Actions

Work Header

Five Simple Steps

Chapter 9: The King's Faithful Servant

Notes:

So... the original chapter nine was more than 20k words long, so I had to chop it in half to be able to post it this week. I guess we're going to have two (2) Lake-town chapters. There was just so much banter, and everything got out of hand with the Elves...
Thanks as always for reading, commenting, and leaving kudos! Please enjoy!

Chapter Text

“How’d you manage to hide a Halfling in your cell for three weeks?” Dwalin inquires as the company follows Master Baggins into the Elven King’s cellars.

It’s a fair question, despite the offensive language. Thorin can understand why Dwalin might not have processed the correction he was given in the depths of Mirkwood. After all, the entire company was delirious then, and until they met Master Baggins, they all used ‘Hobbit’ and ‘Halfling’ interchangeably to refer to the residents of the Shire. “A Hobbit. He can turn invisible,” Thorin replies. 

“Explains a lot,” Dwalin decides. 

“That it does,” says Balin. He’s got quite the spring in his step, now that he knows how the Hobbit got past his lookout after they escaped from the goblin tunnels. Apparently, that particular puzzle was bothering him until he began eavesdropping on Bilbo and Thorin in their shared cell. Thorin is somewhat preoccupied by other matters.

He knows that there is a plan, but he does not know what that plan is. He knows that Master Baggins has armed some of the company, but he does not know whom or with what. He also knows that his beloved nephew has been bewitched somehow by an Elf, which is perhaps the worst fate that could befall anyone of Durin’s line. Thorin can only hope that Kíli will see sense once they are free of the Woodland realm. 

Master Baggins leads the group down to the cellars. This is the plan that he’s been touting for the past several weeks? Of course it is. What was it he said, right before Thorin’s ill-advised confrontation with Thranduil? I’ve found the best plans are the ones that you don’t like. In that case, he will be pleased to know that Thorin absolutely hates this ridiculous plot. 

“Right. Into the barrels,” the Hobbit instructs.

Thorin feels compelled to trust him. It is as though his body is doing the trusting without his mind’s consent, and he does not care for the feeling. He does not care for any feelings, really. He’s been pushing them down as long as he’s been aware of them, but that is no mean feat around Master Baggins. Thorin will reluctantly admit that his feelings about the Burglar are becoming more than a simple distraction. They are becoming a liability.

He nearly did not allow the Hobbit to leave his cell. For a few moments, Thorin was prepared to spend the remainder of his life rotting in an Elven dungeon if it meant keeping Bilbo Baggins within his reach. Which was ridiculous, and a selfish line of thinking, and counterintuitive to his very important quest. That is why Thorin swallowed his pride and feigned contrition, requesting an audience with the Elven King. 

That part wasn’t so bad. Perhaps the swearing and spitting was a little much, but Thranduil deserved it. Actually, Thranduil deserved worse, and had Thorin’s hands not been bound on that occasion, he’d have gotten it, too. As it stands, Thorin wasted about twenty minutes of the Elf’s time, said nothing that was not known already by all, and earned a harsh reprimand from an Elven guard. The Woodland King, of course, is too much of a coward to deal with his own prisoners, not that this came as any sort of surprise. And that son of his! Thorin fully intends to reclaim Orcrist from the Elven Prince at the earliest opportunity.

“Do as he says,” Thorin instructs his company when they greet the Hobbit’s instructions with grumbling. 

“Really? Barrels?” Kíli does not seem convinced. “I still think Tauriel would look the other way if we did something less…” At least he doesn’t seem to be trying very hard to find the right word to describe Bilbo’s plan. Something tells Thorin that truly voicing such an adjective would not go well for the lad at all. 

“You are blinded by your own affection,” Bilbo tells Kíli with false cheer. “And anyway, she’d lose her job, and then what would happen to her? Into the barrels, now, please, unless you’d like to try and swim the river.” 

“Do as he says,” Thorin repeats, much more harshly this time. He is not pleased with his sister-son. 

Kíli rolls his eyes and mutters under his breath but allows Bilbo to help him into the barrel. The rest of the company responds in more or less the same way. “I’m going to send you down the river now,” Bilbo announces. “I’ll be right behind you. Be ready for battle.” 

“Battle?” Óin demands. “Did I hear that right, lads?”

“It seems you did,” Bofur confirms. 

Bifur asks what Master Baggins is talking about, and Thorin finds that he would also like to know. But before he can translate the question to the common tongue for the Hobbit’s benefit, his barrel is turned on its side, and he is tumbling with the rest of them down into the icy river. 

 

In eighty years, Bilbo has still not found a way around the obvious problem with the barrel-riding plan: he, himself, is not in a barrel, and he has nobody to pack him into one, because all his friends are already floating away.

“Where is the keeper of the keys?” And that’d be Tauriel, again, hot on Bilbo’s heels. 

Thankfully, he distinctly remembers shuffling backwards in a panic the last time he was caught here, and in doing so, inadvertently opening the chute. This time, he goes at a run, rushing to the same spot where once he stood by mistake and tipping the balance of the large plank so that it pushes him into the water. He manages to paddle his way to his friends, which is no small feat. Strangely, upon his return to the Shire, Bilbo did not take the time to teach himself to swim. 

“Well done, Master Baggins,” Thorin tells him solemnly. And then the lads are ushering Bilbo over to their barrels as best they can, setting him up so that he’s posed at an awkward angle between the two of them. Still, at least he isn’t drowning. 

They are out of the frying pan and into the fire once again, Bilbo knows. There will be an orc attack just as they reach the gate, which will, of course, be shut on them. And Bilbo remembers all too well what happened the last time they were here. The waterfall is not any more pleasant this time than it was on the last adventure, that’s for certain. 

He’s come up with a plan, though, and it’s foolproof. Well, actually, it’s incredibly dangerous and may result in his death, but he’s willing to take the risk anyway, which he knows is stupid of him. Everything worked out just fine the last time, didn’t it? Nobody died. And his friends were a lot of help in Lake-town when push came to shove. He knows that Fíli in particular did some wonderful fighting to protect Bard’s family, though the lad was appropriately bashful about it when Bilbo asked for more details.

But Bilbo cannot allow himself to stand by while one of his friends suffers, especially not if he can prevent it. He doesn’t remember the exact details of the confrontation, because he wasn’t paying much attention when it happened, but he does remember the basics of the situation. The Elves closed the gates, and the orcs attacked while the company was trapped beneath the bridge, an outcome which seems imminent at present. Kíli went to lift the gate and was hit in the leg by a poisoned arrow.

Bilbo would love to have more accurate information than his dim recollection on which to base his assessment of where the enemy will come from, but unfortunately, that isn’t possible. He will have to do his best to protect the lad. 

There is distant shouting in Sindarin and the blowing of a horn. An Elven guard in full armor pulls a lever, and the gate slams shut, barring the company’s progress through the river. “No!” Thorin roars.  And then an arrow hits the Elf, and orc speech can be heard, even by those so far under the bridge that they cannot see what is taking place above them. 

“Watch out!” Bofur shouts. “There’s orcs!” 

And their enemies fall upon them then, leaping at the Elves overhead and the company down below. There is much slashing and swinging of fists, much ducking and dodging and grunting. The last time, Bilbo was too overwhelmed by it all to act. But this time, he does not have that option. He has no choice but to act.

“Listen, Kíli,” Bilbo orders, catching the lad before he can try something stupid and dangerous. “I see the lever, too, and I’m going to go for it. I need you to stay in your barrel and cover me. Aim for those archers.” 

“Are you going to turn invisible?” Kíli hisses. He couldn’t get out of his barrel if he wanted to, with Bilbo clinging to the side the way he is. 

“I am,” Bilbo agrees, “Don’t move. I might kick you, and you won’t see it coming.”

And with that, Bilbo slips the ring onto his finger and makes for the lever. Climbing up onto the shore using his friends’ barrels as a foothold is simple enough. Only, reaching the lever itself looked far easier when an agile and practiced Dwarven warrior was doing it. For an underfed Hobbit, who, after all these years and all this adventuring, has still not done very much in the way of athletics, the passage is a bit more precarious. Still, Bilbo makes it to the bridge, probably with no small measure of help from whichever Valar have become so invested in his quest and its fate. He crawls along on his belly, trying his best to avoid the flying arrows and to dodge between the legs of the orcs. 

