Actions

Work Header

Five Simple Steps

Chapter 4: Burdens Carried Over Hill and Under Hill

Notes:

Thanks as always for all the comments and kudos this week, and thanks for reading!
It's an angsty one today! Lots of grief and mourning, talk of death and dying, and battle flashbacks. I did not expect this chapter to be as heavy as it was, but considering we've got the thunder battle AND the finding of the ring to contend with I guess it had to be this way. Still, hopefully the middle part balances that out? Either way, please enjoy.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

It is nigh on impossible to see through the storm. The rain falls in thick, heavy sheets, and thunder echoes through the peaks and valleys of the Misty Mountains. Brief flashes of lighting are veins of metal in the sky, but utterly useless in clearing the way. There is too much wind even for keen Dwarven eyes to parse anything through the rain. Thorin pushes forward, despite his sodden hair and clothes, battered by the icy wind. They cannot turn back and they cannot stop where they are. They must continue on, whatever happens. They’ve done it before. They’ll have to do it again before their journey is through. They may as well get used to it, even the Hobbit, who has been shooting Thorin charged looks since they left the House of Elrond. 

Thorin has ignored these glances to the best of his ability. He has no idea why Master Baggins has become so invested in him and his quest, nor why the odd creature felt compelled to offer him encouragement at Rivendell. The King Under the Mountain does not require counsel from anyone, least of all someone less than half his age who has never seen a battle or faced any hardship more harrowing than running out of butter for the porridge at breakfast time. It occurs to Thorin that he is being unfair, but then, fairness is a dangerous thing, out here in the wild. It is one thing to apologize for accidental use of insensitive language, an overstep which Thorin genuinely regrets. He knows well enough what it is like to be looked down upon, having spent years of his life toiling in the towns and villages of Men. 

But this does not mean that Thorin should allow himself to get close to Master Baggins. A friendship with the Hobbit would be a very poor idea. Thorin has no need of friends. He is the leader of an exiled people, with burdens enough on his back, without taking up responsibility for an entertaining and attractive creature who seems determined to place himself in harm’s way at every opportunity. Master Baggins was the one who rushed off to challenge the trolls alone, and then he had the nerve to complain about his lack of a weapon as he snatched the Elven blade from Thorin’s hands. Such erratic behavior will surely lead the Hobbit to a bad end, and Thorin does not have the time or energy on hand to drag himself through another loss.

What in Durin’s name is Thorin doing, thinking about the Hobbit while traversing the side of a mountain? Is he trying to get himself killed? That can’t happen, not until the quest is through. Thorin will not put the reclamation of Erebor on Fíli’s shoulders. He would be a fine King Under the Mountain, but he is young yet, and deserves a few more years of practice before he starts ruling in earnest. He should not have to be the one to take back their homeland. It should be Thorin. By the grace of Mahal, it will be Thorin. 

This is his burden, and his burden alone. His birthright and his task. He is not his grandfather. He has proven himself as a brave and pragmatic leader. He has provided well for his people during their sojourn in the Blue Mountains, and now, he must provide them with a restored homeland, their own kingdom, an end to the decades of living on whatever scraps are thrown to them. Should he fall, his people will be taken care of, but he owes it to his heirs to keep himself alive so that they might never be forced to carry the great weight that now lays across Thorin’s shoulders.

A particularly strong gust of wind reminds him that this is not the time to be lost in thought. Brooding, his sister-sons would call it. Dwalin, too. And the Hobbit used that word by the campfire, a sly smile on his handsome face, his head cocked to the side as he regarded Thorin with oddly trusting eyes. Master Baggins is a fool to trust his safety to a company of thirteen strangers.

Why is Thorin thinking about the Hobbit again? He should consider the rest of his companions. He should be more fair. He should stop thinking altogether and focus on getting all of them to relative safety. They are still in the mountains, after all, and the storm is getting worse. He must keep his wits about him. He must not fall to sentimental musings. He can trust no one but himself to lead the company through this. If anything goes wrong, it will be on Thorin’s head alone. He must not pass his responsibility along to his sister-sons or his advisors. 

“Hold on!” Thorin orders his company, as if they would have done anything else. He hears scuffling behind him, but pays it no mind. Had anything serious happened, he’d have been informed. He must not dwell on whatever calamity was avoided; that way lies madness. “We must find shelter!” 

“Look out!” Dwalin roars, and then a rock comes careening into the side of the mountain. The pieces of the boulder rain down around them, and Thorin is painfully aware of all of the lives in his care at the moment. If any of them fall, it will be Thorin’s fault for leading them here. 

“This is no thunderstorm,” Balin realizes, “It’s a thunder battle! Look!” 

Thorin can only stare in horror. A thunder battle? Stone giants, throwing boulders at each other, with his company in the middle of it? He can only pray that they will all have the sense to keep under cover, and that Mahal will preserve them from an early journey to his halls.

“Well, bless me!” Bofur dashes his king’s hopes immediately, as though trying to remind Thorin of how little control he truly has. “The legends are true! Giants! Stone giants!” Bifur scolds his cousin sharply for his behavior, in low tones that do not travel to Thorin’s position. Not that the Khuzdul reprimand has any affect on Bofur, who continues to stand there gawking. 

“Take cover, you fool!” Thorin cannot deal with this.

He cannot lose any member of his company. He simply cannot. He is not his grandfather, and he will not fail. He is the custodian of his people, and he will not fail. He will get his company across these mountains and then on to Erebor, and then he will use his newfound power and the resources that accompany it to search every corner of the known world for his missing father. He will not fail. 

But he is powerless to do anything but stand there clinging to the stone as the rock face he thought so stable begins to move. Boulders rain down to hammer the mountainside, and Thorin finds himself thinking once again of the Hobbit. Oh, what in Durin’s name was Gandalf thinking, sending such a weak little creature on a journey like this? Master Baggins has never left his cozy home before. Whatever skills he learned play-acting at adventures in peaceful Hobbiton will do nothing to protect him from the perils of the road. He does not belong in the Misty Mountains, of all places! He’ll be killed. He’ll be killed, violently and horribly and tragically, and it will be Thorin’s fault for not putting his foot down. More blood on his hands, just like Thrór, just like Frerin. A better king with more foresight could have prevented this. 

The rock splits where the company stands. Thorin can hear his nephews calling out to one another, and he does not look behind him, does not, cannot, cannot think about it now, needs to keep himself from falling to his death before his duty is done. He owes a debt to his people, to his ancestors and his Maker. He owes a debt to his company, each and every member. Panting from the strain and buzzing with nerves, Thorin scrambles to more steady ground, following what little stone-sense he has, his mind frantic with a nonsensical prayer. Only once he has braced himself against the rock can he bring himself to look behind him. To his horror, he finds only four of his companions. Glóin, Óin, Balin, Kíli. 

