poor and so erratic as of late, not to mention recent events. Perhaps it is just his imagination, but the ring feels like a rock in his pocket, and it takes genuine concentration to keep from reaching inside and running his fingers over it.
Last time, Bilbo remembers marching through this segment of the journey in a near-euphoric haze. Finally, he’d proved himself to Thorin Oakenshield and earned some measure of the king’s respect. And that embrace had merited not a single complaint, Bilbo can say now with certainty.
This time, though, it felt much different. To be held in those strong arms once again, to rest his face against that warm, broad chest. The last time, Bilbo was baffled, hesitant. It took him a moment to realize what was going on. This time, he threw his arms around Thorin, in turn, taking care not to agitate the king’s injuries. If only Óin had not ruined the moment! Bilbo could have stayed there all day, all night, for the rest of time.
But they are in the middle of a quest, and the Eagles have been kind, but Bilbo knows better than anyone that they are not out of the woods yet. They’ve got a head start, and they should make use of it. They must get to Beorn’s hall, where Thorin can recover from his wounds, where all of them can catch up on sleep and get something to eat. They cannot delay. Bilbo might’ve liked to soak his waistcoat in warm water, at least, in a vain attempt to get the blood out of it, but that will have to wait until they are safe. Any fire they might build should not be wasted on heating water for laundry, nor should any of their scant water supply be used for such a purpose. He’s gotten his face cleaned up, at least, and his hands, and he’s choked down a bitter brew of herbs and water.
Bilbo jumps and loses his train of thought when an arm comes down around his shoulders. “You scared me!” He scolds.
Nori does not seem particularly put off by this. “Apologies,” he says, attempting a sort of mocking bow while still clinging to Bilbo. “Got time for a word or two?”
“I’ve got nothing but time, it seems.” Truly. From what Bilbo remembers of his last adventure, he may as well have closed his eyes on the Carrock and opened them again at Beorn’s door. Apparently, this recollection is not entirely accurate, or else Gandalf is leading them on a different and more taxing route this time. “This walk is dragging ever on and on.”
“That’s the spirit,” Nori agrees vaguely. “I suppose that’s normal, though, coming down from a battle-rage like you are.”
“Battle-rage?” Bilbo echoes.
“That’s the way to say it in Westron, I think,” Nori explains, “Not sure, to be honest, but even I’m not the sort to go handing out Khuzdul like it’s candy.”
Ah, yes. The secret language, not for the ears of outsiders. Bifur gets some kind of pass on this score on account of his injury, but for the others, it is strictly forbidden. Bilbo elects not to mention the fact that Kíli has already spoken to him in Khuzdul once on this journey, and does not even consider bringing up all of the major cultural transgressions that will be made in future.
“I’ve never seen any of the little folk fight like that,” Nori continues, before Bilbo can think of an appropriate response, “And before you ask, Master Burglar,” there’s a mocking emphasis on this title, which might upset Bilbo coming from anybody else, but he’ll allow it from Nori, “I have seen little folk before. Even seen ‘em fight, a time or two.”
“Please don’t keep me in suspense,” Bilbo deadpans. He is in no mood for showmanship.
Unfortunately, Nori does not cater to the moods of others. “I’ve spent my fair share of time in Bree. More than my fair share, as a matter of fact. Good place to hide, nice enough market. You pop off to Bree for a few weeks, pop back with a few coins and some drivel about selling your wares, and now there’s bread on the table and a smile on your baby brother’s face.”
Bilbo had never thought of it that way, but now that Nori is telling him, this does make a certain sense. He knew from the beginning that Nori was a thief. It did not occur to him that perhaps Dori’s impeccable manners were some sort of shield, that perhaps the three brothers did not have the money to keep themselves in food, or at least, not without Nori’s lifting and re-selling of things, collection of bets, and other such nonsense. None of the company lived in splendor in the Blue Mountains, Bilbo reminds himself, and things were far worse for their people before they arrived in Ered Luin. All of them did what they had to in order to survive once their home was taken from them.
He might not have understood it, eighty years ago, but now, he does. If Bilbo ever had to steal to keep Frodo fed, he’d have done it in a heartbeat. And worse than that, too, if it had come down to it. “And you’ve seen Hobbits fighting in Bree?”
“A few times,” Nori replies. “You know how it is: ale flowing, purse missing, fists flying.”
“I can’t say I do know how that is, no,” Bilbo admits, “But I’ll take your word for it.” He does not know how he feels about the idea of Nori picking the pockets of Hobbits, but then, it isn’t so very different from pillaging the larder of Bag End or removing light fixtures from the Last Homely House.
“Yours are a peaceful folk,” Nori decides. “That much I know. No training, no technique. You’ve got a little of one and less of the other, though I’d guess you’re better off than your neighbors in the Shire. Still, I didn’t think the battle-rage would touch you.”
“I have no idea what you’re talking about.” But Bilbo isn’t being entirely truthful anymore.