Fíli and Kíli are doing what they can. Unfortunately, that is little help, considering that they have perhaps one proper weapon between them and are otherwise armed with pinecones and small river stones. They’ve both got strong arms, but Bilbo knows he can’t rely on them to cover him with impunity. He must behave as though there is a poisoned arrow always headed in his direction. Dwalin throws a spear, commandeered from one of the orcs, either in an attempt to arm Bilbo (who, mind you, is already armed) or to take out some of his potential assailants. Not that any of them pay much mind to the Hobbit sneaking between their legs. They seem a bit preoccupied with the fact that they’re being pummeled on all sides by the Elves. 

Fíli throws a well-timed knife, felling the orc who has been guarding the lever, though he can’t possibly know how close Bilbo is to his goal. Last time, Bilbo distinctly remembers watching Kíli decapitate another orc immediately before getting shot. This time, Bilbo slashes at the final guard’s legs with Sting, sending him topping into the water. He can only hope that his timing is good enough and his friends are placed well enough to avoid being crushed or impaled on the falling orc’s weapon. 

When Bilbo reaches the lever, he becomes aware of yet another feat which he should have foreseen. He wasn’t paying enough attention before, plainly. And he did not think this through. It was a struggle enough for Kíli to open the gate. So why does Bilbo think that a Hobbit with no upper body strength to speak of will be able to manage the same task? But then, Kíli was already injured when he pulled the lever, and Bilbo is well enough. 

Tauriel appears, then, and Legolas. The two of them fight well, in tandem, clearly practiced at working together to achieve such ends. Bilbo cannot afford to stand around watching. He must act. He trusts his friends and the Elves to cover him as he wrestles with the lever.

Shouts down below alert Bilbo to the partial opening of the doors. But he knows there’s more to go. He’s got to put more force into it, force that he doesn’t have. Just as Bilbo is trying to figure out how to do that, he feels a sharp, sudden pain just at his hip. An arrow. An orc arrow. Probably the same poisoned arrow that would have been stuck in Kíli’s thigh, had he been the one to come up here.  

Bilbo utters a string of words that would’ve induced any Hobbiton matron to box his ears, even at his advanced age, the sort of phrase he’d never have dreamed of uttering in Frodo’s impressionable presence. 

“Bilbo!” Kíli calls, scrambling onto the bridge. He’s fast. He’s very fast. And he would have to be, to have executed this maneuver so seamlessly the last time. He plucks a weapon from a dead orc and makes his way to Bilbo, making quick work of those few orcs who are not engaged with Elves. “I can’t find you. Where are you?” 

The Elven archers have taken out the orcs with bows, at least. Bilbo knows without having to look behind him that one Elven archer in particular will be paying close attention to this interaction, and, if the Green Lady is merciful, covering Bilbo and Kíli for the moment. Still, Bilbo does look. As expected, Tauriel does not take her gaze from Kíli.

But the lad is distracted, frantic. Searching for Bilbo, who must get the gate open. The pain is excruciating. Bilbo cannot believe that Kíli was even able to hold a conversation in Lake-town, let alone to walk around. “Here,” he mutters. He needs Kíli to get out of the way before he gets himself shot and negates whatever sacrifice Bilbo just made. Then, remembering the obvious solution, Bilbo slips the ring off his finger and into his pocket. He throws himself to the ground, clinging to the lever with full force and using the momentum of his fall to push the gates the rest of the way open. 

If Tauriel is surprised by the sudden appearance of a Hobbit, she does not show it, but an arrow flies over Bilbo’s head, and it’s clear that she is still paying attention. Kíli breathes a few mysterious words in Khuzdul, then scoops Bilbo up. “Are you alright?” Kíli asks. 

“Poisoned,” Bilbo murmurs. 

“Shot, you mean,” Kíli corrects him. 

Before Bilbo can argue, the lad tosses him in the general direction of their friends’ barrels (ill-advised plan, that) and follows after. 

Bilbo comes down around Nori’s shoulders, just barely missing being thrown into the river and probably drowning or hitting his head on a rock. He couldn’t swim before he got hit with an orc arrow. Yavanna knows how he’d fare in the water afterwards. Perhaps Bilbo should’ve mentioned that to Kíli, who, he realizes, has now saved his life on two separate occasions. And Bilbo still has not thanked him! 

“Sorry,” Bilbo manages to say to Nori, once they are over the second of what will probably be many waterfalls. He grits his teeth through the pain. He does not have the option of suffering. It is a luxuryhe cannot afford. Their fight with the orcs, after all, is just beginning. 

“Oh, no problem,” Nori grits out. “Didn’t hurt at all.” 

“Yes, well, Óin can see to your bruises when we’re not in the middle of a battle,” Bilbo quips. 

Bilbo has endured worse pain, he reminds himself. He watched Thorin Oakenshield die. He saw little Frodo come back from Mordor, irrevocably changed, unable to enjoy any of the simple pleasures which once defined his life. If Bilbo could handle those horrors, surely a poisoned puncture wound is only a small matter. 

“Why didn’t you send down an extra barrel for yourself?” Nori asks. He has claimed an orc’s hammer and is currently making very liberal use of it. Bilbo decides that this is not an ideal position for him to occupy.

“Because I didn’t think of that.” And he had eighty years to do it, too. Honestly, Nori is the real expert Burglar here. 

“Should’ve run your plan by me instead of Thorin.”

“You think I ran this by Thorin?” Bilbo manages to impale an orc on Sting, and Nori reaches his arm into the water to paddle a little, steering the barrel away from the corpse. “He never would’ve agreed if he’d known what my plan was.” He’s not going to be happy that Bilbo is injured. Still, better him than Kíli. 

“I’m surprised he let you out of his sight long enough to find a way out.” Nori’s tone is knowing. Of course it is. On the last adventure, at least, people were polite enough to keep their thoughts about Bilbo and Thorin to themselves. But then, on the last adventure, Thorin was never so very possessive as he is these days. Bilbo supposes that he might say something, too, if he were watching his fearless leader fret over a Hobbit all the time. 

“Oh, so am I,” Bilbo agrees.

And then the battle is in full swing, and there isn’t much time for conversation. Luckily for the company, the orcs prove once again to be a distraction for the Woodland Folk. They seem to forget their original objective of reclaiming their prisoners, and instead direct their attention to slaughtering the orcs. And if Bilbo catches Tauriel’s worried stare more than once during the skirmish, well, that’s hardly much of a surprise, is it? 

 

The company washes up, once again, on the shores near Lake-town, and it seems that any surviving orcs have retreated. Bilbo works automatically, helping to pull his compatriots out of their barrels. He’s not even shocked when Thorin corners him, both of them soaking wet and shivering. 

“Burglar.” So it’s back to just Burglar, then. Thorin is apparently not going to acknowledge the fact that they just spent three weeks perpetually in each other’s arms, which is fine by Bilbo. He doesn’t particularly want to acknowledge that, either. 

Bilbo’s annoyance is not justified. Obviously, Thorin can’t go about telling the whole company that the two of them have been sharing the stone slab that the Elves were cruel enough to call a bed. As if everybody and his brother doesn’t know that already! And why would Thorin feel the need to bring it up? They’re away from it now. Perhaps he wouldn’t have done it for just anybody, but it no longer matters very much that he shared his bed with Bilbo. 

Besides, Bilbo should enjoy these next few moments, while Thorin is entirely unaware of his injury. He knows that the king will become insufferable the moment he figures out that Bilbo has been shot. Though some small part of the Hobbit does want to see the sort of passionate reaction that he knows Thorin is capable of. Can he really blame Thorin for being so protective of him, when Bilbo himself acts just the same way? They really do need to have a conversation about this, and soon. 

Or is that not the best idea? Will it change how Thorin reacts in Erebor, if Bilbo is upfront about his feelings? Will he be weakened somehow? Will he pay less attention to the dragon? But what if knowing all the ways in which he is loved is a strengthening agent for Thorin? Bilbo has no clue how to proceed.

He elects to meet Thorin where he is. “Your Majesty.” Bilbo feigns a little bow, wincing as the motion jostles his injury. Thankfully, his face is turned downward, preventing Thorin from getting a good look at his pained expression. No doubt that would lead to all sorts of pointless nonsense. After all, there is perhaps nothing for Bilbo’s oncoming illness now but the healing magic of an Elf, and there don’t appear to be many of those on hand.

“I thought I told you never to put yourself in danger for my sake again.” Thorin actually sounds serious. As though he thought Bilbo would simply roll over and follow the instructions he gave on the Carrock! 

Bilbo shakes his head. “And I told you that I’d do any number of dangerous things in the name of protecting the company.” 

