Chapter Text
Perhaps being captured by Elves is marginally better than being eaten alive by giant spiders, but only marginally. It’s humiliating, watching as bowstrings twitch and knives fly and spiders fall in neat heaps upon the forest floor, the Elves accomplishing in a few moments what Thorin’s company could not manage over the entire course of their prodigious fight. Thorin is still groggy from the spider venom, and the ensuing battle did nothing to aid the healing of his recent wounds. He is tired, confused, and aching.
His company is at the mercy of the Elves. They very nearly let Kíli die, trapped and cornered as he was. It would mean little to them, Thorin is certain, having one less prisoner to bring back to their cowardly king. The red-headed guard who now handles Kíli so roughly likely only stopped the spider to protect herself from its wrath. Elves do not, as a rule, risk their lives for other folk, as Thranduil proved perfectly on the day when he watched Thorin’s people fleeing their burning home and did nothing. Nothing. Nothing.
“Where did you get this?” An infuriatingly clean Elf demands. His grip on Orcrist is confident, as though he owns the blade.
“It was given to me,” Thorin replies. It is the truth, but the less these Elves know, the better. He owes them no explanation, anyway.
“Not just a thief, but a liar as well.” The Elf points Thorin’s own sword at him before shouting an incomprehensible order over his shoulder. The Elvish language sounds more like wind through the trees than proper speech, as though Thorin and his kin were being led away at the mercy of the wicked forest itself. Is there any meaningful difference, though, between these Wood Elves and the cursed land they occupy?
Thorin would rather have been eaten by spiders. That would have been far less shameful. He has no love for any Elves, but these are the worst folk imaginable. They are cruel and selfish, and Thorin knows that they will not treat his people well. His fists clench as he watches one of the guards removing knife after knife from Fíli’s person. He knows that his sister-son conceals those weapons well. In order to find them, the guard must be conducting an intimate search. A violation.
“Thorin, where’s Bilbo?” Bofur hisses as he is dragged away, quietly enough for only his king to hear. It seems that Thorin must put aside his fantasies of kicking the haughty blond Elf hard enough to bruise. This would be ill-advised, he knows, but the thought is a comfort. Were Thorin alone, had he no fear of retaliation against his companions for his own behavior, his fists and feet would be flying already. “Where’s the Hobbit?”
As Thorin processes the words through the spider venom and the fog of Mirkwood presently clouding his thoughts, a chill settles over his heart. Where is Bilbo, indeed? Where is the Hobbit?
Thorin’s first thought is that the little creature is dead. That would be the most logical explanation. This forest is no place for a Hobbit. There are plenty of fell beasts here aside from the spiders, not to mention the curse of the forest itself. Bilbo is no master of the sword at the best of times. How would he fare with his mind muddled by Mirkwood? And this is Thorin’s fault, for not fighting hard enough. Not killing enough of the spiders. Not killing any of the Elves. Allowing the Hobbit to leave his sight for any length of time, which he knew was a foolish idea. Bringing Master Baggins along on this quest in the first place.
“He was the one to cut me out of my cocoon,” Ori shares, quietly enough that Thorin isn’t certain even Bofur heard the answer to his question.
And it isn’t much of an answer, not really. It certainly sheds no great light on the Hobbit’s current whereabouts. But it does tell Thorin one thing: Master Baggins was alive before their battle with the spiders. He somehow managed to avoid being taken, and he had the presence of mind to free the company. This would have required climbing, careful sword work, and enough vigilance to dodge the spiders while he worked. So Bilbo must have been at least semi-lucid at the time.
Perhaps he would also have had the presence of mind to flee. He might even make it back to Beorn. The Hobbit is lithe and clever, and a friend to things that grow. He was able to scramble over the vines at the stream with ease, and he attempted more than once to prevent Thorin from leaving the path. And Bilbo, too, was the one to suggest that perhaps the company might be lost. At the time, Thorin argued with him, but now, he suspects that the Hobbit may have been right. He could get himself out of this forest, Thorin is sure of it.
But he is also sure that Bilbo will not do this. “Mahal watch over him,” he mutters, followed by a quick prayer in Khuzdul that he hopes the guards interpret as more cursing. Spare my Burglar, and I will do whatever you wish. Guide him safely on whatever foolish mission he’s taken it upon himself to enact.
Several of Thorin’s companions shoot him sharp looks for that. Under normal circumstances, he would be of complete accord. It is frowned-upon to speak Khuzdul in front of outsiders, and Elves are the worst outsiders imaginable. But Thorin must speak to his Maker. He must make it clear to the Smith that he is willing to do anything for the sake of Master Baggins. Besides, he doubts the Elves are paying attention to any words their prisoners might say as they are led single-file into the halls of the Woodland King.
Thorin knows Bilbo well enough by now to be fairly certain that the Hobbit is plotting something odd and inadvisable. Almost definitely, it will involve the Burglar flinging himself into danger for the sake of the company, and the stubborn little creature will accept no thanks for it afterwords. It gives Thorin hope, but it also fills him with fear for the wellbeing of his Hobbit. But, then, Master Baggins has proven himself time and time again. Perhaps he has something surprising up his sleeve for this situation, as well.
This is not Bilbo’s first time in the Halls of the Woodland King. On his original journey, the Hobbit spent several weeks wandering around Thranduil’s very impressive palace. He dedicated himself to the liberation of the company through whatever means necessary, entertaining even the flimsiest of escape plans and each one until it proved itself inviable.He spied on guards, gathered information, and haunted the kitchens, nabbing little bits of food that would not be missed. He kept his cover by wearing the ring for days on end. He slept in dusty cobwebbed corridors and had little time to spend with the members of the company, so busy was he plotting their escape.
This time is quite different. Bilbo already has their escape plotted out to the letter. He knows where to find the empty barrels that will convey them to Lake-town, and from there, the Lonely Mountain is only a hop, skip, and a jump away. Of course Bilbo cannot simply march down to the cellars and steal the keys now. He must wait for the Festival of Starlight, as he did the last time.The guards will be distracted then, making it easier to release the company from their cells. Also, Bilbo can be certain that the barrels will be available then, and not full of wine or something equally cumbersome and difficult to get rid of. Not to mention that while they might very well be able to avoid the orc scouts if they depart ahead of schedule, they will doubtlessly meet other, unforeseen dangers, and there is no guarantee that Bard will be waiting for them when they arrive on the outskirts of Lake-town.
It is better, Bilbo decides once again, to do everything the same way they did it before. So he resolves to wait until the night of the festival to make their escape. This should give Kíli time to charm the Captain of the Guard, as well, which, though it will make Thorin furious, will induce Legolas and Tauriel to fight alongside the company in the battle of the Five Armies, just as they did before. Of course, that didn’t go over so well the first time (don’t think about it, don’t think about it, don’t think about it) but Bilbo would rather not lose their alliance the second time around.
The long and short of it is that Bilbo has a good deal of time to kill in the Woodland realm. He’s certainly not going to waste it spying on guards again. He might have a look at the library, or pilfer the pantry. Maybe he’ll visit with his friends a bit, too. He could try to find where the Elves are hiding the weapons taken from the company, or any other weapons Bilbo can get his hands on. This will help them in their fight with the orcs. Granted, it will be difficult for a single Hobbit to smuggle out such an impressive arsenal, but he’ll probably be able to get his hands on a few of Fíli’s knives. Actually, now that Bilbo thinks about it, it’s entirely possible that the lad has a few weapons on him even still. Bilbo seems to remember a knife being thrown at some point as they traveled down the river.
But there is also another matter to consider. Something that has been bothering Bilbo since he climbed down from the canopy and found, much to his mortification, that the ring had a steadying effect on his thoughts. Bilbo knew on the Carrock that his relationship with Thorin is different this time around than it was on his first adventure. They shared inane conversation at Beorn’s, which never would have happened eighty years ago. But in the forest… Thorin was downright possessive. It was a battle to get him to agree to letting Bilbo out of his sight at all, and he wasn’t shy about it, either. Something is different, and Bilbo isn’t certain whether it’s a good thing or a bad one.
Nothing has changed on his end, anyway. He’s still very much in love with Thorin,and he wants to make sure that the king is alright. Logically, of course, Bilbo knows that Thorin is just fine. He was just fine last time, was he not? But that’s not necessarily a guarantee, and, anyway, Bilbo doesn’t need to make up an excuse. He has time on his hands and can do what he wishes with it.
So he does not linger outside watching Prince Legolas brood, and he does not follow the guards who shuffle the company off for the removal of their outer clothes and various other invasive procedures. Strange, that this should be done before anybody has been asked what they are doing in the forest.
Bilbo has always been fond of Elves, but this interval in Thranduil’s kingdom never sat right with him. Their company did nothing wrong, but the king imprisoned them anyway, and he wasn’t particularly kind to them during their stay. No wonder Thorin refused to treat with him before the battle. Granted, Bilbo would have done differently, in the honor of diplomacy, and he still thinks he was correct to suggest the same course of action to Thorin, but on principle, he understands where his king is coming from. Came from. Will be coming from? This is all still far too confusing!
Bilbo is standing just below Thranduil’s imposing throne when the guards drag Thorin into the great chamber. Pushing aside his reservations, the Hobbit steps forward, careful to stay out of the way of the guards so that he can put himself by Thorin’s side. It’s stupid of him, Bilbo knows, but he does not like to see the rage on Thorin’s face. It reminds him of terrible times past, and terrible times to come. It reminds him of the complexity of this whole affair. It makes him want to roll his eyes at Thorin’s stubbornness, yes, but Bilbo also wouldn’t mind rushing up that ridiculous treelike staircase and throttling the Woodland King. His thoughts are all muddled up, and that is not a good position in which to find himself while all his friends are being held prisoner.
