Actions

Work Header

Five Simple Steps

Chapter 11: The Many Uses of Dragon Fire

Notes:

I'm back!! Thank you once again for reading and all the kudos and kind comments that you left while I was away. Hopefully this longer chapter is worth the wait. As always, enjoy!

Chapter Text

Thorin does not speak to the Burglar at all as the company crosses the Long Lake. He does not know what to say. He did not like that Bilbo went out of his way to speak to the bargeman any more than he liked that Bilbo went out of his way to ensure that Bofur was awake and ready for the journey. Bofur should be perfectly capable of handling his own sleep schedule, and if not, then his kin should see to it. Thorin’s Hobbit should not be responsible for the wrangling of any member of the company, nor should he have any reason to consort with Men. 

But Bilbo made it very clear in Lake-town that he did not wish to be smothered, that he found Thorin’s behavior quite overbearing, and that his sending Thorin away for an afternoon did not mean that Thorin was not wanted at all. And before the king could request clarification, the Burglar kissed him on the lips, in public, as though they were a married couple. Perhaps this is typical among Hobbits. Perhaps they offer kisses freely, and insinuate a desire for marriage at the start of each dalliance. Perhaps it did not mean as much to Bilbo as it did to Thorin.

He did not ask. There was no time, between the preparations for their departure and the chaos of embarking, and besides, there did not seem to be any point to it. Thorin knows, at least, that Bilbo cares for him, and would like to someday become the consort of Erebor. Does he need more than that, when he cannot even procure a gift for the Hobbit? Traditionally, such a conversation would follow the first gifting and precede the second. But they have been bucking tradition since their imprisonment in the Woodland Realm, sleeping side-by-side for several weeks. Sharing a kiss certainly did not help matters. 

Thorin is at war with himself as they disembark from their boats and bid farewell to the Lake-men who have ferried them across. He knows very well that he should be focused right now on his kingdom and the dragon that has stolen it. He must think of Master Baggins as an expert burglar, and he must permit the Hobbit to enter a Mountain with a sleeping dragon inside for the express purpose of removing the Arkenstone and securing Thorin’s right to rule. But he does not wish to allow Master Baggins out of his sight in any capacity, least of all a capacity that might involve a tussle with a wicked wyrm. He knows that Smaug would delight in killing Bilbo, and he does not wish to see that done. 

In his dreams, when he finds sound enough sleep for them, Thorin watches his Hobbit burn. It is a blessing that he is usually kept awake by his worry until the small hours, and woken again before sunrise by the same energy that has propelled him every morning hitherto. Thorin will rest when his kingdom is restored. He will rest, he will find a courting gift, and he will have a conversation with his Hobbit. Not that this does much to assuage his fears. 

Thorin knows that Bilbo is a stubborn little creature that will not take kindly to being refused the opportunity to do what he was hired for. They both signed the contract, and the stipulations could not be more clear.There is no going back now, and Thorin has no better plan. He’d like to follow Bilbo inside the mountain, but he knows that he cannot. Smaug would recognize his scent and Bilbo would lose the element of surprise. What was the point of bringing a Hobbit on this journey, if not that he’d be unfamiliar to the dragon? 

When the contract was drafted, of course, Thorin had not yet met the comely Hobbit. When it was signed, he refused to acknowledge his attraction to Master Baggins. By the time of their stay with Beorn, though, Thorin knew that he harbored more than simple professional admiration for the Burglar. And now, in Lake-town, everything has been confirmed, far too early, and in an inappropriate fashion. Knowing that Master Baggins cares for him has changed Thorin’s outlook significantly, even if it has not altered his larger plans. He knows precisely who to blame for this development. 

“You should not have meddled in my personal affairs,” he growls to his sister-sons when, finally, he is able to corner them away from the rest of the group. Thorin neglected to bring this matter up in Esgaroth, largely because he was too stunned by Bilbo’s sudden boldness to even consider the source of the idea planted in his Hobbit’s lovely head. “And to exchange bets over such matters was below your station as princes of Erebor.” 

“Who says we were betting?” Fíli looks affronted. 

Kíli purses his lips. “I may have implied as much to Bilbo when I was giving him advice.”

“Why?” 

Kíli shrugs. “I didn’t want to embarrass him.” 

“You don’t think he’d be less embarrassed knowing we want him to be happy than thinking we had money riding on his coupling with our uncle?” But Fíli seems to find this more amusing than horrifying. Thorin does not know whether to be more concerned for the Burglar’s fragile feelings or for what Bilbo will do to his sister-sons if he ever learns the truth. 

“It was not your place to speak with my—“ Thorin cuts himself off with a huff because he doesn’t know how to describe his relationship with Bilbo. They are not properly courting, despite Bilbo’s clear announcement of intent, because neither of them has given the other one a gift. Thorin would have done, if he’d found anything fine enough in Esgaroth, but it seems more prudent to wait until they have secured Erebor. He wishes Bilbo to have the best courting gift imaginable, and also, he would very much like to stave off the distraction of full courtship (and serious acknowledgment of the bond that has formed between himself and Master Baggins) until he has his kingdom well in hand. 

They have years ahead of them to discuss such things. The dragon, however, must be seen to now. It is straightforward. Thorin will not pretend that he did not enjoy the brief kiss he shared with Bilbo, but it would be foolish to initiate another before their work is done.

Ah, but it was such a pleasant thing. Thorin was surprised, at the time, by the force with which the Burglar accosted him, the way the kiss melted into something soft and sweet. Thorin should have stopped him, should have explained that such an act in Dwarven society was tantamount to a proposal of marriage. Then again,  Bilbo did admit aloud that he would like to serve as Thorin’s consort. Not that there is any question of the kiss springing from the Hobbit’s political aspirations alone. No, that could not be possible. Thorin could feel his Burglar’s affection, could taste it on his lips. 

“But he would not be your intended if I hadn’t interfered,” Kíli points out shamelessly. 

Thorin looks around frantically, but of course, they are too far ahead of the rest of the company for their voices to be heard with the wind at their backs. “He is not my intended now,” the king growls. 

“Why not? He’s interested.”

“I’m starting to see how you wound up courting an Elf,” Fíli observes. Much like his brother, he fails to see the seriousness of the situation. Still, at least he defends Thorin’s position. “Mutual interest isn’t the only factor. There’s timing to consider.” 

“Wouldn’t you want to secure the match before he slays a dragon and starts getting other offers?” Kíli muses. 

“I don’t think Bilbo will be the one to slay the dragon,” Fíli protests in a vain attempt to steer the conversation in a more pleasant direction. 

“Still, he means to face Smaug on his own,” Kíli points out. He does not seem to comprehend the danger in this, or else he is very confident indeed in the Burglar’s abilities. “That’ll catch some attention, especially when the mountain starts filling up again.” 

Thorin’s blood does something violent in his veins, a physical sensation he’s never experienced before. “He will not consider other offers. He’s made his intent clear enough.”

“Thanks to me,” Kíli sings. “Honestly, Uncle, this is only too simple. Master Baggins will make a fine consort, and he’ll treat you very well, and you’re obviously besotted with him. I just thought he should know the way our people love.” 

“Even if you don’t start courting now, it’s better if he knows what to expect,” Fíli agrees. “In case anything happens, you both know where you stand.” 

“I do not know anything.” Thorin is embarrassed to share as much with his sister-sons, but he’ll not have them thinking that they’ve changed his life in any meaningful way with their underhanded meddling. Why they care about the nature of his relationship with the Burglar escapes him entirely. 

“He didn’t tell you that he loves you?” Kíli sounds surprised. 

“Why would he say such a thing?” 

To feel the pull toward a One is not the same as to be in love. Obviously, Master Baggins cares for Thorin. Obviously, he wishes to be with him, once they have taken back the Mountain. There is no question of whether the Hobbit is prepared to rule Erebor by Thorin’s side. But that does not mean that Bilbo loves Thorin, only that he is willing to entertain the notion of loving him. And it certainly does not mean that he would say such a thing aloud.

“Oh.” Fíli seems to realize what is happening before Thorin does. “Oh, Mahal, no. Tell me I’m wrong?” 

“He said it,” Kíli sings. “I did tell him to talk to you. I don’t know why he didn’t. Honestly, you’re both lucky you have us to do the communication for you.” 

“He kissed you without saying anything?” Fíli asks, incredulous. Among their people, such an act would be unimaginable. Thorin supposes that it does make sense that, after hearing about what happened in the marketplace, the rest of the company might leap to some premature conclusions. 

Thorin shakes his head, fighting off the swooping sensation in his stomach. Whether Master Baggins loves him or not is immaterial. It cannot be addressed now. When the dragon is dead, Thorin will give his Hobbit a courting gift. He will say all the things that he has kept from his tongue in recent days. They will continue as they have done, not discussing it. Why do any more? It seems foolish to plan for a future that they cannot envision, not yet knowing the state of Thorin’s kingdom or the fate of the beast lurking inside. “It is still none of your business. I would have you stop meddling.”

“Until our kingdom is restored?” Kíli asks, still far too glib. Even after all he has seen, as far as Kíli is concerned, the dragon is only a monster from a story, not worth a second thought. Thorin might be endeared, were he not so troubled by the implications. 

“That seems fair,” Fíli decides. “We’ll start meddling when you’ve got your crown back, how does that sound?”

“You will not need to,” Thorin grits out, much to the delight of the lads. When Thorin has his crown back, he will make his intentions known to the Hobbit before his nephews even have time to concoct another poorly-thought-out plot. 

 

The journey to Erebor is spent in relative silence for Bilbo. Worry eats away at him from all sides. He isn’t certain that his warning to Bard will be effective in protecting the Men of the Lake. After all, the Town Master distrusts Bard, and though the bargeman does seem to have some friends, most of his fellow citizens refused to heed his initial warning. It is entirely possible that he will be detained somehow before he can kill the dragon. And what if the journey is of a different length this time, and Bard is waiting in the watchtower too early? What if he gets there too late?