Even though he didn’t say that. No, he’d been very clear when he’d said that he’d stick his neck out for Thorin in particular. But he would risk himself for any of them. Case in point, it is a struggle to hold himself upright at present. And still, Bilbo would do it again.

“You should not have been the one to pull that lever. You are the weakest among us and not trained for fighting. Fíli or Kíli—“

“Would have been shot with an orc arrow,” Bilbo nips this line of conversation in the bud. 

It is only then that Thorin notices the wound on Bilbo’s hip. Honestly, Bilbo doesn’t know what he was expecting. Perhaps he thought that Thorin might scold him further, or thank him for protecting the lads from such a painful fate. Certainly, he would not have put any money on the idea of Thorin falling to his knees upon the rocks before him. “You are wounded,” Thorin observes, before lapsing into incomprehensible Khuzdul. 

“Only a little.” Bilbo does not wish to worry the king, after all, and besides, they have places to be. They’ve got to get to Lake-town, away from the orcs and Elves, before any more of them get shot. They’ve got to follow the path of the last adventure exactly. Bilbo can’t very well go around moping about his injury. If Kíli could do this, so can Bilbo. “It’s really just a scratch.” 

Thorin shoots him a sharp look. “I am not a fool, Master Baggins.” 

Well, at least that brought him back to himself. “Alright, fine, a bit more than a scratch,” Bilbo concedes, “But we can hardly do anything about it now. The arrow’s out, and that tumble through the river has cleaned it better than anything else could. The wound is very shallow. I’ll be fine.” He is not being entirely truthful. 

But at the same time, he knows that Óin will not be able to do anything about the poison. He couldn’t help Kíli the last time, could he? Bilbo remembers how sick the lad was when they were boarding the boats to cross the Long Lake. What he needs is Elven medicine, and until he can get it, there’s no point worrying the rest of the company. Besides, Bilbo is a Hobbit. His people are hardy and can withstand the sorts of injuries that would fell any of the big folk. Maybe he’ll be spared the worst effects of the poison, at least long enough to get to Erebor. Bilbo can destroy the ring and riddle with the dragon, at least, before he meets his end.

“You should not have risked yourself,” Thorin scolds him. 

“And whom should I have risked?” 

“Nobody.” Ah, such a wise and logical monarch that Bilbo has chosen to follow! 

“Nobody,” Bilbo echoes. “Forgive me, My King, but if nobody had pulled that lever, then we would probably all have been shot or stabbed or who knows what else, and then no doubt taken back into the custody of the Elves! Do you think Thranduil would’ve let us escape a second time?” 

“Let me see to you,” Thorin resolves. And oh, isn’t this just the same argument all over again? But this time, Bilbo will admit that he has no ground to stand on. “And once we are safe, Óin should have a look.” 

After all, Thorin is not injured, and he has a point about Bilbo’s need of aid. Unfortunately, Bilbo knows that this is not an option right now. “There’s no time,” he protests, “We’ve got to get to Lake-town before the orcs catch up with us. Or worse, the Elves.”

The joke falls flat. “You will go nowhere with an open wound on your leg.” Thorin was nowhere near this obstinate when Kíli was the injured party. 

Then again, that may have had something to do with the fact that Fíli insisted upon seeing to his brother’s leg, and Thorin had no one to argue with. He was concerned about making a quick escape then, as he is now. And it does make sense that he would worry less about a trained warrior than he does about a gentlehobbit who, apparently, bears an awfully close resemblance to some sort of fruit seller. In all his years, Bilbo still has not entirely forgiven that grocer comment.

“Don’t be ridiculous! We’re in the middle of the wilderness. I’m perfectly alright with providing a show for our company, but we’re bound to start attracting nasty visitors sooner or later if you keep this up.” 

“If I keep this up?” Thorin echoes, his resolve faltering. He drops his hand, which is probably a good thing, because it looked suspiciously as though he was planning to grab the back of Bilbo’s thigh. 

“You heard me. We can have this conversation later, my—“ Not my love. Do not call him that in the middle of an argument, Bilbo Baggins, you fool! Perhaps the poison from the arrow is getting to his head already. Then again, if he’s got to save the term of endearment for a time when he and Thorin are not bickering, in all likelihood, Bilbo will never get the chance to say it at all. “Anyway, we’ll discuss it once we’re safe.”

“Mahal save me from stubborn Hobbits,” Thorin grumbles under his breath. Bilbo gets the feeling that this is not the first time the king has uttered those very words. “You cannot walk around with an open wound. It will only take two minutes to bind.” 

“Well, let’s see if Óin has two minutes.” The last thing Bilbo needs is for Thorin to start touching his legs with those strong hands of his, tending to his battle wounds with such firm care. And Thorin should be pleased that Bilbo is willing to endure a pointless visit with a healer who bears no supplies whatsoever. The Elves took all their baggage, after all, and Óin’s medicines and bandages with them. 

They are interrupted by the clearing of a throat. “Thorin,” Balin hisses, “We are under attack.”

For a moment, Bilbo thinks that the orcs have returned. That would be a pretty pickle, indeed: to be cornered here on this little strip of land, where they had not been cornered before. It would be an indication of a serious change to the plot of their adventure, which Bilbo would not know how to handle in itself or as a sign of things to come. After all, their last serious confrontation with the orcs was very different from the one that Bilbo remembers, and almost exclusively because of his actions. It’s perfectly possible that something could have changed. 

But, no. It’s only Bard. “Oh,” Bilbo says absently, “Hello, Bard.”

Not his smartest move by a long shot, but Bilbo is flustered by his recent fear, and he still has orc poison in his veins, and he has not yet cooled down from his argument with Thorin. But really, that’s his own fault. Bilbo should realize that things aren’t going to get much easier for him any time soon if he can’t handle being antagonized a little by an obstinate king. 

“How do you know my name?” The bowman demands. It is a very fair question, and one Bilbo cannot answer. 

Thorin shoots Bilbo a shrewd look, but says nothing. Clearly he would also like to know how Bilbo knows the Bowman’s name. Drat it all! Apparently, being injured is making Bilbo careless. Maybe Thorin has a point, and Óin should see to him. 

But then, Bilbo can’t very well say that he’s done all of this before, can he? He has to think on his feet. Thankfully, Hobbit feet are very sturdy indeed, and Bilbo is a good talker in a pinch. “Is Bard your name?” He puts on his best confused expression. He’s had a lot of practice with confusion, after carrying out most of his adventure two times over. “In my homeland, it is a common mode of address. A polite way to greet a stranger, nothing more.”

“And where is this homeland of yours?” Bilbo can’t tell if Bard is buying what he’s selling. The Man is truly unreadable. 

“Do not tell him,” Thorin urges quietly.

Bilbo ignores this advice. As a general rule, one should never take direction from Thorin while dealing with people. “The Shire, in the far West. A very lovely place, if I do say so myself.” 

“And what brings you to Lake-town, then, Halfling, with such an odd company?” 

It never occurred to Bilbo before that Bard was familiar with Hobbits. There was simply too much going on, and he was distracted with worry for the company and the quest. If he remembers correctly, he was also concerned about poor Gandalf. He had believed (perhaps erroneously) that the Wizard was in some serious danger and might be killed without his friends even knowing where to look for him.

“We are simple merchants from the Blue Mountains, journeying to see our kin in the Iron Hills,” Balin cuts in before Bilbo can try to come up with another clever answer, which shows Bilbo what his friend thinks of the completely falsified cultural heritage he’s just manufactured for the Shire. 

“And the Halfling?” Bard seems more suspicious this time than he did before. Probably because Bilbo greeted him by name. He watches with narrowed eyes as Thorin steps in front of Bilbo, as though he seriously believes that Bard poses some threat. This will not make things easier when battle comes to the slopes of Erebor, but Bilbo supposes he’ll have to cross that bridge when he gets to it. If he gets to it. “Ah, I see. You are their servant, then.” It’s refreshing that he addresses this false accusation to Bilbo directly. 

Before the Hobbit can protest, which he means to do quite vehemently, Thorin cuts him off. “Yes.” 

Bilbo is sure that his eyes give him away completely. He’s about to start sputtering, but Dori puts a hand on his shoulder. “You’d best go along with it, Master Baggins. Thorin seems to have a plan.” 

He’s probably wrong, of course, and if he’s right, Bilbo fears a little for their lives, but he understands the sentiment. He can’t very well contradict Thorin and expose him as a liar, can he? But he is not pleased by this development. He will have words with Thorin later. But perhaps this is a good thing. The more irritated Bilbo becomes, the less his hip pains him, or, at least, the less aware he becomes of the pain. Perhaps he should stick with Thorin, after all. 

