Chapter Text
When Thorin was young, a spoiled little prince with a kingdom guaranteed to him, he was frightened of the Greenwood. He did not like the Elves, with their long bodies and unblinking eyes. He did not like the thought of trees, with their constant noise and constant movement, nothing like the steady, solid stone of Erebor. He did not like the idea of a place that teemed with creatures, the birds that fluttered and the rodents that crawled along the ground. Much like his grandfather, Thorin avoided the Greenwood at all costs. His first true experience of the forest came when he fled through it, leading his family and his people away from the dragon that had stolen their home. It seemed a fell place, unfamiliar and crowded.
But Thorin would gladly take a hundred years in that forest over whatever shadow of it he now travels through. The Hobbit spoke, just before the Wizard left them at the edge of the woods, of a sickness lurking among the trees. Thorin cannot sense it, but he believes the Burglar nevertheless. Master Baggins would not lie to him. There is some malady hanging over these lands, something horrible, unspeakable. He can feel it reaching into his brain and scrambling his thoughts, misdirecting him.
He sees things that he knows cannot be there. Large eyes watching through the trees. Small eyes, blinking in the night. Mithril glinting between branches above him as he tries and fails to sleep. The more he sees these things, though, the more he begins to wonder if perhaps he can trust his perception, after all.
The days blur together. Thorin does not know how long he has been in these woods, how long it was since Tharkûn left them at the edge of the forest, since they sent off Beorn’s ponies. He does know that their supplies are dwindling already, that there are fewer honey cakes than he would like to see and far too little cheese. What fruit Beorn sent with them is beginning to spoil, and the other provisions will soon follow, assuming they last long enough to do so.Thorin cannot remember the last time there was meat to be had. But then, he can barely remember what he’s doing in this cursed forest to begin with.
Erebor, he tells himself when his steps begin to drag, when the air feels thin and the trees seem to crowd him, Erebor. That is why he does this.
Once, Thorin swears that he sees Thráin, old and haggard, wandering aimlessly just a little to the left of the path. Balin grabs hold of the back of Thorin’s coat before he can even think about darting after his father. “Thorin,” Balin counsels him, “No. The Wizard said not to leave the path.”
“My father is out there,” Thorin tries to tell him. “He is out there. I must go to him.”
“I can assure you that he is not,” is Balin’s assertion, but Thorin isn’t so sure.
But when he looks again, his father is gone, as though he were never there. Perhaps Thorin only caught sight of his own reflection. How much has this quest aged him, in only a few short months? No. There is nothing there for his image to be reflected in. It must have been some trick of this wicked forest, he tells himself. That is all.
Thorin is not going mad. His proximity to Erebor is not driving him to dragon sickness. He has not fallen to Thrór’s malady. He is well. He is strong. He is not his grandfather. He is not his grandfather. Only, his hands look older in the faint light that seeps through the trees than they did in the skin-changer’s hall. Sometimes, he swears that he can see his grandfather’s ring on his finger, but that cannot be. It went missing with his father. His father. Where is Thráin? Thorin must search for him! Why did he stop searching?
This time, it is Master Baggins who pulls him back onto the path. He shudders at the touch of the soft hand, even through his heavy coat. Thorin feels as though he is being dragged deep into the ground, back into the safety of a mountain, while simultaneously floating far above his own head. He is being spun around in circles, yet his inertia could kill him.
“Don’t go,” the Hobbit whispers, eyes wide.
Thorin can see himself reflected in those brilliant irises. He is not his grandfather. He is Thorin, son of Thráin, and he is strong. The King Under the Mountain. He will take his homeland back and he will rule it well and he will have this Hobbit as his consort. When they reach Erebor, Thorin will find all the best jewels in his possession and he will give each and every one to Bilbo Baggins. He will fall to his knees, he will shower this lovely and perplexing creature with gifts, he will protect him at all costs.
“You must stay,” the Hobbit pleads, “You must stay with me. Don’t go, Thorin; please don’t leave me again.”
Thorin has no intention of going anywhere. He wants to tell Bilbo as much, to catch the Hobbit in his arms and never let him go. He does not like the way the others look at Bilbo. Thorin feels a sudden rage at the concerned expression on Bofur’s face. What business is it of Bofur’s if Bilbo and Thorin want to have a conversation? The Hobbit is his.
He takes two more steps forward and it all falls away. Why is Thorin angry? Of course Bofur would be concerned. The Hobbit looks to be near tears. And why? Because Thorin nearly stepped off the path. Stupid of him, yes, but not worth crying over. “Are you alright, Master Baggins?” He asks softly, trying not to startle his Burglar.
The Hobbit’s eyes are glazed over. He does not look as though he is entirely here, entirely present in the moment as he continues to grip at Thorin’s sleeve, muttering nonsense about not leaving him. As though Thorin ever could. He turns back to Bofur, in search of aid, the comfort of knowing that someone else here is aware enough to notice that something is not right, but when he glances back, Bofur is glaring daggers at a tree.
“This place is cursed,” Thorin mutters. “We should not linger here. Forward!”
His words don’t have very much effect on the rest of the company, but at least they appear to shock Bilbo out of whatever reverie has lately gripped him. “Oh my goodness, I’m so sorry!” He exclaims, letting go of Thorin’s coat with a sheepish little laugh. Thorin wishes never to take his eyes off of the Hobbit. He would be pleased, he thinks, to do nothing but look upon Bilbo for the rest of his days. No treasure in any mountain could ever compare. “I was clinging to you like a leech.”
Thorin is just about to offer Bilbo his hand, but his next step assures him that this is not a sound plan. Mirkwood itself is already distracting enough. Thorin cannot focus on the warmth of the Hobbit’s touch, the softness of his skin. He must direct whatever energy he can muster toward getting his company out of these woods.
Bilbo’s face radiates heat as he steps away from Thorin. Oh, how terribly embarrassing! The memory is fuzzy now, which is troubling, considering its recency, but Bilbo knows that he had no idea where he was just then. Seeing Thorin confused him. He thought the king was a ghost, a spirit, but he wasn’t able to restrain himself from reaching out. And when his hand made contact with the cool cloth of Thorin’s coat, Bilbo burst into tears.