Moreover, there is the small matter of Bilbo’s impending confrontation with a dragon. Yes, he’s done it before, and he was terrified then, too. Now, he knows exactly what Smaug is capable of, precisely the feeling of having a dragon attempt to slither into one’s mind and corrupt one’s thinking. He knows exactly what the Arkenstone is capable of, besides, and he knows what the treasure in the mountain is going to do to Thorin. And he knows that he will need to take advantage of Smaug’s presence and force the dragon to unknowingly destroy the ring somehow without accidentally adding the One Ring to an already massive hoard, thereby empowering the creature to do great harm.

The dragon is not the greatest threat, whispers a slimy voice in Bilbo’s mind. Thorin Oakenshield seeks to possess every treasure he sees. He could easily take your Precious from you if he wished. 

Bilbo very nearly takes the ring out of his pocket and leaves it on the cold ground of the desolation. He can see the battered skyline of a ruined city in the middle distance. When did they get so close to Dale? For how long, exactly, has Bilbo been trapped in his own thoughts? Oh, this blasted ring! Yes, Bilbo would do well to leave it here! 

But no. He knows that he wouldn’t be able to give it up so easily if the ring didn’t want to be given up. Probably, the Valar-forsaken thing would be over the moon if Bilbo simply handed it over to Thorin. He’d like to think highly of his love, of course, but Bilbo knows in his heart that Thorin would not be able to part with the ring once he had it, would not be able to see through its influence until after it was too late. After all, the Arkenstone is nothing compared to the ring. 

Bilbo, on the other hand, has parted with the ring before, when it was stronger and had a tighter hold on him. So it will be no trouble to part with it now, he assures himself. He can handle it, and he’s going to have to. If it isn’t him, then it will be Frodo, and that will be far worse. Anyway, on top of all of that, Bilbo has arrived at a significant hitch in his plan. If he destroys the ring while the dragon still lives, then he will not have the ability to turn invisible during the Battle of the Five Armies. The last time, he had a great advantage and still was not able to warn Thorin and the lads in time to save them. Now, Bilbo will be without this advantage, and he’ll have to come up with a new plan that will probably involve a lot more fighting than he had to do the last time. 

“You alright there, Bilbo?” Bombur asks from beside him. Since when is Bombur beside him? 

Perhaps it’s only Bilbo’s imagination, but the sun seems lower on the horizon than it was when last he looked. Bilbo does not recall losing so much time to the ring on his first adventure. But then, he wouldn’t, would he? He had no reason to fear the little trinket. He did not understand what it truly was. He could have lost hours of the journey and never been any the wiser. 

All of these thoughts together are perfect fuel for nightmares. On the first night, Bilbo dreams of Thorin’s death again. He wakes abruptly, then falls asleep again to watch the lads drowning in molten gold while Thorin stares on placidly, entirely corrupted by dragon sickness. On the second night, he wakes up to find the king wrapped around him, holding him close against the chilly Northern air. 

The two of them have been setting their bedrolls side by side without a word about it since they left Lake-town. It would be silly not to, now that they’ve spent the past month in each other’s arms. But Thorin seems to be just as preoccupied as Bilbo is (no great wonder, that) and therefore equally content to simply allow the situation to unfold as it will without a running commentary. Neither of them needs further clarification. Bilbo knows what he is to Thorin because Dáin told him twenty years ago, sixty years in the future, on a timeline that will hopefully never come to pass. Thorin knows what he is to Bilbo because Bilbo made it abundantly clear at the market in Lake-town. So, that’s that, then. 

If all goes well, they’ll be able to make a more formal arrangement after the battle. And if not… well. Bilbo cannot think about what will happen if all does not go well. Perhaps it wouldn’t be so bad. If Thorin does not survive the battle, if Bilbo fails another time, he might be compelled to simply pitch himself into Mount Doom and have done with it. For one dark moment, he wonders if perhaps that was Galadriel’s intent. Did she truly show him his future, or did she merely show him a series of images that she knew would have him agree to her plan? If she could see into his mind, surely she would know what losing Thorin again might do to Bilbo. And those boys! 

“You were talking in your sleep,” Thorin informs Bilbo. 

He worries at his lower lip. That’s not good. Just how often does he do this? Is there some possibility that Thorin has heard his mutterings before, the dialogue from previous nightmares, and leapt to conclusions? Bilbo is uneasy with his lack of knowledge of the things he says while in the grip of his trauma. And the ring, which certainly does not make things easier. 

It would be easy for him, the ring taunts Bilbo. He could take your precious away. Kill him now and stop him. He would not expect it. He’d let you do it. 

It is pulling out all the stops this time, doing everything in its power to regain control of Bilbo. To gain control of Bilbo, he corrects himself. Whatever influence it had on him during his first lifetime does not seem to have carried over. But its power is comparatively weak, and Bilbo’s mission is too important for him to entertain such ideas. Also, Thorin would sooner chop off his own hand than rifle through Bilbo’s pockets while he slept. After all, if he didn’t do it while he was overcome by dragon sickness, then he’s not likely to do it while he’s more or less in his right mind. 

And even the ring could not believe that Bilbo would ever deliberately harm Thorin. No. It must want Bilbo to give in, to simply hand it over to Thorin and have done with it. To believe that he is protecting himself by doing so. But he will not allow Thorin to suffer as he and Frodo have. 

“You were muttering about fire and gold,” Thorin breathes when Bilbo does not say anything. “I could not stand by and do nothing when it was clear that you were suffering.”

“How often do you do this for me?” Bilbo asks around his dry throat. He wishes there were something to do to get the ring to stop whispering to him, but he knows that is far too much to ask. He knows he should not be worrying right now about Thorin’s hands in his hair, Thorin watching him sleep, Thorin going out of his way to care for him on the eve of what the king likely believes will be a great success. 

“Your dreams trouble you.” Thorin’s non-answer is answer enough for Bilbo’s purposes. “Why is that?” 

Bilbo swallows. How is he supposed to respond to a question like that? So he gives his own non-answer: “Because I am on a quest to slay a dragon, and I am terrified that I will fail.” 

“You will not fail,” Thorin assures him. He seems to actually believe this. “The Wizard would not have sent you if you were poorly suited to the mission.”

Bilbo attempts to sit up on the bedroll, but he doesn’t get very far with Thorin’s arms encircling him. They may not be talking about it, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t happening. Bilbo would never have dared to dream about anything like this the first time around. “You trust Gandalf now?” That seems highly unlikely. 

“You heard him telling Elrond at Rivendell about how important it was to see Erebor reclaimed,” Thorin replies. The anger lurking in his tone is unmistakable and clears up Bilbo’s misapprehension immediately. “He would not put his own plan at risk by sending someone who could not complete the task.” 

“I don’t know,” Bilbo grumbles, “I don’t think he’s half as bright as people imagine he is. I mean, really. What did he think was going to happen, having us walk through Thranduil’s realm? And sending us over the Misty Mountains when he knew there were goblins there? Always leaving off, going one way or another… I don’t think he has any clue what he’s doing at all. He should be with us now.” Is this Bilbo’s own justified resentment at the Wizard’s erratic behavior, or is it the ring which causes him to feel this way?

“He should not,” Thorin muses, adjusting his grip on Bilbo so that those big hands spread out across the Hobbit’s ribcage. “The first sight of Erebor should be for Durin’s folk and those we claim as kin. I would not share it with a meddling vagabond.” 

Bilbo lets that hang in the air. He does not ask Thorin if this means that he claims Bilbo as kin. More likely than not, Thorin would have no qualms if the wizard suddenly reappeared and offered his aid in fighting the dragon. Bilbo would not be surprised if this were only Thorin’s way of easing his own nerves. A discussion of this nature at this juncture would likely not be wise, Bilbo decides, nestling into Thorin’s embrace and pretending to go back to sleep. 

 

The interval on the doorstep is much less tense than Bilbo remembers it being. He takes a pear out of his pack and munches on it while he leans against the spot where he knows the door will be. Bilbo has gone in and out of it so many times by now; there is no doubt in his mind of its location. Finally, he has completed the second step of his plan. Bilbo got the company through their adventure a second time, and now everyone is whole and hale and poised for entry to the Lonely Mountain. He has every reason in the world to be as relieved as he is. The others stare at him incredulously. 

“Something you’re not telling us, laddie?” Glóin inquires testily. He is perhaps getting a little sick of eating dried fish, which does not bode well for the time that Bilbo knows they will spend stuck in the mountain with their meagre rations alone. “You seem comfortable."

“Tomorrow is Durin’s day,” Thorin reports, looking very tense indeed. His jaw is set and his eyes do not leave the side of the mountain. Bilbo pretends that this has nothing to do with the gold inside, that this time, his love has rescued Thorin from the terrible fate that awaits him. He knows it isn’t true, of course, but he cannot help but indulge in a little bit of wishful thinking. If he starts fretting, the rest of the company will start fretting.

“Then we’ll have to wait until tomorrow, won’t we?” Bilbo puts on a casual tone. From the look that Fíli shoots him, at least one person is aware that their Burglar’s thoughts are not truly so rosy, but Bilbo thinks he can count on the crown prince to keep his secret.

“I think we should figure out a plan before then,” Balin decrees. Bilbo can recognize that this would likely be very helpful, were there anything to make a plan about. 

“I don’t think that’s really necessary,” he explains gently, rather than raising his voice to point out that they should’ve made a plan before they left the Blue Mountains. “The moon runes were quite clear. The thrush will be along at the keyhole sometime tomorrow, to show us where it is, and then all we’ve got to do is wait for the moon to rise and show us where to put the key.” 

Actually, Bilbo could probably find the keyhole without the last light of Durin’s day, but he neglects to mention this to the company, let alone to try it out. After all, it is best not to fiddle with the timing of things. He gave Bard a particular date for the dragon attack, and he does not want to trigger the carnage too early when the bowman will be unprepared. 

