Actions

Work Header

Five Simple Steps

Chapter 12: Bad Ideas All Around

Notes:

Yikes. Welcome to the first of the dragon sickness chapters! For the foreseeable future, nobody will be doing well, in any way, at all. But please enjoy anyway, and thank you for reading/commenting/leaving kudos!

Chapter Text

Thorin is surrounded by beautiful things. Gold and jewels and gems beyond his wildest imaginings, which are very wild, indeed. Silver, too, and fine woodcraft. Lesser metals, forged with care. Crowns and coins and the most elegant of swords. Fine Dwarven work, yes, supplemented with only the best of imports from other peoples in other lands. And the Arkenstone, as well. Thorin aches to touch it, to hold it in his hands. He wants to find it, needs to find it, must find it and return it to its rightful place above his throne. For the time being, he settles for lifting a handful of golden coins and dropping them again, letting them fall through his fingers one by one. The cool metal against his skin is a comfort; it brings him great joy. Or, it would bring him great joy, if only he had the Arkenstone in his possession. 

“Thorin?” Yet another beautiful thing enters the chamber. Beside Bilbo, the golden trinkets littering the floor appear quite dull. The Hobbit’s eyes are like prisms, his voice like the song of the mountain and his hair more lovely than the ridiculous emerald necklace that Thorin has lately picked up. 

The king tosses the jewelry aside in disgust. It will not do. Not any piece would be good enough for his One. In fact, most pieces fall short of this lofty mark, even those crafted by the Ereborean masters of old. “Come here,” Thorin orders. He wants Bilbo near him. It sets him on edge, the thought of his Hobbit mingling with the rest of the company. They might become covetous, if left to their own devices. 

“I thought you’d be hungry.” Bilbo’s voice is so lovely that Thorin is momentarily unable to parse the words the Hobbit speaks. “I brought you something to eat.” He is always doing this, always trying to feed Thorin. Perhaps it brings the little creature some pleasure to do so, to prove his ability to provide even for a king. It is endearing, if a touch silly, and so Thorin entertains the practice, no matter how annoying it might be coming from anyone else.

“I am not hungry,” Thorin assures him. “Join me, please.” He needs to have Bilbo in his arms, he decides. Perhaps that will sate the ache that has settled in his belly.

It does not. He is pleased when Bilbo settles obediently into his embrace, under his arm, leaving his other hand free to search through the treasure. He can appreciate the Hobbit’s pleasant warmth, the surprising sharpness of his shoulders, the gratifying softness of the rest of him. But it is not enough. Thorin needs all of his treasures together in one place: the hoard, the Hobbit, and the Arkenstone. Only then will he be able to justify concerning himself with such trivial matters as food and drink. 

“You have not been hungry for days,” Bilbo protests. “Please eat just a little. You’ll need your strength for things to come.” What could that mean?

“The Arkenstone cares not whether I have eaten,” Thorin reasons. He only needs to find the jewel, and then he will settle down and do as Bilbo wishes. 

“Nor whether you have slept,” is Bilbo’s dry retort. 

“It will not be long before I find it, ghivashel,” Thorin murmurs in an attempt to soothe Bilbo. He does not like to see his One so agitated, but he cannot for the life of him understand the little creature’s worry. Perhaps Bilbo feels that it is taking Thorin too long to locate the Arkenstone. Perhaps he will lose interest and try to leave if Thorin cannot prove his divine right to the throne. “Do not worry.” 

“I’m very worried,” Bilbo informs Thorin, grabbing modest handfuls of his luxurious fur cloak. “But I couldn’t care less about the Arkenstone.” Before Thorin can argue with him, the Hobbit continues, “I care about you.”

“That is a great honor, indeed.” And Thorin means it. To be more important than the Arkenstone? That is a concept that Thorin cannot comprehend. The Arkenstone is the most valuable thing in Middle Earth, and yet Bilbo places Thorin above it. He hardly seems to notice the lovely things that surround him; he simply steps over them with his eyes trained on Thorin. As it should be. 

“I came to Erebor for you, my dear,” Bilbo reminds him, “Not for the Arkenstone. And you came to give your people back their home.”

“And now they will have it.” It is exquisite, hearing his Hobbit singing his praises. Bilbo may not understand the significance of the Arkenstone, but nobody in their right mind could doubt that he returns Thorin’s feelings. He would not betray his king, would not be unfaithful. He has done everything in his power to bring Thorin closer to his treasure, and now, here he is, dressed in Thorin’s colors, fretting over his king in the most endearing manner. 

The Hobbit has refused the gems he’s been offered, but Thorin cannot fault him for that. He imagines that the Arkenstone would feel just as offended if he tried to cover it in rubies. He wonders absently if the Arkenstone’s touch will feel anything like Bilbo’s, warm and living and full of palpable affection. 

“Please.” There is something strange in Bilbo’s tone, a sliver of pain or doubt that makes no sense to Thorin. “Please, you must rest. Just for a few moments. This is not healthy, Thorin. The Arkenstone is here anyway, isn’t it? And it’s yours already. What does it matter if it’s in your hand or amongst your other treasures? And you’ll be able to look for it faster if you eat, maybe sleep a little.” 

Thorin looks at him, baffled by the Hobbit’s concerned gaze. “You wish to have my company?” 

Is that it, then? Bilbo is jealous of the rest of the treasure. He is jealous of the Arkenstone. He wishes to be the sole recipient of Thorin’s attention, at least for the time being. Of course he would. Thorin cannot fault him for that, either. It is sweet, to be desired so. To be revered, a great king, worthy, now, of such devotion. 

“Yes,” Bilbo breathes out shakily, “Please?” 

“You do not need to beg,” Thorin assures him, voice heavy with longing. Longing for the Arkenstone, yes, but for Bilbo as well. It will be easier when he has them both in the same place. To look upon two such jewels at once would be bliss beyond anything Thorin has ever known. He grows impatient, combing the treasury and finding nothing of any particular value. 