The others stand on a disembodied ledge, brandished in the monstrous hand of one of the giants. Thorin is single-minded in his terror. His heir is in danger, his sister-son. And Dwalin, his dearest friend. Foolish, comely Master Baggins. And the other six, steadfast and loyal folk who chose to follow their king on this journey because, as the Hobbit made so very clear, they believe in Thorin. He has failed them now. He has failed all of them. 

He can only stand and watch, can only scream, “Hold on!” As if that will do anything, can only cling to the rock to hide his trembling as the trajectory of his companions becomes obvious. They are in for a collision with the mountain’s face, and there is nothing Thorin can do to stop it. At the front of the group is Fíli, looking decades younger in his terror, his back to the stone as he braces himself. That will do nothing. 

Thorin remembers Fíli as a little lad, always standing back, always keeping himself and his brother out of the way, stepping into shoes too large for any child to fill. He remembers reading stories to the boy, braiding golden hair and bandaging skinned knees. He remembers waking up to find that his nephew had climbed into his bed at night, ostensibly afraid of the dark, though this fear only seemed to plague the boy on the nights when Thorin’s nightmares were the worst. He remembers training Fíli with a sword, watching him grow, watching him become skilled. Telling him that under no circumstances could he come on this quest. He remembers being worn down, acquiescing, by the argument that Erebor was Fíli’s birthright, too. The rock hits the mountain, and Thorin’s blood freezes in his veins.

“No!” He screams, “No, no!” He is senseless now, unable to compose himself, unable to think straight, unable to remember that he is supposed to be a king. 

It is beyond Thorin’s comprehension to lose any member of his company this way. He knows that in the days to come, he will mourn for loyal Dwalin, who followed Thorin to this horrific end. All the others, the Burglar and the near-strangers who nevertheless devoted themselves to Thorin’s cause. But now, his heart cries for his sister-son, the boy he helped raise from a pebble. Thorin could not have stopped Dwalin from coming on this quest. It would dishonor him as king to stoop to such a level, refusing the service of a talented soldier for petty personal reasons. Nor could he have refused the service of the others without giving them a major slight. 

But he could have protected Fíli. He could have had the final word, not as the lad’s king but as his uncle. No one would have blamed him. Dís would have supported him. She did not wish for her sons to come with Thorin, after all. In fact, she begged him to set them straight, and he refused, with pretty words about Sons of Durin and their duty to their people and how cruel it would be of him to steal this opportunity from the boys. Thorin was proud, and he wanted every sword he could get for use against the dragon. And look what has come of all that. 

Horrible images float through Thorin’s head. Blood and gore and stained armor and Thrór’s head twenty feet away from the rest of his body and half of Frerin’s young face ripped away and dragon fire and the smell of burning flesh and burning trees and burning fabric and the roar of the wyrm and the cold glare of an Elf turning his back on his allies and little Fíli tugging at Thorin’s sleeve to get his attention and and Dís, sobbing over her husband the same way she will soon sob for her son. Thorin’s body moves of its own volition and gets him over to the space where he knows that the carnage will be. 

He steels himself. He does not have the luxury of responding to this as any other person would. He does not have the luxury of shock and horror. He will have to put on a brave face and lead what remains of his company past the mangled remains of their fallen comrades. Past the mangled remains of the little boy who noticed his uncle’s nightmares and began to sing him lullabies to try and calm them. He will have to be a king, and then, when night falls and the mask comes off, he will have to be an uncle. Kíli yet lives, but he will never be the same. Thorin wasn’t. He knows. Kíli will lose that glimmer in his eyes, that bounce in his step, just as his uncle did before him. And he will need to learn how to lead, how to rule. How to mourn. 

Thorin takes a ragged breath and forces himself around the corner. He stops dead, nearly sending himself and those behind him tumbling over the side of the mountain when he sees all of them there, fully intact, huddled together and shaking but alive, all of them alive. He feels flimsy with relief and residual anger, heavy with sudden awareness of his utter lack of control. 

 

Somehow, Bilbo, with all of his foreknowledge, manages to topple over the same ledge again the second time around. It’s impressive, really, that he put himself in the exact same place at the exact same time, resulting in the exact same outcome. Of course, that’s not as much of a comfort as one might imagine. Bilbo knows that he can’t hold onto this slippery ledge indefinitely, and that his being rescued before is not a guarantee of his being rescued again.

“Where’s Bilbo? Where’s the Hobbit?” At least Bofur is aware of his absence. 

“There!” Someone shouts, and the company’s attention is drawn to the spot where Bilbo hangs. 

Perhaps it is not the same exact spot. Perhaps there was never any guarantee that Bilbo was going to go flying off the side of a cliff during the thunder battle, and he is just incredibly unlucky. It would only be fair, for him to have poor luck in this venture when the Valar have been so diligent in guiding him along the rest of his journey. What will happen if he does fall? Will he wake up in the care of Yavanna, like a proper Hobbit, or will Lady Galadriel collect him somehow and take him back to the start? And what will become of the company, either way? Bilbo begins to hyperventilate at the thought of what might happen if he falls now. 

“Get him!” Someone screams, and the company responds by extending their arms to Bilbo. But he knows he cannot support his weight one-handed, and he also knows how he was saved the last time. It’s a gamble and a risk he shouldn’t take, but he closes and eyes and waits for Thorin to come to his rescue. 

I will return the favor, Bilbo promises silently. I will save your life. I will not let you fall in battle. I will stick Sting into Azog’s eye and teach him what happens when he tries to lay his hands on my beloved.

As expected, Thorin is able to scramble down the side of the rock in a split second and haul Bilbo up by the back of his jacket. The king gives Bilbo a firm push toward the others, who pull him back onto the ledge with haste. That warm, rough hand moves him so deftly, with such ease, as though the Hobbit weighed no more than a bag of flour. 

Oh, those hands. Those hands, those powerful king’s hands, those calloused smith’s hands, those hands which Bilbo has gripped until all the warmth seeped out of them. Those hands of which Bilbo has dreamed for so very long. Those hands which are, at the moment, the only thing standing between Thorin Oakenshield and certain death. What a stupid, needless risk. Clearly taken without thinking, or with some skewed sense of honor in mind, because for the purposes of the quest, they’d be better off without a burglar than without their leader. 

Thorin nearly loses his grip, but Dwalin is strong and fast and constantly aware of his king’s position and wellbeing. Bilbo attempts to lie to himself, to pretend that Thorin was never in any real danger, but he knows that isn’t true. They have both been lucky this day, and it doesn’t matter that Bilbo had prior expectations. Things could have turned out very badly indeed. I will return the favor.