“You think it is the moon?” Dwalin does not sound particularly convinced. 

“The sun is not truly the last light of any day, is it?” Bilbo asks, putting on a smug expression. “That’d be the moon. So we’ll have to look out for a thrush, wait for the moon to rise, and unlock the door. Simple.” 

Thorin rather abruptly falls to his knees before Bilbo, so that the pair of them are at eye level. He’s been doing this a lot lately, as he never did on their first journey together.Before Bilbo can make sense of what is happening, he is in the king’s arms once again. He shouldn’t be so taken off guard, considering how often this happens, but he knows he’ll never get used to it. “Oh, my clever Burglar,” Thorin mutters into Bilbo’s hair. “What would we do without you?” 

Ah, yes. Yet another difference. “Your gratitude is much appreciated,” Bilbo admits, “Though getting inside is only half the battle.”

“A lot less than half, I’d say.” Balin is entirely correct, though he has no way of knowing about anything that will come to pass, let aloneBilbo’s plans to challenge fate. 

“Oh, sure, but the other seventy percent is really just logistics,” Bofur reasons, “Once Bilbo gets inside, all we’ve got to do is kill the dragon. There’s fourteen of us and only one of him, so that shouldn’t be too much trouble.”

Bombur takes the liberty of elbowing his brother in the side, for which Bilbo is thankful. It would have been a great feat indeed, worming out of Thorin’s embrace just to smack Bofur upside the head, but he’d have done it if necessary. “Now is not the time to jest,” Thorin declares, though he does not release Bilbo. “We are on the threshold of our kingdom. The time has come to reclaim what was taken from us.”

The sight of them must be comical for the rest of their company. In fact, Bilbo can see that both princes are making a valiant effort to fight off laughter. Nori wears an amused expression as he fiddles with his knife, and Ori is furiously scribbling something in a leather book he managed to obtain in Lake-town. Bilbo hopes that the lad is composing a song or a poem about the heroism of the King and the Burglar, but more likely than not, it’s actually a piece about the way that they are touching right now. Thorin’s intentions, at least, are undeniable. 

“You should let him breathe, Uncle!” Kíli calls eventually, which is very bold, considering Thorin just made it clear that he would not entertain joking comments at this time. “We’ll have no chance against Smaug with a squashed Burglar.” 

“And some of us would like to preserve our innocence for as long as we can,” Fíli grumbles. 

“Oh, aye, you’ve been preserving that a long time,” Bofur shoots back with a wide smile.

“Even here, upon the face of Erebor, my own subjects do not listen to me,” Thorin pouts, though there is something playful about it. 

Of course. The king must be nearing hysterics, and why would he not be? For decades, he has wandered, kept away from this home of his which has ever meant so much to him. Now, here he is, so close to entering the mountain and yet so very far away. 

“Oh, quit griping.” Bilbo isn’t sure whether he has any right to be as proud of himself as he is with his successful restoration of a cheerful mood. After all, cheerful or not, they’re all going to have to face a dragon in the coming days. And with the entire company present, things will undoubtedly be different than they were the first time, even if Bilbo didn’t intend to destroy the ring. He won’t have the advantage of complete foreknowledge from this point on. “You have to let them cope with what’s to come in their own ways.” 

Thorin doesn’t seem to like this course of action, but he doesn’t argue with Bilbo, either. Then again, he also refuses to take his hands off of the Hobbit for several hours after this. But Bilbo will humor being used as a security blanket if it has any chance of preventing the onset of dragon sickness. 

 

The next evening, Bilbo finds himself inside the mountain, just like last time. The actual opening of the door was much less climactic than it was on the original adventure; the company simply waited until the moon was in the sky and placed the key in the keyhole when the light shone on it. Bilbo was right about the placement of the keyhole, by the way, and could have gotten in at any time if he’d so chosen. But he is not going to complain about a delay in having to face Smaug once more. 

It’s just as terrible as it was the first time, though for different reasons. Before, when Balin walked him inside, Bilbo was distracted by the uncertainty of what lay before him. Now, Bilbo is distracted by the certain knowledge of everything that will come to pass. The treasure hoards will pose a challenge for Thorin no matter what, and there is only so much Bilbo can do to help him. The Arkenstone is down there, and the dragon, and Bilbo is confronting them both with a Ring of Power in his pocket. And not just any Ring of Power, either. What could possibly go wrong? 

“Are you alright, lad?” Balin asks, placing a gentle, paternal hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. Well, not paternal, exactly. Bungo Baggins would probably pick his son up and carry him as far away from the dragon as he could get, could he see what was happening. And Bilbo knows that if he ever found Frodo in his present situation, he’d have to sit on his hands to keep himself from intervening. Case in point: he did exactly that during the council at Rivendell, and a fat lot of good it did him, too. 

“Fine,” Bilbo chokes out, “Just about to face a dragon, is all.” 

“Thorin did not come up with very much of a plan for this section of the journey,” Balin admits. 

“Watch over him for me,” Bilbo advises. He only means that Balin should keep an eye on Thorin while Bilbo is alone inside the mountain with Smaug, but of course, it sounds much worse than that to poor Balin. 

“Bilbo—“ 

“You know that this treasure carries… some sort of curse,” Bilbo elaborates, “Just… please make sure that Thorin is well. The princes, too.”

“Thorin won’t be well until he knows that his intended is safe and the dragon is slain.”

“It’s news to me that I am his intended,” Bilbo quips. “I don’t think putting his hand on my back and refusing to let me out of his sight necessarily constitutes a proposal.” It would be improper and reckless to talk about the kissing right now. “And for the record, I do hope he doesn’t expect me to go slaying the dragon.”

“He knows how you feel,” Balin decides, refusing to take the ridiculous bait that Bilbo has set for him. Nobody in their right mind could believe that Thorin seriously expects Bilbo to slay a dragon for him. “And you know how he feels. That’s enough for the heart, if not for the law. And what the two of you were doing in the Marketplace only happens between Ones.” His eyes twinkle, and his smile is knowing, as though he thinks that he and Bilbo are co-conspirators in some sort of inside understanding. 

Bilbo sucks in a breath. Does he know how Thorin feels? Yes. Yes, and that knowledge has brought him a surprising amount of pain, because Thorin’s expressiveness on this journey has been a direct contradiction to the way he treated Bilbo the last time. If Thorin loves and trusts Bilbo now, and this is how he behaves, how did he feel about the Hobbit before? He clearly cared for Bilbo enough to give him a mithril coat, but not enough to defend him so passionately from every threat, real or perceived. If he had more time, Bilbo would revel in the conflicting emotions that have begun to bloom inside his ribcage in response to Balin’s words. But he does not have time. Every moment that he spends with the ring, it digs a few more of its foul roots into his mind. Every fraction of a second that it stays in his pocket, he becomes less able to destroy it. 

“Right,” Bilbo says, steeling himself. He didn’t linger this long in the passageway the last time. This is a waste of seconds that he really cannot spare. What if Smaug wakes up before Bilbo gets down there? “Can’t argue with that. I’ll be off, then.” He seriously considers just going ahead without a further word, but remembering his plan, it occurs to Bilbo that there is some chance that things will go differently this time than they did the last time. “Balin, if I don’t— if the worst happens, will you tell Thorin that…” Oh, how to put it into words? “Will you tell Thorin that—“ 

“I will, laddie, I will.” Balin does not patronize Bilbo by pretending that it won’t be necessary, or that he doesn’t understand what the Hobbit means. It may very well be necessary, and Bilbo’s meaning could not be more clear, after the conversation they’ve just had. And Balin is a good friend, whether he is leading Bilbo down the passage to his death or no. 

Bilbo follows the same path into the treasury that he took the last time. He steps over piles upon piles of gold, more riches than any one creature could ever hope to enjoy. He makes no effort to quiet the racket he is making, knowing as he does that he was just as loud prior to his first confrontation with the dragon. He ignores the lovely Dwarven architecture of which he knows that Thorin is so proud, the lovely carvings from a type of green stone that Bilbo cannot, for the life of him, identify. It shines, and it sparkles, and even Bilbo, even a Hobbit, even one who has done all of this before, must close his eyes for a moment against the sheer brilliance of it, the desire that the hoard engenders to take and take and take. 

The beast wakes, naturally. Smaug opens his eyes and breathes fire and makes threats, just as before. Clever though the dragon may be, he cannot see into the Hobbit’s mind, as was Bilbo’s fear when first they had this conversation. If Smaug knew who Bilbo was, or how he had come to be here in Erebor once again, he would not repeat the same tired quotations that he used the first time. But Smaug appears to be reading from the same script. 

Bilbo refuses to listen to the dragon’s words this time around. He forces himself to shut his ears, to focus on other things, and pays just enough attention to get his own two cents in. He knows the dangers of listening to dragon speech, and even with his careful inattention, he begins to wonder if Smaug might not have a point. If Bilbo’s friends might not be deceiving him. But, no. Smaug is a manipulative creature who does not know any member of the company as well as Bilbo does. And if Bilbo can resist the One Ring, can tell it to shut its mouth and leave him alone, please and thank you, then he can resist the warbling of a silly little dragon. A silly little dragon that could kill him by breathing in his direction. 

Bilbo reluctantly slips the ring onto his finger, trying frantically to remember his exact dialogue in the heat of a scorching moment. But Bilbo has the confidence of foresight and hindsight. He has done this all before. He knows what makes Smaug angry, and he knows what the dragon likes. Just as he did with Gollum, Bilbo pulls the riddles he used before out from his memory and recites them again, with a little more showmanship and a little less fear. There is no reason why this should not work. Besides, Bilbo has the advantage of knowing when Smaug is going to attack, how he’s going to move, and what that’s going to do to the treasure. His memory isn’t perfect, but he has a better understanding this time than he did the last time about how the mounds of treasure happen to be balanced. All things considered, his conversation with Smaug is not much different from the way it was the last time.