“Then come and rest with me? Just for a moment.” The pleading look in his Hobbit’s eyes is too much to resist. Perhaps Bilbo has a point, after all. Whether the Arkenstone is in his hands or not, it still belongs to Thorin. It is still his, still within his mountain. And he has other treasure to enjoy at the moment. 

“Yes,” Thorin decides, “Yes, I will sit with you. Then you will stay and help me look for the Arkenstone.”

Bilbo swallows. He looks to be on the verge of tears, his eyes swimming as he stares up at Thorin. So it is true, then. He is jealous of the stone. He does not understand that Thorin loves them both equally, each with his whole heart. “As you wish,” the Hobbit breathes with palpable trepidation. “My dearest love.” 

As Bilbo leads him back down the passage that runs to the throne room, Thorin thinks about what kind of gift he might bestow to make his love and loyalty clear to the Hobbit. To keep him in place and protect him from harm, to communicate the sheer extent of Thorin’s devotion. For now, a strong arm around the perplexing creature will have to be enough. 

 

Over the course of the past few days, Bilbo’s successes have been few and far between, but notable nevertheless. He’s gotten Thorin to take more than a couple of meals, which is better than he managed the last time, and though Bilbo doubts that Thorin is capable of finding sleep in his present state, at the very least, he has agreed to lay down beside the Hobbit for a few hours on two separate occasions. It took an awful lot of cajoling and no shortage of vaguely subservient drivel, but Bilbo can endure such things if it means that Thorin eats and rests. 

It’s far worse than last time. Not the sickness itself, necessarily, but the watching of it. Eighty years ago, Bilbo managed to convince himself that Thorin was still the same noble being that he got to know during their time on the road. He genuinely believed that if his tone were sharp enough, if his words were true enough, then the person he’d fallen in love with would blink and shudder and reveal himself. If Bilbo hadn’t thought that, he never would have bothered with the Arkenstone. Which, he supposes, is why this time, he’s left the blasted thing to rot in the depths of the treasury.

Although, one would think that Thorin would have no trouble finding the gem, considering how much time he spends amongst his treasures. When he’s not down there himself, he’s seated on his throne, with Bilbo at his side, waiting for his kin to provide him with his prize. If Bilbo didn’t know any better, he’d be able to delude himself into believing that this is a good sign. Oh, yes, Thorin will allow other people to put their hands on his gold if it means he might get closer to the Arkenstone, but this means very little. Thorin certainly would not allow any of the company to remove anything from the mountain, not even to purchase food or security from attack. 

“Why have they not found it already?” Thorin demands from his position on the throne. He looks so regal there, poised like one of the majestic kings of old. A character from a storybook, better than even Bilbo could have written him. “I have given them more time than is reasonable, and yet it still it is not in my hands.”

“I’m not sure.” He doesn’t bother to ask what it is. He knows well enough already. Bilbo must tread lightly. His feet are sore from standing beside the throne all day, but his priority is keeping the company safe. Perhaps it is wishful thinking, but it seems to Bilbo that he has been able to soothe Thorin with his presence hitherto. Nobody has been screamed at or threatened yet, at least. And with the way Thorin looks at him, it’s clear that any love he might’ve felt prior to entering the mountain is still present in some capacity. “Would you like something to drink?” 

There’s wine and ale aplenty in Erebor. Apparently, the dragon would not touch the stuff, though perhaps that had more to do with Smaug’s inability to access the cellars than with a lack of interest in drink. Regardless, the other rations have run low enough that Bilbo does not have much to offer in the way of snacks, but pouring wine is no trouble.

“Yes,” says Thorin. “Bring me something.” 

Bilbo hates this more than he has hated any other part of the journey. He does not take well to being ordered around, but he knows that Thorin is suspicious and irritable from his illness, and it probably isn’t helped much by the lack of sleep and proper nutrition. Bilbo could try to argue, yes. He did it the last time, and it didn’t work. Thorin attempted to murder Bilbo for it before, and then he died in guilt that could not be assuaged no matter what anyone said to him. Bilbo would not wish that fate upon his worst enemy, and certainly not upon his greatest love. He hates pretending at anything even resembling subservience, and desperately wants to grab Thorin by the shoulders and shake him, but playing along a little bit seems to mean that Thorin’s basic needs are seen to.

Isn’t that better, in the long run? Maybe he’ll be stronger by the time of the battle. Because Bilbo knows that there will be a battle no matter what he does. Even in a perfect world where he could prevent the Elves and Men from attacking, where he could somehow stay Dáin’s hand, where he could talk some sense into Thorin, the orcs would still press forward. Thorin will have to fight sooner or later, whether he charges into battle or the battle charges up to him. They must be all prepared, but Thorin especially. 

So Bilbo pours wine into a golden cup that he would personally prefer to toss over the battlements, never to be seen again. “Here you are, My King.” The sound of his own voice makes him cringe. He should not be indulging Thorin in any of this nonsense. 

The smile that he receives in return is not entirely hollow. Bilbo refuses to allow himself the hope. “Come and sit with me,” Thorin orders. Orders. 

“Where, exactly?” Bilbo pushes, ever so slightly. He doesn’t know what he’s expecting. He knows that no amount of playful prodding will be enough to snap Thorin out of this, but maybe— oh, he doesn’t know. He has no plan. As it happens, plotting is not easy when you’re watching someone you love fall into madness. 

“You may share my throne.” Well, if that isn’t a symbolic gesture, Bilbo doesn’t know what is.

Is this a positive development? Does it mean that Thorin trusts him more than he did the last time? Or simply that he feels more entitled to Bilbo’s time and space than he did eighty years ago? Bilbo wishes there was someone he could ask, but he can’t exactly march up to Balin and demand to know why Thorin is behaving differently than he did on the original timeline. Actually, now that Bilbo thinks about it, the King’s advisor would probably offer him a great deal of insight about just what happens when one allows Elves to rule one’s destiny, and he’d probably be entirely correct. 