It makes perfect sense to Bilbo. This place is under some fell enchantment, and the entire company is on edge. Bilbo in particular is especially on edge, because he alone knows exactly what is going to happen to them in Mirkwood. First, their minds will weaken. Then, they will forget the Wizard’s advice and wander off the path. Next, they will be attacked by giant spiders. Finally, they’ll be thrown into Elven dungeons, and only then will they begin to think clearly again. And poor Bombur is going to fall into the enchanted stream at some point. When? Now? No, not now, they aren’t by the stream.
Shouldn’t there be a boat? And a stag. Last time, there was a stag. Bilbo distinctly remembers. Was it a stag? Perhaps an elk?
A dragon. There was a dragon, breathing heavy fire over the land, nearly killing Bilbo.
No, no, a stag. It was definitely a stag, pure white. Who shot at it? Somebody tried to kill it and failed. Succeeded? Bilbo can see the dead deer in front of him, flies swarming its great white body, stained red. But nobody else seems bothered. “Look,” he says, “Look, look.”
“There’s nothing there.” Dwalin claps his hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. Bilbo looks at his friend’s grim face, then back at the deer, and he finds that Dwalin speaks true. There is nothing blocking their path.
Right. But there was a deer the first time. Someone tried to kill it. Who? Bard killed the beast, but Bilbo had not been there to watch. He waited and waited for the dragon to return, stared out at Lake-town and thought of his friends burning to death on that little island, only to find that they were all miraculously alive and well, the dragon lying in the middle of the lake. No. That was later. There was a deer. What about the deer?
Thorin shot at it, but he missed, and the creature ran away. It reminds Bilbo of another arrow, fired from a much nicer bow and a much greater height, a warning shot placed at the feet of an Elven king. That was the beginning of the end, the day that Thorin sealed his fate. Would things have turned out differently, if he’d offered gold to the Men and Elves, friendship rather than war? But that does not matter. Things will not turn out any differently. The moment Thorin sets foot inside that mountain, the dragon’s hoard will begin to poison his mind.
What are they doing, going to Erebor? What is Bilbo doing, going to Erebor when he knows that his friends will die there? He cannot do this. He cannot do this. Oh, but he must! He must follow Thorin, because there is no universe where he can force his king to stay behind. Not if Bilbo locked him up, as though that were possible. There is no way around this; Bilbo and the company must press forward. He must keep going.
Bilbo forces his feet to move. He follows blindly, allowing himself to be led, trusting the company. Why is he trusting the company? He knows what’s going to happen. He knows what to expect from this place, and he is letting it happen again. Bilbo knows what to expect. He knows what’s coming next.
What is coming next? He wracks his brain and can’t remember. The only thing he is sure of is the padding of his feet against the root-strewn ground, the heavy rhythm of his steps on the forest floor. The trees are blurry, and he loses track of each of his companions.
“We found the bridge!” Kíli announces.
It takes Bilbo a few seconds to get his bearings, to figure out where everyone is. After that, it takes a few more seconds to look ahead and notice the bridge, or rather, the lack thereof. “Something… took it out,” Bilbo muses. He is fascinated by this idea. What could be big enough, strong enough, to destroy a bridge? There is a large chunk missing from the middle of it, making the stream impassible. But… where is that chunk? Bilbo looks down into the water in a vain attempt to locate the stones. “Where did it go?”
“We could try and swim it,” suggests an echoing voice behind him. Bilbo cannot place the speaker.
“Didn’t you hear what Gandalf said?” But that voice, Bilbo would know anywhere. Thorin is here. Bilbo feels safer all of a sudden. He knows, in his heart, that he will be perfectly secure so long as he travels with Thorin Oakenshield. No, that’s not right. It’s the other way around. He’s supposed to be the one keeping Thorin safe. “A dark magic lies upon this forest. The waters of this stream are enchanted.” But it is difficult to think about the words when the voice that speaks them is so pleasant. This is a voice from Bilbo’s dreams, a voice that gave him comfort across long years when he was all alone in the world.
“Doesn’t look very enchanting to me,” Bofur mumbles, staring into the stream.
“Do you see the rest of the bridge anywhere?” Bilbo asks. He cannot imagine where it could have gone. It would be very large, after all.
“I do not,” Balin pipes in. Bilbo turns and finds his friend staring behind them, which might explain his inability to locate the rest of the bridge. Although, then again, Bilbo is staring in front of them, and he can’t find it either.
“Not up here, neither,” Ori reports helpfully. He is looking skyward, up among the branches.
“We must find another way across,” Thorin resolves. At least someone is thinking clearly. Ha! Thorin, thinking clearly. This would be the first time.
“These vines look strong enough,” Kíli suggests, placing one boot on the base of a tangling mass of vines that seems to reach out across the river. Something about this feels very familiar to Bilbo. He has been here before. There were vines before.
“I remember this place,” Bilbo mutters. He can hear his own heartbeat in his ears.
“You’ve been here before?” Fíli seems to think that this might be plausible. “When?”
“I don’t know,” Bilbo admits. “But it isn’t right.”
“Kíli!!” Thorin calls his younger nephew back, though Kíli was making good headway. “We send the lightest first.”
“Why?” Bilbo asks. “Even if I make it across, it doesn’t mean the rest of you have any hope.”
But for some reason, he knows that he will make it across. He is certain of it, in his heart. He has already navigated these vines, and he has already cleared them. He can do it once more. But he has a strange feeling that something horrible will happen once he does, and he does not want to find out what comes next.
“Master Baggins,” Thorin does not sound particularly patient. Well, that’s nothing new. Bilbo is beginning to forget precisely who Thorin is, but he remembers that his friend is impatient. And demanding. And very handsome. Bilbo has seen him before somewhere. In Bag End? On a battlefield. There was a battle, and something went wrong. “Do not worry. I am right behind you.”