Thranduil regards Thorin with a cold, haughty stare. He really isn’t helping his own cause. There should not be any need for bargaining, by Bilbo’s reckoning. Thranduil is decidedly in the wrong, holding people prisoner because he thinks he can get something out of them.
“Some may imagine that a noble quest is at hand. A quest to reclaim a homeland and slay a dragon,” the king begins what Bilbo imagines is about to become a monologue. "I myself suspect a more prosaic motive: attempted burglary, or something of that ilk.”
Bilbo nearly cannot help himself. He is so angry that he thinks he really might rush forward and challenge the Woodland King. It’s hard not to to feel that he is watching events unfold which will culminate in Thorin’s death. Eighty years ago, Thranduil acted as though he was entitled to anything he wished from the Lonely Mountain. Bard made a deal with Thorin, yes; the people of Lake-town had been promised aid and then refused it. But Thranduil? Thranduil was nothing but cruel to the entire company, and he made war for purely selfish reasons, when clearly, he had wealth enough in his fine kingdom. He egged Bard on and taunted Thorin and showed no sign of regret when it was all over and the King Under the Mountain lay dead upon Ravenhill. It was his fault.
Still, this is not a battle, and Bilbo knows that he must stay his hand. Thranduil may be annoying, but who is Bilbo to decide that the Elven King deserves death? All of this assuming that Bilbo would actually be able to deliver it, invisible as he is, with so many guards around. Even if Bilbo were fool enough to attack Thranduil, to seek vengeance for slights not yet committed, the consequences for the other members of the company would not be good. No doubt Legolas would inherit the throne and promptly retaliate. He might later regret his actions, whatever those might be, but it would be too late. Bilbo cannot imagine Gimli ever becoming friends with one who would visit such horrors upon his people. And what would that mean for the future of Middle Earth?
No. Bilbo will not lash out. He will be here for Thorin, where he is needed. He will offer support and serve as a witness, but he will not interfere. He cannot change the course of history in this way, cannot risk the ramifications. Besides, he is not here for vengeance. He is here for the love of his friends.
“You have found a way in,” Thranduil drawls, "You seek that which would bestow upon you the right to rule. The king’s jewel, the Arkenstone. It is precious to you beyond measure. I understand that.”
As a steadying gesture, Bilbo places his hand on Thorin’s arm. He clearly isn’t thinking, because if he were, he’d know that was a risky move. Thorin has no way of discerning that it’s Bilbo beside him, considering that the Hobbit is invisible. He would be well within his rights to attack, even having no weapons. He glances, briefly, in Bilbo’s direction, but of course he sees nothing, even as Bilbo clings to his sleeve.
“There are gems in the mountain that I, too, desire. White gems, of pure starlight,” Thranduil continues, "I offer you my help.” He almost looks as though he is telling the truth.
“Don’t listen to him,” Bilbo whispers into Thorin’s ear, “We will escape whether he wills it or not.”
This way, at least, there will be no deal upon which Thorin might renege. As much as Bilbo knows that he should be on the side of peace, it is better to ensure that there are no debts to be settled when they reach the mountain. Besides, it’s not as though Thorin would have listened if Bilbo tried to talk him into making a deal with Thranduil. Really, all he can do here is provide the assurance that he has a plan.
Thorin chuckles. Thranduil might believe that the king is reacting to his offer, but Bilbo knows that he’s received tacit approval. “I am listening.” Thorin sounds every inch the monarch.
“I will let you go… if you but return what is mine,” Thranduil proposes.
“A favor for a favor,” Thorin muses, turning on his heel and pacing toward the ledge overlooking much of the palace’s grand interior. Bilbo scurries after him, pleased that his Hobbit feet are silent as they hit the fine floors.
“You have my word. One king to another.”
“I would not trust Thranduil… The great king… To honor his word… Should the end of all days be upon us!” Thorin roars. His voice carries down to Thranduil’s people, many of whom look up in utter shock, that such words could be spoken, here of all places. Many others simply continue about their daily business, as though their monarch is dressed down each day by exiled Dwarven royalty.
One might imagine, Bilbo supposes, that Thorin’s left hand is clenched in a fist as demonstration of his anger. In reality, however, he is gripping Bilbo’s shirt like a vice, clearly drawing some degree of strength from his proximity to the Hobbit. Would he have said these things anyway? Bilbo does not doubt it. He knows Thorin well enough to understand that there was never any possibility of a deal being struck. It did not happen the first time, after all. But Bilbo hopes that he is at least able to give some hope and some comfort in this awful situation.
“You, who lack all honor!” Thorin has sealed his fate now, and he knows it. His hand is sweaty, and his body trembles. He may be practiced at hiding this, but Bilbo is close enough to detect it either way.
“Steady, now,” Bilbo counsels quietly. He does not wish to see Thorin receive any harsh treatment as a penance for his rough words, and he can’t put such barbaric behavior past Thranduil. Though Bilbo is fond of Legolas, he has never been particularly friendly with the lad’s father. For obvious reasons, which are becoming progressively more obvious to Bilbo as he is forced to stew in the unseen context for his decades of grief.
“I have seen how you treat your friends,” Thorin continues, releasing Bilbo and turning around slowly to face Thranduil. Bilbo keeps a gentle hand on his back, rubbing soft circles as a silent gesture of support. Thorin is correct, of course, though it is perhaps unwise to yell such things at the top of his lungs. “We came to you once, starving, homeless, seeking your help. But you turned your back! You turned away from the suffering of my people… and the inferno that destroyed us.” Thorin proceeds to release a selection of choice words in Khuzdul.
Bilbo once again wishes that he took the time to learn the secret language.It was too painful after the battle, and then, years later, when he returned to the mountain, his mind was too battered by the ring and his old age to allow for much retention of new words. It seemed disrespectful, somehow, to try and learn the language on his own. A closed cultural practice to which he was not entitled, not having married into that culture. He would’ve, if he’d been given the chance, but the opportunity had died with Thorin. Died in battle. Impaled on a sword. Bilbo is going to need to find someone to hoist him up on their shoulders so that he can take Azog’s head off, slowly and painfully.
“Do not talk to me of dragon fire,” Thranduil hisses. “I know its wrath and ruin. I have faced the great serpents of the North.” For a moment, his beautiful face flickers away, showing the burned flesh beneath. Is this an illusion, or is the visage he wears the rest of the time a mere trick of magic? The ring offers Bilbo no answers. “I warned your grandfather of what his greed would summon. But he would not listen. You are just like him. Stay here if you will, and rot.”
Bilbo has to spring out of the way as two guards seize Thorin by the arms and begin hauling him in the direction of the dungeons. Unfortunately, Bilbo’s leap takes him further down the stairs, forcing him to scramble to the bottom at speed to avoid being bumped into. He cannot risk discovery.
“A hundred years is a mere blink in the life of an Elf!” Thranduil calls after them. “I’m patient. I can wait.”
But he is lying. He will descend upon Erebor the moment he thinks he can get in. He will take his people to war over a handful of jewels. He has no right to accuse Thorin of greed when he himself is just as greedy. Many Elves will die in the name of those white stones.
Bilbo doesn’t get much time to ponder this, however, because as he is herded out of the room. This was a major flaw in his plan: he can’t stay where he is, because the guards will run into him. He can’t jump to the side, because there is no side to jump to. The corridor they’re taking Thorin down is narrow, and whenever Bilbo attempts to turn, he finds the way blocked by more guards. Right. They think there’s some chance that Thorin might try to escape, and they are entirely correct. And he certainly can’t scramble back up to the throne room with Thorin and the guards blocking his way.
The procession arrives at the block of cells where the company is detained, and Bilbo considers rushing up the stairs to the higher level where he knows that Kíli and some of the others are being held, but of course, just his luck, there are guards standing up there, as well. He would not get very far, and he cannot risk discovery.
His options, it appears, are to try and dart between the legs of the guards, which does not seem particularly wise, to allow himself to be herded into a cell, or to jump off the ledge to his death. Slim pickings, for sure.
While Bilbo is dithering, a guard approaches and opens the door to the cell at Bilbo’s back. The door opens inward. With dawning horror, Bilbo realizes that he has no choice but to scramble into the cell. As though that were not a problem enough, the guard shoves Thorin into the tiny space behind Bilbo, and, naturally, he slams into the Hobbit with his full weight, knocking Bilbo to the ground. Thankfully, Thorin is able to right himself and maintain his footing, because Bilbo is not certain that he would be able to survive being pressed between an irate Thorin and the hard stone floor. For any number of reasons.
“Bother stone floors and everything to do with them!” Bilbo mutters under his breath. The impact has not exactly been kind to the bruises he’s carried since the confrontation with Azog, not to mention the many injuries that he unknowingly incurred during the fight with the spiders. This is just lovely. Now, Bilbo is trapped in Thorin’s cell. There will be no spying and no sneaking, and Bilbo is more than likely to get an earful from their fearless leader.
The Elf guards may not have heard Bilbo, but Thorin is staring at the spot on the ground where Bilbo happens to be laying with an utterly illegible expression on his face. Yes, Bilbo is in for an earful, indeed.
“Did he offer you a deal?” Balin’s voice echoes from a neighboring cell.