“Great,” Bilbo mutters, climbing awkwardly onto the throne. “Surely the consort must have their own throne. Perhaps a smaller one? I wouldn’t mind a proper cushion, either.”

Thorin waves his hand. “My grandmother did not care very much about such matters.” He wraps a possessive arm around Bilbo, pulling him close. Bilbo can feel the way the king’s chest relaxes in response to the touch, and he considers allowing himself to pretend that this is an indicator of Thorin coming back to himself. 

It isn’t. He’s treating the golden cup in his other hand with almost the same reverence. At best, he sees Bilbo as a second Arkenstone, which is a disturbing enough prospect without taking into consideration the fact that when he looks at the Hobbit, Thorin certainly does not see Bilbo. Whatever love exists between them has been muddied significantly by the dragon sickness. Worse than last time, because last time, Bilbo never made the mistake of encouraging Thorin.

“I don’t think I care much about it, either, but I can’t very well sit here while you hold court.” He’s throwing everything at the wall. Perhaps Thorin will snap out of it if he remembers that sooner or later, he is going to have to actually act as king. He’ll have a kingdom to rule, and lots of responsibilities, and no time to worry about shiny stones. 

But if that had worked, then Balin would already have pulled Thorin out of his trance on their first day in the mountain. He’s been delivering lectures about kingly duties since before they arrived in Erebor, and this has not let up with the onset of Thorin’s illness. 

“And why not?” Thorin murmurs, “You are mine, are you not? I can have you here if I wish.”

Bilbo cannot help but roll his eyes. This is Thorin, he reminds himself, And you love him. You’re here to save his life. Telling him to shove it and marching yourself back to the Shire won’t do anybody any good, no matter how tempting it may feel right now. 

Perhaps it’s only Bilbo’s imagination, but he thinks he hears a sudden, sharp intake of breath from the gallery above. He looks around, but sees nothing more than a flash of gold out the corner of his eye. A trick of the light, perhaps, from the torchlight catching on the glint of the treasure. 

“And do I get a say in the matter at all?” He may be treading carefully, but he’s still Bilbo Baggins. He’s not going to abandon the sarcasm entirely, not even in a situation like this. And it’s a nice middle ground between bending completely to Thorin’s whims and demanding to know what His Majesty thinks he’s doing. Not that either of those strategies seems any more effective than the one he’s apparently settled on. “Or is it only up to you?” 

Thorin gently wraps one of Bilbo’s curls around his finger. Bilbo forces himself to find the gesture unsettling. He has watched while Thorin grabbed handfuls of coins and played with them in much the same way. It would be unfair of Bilbo to pretend that there is any genuine romance in this touch. He has no doubt that Thorin loves him, somewhere deep down. But the king is not in his right mind at the moment.

“Of course it is up to me,” Thorin breathes, “I am the King of Erebor. Everything that happens here is up to me, and everything in this mountain is mine.” He follows this insight up with some murmuring in Khuzdul. Bilbo tries to remember the words so he can ask someone to translate them later. That is forbidden, but surely it will be okay if the future consort requests it.

Bilbo kicks himself internally for thinking of himself as the future consort of Erebor. Is he so shallow as to allow himself such fantasies in a situation such as this? Perhaps. But maybe that is just the ticket. “I think I rather have something else in mind,” Bilbo blurts out. This is a risk, he knows it, but he’s starting to feel that every conversation with Thorin is a risk. Antagonize him too much, and Bilbo might be dangled over the battlements by his neck once again. Indulge him too much, and the Valar only know what will happen. 

“Oh?” Thorin continues playing with Bilbo’s hair, and it is distracting for any number of reasons.

But Bilbo pushes forward. This will not work. It couldn’t be so simple. But he must at least try. He wishes he could ask Dwalin and Kíli what they said to help Thorin the first time, but of course, they would not remember things that have not happened to them yet.

“We could find ourselves some nice, cozy rooms,” Bilbo pretends to muse, trying to steady the trembling in his voice, “With our very own kitchen, and I could cook for you. We’d have… a greenhouse, that’s what it’s called, isn’t it? And I’d grow fruits and vegetables and herbs. And a library, and a nice fireplace, and we could read and eat and blow smoke rings all day long. Perhaps we could have the lads over now and again, feed them some pie and make them dust the chandeliers or what have you.” 

“The servants will do our dusting for us, ghivashel,” Thorin assures Bilbo. 

“You’re missing the point, darling,” Bilbo protests, “And I don’t know how I feel about having servants. I like keeping care of my own house.” Someone else would only do it wrong. It’s one thing to dole out chores to rambunctious nephews (Bilbo has plenty of experience with that) but he doesn’t like the thought of leaving someone else to dust and scrub in his place. In fact, he gets many of his best ideas while engaged in idle housework. 

“You should not have to do any work at all,” Thorin declares. “I would rather keep you in a fine place with fine things and not a care to trouble you.”

“And if I happen to find joy in my work?” So much for Bilbo’s gentle fantasy. 

He should have known better than to think that his plan would work. And he didn’t, not really. It’s only that he had a little hope, and now it has been dashed. No, Thorin does not want a peaceful future by Bilbo’s side. He has no interest in cozy rooms or laughing nephews or well-made meals. He cares only for gold, and with his blurred vision he has mistaken Bilbo for a part of his treasure hoard. 

“You would be safe there,” Thorin muses. He does not seem to realize how disturbing this prospect is. 

“Would I?” Bilbo laughs nervously, bordering on hysteria. Did Thorin wish to imprison him last time, as well? If Bilbo had not given away the Arkenstone, is that what would have happened? Is that what’s going to happen this time? Will Bilbo be rewarded for his compassionate care with a life locked away? 

“No one could get to you,” Thorin decides, “No one could dispute my claim upon you.”