“What if you fall in?” Bilbo asks.
“I will not,” Thorin resolves. Bilbo trusts him.
There was a battle, he thinks as he steps out onto the first vine. And something went horribly wrong. Only Bilbo cannot remember exactly what happened. There was an Elf queen involved, and a bear that rode a giant bird, and an evil eye watching from a dark tower. The party tree, a disappearing trick, and Gandalf’s fireworks. A sword, and blood. A long fall. The sound of bones cracking. Goblin tunnels. Spiders. The broken scales of a dragon’s belly. A young Hobbit, getting caught stealing mushrooms. The Shire, ravaged. A mountain under siege.
Bilbo nearly falls off of the vines, which reminds him where he is. Where is he? The woods somewhere, crossing some water.
“Keep going,” Thorin urges, his voice sounding oddly soft, though he remains on the bank of the stream while Bilbo makes his crossing.
“I’m fine,” Bilbo assures him, “It’s all fine.” If there was a battle, it must have been a thousand years ago. Bilbo has been in this forest for as long as he can remember. He slips a few more times, but manages to cling to the branches with his legs. The water seems to ripple. Ah, of course. Just his luck. Is it speaking to him? No. That is not possible. There was a battle. Bilbo can remember rushing through it, orcs and Elves slashing at each other as he barreled past. A hill he had to climb. “Everything’s fine.”
Before he knows it, he is scrambling onto the bank. Something terrible is going to happen. Bilbo does not know what, but something. He can feel it in his heart, in his head, in his very bones and all his muscles.
“Something’s not right,” he realizes. The words feel strange in his mouth, as though he has spoken them before. “It’s not right at all. Stay where you are!”
But the company is already scrambling across, and having much less luck than Bilbo did. They are all heavier than he is, after all, and not so lithe. They get stuck. They stare into the water. They teeter precariously, clinging to vines which do not look strong enough to hold their weight.
Bilbo blinks, and Thorin is beside him on the bank. How? When did he get here? “Are you alright?” The king inquires. Thorin is the king of something, Bilbo can remember that.
“Fine,” Bilbo manages.
A hand reaches out for him. To choke him, Bilbo realizes. To hold him over a ledge and shake him. Why? Why would Thorin do something like that? Because Bilbo betrayed him. How? Bilbo cannot recall. He flinches away from Thorin’s touch.
“I will not harm you,” Thorin resolves, “I will never harm you. Have I not proven that to you by now?”
The king looks hurt, which Bilbo thinks is somewhat unfair. Thorin is the one who attacked Bilbo before, the one who tried to attack him again just now. Is Bilbo not entitled to flinch away from that? He doesn’t want to be thrown into the water, thrown down from the battlements, thrown out into the fighting.
“But I took it.” The moment Bilbo says this, he knows it to be true. He stole something from Thorin. “It’s all my fault.”
There are Elves and orcs slashing at each other down there, a hill Bilbo must climb. He has to climb the hill. He can’t stay here standing around waiting for Thorin to kill him.
“Yes.” Thorin smiles then, ever-so-slightly, though his eyes remain cautious and his hands upheld. “You have taken something important, my Burglar.”
A confused response dies on Bilbo’s lips when a white stag bounds into the clearing. The sounds of the company behind them fade, and Bilbo turns his head to focus on the stag. He remembers this. And he remembers remembering this. He has seen this creature before.
He can feel a bowstring being pulled taught in his peripheral vision. “What are you doing?” Bilbo asks, though he knows already. Thorin is going to kill the deer.
The king does not seem to hear him. He stares straight ahead, locking eyes with the stag before loosing his arrow and missing. Thorin breathes heavily, and his hair is a mess, the careful braids his nephews wove into it in Beorn’s hall having come entirely undone. When did this happen? Just how long have they been in Mirkwood, that this could have time to happen?
“You shouldn’t have done that,” Bilbo murmurs, laying a hand on Thorin’s arm. Despite himself, he finds he likes the feel of the warmth underneath all those clothes. Too many clothes, in Bilbo’s opinion, but that is of no consequence in these woods. Still, he could keep his hand on Thorin’s arm all day. “It’s bad luck,” Bilbo realizes.
“I don’t believe in luck,” Thorin snarls, though he doesn’t move away from Bilbo’s touch. “We make our own luck.”
Bilbo blinks at him. A face that beautiful should not exist. It is not possible. How does Bilbo know that Thorin is really here? He’s been dead for eighty years, of course he isn’t here. This is another nightmare. Bilbo is in another of his nightmares, that is the only possible explanation. He needs to wake up! But how?
A loud splash answers his question. Bombur has fallen into the stream! Of course he has! Bilbo remembers this, as well. Bombur fell into the stream before, didn’t he? “We have to help him,” Bilbo declares, but Thorin holds out an arm, barring his way.
“You will stay here,” the king orders, a decided edge to his tone. “By my side, where you belong.”
“Bombur has fallen into the stream!” Bilbo protests.
“The others can get him out. You will not leave my side,” Thorin reiterates. “I will not see harm done to you.”
“But what about Bombur?” Bilbo feels as though he is trying to have a conversation with a stone wall.
Thorin grips his shoulders and stares at him for a moment that seems to drag on a little too long. “I will not see you harmed.”
Bilbo says nothing, only stares up at Thorin for what feels like only a few seconds. When they pull apart, however, he realizes that it has been much longer. The rest of the company has already heaved Bombur out of the stream and onto the bank. “We should make something to carry him,” Bilbo breathes. He distinctly remembers Bombur being brought through the forest on a stretcher.
“Stay by my side,” Thorin orders. Single-minded as always, even when his mind is falling apart. He was like that before, too.
Before? What happened before? There was a rock involved. Bilbo gave away a rock, and Thorin was not pleased with him.
In the time that it takes Bilbo to wrack his brain for memories that will not come, the others manage to heave Bombur onto a makeshift stretcher, someone’s bedroll slung over two strong, heavy boughs, and they press onward. It takes four of them to carry him.