“I thought we’d lost our Burglar,” Dwalin comments, because somebody needs to say something. 

Bilbo knows what is coming next, although perhaps things will be different this time around. After all, he and Thorin have been closer on this journey than the one that came before. Bilbo has shared his food and even pipeweed with Thorin, and they have bickered good-naturedly about how he chose to fill his pack. He has offered Thorin comfort in a time of need and been gentle with him about his rude comments. It seems that one of them is always staring at the other, then looking away in embarrassment when he is caught. None of that could have been said at this point on the first adventure. 

“He’s been lost ever since he left home.” No. Of course not. Bilbo should have known. Thorin offers the same scathing words that he threw at Bilbo before, only this time around, Bilbo feels he is much less justified in doing so. “He should never have come. He has no place amongst us.” 

The last time, Bilbo was stunned by these words, speechless as he was submerged in the truth of them. He remembers blinking away tears, believing Thorin completely, trusting his judgment for some inexplicable reason. He was fooled by the king’s modulated tone, and did not know him well enough to understand what was going on. Last time, perhaps, one could have argued that Bilbo did not belong with the company. He kept his distance from them, laying out his bedroll in an isolated corner or near the Wizard whenever he could. He did not share in their jokes, and at the start, they’d taken bets about whether he would even come on the adventure at all. 

This time, however, Bilbo has integrated himself into the company quite well. He tells stories and sings drinking songs with Bofur, he’s treated Nori’s injuries, and he’s rather close with Fíli and Kíli. He’s shared food with everybody, and his disappointing book is currently in Ori’s pack. He even let Glóin spend an entire day regaling him with tales of little Gimli! One could argue that perhaps Bilbo is not the best fighter among them (alright, he is easily the worst fighter among them, but that’s beside the point) but to say that he does not belong at all? To say that he has been lost? Bilbo has barely thought of the Shire since he left it. He’s been exceptionally prepared for all of their encounters. He’s been nonchalantly reading while the rest of them were fretting about orc attacks, and Thorin still has the nerve to talk about him like that! 

Obviously, Bilbo thinks huffily as he follows the rest of the company into the convenient cave where they’ve decided to make camp, Thorin’s unkind words had nothing to do with Bilbo. The king was only lashing out, hitting the closest target as hard as he could with as much force as he could muster. And it doesn’t take a genius to figure out why. He’d nearly lost half his company. Bilbo understands, as he did not understand the last time, that Thorin feels personally responsible for all of them. It does not matter that Thorin had no way of knowing about the thunder battle, that even if he had known, there would have been no way around it, that everybody in their company is an adult who made a conscious decision to come along. If anything had happened, Thorin would’ve taken it personally. He would have blamed himself. 

And he chose to blame Bilbo instead, rather than sitting with the guilt. Rather than tearing himself up inside, he went after the Hobbit. And really, Bilbo should leave it there. He should be supportive and understanding. After all, he knows that Thorin will come around eventually. They won’t be dancing about one another forever. He’ll prove himself in battle and Thorin will apologize for doubting him; they’ll hug, and after that, they will be friends. Simple and straightforward, exactly as it should be. 

But Bilbo Baggins cannot leave well enough alone. If he could, he’d be in the Undying Lands right now, reclining on green grass and staring up at a blue sky, not soaked to the bone and trembling with cold while an emotionally immature monarch uses him as a training dummy. He at least has the courtesy to wait until they’re inside the cave to make his move, though. Unlike Thorin, Bilbo has no desire to publicly humiliate anybody. 

“What are you doing, lad?” Glóin demands with a hand on the Hobbit’s shoulder as Bilbo makes his way over to Thorin. “Best not to make it worse, I’d say.”

Bilbo pays him no mind, shaking the hand off and striding past, ignoring Balin’s amused snort and quiet comment with equal resolve. “What’s he doing now?” Óin inquires at such a volume that the goblins in their tunnels below can probably hear him with perfect clarity. 

Thorin, too, can hear, of course. He looks up and meets Bilbo’s eyes. “Let’s see about supper,” Bombur says conspicuously to the little gaggle of spectators. “There’s no fire, but I know I can work something up. Who’d like to help?”

“And miss the show?” Kíli, unfortunately, somehow manages to be even more conspicuous. 

Bilbo doesn’t blame him one bit for trying to find amusement in this dismal place. The color is gone from his cheeks, and he has been gripping the strap of his pack with white knuckles since they arrived in the cave.Thankfully, he has his brother nearby to drag him away, with cheerfully articulated threats and no trace of whatever terror plagued him only moments before. These lads are accustomed to wearing brave faces, as is every member of the company.

Well. This isn’t awkward at all. So much for a private conversation. Their companions may not be watching openly, but Bilbo knows that they’ll be paying attention as he speaks to Thorin. Still, he can’t let this wait until they’re clear of the tunnels. He wants to fix it now, before the wounds have a chance to fester. He needs to speak up for himself, and, even worse, he wants to help. The one he loves is suffering, and Bilbo, despite his better judgment, wants to put it right. 

“Hello,” he says, sitting down beside the king. Everyone else has given him a wide berth, joking comments aside, probably owing to some sense of self-preservation which Bilbo apparently lacks.

Thorin only grunts at him in vague acknowledgment as he withdraws his bedroll from his pack and begins to lay it out just so. Well, Bilbo should have known that it would be like this. Just because he understands what Thorin is going through doesn’t mean that the king is going to open up and let him in at the first knock. 

“Look,” Bilbo tries again, “I understand that you’re upset. You’ve just had a shock, we all have. And I can’t imagine what it must be like for you, having your heirs out there, and everything. And considering what they’re like… well, I’m sure I’d be terrified out of my mind, if those were my nephews.” Thorin pauses briefly in his methodical preparation of his bedroll, but says nothing and returns to his work just as quickly. “And obviously, you’ve got to look after the entire company as well. It’s a heavy burden on your shoulders, and no mistake.”

“What do you want?” Thorin growls. 

Bilbo blinks at him. Well, so much for that, then. He may as well double down, if he’ll be met with anger no matter what he says. “To express my sympathy, first of all, because what you’re doing isn’t easy, and I can see that, even if nobody else can.” 

“Thank you.” Thorin does not sound remotely grateful. 

“But second of all,” Bilbo presses on, “I’ll thank you not to talk to me like that ever again. I signed a contract to work as your Burglar, not to dangle off the sides of mountains. And you signed the same contract, if I recall. If we’re to have a working professional relationship, then you’re going to have to treat me with civility. I’ll not have you yelling at me in front of the company every time you feel you need something to control.” 