“I don’t think anyone is trying to do that, Thorin,” Bilbo replies honestly. “I really don’t.” And he doesn’t care for that phrasing, either. 

“I do not like the way that Balin looks at you.” 

“Balin?” Bilbo echoes, dumbfounded. “You’re jealous of Balin? He’s old enough to be my grandfather! And however you think he’s looking at me, you must be misreading it.” 

“He looks as though he wishes to take you from me,” Thorin resolves. 

Ah. That makes sense. Bilbo can only imagine how horrified poor Balin must be by this situation. After all, Thorin is functionally holding Bilbo hostage while Bilbo tries desperately to wake the king from an endless nightmare. It would be difficult for anyone to watch, but for someone who witnessed Thrór’s descent into madness as well? For someone who swore to watch over Thorin and protect him from this very thing? Bilbo knows that feeling intimately, and he would not recommend it. 

“But it isn’t up to him, or anyone else, where I spend my time.” Bilbo hopes that Thorin will catch the deeper meaning behind these words, though he sincerely doubts it. “I want to stay with you, and that’s that, Thorin. As long as you’ll have me, I’ll be here.” And that must be true, because if Bilbo had any sense, he’d have run away the moment Thorin started clinging to him so closely. But he’s still here, still promising to stay knowing what could happen if he does.

“Yes, you will be,” Thorin agrees. “I will have you for the rest of time.”

Bilbo does not mention the relatively short lives of Hobbits or the fact that Thorin, too, is mortal. He merely sighs. “But it really does sound nice, doesn’t it, making a life together?” 

That’s what Bilbo has wanted, all this time. A marriage between the life he lived with Thorin on the road and the years he spent in Bag End after Thorin was gone. To be with his king, his love, in a happier context. To see Thorin, well-fed, well-rested, and stable. To spend their days relaxing, enjoying one another’s company between their respective undertakings. Oh, yes, they would both be very busy. Bilbo would have his writing, and Thorin would still be king, but could they not make some time for each other? 

“I will find you a comfortable bed,” Thorin decides, “And I will hire the best chefs to cook for you.”

“Oh, really?” This sounds promising. Bilbo fights the hope that blooms within his chest. It isn’t possible, is it? That his daydream would be enough to break such an ancient and all-consuming curse as the one from which poor Thorin suffers? 

“Mhm,” Thorin hums against his neck. The position is intimate, to say the least, and goosebumps rise on Bilbo’s skin. “I will have all of your things imported from the Shire. The family heirlooms, your own little treasures.” This is very promising, indeed, if Thorin is thinking of porcelain cups and Belladonna’s glory box as treasures. “I will find a way to recreate your garden, all of the flowers that you love so much.”

“Will you?” Bilbo grins. Yes, this is the way that it’s supposed to be. His love is enough to drag Thorin from the madness. A seed planted, hope grown. And apparently, Thorin wants this as much as Bilbo does: to build a life together. To live happily and peacefully, to share their unique blend of the Shire and Erebor, two cultures meeting and meshing in their little household. There will be second breakfasts and weapons training and multi-lingual sweet nothings breathed against bare skin, and— 

“Yes. I will bring all these things into the vaults for you, ghivashel. And then you will be safe there, with all that you hold dear.”

As Thorin’s words sink in, Bilbo feels his own chest heave. Of course. It is just more of the same. Thorin is not cured, not any better, not thinking any more clearly or more rationally. He does not wish to build a life together with Bilbo. No, Thorin wishes to cage Bilbo here in Erebor, but he is willing to concede to bringing some things from the Shire to entertain Bilbo during his imprisonment. It would not be an act of love, having Bilbo’s things sent for, furnishing him with a soft bed and good food. It would only be another act of greed.

Bilbo releases a choked sob, mourning the demise of his small hope. He truly believed that Thorin was turning a corner. He allowed himself to dwell in the land of fantasy and for his troubles he has received only pain, only sadness. Bilbo does not know why he expected anything different. 

Thorin wraps his arms around the Hobbit, and it is, unfortunately, very nice. Those strong arms are still a great comfort. That soft, low voice by his ear, muttering endearments in a language that he does not speak, still soothes Bilbo, still grounds him, still makes him feel impossibly close to Thorin. This greedy, jealous, and suspicious creature who wants to lock him away from the world is still the love of Bilbo’s life. Nothing could change that. But he must remind himself to be unsettled, not to melt so easily into this. 

“Do not cry,” Thorin orders very softly. Over the course of the past several days, the king has grown accustomed to having his orders obeyed. He must be taken aback at Bilbo’s lack of compliance, though he does not seem angry. “It will all be over very soon. I will have the Arkenstone, and none will be able to deny my right to rule. Do not fret.” 

Bilbo needs to collect himself, he knows. He can’t waste time feeling sorry for himself, or even feeling sorry for Thorin. He needs to do something about this, but he can do nothing to stay the frustrated tears which stream down his face. 

 

The time continues to pass in the Lonely Mountain. Bilbo continues fretting over Thorin’s increasing madness, despite all orders to the contrary. Things are different this time, yes. The bond between the Burglar and the king is greater now than it was eighty years ago, but no words or actions that Bilbo can muster seem capable of shaking Thorin out of the grip of his sickness. Bilbo has tried everything. Arguing failed, acquiescing fell flat, and even silent sobbing had very little effect. Thorin seems concerned for him, yes, but he does not seem to understand why Bilbo is so agitated. He will not listen to logic or reason.

Bilbo shouldn’t be surprised. He should have known better than to believe, as he apparently did, that love would be an effective cure for dragon sickness. If he’s being honest, the most shocking part of all of this is that Thorin has yet to actually find the Arkenstone. The last time, of course, that was perfectly explicable: Thorin never found the Arkenstone because he did not think to rifle through Bilbo’s pockets. Now, however, Bilbo definitely does not have the stone on his person, which leaves, in his mind, three distinct possibilities. 