They make camp. Over and over again, they make camp. The forest stretches on forever and Bilbo does not know what to make of it, does not know how long they have traveled or how far. It is perpetually hazy outside, so it is difficult for Bilbo’s Hobbit eyes to tell when it is night and when it is day. His friends can all see perfectly well in the dark, but when they grow too tired to proceed, they rest. The bedding they carry is courtesy of Beorn and Dori, who worked together during their stay to supplement what could be found among the skin-changer’s stores. Some of the stronger members of the company carry man-sized bedrolls, though why Beorn would need these, Bilbo does not know. Could he not simply transform himself into a bear whenever he gets tired? But perhaps there are places he travels to where it is safer to be a man than it is to be a bear. Bilbo should like to stay a Hobbit for as long as he is able.
“By my side,” Thorin orders.
Usually, their leader does not sleep. He keeps watch for most of the night, laying down when he is forced to but keeping his eyes open. Sometimes, he sets his bedroll down beside Bilbo’s, though he does this only once he is certain that the Hobbit is asleep. But even when he is awake, Bilbo feels as though he’s deep in dreams. The pack he carries is over-large, taken from Beorn as everything else is, and it weighs him down, despite being near-empty.
“You could ask nicely,” he grumbles. But he does as he is told and throws his bedroll on the ground beside Thorin’s. Why?
Because he would have done it anyway, even if he hadn’t been ordered to. “You must not stray far,” Thorin informs him, as though there were a chance of him doing so. “I would keep you by my side, where it is safe.”
“A spider could scoop me up and eat me just as well next to you as it could if I were by myself,” Bilbo points out, “You didn’t do this last time, and it all turned out just fine.”
“No,” Thorin argues against Bilbo’s very reasonable statement. “I will defend you.”
“You will be asleep,” Bilbo reminds him.
“Even so, I will defend you.” This makes no sense at all!
But Bilbo is exhausted from so much walking, and he doesn’t understand why he is even fighting on this score. It’s not as though he isn’t pleased to sleep beside Thorin! Just that he is perplexed as to why they are having a conversation about it, and why it has to be this conversation, of all the discussions they might possibly undertake. Mirkwood has shortened everybody’s tempers. They are running out of food and water, they are tired, and Bombur must be carried and guarded at all times.
“Oh, whatever,” Bilbo grumbles. He lays his bedroll beside Thorin’s and settles down to sleep.
He dreams of a million eyes above him, watching as he sleeps. Or he does not dream and wakes periodically to see a million eyes above him, watching as he rests. Beside him, Thorin sleeps like the dead. Bilbo laughs wetly at that, a dark joke that isn’t very funny and brings tears to his eyes. He never could find humor in it all, no matter how he tried. He searched for irony, old lines about what happens on adventures and why respectable Hobbits should never endeavor to undertake them. But Bilbo has never considered those jokes very funny, and he finds himself reaching for Thorin, just to feel that he is warm and breathing and alive. Then he remembers himself and jerks his hand back. It is only one night, or it is two nights, or three, or four, or five. Bilbo has no idea. He loses count easily in this horrible place.
But in the morning he wakes to see Thorin looming over him, brandishing a bundle of cloth. “Why do you have this?” The king demands.
“Why do I have what?” Bilbo asks, groggy.
The other members of the company are breakfasting, eating the last of the honey-cakes in deliberately tiny bites, trying to trick their bodies into believing that it is a proper meal. With Bombur unconscious, Bifur has taken up role of company chef, though his skills don’t seem to extend beyond handing out the provisions from Beorn. Bilbo would gladly cook for his fellows, but he lacks the strength to carry all of their foodstuffs. Or, he did when they set out. Now, Bilbo suspects that he could lift that particular bag easily, and not because he’s gotten any stronger.
Some of the company are polite enough to avert their eyes. Most of them lack the decency even to disguise their staring. And they are not the only ones.
The day is young and new and fresh and the sun is slow to come to Mirkwood and the tiny little eyes that dance above them like blinking stars are ever-present. Bilbo hopes he is imagining them. He knows, in some deep part of himself, that he is not. “This.” Thorin shoves the bundle in Bilbo’s face.
Óin curses loudly, somewhere off to the side. Probably, he thinks he’s being quiet. Presumably, he recognizes the thing being waved around and understands its significance. Bilbo, however, takes a moment to process what is being show to him.
A shirt. An over-large shirt. A Man’s shirt. A skin-changer’s shirt. “What do you mean, why do I have it?”
“Why did he give you this?” Thorin growls, apparently not pleased. He shakes the garment once more.
A small, fur-wrapped bundle tumbles out and onto the forest floor. It lands amongst the dead leaves on the ground beside Bilbo’s bedroll, but Thorin does not seem aware of it.“Why did he give you this?” He demands again.
“He didn’t,” Bilbo tells the truth, exasperated. Who is Thorin to make demands about what’s in Bilbo’s pack. “Why were you going through my things? I stole it, if you must know. I had need of the fabric.”
“What need?” Thorin snarls.
Bilbo picks up the smaller bundle and slips it into his pocket. Thorin doesn’t even notice. He is so focused on the stupid shirt, this shirt of Beorn’s that Bilbo took to disguise the magic of the ring. Instantly, Bilbo feels at ease, more able to make sense of his surroundings. It is as though the spell of the forest has forgotten about him, passed over him. “I was hoping to make a smaller shirt out of it,” Bilbo lies primly, “One that might actually fit me. I can’t imagine I smell very good, wearing the same thing every day. May I have it back, please? Nothing to do with Beorn, just that he was the only one nearby with fabric for the taking. Well, save Dori, but he’d have gotten me with those scissors of his if I even tried it.”
“Lay off, Thorin,” Dwalin advises. “Let the Halfling have his shirt back.”
“Hobbit,” Bilbo and Thorin correct him at the same time.
Bilbo knew that Thorin didn’t like Beorn. He never did, not really, but he tolerated him better on the first adventure. “You shouldn’t go through other people’s things,” Bilbo informs the king.