It all feels a little bit pointless, this expedition of his. The last time, he was sent to see what waited in the mountain and, theoretically, to steal the Arkenstone back from Smaug. Now, Bilbo is here exclusively to wake the dragon so that he can be killed. How? How can the company kill the beast? 

Something occurs to Bilbo, then, something so obvious that he’s a little ashamed not to have thought of it before. All that work to protect the people of Lake-town! But that is not true. No. Bilbo did what he could for them, of course. He warned Bard, and he felt terrible about vouching for Thorin, but the best possible outcome involves the dragon attacking Lake-town. If Smaug flies into Bard’s trap, he will be killed. If the company has to face him, they will all be burnt to a crisp. If Thorin and company had some secret weapon hiding up their sleeves, they would have used it the first time around.

Bilbo can tell himself all he likes that Kíli is their best archer, and that he was not here the first time around, but the fact stands that Kíli does not have a black arrow. And even if he did, he does not have a bow large enough from which to fire it. Moreover, Smaug would never allow the lad into a position to even see the broken spot on his underbelly, even if the company were able to procure some sort of miniature wind lance. Bard is, and always has been, their only hope. Bilbo should have introduced himself as Barrel-rider and had done with it. If he wanted a clean conscience, he’d have done better to stop Thorin from entering the Mountain at all. He has been a fool to think otherwise. 

Bilbo ignores the glow of the Arkenstone when it flashes at him from amongst the coins. When the dragon moves, displacing more gold and covering the stone with shiny coins, Bilbo feels genuine relief. The decision has been taken out of his hands. 

Even giving that meddlesome rock to Bard and Thranduil did not prevent Thorin’s destructive actions. Bilbo knows that having the Arkenstone would be worse for Thorin than not having it, but he also knows that collecting the Arkenstone will ultimately result in Thorin’s death. He was strong enough last time to resist handing it over, but what he did with it only made things worse. Besides, last time, Thorin actually let Bilbo out of his sight long enough that he could sneak down to the army below and deliver the Arkenstone. At this point, Bilbo is not convinced that the king will leave him to his own devices long enough to take a breath of fresh air. Thorin was bad enough in Lake-town, without the influence of a cursed hoard hanging over him. Who knows how he’ll treat Bilbo when he’s reclaimed his Mountain and the treasure it contains?

But most importantly, Bilbo has another priority. He must destroy the ring. He cannot allow it to threaten him any longer. Maybe, he tells himself, the Arkenstone had nothing to do with it. Maybe it was the ring which corrupted Thorin, all those years ago. Perhaps he became so covetous through sheer proximity to the thing, never knowing why. Perhaps that is why he recovered only in Bilbo’s absence. 

You fool, the ring hisses, Do not give up your chance to save the one you love. The Dwarf will suffer greatly from his madness if you destroy the only thing that could control his mind. 

Control his mind? Even if Bilbo believed that this were possible (which he doesn’t, knowing Thorin Oakenshield), he would not wish to do it. The ring seems to believe, for reasons unbeknownst to him, that Bilbo craves power. That he wishes to wed Thorin for the scepter he would wield as Consort Under the Mountain rather than for the love of the king. “You’re the fool,” Bilbo mutters. 

The way forward is clear enough. He finds a convenient pillar, which he hopes is heat resistant, like the ones in the forges. It must be, if it is still standing after decades of Smaug’s occupation. At least, Bilbo must tell himself as much. He may die in this venture. “Over here, O Smaug, great and terrible!” He calls. Then he wrenches the ring off his finger with no small amount of difficulty and sets it on the other side of the pillar, behind a golden cup. The very same golden cup that inspired his invention in his book. 

He should keep the ring. He should cling to it forever. He should let it help him, let it grant him invisibility. The ring will not hurt Frodo if Bilbo only keeps it close. It will grant him what he wishes. It will give him the power to protect the ones he loves. Azog and Bolg are stupid and weak, blinded by their senseless desire for revenge. With a little cunning and a little magic borrowed from the ring, Bilbo can kill them easily. But he need not choose to do so. The ring could give Bilbo the power to make them both suffer, to punish them for harming those close to him. Why struggle through a battle, blind to what the future holds, when he could change it all with a wave of his hand?

These thoughts are only the ring trying to manipulate him. He had it last time, and it didn’t help him protect Thorin. He kept it very close, and still, it did unspeakable damage to poor Frodo. Whether or not it is capable of these feats, the ring will not perform them. If Bilbo keeps it, the ring will break its promises and twist his mind. This single, stupid piece of metal nearly killed Bilbo’s nephew, tortured him, in fact, and now it is using Thorin and the lads to try and lure Bilbo into letting it do the same thing again. Bilbo has cast it off before, when its power was much greater than it is at the moment, and Bilbo’s spirit much weaker, to boot. If he could place the ring into Gandalf’s envelope and walk out of Bag End with his pockets empty, then he can just as easily do this. For Frodo. If nothing else, Bilbo can do this for Frodo. As Smaug lumbers over, he wrenches the little metal circle off his finger and throws it down in front of the pillar.

It is agony, not stepping forward to rescue his ring. Even in its weakened state, he can feel it calling for him, screaming his name, begging for help. He can feel its pain, its rage, its betrayal. The ring will not forget if he leaves it, but of course it will forgive him if he takes it. If he steps into the dragon fire and puts the ring back on, it will take care of him. It will give him the courage to save the ones he loves. Does he really think he can do it on his own? Does he really think that one little Hobbit without the power of invisibility can save Thorin from himself? And then the ring is silent.

“Are you dead yet?” Smaug roars. Bilbo comes to his senses. No, he isn’t dead, by some miracle. 

It is the luck of Hobbits, or the indestructible nature of Dwarven stonework, or the kind act of some Vala who would prefer not to see three Sons of Durin and a Baggins of Bag End dead on a mountainside. Not that Bilbo thinks the Lady Yavanna has any power over stone or fire. No, if he was saved by anyone, it was his Lady’s husband, to whom he will be grateful for the rest of time. 

“Were you trying to kill me, o Smaug the magnificent? I had thought that an estimable dragon lord such as yourself would be able to think of a much more creative method for doing away with a puny little creature like me.” He can’t very well make himself invisible, he realizes belatedly, and he just practically asked the dragon to come and kill him. Really, Bilbo has forgotten the perils of thinking on his feet. He’s been spoiled, with all this foreknowledge. But no more. 

“Is that so?” Smaug turns around, presumably for dramatic effect. Bilbo takes advantage of this to reach out and fumble for the ring. He must make sure that it was really destroyed. For a moment, he does not find it, and he is willing to believe it dissolved, as Elrond promised him it would. Then, his finger brushes the familiar metal circle, and his hopes are dashed. The One Ring is fully intact.“You ask very much of me, thief. I must entertain you with a creative death?”

Well. That plan failed. Bilbo’s body is buzzing with the terrible realization that he has failed to destroy the ring, and the grateful knowledge that, at the very least, he will be able to make a clean break with it on his finger. He slips it on and nothing happens. He takes it off again and puts it on again and once more, nothing happens. Has the ring forsaken him? Is it able to refuse its power to those it deems unworthy? There is no response, and that is how Bilbo knows that something has changed. The ring could never resist an opportunity to criticize him and increase his reliance upon its power. 

But he doesn’t have much time to think about it now as he takes advantage of Smaug’s distraction and dashes down the closest narrow passage he can find. It is the same one that he took before. At least he remembers that much. Ring or no ring, Bilbo must now run for his life. 

 

 

Bilbo races up the stairs as fast as his legs will carry him. It’s odd. What little rational thought still remains inside his head reminds him that he has done this before and been successful, and yet he just can’t quite bring himself to shed his fear. He knows that the attitudes and actions of his companions have been altered by small changes in Bilbo’s behavior; it only makes sense to think that the dragon would be much the same way. For all he knows, Smaug will be even worse this time around. He can’t let his guard down quite yet. And, distracted by his own thoughts, Bilbo nearly barrels into Thorin at the top of the stairs. 

“You’re alive,” the king breathes with palpable relief.

“And no thanks to the dragon behind me.” Bilbo does not have time for an emotional reunion. He can appreciate that Thorin must have been very scared by the loud noises and obvious bursts of heat that he witnessed from his position outside the mountain, but now is not the time to talk about it. Also, Bilbo knows what is coming, and he wants to avoid it if he can. Maybe it’ll be different if he handles the situation differently.

“Did you find the Arkenstone?” So, not very different at all, then. 

“There is a dragon chasing me, Thorin!” Bilbo takes his usual tack and addresses Thorin directly. Calling him on his nonsense, as he’s been doing this entire trip.

But it isn’t enough. Bilbo can tell from Thorin’s eyes that the madness has already begun to take root. “The Arkenstone! Did you find it?” 

“I didn’t even begin to look,” Bilbo hedges. There is still time for things to go differently, he reminds himself. Thorin may surprise him yet. “I was preoccupied. You know, with the dragon?”

Bilbo tries to step forward to join Thorin in the doorwaybut the king blocks his exit with his sword. It isn’t Orcrist, but it’s still a good blade, and even the dullest of swords could do irreparable damage to Bilbo, especially in Thorin’s practiced hands. “You are not thinking clearly,” Bilbo tries. He has to try, not just for his own sake, but for Thorin’s as well. 

Those intense blue eyes do not leave him as Thorin twists his wrist, realigning his sword so that it is pointed directly at Bilbo’s chest. Thorin doesn’t even blink. This has happened before, so Bilbo should not be so troubled by it, should not be trembling as he is. He knows that Thorin will not kill him, after all. But he is shaking with the realization that there is nothing he can do to prevent the dragon sickness from taking root. Bilbo has been kind to Thorin, has given him the benefit of the doubt, shown him nothing but compassion and cut him more slack than he deserved at many points on the journey. Bilbo has indulged the king’s over-protective nonsense and fed him affirmations on countless occasions when he would’ve been well within his rights to stomp off like he did the first time. All of it the product of a foolish hope that Bilbo’s affection alone could be enough to stave off dragon sickness. All of it deriving from the naive belief that the first time, it had been Bilbo’s fault for not loving Thorin properly, not doing enough to help him avoid the call of the treasure and the madness that would claim him. 