“And what gives you the right to speak to me this way?” Oh, goodness, he’s as ornery as ever. 

“Well, for a start, you’re not my king,” Bilbo points out, “And I’m not afraid of you. I’ve been minding faunts for years, and I know what sulking looks like when I see it. Besides, if you can’t handle a talking-to, you shouldn’t be throwing them around yourself, now, should you?” Bilbo receives no response, but Thorin, at least, has the grace to look chastened. “Now, chin up. You’re a fine king, like I told you at Bag End, and I know you know better than to speak to any of your subjects the way you spoke to me back there. Everybody’s well, and of course nobody blames you for anything those giants were doing! It’ll all look better in the morning, I’m sure.” 

Which is not strictly true, because in the morning they’ll be fumbling along through the goblin tunnels, running for their lives. But that won’t help Thorin sleep any sounder, and anyway, Bilbo knows for a fact that after that battle, the king will feel better about his ability to lead. He pats Thorin on the shoulder before taking his leave and wandering over to set up his own bedroll. 

But no. This conversation isn’t over yet. There is one crucial think that Bilbo has forgotten. He turns back. “Have you come to strike me another killing blow, then, Master Burglar?” Thorin drawls. 

“Not this time,” Bilbo admits. He’s very well put his foot in it now, and it would be nothing short of cowardly for him to back down now that he’s made his decision. “I almost forgot to thank you for saving my life.” 

Thorin laughs. Really laughs, the sound abrupt and shocking. Judging by his wide-eyed expression, the king was not expecting that any more than Bilbo was. “I could do nothing else. You are a member of my company,” he says, by way of explanation. 

Bilbo can only stare at him. A member of his company? Oh, sure, yes, that is the bare minimum for Thorin to admit, and true in point of fact, but they never would have gotten this far on the first adventure. Not even by a long shot. Not until the Carrock. Apparently, Bilbo’s stammering attempt to stand up for himself has earned him some grudging respect.

Thorin still looks amused as he regards Bilbo across his bedroll, which is now ready for a night of fitful sleep. “Did you have something more to say?” Still, that fondness Bilbo senses in his tone must be a product of the Hobbit’s hopeful mind, and nothing more. Perhaps in another life, Thorin Oakenshield did love him, but here and now, Bilbo knows better than to expect such a thing. It is far too soon for all that. 

“No, no, of course not, that’ll be all then, thank you.” Bilbo shakes himself and begins backing away. “Good night, Thorin. I suppose I’ll see you in the morning.” That is more or less true, anyway. 

 

Once the issue with Thorin is resolved, the company’s present peril dawns on Bilbo. None of the others know anything about the goblins, of course, so they can be forgiven for their foolishness, but Bilbo certainly understands what awaits them on the other side of the wall. He contemplates speaking up, but the minute the idea enters his mind, it begins to fall apart. 

For one thing, he knows that Thorin would never listen to him. Such a conversation would immediately reverse whatever progress Bilbo managed to make with his earlier assertion. Bilbo would voice his concern, but of course, he wouldn’t be able to say anything specific, so Thorin would accuse him of pining for home, and Bilbo would point out that there are goblins in these mountains, and Thorin, almost definitely, would contend that Bilbo knows not of what he speaks. And then the goblins would catch them anyway, in the middle of an argument, with the rest of the company no doubt gathered around like spectators at a midsummer dance. 

Also, just like with the trolls, their encounter in the goblin tunnels will play a vital part in their adventure. If Bilbo never faces Gollum, he will never get his hands on the ring, and therefore will not be able to turn invisible. He won’t save the company from the spiders or the Elves, and he does not know how his encounter with Smaug will go, if he ever actually gets to see Erebor. And, of course, he won’t be able to destroy the ring if he does not have the ring, even assuming that he manages to concoct completely new plans for dealing with everything else. Moreover, Bilbo doesn’t like the company’s chances out there on the mountain. They may not find another place to camp, and it’ll be a lot worse trying to navigate this stretch of their journey in the dark. The stone giants are still out there, and Yavanna only knows what else. 

And who knows how long it will take them to pass through the Misty Mountains without the shortcut through the goblin tunnels? It’s not a chance they can take with limited time. Better the goblin that you know than the warg that you don’t, Bilbo decides. He can’t afford to take new chances. He’ll do everything the same way he did it before. Except, no he won’t, because he does not intend to leave, nor to tell Bofur to his face that their people do not belong anywhere. Bilbo didn’t mean that when he said it, and he’s spent eight decades regretting it. For a moment, Bilbo wonders if he should just stay in bed. 

But that’s not possible, either. Last time, Bofur saw the glow of Sting and said something, and Thorin roused the rest of the company. Of course he had. He’d been wide awake, listening to the nasty things that Bilbo said about his people. No wonder he’d been so angry with the Hobbit when they were reunited later. All of Bilbo’s righteousness about Thorin’s use of insulting language, and yet, on the first journey, he was no better! Worse, even. Thorin had no way of knowing that halfling was an offensive term, but a moment’s reflection would’ve reminded Bilbo of the Dwarven cultural heritage regarding their status as an unwanted people. Which they emphatically are not, because even if every Elf, Man, Orc and Wizard in Middle Earth turns up their nose at this company, Bilbo loves each of them with all his Hobbit heart. 

Regardless of all that, though, they were all awake and aware when they tumbled into the tunnels. Who knows what could happen to them in any other state? He has to go and talk to Bofur, then. 

“You should get some rest while you have the chance,” Bofur advises when he catches sight of Bilbo, “No telling how long we’ll be staying here.” He does not add any commentary about Thorin’s apparent restlessness, but this assessment is implied with the way he nods toward their leader. 

Bilbo passes his gaze over each member of the company in turn, but quickly deems this practice too distressing. He’s improved a lot since setting out from Bag End, truly. He was able to distract himself well enough with his book and his snacks during the first leg of the journey, and then, in Rivendell, he was preoccupied with the question of the ring. But he’s had strange dreams every night since they left the Last Homely House, and these have shaken him. He’s taken to sleeping slightly apart from the company, just as he did on the original adventure, though this time, it is to shield them all from his kicking and whimpering as he contends with the same nightmares that drove him from Erebor all those years ago.

Nobody has said anything about it to him, but he imagines that his fellows must know his predicament. It would be hard to miss something like that, on watch, although Bilbo doesn’t know for certain that he’s been kicking and whimpering. Only, he can’t imagine he would be so lucky as to have no embarrassing reaction whatsoever to the dreams. They’re not fantastical like the one he had the first night at Bag End; they are true to life, his worst memories repeated ad nauseam. He has watched Fíli fall and seen the light leave Thorin’s eyes and found Kíli laying on the ground upwards of a thousand times by now, and yet, the pain is still fresh with every nightmare. 