But Thorin remains silent. Bilbo looks around to find the king staring back at him, though, of course, Thorin cannot see Bilbo. Ever so gently, he nudges the Hobbit in the thigh with the tip of his boot. Probably, he wasn’t aiming for Bilbo’s thigh, considering he must not know what position Bilbo is laying in. Still, it’s a good thing Bilbo is invisible, so that Thorin cannot see the expression on his face.
“Thorin.” Balin breaks the tension that has accumulated at a mind-boggling pace inside the little cell. “Did he offer you a deal?"
“He did,” Thorin confirms slowly. “But I refused.” His eyes are wide as he continues studying what must, to him, appear to be nothing more than empty air.
“Well, that’s that, then,” Balin echoes Bilbo’s sentiments exactly. “A deal was our only hope.” That’s not so true, of course, but Bilbo isn’t very well about to give himself away by arguing the other side.
“He would not have kept his word,” Thorin resolves. “He lied to me and taunted me. He is holding us here when we have done nothing wrong! Thranduil would not honor any deal we might make.”
Bilbo takes the opportunity to get a handle on his surroundings. The room is slightly larger than the coat closet in Bag End, with a stone bench for resting or sitting on. There are minimal blankets and no pillow. It is a tiny space, and Bilbo does not look forward to sharing it with Thorin. Doubtlessly, the king will be angry with him for managing to get captured without getting caught, for failing in his plan to find them a way out. And time spent together in such tight quarters will probably produce a level of intimacy that Bilbo has never experienced with anyone before. Who knows how long they will be in here? The cell is fully plumbed, but there is no semblance of privacy. Even less of it than they’ve had on their journey hitherto.
“I do not think we will find another mode of escape,” Balin informs his king dryly.
“None of us know what we will find in this foul place,” Thorin murmurs, so quietly that even Balin might not be able to hear him.
They both wait, then, to see if any of their companions will offer Thorin any further conversation. But it seems that, truly, that is that. They have all resigned themselves to whatever fate they might suffer as a result of Thorin’s refusal to treat with Thranduil. Or, even worse, they are all plotting in retaliation.
Not that Bilbo has time to think about that just now. He must trust that his friends will behave in the Elven prison exactly as they did the last time, and he must contend with whatever questions Thorin is about to throw his way.
“Master Baggins,” Thorin finally whispers. His voice is so low that Bilbo nearly does not hear him. “Am I going mad, or have you managed to find your way into my cell?”
“I’m here,” Bilbo sighs, “Unfortunately.”
“You were with me in the throne room, as well.” There is a slight uncertainty lurking under Thorin’s authoritative tone, but he does not seem particularly angry. Or, at least, he does not seem particularly angry with Bilbo. The Elves are another matter altogether.
“Yes.”
“You can turn invisible?” This is framed as a question, at least.
“Yes.”
Thorin sighs. “That explains a great deal. I can see how you got out of the goblin tunnels, even if I cannot see you. I take it that you have a plan.”
“Well, of course I do,” Bilbo replies, “Though admittedly, getting locked in here with you wasn’t part of it.”
Thorin regards the space slightly to Bilbo’s left with a hard glare. Bilbo wishes he could take the ring off and become visible again. He’s sure it makes Thorin uncomfortable, not being able to see him, and it certainly makes Bilbo uncomfortable having to wear the blasted thing. The longer he has it on, the more he grows accustomed to the hazy quality of the world around him, and this troubles Bilbo deeply. “But you have found a way to escape?”
“I have.” This much is true at least.
“Quite a lot of exploring that you managed to do in such a short time,” Thorin observes with a palpable edge of skepticism.
Bilbo does not feel that now is the best time to explain things to Thorin. He will have questions that Bilbo won’t be able to answer and still keep his wits about him. “Isn’t that what you hired me for? Sneaking around, quickly and quietly? Not that it matters. All of it will be for nothing if I can’t get out of this cell.”
“Tell me what you have in mind.” This is the problem with getting Thorin involved in Bilbo’s escape plan. The first time around, Bilbo had the upper hand, and could simply announce that he’d found a way out. After weeks in the Elven dungeons, Thorin hadn’t been in any position to argue, let alone to try and take command.
But now, Bilbo needs to manage not only the company’s escape from the Woodland Realm, but also his own escape from this cell and the serious control issues of a certain Dwarven king. “I don’t think that’s such a good idea.”
“I can’t help you if you refuse to tell me your plan,” Thorin protests.
“No, we shouldn’t speak of it,” Bilbo argues. “Not openly, at least. We don’t know who’s listening, do we?”
“I must confess, Master Burglar, I’m beginning to suspect that you don’t have any plan at all.”
“I do,” Bilbo assures him, hoping against hope that Thorin will believe him. “But I’m afraid we must be patient. It will take several weeks to come to fruition.” After all, they’re going to have to wait for the feast, when Thranduil and his guards alike will be distracted enough for Bilbo to steal the keys to his friends’ cells. All of this, of course, is assuming that he can slip out of Thorin’s cell somehow.
“Not sooner?” Thorin asks.
“I don’t think so.” Bilbo knows that the company only escaped the first time through sheer luck. The guards were distracted, there were empty barrels available, and Bilbo happened to think of the right idea at the right time. It is extremely unlikely that similar conditions will be replicated under any different circumstances.
“And what would you have done in the meantime, had you not been locked in my cell?” Thorin, at least, seems to find some humor in this, if the slight quirk of his lips is any indication. Bilbo, too, is reluctantly willing to admit that it is a little funny.
He shrugs, though of course Thorin can’t see him. “To wander around spying until then. I’d have liked to find our weapons and get a few of them back.”
“You could not carry many.”
“Yes, thank you, I had no idea.” Is Thorin trying to infuriate him? “But I could make multiple trips, you know.”
“What would you have eaten?” Such an odd thing to focus on.
“I’m sure I would have found something.” Bilbo does not understand. This is new territory for him, something completely different. For the first time since restarting his adventure, he genuinely does not know what’s going to happen next, and he has to think up a completely original plan for how to get out of this cell.
“Then it is good that you are here,” Thorin decides, “Where I can keep an eye on you.”
“You can’t see me!” Bilbo sputters. “And this is not good at all! We are locked in a cell, Thorin! A cell, in the Woodland realm, and Yavanna only knows what the Elves will do to you for how you spoke to Thranduil!“
“You didn’t seem so opposed to it at the time,” Thorin growls.
“Well, you didn’t say anything that wasn’t true,” Bilbo admits, “But I don’t trust Thranduil not to… enact retribution of some kind, and—“
“Shh.” Thorin holds up his hand in what he seems to think is Bilbo’s general direction. Honestly, no wonder he got lost in Hobbiton, of all places, if he can’t parse where in this tiny cell Bilbo’s voice is coming from. And they are below stone now, are they not? Perhaps the caves of the Elven king simply do not count. Is it the wrong type of stone? Is there some magic here which hinders stone-sense? Or is Thorin’s perception of direction terrible in all unfamiliar places? “Enough chatter. The others will hear you.”
“Now you worry about that.” Bilbo makes a rude gesture, before realizing that Thorin can’t see him. He takes off the ring to make the gesture again, and Thorin’s eyes widen. It’s almost satisfying to see the small, gentle smile that graces the king’s face.
But then Thorin’s gaze hardens, and he shakes his head. “Make yourself invisible again, Master Baggins,” he orders. “No one can know that you are here. I will not jeopardize your safety.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes but does as he’s told. Only because Thorin has a point, of course.“Maybe it is better that I’m here,” he lies, trying to lighten the mood. He and Thorin will both need to keep their spirits up if they’re to concoct an escape plan. “Where I can keep an eye on you.” If Thorin thinks anything of having his own words tossed back at him this way, he does not give those thoughts voice.
Somehow, Bilbo manages to find sleep in the halls of the Elven King. It’s a real wonder than he does so, because the torches in the corridor are perpetually lit, and he can hear not only the snoring and hushed conversations of his companions, but also the footsteps of the guards. Still, the journey through Mirkwood exhausted Bilbo more than he was willing to admit before his arrival here, certainly more than it did the first time around. He does not fully understand why, but he suspects that his advanced years and the damage done to him during them played some role. And then there is the matter of the ring. Wearing it at all is much more draining than Bilbo remembered, and wearing it perpetually without any hope of imminent removal puts him in a lamentable state of lethargy.
He did not notice this feeling when last he visited Thranduil’s realm. It was hard to pay attention to how tired he was when he was busy searching for a way out, constantly moving, never safe to rest his eyes for longer than a few moments. Now, however, Bilbo has plenty of time to sleep. Little time, in fact, to do anything else, and there is no chance of his being discovered. Even if the Elves were foolish enough to open the door to Thorin’s cell, they would not step inside it with him. And none of them have any reason to suspect Bilbo’s presence. A fourteenth member of the company slinking around, invisible, and menacing the Elves is much more plausible than the same invisible fourteenth member secreting himself away inside Thorin’s cell.
Bilbo curls up in a corner, his coat wrapped around him as best as he can get it. His pack has been left behind somewhere in the forest, and he doubts he will eversee it again. Its contents were limited to his bedroll, a shirt he never would have fit into, and a little bit of rationed food. His only remaining possessions at this juncture are the ring and the clothes on his back.
He dreams of Ravenhill. Always, over and over again, he dreams of Ravenhill. This should come as no surprise. He should not be so affected by it, after having the same nightmare so very many times, but still, he can feel the icy wind stinging his face and the tears pricking his eyes each time that Fíli falls. He can taste the dry air as he listens to the heaving sound of Thorin’s last breath, can see the blood all over his own hands. And even though he knows what is coming, he forces himself to run down those stairs again, in search of Kíli, and though it is no surprise, in his dreams, Bilbo always falls to his knees when he sees the poor Elf sobbing over the body of her lost love.