And it has all been for naught. No, Thorin will not kill Bilbo. He does not have time to do so, and he must know that he’ll be hard-pressed to get his hands on the Arkenstone without a Burglar by his side, but he is apparently perfectly content to point his sword at the one loves. He is already not himself, and this will only get worse, the more time he spends in the Mountain. And this is where Bilbo’s plans begin to fall apart, because he may have fighting spiders and escaping from Elves well in hand, but he does not know how to help someone who is suffering from Dragon sickness. If he did, he would be with Yavanna now, waiting for Thorin to join him after many years of successful rule. 

The last time, Bilbo merely stood there in shocked silence, watching in horror and waiting to see what Thorin would do. He genuinely believed that the king would see reason on his own. Now, Bilbo knows better. He is not surprised in the slightest. He led Thorin to Erebor, into this obvious trap, toward the hoard that Bilbo knew would make him sick. He has no right to be shocked that his king is now showing symptoms of that sickness. 

“I did not think,” Bilbo speaks up, which may be a very stupid thing to do. After all, Thorin did not kill him the last time, when Bilbo was silent. He really should be doing everything the same. But some small, foolish part of him still wants to prove that he is able to save Thorin with his words alone. That he can mend whatever the dragon sickness has broken and protect Thorin from the worst of it. “I did not think that you would be pleased, to come down to your treasure halls and find me burned to a crisp and the Arkenstone destroyed by dragon fire in my hands.” 

He does not know why he thinks that will have any any effect. Thorin only stares at him with those sharp, molten eyes. “No,” he agrees, jabbing at Bilbo with the tip of his sword. This is not good at all. “I would not be pleased.” 

They continue to stare at each other. Bilbo is waiting for the dragon, hoping that Smaug’s arrival will force Thorin back to his senses. Thorin is apparently waiting for Bilbo to produce the Arkenstone from somewhere on his person. There isn’t much logic to all of this. If Thorin wants Bilbo to rush back down and steal the Arkenstone, he should probably ease up with the sword and let the burglar get back to his burglary. But that does not happen. Thorin’s eyes do not leave Bilbo’s. 

The sound of footsteps breaks whatever trace they’d both fallen into. “Uncle?” Fíli calls. He steps into Bilbo’s line of sight, and it’s clear that he, at least, has witnessed more than he should’ve. He can see Thorin pointing a sword at Bilbo. “What are you doing?” The lad reaches for his own blade, and Bilbo doesn’t know whether Fíli intends to join Thorin in his attack or to defend Bilbo if it comes to it. 

Thorin continues to stare at Bilbo, the fire in his eyes rapidly cooling into a sort of stunned shock. He heaves out a heavy breath, glances down at his sword arm, and quickly lowers his blade. “By Mahal, I—“ His eyes are wide and frantic, panicked, which is not good. 

“It’s alright, Thorin,” Bilbo assures him, grabbing the king by the arm and steering him back just as the dragon begins lumbering toward them. Thank the Valar for Fíli, though Bilbo doesn’t know why the lad’s voice was more effective than his own in combatting Thorin’s dragon sickness. “I’m not angry with you.” How could he be? It isn’t Thorin’s fault that he’s succumbed to an ancient curse he did not believe in. It is Bilbo’s fault for knowing this would happen and bringing Thorin here anyway. “But we really need to go.”

The rest of the company bursts out of the shadows. From the looks on their faces, they didn’t witness anything to make them question their loyalty to Thorin. Fíli, however, wears a troubled expression, and opens his mouth as though to voice a question better not asked. Bilbo shakes his head at the lad. Now is not the time to discuss dragon sickness and the impact that it’s already begun to have on Thorin. Bilbo would like to help, of course, but for the moment, their primary concern is getting away from the dragon that is chasing them. 

“You will burn!” Smaug roars, and Bilbo barely has time to drag Thorin through the nearest passageway before the dragon is breathing fire at them. 

This time, Bilbo is the last one through the door, using force he didn’t know he had inside his body to urge Thorin forward. His king can point a hundred swords at Bilbo, and it will not change a thing about the way he feels. Bilbo will protect Thorin if it’s the last thing he does, and it may very well be, because Bilbo can feel dragon fire on his back, burning the nice blue tunic that he picked up in Lake-town. Instinctively, he flops to the ground and rolls a little, putting out the flame. 

“Bilbo!” Thorin cries, rushing to Bilbo’s side when he really should be rushing away from the dragon that is chasing them. Oh, this is not good at all. Bilbo has distracted Thorin from the task at hand twice over. “You are hurt.”

“I am not,” Bilbo protests, sitting up. It stings a bit, yes, but the pain is by no means agonizing. His tunic got the worst of it, and anyway, the rush of battle is working wonders for him at the moment. “We have to keep going. Óin can see to my back later.” 

“Aye,” Óin agrees, “It looks like a second-degree burn to me. Nothing that can’t wait, though I’d like to get it bandaged once we’re through this fight.” 

The fire returns to Thorin’s eyes. For some reason, this, too, feels wrong to Bilbo. Something is off, and he can’t put his finger on it. “That worm hurt you.” If he heard his cousin’s words just now, he does not react to them. 

“Yes, well, he is a dragon,” Bilbo reasons, scrambling to his feet before attempting to pull Thorin up as well. “They do tend to do that sort of thing.” He doesn’t feel the need to remind Thorin that Smaug has hurt many of his kin already. 

“Come on, Uncle,” Kíli urges. “We must keep going. Is there another way out?” 

“Yes.” Thorin breathes. He does not sound well at all. Bilbo tries to steady him with a hand on his bicep, but the effects are unclear as Thorin begins shouting directions and the company scrambles to follow. 

Bilbo can think of little other than his aching legs and the change in Thorin as they navigate the passages of Erebor. He cannot bring himself to pay attention. He can barely bring himself to move his body forward, step by step. If he were thinking clearly, he might steer them away from the entryway, where he and he alone knows what they will find. But he does not think of it. He’s thinking only of the rage and dread that he saw in Thorin’s eyes, the danger that all of them are in, and the uncertain expression on Fíli’s face when he walked in on Thorin and Bilbo with the sword.

When they enter the hall of corpses, Kíli grabs Bilbo by the arm and exclaims in Khuzdul. “Our kin,” he breathes in the common tongue. “They are our kin.”

On the first adventure, the lads did not have to see this. They did not have to watch the utter despair on their uncle’s face before he schooled his expression into something more worthy of a fearless leader. They did not have to listen to him calling their dead subjects cowards. Truthfully, this is not Thorin’s greatest moment, though Bilbo knows it will not be his worst, either. 

He does not quite know why Kíli is clinging to him, though. Perhaps the archer simply knows better than to try and seek out comfort from his uncle right now. “It’s alright, my lad,” Bilbo assures him, “We’re going to make it out.”

“I know.” Kíli releases Bilbo instantly, as though remembering himself. “But—“ 

He is cut off by Thorin shouting orders at the company once again. Fíli stands behind his uncle like a shadow, watching, waiting. Now that they are in their kingdom, ruined as it may be, they are each of them every inch the royal. Bilbo could stand here and marvel, were he not busy following Thorin to what might become their doom. 

But Bilbo does follow. He scuttles along dutifully, ignoring any pain that he might feel in his back and waiting for instructions from Thorin, which, when he receives them, he follows to the best of his ability. Just like last time. They wind up near the forges once again. Apparently, not enough has changed on this journey to dissuade Thorin from enacting his utterly foolish scheme. 

“The plan’s not gonna work,” Dwalin announces. He is wrong, but Bilbo can forgive him that. It does seem downright ridiculous. “These furnaces are stone cold.” 

“He’s right. We’ve no fire hot enough to set them ablaze,” Balin agrees, matter of factly. 

“Have we not?” Thorin demands. 

Bilbo would very much like not to be distracted right now, but he feels something in his guts watching Thorin take charge this way. Part of it is guilt, of course. After all, it is Bilbo’s fault that Thorin never truly got a chance to rule his beloved mountain. But part of it is something else, something Bilbo did not want to unpack eighty years ago and does not particularly want to unpack now. It matters very little, anyway. Now would hardly be the appropriate time to initiate another kiss, especially considering what Bilbo now knows about the significance of such gestures in Dwarven society. Bilbo can’t afford to be distracted, and it would be unthinkable to do anything that might distract Thorin at this juncture. He cannot undo what he has already done, and he knows there is little he can do to assuage Thorin’s constant worry, but at the very least, Bilbo can stop himself from making things worse. They can lock lips all they like when they’ve escaped this mountain with their lives.

“I did not look to see you so easily outwitted!” Thorin yells in the dragon’s general direction while the company stares on in shock. “You have grown slow and fat in your dotage! Slug!” He turns to his people, as though it is completely normal for a king to deliberately provoke a dragon into blowing fire at him. “Take cover, go!” 

“This is suicide,” Nori grumbles from beside Bilbo. But Dori is hauling his brother behind a pillar with hurried admonitions before the Hobbit can say anything. Whether Thorin’s plan is solid or not, the fact remains that Smaug is about to breathe fire at all of them, and the best thing they can do is follow their king’s instructions.

Bilbo knows from his brief interval staying with Dáin that the pillars in the furnace chamber are built to resist fire, which makes him slightly more confident ducking behind one of them than he was the first time around. Truly, Bilbo believed that he was going to die. He supposes that none of the company were in a position to explain it to him, and does not blame any of them, but his fear at the time was entirely genuine. Now, at least, he has a better idea of what is going on. He cowers behind a pillar and waits for the fire to pass. 