“Well,” Kíli whispers to his brother, in a voice that is thankfully too quiet for the bowman to hear, “You may become King sooner than expected when Bilbo murders our uncle.” 

Fíli snorts. “My first act would be to grant him pardon.” 

“We need food, supplies, weapons,” Thorin ignores his nephews entirely. “Can you help us?” 

“I know where these barrels came from,” Bard muses. 

“What of it?” Thorin is doing an excellent job of hiding whatever emotional turmoil lurks beneath the surface. 

“I don’t know what business you had with the Elves, but I don’t think it ended well. No one enters Lake-town but by leave of the Master. All his wealth comes from trade with the Woodland Realm. He would see you in irons before risking the wrath of King Thranduil.” All of this, of course, is entirely expected, at least as far as Bilbo is concerned. 

Thankfully, Balin takes over from here. There is some more discussion, but Bilbo pays it little mind, affronted as he is by Thorin’s recent words. Also, his pain, while bearable for the time being, is no small matter. Balin offers a few smooth words and more money. The bowman seems persuaded by this, if only because he has three children to feed, and they are allowed onto the boat. Bilbo makes a big show of sitting as far away from Thorin as he can get.

“Trouble in paradise, eh?” Bofur asks, which doesn’t help Bilbo’s dark mood in the slightest. Couldn’t he join the others in fussing about money or staring out at the Lonely Mountain on the horizon? No, he can’t. And he’s not going to fret about Bilbo’s injury, either. No doubt, Bofur can tell that Bilbo is in pain, and he’s trying to distract him from it with his impertinent question. 

“Not a word from you,” the Hobbit warns. The last thing that he wants is to tip Bard off to the fact that Thorin is, apparently, a liar. But he will admit that this conversation, too, is a welcome distraction from the nagging pain. 

“Oh, no, of course not.” But obviously, Bofur can tell what’s going on. He might not know the specific, time-travel related details, but he seems well aware of the growing tension between Bilbo and Thorin. It would be hard not to be aware of it, Bilbo supposes, but there’s nothing to be done about it now. They’ll have to sort out this whole servant business, anyway, before they touch on any of that other stuff. “You spent the whole three weeks in his cell, did you?”

“Not a word,” Bilbo protests with a fond eye-roll. Thankfully, Bard is too distracted dealing with the boat and making a plan for how to hide them all to eavesdrop on this very telling conversation. 

“It’s quite the high honor, you know, being a servant to the king.” 

Bilbo smacks Bofur in the arm, eliciting laughter. “I said not a word!” 

Bofur holds his hands up in surrender, though Bilbo didn’t hit him very hard. The whole roughhousing business really doesn’t sit to too well with Bilbo, even after all these years. It is simply not the done thing among Hobbits. “And we’ll speak no more of it.” This seems too easy. “Until we get to Erebor.” 

Bilbo sighs. “I’m not talking about it then, either. This is between me and Thorin.” And what an admission that is! But it is the most obvious thing in the world, truly. And Bilbo has spent weeks now planning to speak to Thorin about their feelings in Lake-town. Now he can throw this other business into the mix. 

Bofur starts to say something else, but one glance from the king shuts him right up. So Thorin was eavesdropping again? Good. Bilbo hopes he was. He should know what to expect the moment they’re alone. 

Until then, though, Bilbo elects to be as contrary as possible. Bard packs them into the barrels again, much to everyone’s dismay. Even Bilbo had forgotten about that, after the whole servant fiasco, and, of course, the feeling of a thousand rusty knives ripping into his hip. The bowman steps away to purchase the fish he’s about to have dumped on them. Perhaps the reason why Bilbo forgot that detail was because the moment was somewhat traumatic for him the first time around, though it is nothing compared to the quarter-hour that they’ll have to spend navigating the interior of a privy. That can’t be a wise move for somebody with an open wound. But then, Bilbo has already done what he can to dress his injury. 

Regardless, once again, Bilbo is the only one in any position to see what’s going on as Bard procures the fish. “What do you see?” Thorin asks from a neighboring barrel. 

“I see nothing, My King,” Bilbo replies in his best imitation of a servile tone. 

Someone in another nearby barrel snorts. Bombur, it sounds like. “You are being immature,” Thorin growls. Perhaps Bilbo is imagining the sheer intensity of this edict. After all, he and Thorin tease one another often. Their dynamic involves a great deal of back-and-forth. Thorin can’t be surprised that Bilbo would play the situation this way, arrow wound or no arrow wound. 

“I hope that you would forgive your faithful servant such impertinence, My King,” Bilbo says, smiling to himself. 

“Should I have introduced you as my burglar instead?” He is definitely not imagining the slight emphasis on the my in that question. Bilbo’s heart gives a little spike. Not helping, he tells himself resolutely. He should not find this attractive. And, yet, if he did not, then he and Thorin would likely not be in their present situation. “And given us all away?”

“How you choose to introduce your humble servant is entirely at your discretion, My King.” Bilbo manages to keep from laughing when the King Under the Mountain has a barrel full of stinking fish dumped onto his head. It does help that Bilbo is in precisely the same position. At least the fish isn’t salted. That would’ve worsened the pain in his hip, surely, if such a thing is even possible. 

After that, of course, there isn’t much time for conversation. Everyone, Bard included, falls silent as they approach Lake-town. It is much less grand than Bilbo remembers, and he is stricken with a series of other relevant recollections instead. Many of the townspeople that he passes in the market are going to die when Smaug comes in and rains down fire upon them. 

Bilbo may be quite annoyed with Thorin, and he might be in quite a bit of pain, but that’s no excuse to ignore the suffering of the Men of the Lake. There must be something to be done, some extra step that he can take to lessen the damage. Bilbo will not be able to prevent the dragon from escaping altogether. He can refrain from calling himself Barrel Rider, but Smaug is not so stupid as Thorin seems to believe. Probably, the wyrm will figure out for himself that Bilbo has come to the mountain through Lake-town. After all, there are only so many ways to go. And even if Bilbo did not know the Men of the Lake personally, surely Smaug would seek to cause as much harm as possible. 

Also, the fact stands that Bard is the only person in Middle Earth who has a decent shot at killing the dragon. He has a black arrow, and a bow, and good aim. Perhaps if Bilbo could warn him in advance and tell him about the imperfection in the dragon’s armor, Bard could simply wait at the top of the tower and shoot the dragon before any serious harm is done. That’s a long shot, of course, but what choice does Bilbo have? 

 

Thankfully, he’s got time to think it through as the company undergoes the long process of getting into Lake-town. First, they sit through the whole rigamarole with the customs officials and guards, who seem intent on dumping the ‘unauthorized fish’ back into the lake until Bard talks them out of it. Then, they are led through the town. Bard orders them to keep their heads down and keep moving, but considering they are surrounded by Big Folk, it’s difficult to avoid being conspicuous. A chase ensues, of course, and Bilbo staggers along as best he can, aggravating his wound as he does so. There’s a bit of fighting, just the same as last time, and then Bard somehow manages to talk them out of another jam. Those diplomatic skills will serve him very well in future. 

Sneaking through the privy, of course, is less than ideal. Many of the company grumble about this particular facet of Bard’s plan for concealing them, and Dwalin even threatens young Bain as he emerges, but the fact stands that all of them are living and in one piece. Bilbo never liked Lake-town, and his second experience with it is not proving any more pleasant than the first. 

Bilbo can only hope that his makeshift bandage prevents him from acquiring some sort of infection from the privy. Not that it matters much, anyway. Either he will find an Elven healer, his Hobbit strength will save him, or an infection will be the least of his troubles.

“Da, why are there Dwarves climbing out of our toilet?” Sigrid, Bard’s eldest daughter, inquires. 

“Will they bring us luck?” His youngest asks. 

“Absolutely not,” Bilbo disabuses young Tilda of that particular notion straight away. There’s no reason for her to go around thinking that proximity to this particular company will bring anything but trouble. 

“The opposite, in fact,” Fíli offers the little girl a conspiratorial wink, betraying no sign of the present danger or any animosity he might bear toward her father. “We bring mischief aplenty.” 

“Hobbits are lucky, though,” Kíli declares, “I think Master Baggins cancels the rest of us out.”

“No, no I do not,” Bilbo protests. 