When he wakes, Bilbo jolts and taps his head against the stone wall behind him. Ah, yes. He is still trapped in the dungeons of the Woodland realm. How lovely. He rises, stretches (by the Valar, his poor back is very stiff) and looks around him. The facilities are probably older than Bilbo is, and they leave more than a little to be desired, but he is grateful for their presence nonetheless. There is a faucet, so he will not die of thirst. It only takes a little bit more scanning of the room for his eyes to fall on Thorin.
The king is laying on his back on a stone bench in a dimly lit room. Bilbo’s vision is flooded, all of a sudden, with the same image in a different context: Thorin, in eternal slumber on a carefully carved stone slab, his eyes closed, his hands resting just over that fatal wound. To cover the gaping hole. To cover the bloody mess. His hair, freshly braided by Dáin, his technical next of kin. It should be you, Dwalin muttered to Bilbo while the braiding was going on.
Why? Bilbo asked. Why should it be me? Dáin is his cousin and the next king, he has every right to… I wouldn’t know how to do it, even if… I couldn’t. I can’t…
Because Bilbo’s hands had been shaking worse than anything. Completely useless. He could not be in the same room as Thorin and the lads without bursting into tears. And anyway, Dáin was not their next of kin. That honor belonged to Dís, who would find, after many months, that the worst had happened and she had lost her entire family. Bilbo never met her. She stayed in the Blue Mountains when she heard the news, and she died there before Bilbo ever thought of visiting Erebor again. Well-respected, prosperous, a great leader of her people, and entirely alone. Bilbo could have visited, but he chose not to because he knew that the deaths of her family were all his fault. If he had only arrived five minutes earlier…
That is not true. Bilbo did not try to visit Dís because he did not want to see how closely she resembled Thorin. He did not want to look into blue eyes that he knew but had never seen before. He did not want to see Kíli’s easy smile on another face or hear Fíli’s turns of phrase coming from different lips. He wanted to forget all about the three of them, to pretend that their deaths were easy for him to overcome. To pretend that he had not been gutted. To pretend that he had continued to be a whole and functional person even after he heard the sound of Fíli’s bones shattering against the rock, even after he felt the life leave Thorin’s body, even after he rushed to find Kíli and discovered that the lad was long gone.
Bilbo had no desire to share that pain with anyone. He wanted the ache to go away, so he drove it down. He left the gory details out of his book. He pretended that he never witnessed such horrible events at all, claimed that he’d been unconscious for them. He never even reported the story. Let Frodo and the other children of the Shire believe what they would about the ends that Bilbo’s companions met. Let the tale of Thorin’s death be about the lesson he learned and not the love that was taken from Bilbo on that horrible, cold day. Leave out the part about the bodies on stone slabs, the grieving mother, the poor Hobbit sobbing so hard that his nose bled. Leave out Dwalin’s trembling and Dori’s inability to fix the lads’ hair and the poor Elf maiden, clinging to the lifeless body of her love. Leave out the pitying looks that Bilbo had received. Make it about the treasure, make it about the importance of home. Make it a story to keep Hobbit faunts grateful. Nothing more. Nothing more at all.
“Hush.” Bilbo did not notice Thorin’s approach. He barely registers the cool hand on the top of his head. Probably, Thorin was going for his shoulder but miscalculated. There must have been some fumbling involved. Bilbo is unsure whether he is glad or sorry to have missed it. “Hush, now. There is nothing to cry about.”
Apparently, this is Thorin’s way of giving comfort to a Hobbit who is sobbing openly and therefore in serious danger of being discovered by the looming Elven guards. He’s not doing such a bad job, all things considered. At the very least, Thorin’s touch reminds Bilbo that they are both alive and well and here, which is better than Bilbo could’ve said six months ago. Thorin is breathing, and Bilbo is much more than the rapidly-aging shadow of himself who last visited the halls of Erebor.
Bilbo says nothing but throws his arms around Thorin, burying his face in his friend’s sturdy chest. How embarrassing, to cry like this. And Thorin does not even know what Bilbo is crying about! In fact, he cannot even see Bilbo. The sound of sobbing must have woken him up, and Bilbo hadn’t even been aware that he was doing it!
“We will escape soon,” Thorin assures him, gently stroking his hair. “You have a plan already, and now all we must do is wait.” Of course, the gentle words do not last very long. “You will only draw attention to yourself, carrying on like this.”
“Thanks,” Bilbo grumbles against Thorin’s chest. But neither one of them releases the other.
Thorin does not ask why Bilbo is crying. Perhaps he does not care. Perhaps he imagines that Bilbo would not wish to tell him, which, in all fairness, is entirely correct. Perhaps he would rather not have this conversation in the first place, or perhaps he does not know how to go about initiating such a discussion. Instead he says, “I would protect you, if I could. I will not allow any harm to come to you while you travel in my company.”
Bilbo sniffles. “You hired me to face a dragon for you,” he points out.
Thorin stiffens. Bilbo can feel the king’s muscles tensing. Did he… forget about the dragon? No, that can’t be. Thorin is constantly thinking of Erebor. He would not be able to lose the thought of Smaug completely, even in his happiest moment, which this is certainly not. He must simply have forgotten that Bilbo would be the one to face the beast. “I will go inside the mountain with you, if you wish,” Thorin offers instead, “It is my birthright, not yours, and the dragon’s wrath is my burden to bear.”
This is actually much more effective than the hair-stroking in helping Bilbo to return to himself. For one thing, it is a shocking contrast with Thorin’s attitude on the first adventure. Oh, yes, things have certainly changed between them. Bilbo has had the courage to challenge Thorin’s assumptions from the start, and this has clearly endeared him to the king more than his irritated fumbling did the first time around. That, or he has proven himself trustworthy more quickly than he did before. Or any number of things.
“Don’t be ridiculous,” Bilbo protests as quietly as he is able. It is the middle of the night, and he cannot hear the voices of any of the company, but that does not mean that he and Thorin should behave as though they are the only ones awake. Even if they were, which Bilbo highly doubts, they would not be for much longer. “Did you not listen to a word Gandalf said at Bag End?”
“I believe it was you who slunk off to another room—“
“To wash the dishes!”
“— And did not read the contract you were given,” Thorin pushes ahead. “You want looking after, clearly.”
“And I suppose you’ve taken that task upon yourself?” Bilbo tries very hard to be annoyed. Considering that he’s been in love with Thorin for eighty years, it’s easy to interpret this protectiveness as a romantic gesture. But Thorin has only known Bilbo for a scant matter on months, which colors the entire affair in a significantly different light.
“I have,” Thorin resolves, his expression entirely serious. He seems to be looking into Bilbo’s eyes, though of course, he is not. He cannot see Bilbo’s eyes. “This is strange, like holding a spirit in my arms. I don’t care for it.”
“Well, I don’t care for being locked up in an Elven prison, myself,” Bilbo quips. He simply can’t help himself. He’s trying to take this seriously, and half the time, the emotions just come bubbling up, boiling over the edges of the cauldron that is his ancient mind. But the rest of the time, he finds he is still the same sarcastic Hobbit who set out from Bag End all those years ago. “We must all make sacrifices on this journey, apparently.”
“You’ve lost your handkerchiefs, then,” Thorin decides.
“Not all of them.” Bilbo withdraws one of these from his pocket, as best he can while held in a vice grip, and waves it about in front of Thorin, who, of course, cannot see it. Bilbo takes the ring off, only for a moment, and repeats the motion. He cannot dwell in the lightness of his sudden freedom, the brilliant saturation of the colors of the world. He knows that he must hide himself again, and so he does, quick as a flash.
Thorin only blinks at him, which is very endearing indeed. If it weren’t for Bilbo’s sore body and his occasional involuntary sniffling and the glaring lights of the torches all around them, he might even be able to forget where they are. Of course, that was the whole problem to begin with. Bilbo genuinely believed, for just a moment, that he was back upon Ravenhill, in the aftermath of the Battle of the Five Armies. Which has not happened yet. Which will not happen the way that Bilbo remembers it. He will give his own life before letting any of his family fall on that battlefield.
“If you still have a handkerchief,” Thorin drawls, once he has gotten his bearings, “Then what excuse have you for using my shirt as one?”
“I seem to recall being gathered up in your arms and pressed against your chest like a faunt,” Bilbo recounts. “Which I did not ask for, by the way.”
“You’d have given yourself away with your crying,” Thorin points out.
“And here I thought you were comforting me, when you only wanted to shut me up!” But Bilbo can’t help but laugh. Things are strange between them, different. He does not know how to navigate this changed dynamic. And he can’t help but feel a little bit hurt by it, as well.
He did hope that Thorin returned his feelings eighty years ago. But clearly, back then, something held Thorin back, either from developing feelings for Bilbo or from expressing them. Granted, now that Bilbo thinks about it, there isn’t very much of a question at all. Bilbo was the one who constantly pushed Thorin away, refusing to speak to him unless spoken to. Bilbo was the one who said rude things about the company, implying and then directly stating that they didn’t belong anywhere. Bilbo was the one who isolated himself for the first month of the journey. Fíli and Kíli practically had to force him to talk to them, and even then, he wasn’t happy about it. Could Thorin really be expected to give his love to someone who had been so dismissive toward his beloved nephews?