He should be more careful in his concealment of the ring. Thank the Valar for Thorin’s jealousy! Otherwise, who knows what could have happened? If he’d not been distracted by the shirt, would he have discovered the ring? But what reason does Thorin have to be jealous of Beorn? He could not possibly… oh. Oh, goodness. Bilbo finds, all of a sudden, that the dead leaves littering the ground are quite interesting.
“Did you not go through the skin-changer’s things when you took this shirt from him?” Thorin asks. He could not possibly return Bilbo’s feelings. Not yet. Not now.
But why not? Plenty of things on this journey have been different from Bilbo’s first adventure. He and Thorin have spent more time together than they ever did before. Thorin excused himself from the dinner table when Beorn ventured to tease Bilbo, and now, the king is upset with Bilbo for carrying one of the skin-changer’s shirts in his pack.
Not that it matters. Bilbo’s first priority is to keep his secret and defend the ring. He must protect Thorin from the wicked magic, and he must ensure the safety of the company as they traverse the forest. They’ve still got to deal with the spiders and the Elves and the blasted barrels, and then they’ll be nearly there. If there is a conversation to be had, Lake-town is the place to have it. But not here.
“Yes, well, that’s different. I didn’t get caught,” Bilbo replies, forcing himself to keep a light tone. “And you marched up to me and turned yourself in. And by the way, it’s barely even morning yet. I would’ve liked to get a little bit more sleep before another day of traipsing through the woods, you know.”
Thorin only scowls at him and marches off. He must know that he’s being ridiculous. He can’t be angry with Bilbo for carrying someone else’s shirt in his pack for perfectly practical reasons. Especially not when the two of them have not arrived at any sort of understanding! And now Thorin is going to be in a foul mood for the remainder of the journey through Mirkwood. Bilbo had better steer clear of him as much as possible.
It troubles Bilbo that Thorin’s behavior is different than it was the last time they did this. They survived last time, yes, but most of that was due to chance. Bilbo happened to be above the trees when the spiders attacked, enabling him to save his friends. All of them were caught and strung up alive, and the spiders did not happen to kill anyone before Bilbo could pull off a rather slapdash rescue. The Wood Elves were in the right place at the right time to intervene, and the entire company just so happened to be together. But what might happen if Thorin’s priorities have changed? Will he fight differently, when the spiders attack? Will he be more aggressive with the Elves? Or will he be distracted, looking for an invisible Hobbit in the midst of an important skirmish?
It all sounds very vain to think about, but Bilbo must consider these things. He cannot change anything at this point in the adventure. Already, he has been too casual, too free with his actions and words. He cannot distract Thorin, and it won’t do to let Thorin distract him in return, either. Bilbo had better keep his distance from the king for the time being.
A sound and solid plan, or the soundest and most solid of plans concocted within the bounds of Mirkwood. Bilbo takes up the shirt again and carefully wraps the ring, shoving it back into his pack. Well. That’s no more sleep for him, then.
They break camp and start walking again. There is nothing else to do here, with their food supplies dwindling dangerously and the enchantment of the forest wreaking havoc on their minds.It isn’t long before Bilbo becomes aware of the heavy silence that hangs over the woods. Odd. Bilbo knows for a fact that the last time he was here, he heard whispering in the trees overhead. “There should be voices,” Bilbo murmurs. “Does anyone hear voices?”
“I hear nothing,” Thorin growls, “No wind. No birdsong. What hour is it?” His voice seems distorted, as though he is calling up to Bilbo from the bottom of a very deep well.
“I do not know,” Dwalin confesses, “I do not even know what day it is.”
“I can’t remember what year it is,” Bilbo realizes. This is not good.
“This is taking too long! Is there no end to this accursed forest?” Thorin ignores Bilbo altogether and shouts into the trees. His voice echoes, coming back to them again and again.
Bilbo knows that he should remember exactly how long it takes to navigate this forest, and how to get out of it, too. But that can’t be. Bilbo has no idea how to get out of this forest.
“Not that I can see,” Glóin says. He looks so terribly young, nothing like the old graybeard Bilbo last met at Rivendell. Can people age backwards, here in this horrid place? “Only trees and more trees.”
“There. This way!” Thorin roars. The others protest, but their leader ignores them, pushing past them in his effort to abandon the path. “Do as I say! Follow me!”
Bilbo would follow Thorin to the end of the earth, he decides, but he is a little hesitant to leave the path. There is something not quite right about this forest. Bilbo is distracted by a silvery mess in front of him. What is that? Fishing line? No, no… a spiderweb. A very large spiderweb.
All of a sudden, Bilbo remembers something very important. “Spiders!” He yells to no avail. The company is already too far ahead of him. They cannot hear him. “There are giant spiders in these woods! They will catch you all! I will have to fight them!” He distinctly remembers cutting each member of the company out of the spiderwebs, one by one.
“There are no spiders, Bilbo.” Fíli has turned back to collect Bilbo, grabbing him by the arm and dragging him forward. Bilbo would not move otherwise. He wants the company to turn around, but he knows he cannot argue with Thorin. He will only be told to stay by his leader’s side, over and over again, until Bilbo runs out of things to say in return. “We are the only creatures in these woods.”
“No,” Bilbo protests. “There was a dragon.” There was a dragon, fire-breathing and fierce. Was it not in these woods?
“The dragon is in Erebor,” Fíli reminds him very helpfully, “I don’t know anything about the spiders.”
“What spiders?” Bilbo is confused beyond belief.
“I have no idea.” Fíli drags him back into line with the rest of the company, and their conversation fizzles out. Bilbo tries to figure out what the lad was talking about. Spiders? Where would he get a silly idea like that?