Smaug is not half as clever as he believes, if he fell victim so easily to Thorin’s manipulation. Probably, he didn’t know about the pillars, either, and he thought that he’d make quick work of the company, whether that meant lighting the furnaces or not. But he plays right into Thorin’s practiced hands. It would be impressive, maybe, if the entire situation weren’t so ridiculous. There’s a good reason why Bilbo left this sequence out of his book. It all feels very silly, now that he’s not distracted by the fear of death and confusion about why Thorin threatened to impale him in the name of a single stupid rock.

As Bilbo mulls things over, Thorin shouts more orders to the company, directing them to carry out his latest hare-brained scheme. Honestly, if Bilbo didn’t know for a fact that this would work, he’d have intervened now three times over. Fíli seems to be having similar thoughts, and he meets Bilbo’s eyes once again with a look of utter bafflement. 

Bilbo is too far away to reassure the prince, and in many respects, he’s glad of that. What could he say? Oh, don’t worry, I know it seems like your uncle is going mad, and he very much is, but I happen to know from the last time I did all of this that we’ll all survive to the end of the night! And if I can get my act together in time for the  battle only I know is coming, you might even live to be king some day! 

“Bilbo!” Thorin calls, shaking the Hobbit from his thoughts. “Up there, on my mark, pull that lever.” The same directions as last time, then. Good. Bilbo knows how to follow them, and he knows what will happen when he does, though Thorin could’ve explained it better the first time. “Fíli, Kíli.” This is new. “Cover him, and help him with the lever if he needs it.”

“Do I need cover?” Bilbo asks, but the lads are already ushering him up toward their goal. “I don’t need cover. And I certainly don’t need help with that lever.” After all, he managed it well enough on his own the last time. And what’s more, Thorin knew that, and did not send anybody to aid Bilbo in such a simple venture. 

“No, you don’t,” Fíli agrees. “But try arguing with him.” Bilbo ignores the edge to his tone. Everything can be explained later. For now, they’d better get to pulling that blasted lever. 

“You may need help getting up those stairs,” says Kíli as the three of them run at top speed toward the lever. 

“Excuse you!” Bilbo scolds him. “I’m not that old, thank you very much, and I’m not that small, either, before you say it.” 

“I think Uncle Thorin is trying to preserve the bloodline,” Fíli mutters, hoisting Bilbo onto the first step. The Hobbit tries and fails to be annoyed by this. After all, he got up these stairs perfectly well on his own the first time. But then, Fíli is the future King of Erebor. It is second-nature for him to offer aid, whether it is strictly necessary or simply helpful. “And protecting his intended along with us.” 

That much never occurred to Bilbo, but he does see the logic in it. After all, they’re going to be as far away from the dragon as any of the company could get, and they’re going to be right next to a rush of water. Easy cover from the dragon and his fire. “He could be a little more subtle,” Bilbo grumbles. He doesn’t like being hoodwinked into safety like this, though he’s pleased to see that the lads, at least, are being protected. “And I’m not his intended.”

“I think this is about as subtle as Thorin gets,” Kíli decides, helping Bilbo up to the lever. “And I’d wager he’ll be giving you a gift as soon as the dragon’s dead.”

“Well, that’s something to look forward to,” Bilbo grumbles. He’s had enough of Kíli’s meddling to last a lifetime. 

He will reluctantly admit, if only to himself, that there is much less jumping involved this time around as Bilbo pulls the lever, with an embarrassing amount of help from Kíli. Still, perhaps Bilbo is being too hard on himself. He is injured, after all, twice over, counting his hip. And the last time the Hobbit tried to pull a lever, Kíli had to rush through an armed skirmish to extricate a severely wounded Bilbo. “There,” Fíli announces with a smile when the water begins gushing out. “That should do it.” 

“Do what?” Kíli asks. “What is uncle planning?”

Fíli gestures at the mill that will use the forthcoming water to move a series of buckets. “I think that’s our escape route.” 

“He isn’t thinking clearly,” Bilbo grumbles. He really shouldn’t have said anything, because Fíli now looks far too thoughtful for Bilbo’s comfort. He resembles his uncle more and more by the minute. Clearly, he can see that Thorin is faltering, and he’s preparing to take on the mantle of leadership. Dreading it, no doubt, but preparing nevertheless. But now is not the time to be questioning their loyalty to Thorin. His plan is absolutely ridiculous, but Bilbo knows for a fact that it will keep the company alive for the time being. 

“He threatened you,” Fíli points out. 

“What?” Kíli, obviously, has not been filled in. “When?”

“Now isn’t the time to talk about it,” Bilbo declares, “Come on. Are you going in the buckets, or are you coming with me?” 

The lads take a moment to study the rickety-looking buckets. The things are made of wood, and they’ve been out of use for over a century. “We’ll go with you,” Fíli decides. “Let Uncle take his wild risks.”

“I’d prefer it if he didn’t,” says Bilbo, but the lads are already practically carrying him down the stairs. Kíli’s hand on his shoulder does not feel as comforting or steadying as it might if Bilbo had not been burned by dragon fire in that exact spot, but he doesn’t want to make the lad feel guilty and therefore says nothing about it. 

“Master Baggins,” Kíli observes, “Your face is red.”

“Yes, well, I am running through a furnace!” Bilbo shouts back.

Neither of the lads seem to be particularly affected by the heat. Bilbo knows that many of the residents of Erebor burned in dragon fire. He’s heard the song, after all, and he has spoken to Thorin for more than five minutes. But he has also seen his king riding down a river of molten metal, an activity which would easily kill a Hobbit from the heat alone. Clearly their line bears some measure of heat-resistance with which, unfortunately, Bilbo has not been blessed.

“You can go faster,” Fíli realizes, after they’ve scrambled down the stairs and set off at a run through the halls of Erebor. “We’re slowing you down.”

“No,” Bilbo protests weakly, but it’s true enough. He’s always been a fair runner, and he’s not bogged down by weapons as the lads are. Also, he has no reason to preserve his energy. Nobody could possibly be expecting Bilbo to fight a dragon. 

“It’s true,” Kíli agrees, “Don’t lie to us, Master Baggins. We’ll be alright.” 

“I’m not going to just abandon you with a dragon chasing you!” Bilbo sputters. He doesn’t like that they’re here at all, though he supposes it’s preferable to allowing a severely injured Kíli to do battle with orcs in Bard’s home. 

“This heat will kill you!” Fíli gives him a shove. “Go! We’re right behind you. We’ll be fine.” 

“Durin’s folk do not fear a little fire,” Kíli offers with a grin. To his credit, it would be difficult for any but his closest friends and relations to discern that the smile is entirely false. “We were born for the forges of Erebor.”

Thankfully, Bilbo has the presence of mind to actually believe what the lads are telling him. He knows that Fíli would not risk his brother’s safety by initiating an attack on the dragon, even if Kíli would happily charge toward Smaug with his flimsy wooden arrows. He knows that their heat-tolerance is far superior to his own. He also knows that the lads will not take no for an answer, and that they will probably tattle to Thorin about his refusal to flee once the company is safe. He feels profoundly guilty about it, but he does as he’s told and bolts forward at top speed. 

He uses his large, quiet feet and the light clothes he’s wearing to his advantage and scrambles through the passageway, until he is very close to something exit-like. Of course, the way is barred by a door intended to be opened by several people together, all of whom are individually much stronger than any Hobbit. Bilbo is here now, with no chance of escape until the lads join him. He should have conserved his energy. He should have—

The dragon bursts through the wall, and Bilbo changes his tune immediately. He’d forgotten about this part, but he’s glad the lads are well behind him. If Smaug is here, then it stands to reason that he is not wherever Fíli and Kíli are, and that the brothers, therefore, are safe from dragon fire for the time being. 

Smaug catches sight of Bilbo, who has dragged a fallen tapestry over himself to no avail. “Do you take me for a fool?” The dragon bellows. “You have come from Lake-town; I can tell it from your dress.” Of course. Smaug has eaten his fair share of Lake Men and he would be familiar with their designs. Bilbo’s heart sinks as he realizes that all his careful talking in the treasury meant nothing. Whether or not he presented himself as Barrel-rider, the dragon was always going to attack Lake-town. “This is some sordid scheme hatched between these filthy Dwarves and those miserable tub-trading Lake Men. Those sniveling cowards with their long bows and black arrows. Perhaps it is time I paid them a visit.” 

Bilbo distinctly remembers attempting to plead with the dragon the last time. It didn’t go well. Smaug rightly guessed that Bilbo cared about the town and flew off to destroy it. Maybe if Bilbo takes the opposite approach, Smaug will do something different. But does he truly want Smaug to do something different? After all, if Bilbo could convince Smaug not to attack Lake-town, would the dragon not then turn his ire upon the company? If that’s the case, then Bilbo really should simply do exactly as he did the last time. But how could he possibly? How could Bilbo knowingly encourage Smaug to harm those innocent people, even with Bard waiting with a black arrow? 

When Bilbo spoke to the bowman, he convinced himself that he was setting up a sort of failsafe. But that is not true. Bilbo never seriously expected that the company would be able to fell Smaug. In his shame, he can say nothing and do nothing, only gape at the dragon in shocked disbelief. 

Bilbo can hear footsteps coming to a stop behind him. He can only hope that Fíli has the presence of mind to pull his brother behind a wall, out of sight of the dragon. He already knows that Kíli would never avoid a fight of his own accord. Bilbo would really prefer it if the lads had someone sensible with them to keep them out of trouble. Unfortunately, he has no choice but to focus on the dragon for the time being. If he turns around, he might divert the wyrm’s attention toward the princes.

“Nothing to say?” Smaug sounds amused. “No matter. You will watch as Esgaroth burns, and then you will burn!” 