It’s just a little too much, to look at them all like this. The lads are sleeping on their backs, bedrolls pulled up close to conserve warmth, and even in the narrow light of the cave, he can see the rising and falling of their chests. They are both breathing, he reminds himself. They are both alive. There is no blood to be seen, and there are no limbs forced into awkward positions. This is not Ravenhill.

Thorin, however, is laying on his side with his back to Bilbo, who has to resist the urge to start stepping over people to get a better look and check that the king is breathing. Oh, yes, that’d go over well. No doubt he’d wind up with a sword in his own chest before Thorin even opened his eyes to see who was pestering him. It’s not wise to sneak up on any warrior, but somebody as high-strung as Thorin is particularly dangerous when teetering between wakefulness and sleep. Bilbo’s only comfort is the logical conclusion that Thorin has no reason to be in any state other than perfect health at this juncture on their journey. 

“What’s bothering you?” Bofur asks. 

Bilbo has long since learned that his friend’s jovial front is just that: a front. It’s not that Bofur doesn’t find joy in life, because of course, he does, but he’s not the jolly fool that he often makes himself out to be. He can more than hold his own in a fight, and when it suits him, he can be very perceptive. More likely than not, he has his own set of hypotheses about what’s bothering Bilbo, but he knows better than to ask a leading question. It didn’t occur to Bilbo the first time, how closely he was being observed by every member of the company, but now, it’s obvious to him.

He does not think that any of his companions suspect him of the grief he bears so heavily. Why would they, after all? Bilbo’s circumstances are far beyond the realm of possibility that he’d have comprehended prior to the onset of his second adventure. But it is plain that they can tell that something is off about him. They may think he’s too trusting, or too kind to possibly be genuine. Perhaps they’ll attribute these apparent qualities to Hobbit nature or culture, just as once they did with his standoffishness. Some of the more perceptive fellows may even think that Bilbo has a little crush on Thorin. They don’t know the half of it, of course, but no use saying any more. 

Bilbo sighs. He can’t very well tell the truth, can he? “Well,” he begins, pithy as ever, “I nearly fell to my death out there.” 

“True enough,” Bofur shrugs. That’s something Bilbo appreciates about him. He doesn’t sugar-coat. “But as far as I can tell, you’re still alive. That’s something to be happy about.”

“Oh, yes, I’m very pleased. And you should be, too. As long as I’m alive, none of you have to face the dragon.”

Bofur snorts. “Oh, I imagine we’ll be facing it sooner or later whether you’re with us or not.” With us, he says, not simply alive, as though he thinks there is some possibility of Bilbo leaving. 

“Hm.” Bilbo can’t really argue with this point. Well, actually, he could argue; he could tell Bofur that some people will be hungover in Lake-town when the dragon attacks and therefore will not have to do very much wyrm-fighting, but then, of course, he’d be showing his hand. If he were going to confess to anybody about his foreknowledge, it would probably be Bofur, but Bilbo isn’t planning to reveal his secret at this point in the journey, especially not while Thorin is eavesdropping. “I don’t suppose you’ll ever have to find out, because I’m certainly not going anywhere.” 

“That’s the spirit.” Bofur wraps his arm around Bilbo and jostles him to and fro.

In the Shire, this would be considered incredibly rough treatment, and if anybody had tried it on Bilbo eighty years ago he would’ve balked and said something snarky. But he understands now that in Dwarven culture, it is a gesture of affection between equals. He’s seen his companions engage in it many times, and if anything, he should be honored that Bofur apparently views him as friend enough to justify such informality. But, then, he’s had Bofur’s friendship for so long that it’s strange to think of having to win him over again, even if the circumstances are perfectly explicable. 

Oh, by the Valar, what kind of life has Bilbo led that he considers circumstances such as these ones perfectly explicable? “Anyway, I’m sure you lot will need me long before we get to Erebor.” He has to bite his tongue once more to keep from telling any tales that should not come to light just yet. Bofur will live through them soon enough, and it won’t do for him to be lulled into a false sense of security by the knowledge that Bilbo managed to carry things off once before. Moreover, it would be patently unfair to force poor Bofur to keep such a heavy secret from his brother, his cousin, and his friends, not to mention his king. 

“Oh, aye,” Bofur agrees. “Who’d be handing out handkerchiefs if you were to leave us?”

“You’ve already had four,” Bilbo reminds him with a laugh, “I don’t know what you keep doing with them. I don’t suppose I want to know, either.” 

“One of them was for Bifur,” Bofur recounts, “He did thank you for it, didn’t he?”

“I don’t speak Khuzdul!” Bilbo protests gleefully. It’s easy to forget his troubles around Bofur. He can almost imagine that they’re not about to fall through the floor. “Was he thanking me? I didn’t know! Oh, goodness, I hope I haven’t offended him.” If only Bilbo had taken the time to learn the secret language on his return to Erebor! He’d have had to petition Dáin for permission, of course, and that could easily have been denied, but it would have served him well had he been granted the opportunity. 

“Shh, you’ll wake the company,” Bofur, too, is smiling. “I don’t think Bifur’d be offended by you not speaking Khuzdul. It’d be worse if you did understand him, actually. Secret language and all.“

“Right.” This does make Bilbo feel a bit better. Still, he resolves to find some way to communicate better with Bifur in the future. He can’t wait until the Elven dungeons to start learning simple signs the way he did the last time. 

“Anyway, you know the trolls took the first handkerchief you gave me,” Bofur continues his litany of excuses. 

“I continue to find that very difficult to believe.” Not that Bilbo cares. But it’s good fun, going back and forth with Bofur. 

“And Nori took the next one, if you can believe that. He got a few of them out of your pack, too, and won himself a couple of coins from Dwalin.” Bofur winks conspiratorially. “Says he’s gotta keep himself sharp, and you’re good practice.” 

“Dwalin was placing wagers on Nori stealing from me?” Actually, when he says it out loud, this doesn’t surprise Bilbo very much. “Of course he was. I suppose everyone has to find something to entertain themselves with, out on the road.” Besides, Bilbo has plenty of handkerchiefs to go around, and those left in his pack won’t even survive the night. Perhaps it’s a good thing that Nori has taken some of them; those might yet remain with the company after they’ve left the goblin tunnels. 

“And I still have the fourth one,” Bofur plows right on ahead with accounting of the whereabouts of Bilbo’s handkerchiefs. Oh, how Bilbo missed such mischief, all those long lonely years he spent holed up in Bag End! “And a great honor it is, too, carrying the favor of a gentlehobbit such as yourself.”