The first is that Thorin has actually found the gem, but for reasons entirely his own, he is pretending not to know where it is as a test of loyalty. Perhaps he wishes to see who in the company is devoted enough to him to continue searching indefinitely for a useless rock simply because he desires it. This, admittedly, seems a little far fetched. For one thing, Bilbo doubts that Thorin would be able to stop himself from displaying the Arkenstone if he ever got his hands on it. For another, Thorin does not seem to be operating based on any kind of logic at all, and it seems beyond him at this juncture to orchestrate such a cunning plot. Not to mention that there is no need to test anybody’s loyalty after the quest they’ve all just endured.

The second possibility is that the Arkenstone has hidden itself somehow. Bilbo does not know why the gem would do this, but he’s familiar enough with magic objects to understand that they often have their own minds. It’s perfectly possible that the stone wished only to be found by Bilbo, although he suspects that in that case, he would’ve stumbled upon it again. He’s spent more than his fair share of time combing through the treasury, if only to keep an eye on Thorin. He’d have seen it, then. And he has no reason to believe that the stone has the ability to hide itself in the first place. Surely, if that were the case, and if it were in any way averse to being placed above the throne of Erebor, it would have kept itself safe from discovery in the first place and the whole business would’ve been done with before it even began.

The third possibility, admittedly, the one toward which Bilbo is leaning as an explanation for the stone’s notable absence, is that somebody has picked it up and is keeping it from Thorin for the same reason that Bilbo hid it in his pocket on the first adventure. It would make sense, surely, that others in the company might be disturbed by their king’s behavior. Thorin has been single-minded, snippy, and downright rude, often ignoring everyone but Bilbo for hours, even days, at a time. And much of the attention that he pays to the Hobbit is so tainted by his gold sickness that the conversations are one-sided and nonsensical. It would be upsetting for anybody to observe. 

The real question, Bilbo thinks, is who? Who has the Arkenstone? Thorin seems to believe that Balin is behaving suspiciously, and Bilbo wouldn’t put it past his friend to take the stone. Wasn’t he the one who advised Bilbo against giving it to Thorin in the first place? But Dwalin, too, seems deeply disturbed by Thorin’s behavior, and there is no question that he could overpower the king in a physical contest. Perhaps he has taken it upon himself to guard the stone. Nori has notoriously sticky fingers, and Bilbo finds it difficult to believe that if the Arkenstone were available for the taking, their resident thief would not simply pick it up. Bilbo finds it difficult to believe that Nori would have any interest in keeping the stone for himself, of course, but who knows how any of them are faring in the face of the dragon’s curse?

Glóin rarely leaves the treasury of late, so busy is he picking up the contents of his fourteenth share, and though Óin has spent most of his time in Erebor attempting to recover medical supplies from the old apothecary’s stalls and the half-burnt infirmary, his evenings are passed often at his brother’s side. Ori has been guarding Erebor’s half-ruined library, with the same jealous fervor that Thorin has devoted to the reminder of the treaure. Dori paces often and at length, which could be a sign that he is worried for his king and his brothers just as easily as it could be an indication of guilt. 

Bombur has made it clear on multiple occasions that they are running out of food. Would he take the Arkenstone as a bargaining piece to push Thorin toward some kind of trade deal? Bifur has certainly made himself scarce lately. Could he be hiding something? And Bofur is incredibly observant. Last time, he proved that he was willing to undermine Thorin’s rule when he helped Bilbo sneak away on the eve of battle. He may very well have decided to hold onto the stone until such time as the king could be trusted with it. 

And on the subject of observant people, Fíli was the one to witness Thorin’s display with the sword just before their fight with the dragon. Perhaps he was disturbed by his uncle’s behavior and took it upon himself to guard the Arkenstone. But it would be treasonous for Thorin’s heir to take the stone, as though he was claiming the crown for himself. Would Fíli really be so bold as to commit treason? Probably not, unless his brother’s safety were on the line.

Kíli might do it, though. Bilbo could see that easily. He may not understand the seriousness of the situation, though that stretches the imagination rather painfully. More likely than not, the lad knows this moment to be very grave indeed, though he’d be believed if he said he didn’t. He could hide the stone for everybody’s safety and then pretend at the last minute that he he was merely playing a child’s game of keep-away. Thorin wouldn’t fall for it, Bilbo knows, but Kíli has no reason to believe that his uncle wouldn’t be melted by his antics, per usual. 

No. Bilbo refuses to believe that Kíli has the Arkenstone. That would be a disaster waiting to happen. It’s probably Balin. The old advisor can take care of himself. He’s a quick thinker and he knows Erebor well, not to mention his understanding of dragon sickness. He could easily get away from Thorin if he needed to; he’d know where to go and what to do to ensure that he never ends up held over the battlements. Probably, he’s already destroyed the stone, if it can be destroyed, or hidden it deep within the mountain. He’d never be so foolish as to simply carry it around inside his cloak. When Balin does something, he does it well, and with careful consideration for all possible outcomes. Bilbo trusts him to do what needs to be done, to make the right decision. 

There is little else that he can do. He rarely sees the rest of the company anymore, save for the awkward intervals that they spend reporting to Thorin, while the king keeps Bilbo by his side. Any joviality that was present on the first night, when his friends frolicked and sang and played with tuneless harps like Hobbits underneath the party tree, has melted away in favor of a stern solemnity. Thus far, nobody has dared to attempt a private conversation with Bilbo. Not that he has any privacy for anyone to interrupt in the first place. 

“Master Baggins, can we talk?” 

Bilbo nearly falls off the side of the mountain at the sound of Fíli’s voice. Well, wouldn’t that be lovely. “You scared me,” he scolds. He should not have gotten so wrapped up in his thoughts. There are plenty of threats afoot, and it would not do to trifle with any one of them. “But alright.”  