“And it did not even work,” Thorin pretends to lament with a soft smile. “I must find a new tactic before we’re discovered.”
“We won’t be discovered,” Bilbo argues. I wasn’t the last time, he almost says, but thank the Valar, he stops himself at the last moment. That’s not a can of worms that he’s prepared to open just yet.
“You will not sleep on the floor again,” Thorin decrees with a meaningful look.
He will not ask Bilbo directly to join him in his bed, if the stone slab upon which he has slept can even be called a bed. Bilbo knows this. Thorin is too proud for that, and far too awkward, as well. He does not have much practice in making gentle requests, or in expressing his worry, or in giving comfort beyond whatever he must have offered to his nephews when they skinned their knees as children. Thorin is pragmatic, a warrior king if ever there was one, and he is never going to be any more forward than this.
“I don’t want to aggravate your injuries,” Bilbo informs him. He can be forward enough for both of them.
“I was barely injured, and have healed thanks to Óin’s incessant hovering,” Thorin assures him.
“You’ll tell me if I cause you any pain.” Two can play at this game. Bilbo isn’t really one for the gentle request-making, either.
“Of course,” Thorin says. “As long as you promise to do the same.”
Bilbo chuckles. “Fair enough,” he decides. It’s an agreement he can work with, at the very least.
It is difficult to keep track of the passage of time inside the cell. They are definitely not being given the requisite seven meals per day, though of course, Bilbo has gotten plenty used to that on his travels. He’s grown accustomed to settling for three meals, perhaps four, if his traveling companions are at all familiar with Hobbit-y ways. But either the time is dragging on at an alarmingly slow pace, or the Elves only feed them twice each day.Not that their meals were much more frequent while the company traveled through Mirkwood.
The food isn’t bad, Bilbo supposes. He’s always been fond of leafy greens, and the porridge, while lacking the butter and cream that he would probably add to it if he were cooking it at home, is not so terrible, either. A few times, they are given eggs, though Bilbo does not know what bird these come from. Thorin, when asked, does not know either, and does not seem to understand why Bilbo would be at all interested in finding out. But then, his general comportment seems to indicate that since arriving here, Thorin has thrown what little common sense he had to begin with entirely by the wayside.
“You’re being ridiculous,” Bilbo complains, and not for the first time, after their evening meal is delivered.
“It could be poisoned,” Thorin decrees. Bilbo doubts this, but explaining as much has not gotten him very far hitherto. He’ll have to change tack, then.
“So, in that case, surely the Burglar should taste it before the King does?” He knows this is a losing battle.
“No. You are my responsibility,” Thorin tells him firmly. “I will not see you harmed.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes, though, of course, Thorin cannot see the gesture. To compensate, the Hobbit heaves a dramatic sigh. “I’m the one that saved your life, Thorin. Shouldn’t I be responsible for you? And I’m not your subject, by the way. You can’t order me around.”
Thorin shoots him a look that confirms Bilbo’s suspicions well enough. Though the king has yet to breathe the word One in Bilbo’s presence, let alone to try and explain his feelings to the Hobbit, it’s clear what he’s thinking. This is not about debt or propriety, and it has nothing to do with the quest. True, Thorin would sacrifice himself for any member of the company in a heartbeat, but this seems a little much.
Not that any of that matters now. Bilbo is getting awfully full of himself, assuming that he might mean so very much to Thorin when they haven’t even spoken about it. It’s not unheard of, he knows, for the call of the bond to go completely ignored. Even if there is some cosmic connection between the two of them, that doesn’t mean that Thorin will wish to pursue it. He may be acting on instinct now, but once he survives the battle, he might prefer to focus on his duties. And Bilbo is perfectly okay with that.
He’s not doing this because he expects to get something from Thorin in the end. Far from it, actually. He’s doing this because he cares about his friends, and he does not wish to see them die. And even if he did have some definite intention of pursuing a future relationship with Thorin, now would not be the time. Bilbo cannot become a distraction. Though he’s beginning to worry that it’s a little late for that, and he will be a distraction no matter what he does.
The more time they spend here, the more Bilbo thinks on this. The more pressing matters of their escape and the quest and Bilbo’s nightmares slip away, and they are left alone in a room with very obvious feelings that neither of them dares voice. They have distracted themselves with conversation, idle tales of Erebor and the Shire. Bilbo has heard stories of the games the royal children got up to in their ample free time, before they could comprehend the particulars of their grandfather’s madness and before the dragon drove them from their home. In return, Bilbo has recited family trees and spoken at length about his youthful antics and those of his more adventurous relations. But mostly, they have stayed silent, preserving their voices and Bilbo’s secret in the face of the lingering guards.
Regardless, Bilbo is not naive enough to believe that adding a courtship into the mix at this point on their adventure would be wise, and clearly, Thorin does not believe so, either. And why would he? Dwarven customs dictate the exchange of gifts, which is virtually impossible when neither of them has anything more than the clothes on their back. Perhaps Thorin could give away one of the beads in his hair, but what would Bilbo give him in return? A handkerchief? The One Ring?
Oh, what a ridiculous thought to pop into Bilbo’s mind! He knows where it came from, of course, though he does not know whether to be relieved or troubled by the knowledge that it was not his own idea. Bilbo loves Thorin and would never curse him with this burden. Although, he loved Frodo as he would love his own son, and that didn’t stop him from passing that same awful weight down to the lad. And it destroyed him. Painfully, slowly, irrevocably, the ring pulled the strings of Frodo’s mind apart until the tapestry was damaged beyond restoration, and Bilbo could do nothing but stand back and watch.
Your fault, a voice hisses in his mind, That was your fault.
“It is safe to eat,” Thorin decides when nothing happens after what seems to be an arbitrary amount of time. Perhaps he was trained for this as a young Prince of Erebor. It would be a handy thing to know. How long before one can expect the Royal food-taster to start dying after ingesting poison?
“You’d better have more than that,” Bilbo scolds him. The ring seems to get stronger by the day, but he cannot risk taking it off. “I won’t have you going hungry.”
He is doomed, no matter what you do, says that same voice. But Bilbo shakes it off, ignores it, pushes it away. He’s had the ring on far too long, if it is speaking to him. Did it do this the last time?
Probably. Almost definitely. But it would never have occurred to Bilbo that the voice speaking in his head was not his own. He knows better now. He cannot trust his own thoughts, especially not while he is wearing the ring. After all, the cursed thing has some ability, at least, to reach into Bilbo’s mind and rifle through it. It has some knowledge of its own destruction, some knowledge of the future that Bilbo has been dreading since he found himself outside Bag End. It knows what he would do to it, and though it may not be as powerful as it was when Frodo bore it, the ring will still do everything it can to protect its own interests.
“I am fine.” Thorin is lying. Of course he isn’t fine. Every time they are offered a meal, he barely picks at the food before claiming he isn’t hungry and passing the plate to Bilbo.
“I already had most of breakfast.” And it still wasn’t enough to feed a Hobbit, but that is beside the point. “And last night’s dinner. It’s your turn to have the lion’s share.”
“I have traveled with you long enough to know that you require more food than I do, Master Baggins,” Thorin explains with remarkable patience. Well, remarkable for Thorin. If any Hobbit tried that tone on Bilbo, he’d slam his door in their face, and they would not be invited back for tea. Case in point: Lobelia Sackville-Baggins. “Why must you make everything so difficult?”
“You need your strength,” Bilbo hisses, “I don’t know how you expect me to sneak you out of here if you’re half-starved, seeing as I can’t very well carry you, and you’re going to need to be able to—“
“Someone’s coming.” Thorin cuts him off, taking back the plate and snatching the fork out of Bilbo’s hand.
Well, that wasn’t how Bilbo would’ve liked to win that battle, but he’s relieved to see Thorin eating, at the very least. He knows the king would not risk seeming as though he does not enjoy or appreciate the food. This is entirely for Bilbo’s sake, of course, because Thorin clearly neither enjoys nor appreciates the food itself or the fact that it is given, sparingly, by Elves who are holding him prisoner. But it’s plain that he does not wish for his jailers to believe that it is a waste to bring him meals in the first place. Anyway, he won’t touch the greens, so Bilbo will have those, but the porridge and eggs should make a good enough meal. They have the same argument every day, each of them urging the other to eat more, as though that were possible in their present circumstances.
There are, indeed, footsteps approaching. Elven footsteps, long and soft, though not as soft as the ones that a Hobbit would take. Bilbo has not seen Legolas since the party was taken in the forest, but here is the prince now, standing with his back as straight as any of his arrows, beside the red-headed guard.
The two Elves come to a stop outside of the cell that Bilbo and Thorin have been sharing. Bilbo is not pleased with this at all. He knows from Frodo’s stories that young Legolas (who is probably about seven times Bilbo’s age, though he looks barely older than a child) has keen sight and hearing. He may pick up on Bilbo’s breathing, if the Hobbit is not careful.
Thankfully, the prince seems distracted this night. “You are spending too much time in the dungeons, Tauriel,” Legolas scolds in his native tongue. Of course, Bilbo can understand Sindarin far better than he can understand Khuzdul. He has gotten his hands on far more Elvish tomes, comparatively.
“I am merely doing my job,” Tauriel protests. “The prisoners are in my charge.” This is not strictly true, Bilbo knows. He distinctly remembers another Elf saying the same thing, just before Bilbo snatched his keys away. While it may be Tauriel’s right to pass time in the dungeons, it is by no means an obligation.