Bilbo rolls his eyes. “Oh, please shut up, and don’t embarrass yourself.” But they’re both grinning. That much Bilbo can tell, even in the dark. 

He’s glad he hasn’t threatened to leave this time around, and somewhat sad, too. Given the choice between the two conversations, Bilbo decides that he’d much rather have this lively discussion than the talking-down that Bofur attempted the first time around. And it didn’t even work. Bilbo really would’ve walked out on the company, and then where would they all be? On the off chance that he ever made it home to the Shire, Bilbo would be miserable for the rest of his days without ever knowing why. And Thorin would probably be killed by Azog the Defiler after the company escaped the goblin tunnels. What would become of the others then? 

Bilbo shudders to think about it. “But there’s still something the matter, isn’t there?” Bofur observes. 

“Yes, there is.” Bilbo isn’t going to lie to him. He’s just so tired of carrying so many secrets around, so sick of obsessing over the horrible things he has witnessed. It’s frustrating, being so in love with Thorin, knowing in his heart exactly what kind of person the king is, but having to contend with the distrustful, brooding disaster on legs who is presently leading their company. Not to mention the princes, who have been nothing but nice to Bilbo, going out of their way to include him whenever they can. Bilbo feels guilty for not telling them what he knows, and personally responsible for their fates. Perhaps he could have convinced them to stay in Rivendell. But no, that’d never have gone over. Bilbo might have managed to make Fíli see reason with a solid argument about ensuring the safety of the heirs to the throne, but Kíli would almost certainly have talked his brother out of that within the hour. 

“Wanna talk about it?” Bofur prods, jabbing Bilbo in the side while he’s at it. 

Bilbo takes a moment to collect his thoughts. He can feel Bofur’s eyes on him, scanning his face with keen vision and palpable concern. The Hobbit sighs heavily. “I know that Thorin did not mean what he said to me out on the ledge.”

“No, of course he didn’t,” Bofur agrees, “Sometimes our dear king can say things without meaning them. Especially when he’s had a shock.”

“Still,” Bilbo continues, knowing that he must tread carefully. After all, Thorin is almost certainly listening in. Bilbo cannot help being aware of that fact. He finds himself absently fiddling with Sting, taking the blade from its sheath and turning it over in the dim light of the cave. “It hurts, being told I don’t belong. I wish he knew that I would gladly lay my life on the line for… well, for anybody in the company, just the same as he would. Just the same as any of us would, I imagine.” 

“And did you tell him as much, when you went over?” Bofur is shameless with his prying. 

Bilbo would have to be a fool, indeed, to believe that his little interview with Thorin went unnoticed by any member of the company. “No. I told him to keep his head up and stop brooding, because he’s a perfectly fine king."

Bofur offers him a disbelieving laugh. “And how did that work out for you, lad?” At least someone can find humor in this situation. 

Bilbo knew that it would be an uphill battle, getting back into Thorin Oakenshield’s good graces. He knew he’d be contending with decades of distrust and fear and trauma, that any love he might feel is entirely unrequited, at least for the time being. He knew all of this, and yet, it is torture, to look into Thorin’s eyes and see none of the affection which once he found there. It was torture, to be heaved back onto the ledge by those strong arms without being held in them after. Torture, that Bilbo should have to be the one to comfort Thorin after such a harrowing ordeal, when the smallest and most selfish part of him wished to share in a moment of mutual consolation. Even when Thorin is being cordial, he keeps Bilbo at a painful distance. 

“He has every reason to distrust me, I suppose,” Bilbo says deliberately. “I would, I’m sure, in his position. I’m a stranger to you, and I know I’m not much in battle even on my best day. No, I’m not at all angry with Thorin for what he said.” 

“He can be a prickly one when he sets his mind to it,” Bofur observes. “Still doesn’t give him the right to speak to you the way he did. You know we all think of you as one of our own. Couldn’t get along without you.”

“Oh, believe me, I am well aware.” Bilbo assures him, forcing a smile. The problem is that he has no reason to be so troubled by Thorin’s rejection of him. Why would Bilbo care so much that a stranger far above his station does not like him? Thorin has proven that he is willing to risk his life for Bilbo’s, no matter what he feels about the Hobbit as a person. He’d have jumped for joy if Thorin had called him a member of the company at this point on the first adventure. Now, though, his shoulders sag at the realization that weeks of loving effort on his part have yielded nothing more than an acknowledgement of the truth from Thorin. At this rate, they may have a conversation about their true feelings on Bilbo’s next eleventy-first birthday.  “But it doesn’t matter. You can’t get rid of me that easily.”

Bofur laughs at that. “I hope you don’t expect to be falling off many more cliffs in the future. Once was quite enough for me to watch a thing like that.”

“I’m a Hobbit,” Bilbo reminds him, “We’re not built for heights, and our feet aren’t made for climbing on rocks. It’s not my fault that… Oh.” Sting’s blade shines in a faint but unmistakable shade of blue. “Oh no.” How did he manage to forget where they were? 

“What is it?” Bofur asks. 

Bilbo brandishes his sword. “It’s glowing blue. There must be goblins nearby.“

“Wake up! Wake up!” Thorin roars, but of course, just like last time, he is too late. A small crack in the wall turns into a rather large chasm in the floor, which leads into a tunnel, through which everybody tumbles.

It is absolute madness. Utter pandemonium, really. Bilbo just barely manages to put Sting away before he can do any serious bodily harm to himself or somebody else. He flails his arms as he slides down the rather convenient chute. Somebody, Bofur, maybe, tries to grab at Bilbo’s jacket, but to no avail. Bilbo manages to right himself so that he’s sliding on his bottom rather than tumbling head-over-heels, though he knows he’s going to be nursing a nasty set of bruises for days to come. The last time, he’d been sore well into Mirkwood. 

Someone slams into him from behind (Dori, Bilbo thinks) and actually does manage to get ahold of Bilbo just before they hit the ground. Is it called the ground in a goblin tunnel? Surely the ground is several hundred feet above them. But, then, they were on a mountain to begin with, which would imply that the ground is now several hundred feet below them. That thought makes Bilbo feel a little dizzy, and it doesn’t help that Dori just flipped them over midair so that the Hobbit would not be crushed in the fall. Very thoughtful fellow, that Dori. He did this same thing the last time, too. 

“Terribly sorry,” Bilbo mutters, springing off of Dori as quickly as he can while the goblins begin to close in around them, muttering and hissing in their foul tongue. “Are you alright?” 