Bilbo marches onward, trying to remember where he is. He stares down at his feet, feeling as though he is floating and flying. Is he moving forward or backward? Forward. He’s moving forward. He must be in the Old Forest. That’s not something a respectable Hobbit would do. It’s more suitable behavior for a faunt, one who doesn’t know better. A faunt! Frodo must have run into these woods, and Bilbo must be following him. Yes, that makes sense. Little Frodo has been living at Brandy Hall since the deaths of his parent, and Bilbo often visits to watch over the lad and his young cousins. Frodo is the adventurous sort, though, always dashing off. Bilbo looks ahead. Frodo is not there.
Bilbo has lost his nephew. He has lost young Frodo somewhere in the woods! The trees here are alive! This is not a safe place for a little one to wander alone. What was Bilbo thinking? He must find Frodo before it is too late. His heart accelerates, remembering what happened to Drogo and Primula. If Bilbo isn’t careful, something even worse could happen to poor Frodo. This is what Bilbo gets, all caught up in his books and maps all day, stuck in the past. He’s a horrible guardian.
An awful one, really. Because Frodo is not in the Old Forest, nor is he safe in Bag End. He is in Mordor. Gandalf and Elrond have sent young Frodo away from Bilbo, off to his death, and it is Bilbo’s fault for being so irresponsible. For picking up a cursed ring and giving it to his nephew in the first place.
“Look,” says a voice behind him. Is that Ori? Bilbo hasn’t seen Ori in years!
“A tobacco pouch. There’s Dwarves in these woods.” And Dori! They must have come to visit him in the Shire. It’s happened before, after all. Perhaps they could help him find young Frodo.
“Dwarves from the Blue Mountains, no less.” And Bofur is here as well. What are they all looking at? Why have they all stopped walking? Frodo is missing! They must make haste. “This is exactly the same as mine.”
All of a sudden, Bilbo is stricken with a sense that he has lived this out before. He remembers shouting at the top of his lungs: Because it is yours. Do you understand? We’re going round in circles, we are lost! But this makes no sense. They are not going around in circles. Bilbo has never seen this place before. Has he? He must have, if he remembers it so vividly. “I think we’ve been here before,” Bilbo says, “We must be lost.”
“We’re not lost,” Thorin argues. He just loves to contradict Bilbo, does’t he? They’ll never find Frodo if they keep bickering like this. “We keep heading East.”
The others break down into various complains. Bilbo has heard all of this before. When has he heard this before? If only he could remember, perhaps he might also recall the way out. If there is a way out.
“That’s the problem, then. We should be going West. Home is to the West,” Bilbo knows this much for certain.
“I think we are going West,” Nori declares, “Sun’s off that way.” He gestures through the trees, though Bilbo cannot see this alleged sun for the life of him.
There is a murmur of voices in response to this, but Bilbo pays it no mind. He is busy looking up above his head. It must not be too far to the highest canopy of the forest. Hobbits do not typically have very much love for heights, but Bilbo is willing to make an exception under these circumstances. If he can climb up high enough, perhaps he’ll be able to see Frodo on the ground. His old friends are no help. Bilbo will have to take matters into his own hands.
Bilbo ignores the squabbling behind him and steps forward, using some conveniently low branches to get a foothold on a nearby tree. There is a vague sense of rightness about this action, as though Bilbo must do it, because he has done it before. When? He can’t remember. But he does know that he has done it, and it will be easy to do it again. All he needs to do is scurry up the trunk, get himself into the higher branches, and…
A strong hand comes down on his shoulder, gripping his jacket more tightly than would be necessary simply to stop him from climbing up. Who is stopping him from climbing up?
“No,” Thorin’s ghost tells him resolutely. “It is too dangerous.”
“You’re not being reasonable,” Bilbo complains. “I want to make sure we’re going the right way.”
“We are going the right way,” the spirit assures him, “We are heading East, as I told you. I can feel it in my blood.”
Bilbo shudders. It is news to him that ghosts have blood, and he isn’t sure he appreciates it. “All the same,” he manages to say. Something feels very wrong about this, indeed. “I don’t know where he is, and I want to see if I can find him.”
“And who is ‘he,’ exactly?” Thorin demands, not sounding very pleased. “The skin-changer said himself that he would not look out for you here.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes. Now is really not the time for this. He knows that Thorin is capable of great possessiveness, but to assume that Bilbo would love anybody else after Ravenhill? To assume that Bilbo could ever move on from that, could ever trust anybody with that part of himself, even if he wanted to? To assume that he would ever have any desire to paper over the memory of what they shared together? It’s preposterous. And to suggest that Bilbo might have some interest in Beorn, of all people!
“You know you were the only one, but I have to get up there.” Bilbo tells him directly. Why is Thorin’s ghost here in the Old Forest, anyway? And why does the Old Forest look so different from how Bilbo remembers?
Because this is not the Old Forest. Because this is Mirkwood. Because Bilbo is back on his adventure again, and Thorin is alive again, and these facts slipped Bilbo’s mind entirely. He begins to tremble, nearly losing his grip on the tree.
“It is not safe,” Thorin’s gaze bores into Bilbo’s eyes, as if he can see the turmoil behind them. Bilbo tries to remember what he did the last time this happened, but he can’t. He still has this nagging feeling that Frodo is in these woods somewhere, or perhaps that Bilbo is on the way to Mordor to meet Frodo, or that they’re in the Shire, or the Old Forest. He can’t stop remembering dragon fire. He tries to force himself to remember the battle instead and he can’t, he simply can’t.
“There is something wrong in this forest,” Bilbo breathes, “I need to see to the end of it. Let me just take one look, Thorin. It will help us.”
Thorin glances up at the top of the tree, then at Bilbo. “I do not wish to let you out of my sight,” he informs the Hobbit.
“Only for a moment,” Bilbo promises through the haze that has begun to establish itself between himself and Thorin. Even though they are touching, even though Bilbo can feel Thorin’s grip, which is beginning to bruise, he can’t be sure that his old friend is really here. He can’t even be sure of where here is. “I’ll come right back down. At least I’ll let you know if we’re going the right way.” The right way back to Bag End, where he and Thorin can spend the rest of their days together in peace.