Fíli shuffles over, looking nervous. The past few days have aged him; that much is obvious from the bags beneath his eyes and the tired set of his formidable shoulders. And yet he looks so very young. He looks very much like Frodo did at Rivendell, before that terrible quest, and that sends a pang to Bilbo’s heart. The sensation is nearly unbearable, and the Hobbit sways, catching himself against the stone ledge. He makes a mental note, in a moment of hysteria, to encourage Thorin to have some proper railings put in once this whole Arkenstone business is over with. At this altitude, safety precautions must be taken, whether they damage the cultural heritage of Erebor or not. 

“Bilbo,” Fíli begins, establishing himself beside Bilbo on the overlook. “Do you think Uncle Thorin has been acting strangely?”

Bilbo can’t help but snort at that question. “Do I think… yes, my boy, yes, I think your uncle has been out of his mind ever since we got here.” 

Not the smartest thing to say, but Fíli asked, and Bilbo is sick of beating around the bush. He spends most of his time thinking strategically about how to help Thorin, speaking deliberately to the king to no avail. The only reason he was able to get out here at all was because he started hyper-ventilating in the treasury after another failed conversation, and Thorin mistook his panic for a want of fresh air. Even then, even thinking that the state of the treasury had put Bilbo into some sort of physical shock, the king was not willing to leave his hoard. 

“I thought so,” Fíli breathes, looking out over the desolation with oddly steely eyes. He is not the same carefree, clever lad who waltzed into Bilbo’s smial all those months ago, but neither is he sprawled lifeless upon the stone below the watchtower on Ravenhill. Bilbo hasn’t seen that soft, playful smile of his since before they arrived at Erebor, but Fíli yet lives, and therefore any damage done is not irrevocable. “My mother warned me that this might happen.”

“Your mother?” Bilbo echoes, though of course, it makes perfect sense. Dís may be the only person in Middle Earth with the understanding and the courage to have spoken openly about the possibility of Thorin’s dragon sickness before he contracted the illness. 

“She was very worried before we set out,” Fíli explains, “She thought often about the treasure. She remembered her grandfather when he had the,” he waves his hand, “The illness. It is gold sickness, isn’t it? That’s what Thorin has.” 

“Yes.” Bilbo won’t lie to any of his friends. It is bad enough that he knew this was coming and did nothing to stop it, bad enough that he was so foolish as to genuinely believe that his affection would be enough to protect Thorin from the curse. Thorin is suffering because, despite having an entire journey to think of a way to help him, Bilbo has failed to do so. The least he can do is tell Fíli the truth. “Dragon sickness compounded by the curse of Durin’s line, I’d guess.” It is the gentlest warning he can give. 

“I thought it was something like… when your mother says that your beard won’t grow unless you eat the crusts of your bread,” Fíli continues, “She didn’t want me to go with Thorin at all, and she seemed on the brink of losing her own mind when Kíli said he was coming along. I just thought she was trying to talk us out of it. You know how parents can be.”

Bilbo considers this. “You couldn’t possibly have known,” he assures the lad, “Thorin isn’t himself now, but… he never had any sign of gold sickness before, when he lived in Erebor. Even if your mother had some idea… well, it was only a small possibility, wasn’t it?” Bilbo regrets not learning more about the history of Erebor, the curse of Durin’s line, and the effects of dragon occupation upon a hoard of gold. It’s only that he didn’t want to know more, in the aftermath of his tragedy. He wanted things to have been different so badly that it took him years to even consider any meditation on the way they actually were. 

“Yes,” Fíli agrees, if a little tenuously. “I just… is there nothing we can do for him? Nothing to reverse it? He is not thinking clearly. He is not ruling, only playing with his coins and jewels all day. We are running out of food, Bilbo.”

“I know.” And Bilbo does know. Despite his best efforts, the provisions from Lake-town are running thin. Even the members of the company who do not require seven meals a day are beginning to suffer the pangs of hunger, and it will only get worse from here. 

“So, what can be done? You spend the most time with him. Is there any sign that it might get better on its own? Has he made any… progress, in the past few days? I have not spoken to him since the night before last.”

Bilbo swallows a lump in his throat at the obvious hope in the lad’s voice. Fíli is clever, brave, and a good leader. He’ll make a fine king some day. Bilbo refuses to entertain the possibility of what might happen on Ravenhill, not now, not when he has so many other things to worry about. He forces it down, deep into his guts, the same way he’s been doing for the past eight decades. Bilbo does not have the option of lingering on what might take place several days hence, because Fíli requires guidance that he won’t find anywhere else. Bilbo may be the only person alive who has seen someone recover from gold sickness, if only very briefly. 

“I don’t think it will stop on its own,” Bilbo says finally, “I think we have to take responsibility and do what we can to help Thorin.”

“He does not listen to you,” Fíli points out. “I’ve seen you two together.” 

He means, of course, that he has been spying, which Bilbo has suspected from the beginning. Thorin may be too wrapped up in his gold to notice when he’s being watched, but Bilbo is not. In fact, he imagines that most of the company has been spying, but it makes sense that Fíli would take it upon himself to do something about what he has witnessed. He is the heir, after all.

He did not intervene last time, but many things were different then. For a start, Thorin was much less attached to Bilbo, much less protective of him. Whether that was because he did not return Bilbo’s feelings or because he did not think that the Hobbit would receive his advances, Bilbo does not know. But, in keeping with Kíli’s warning in Lake-town, Thorin’s mild possessiveness has twisted in on itself since they arrived in Erebor. There is much more to object to this time around. And besides, Fíli witnessed something that nobody else saw on the first adventure.

“That thing with the sword,” Bilbo gestures to encompass the strange interaction. “Thorin wasn’t really going to hurt me.” 

“No,” Fíli agrees, “Not any sooner than he would hurt his crown or his throne or the golden cup he drinks from.”

Bilbo cannot even pretend that isn’t a fair assessment. “It does seem that I’ve become a part of the hoard.” It’s a relief to speak these words aloud, though it does not stop them from weighing on his gut and his heart in equal measure. Why did he expect things to be different? Why did he expect things to be better? Why did he believe that his love would have any meaningful effect on Thorin’s mental state?