“But you seem only to be guarding one of them,” Legolas returns. It’s very polite of him not to mention Tauriel’s stretching of the truth. “And he does not seem poised to escape.”
There is a long pause, where Tauriel glances down at the ground. Surely, she isn’t being bashful. “Do not tell me you are jealous of a Dwarf locked in a cell.”
Bilbo knows from his earlier spying that Thranduil believes there to be something romantic between Tauriel and Legolas. But seeing them together now, he finds he has his doubts. Legolas glances up at the ceiling, as though exasperated.
“I am not jealous,” the prince announces, “Only confused.”
“I do not see what there is for you to be confused about.” Her tone is sharp, though she continues looking downward. “Is it a crime now to speak to the prisoners?”
“A crime?” Legolas sounds genuinely offended at the thought that he might be accusing the guard of any wrongdoing. “No, it is not a crime, my friend. And even if it were so, I’m sure you’d be exempt by virtue of your position. But it is foolish.”
“Is it indeed?”
“He has no reason to be interested in you, other than that you hold the keys to his cell.”
Bilbo is still not entirely certain to whom they are referring, though he has his suspicions. Judging by the expression on Thorin’s face, the king cannot even understand the words. That is probably for the best. He would not be pleased to learn that his nephew is fraternizing with Elves. “He is kind and funny to speak to,” Tauriel replies sharply. “And he is interested in the stars.”
“Ah, yes, the stars he cannot see while locked away,” Legolas says. His small smile is unreadable. Does he pity the prisoners, then? “Perhaps he thinks his kindness and his humor will entice you to open his cell.”
“I am not a fool, Legolas. I will not be seduced into freeing the prisoners.”
“Seduced?” Legolas echoes. “I was not aware that you were being seduced in the first place, Tauriel. But whatever the Dwarf has been saying to you—“
“His name is Kíli,” she interrupts the prince, which has to be a great impertinence. Thorin shoots to attention at that, his back stiffening and his fists clenching.
Bilbo places a gentle hand on the king’s thigh. He wishes to calm him, somehow, but of course, he cannot risk the words.
“Fine,” Legolas does not seem to miss a beat. “Then whatever Kíli has been saying to you, I would not trust. He has much to gain from earning your friendship. You, however, have little to gain from earning his. At best, he will escape with his people and be gone from here forever. He would have to be a fool to return, even for you. And where will that leave you?”
“It will leave me here, with a friend who lives in another kingdom,” Tauriel argues, “Not such a bad fate.”
“Is that all it is, then, really?” Legolas asks, eyes penetrating.
“What concern is it of yours?” Tauriel demands. “And besides, that is all it can be. I will not plant my hopes where there is no soil for them.”
“As you should not,” Legolas agrees.
“Your father thinks that you are interested in me,” the guard changes the subject abruptly, and Bilbo can see why. “And you are not helping matters by getting jealous of the prisoners.”
“I am not jealous,” Legolas assures her, “As I said. I am confused.”
“It looks very much like jealousy,” Tauriel says, “And it will look that way to your father.”
“My father does not look often into his dungeons,” Legolas retorts, “And I do not see why you care what he thinks.”
“I care because he is my king,” she explains, “And because he is the father of my dearest friend. In every way but blood, he has been a father to me, as well.” Though not a very kind father, if he would tell her to her face that he does not think her good enough for his son.
“He expects me to be interested in Elf Maids.” Legolas seems to have come to terms with this idea, though he does not appear quite pleased with it. “And you are the only Elf Maid with whom I spend any time. It is natural for him to make assumptions, but you have nothing to fear. He will expect nothing.”
Bilbo recalls a story told gleefully by Pippin Took, in which Prince Legolas rode off into Fangorn Forest with Gimli, son of Glóin, perched on the back of his horse. Apparently, Legolas prefers the company of Dwarven fellows to that of Elven maidens, at least when he is choosing a companion for his rides into the sunset. Bilbo can only imagine how Glóin would feel about this, if he knew.
Tauriel does not say what she said the last time Bilbo eavesdropped. She does not express to Legolas that Thranduil does not think her worthy. Instead, she says, “I do not think that these Dwarves pose any serious threat.”
“Tauriel…”
“I cannot understand why your father would insist upon locking them up,” she proceeds, ignoring the Prince’s warning. “Kíli’s brother still carries several knives, but has made no attempt to use them.”
“If one of the prisoners is still armed,” Legolas replies cautiously, “You should have disarmed him immediately.”
“Many of them are warriors, but none have caused any trouble,” Tauriel continues, “And I do not remember when it became a crime for any to pass through your father’s lands.”
“My father is afraid,” says Legolas, “Between the spiders and the orcs—“
“Then we should be fighting spiders and orcs, not locking up travelers who have committed no crime.” Tauriel takes a breath. “I will follow the orders of my king. But surely I am permitted to my own opinion.” Bilbo doubts this, actually. He can’t image that Thranduil is fond of dissent within his kingdom, especially not when it comes from his primary enforcer.
“It seems the young Prince of Erebor has stolen something quite precious from the Woodland Realm,” says Legolas with a soft smile. There is a mocking note to his tone, however, one that shows precisely what he thinks of the Prince of Erebor. Bilbo is thankful that Thorin cannot understand the Elves, or else this might quickly become a mess that even Bilbo’s remarkable problem-solving abilities could not clean up. “The heart of its chief guard.”
He is joking, of course. He has to be. No Elf, not even a kind one like Legolas, would take so easily to such an idea. Bilbo remembers that Legolas and Gimli did not get on well at the Council in Rivendell. Their bond must have formed slowly, over the course of their journey, which is something Bilbo can relate to. Regardless, the prince was not kind to the company in the forest, and he is not being particularly kind now.
“I still have my bow,” Tauriel warns him, though the threat does not sound genuine, “And even if my heart were stolen, which it has not been, I would not give my love so freely to one I hardly know.”
“But it does not bother you that he is a Dwarf.”
“No, it does not.” The words fly out of Tauriel’s mouth, and she quickly qualifies them: “It bothers me that his people are being held here against their will, and that our resources are being spent upon them.”
“That is how prisons tend to operate, Tauriel,” Legolas reminds her. “We have a duty to the realm and to its King. We must—“
“Legolas,” Tauriel levels him with a shrewd glare. “You know as well as I do who these prisoners are.”
“It would be obvious to anyone who paid attention.” Easy for him to say, Bilbo thinks.
“They seek only their homeland. The dragon will not bother us, should they release it. Your father has no reason to hold them here.” She pauses. “Not when the threat upon our own doorstep grows greater each day. You cannot believe that these thirteen starving warriors have anything to do with the illness that plagues our forest.”
“You would see them free, then, if the choice rested in your hands?” Legolas asks.
“You would not?” Tauriel seems equally taken aback. “I would rather have my guards free, at least, to tend to other matters. It has been only a fortnight since we last cleared the spiders from that area of the woods, and yet, already they are back again in such great numbers!”
But then Legolas laughs. He throws an arm around her shoulder, a seemingly uncharacteristic gesture that Bilbo recognizes. He has seen Dwalin and Thorin interacting the same way. It is the behavior of a comrade in arms, the sort of bond that transcends social status and, apparently, the strict boundaries of Elven gender roles.
“I would see them free,” the prince decides, “If only to see your heart-thief on his way. I feel as though a wandering marauder has made a pass at my little sister. Perhaps I should speak to him.”
Tauriel swats at Legolas’s arm, but this apparently does not deter him. It is easy to imagine the two of them establishing this routine when they were much younger, before the broad gap in their social positions made itself apparent. “You should not!”
“Perhaps I should speak to his brother, and you will wind up with a Dwarven blade lodged in your throat. Then you’d learn to disarm prisoners, whether you’re fond of them or no.”
But he is clearly playing, joking. He is much different when chatting with his friend than he was when taking the company prisoner in the woods. It’s a good thing he isn’t serious. Bilbo doesn’t know how it would play out if Legolas attempted to have a conversation with Fíli about Kíli’s relationship with Tauriel, but that doesn’t sound like the wisest or safest course of action for anyone involved. Also, Thorin would probably overhear and start shouting.
“I would catch the knife,” Tauriel assures her friend.
“Oh, I don’t doubt it. So there would be no risk whatsoever.”
“Enough of that. Your father will soon miss you, and once you explain that you were with me, neither of us will hear the end of it.”
The captain elbows the prince in the ribs, and the two of them pass out of sight. Once their footsteps have retreated far enough that Bilbo is confident he won’t be overheard, he turns his attention back to Thorin. The king does not look well. His face is pale and tight with palpable anger. Of course. He could not understand what the Elves were saying, and caught only a few mentions of his nephew’s name, perhaps a couple of ‘Erebors’ here and there.
“Relax,” Bilbo breathes, “They mean Kíli no harm.”
“You understand Elvish?” Thorin snaps. Clearly, he’s elected not to follow Bilbo’s advice.
Bilbo shrugs. Of course, the gesture goes completely unobserved, but he cannot stop his natural reflexes. “I understand Sindarin far better than I speak it, but most of what I know comes from reading.” He’s spent years poring over Elvish books, though it’s best not to go down that road. He’s been reading Sindarin for longer than he’s supposed to have been alive, which is not something that he feels particularly inclined to explain to Thorin at this juncture. “Anyway, you have nothing to worry about.”
“They mentioned my sister-son by name several times.”
“Yes, they did,” Bilbo concedes. He doesn’t want to get Kíli in trouble, but he also has no desire to let Thorin worry needlessly. “Apparently, he’s made friends with the Captain of the Guard.”