Or to the afterlife that they were supposed to share together. Didn’t Lady Galadriel promise that? Bilbo’s thoughts are all jumbled up. He has to keep reminding himself that he is in Mirkwood, with the company, on their adventure, or he will forget where and when he is. When Thorin only continues to stare at him (though who knows what the King is really seeing) Bilbo adds a quiet, big-eyed entreaty. “Please.”
That seems to do the trick. Thorin releases him. “Fine,” he says, “But be quick about it.”
He really seems to dislike the idea of letting Bilbo climb the tree. Why? He was perfectly happy to let Bilbo climb over an enchanted stream. He held Bilbo over a great height once, as well. For what reason? Something nags at the back of Bilbo’s mind, but he cannot remember what it is. “Thank you,” he says, flashing a genuinely grateful smile over his shoulder as he begins to climb the tree.
As he gets higher and higher, inching out of Mirkwood’s mist, his thoughts begin to realign. The facts of the matter: Bilbo is repeating his adventure for a second time. He is in Mirkwood, and every member of the company is still alive, and Frodo has not been born yet. Thorin is not a ghost but a living person Bilbo has sworn to protect, and the same can be said for Fíli and Kíli. But Bilbo forgot all of that.
He does not remember being so disoriented in Mirkwood the first time. Why? What’s different? What has changed? Yes, his relationship with Thorin is certainly better than it was the last time they did this. That much is obvious from the king’s possessive behavior, which Bilbo will have to revisit at a later date, because honestly, they’re not going to get anywhere if Thorin won’t let Bilbo out of his sight without a lengthy argument on the matter, but that doesn’t seem reason enough for such utter confusion.
A more significant difference occurs to him just as he nears the top of the tree. This time, before they left Beorn’s hall, Bilbo did everything in his power to dilute the influence of the ring. He wrapped it in cloth and shoved it into his pack as far away as he could get it from his body, hadn’t he? All of a sudden, Bilbo remembers a story Samwise told him, about putting the ring on in the tunnels of a giant spider. A giant spider… oh, by the Valar! The spiders will be upon the company soon!
He pokes his head above the canopy, and suddenly, he can see it all. The sky, the sun, the Lonely Mountain. Wispy clouds and deep valleys and the fantastic pink leaves below him. It is autumn now, then. Durin’s Day is fast approaching. Blue butterflies flutter around Bilbo, settling beside him, in his hair, on his clothes. But none of it matters in the slightest. He must get back to his friends.
Bilbo feels his chest constrict, his heart rate quicken. No. He cannot come down yet. He needs to spend the same amount of time up here that he did the last time. He needs to sort things out and get his bearings. If he’s there when the company gets caught, then he’ll get caught, too, and he won’t be able to help them.
Perhaps he got it wrong, when he put his plan together in Beorn’s hall. Perhaps it wasn’t the ring that caused the company’s disorientation in Mirkwood, but the enchantment on the forest, as Bilbo had suspected to begin with. In that case, his proximity to the ring might have spared him from the worst of it the first time around. Young Samwise once told him that the ring enabled him to hear voices which otherwise would have been too far away. It’s perfectly possible that Bilbo experienced equally heightened senses, for those sixty years that he carried the ring, but grew so accustomed to the extra gifts that he did not notice them as anything special. Then, when those gifts of improved sight and hearing faded, he must have chalked it up to his sudden, rapid aging.
It’s certainly possible that wrapping the ring diluted its power and prevented it from protecting Bilbo from the worst of the forest’s evil. Or perhaps the layers of cloth did absolutely nothing, and the ring is punishing him for trying to get away from it. Regardless, his next course of action is clear. Sighing, Bilbo reaches into his pack and pulls out the bundle of cloth. He unwraps it, shoves the fur and the shirt back into his pack, and gingerly places the ring into his jacket pocket.
“No,” he tells it in a stern voice, “Enough from you. I’ll not be dealing with any more of your wicked nonsense today.”
He is so angry with the ring that he wants to toss it back down into the forest, but he understands that this is probably what the ring wants. If Bilbo discards it, it will no doubt fall into the hands of a giant spider or an Elf, which would furnish the ring with far more power than Bilbo ever could. It is his burden to bear, and significantly lighter now than it was when Frodo carried it.
Of course, there is always the possibility that Bilbo is wrong again, and that the ring has nothing whatsoever to do with his disorientation. It could be because Bilbo has lived much longer and had many more experiences now than the first time that he was in Mirkwood. The forest had much more to fall upon, more to tug at, more to twist and reassemble than it did originally. If that’s the case, then Bilbo won’t be protected at all when he goes back down. He’ll have to muddle through with his mind half-gone, but he has no other choice. His friends need him.
The same thing happens again. Bilbo should probably have expected this. The moment he steps down from the trees and hears the spiders murmuring, his vision begins to blur. Bilbo has spent eight decades not thinking about the spiders. Even when he wrote about this encounter, he invented most of what he put onto the page.
In his book, Bilbo sang a little song and danced around and led the spiders on a merry chase. He cut his friends free and, groggy as they were, they helped him fight the monsters off. Bilbo expressed a little of the danger in his tale, but he deliberately kept the details vague. He made it one more silly story, one more episode of comic peril on their long and winding journey. A time for him to show his valor, to prove himself to his companions by keeping them safe.
That is not what really happened. What really happened is that Bilbo was shaking with fear, convinced that his friends were dead inside those hanging bundles and that he was left alone in that cursed forest. He cut them out with little hope. By some miracle, all of them lived, but before they could regroup, there was a battle to be had.
In his book, Bilbo claimed that Thorin was not with them for this interaction. It was selfish of him, this obfuscation of the truth. Only he didn’t want to write the stabbing feeling in his gut when he found Thorin, unmoving, wrapped in spiderwebs. He had no desire to record the terror, the sickening feeling of helplessness, the unfairness of it all. The idea that a great king could be felled by a nameless arachnid in the woods, simply because the beast was hungry. The idea that Bilbo’s love could be taken from him at the drop of a hat, for some noble cause or by some wicked accident, and that he would be powerless to do a thing about it.