“When our people love, we love jealously,” Fíli shares. “And Thorin in particular can be…” He trails off, apparently trusting that Bilbo knows exactly how Thorin can be. “I know Kíli already warned you, but this is… excessive.”

Bilbo snorts. “Oh, is it?” 

“It’s a good thing you don’t speak Khuzdul. Some of what Uncle says to you, if you knew what it meant, you’d be well within your rights to leave Erebor forever.”

“Maybe I would be, but you must know I wouldn’t do that. It’s not really Thorin saying those things, my boy. It’s the sickness.” Bilbo must believe this. In fact, he has clung to this belief for eighty years. Yes, Thorin tried to kill him, but he wouldn’t have done it if he’d been in his right mind. It was only the sickness, the blind greed brought on by proximity to a cursed treasure. “He’ll feel terrible about it when this is all over. I wouldn’t— I will not harm him. Not in any way.” No matter how many lifetimes Bilbo lives, he will never forget the despair in Thorin’s eyes when he learned that it was Bilbo who betrayed him. The Hobbit hopes sincerely never to see such a look again. 

“Not even when he locks you in the treasury?” When. Not if. Bilbo is not sure if Fíli was eavesdropping when Thorin made that threat, or if he simply knows his uncle and understands the situation well enough to read the writing on the wall. 

“Not even then.” It’s not even a question.

Fíli sighs. “I do not wish to be king before my time. I hope— I would hope that Thorin returns to his senses quickly. I cannot— Mahal, I can’t rule this Kingdom. I know he won’t accept a regent. And if he ordered the others to— to do something about it, well… he is still our king. He is mad, but he is our king, and he is my uncle, and…. Bilbo, I don’t know what to do.”

Bilbo doesn’t ask what the prince is talking about. He understands perfectly. If anybody had a right to step in and take the crown from Thorin, it would be Fíli. Bilbo is a little surprised by this turn of events, but clearly, whatever Fíli has witnessed lately, whatever Thorin has been saying to Bilbo, has been enough to push him toward this line of thinking. Bilbo does not know whether it is a good or bad thing that the lad is questioning his loyalty to his uncle now. 

“I don’t think that would help him,” Bilbo says eventually. “I think maybe that might make it worse.”

Last time, Thorin nearly attacked Fíli for disobeying his order to execute Bilbo. If the prince tried to take the Raven Crown, things could very well get bloody. Bilbo doesn’t think that Fíli could kill his uncle, if it came down to that, but he knows that in his madness, Thorin would have no qualms about murdering any member of the company. Even Bilbo is not safe. Thorin would be destroyed by it, once he came back to himself, but he would do it. 

“I know.” Clearly, Fíli has thought things through on his own. Of course he would have. “I don’t know what to do.”

“I don’t either,” Bilbo admits, fighting tears. He must be the strong one now. The lad needs support and guidance, things that his uncle can no longer provide. “Come here, my boy. It’s alright.” These may be empty words, but Bilbo pulls the prince into a hug regardless. It is the least he can do. 

“We’re going to figure this out,” Fíli announces, returning Bilbo’s embrace. He is shaking ever so slightly, and Bilbo wonders who, exactly, the lad is trying to comfort with his optimistic declaration. “It’s going to be fine. We’ll figure something out. We have to, don’t we?” The typically quiet prince is rambling like a Hobbit. “I have no other choice.” 

Bilbo does not know, because he has not been there, but all of a sudden, he can imagine what things have been like for the rest of the company. Fíli has been leading them, hanging on by a thread, presenting a front of regal certainty. Perhaps they expect him to have some sort of plan, some magical work-around for his uncle’s illness which will save them from the coming peril. But Fíli has nothing. None of them have anything in the face of Thorin’s madness.

“What is the meaning of this?” The snarl from the doorway chills Bilbo to his bones.

It is almost the same tone that Thorin used when he banished Bilbo from Erebor the first time around. Fíli releases Bilbo with lightning speed and turns to stare at his uncle in shock and horror. Bilbo has seen the prince wearing that expression only once before, when he was held with a sword at his throat moments prior to his death. Oh, what a fool Bilbo has been! 

Gingerly, he steps away from Fíli. “Thorin,” he greets this person he loves so much, more than Bilbo has ever loved anyone else. More than Bilbo ever will love anyone else. “We were just talking about—“ 

“You think you can put your hands on what is mine?” Thorin all but growls at his nephew, ignoring the Hobbit entirely. 

And Bilbo is trembling, whether with ire or fear he does not know. Yes, this is Thorin, his love. But this is also the dragon sickness, the spirit of Smaug and the horrible burden of Durin’s line all mingled together inside one strong but tired body, wreaking havoc on the king’s great mind. Oh, certainly, Thorin would not behave like this at all, were he well. He’d never raise his sword to any member of his family, were he thinking clearly.

But he is not thinking clearly, and he is not well, and Bilbo knows in the deepest reaches of his writhing guts that unless someone stops him, Thorin will not hesitate to hurt Fíli. All this time, Bilbo has been tip-toeing around it, trying to convince himself that he can love Thorin back to his senses. That at the very least, he can ensure that when the battle comes and the king returns to himself as he did the last time, he will be better fed and better rested than he was when he fell.

But all of that has flown out the window, and Fíli is still staring, wide-eyed, at the horrible, twisted expression on his uncle’s face. Does he notice the hand on the sword? Would he even look for something like that, from the person who helped raise him, his hero, his king? It does not matter. Bilbo’s heart is broken and he is no longer able to hold himself in check. Whatever Tookish part of him concocted this fantasy to begin with takes flight, and the Baggins wakes, shakes himself off, and plants his hands firmly on his ample hips. 