“I’ve just fallen through a hole in the floor,” Dori points out. “I can’t say this is my best evening, Master Baggins.” 

Before they can have any more such riveting conversations, the company is being prodded by goblins on all sides. The creatures are worse than Bilbo remembers. He’s never been terribly clear on the cultural differences between these goblins and proper orcs like Azog. He knows that the goblins of the Misty Mountains are smaller than most orcs, though both groups are equally violent and horrible, as far as he’s concerned. These goblins may not be working for Azog, and they may not be his allies yet, but they certainly will be by the time of the battle. Especially considering that Bilbo’s friends are about to kill the Great Goblin. 

Bilbo decides to table that problem for the moment. He really will have to do more research, though. Absolutely abysmal that he managed to write a book in which goblins feature heavily without clarifying the terminology issue. He’d thought it irrelevant when he sat down to write, defaulting to the language most common in the Shire for the benefit of his fauntling audience, but perhaps that was the wrong decision. This is the problem with doing everything for a second time. Bilbo has questions now, for which he wants answers, and it distracts him from the task at hand. He almost misses the corner around which he is supposed to be slinking.

Bilbo knows what he has to do. As the company is driven away at the mercy of the goblins’ whips, Bilbo slips into the shadows, catching Nori’s eyes as he does. Good. Just like last time. Nori can tell the others what has become of Bilbo, once they all make it out of the mountain. It fills him with guilt, abandoning them all to their fates, but what else can Bilbo do? He can’t follow his friends, no matter how much he may want to. For one thing, he knows that his presence would change the logistics of the fight that they’re about to undertake. They made it out without him the last time, and it’s much wiser to trust that they’ll be able to do the same again than to introduce new variables and see how it pans out. They do not need his help. 

And he can’t very well drag anybody down with him. Never mind that the fall itself will be dangerous. Who knows how Gollum would react to two intruders? And having a friend with him would change the interaction in unpredictable ways. It’s far better, Bilbo decides, to trust in his friends and undertake the meeting with Gollum alone, though he has no desire whatsoever to do so. He’d be perfectly happy to skip over this exchange altogether. 

But he understands that the has no choice. Bilbo has to riddle with Gollum, because he has to pick up the ring, because he has to be invisible to fight the spiders and to help the company escape the Elves, not to mention the fact that his primary purpose here in the past is to destroy the One Ring. Bilbo wracks his brain to remember how he fell down into Gollum’s cave before. If he can remember the spot, maybe he can slide down more gracefully and avoid the bruises he incurred the first time he did this. 

But of course things couldn’t be that simple. Before Bilbo can remember where and how he fell in the first time, there’s a goblin charging at him. Oh, yes. Now he remembers. That was how he got down to Gollum. Lovely. 

Bilbo draws Sting and grapples with the goblin, trying to approximate the fighting style he would have used eighty years ago. Which is to say that he sort of stabs forward a little bit, taking little care with his aim, prioritizing blocking blows above landing them and hoping that his assailant will throw him in the same direction as last time. Once more, the goblin charges at him, and they topple together over the side of the rickety bridge and into the chasm below. Bilbo can only hope that he’s been pulled down into the same odd tunnel that he was in before. The goblin cushions his fall, but it isn’t so lucky as Dori, because it lands on some very hard and sharp rocks with Bilbo’s entire weight on top of it. It’s still alive, he thinks, but not for much longer. 

He retreats to the shadows, hiding just out of sight in this dark and damp cavern, because that is what he distinctly remembers doing the last time. If he wants to escape with his life, then he’d better not make any last-minute changes. Certainly not for the sake of a goblin that would gladly have killed him, had their positions been reversed. 

It only takes a moment for Gollum to make his presence known. Bilbo watches, from his obscure position, as the waif appears, pale and starving, to make a meal of the groggy goblin. If there was any doubt in his mind as to whether the goblin is still alive, it is completely quashed by the loud screeching that ensues. The first time around, Bilbo supposes, he was concerned that the noise would attract attention. He had no idea, then, where he was, who he was with, or what was going to happen. He’d been worried about his friends, as well. He didn’t know about the price on Thorin’s head, but he hadn’t needed to. After all, there were only thirteen of them facing off against what could only be thousands of goblins. That couldn’t have gone well, no matter how well-trained they were.

This time, however, Bilbo is distracted by something else. He keeps his eyes on Gollum and watches as the Ring flies out of the creature’s… pocket? Does Gollum have pockets, on that little rag he wears? He must. Or perhaps the very problem is that he does not. The writer in Bilbo could spend hours pondering the logistics of this. The Hobbit in Bilbo worries that his heart rate might accelerate to such a pace that the organ beats right out of his chest. Once he spots it, he cannot shift his gaze from the ring. 

The pull is much weaker than he remembers it being, but it is present all the same. Bilbo has no physical connection to the ring now, but it is still a Ring of Power. It is still the One Ring. It is still calling out constantly to every being that gets close to it, eager to take hold of any mind it can get its hands on. And Bilbo would really rather leave it there. The ache of desperation in his gut unnerves him. He could put it on and have done with it. It would be so easy to slink out of these tunnels. Bilbo already knows the way. And easier still, to sneak up on Gollum and dispose of him now, to protect the world from his crimes. Are these his own thoughts? Or do they belong to the ring? The enemy? Is Bilbo using the dark magic he knows lurks here as an excuse to indulge the worst parts of himself? 

The ring wants him to think this way, he understands. The ring wants him to distrust himself and his resolve. Bilbo did not comprehend Frodo’s stories when first he heard them, did not internalize them. By that point, his long years in Middle Earth had begun to catch up with him. Half the time, Bilbo couldn’t remember where he was or what he was doing. More than once, alone in Rivendell, he thought he was still on his adventure. He wandered out of his rooms in search of his companions, and became turned around in the halls of Elrond’s home when he did not encounter their makeshift campsite. He spoke to the air as though to members of the company, and the Elves apparently decided that he was too far gone for anyone to bother doing anything about it. 

Bilbo was in no state, then, to understand the true power of the little ring. He could not comprehend its malice, its capacity to manipulate. He could not draw the parallel between the torments Frodo underwent and little voice that spoke inside his own mind sometimes, urging cruelty and selfish violence. Bilbo rarely ever acted on the suggestions of the little voice, and it had all but disappeared by the time he learned the ring’s true nature. 

Bilbo does not know whether his decline had anything to do with the destruction of the ring itself. He does know that there were times when he could not remember that the ring was destroyed, when he forgot about what it really was, though he longed for it nevertheless. He remembers asking Frodo, on their journey West, whether he could see the cursed thing again. By this point, of course, Frodo had explained it to him many times, and every time, the story had distressed Bilbo to no end. To think that his little ring was responsible for so much pain, for hurting his own nephew, for nearly causing him to hurt his own nephew? Oh, it was unbearable.