Bard distributes blankets and what clothing he can offer, which, admittedly, is not very much. The company is as gracious about it as anybody could expect them to be. Just as he did on the first adventure, Bilbo finds Thorin by the window, marveling at the Dwarfish windlance at the top of the city’s watchtower. The last time, Bilbo initiated a conversation. This time, all he does is put his hand on the king’s back. There’s no point in forcing Thorin and Balin to drudge up their horrible memories of the day the dragon came. 

Thorin closes his eyes, leaning his forehead against the cool, smudged glass of the window. He does not say anything, and Bilbo returns his silence. It is as though the great warrior king is gathering strength and courage from the gentle touch of a wounded Hobbit. Then, he steels himself, visibly. Bilbo watches as his king’s shoulders rise and stiffen, as Thorin replaces the mask that he must wear as the leader of his people. “You took our money,” he reminds Bard, skipping the conversation about Girion’s arrow entirely, “Where are the weapons?” 

 

The weapons are out in the lake, apparently, hidden beneath a boat in a fishing net. Bilbo watches as Bard collects them, listens patiently as the bowman describes each implement, and rolls his eyes as the company grumbles about the sorry state of things. As far as Bilbo is concerned, everything Bard has offered them looks perfectly deadly. 

“We paid you for weapons,” Glóin complains. “Iron forged swords and axes!” 

“It’s a joke,” Bofur protests. They all begin to throw their weapons back down on the table. 

“Please,” Bilbo shakes his head. “I’m sorry, but you’re all being very rude! We are guests in Bard’s home, in case any of you had forgotten.” He cuts his eyes to Glóin in particular. 

“That’s true,” Dori concedes. He, at least, has the decency to look abashed, though his grumbling was barely audible to begin with. The lack of a dent in the table also demonstrates that he was exceptionally gentle when he set down his weapon. With his prodigious strength, Dori could easily destroy any piece of Mannish furniture with such a hammer. 

“And,” Bilbo continues, “What’s more, nobody ever promised us fancy-forged weapons. We paid for a means of defending ourselves, in a town where the people are willing to help a band of strange travelers escape the guards of their own Town Master. Clearly, all is not well here, and Bard has given us what he can. Not even Orcrist would be any use against the dragon, by the way, so it doesn’t matter what sort of weapons we bring with us.” 

Balin opens his mouth, presumably in an attempt to join Bilbo in making Thorin see reason. Though, Bilbo already knows that’s a doomed venture. He can practically see the inner workings of the king’s mind, and knows in that moment that nothing will deter His Majesty from rushing forward with a half-baked plan. But before Balin can try, someone else beats him to it. 

“This handles well,” Fíli informs Bard, brandishing his new hammer. “Even if you did steal it from a smithy.” This seems to be a diplomatic act, judging by the way the rest of the company regards the implements the bowman has distributed.

“Easy for you to say,” Glóin complains, “You still have knives.”

“Only four,” Fíli chirps. 

“How many did you have to begin with?” Tilda seems particularly interested in this information. 

“Hold on a moment, I’ll have to do the math,” Fíli tells her. He’s probably exaggerating, but the look in his eyes shows that there’s a little bit of addition and subtraction involved to get to the answer. “Thirty three.” 

“Did you count the three that I stole at Beorn’s?” Kíli asks with a grin. So they weren’t making up the knife-stealing story, after all. 

“Of course I did,” Fíli reports. “Since I got them back within the hour. I forgot you ever took them.”

“Where do you put them all?” Tilda ask.

“That should be all for now,” Bard cuts in. Bilbo can’t really blame him. He wouldn’t have wanted Frodo learning about where to conceal dozens of knives on one’s person, either. “My children have no need to know such things.”

“Why should we not be armed?” Sigrid, places her hands on her hips. “There is much we could do to help you, Da, if only—“

“There is nothing for you to help me with,” Bard assures her smoothly. “And if there were, I think you will find that there is not a father in Lake-town who would allow any of his children to put themselves in so much danger.” 

Unfortunately, young Bain keeps a keen eye on Fíli, probably tracking any odd lumps in the prince’s clothing that could indicate hidden weapons. It’s clear that even the children understand that there is something seriously wrong in Lake-town. The Town Master is greedy, and in his avarice, he has allowed his people to starve. It will not be long before civil unrest breaks out, dragon or no dragon. 

“You might share a few of those daggers, lad,” Óin suggests. 

“You have a perfectly good fishing rod!” Fíli protests, though his laughter gives him away. He wasn’t this jovial in Lake-town the first time around, but then, he wouldn’t be, not when his brother was wounded. 

The implement in Óin’s hands has been sharpened like a spear, yes, and barbs have been added in place of the loops to hold the line, but it really is still just a fishing rod. “We’ve all made due with less,” Balin points out. “Why not leave now?” 

“You’re not going anywhere,” Bard declares. He proceeds to tell them all about the spies watching the house and urges them to wait until nightfall to take their leave.

This suits Bilbo just fine. He was already planning on passing some time here in Lake-town, after all, and he and Thorin still have that conversation to have. So he lets the company grumble and joins his ornery king by the window. 

“I am sorry,” Thorin says quietly. 

“Oh?” Bilbo feigns innocence. “What are you sorry for?” 

“Do you not know already?” 

Bilbo supposes that this is more than he ever would’ve gotten the first time they were in Lake-town. “You could’ve just told him I was your friend. You know, as that’d be the truth?”

Thorin sighs. “That would have raised questions.” 

“But it doesn’t raise any questions at all that you might travel with an antagonistic Halfling servant?” Bilbo rolls his eyes. He does realize being that he’s being a bit unfair. But better to be a little snappish than to focus on his impending peril. If he isn’t healed in time, will he be allowed to continue to the Lonely Mountain with the rest of the company, or be left behind, as Kíli was before? And if that’s the case, who will stay with Bilbo? 

Thorin cannot. He may wish with all his heart to remain by Bilbo’s side, though perhaps it is a little vain of Bilbo to tell himself as much, but that will never be possible. Thorin must be the one to reclaim Erebor. Óin would linger, for certain, but who else? Bilbo is closer now with all the company than ever he was on the first adventure, but how could any of them be asked to stay in Lake-town to tend to a dying Hobbit rather than reclaim their home? 

“I was not thinking. He was going to shoot you.”

“He wasn’t going to shoot any of us.” 

“You cannot be sure of that,” Thorin protests. Bilbo can be sure of it, actually, but of course, Thorin doesn’t know that. “He suspected you already. How did you learn his name?” 

Bilbo bites his lip. This is not a conversation he’s prepared to have at this juncture. Before long, Thorin will start making other connections: Bilbo’s odd behavior in Mirkwood, his assertions that they’d done all this before. His lack of fear at the beginning. His intimate understanding of every member of the company and their interpersonal relationships. His utter confusion about who is king of what kingdom or master of what city and his unfortunate propensity to name the son or grandson of the current ruler. He doubts that Thorin will arrive at the very specific truth, but he may get somewhere in its general vicinity, which will bring up subjects that Bilbo isn’t prepared to broach. 

“I’m an Expert Burglar, aren’t I? I know things,” Bilbo says weakly. 

“Too much, some might say.” 

“Or too little, as you’ve been saying this whole time,” Bilbo points out, “Anyway, didn’t you want to look at my wound?” 

“Not here.” There is a certain heaviness to these words, as though Bilbo is expected to take some secondary meaning from them. Perhaps Thorin does not wish for Bilbo to be so vulnerable in front of Bard. Or perhaps he has actually been swayed by Bilbo’s entirely false assertions that the arrow wound does not hurt one bit and the binding Bilbo applied on the boat is all the first aid that he is going to need. 

This will pose a problem shortly, Bilbo knows, but there are so many other things to accomplish! And really, if he were dying, wouldn’t he know it? Hobbits are hardy folk. Perhaps all Bilbo needs to do is get his hands on some kingsfoil, bring it to Óin, and explain the situation. Then he’ll be right as rain. No need to worry Thorin. 

“Ah, I see. It would not be appropriate to behave so familiarly with your servant. Would you like me to care for your armor now, my King? We’d best keep up appearances.” Bilbo must tease Thorin now. He must lift the king’s spirits by flirting with him. Gone, now, are his plans for giving voice to his true feelings. That would be too heavy. Too much.

“I no longer have any armor,” Thorin complains, “It was stolen from me by Elves, and my Burglar failed to reclaim it.” 

“If only you’d had a faithful servant at that time, instead of a Burglar, my liege. I’d have rushed in and risked my life to have the honor of retrieving your gauntlets for you.” 

Thorin snorts. “I do not mind this,” he waves his hand to encapsulate Bilbo’s present behavior, “As much as you seem to think I do.”