“Don’t be preposterous, Thorin!” Bilbo steps between uncle and nephew. He must look ridiculous, trying to shield a strong Dwarven warrior with his soft little Hobbit body. He does not care. “Have you entirely lost your mind?” Yes. He has. “This is your nephew. Your sister-son. Practically your own child! Do you have any sense left to you at all?”

“He was touching you,” Thorin snarls. “Why have you allowed him to touch you?”

Bilbo is at an utter loss. His mouth opens and closes several times before he says. “Because the poor boy was close to tears fretting about you and that ridiculous rock you’re looking for.” Technically the truth. “And anyway, he’s your kin, and you and I are… well. We are… as we are, aren’t we? Aren’t you glad to know that your family approves of the match? Surely you should be pleased that your nephew treats me as an uncle already.”

“My sister-son,” Thorin mutters. His hand does not leave the pommel of his sword, but he does not step any closer. If he wanted to, he wouldn’t meet much resistance shoving Bilbo out of the way. Would Fíli fight back, in the event of an attack? Against his king? Against his uncle? Probably not. 

“Yes, your sister-son, whom you love very much, when you have your wits about you,” Bilbo reiterates. 

“Uncle,” Fíli breathes, hesitant. All of a sudden, he withdraws a white rock from his pocket. For a moment, Bilbo thinks that it might be the Arkenstone. But no. It is only a regular crystal, round and smooth, with none of the Arkenstone’s awful brilliance. The light catches it, and Bilbo can see that there is a perfectly round hole in the center of the stone. “Do you remember this stone? We found it in that village, I forget the name. You told me that it was a blessing from Mahal, to find one so well-shaped upon the earth. You told me it would bring clarity of mind, so that I would always remember the sort of leader the Maker shaped me to be. I’ve carried it all this time. Do you remember?” 

“I am your king,” Thorin says quietly. 

“But you are also my uncle,” Fíli ventures. Foolishly brave, really, coming from one who is effectively bargaining for his own life. He sets the little rock upon the ledge overlooking the desolation. “You must remember. It was a cloudy day, and Kíli was just learning to walk, so Mum had her hands full with him, and—“

“I am your king!” Thorin roars. Any trace of the flawed but loving uncle has disappeared entirely in the shadow of the mad monarch. 

Grief and terror flash in Fíli’s eyes, and his mouth drops open as words fail him. He has seen his uncle in battle, Bilbo knows. It’s not as though he’s never heard Thorin use such a tone before. But this is likely Fíli’s first time hearing Thorin yell that way at anyone other than a foe. He is taken aback, more a wounded young lad than a warrior prince in this moment. He does not know what to do, and any hope he might’ve had of his uncle’s recovery has surely begun to evaporate at speed. 

Bilbo is the one with the advantage of foresight. The only one, perhaps, who has any idea what’s going on. The only one, certainly, who has any idea of how to get Thorin back to himself. Not that his ideas have proven to be very good hitherto. But still, Bilbo must be the one to try. “You are a good king, Thorin,” Bilbo points out. It is true, or it was true, before this whole Arkenstone business began. “A just king. As I told you in Rivendell, remember? You are not your grandfather. And now you’ve reclaimed Erebor! Don’t throw that away, my love. Don’t do anything you can’t undo.” 

“You are too trusting,” Thorin complains. “Someone has stolen the Arkenstone from me. Someone is keeping it. And yet you would—“ 

“Fíli is loyal to you,” Bilbo says flatly. This, too, is true. If Fíli were not loyal to Thorin, he’d not be waffling about taking the crown from his mad uncle. From a political standpoint, that would surely be the wisest move. Fíli, at least, would do something to prevent his people from starving to death. “Loyal enough to indulge the whims of your silly old consort.” 

“You are not yet my consort, ghivashel,” Thorin breathes. He sounds almost like himself again, but Bilbo knows better now than to be fooled. After all, the ‘real Thorin’ has always been present to some degree within this violent stranger. 

“Oh, well, not yet, I suppose, but I’ve been doing the job since we got here, haven’t I?” Bilbo tries to sound casual. He tries not to sound as though his heart has shattered, tries not to sound as though he hates himself for how manipulative he’s being. But then, what choice does he have? He cannot allow Thorin to harm any member of the company. “Now. Enough of this nonsense. It’s a waste of time, really, with our food stores running out.” He swallows, hoping that this is the right decision, “And the Arkenstone still not found.”

“Yes,” Thorin agrees, finally taking his hand off his sword. He comes forward and drapes an arm around Bilbo’s shoulders in a clear gesture of possession. Bilbo has to remind himself that the king’s mind is still addled by his illness. “Fíli, you should find your brother in the armory. There is much to be done.” The dismissal is pointed, but not as sharp as it could be. And seeing as it’s not a sword to the lad’s throat, Bilbo feels he has averted catastrophe, at least for the time being.

“Back to the throne room, then, my love?” It’s better than the treasury, at least. 

“Mmm,” Thorin hums. “No. I think not. We will look for the Arkenstone ourselves, since my subjects have failed in its recovery thus far.” 

Bilbo doesn’t like the sound of that, but at least Thorin has decided not to murder his own nephew for the apparent crime of accepting Bilbo’s hug. 

“I will go and assist with the restoration of the armory, my king,” Fíli announces, but he continues to stand stock-still. And Bilbo cannot blame him for being in shock, if that is in fact the case. 

“Very well.” Thorin maneuvers Bilbo back toward the darkness of the Mountain. “Come along, my Hobbit.” 

Bilbo spares a glance behind him even as he follows Thorin inside. Fíli stands with his back to the retreating couple, staring out over the desolation once more. He has his right hand on the hilt of his own sword, as though he thinks that Thorin may attack him after all. His left hand rests in his pocket. No doubt he’s clutching that old stone of his, wondering how such a monumental change could lately have overcome the person who gave it to him. Just for a moment, staring out over the battlements with a thoughtful expression and every sign of exhaustion upon his regal face, the prince looks very much like his uncle.