But Bilbo must bear it now. He can’t just sit here looking at the ring. He needs it to get out of the tunnels, he reminds himself, and to save his company from the spiders and the Elves. He’ll need it when dealing with Smaug, and he needs to destroy it. If what Frodo once told him is true, the ring was trying to get away from Gollum in the first place. Who’s to say what kind of creature would pick it up next, if not for Bilbo? A goblin? An orc? For all he knows, it could be Azog the Defiler.

Bilbo does not have the luxury of refusing the ring. He does not get to choose for all of Middle Earth. He cannot shrug off the heavy cloak of duty, not just now. He may yet have peace, once the ring is gone, but for the moment, he has no choice but to take the thing and continue his adventure. So take it he does. He lunges forward and collects the ring, which is cool in his hands. It is not what he remembers. 

The last time he held it, after his birthday party, in Bag End, the ring was warm and comforting. Thrumming, always thrumming, a soft murmur of incomprehensible voices. Powerful, yes, of course it was powerful. Bilbo remembers feeling as though he could take on just about anything, so long as he had his ring with him. He couldn’t bear to part with it. It was like a pair of arms forever wrapped around him, a perpetual piggy-back-ride for a power beyond his comprehension. It was as though he was wearing armor always, protected and cocooned, no matter how stretched or warped his mind became. Now, however, it is little more than a cool piece of metal.

It’s not any heavier than a regular ring, and it certainly doesn’t have anything to say. The ring is weaker now, Bilbo supposes, because its master is weaker. He never noticed as the power contained within the ring increased, but obviously, it must have done so, tucked away in the pocket of his waistcoat. It was a gradual process, and as the ring grew more powerful, its hold on Bilbo grew tighter. For now, though, Bilbo truly thinks that he could put it down if he needed to.

No, he couldn’t. He does need the ring to complete his quest, so its relative power and his relative reliance on it are both moot points. Bilbo briefly considers putting the ring on now, making himself invisible, and slinking out of the tunnels that way, but there are several problems with that plan. For one thing, he’s not entirely certain that he remembers the way out of the tunnels. It was eighty years ago, after all, and he was highly preoccupied, and to Bilbo’s Hobbit-y eyes, all these stalactites and stalagmites really just look the same. He’s not convinced that he’ll be able to navigate out of here without Gollum’s help.

Also, the issue of timing is not far from his mind. If Bilbo leaves too early, he may not be able to catch up with the company. He may get lost searching for them in the woods before they’re even out of the tunnels. He may come to the exit and find it blocked, because Gandalf and the company have not yet been through. He may find goblins down there. And if he comes out too early, there is always a chance that he could run into some hitherto unknown threat. There are orcs and wargs prowling these woods, after all, and for all he knows, they were lucky enough the last time to have missed a scouting party. 

Yes, the Valar are on his side, but that does not mean that Bilbo should take unnecessary chances. He’s gotten past Gollum before, hasn’t he? And that all turned out fine. So, sighing, he steps out of the shadows and endures the whole rigamarole again. He riddles with Gollum, just like he did the first time, though now, he is much less frightened, because he knows almost exactly what will come to pass. Bilbo has told and re-told and written and re-written this conversation many times, so, at the very least, he remembers the riddles he used and how Gollum responded to them. And, of course, he remembers all of the answers to Gollum’s riddles. 

It feels a bit unfair, tricking the poor creature with the ‘what have I got in my pocket’ question, but Bilbo decides that he would rather deal with the same sticky situation a second time than put himself in an even stickier situation by coming up with a different riddle. After all, Gollum might guess that, and then produce a new riddle that poor Bilbo has never heard before. It won’t do anybody any good if he gets eaten by that creature. And he’s already playing it fast and loose. He’s made one very significant change by refusing to give the creature his name. That way, even if he fails, nobody will ever come to the Shire to bother Frodo. Even if Gollum is tortured (poor creature, Yavanna save him) he won’t have any information to give up.

As expected, Gollum is not pleased with Bilbo’s victory, or the fact that Bilbo has stolen the ring. Which he has done. It wasn’t his to take, and he took it, took it from this poor, pathetic creature who has nothing else in the world. Bilbo does feel somewhat sorry about that, though it would by no means be a good thing if Gollum retained the ring. Bilbo puts the ring on and follows the creature, just as he did the last time. He loses just as many buttons, and if he’d had more, he’s certain he would lose more. Thanks to his provisions, Bilbo hasn’t lost as much weight on this journey as he did on his first go. He’s much healthier, which means that he has more energy and can move faster. A good trade off, especially considering that, being a Hobbit, he is still small enough to fit through most of the tight spaces he encounters. And, anyway, all that weight will fall off him in Mirkwood no matter how much food he stores away. He could carry Beorn’s larder on his back, and still the company would end up going hungry in those awful woods. 

At the end of the tunnel, with Sting poised over Gollum’s neck, Bilbo hesitates. It would be so easy to end everything right now. He knows this creature’s future, after all. He knows that Gollum will spend decades wandering around in search of his Precious, alone and lonely and miserable and angry. He knows that eventually, the enemy’s forces will capture poor Gollum and do unspeakable things to him. And then, of course, Gollum will follow Frodo, who will show him kindness and pay the price for it. Ultimately, Gollum will do bodily harm to Bilbo’s beloved nephew before falling into a fire mountain and dissolving in the heat. 

Wouldn’t it be kinder to prevent all of that misery now? Gandalf’s advice about mercy surely doesn’t apply when Bilbo knows exactly what Gollum will do to Bilbo’s own kin. He would only do it to protect Frodo. And Gollum’s life can’t be worth very much, anyway. He’s just going to suffer for another eighty years until he dies a painful death. Bilbo could save everyone a lot of trouble by getting rid of him right now. But, then, who is Bilbo to decide that one creature’s life is worth more than another’s? Who is Bilbo to decide who deserves life and who deserves death? Not to mention that, should Bilbo succeed, Gollum will never enact the horrible deeds that Bilbo remembers. He can’t punish this lonely, tortured person for crimes he might have committed under circumstances that will never come to pass. 

So he spares Gollum once again, darts out of the tunnel just like he did the first time, and makes his way, only slightly shaken, over to the clearing where the company awaits him. Bilbo is so busy bracing himself for Thorin’s scathing words and unfounded accusations that he forgets, if only for a moment, what he knows will happen after. 

Notes:

... Now that I think about it, the next chapter is going to be even angstier, so brace yourselves, I guess?