Bilbo tries to keep himself from blushing or taking any nervous steps away from Thorin. After all, that would clearly be the intended reaction. “Oh.” He manages to reply. “Thank you for letting me know. I’ll knock it off right away, then. Best not to give you the satisfaction.”

Thorin sobers then, all of a sudden. “How’s your leg?” He asks softly. Bilbo should have known he couldn’t keep Thorin away from this subject for long. 

“Fine, thank you,” Bilbo tells him. 

It’s not technically a lie. Or at least, it won’t be a lie, once everything is set right. Tauriel and Legolas will be along shortly, will they not? Tauriel will see to Bilbo’s injury and cure him of the poison. And then he will truly be fine. 

Well, that’s assuming that they show up in the first place. There is always the possibility that Tauriel came to help Kíli because she cared for him personally, and that she might not extend the same courtesy to an unfamiliar Hobbit, especially not at such great cost to herself. There’s also the chance that they were only tracking the orc pack and happened to stumble into Lake-town just in time, and that Bilbo’s changed actions may have altered the course of events in this sphere as well. But he cannot afford to think about that now. 

 

The next natural step, of course, is a journey to the city’s armory for better weapons than what Bard can provide. Bilbo finds this quite silly, in the scheme of things. He knows he won’t make any headway trying to get through to Thorin (he can barely get the king to concede that blind self-sacrifice is not always the best course of action, and it surely doesn’t help that Bilbo himself has begun to rely increasingly upon the same method), but he’s grateful for Bofur’s presence behind him as they file into the dark building.

“I don’t think a professionally-forged spear will be any more use against a dragon than that sharpened fishing rod,” Bilbo grumbles to his friend. “Why are we risking our lives?”

“I don’t think Thorin likes the idea of you going in to face the beast unarmed,” Bofur, of course, takes the opportunity to tease Bilbo yet again. It’s very annoying. 

“I have a sword,” Bilbo points out, “And, anyway, he can’t expect me to just walk up and stab the dragon on my own. Even if I could get close enough to do it, it wouldn’t do much damage. The only effective weapon against a dragon is a black arrow. You all know as much, don’t you?”

“Oh, sure, but our people like to be armed,” Bofur reasons, “And, anyway, it’s a laugh, isn’t it, sneaking around?”

“You, my friend, find joy in the most unworthy places,” Bilbo protests, but he can’t help being fond. 

“What are we talking about?” Kíli asks, turning around to face them. 

“How utterly stupid this entire enterprise is becoming.” Bilbo is more than happy to fill the lad in, and very pleased to see him scurrying around Lake-town. Thus far, his greatest achievement has been sparing Kíli the pain of being shot with an orc arrow. Of course, it will change his relationship with Tauriel, but Bilbo supposes that’s a small price to pay if the lad does not spend the next few days on death’s doorstep. And who knows? Perhaps having the entire company together at the mountain will change things for the better. It has beenseveral hours, and Bilbo still does not feel as though he’s going to die.

Last time, of course, Kíli’s injury caused him to falter and sent his armful of weapons tumbling down the stairs. But this time, they are spared that particular calamity. The lad carries his burden perfectly well, earning him more than a few pats and slaps on the back when he reaches the bottom of the stairs. Fíli, accustomed to carrying far too many weapons, manages even more than his brother did. 

“Do you seriously expect your nephews to march to the Lonely Mountain weighed down with all that nonsense?” Bilbo hisses in Thorin’s general direction. 

“We will distribute the weapons once we reach the other shore,” Thorin shares. Bilbo cannot see the king’s eyes rolling, but he can imagine the sight well enough. 

“But why do we need so much? This, on top of what Bard gave us? Erebor has an entire armory.”

“We might meet something on the way to Erebor. Have you forgotten about the orc pack?” 

Bilbo is about to point out that, no matter how many weapons they might carry, there are still only fourteen of them to use those weapons, when he is accosted by a sudden stabbing pain. Ah. That’d be the poison, then. This time, it is not the noise of swords and spears clattering down the stairs that alerts the Master’s guards to their presence, but the sound of a Hobbit taking the same tumble, cursing all the way. Thorin’s shocked roar and rushing footsteps probably don’t help matters very much. 

Ori is the first to recover from the stupor that has fallen over the company. “Bilbo!” He exclaims, “Are you okay?” 

“Fine,” the Hobbit murmurs from the ground. He won’t be running anywhere any time soon, and his leg feels poised to fall off, but at least he is still living. 

 

Of course, they’re all caught, with swords to their throats and all the other trappings. Bilbo is scooped up off the ground and marched forward, and he makes a fair job of it, too, all things considered. The pain increases steadily with every step he takes, but Bilbo does not fall again, and he does not make a scene. All will be well, he assures himself.

“What is the meaning of this?” The Town Master demands when the company is brought before him. Lake-town is very cold at night, apparently. Far colder than Bilbo remembers from the first time around. 

“We caught ‘em stealing weapons, sire,” his sniveling servant replies. Bilbo truly does not understand how the ruling class can stomach being surrounded by such people. He resolves to make certain that Thorin’s court in Erebor includes plenty of advisors that will check the king’s whims without any hope to take advantage of his power. They may be difficult to find, but Bilbo would do anything to avoid being trapped in a larger-scale Lake-town for the remainder of his days. He shakes himself. Bilbo does not have the time right now to wallow in fantasies of his future as the consort of Erebor.

The Town Master and his servant then make a few unkind accusations about the company, and Dwalin, naturally, takes issue with this and introduces the town to Thorin. Bilbo has to fight against rolling his eyes. He’s heard it all before, naturally. He can’t bring himself to pay attention to Thorin’s speech, either, well-spoken as the king may be. The first time, Bilbo was enraptured, but then, the first time, Bilbo had no reason to disbelieve Thorin’s words. Now, he knows better, and it eats away at him.

If he vouches for Thorin when called upon, Bilbo will be cosigning a promise that he knows will not be kept. Thorin may genuinely believe that he’ll give gold to the people of Esgaroth. In fact, Bilbo knows that Thorin believes this. He does not know what the treasure in the mountain will do to his mind. He underestimates the power of the Arkenstone. But Bilbo understands all of these things with perfect clarity. How can he tell the people that Thorin will keep his word when the opposite is true? 

“Death!” Bard roars, so loudly that even Bilbo is distracted from his thoughts. “That is what you will bring upon us! Dragonfire and ruin. If you waken that beast, it will destroy us all.”

He’s right, of course. Bilbo looks around at the faces of the people of the Lake. Some of them are very young, and some of them are very old. Some of them look hopeful, while others seem to have their doubts. A beautiful young woman with deep skin, twinkling eyes, and a thoughtful expression that reminds Bilbo very much of his cousin Primula is looking at Nori, of all people, with hopeless admiration. The typical business, Bilbo supposes. If a group of handsome strangers had sauntered into the Shire when he was barely grown, he, too, probably would have developed a little crush on one of them on sight. But for all he knows, this young woman will be dead in a few days time, burned beyond recognition in the wrath of the dragon. And it will be all Bilbo’s fault. 

“You can listen to this naysayer, but I promise you this.” Thorin really is an amazing speaker. Bilbo could listen to him talk all night.  “If we succeed, all will share in the wealth of the mountain. You will have enough gold to rebuild Esgaroth ten times over.” If only that were true. 

“Why should we take you at your word, eh?” The Master’s servant demands. “We know nothing about you. Who here can vouch for your character?” 

This is the moment that Bilbo has been dreading. For a split second, he considers saying nothing. What is the worst that can happen if he does? The company will be turned out of Lake-town, and they will march, weaponless, and without provisions, to Erebor. 

If they don’t starve to death on the way, they will wake the dragon just as they did the last time, and he will come here, and he will kill these people regardless of the welcome that they gave to Thorin’s company. And if they do starve to death on the way, the ring will just be laying there, in Bilbo’s pocket. Orcs will find their corpses, certainly. They are actively being hunted. Or the Wood Elves will come looking for their lost prisoners and discover a dead Hobbit bearing a Ring of Power. Not that Bilbo will live long enough to starve to death with the rest of the company. Regardless, somebody new will come into possession of the ring, and who knows what horrible things it could make them do? 