But there is nothing for any of that now. Bilbo will have to fight, whether he likes it or not. He’s more careful this time. He knows what he’s doing, what he’s looking for. He doesn’t fall and the spiders do not catch him.
He sneaks along, quiet, invisible, climbing silently as any Hobbit would. Not that any respectable Hobbit would ever dare to make an attempt on any trees of this size, especially not trees in the middle of Mirkwood. Bilbo wears the ring, and he can sense the spiders, see them, hear them, understand them. He does not think. He proceeds, invisible, and slashes at every beast he sees. Some, he kills. They make awful, wailing noises.
Some, he pushes out of the trees. Others feel the bite of Sting and back away. Bilbo dimly remembers throwing a stone to lure the spiders off, the last time that he did this. Not so now. This time, he slashes through them, inciting panic and pandemonium. None of the spiders seem to remember their quarry, the bundles bound in sticky webs and strung from trees. Bilbo darts over to cut his friends free. He can only hope that, just as last time, their fall is broken by the webs beneath them.
There is Bombur, kicking his legs against spiders that have long since left him alone. He must not be able to see though all the spiderwebs. There is Dori, troublingly still, though Bilbo is relieved to hear him breathing. Ori yelps when Bilbo cuts his cocoon, and Nori and Dwalin both offer him several choice words. In Westron, not Khuzdul, because apparently, even having been injected with spider venom, neither of them is prepared to share their secret language with outsiders. Even outsiders with eight legs and a million eyes and terrifying pincers; even curly-haired, pointy-eared, furry-footed outsiders who mean well, truly.Bilbo frees Bofur, another silent, still one. Then Bifur, with his axe sticking out through the sticky floss. Glóin, as it happens, also has an axe sticking out, and he nearly takes Bilbo’s head off with it as he goes down.
Fíli says something that sounds like, “Careful; don’t bruise me.” His long nose has evidently enabled him to breathe under all his wrappings, and even whatever he’s endured at the hands of the spiders has not robbed him of his quick wit.
Óin gets an arm free and tries to strangle Bilbo with it, clearly thinking that his Hobbit savior is another menacing arachnid. Thankfully, Bilbo has been on the receiving end of Óin’s medical ministrations more than once, and he knows how to dodge the healer’s hands. Balin adjusts his position as best as he can within the sack of spider webbing, then drops like a rock when Bilbo cuts him free. Kíli’s hands twitch somewhere deep in his cocoon, and his bow, slung over his back, pokes Bilbo in the shoulder.
Thorin, like Dori and Bofur, makes no sound and does not move. Bilbo’s hands are shaking as he cuts him free. “You’re going to be alright, my love,” he mutters, ignoring the risk. He should not be saying things like this, things Thorin could hear and misinterpret, or, worse, hear and interpret with perfect accuracy. But would that really be so bad? Bilbo is fairly certain, after that ridiculous incident with Beorn’s shirt, that Thorin returns his feelings. “I’ll be down in a jiffy. But you’ve got to be alright.” It is not that time yet.
Bilbo watched Thorin die, and he did not die this way. He was still and silent the last time Bilbo freed him from the spiders, as well. And Thorin was neither still nor silent as he died. There is no blood to be seen. Thorin falls, then, and is caught by a layer of spider webs. His quiet huffing noise is audible even to Bilbo. So he is alive, then. Yes. Just as on the last adventure.
Bilbo has no time to ponder this, though, because more spiders come at him. He fights them off, not thinking, barely seeing. Keeping his grip on the ring as he slashes and rends. Yes. Those spiders deserve what is coming to them, for daring to harm Bilbo’s friends. They deserve death and pain and suffering.
He keeps the ring on his free hand, which he shoves into his pocket for safety as he slashes with his sword arm. Then his sword arm gets tired and he abandons this practice, fighting tooth and nail, with no regard for his own safety. At some point, Bilbo finds Bofur’s hat in the trees and throws it down after his friends, hoping it is returned to its owner. Hoping Bofur is alive to take his hat back. Bilbo feels a stab of guilt as he realizes he didn’t even bother to check his friend’s breathing, but he doesn’t have time to dwell on that, either.
He’s got to get down out of these trees. For one thing, this is where the spiders dwell, and the longer he spends up here, the more the beasts will dog him. Bilbo can guess that much without being told. And also, he is dimly aware, though the haze of metal-against-shell and the heaviness of rage, that something will be taking place in short order below him. So he jumps, when he can, bouncing as his friends did against one layer, and then another, of spider webbing. Yes. This is how it should be. This feels right. When he gets to the ground, there are more spiders, and these, Bilbo fights as well.
They cannot see him, and they cannot catch him, and they seem to understand this. No more spiders are forthcoming; the creatures have evidently decided to direct their ire toward the rest of the company rather than risk Bilbo’s wrath. So he stands there, sword in hand, panting, twitching, ready for a fight that never comes.
It is not like the last time. With the orcs, Bilbo felt so much he couldn’t stand it, felt so much that it clouded his thoughts and forced him to fight when perhaps to do so was not advisable. With the spiders, though, he feels nothing at all. Now that he is spared from the fighting, if only for a moment, it occurs to Bilbo that he has not been not in control of himself. It is as though his body enacted the entire battle of its own volition. Fair enough. He’s done well, all things considered. Let all the spiders in Mirkwood come and try their hand against Mad Baggins! Bilbo will show them what a warrior-Hobbit can do.
And then he hears his friends. They are loud, all of them always so very loud. They were loud in Bag End and they are loud here in Mirkwood and they will be loud in Erebor, this he knows. And they are all of them alive. Bilbo sags, his entire body exhausted from yet another hearty fight. The Wood Elves begin swinging down from boughs, though how they do this, Bilbo has not managed to figure out in eight long decades. He longs to join his companions, but Bilbo is aware that he has important work to do. He must stay back. He ensures that the ring is securely on his finger, hides himself, and waits.