“Here! You witless worm!” Thorin calls from an adjoining room. Oh, not this again, for Yavanna’s sake…

Bilbo thought it was very stupid of Thorin to attempt to cover the dragon in molten gold the first time. He never figured out how Thorin managed to make the large gold statue melt, and considering that dragons are very famously heat-resistant and well-known for covering themselves in jewels and treasure to protect their underbellies, he never figured out why Thorin thought that this plan would result in anything other than a shiny, infuriated dragon. This will not hurt the wyrm in the slightest, but it will put the entire company at risk.

Of course it will. Thorin is not in his right mind. He is defending Erebor, not himself or his friends. Their lives are not his primary concern. 

“You!” Smaug roars, turning on his heel and stomping off toward Thorin. Well, at least the lads are relatively safe now, unless they decide to follow their uncle’s example and do something stupid, which Bilbo cannot pretend is not a possibility. 

“I am taking back what you stole,” Thorin informs the dragon. There is no fear whatsoever in his tone. Bilbo should not be attracted to such self-sacrificing idiocy, but here he is, biting his lip and pretending that the warmth in his cheeks is due exclusively to the heat radiating from the dragon. Because even in the grip of madness, Thorin still has such a beautiful voice. 

Perhaps Bilbo is wrong. Perhaps he’s being overly cautious, seeing what he wants to see, projecting the madness from before onto this version of Thorin. Perhaps he imagined that blue fire in the king’s eyes; perhaps it was the echo of a memory. Or perhaps it does not matter. Perhaps Bilbo might kiss Thorin again, and that might reverse whatever damage has been done. But he is lying to himself. 

“You will take nothing from me, Dwarf,” Smaug snarls. Bilbo has heard these exact words before, of course, but they still make him shiver against his will. “I laid low your warriors of old. I instilled terror in the hearts of men. I am King Under the Mountain.”

“This is not your kingdom. These are Dwarf lands.” Truly, Thorin may be the best speaker that Bilbo has ever encountered. His voice is beautiful on its own, and when he turns it to such meaningful proclamations, it is impossible to stifle the urge to follow him across the world. They are all in mortal danger. “This is Dwarf gold. And we will have our revenge!” Thorin shouts an order in Khuzdul, and the company does something behind the scenes to reveal the golden statue. 

That blue fire is back in Thorin’s eyes again. In fact, it seems to surround him, radiating out from the king’s imposing person, in Bilbo’s imagination, if not in reality. He is staring through the gaping hole in the wall, watching as Thorin challenges the dragon. Bilbo feels compelled to run to his king and to fight alongside him, a stupid notion that will get him nowhere. He’s got to be the voice of reason. He’s got to keep the lads safe, got to keep Thorin safe, got to make sure that whatever is happening now does not lead to any deaths. 

“Come away, Master Baggins.” Fíli pulls Bilbo away from the broken wall, leading him as far from the dragon as it’s possible to get him. “This way.” 

“Revenge! Revenge?” The dragon roars, “I will show you revenge!” 

“What is he doing?” Kíli, meanwhile, has established himself in Bilbo’s old lookout spot. 

“I don’t know,” Fíli admits, sounding much older than he is. Yes, he has taken on the mantle of leadership indeed. Does he see it too, the flame in his uncle’s eyes? Or is it the fact that he is in Erebor, the homeland stolen from him? Has the reclamation of his birthright made him bolder? “Get away from there.” And he pulls his brother back from the wall just before the statue… explodes. 

“I’m only the spare,” Kíli protests jovially, though he follows well enough. “As long as you’re safe, it doesn’t matter what happens to me.” He must be terrified. Anyone would be. But just as Fíli forces himself to take charge, to protect his brother and his maybe-would-be-uncle, Kíli forces himself to lighten the mood, to keep all of their spirits up. 

This is how they work in tandem. All those years of harmless little plots, smug swaggering and big grins, have prepared them for this moment. For stepping into their roles as Princes of Erebor. Bilbo couldn’t be more proud. He hopes that Thorin will share this emotion, but if he does not, Bilbo will be the one to communicate it to the princes.

“Say that again and I’ll take you to the sparring ring right now!” Fíli hisses. Bilbo wonders if the sparring rings in Erebor are even still intact, though he suspects that even if they are not, Fíli will make good on his threat with a circle drawn in the sand. “If Thorin falls we will both be needed in the coming fight.”

“If Thorin falls, I don’t think the rest of us will be very far behind,” Bilbo mutters, shoving his anxiety down into the very depths of his stomach. Dragon fire at this close range wouldn’t do anybody any good, and the king, in his infinite wisdom, has led the company and the beast all to an enclosed space together. If Smaug remembers that he can, in fact, breathe fire, they’re all done for. But Smaug will not remember. He didn’t the last time. 

But before Fíli can answer, the dragon, now coated in gold and thrashing something awful, destroys yet another wall and sails through the side of the mountain with yet another deafening roar. At least he no longer poses any threat to Thorin. Bilbo can only hope that Bard has heeded his warning and is prepared to confront the dragon before Smaug can do too much damage.

“Well,” Kíli breathes after a moment, “I can’t imagine that was part of Uncle’s plan.”

“I can’t imagine that your uncle’s plan extended very far beyond theoretically using that statue as some kind of weapon,” Bilbo grumbles. He should’ve remembered all this sooner, and then he could have lectured Thorin about wasting time trying to attack a dragon… with gold. Although he doubts that Thorin would listen very carefully to any lecture in his present state.

He did enough lecturing the last time. On the first adventure, Bilbo convinced himself that Thorin was perfectly fine. And where did that get them? Ravenhill. It got them to Ravenhill. 

“He should not have done that,” Fíli decides, “It makes no sense.” 

“But what else could he have done?” Kíli asks. “He had nothing else with which to attack the dragon.” 

Fíli purses his lips. “Perhaps we should’ve brought something to use against it.” 

“You’re just thinking of that now?” Bilbo exclaims. Honestly, bother this entire company! They should’ve brought him into this venture much sooner, and he’d have set them right from the very beginning. 

Before the lads can offer any excuses for the general lack of foresight, the sound of pounding footsteps alerts them to Thorin’s presence. “Bilbo,” he pants upon entry to the chamber. “You’ve survived.”

“We’re alright, too, Uncle, thank you for noticing,” Kíli announces in a teasing tone. If he is genuinely hurt, he doesn’t show it. 

Thorin murmurs something in Khuzdul as he wraps Bilbo in his arms, ignoring his nephews entirely. This is not good. But Bilbo cannot help but return Thorin’s embrace. He may have known with some level of certainty that the king would survive this confrontation, but that didn’t do very much to steady Bilbo’s nerves. 

“I’m alright,” Bilbo assures Thorin, “Are you injured?”

“Not at all.” These words are muffled, spoken as they are against Bilbo’s shoulder, and they are followed by more Khuzdul muttering. Bilbo wishes that he understood. 

“We shouldn’t linger here,” Fíli points out. He looks very uncomfortable, though whether that’s because he can understand what his uncle is saying or because they are standing in a room that was just partially destroyed by a dragon, Bilbo isn’t sure. Still, the lad has good sense. He will make a fine king some day, in many, many years.  But Bilbo does not imagine that he will live to see that. If all goes according to plan, Thorin’s reign will be longer and more prosperous than the life of any Hobbit. 

“That is true,” Thorin decides. He attempts to lift Bilbo up, but the Hobbit shoots him what he hopes is a blood-curdling glare. 

“What do you think you’re doing?” Bilbo demands. 

“I would carry you to safety,” Thorin explains. His voice is heavy with meaning and emotion. Naturally, he puts none of this into words.

And Bilbo does not ask. Nor does he let Thorin know how pleased he is to see him. He feels that came across perfectly well in the hug, and anyway, it would be unwise to distract the king further. “I’m perfectly capable of walking to safety myself,” Bilbo points out. “And you have no reason to strain yourself by carrying me.”

“It would not be a strain.” Thorin looks at him with obvious affection. He is himself. At least for this moment, he is himself. Bilbo wants to kiss him again, to grab him by the shoulders and shake him, to physically drag him out of Erebor and away to safety. “You’re very small.”

No. They can’t turn their backs on this. The battle must take place. The battle will take place, whether Thorin is here for it or not. And even if he could convince the King Under the Mountain to abdicate, which feels more far-fetched than anything else that has happened on their quest to date, he cannot imagine that Fíli and Kíli would accompany them. They, like Thorin, have been raised on their duty to Erebor. And even in a perfect world, where Bilbo could get all of them away from here, the battle might be lost without their presence. 

The ring is not destroyed. It is weak, but it is not destroyed. What would happen, if the orcs claimed Erebor? Terrible things. Terrible things, even if Bilbo went off to go throw the ring into Mount Doom right this instant. Even in the grip of madness, Thorin did not falter in his devotion to the Mountain itself. He is a great king. He will not leave his kingdom, not even for Bilbo. Not even for the threat of madness.

“Yes, thank you, but I’m putting my foot down.” Bilbo holds out his hand to Thorin. “We can hold hands, but that’s it. No carrying.” He doesn’t know why it’s so important to him. Maybe he just wants to be certain that Thorin will listen to him when he says no. 

“Very well,” Thorin grumbles. “Though if your back troubles you, you must say something.” 

“Fine,” Bilbo agrees, and they set off back down the passageway. 

 

On their journey through Erebor, Bilbo is almost able to convince himself that perhaps he misjudged Thorin’s condition. After all, the king listened to Bilbo when he drew the line at being carried, and after a few minutes of fretting over the Hobbit (and not saying a word about the gold, mind you), he seemed to register his nephews’ presence and asked the lads if they were alright. Bilbo is slightly cheered, remembering that first encounter eighty years ago. He tried to warn the lads away from the treasure, but Fíli rushed to it, eyes wide and blazing. Bilbo suspected, for a moment, that the heir to the throne was just as enchanted by gold as the king was. But Fíli snapped out of it quickly.