Bilbo cannot allow that to happen. He’ll do his best to warn Bard about the dragon and to mitigate the damage to Esgaroth, but at the end of the day, his allegiance is to Thorin and Company. Even though he knows that Thorin will not keep his word. Though, Bilbo doesn’t know that, actually. He only knows that Thorin did not keep his word the last time, but things were very different then. Perhaps the Dragon Sickness will not be so bad this time, or perhaps the company will have the courage to take charge of the situation and override Thorin’s poor governance. Or perhaps Bilbo’s warning will be effective and Lake-town will be evacuated early. He tells himself quite fervently that he is not necessarily dooming all these people, but really, he can’t be sure of that. Their blood will be on his hands. 

“Me,” he says anyway, raising his hand. “I’ll vouch for him.” Well, now Bilbo has got everybody’s attention. Last time, he spoke of Thorin’s loyalty and honor, but those words would feel hollow now, considering all that Bilbo knows about the future. Yes, Thorin Oakenshield is a loyal and honorable king, completely worthy of the title he holds and the responsibility it carries with it. But a few days in the mountain will surely change all that. 

“I… I have known Thorin Oakenshield many months, and he has  proven that he will go to great lengths for the safety and wellbeing of others. He is a great king, wise and just. You will have your gold.” And even if everything goes haywire, which Bilbo suspects it might, he isn’t technically lying. Just skirting the truth, because apparently, Thorin’s ability to march toward his doom is more important to Bilbo than the lives of the Men of the Lake. Every single death among them will be Bilbo’s fault. 

“All of you! Listen to me! You must listen! Have you forgotten what happened to Dale?” Bard attempts to reverse the damage that Bilbo has done. The words are familiar, but they were no use before, and they will be no use now. The promise of gold is too much for these starving people to deny. “Have you forgotten those who died in the firestorm? And for what purpose? The blind ambition of a mountain king, so riven by greed he could not see beyond his own desire!” Bilbo takes advantage of the momentary distraction caused by Bard’s outburst to clutch at his wounded hip and curse under his breath. It seems to pain him more with every passing moment, though being a Hobbit, Bilbo can put up with an awful lot. 

The town master cuts in then and speaks about the failure of Bard’s ancestor, as though it were Bard’s own fault. Naturally, his slimy second backs him up. Thorin looks sympathetic. If anyone here is familiar with the burden carried by the descendants of reckless kings, it is him. But in the end, he says nothing. Why does he not say something? Why does he not leap to Bard’s defense? Bilbo is about to, but then the bowman addresses Thorin directly.

“You have no right,” he spits, “No right to enter that mountain.” Bilbo could tell him that that’s the wrong way to go about things with Thorin Oakenshield.

“I have the only right,” Thorin replies, smooth and a little smug.

Bilbo should not feel that sentence in any part of his anatomy other than his rapidly sinking stomach. The tingling in his extremities must be another symptom of the poison running through his veins. Thorin will die, he reminds himself. Because of this, because of you, because you vouched for him here, because you signed on to a promise that you know he’s not going to keep, war will come to Erebor. It will be your fault when he and the lads are killed, even more than it was last time.  

“I speak to the master of the Men of the lake,” Thorin continues. “Will you see the prophecy fulfilled? Will you share in the great wealth of our people?” He looks so noble, so handsome and brave. Bilbo loves him, whether he can keep this promise or not. Whether he goes mad in that mountain or not. Whether he is slain upon Ravenhill or not. “What say you?” 

“I say unto you… Welcome! Welcome!” The town master shouts, after a moment of brief political calculation. Bilbo knows that they should not trust this person. And yet, they are all tired and hungry, and Bard could not offer them much. He barely has the means to feed his own family, let alone fourteen hungry travelers. “And thrice welcome, King under the Mountain!” 

 

The feast to which the company is treated isn’t half bad. There’s plenty to go around, at least, which is a relief to Bilbo, after weeks of splitting meals with Thorin. To the Wood Elves’ credit, they thought they were feeding only one person, and had they been (assuming that person was not a Hobbit), the sustenance provided would have been sufficient. 

“Go slowly,” Thorin counsels during dinner, “Or you’ll make yourself sick.” 

He seems to be in much better spirits after being welcomed by the Master of the town. Probably because he does not know what kind of person the Master is. Bilbo knows it’s unfair to hold the Man responsible for something that he did on a completely different timeline, but he can’t help but clench his fists a little at the sight of the person who refused Kíli medical treatment while he was dying. 

“I know how to eat, thank you very much.” 

Bilbo pushes all thoughts of death from his mind. This is no mean feat, because most of his thoughts at the moment are death-related. Truthfully, he is barely holding himself together, but hold himself together he must. He cannot be a cause for alarm. During their brief interlude in Lake-town, he must recover his strength, help Thorin to do the same, procure more food than they took with them the last time, and warn Bard about the dragon. He doesn’t have time to wallow in self-pity. And there is the matter of his injury, which makes itself apparent every time he moves. Sometimes it’s even obvious when he is not moving. 

Bilbo’s mother always used to say that good meal could fix anything. He sincerely hopes that this remedy applies also to poisoned arrows delivered by orcs, but of course, why would it? 

“Clearly.” 

Bilbo takes the liberty of elbowing the king in the gut. “Watch your mouth,” he orders playfully. Not something he’d have done the first time around, by any means, but three weeks locked in a tiny cell together with someone who is kind enough not to say a word about your constant nightmares can really do wonders in the intimacy department. Also, the pain is becoming too great for Bilbo to focus on keeping it under wraps and minding his manners at the very same time.

“You are still giving me orders, little Hobbit?” Thorin asks quietly. 

Bilbo has plenty of thoughts and feelings about this, which is very nice. If he is thinking about the quality of Thorin’s voice, the king’s relative proximity to Bilbo, and the fact that they are in public right now, then he’s not thinking about his injury. Or, for that matter, about the fact that he could have saved everyone in Lake-town and chose not to, because he has the hubris to believe that he can change the future on his own. 

“You are pestering me in the middle of a meal,” Bilbo counters, “Not a wise move, my King.” 

“What are we interrupting?” Kíli asks cheerfully as he flops into the chair across from Bilbo. Fíli sits beside him, observing the aftermath of whatever was just taking place. Oh, this is lovely. Of course the lads have to be their witnesses. 

“I am having a conversation with my burglar,” Thorin replies coolly. He’s still none too pleased about Kíli’s flirtation with Tauriel. From the way he talks about it, one would think that his nephew had taken up with an entire troupe of trolls rather than one particularly well-mannered and noble Elf. 

“Our burglar, you mean,” Fíli quips. Apparently he can’t help himself. 

“I meant what I said.” Thorin lets these words hang in the air. 

Bilbo opens his mouth to speak, but then decides that he has no idea what he would say. Yes, three weeks in a tiny cell together can certainly change a lot. 

“Anyway.” Thankfully, Kíli seems to have a lot of practice dealing with his uncle and does not seem at all put off by his boldness. “Have you tried the ale yet? It’s delicious.” 

“It’s not wise to drink too much when recovering from… a journey,” Thorin counsels, complete with a long pause as he tries to think of a good word for the escapade with the barrels. He’s just full of advice today, isn’t he? 

“Tell that to Bofur,” says Fíli. He jerks his head in the direction of their friend, who bears an oversized tankard of ale in each hand. 

Bilbo stares up at the ceiling. Here he was, hoping to enjoy a nice evening with Thorin before setting off for Erebor, and instead, he’s got to manage Bofur’s alcohol consumption. “I hope this doesn’t become a habit. Maybe I should put a stop to it before it gets out of hand.” He really does not want to see a hung-over Bofur left behind in Lake-town for a second time. 

The door to the Master’s hall bangs open before Bilbo and Thorin can even have the impending argument about whether Bilbo, personally, must be the one to see to Bofur. Everyone falls silent. They put down their tankards and turn to face the intruder, brows furrowed as they try to piece together the scene before them. An Elven lady, looking as bedraggled as it is possible for an Elf to look. Her hair is tousled, her clothes rumpled, though of course, her skin is still without blemish, and despite her obviously frantic state, her movements are still graceful as she barges into the hall. 

“Say, Kíli,” Bofur makes it immediately apparent that he’s had too much to drink, just as the lads warned, “Isn’t that your Elf?”

What a thing to say in a silent hall! Even Kíli knows better than to respond to a question like that at a time like this. Ori, who happens to be the closest, shushes Bofur and snatches away one of his friend’s tankards. Tauriel, for her part, seems to have other matters on her mind. She strides through the hall with single-minded purpose. 

“What is the meaning of this?” The Town Master’s sniveling second demands. “You have not been invited to this feast!” 