“Friends?” Thorin echoes, “With an Elf? That is not possible. She must be using him somehow for her own gain.”
“That’s not too different from what the prince was telling her,” Bilbo continues, “And you’ll be happy to know that she would rather see the company free, if only so she could use the guards to patrol the forest and fight the spiders instead. It seems that Kíli has won her over, which you should also be glad about. That friendship may save his life one day.” Bilbo knows the story, after all, of what transpired between Kíli and Tauriel in Lake-town. “Also, Fíli is still armed.”
“They know this?” Thorin sounds doubtful. “Are you sure you understood them correctly?”
“Tauriel seemed to take it as a sign of our innocence that Fíli has knives on him still but has not used them,” Bilbo elaborates. “And Legolas thought it was all very funny.”
“He would laugh, while we are detained so unjustly in his kingdom?”
“He was raised by Thranduil,” Bilbo points out. He can’t imagine that Legolas was brought up to behave respectfully toward those less fortunate. Any kindness on his part must be entirely his own.
“Aye, that he was.” Thorin does not seem pleased with this at all. “All their talk of friendship, when they would speak at such length in front of me as though I were a piece of furniture.”
“That part’s not so good,” Bilbo admits. “But Kíli has done well. It doesn’t sound like Tauriel will work very hard to stop us if we tried to escape. He seems to have convinced her that we really only want to go to the mountain, that we have no quarrel with Thranduil.”
“I have plenty to quarrel about with that dishonorable—“
“Yes, I know,” Bilbo cuts him off. “But at least someone in your family is skilled with diplomacy.”
“I cannot see why this Elf has any interest in my sister-son,” Thorin says to the ceiling. “I hope she doesn’t harm him in her sport.”
Bilbo can understand what he means, and gives the king’s strong thigh a reassuring pat. He has no way of knowing that Tauriel is being genuine, and every reason to suspect a trick. “It could be worse,” Bilbo offers. “Besides, we’ll be out of here soon enough, anyway. Nothing to worry about.”
“I’d nearly forgotten that you are only biding your time, Master Burglar.” This, at least, does seem to cheer Thorin up. Bilbo neglects to mention that when they finally leave the Woodland Realm, they will by no means be seeing the last of Tauriel.
After two weeks in the dungeons, very little progress has been made. By which, of course, Bilbo means that he has not come any closer to escaping from the cell. The guards do not open the door wide enough for even a Hobbit to sneak through when they come bearing food, and the cell is never opened for any other reason. It is clear that if Bilbo wants to get out, he will have to manufacture some reason for the cell door to be opened all the way.
The company, too, grows restless. Bilbo cannot blame any of them. He knows that Kíli has been chatting with Tauriel; on quiet nights, he can hear their hushed voices carrying down the stairs, though he can never make out the precise words. The others, however, have very little to entertain them, and it is beginning to show.
“We’ve been here for weeks,” Ori laments, “We’ll be here forever, most likely.”
“Not forever,” Dori tries to comfort his brother.
“Oh, and how do you expect we’re going to get out?” This from Nori, always the realist. “Took my lock picks, they did, and the pins out of my hair.”
“They saw you coming a mile away, eyebrows braided like that,” Dwalin grumbles. It’s hard to tell whether this utterance is fond or grudging.
“Took back all what I stole from Rivendell, too,” Nori continues, ignoring Dwalin entirely.
“I’m impressed you managed to carry that this far,” says Balin from the cell beside Thorin’s.
Bombur mutters something which, typically, is too quiet for Bilbo to hear clearly at this distance, though Bofur clearly has no trouble hearing and cackling at whatever comment his brother just made.
“The goblins still have my candelabra,” Nori grumbles, either ignoring Bombur as well or unaware that he has spoken. Or, perhaps responding to whatever he said. Since Bilbo has no clue what that was, he has no clue how one might respond to it respectfully.
“Elrond’s candelabra, you mean,” Glóin puts in.
“I didn’t see his name on it.”
“Because you scratched it off.”
“No, I scratched off ‘made in Rivendell,’ and I’m sure the goblins are using it to light their tunnels now!”
“Well, good,” Dori groans, “You’ve brought them some culture. Congratulations.”
“When we take back Erebor, we’ll be sure to send you as an envoy with more light fixtures,” Fíli quips, though he doesn’t sound particularly joyful.
Nori mutters something very dark-sounding in Khuzdul. “None of that!” Dori scolds him. “I don’t want your brother picking up such language.”
“Ori swears worse than that all the time,” Kíli pipes in helpfully. He, at least, seems cheerful. Ah, young love. “I’ve heard him.”
“What are you trying to do?” Ori demands, though the entire company must know that Kíli’s announcement was entirely accurate. Ori certainly has a way with words, and not all of them are entirely polite.
“It doesn’t matter,” Glóin huffs, “We won’t be getting out any time soon. You’re safe from your brother’s wrath for now, lad.”
“And if we do get out, I’m sure Ori will be plenty old enough to swear by then,” Bofur joins in with his characteristic gallows humor, “That is, if we’re anything more than dust and bones.”
Now it’s Bifur’s turn to make a comment in Khuzdul. Óin laughs. “That’s just what I was thinking!”
“You need a new trumpet, my friend,” Balin counsels, “I doubt you’re thinking what he’s thinking, unless you’ve developed a death wish.”
“Nothing so dishonorable about that,” Fíli calls, “I’d rather die in battle than rot in a cell.”
“Not a battle at all, thirteen against however many thousand,” Bofur points out.
“At least not a battle we can win,” Bombur agrees.
“We could win it if we had our weapons,” says Dwalin, “I say, if we get out, the best we can do is take our chances.”
“Tauriel would look the other way,” Kíli seems convinced of this, though Bilbo knows that he’s being rather too optimistic. Tauriel might not agree with Thranduil’s decision to hold the company prisoner, but that doesn’t mean she’ll disobey direct orders from her king. Not yet, anyway.
“Seems she spends a lot of time looking your way!” Nori says. Thankfully, there are no guards nearby to overhear. There rarely are at this hour. “Think you could use that to our advantage?”
“No,” Kíli says firmly. “I won’t use her for anything.”
“She locked you in a cell,” Fíli reminds him, quite reasonably, Bilbo thinks. “I don’t think we should trust her any more than any of the other guards.”
“The other guards don’t speak to us,” Kíli alleges, “And they do not return the things they’ve taken.” He does not elaborate on this oblique reference any further. “Tauriel is… different. She didn’t even search me.”
“Not even after you asked her to,” Fíli recounts. “Mahal knows why you did that.”
“Mahal knows why Kíli does anything,” Thorin murmurs, quietly enough that only Bilbo can hear him.
“He’s been bewitched by that Elf,” Glóin decides, “It’s a sad thing to see. Do you know the cure for witchcraft, brother?”
“You’re asking if I know leechcraft? After all these years, of course I do!” Óin calls back indignantly.
“This is a mess,” Bilbo grumbles. He makes a mental note to reclaim Óin’s trumpet from the Elves at the earliest opportunity. It must be horrible, being imprisoned without being able to hear properly.
“My second heir has taken up with an Elf,” Thorin grumbles. “His mother will not be pleased.”
“And we’re all locked in a dungeon, and I’m fairly certain some of our friends are about to get violent, which won’t help us at all.” Bilbo is focused on slightly more pressing concerns. “But definitely the worst thing is that the poor boy has a little crush.”
“I do not trust the Elf Captain.”
“Yes, but you don’t trust any Elves at all, so it’s difficult to take your assessment with anything more than a grain of salt.”
“She is too friendly.” That is not how Bilbo would describe Tauriel at all. In fact, she seems rather reserved, even with Kíli. A practical lass, with a good head on her shoulders. Privately, Bilbo thinks the prince could do a lot worse.
“You’ve still got knives, haven’t you, Fíli?” Nori asks, far too loudly for Bilbo’s comfort. The guards could be back at any moment.
“Just a few,” Fíli concedes.
Bilbo places a gentle hand on Thorin’s arm. “You’ve got to do something before they try to start a fight they can’t win.” Not that they could do very much from behind bars, to begin with, but it’s still not a chance Bilbo wants to take.
Thorin sighs, but evidently sees the wisdom in Bilbo’s words. “Enough, all of you!” He roars. “There will be no mutiny this night.”
“Don’t think it is night, My King,” Dwalin protests, “It’s got to be nearly dawn.”
“Whatever time of day it is,” Thorin grits out, “You will stay your weapons. Or, rather, you will stay your hands. Because none of you have weapons. Is that clear?”
“Oh, very clear, uncle,” Fíli replies. He is probably the only one armed now, anyway, unless one of the others has managed to hide something away. Bilbo has his suspicions about Nori, for one.
“Good. Now, go about as you have been,” Thorin orders, “And do not fear. Master Baggins has a plan.”
The dungeons fall silent after that. Eventually, Bofur pipes in. “Um, begging your pardon, Your Majesty,” he begins, full of bluster. “But the last time we checked, Bilbo wasn’t here.”
Thorin chuckles. “Then you have not checked very closely.” He does not inform the group that Bilbo happens to be locked up in his cell, and allows them instead to leap to the conclusion that their Burglar is presently wandering around unseen in the Elven halls. “We must remain silent and guard his secret closely. Not a word to any of the Elves.” He shoots a sharp glare up the stairs, though Bilbo doubts that Kíli is able to see this.
The resultant cheer has calmed down by the time the Elf guards return, but the emotional environment in the dungeons seems to have changed for the better.