Of course he knows what Nori is talking about. When Bilbo faced Azog, he saw red. All he could think of was Ravenhill, of the blood on that orc’s hands, of everything that was stolen from him and from Erebor and from the world on that cold day. But when he faced down the first orc, the one who had his sword raised to harm Thorin, Bilbo saw nothing at all. Sting moved of its own volition, killing, rending flesh, fury embodied as Bilbo defended Thorin from an enemy that had long since ceased to be a threat. Bilbo could not have gathered his thoughts in that moment if he’d had the wherewithal to wish to. He could only act, could only slash, could only fight.
Nori snorts. “You’ve gotta work on your lying eyes. Trick of the trade, you know. Maybe this lot can’t see through you, but as far as I’m concerned, you’re carved out of clear quartz.” What a lovely idiom. Bilbo should make note of it, if he decides to write about this iteration of his adventure.
Hopefully, Nori is referring only to Bilbo’s inability to hold himself together in battle and not to any of the other secrets that the Hobbit is presently keeping. “You don’t mean to tell me that every fight is going to be like this!” That would not be sustainable. Bilbo must keep his wits about him, remember his purpose, and follow his plan. He cannot afford another reckless, senseless incident.
“I dunno,” Nori admits, “Nobody knows what sets it off. Some fighters get it, some don’t. I’ve seen it from Men, from time to time. Never from an Elf, though I’ve not met many of them. And never from a Halfing, neither, ’til this afternoon. Shows what I know about it. Not much of a warrior myself, I’ve got to say. Haven’t seen a proper battle, just a few scuffles that got out of hand. You’d be better off asking someone with more experience.” He jerks his head in Balin’s direction.
“Hobbit,” Bilbo corrects him reflexively. “Not halfling.” Clearly, whatever time Nori spent in Bree was not given over to cultural education. Why is Bilbo not surprised? Anyway, it gives him a good excuse to drop the other thread of this conversation.
“Right.” Nori gives him an odd sort of squeeze. Bilbo can’t decide whether this is an overstep or not. The two of them are friends, after all. Maybe not the closest of friends (at least, they weren’t on the first adventure), but friends nevertheless. “Still, if I were an orc, I’d steer clear of His Majesty when you were around.”
Oh. Alright. So Nori knows, then. Well, Bilbo supposes that it’s better than anybody working out his other secret. “How long have you known?”
“Told you,” Nori jostles Bilbo to and fro as they walk. “You’ve gotta work on your lying eyes. Anybody with half a brain would guess just from the way you look at him. And the way he looks at you—“
“Don’t be ridiculous,” Bilbo scolds him. He is not up for being teased about this. He would know it if Thorin were looking at him. Of course, he did not know it eighty years ago, but that was then, and this is now, and many things have changed.
Nori only smirks and makes a big show of waving Bilbo’s last remaining handkerchief at him as he saunters off. But before the Hobbit can chase after him, they are interrupted by the booming voice of a tired, injured, and apparently very irritated king. “We will camp here,” Thorin declares gruffly.
“This looks a fine spot for that,” Gandalf agrees. Bilbo isn’t always pleased with the Wizard, but at the very least, he trusts Gandalf’s assessment of the security of their campsites. He’s never been wrong about that before, after all. “We should be safe enough with the fire blazing, so long as we set a watch.”
Thorin mutters under his breath as he abruptly throws himself onto the ground. What could have happened over the course of the past several hours to set him off? He was in a perfectly pleasant mood on the Carrock (a pleasant mood indeed, Bilbo thinks, remembering the feeling of Thorin’s arms around him), and it’s not as though they’ve been attacked since then. No doubt he’s exhausted, and now he can’t even have his ritual of laying out his bedroll as though he’s expecting company. All of their baggage was lost in the goblin tunnels, after all. Or Thorin and Gandalf have exchanged words, and these have set him off. Or, it was Óin’s prodding, which, while usually helpful and necessary, is never very pleasant.
“Well, now he’s in a mood,” Kíli says aloud what perhaps everyone is thinking.
“And we haven’t even taken his pipe this time,” Fíli replies with mock solemnity. “I’ll bet Gandalf told him more about this friend we’re staying with. No doubt he disapproves.”
“Yes, but Thorin disapproves of everyone,” Bilbo puts in before he can think better of it.
The lads laugh aloud at this. “Maybe at first,” Kíli concedes, “But usually, he comes around.”
“Perhaps he’ll be sweeping this Beorn fellow off his feet next,” Fíli muses. It’s a comical thought, if not a very likely one.
“No, I’m sure Beorn is far too big for that,” Bilbo replies with no regard for the consequences. Then the implications of the broader discussion catch up with him, and he finds heat rising to his cheeks. “The cheek of you two, I swear!”
“Master Baggins,” Thorin calls, preventing what would surely evolve into a lecture on manners and minding one’s own business. “Take the first watch.”
That startles Bilbo more than any hug ever could. He’s not been trusted to keep watch alone on this journey yet, and on the last one, nobody asked him until after Lake-town. It’s no small thing, being the only one awake when everyone else is asleep. A gesture of trust if he’s ever seen it. Though perhaps it’s not the compliment Thorin thinks it is, considering that keeping watch will stand between Bilbo and some much-needed sleep. Nori has the audacity to wink at him.