Bilbo has never really made much sense of the Man’s official position in the town, but his title matters very little. He’s antagonistic, self-interested, and cruel. Not to be trusted, obviously. Anything beyond that is mere window dressing. The Master of Lake-town, however, is another beast altogether. 

“Now, hold on a moment.” He extends an arm in front of his servant, as though to bar him from accosting Tauriel. Bilbo gets the feeling that wouldn’t go very well for the Man, if he was truly foolish enough to try it. “Let the lady speak, Alfrid.” 

Tauriel doesn’t even bother to send the Man the glare he deserves. “Good evening,” she addresses the Town Master, falling into an awkward, stiff sort of bow. That’s likely common practice in Thranduil’s court, but it’s clearly a novelty to the people of Lake-town. Still, it endears Tauriel to the Town Master, which can’t be a bad thing, whatever she’s here for. 

This definitely did not happen on Bilbo’s first adventure. Yes, Tauriel did come to Lake-town, but only after several days. The majority of the company had already departed for the Lonely Mountain by the time she arrived. What could possibly have changed? Well, that’s a silly question, Bilbo’s aching hip reminds him. This time, he took the arrow that would otherwise have struck Kíli. But why would that alter Tauriel’s motivations? Surely she’d be more worried about her beloved than about some Hobbit she’s never seen before. 

All of Bilbo’s questions answer themselves when Prince Legolas marches into the hall. He looks slightly more put-together than Tauriel does, as though he stopped to smooth his hair down before demanding audience with the Town Master. The glare he shoots Tauriel suggests that he is not at all pleased with her running ahead, but the fact that he keeps silent about it proves that he bears her no genuine ill will. Bilbo cannot help but feel a little annoyed despite himself. Where was this timely reaction last time?

“Ah, your Highness.” The Master of Lake-town inclines his head ever-so-slightly. He might appreciate bowing and scraping when he’s on the receiving end, but he’s clearly not going to make a big show of it for anybody else. “What brings you and your fair companion to Lake-town?” 

Legolas says nothing, making it abundantly obvious that Tauriel is the captain of this venture. Interesting. “We seek a wounded Halfling,” she announces. Before Bilbo can even think of making himself known, Thorin wraps a protective arm around his shoulders. Ah, yes, of course. 

“They have been tracking us,” the king hisses. 

“Hush,” Bilbo scolds him. “I would like to get this orc poison out of my leg, you know. If they’re going to help—“ 

“What is a Halfling, Lady?” The Master asks. “I have never heard of such creatures.” 

“No Elf will be touching a hair on your feet,” Thorin snaps, perhaps less quietly than he might have thought he was being. 

“I should certainly hope not.” That would be very intimate indeed. From what Bilbo has been told, Tauriel might sing over him for a little while, and the process will likely involve a few weeds plucked from the garden, but otherwise, no scandal will take place. 

“They are little folk from the West,” Legolas explains, “Like Men, only smaller. The one we seek was injured by an orc arrow as he was freeing prisoners from my father’s dungeons.”

Now it is Tauriel’s turn to glare at him. “Time is of the essence, sir.” She quickly turns her attention back to the Town Master. “If you know of this Halfling, I would have you direct me to him so that I might offer my services as a healer. We believe the arrow may have been poisoned.”

“Even one who has violated the laws of my father’s land does not deserve such a painful death,” Legolas puts in. Oh, goodness. 

Bilbo certainly doesn’t feel as though he’s on the verge of a painful death. It stings, surely, and he could happily do without it, but if he hadn’t seen Kíli’s state when they set off from Lake-town the last time, Bilbo would hardly assume that there was anything seriously amiss.Then again, Hobbits are hale folk in general, and it’s possible that Legolas is just exaggerating. Elves can be rather dramatic when they put their minds to it.

Unfortunately, they aren’t the only ones. “Fíli,” Thorin hisses to his heir, “Get Master Baggins to safety.” 

“Aye, of course, Uncle.” The prince is at Bilbo’s side immediately. 

“Bifur, go with them.” Thorin has evidently started handing out orders. And what’s worse, Bifur seems just as willing to go along with it as Fíli does!

“Oh, no.” Bilbo can see where this is going. “Thorin, the Elves are here to help me. Tauriel wants to heal me.” 

“She wouldn’t hurt him,” Kíli, too, joins the huddle. 

Thorin turns to Bilbo. “Can Óin not handle it?” 

Bilbo worries his lip. “He threw together something for the pain while we were waiting for night to fall.” This probably explains why Bilbo does not feel as though he is dying. Still, he remembers the horrible, contorted expression on Kíli’s face when the company set off from Lake-town the first time around. The lad certainly did not look long for this world. “But I fear the Elves are right. I may die if they do not see to me. The arrow must have been poisoned, to cause this much pain.”

It is as though something snaps deep within Thorin, then. “He is here,” he announces, cutting the Town Master off mid-word. “See to him, if you will. But if you harm him—“ 

Legolas, apparently keen to remind everyone present that he is, in fact, the son of Thranduil, takes the opportunity to draw Orcrist from his belt. Perhaps not the smartest move, considering Thorin already distrusts him. “You are not in any position to bargain with anyone, Dwarf,” he announces. “I have half a mind to carry you back to my father now and let you face the consequences.”

“I’d like to see you try, lad.” This from Dwalin, who has almost certainly been furnished with proper weapons by the people of Lake-town. 

“Enough of this,” Tauriel says sharply, “The Halfling will die if I do not see to him. That poison is enough to kill a Man or an Elf twice over.”

“Hobbits are far hardier than Men or Elves, Captain,” Bilbo informs her. “But I see your point.” 

Thorin is seething beside him. He mutters something in Khuzdul, a prayer, no doubt. Bilbo truly does hope that the Valar will be kind to them this day. “Please,” Tauriel says. Annoyingly, she directs this entreaty toward Thorin, as though it is up to him whether she may treat Bilbo’s injury. “For the sake of the Halfling.” 

“He is a Hobbit,” Thorin growls, “And you will not be alone with him.”

“Remind me when this became your decision?” Bilbo hisses. He may be slightly delirious, if he’s picking fights with Thorin when he’s at death’s door. But then, going back and forth with the king is a pleasant enough distraction from the perils Bilbo faces. 

Thorin shoots him a sharp glare. “You want looking after. I told you.” 

“So it was decided by royal decree, without any input from the common folk,” Bilbo shakes his head. 

“You’re hardly common,” Thorin sneers, “I have been inside your smial. It is very fine, indeed. And if you are not capable of acting to preserve your own life—“ 

“Thorin,” Balin cuts him off with a warning glance toward the Elves and Men. Really, this is quite the mess they’ve gotten themselves into. 

“Very well.” Tauriel pretends as though Bilbo’s little digression never happened. Hopefully, everyone will give him the benefit of the doubt on account of his injury. “You may watch over me, along with two of your guards. Prince Legolas, you must stay here.” 

“Tauriel,” Legolas warns, but she shakes her head at him. Bilbo has great sympathy for her, truly. Dealing with royalty is never easy. 

“We are enjoying the hospitality of the Town Master,” she points out, “And I doubt he’d be content having all of his guests crowded together far away from him. Take some wine and rest.”

“Fine.” They must be close, indeed, if Legolas is willing to take such counsel. But he adds to it in Sindarin afterwords, giving her a sharp reminder of the sort of folk she is dealing with.

A sharp pain in Bilbo’s hip reminds him that time truly is of the essence. Thankfully, things seem to happen very quickly after that. Bilbo is supported between Fíli and Thorin as Tauriel trails them into a room indicated by a servant. It’s a modest guest bedroom, not half as lovely as the Master’s feast hall. Something about this doesn’t surprise Bilbo in the slightest, but he hardly has time to worry about it as he is lowered onto the bed. 

Thorin grips his hand like a vice. “I am watching you,” he informs Tauriel, though he has his back turned to her, his eyes still on Bilbo even as he addresses the Elf. “You will not harm him.” 

“I do not plan to,” Tauriel resolves. 

“I’m fine,” Bilbo assures Thorin, patting his hand. “Honestly. It must only be a small bit of poison. I’m sure Captain Tauriel will have it out in a jiffy.” 

For some reason, this does not calm the king in the slightest. “Rest now,” Thorin orders. “You will need it.”

Bilbo means to argue. He really does. But the pain is too great, and the bed is too soft, and his lack of sleep has begun to catch up to him. Besides, he thinks, he and Thorin had something more important to talk about. What was it, again? Well, clearly, it couldn’t have been all that pressing if Bilbo has forgotten it. He sighs, shuts his eyes, and lays back against the paltry pillows, waiting to be healed.