Now, the prince hasn’t even glanced at the hoard, hasn’t made any move toward the treasury. Nor, for that matter, has his uncle, which Bilbo takes as a positive sign indeed. Maybe he really was wrong. Maybe Thorin is going to be okay, and that moment with the sword was just a little hiccup. Yes, because that’s how dragon sickness works, isn’t it? It can be shaken off. Thorin was normal by the end of the Battle, and all it took was a confrontation from Dwalin. Maybe seeing his nephews in danger has grounded him somewhat. After all, wasn’t it Fíli this time, and not the dragon, who interrupted Thorin at his most volatile and helped him come back to himself? 

And that changed things. Thorin knew he did something wrong, when he dropped his sword and stared at Bilbo in horror. He was well aware that he’d not been himself the moment before, and guilty for it. There is still hope. 

Either way, they’re all here now, and the Men and Elves will be coming whether Thorin is stable or not. Bilbo will have to come up with a plan for that which does not involve stealing the Arkenstone (bad idea) or using the ring (impossible). Then, he’ll have to try and convince Thorin and the lads to avoid springing the trap that Bilbo alone is expecting Azog to set, which he knows is much easier said than done.

“I’m just going to sit down and think for a moment, if that’s alright with you,” Bilbo says to the company. Really, though, he’s just talking to Thorin. He can’t imagine that anybody else would have any problem with him just sitting and thinking. 

“Fine,” the king says.

Bilbo settles himself down on a rock and tries to work through the same problems that have been bothering him for months. Years, actually. Decades, if he’s honest. Can he prevent the battle of the five armies entirely? No. He cannot stop the Orcs. Not even if he had a functioning Ring of Power, not even if he were fool enough to try and use it, could Bilbo prevent Azog’s attack. But still, he may be able to talk the other powers involved into fighting as one. Bilbo is good at talking. It’s one of his primary skills. 

Will Bard see reason? It’s possible. Will Thranduil see reason? Not unless Bilbo offers him some other vital piece of foreknowledge, and even then, he can’t be certain. Will Thorin see reason? Not in a million years. Back to the drawing board.

“Durin’s beard,” Balin mumbles, and the pain in his voice shakes Bilbo from these selfish thoughts. 

He is, therefore, paying complete attention when the dragon falls. Smaug bucks forward, then jerks back before tumbling into the Long Lake. Bilbo is too far away to make out the arrow in the dragon’s breast, but he knows that it is there. So Bard has killed the beast, earlier than he did the last time, and the third step of Bilbo’s (admittedly shaky) plan is now complete. He has saved countless lives, though it is plain to see that much of the city of Lake-town is still on fire. Bilbo is not naive enough to believe that there were no deaths  or serious injuries at all. 

It’s hard to concern oneself with the future when one’s present is so utterly horrific. Bilbo cannot focus on the impending battle when Lake-town is ablaze before him. Though he should. He really should be stronger than this, enough to recognize that his attentions are needed elsewhere. If he goes into the battle with no plan, then Thorin and the lads will die, just like before. “Yavanna save them,” Bilbo murmurs. The destruction doesn’t look as bad as it did the last time, but it does not look good. 

“Aye, and Mahal as well,” Bofur agrees. “They’ll need all the help they can get.” 

Ori sniffles and wipes frantically at his eyes with the sleeve of his sweater. Bifur offers him a pat on the back and a few words (presumably of comfort) in Khuzdul, but the warrior’s grief is as plain as the scribe’s. They are all affected, and how could they not be, watching the flames leap?

“The family we stayed with,” Fíli’s eyes are wide with pity and compassion, “Do you think they’re alright?” 

“I made sure they were armed before I left,” Bilbo tries to comfort the lad. The last time, of course, Fíli was there with Bard’s family when the dragon arrived, and he helped get them to safety. “And I warned the father about the dragon. He said he might send his children to the Wood Elves for safety.” Actually, Bard never said this, but he didn’t argue much when Bilbo proposed it. And if Bilbo were in the bowman’s position, he’d have happily sent Frodo off to live with Thranduil rather than be traumatized watching his home burn. 

“Arms won’t have helped them much against a dragon,” is Dwalin’s steady reply. “Neither will that bastard who calls himself King of Mirkwood.” Bilbo does not bother to mention that Thranduil has likely never referred to his own home by such a derogatory name. 

“Don’t the Men of the Lake have some sort of alliance with the Elves?” Kíli muses, “Or at least a trading partnership. Maybe the Greenwood can help them.” 

The Greenwood, not Mirkwood. So Tauriel has been teaching him about her home. More likely than not, the exchange of knowledge has been mutual. Bilbo wonders whether Kíli chose to tell Tauriel the stories he grew up on of the splendor of Erebor, or to share his experiences of a childhood spent in relative poverty in the Blue Mountains. He wonders how many hours the two of them spent in those dungeons, separated by the bars of a cell, trading stories about their respective worlds. 

“I don’t think you can expect your lass to drop by anytime soon,” Nori quips, though it’s clear his heart isn’t in it. His attempt to lighten the mood falls flat; nobody laughs. 

“When have Elves ever helped anyone?” Glóin snarls. 

Kíli opens his mouth to protest, but then apparently remembers that it would be very rude to bring up Bilbo’s near-death experience at this juncture. The company is silent for a moment, allowing Bilbo ample time to count their numbers. A chill runs down his spine as it occurs to him that there are only thirteen of them. 

Slowly, dreading the worst, Bilbo turns around. He hopes against hope that he is wrong, that he is only jumping to unfair conclusions and his apprehensions will soon be set to right. But there, as he feared, is Thorin, his back turned to the company and the carnage in Lake-town. He is staring at the Mountain. Oh, this is not good at all. 

The last time, Bilbo left Thorin to his own devices. He didn’t understand the magnitude of all this, didn’t see it as the sign that it was of terrible things to come. He thought, of course Thorin would want to see the Mountain, after so much time away from Erebor. Of course he’d be thinking about the people he’d lost there, the trauma that ruled his life for more than a century. Bilbo was too charitable then, too trusting, even after the incident with the sword. He won’t make the same mistake again. 

Taking his chances, Bilbo decides to approach the king. He tries to make his footsteps as loud as possible to alert Thorin to his presence, but of course, the king is lost to the world, at least until Bilbo puts a hand on his arm. Then he jolts, but doesn’t take his gaze away from Erebor. “Thorin,” Bilbo begins, somewhat hesitant. He doesn’t have any particular desire to be impaled on a sword at this juncture. “Are you alright?” 

“Mhm,” Thorin hums in response. “I have never been better.” 

“Lake-town is burning behind you,” Bilbo points out. He doesn’t like this one bit. He tried to prepare for it, of course, to remind himself amidst even his most wishful of thinking that this was a genuine possibility, that Thorin was more than likely to develop dragon sickness this time just as he did before. But he apparently could not steel himself for the true horror of watching his beloved descend into madness with complete understanding. “Do you not care?”

“No,” Thorin says, “I do not care. The wyrm is dead, and the mountain is mine again.” 

“Those people helped us.” Why is Bilbo even bothering? What does he think, that a gentle touch will be enough to make Thorin return to his senses? “And they have paid dearly for it.” 

Now, Thorin does look at him. “Come here,” the king orders. And it really is an order, with more authority than Bilbo has heard from Thorin in a very long time. That is saying something, and not a particularly cheery something. “Join me.” 

Bilbo should not go along with this. He should turn on his heel and rejoin the company. Perhaps that might coax Thorin away from his present preoccupation. But Bilbo feels ragged after his confrontation with the dragon, and the sight of Lake-town has not helped. He does not want to be reminded of his own failure to prevent a catastrophe. He does not want to be reminded of his own uselessness, his apparent inability to do anything that he set out to do. He was supposed to save Lake-town, and yet it has burned. He was supposed to destroy the ring, and yet it still rests in his pocket. He was supposed to help Thorin, but the king has already started down the path to madness. 

“Okay.” Bilbo steps forward and allows Thorin to position him so that the Burglar’s back is pressed against the king’s chest. There isn’t really much to see in this direction: just the cold stone of the Lonely Mountain, etched with age but otherwise uninteresting. But it feels nice, having Thorin’s arms around him. Despite himself, Bilbo can’t complain about that. 

“Erebor is mine,” Thorin breathes, “All of it is mine.” What a fool Bilbo was, to believe it meant anything that Thorin ceded to his wishes as they were leaving the Mountain! 

Even at the height of his madness, Thorin had moments of compassion. Moments of love, some might call them. A particular instance with an acorn comes to mind. For the Green Lady’s sake, Thorin gave Bilbo a mithril shirt while the dragon sickness gripped him! It was not as though his spirit left his body to be replaced by some wicked creature who cared only for treasure. No, Thorin was still Thorin, even at his darkest moment. Even when he tried to kill Bilbo, still, he cared, underneath it all. And now, he might care more, but that does not mean that he is not a threat. It certainly doesn’t mean he’s entirely well. 

“Ours, you mean,” Bilbo corrects him. He’s referring to the company, but from the way Thorin tightens his grip around Bilbo, it’s possible that the king may have misunderstood. 

“In the morning, we will go back inside,” Thorin informs Bilbo in a gentle murmur. That tone of voice should have no effect on him, but Bilbo is only a Hobbit like any other, and he cannot help but shudder. He wants… no, what he wants matters very little. He cannot afford to be distracted, and he cannot take advantage of Thorin’s current mental state. Bilbo has waited eighty years, and he can wait longer. “I will show you my treasure, and you may take your pick.” 

“Take my pick?” Bilbo doesn’t understand. Last time, Thorin was deeply protective of the entire hoard. He wouldn’t let anybody take anything, although he did bestow a mithril coat upon Bilbo. 

“As you say,” Thorin whispers into Bilbo’s ear. Just what is he trying to do? “It is ours. All of it is ours.”