“It’s about time,” Balin says just loudly enough for the sound of his voice to carry into the adjoining cell. “I was wondering when you’d deign to let the rest of us in on your little ‘secret.’”
“Aye,” says Dwalin, also nearby, “You two have been keeping me up nearly every night with your chattering.”
“We were being quiet,” Bilbo protests. At least no one can see him blushing or fidgeting.
“You may’ve been trying to.” This, coming from Dwalin, is very charitable indeed. Bilbo doesn’t know why he expected any member of the company to allow Thorin to have the last word with his dramatic declaration.
Bilbo knows that the Feast of Starlight is fast approaching. If he wants to get his friends to safety, he will have to get out of this cell, and soon. He’s slept plenty over the course of the past several weeks, if fitfully, and he’s eaten more than he did when he was last here. He’s done his best to keep Thorin well-fed, too, though that was a challenge Bilbo wouldn’t like to repeat. He makes a point of not asking the king about his experience with food scarcity and self sacrifice. The evidence is right there, and Bilbo can draw his own conclusions.
“The Elves will be having their feast soon,” he informs Thorin, early in the morning, or possibly very late at night. Bilbo has done his best to mark the days, but he isn’t always certain of the precise time. The constant artificial light does not help things. “I have to get out of here and get the keys.”
If Bilbo didn’t understand the language of the Elves, he would not be at all confident on this point, but thankfully, he’s fairly certain of the impending schedule. Thorin sighs heavily. He is clinging to Bilbo, but that is only a matter of practicality: the stone bench they’re forced to sleep on is Man-sized, which gives them plenty of lengthwise space, but it is still a tight fit for them horizontally. There’s a significant chance of Bilbo rolling off onto the stone floor, and it makes sense that Thorin would not want to draw the attention of the guards with the loud thud of a Hobbit hitting the ground.
It’s more than that, of course. But neither of them would be stupid enough to even entertain the idea of acting upon that extra substance here, in the dungeons of the Elven King. Not physically; they could be caught. Not emotionally; they do not have the time or privacy for such a conversation. In Lake-town, though, things will be different. Bilbo will say something in Lake-town.
“I do not wish to see you go,” Thorin murmurs.
Bilbo can’t help rolling his eyes at that. “You do not wish to see me escape an Elven prison? Noted. I’ll file that away for later, and we can discuss it once we’re free.”
But it’s some relief to find that he’s not the only one enjoying this embrace. He still has nightmares, of course. They are graphic and vivid as they always have been. The strange ones with cryptic undertones are a welcome relief from watching his friends die night after night, but they are still deeply disturbing. Even so, Bilbo is comforted by Thorin’s presence, and embarrassed by how much comfort he is able to take in this awful situation. It’s such a horrible mess, and Bilbo does not have time to dwell on it, because he has to save his friends. And quickly, too, before they veer too far off the course of the original adventure.
“Obviously, I was not referring to that,” Thorin grumbles. “I only wish I could go with you.”
“Ah, yes, and how would that work?” Bilbo asks. He’s very fond of Thorin, indeed, but his king can be a little obtuse when he sets his mind to it. “I’d be invisible, and you’d… what, follow around behind me? I’m sure nobody would be any the wiser. How are you going to let me face the dragon alone if you can’t even stomach having me wander around Thranduil’s halls for a few days?”
“Smaug is a stupid beast and will be easy to kill if we sneak up on him,” Thorin resolves. Oh, by the Valar, does he actually believe this? That would explain a lot about his otherwise inexplicable refusal to make any sort of plan for fighting the dragon. “Assuming he is still alive after all these years of silence. Thranduil is unpredictable and would use you to get to me, as he is using the rest of my kin.”
“He’d have to catch me first.” Bilbo forces himself to sit up, because he feels incredibly compelled to kiss Thorin on the lips, and that is not happening. Not here, not now, for any number of reasons. “Anyway, I’m the only one here with anything even resembling an escape plan, and we need to get to Erebor by Durin’s day. You’ll have to let me go.”
Thorin sighs again. He, too, sits up, and his fingers twitch as though he is restraining himself from reaching out for Bilbo. Probably, now that they’re no longer in direct contact, the king isn’t entirely certain of where Bilbo actually is. His spatial awareness is truly abysmal. “I suppose I will,” he admits eventually.
Bilbo does not gloat. He knows that this victory was not easily gotten, and that he should accept it with grace. He may gloat later, though, once they’ve escaped. Lake-town will be a nice place for that, as well, he supposes. “Thank you.” Once more, Bilbo restrains himself from going in for the kiss. That would not help anything.
“You will return to me each night and tell me how you fare,” Thorin orders. Ah, well, Bilbo should not have expected him to give up control of the situation so easily.
“Of course.” It’s only a few nights, anyway. Three or four at the most. And Bilbo likely would’ve come back on his own, if only to make sure that Thorin was eating and sleeping. And then there is the rest of the company to consider. “Do you have some sort of plan?”
“Yes.” This is not typical. “I do not like it.”
“Well, that’s good. I’ve found the best plans are the ones that you don’t like,” Bilbo quips.
Truthfully, he doesn’t enjoy ceding control any more than Thorin does, but he doesn’t see what choice he has. Bilbo can’t see a way out of the cell. If he makes himself known, he’ll be hauled off to a cell of his own, and he knows he can’t win in a physical confrontation with the Elves. He has Sting, but they’re all armed as well, and there must be hundreds of them.
Thorin sighs again. “If I am killed—“
“What?”
“Please do not interrupt.” And now he’s saying please. He is asking Bilbo nicely for something. Oh, by the Green Lady, this really is going to be a horrible plan, isn’t it? “If I am killed or transferred to a deeper dungeon that you cannot find, save the others first. When Fíli has the throne back, he can make arrangements with Thranduil.” Arrangements to reclaim the body, he does not say.
Bilbo blinks at him, then remembers that Thorin cannot see his confused expression. “What exactly are you planning to do?”
“Be silent,” Thorin orders. At least, Bilbo takes it as an order, and not a response to his question. “When they open the door to take me, you must follow.”
Bilbo doesn’t like the sound of that at all. “What?”
“Be silent,” Thorin repeats. Oh, well, Bilbo asked for this, didn’t he? He made his bed, and now it seems that he is going to have to lay in it. “The guards will be here soon.”
Bilbo doesn’t see how Thorin could possibly know that, but maybe he’s better at judging the passage of time without natural light than Bilbo is. Still, the king is correct; after only a few moments, two guards approach, passing the cell on their regular rounds.
“I wish to treat with Thranduil,” Thorin announces the moment that the Elves are within earshot.
Not the most graceful approach, but then, Thorin has been living in a cell for several weeks, and he is making a major sacrifice so that Bilbo can enact his plan, without any knowledge whatsoever about what the plan is. This is not good. It is different from what happened last time, which means that it could change the outcome significantly. But what choice does Bilbo have? He needs to get out of the cell, and he needs to get the company to safety, and anyway, it’s already happening, whether he wants it to or not.
So, as instructed, when the guards open the cell door wider than he’s ever seen it opened before, Bilbo takes his chance and darts away. He feels guilty leaving Thorin, but it’s only for a few nights. And Thorin was just being dramatic, talking about being killed. Bilbo frantically pushes down the emotions boiling in his gut at present, because he knows they will not serve him. He has to rescue the company.
True to his word, he returns to Thorin’s cell at night, and, thankfully, finds the king in one piece. There is a fresh bruise spreading across his face, which Bilbo does not appreciate, but at least Thorin has not managed to get himself killed during Bilbo’s brief absence. “What happened?” Bilbo asks, ghosting his invisible fingers across the irritated skin.
“Nothing,” Thorin lies. “At least, nothing that I would not expect from an coward and a traitor lacking in all honor.”
“He struck you?” Bilbo is going to kill Thranduil. He is going to sort out the battle, ensure the safety of all three kingdoms, and personally stick his sword in Azog’s neck. And then, after all that, he is going to murder the king of the Woodland realm.
No. That is not who Bilbo Baggins is. He is not a murderer. He is entitled to his anger on Thorin’s behalf, but seeking vengeance will not help. Thranduil, really, is no different from Gollum: a pathetic and wicked creature, yes, but that does not mean that Bilbo is allowed to decide whether he lives or dies. He will focus on his own king instead.
Thorin leans into Bilbo’s touch as best he can through the bars of his cell. “No. One of the guards did this.” He does not elaborate with further context, and Bilbo does not request it. There will be time for this, too, in Lake-town.
“Right, well.” Bilbo has to collect himself. “We can talk about that later. For now, I think I’ve found where they’re keeping our weapons. I won’t be able to carry very many, but I should be able to smuggle out a few knives. Not enough for everybody, but—“
“Anything you can find, we can use,” Thorin informs him. “Even small weapons are better than nothing.”
“Yes. Right, then.” At least Bilbo has clear instructions now.“I’ll do my best. And I was wrong about the timing: the feast is tomorrow evening. We’ll have to move quickly. I’ll be back for you as soon as possible.” He moves to turn away, but finds Thorin grabbing his wrist through the bars of his cell. His grip is gentle, but there is urgency in the gesture nevertheless. It is a wonder to Bilbo that Thorin even managed to locate his wrist in order to grab it.
“Take care, Master Baggins,” Thorin orders.
Bilbo shakes his head, before remembering that he is invisible. It’s somewhat troubling, that he is so easily able to forget he’s got the ring on. But he does not have time to dwell on it. “I will,” he promises. “I’ll see you tomorrow night.”
