Chapter Text
Thorin still dislikes the plan. If he had his way, Bilbo would stay safely in Erebor, and some other Hobbit would be hired to carry the ring to Mordor. But Thorin understands by now that there is no talking Bilbo out of this. The two of them have arrived at a stalemate: neither of them wishes for the other to go, so neither of them will stop the other from going. The Wizard has made arrangements, calling on the Great Eagles to give them passage to Mount Doom. Legolas, who has proven himself to be much less infuriating than his father, has offered to lead an army of Elves to the gates of Mordor to draw the enemy off and has promised to send an archer on the quest with the ring. What is more, both Óin and Tauriel have agreed that this is medically permissible and that the foolish Elf will not succumb to his wounds in the process. A Mannish warrior has been brought in from Dale, and though the Man’s armor is too large for him and he does not seem to possess the power of speech, Thorin does not suppose that they’ll get anyone better from Bard’s folk at this juncture. At the very least, their alliance with Dale is secure, and the Men of Arda can claim they had a hand in the destruction of their greatest enemy.
“What is this, ghivashel?” Thorin inquires of Bilbo, who has managed to smuggle a tray of food into their chambers.
Not that this isn’t allowed, of course. The king can have whatever he’d like in his own rooms. But he’s still surprised that Bilbo managed to sneak out of bed while he was sleeping, pad down to the kitchen, procure this feast, and slip back into the King’s Chambers, all while Thorin was none the wiser. How safe does he feel beside Bilbo that he can sleep so deeply, even with a new and dangerous quest looming above his head?
“Breakfast,” Bilbo reports, “I’m not going without it, and neither are you, my heart. Eat up.”
“How did you manage this?” Thorin asks, sitting up in bed and accepting the tray. He does not understand why Bilbo would wish to care for him so, after everything that has happened.
After the battle, Bilbo stripped away the layers of secrets in which he has been cloaked for the duration of their acquaintance. He showed Thorin his truest heart, which was damaged long ago, apparently by Thorin’s own hands. Though the king has no memory of this, though his One has assured him on multiple occasions that he bears no responsibility for it, guilt continues to tug at him from all sides. He does not understand why Bilbo would wish to be with him at all, let alone why the Hobbit would bother to spend such time cultivating a relationship with him, being kind and gentle with him, knowing all the while that Thorin would turn cruel and selfish in the end. Bilbo put his own life at risk to save Thorin when he did not have to. He could have protected Fíli and Kíli alone, but he made the active choice to defend Thorin as well.
Bilbo looks at him with warm eyes. “It’s not so difficult to sneak past you when you’re sleeping, and it’s even easer to get into the kitchens without anybody knowing.”
“I’m surprised the kitchens are in any condition for cooking,” Thorin muses, moving over to allow Bilbo space beside him on the bed. “But perhaps Mahal preserved them all these years, knowing you would come and use them some day.”
“Nothing so dramatic as that, I’m sure,” Bilbo laughs. Only one who knows him very well would be able to tell that his mirth is forced. “More that Smaug wouldn’t have known what to do with them, and once the ice chest is full of ice and the oven is hot, it’s easy enough to keep food and put together a good meal. Bombur says the plumbing took a while to sort out, but it’s all working perfectly at the moment. Durin’s folk do not waste time, it seems.”
The meal on the tray before Thorin is simple enough: only a few slices of buttered toast, some fish from the Long Lake, two fried eggs in a porcelain dish, and a few withered brown strips of dried apple. But considering that they are recovering from a nasty battle, in an area where little will grow, on the eve of winter, Bilbo may as well have produced a table laden with fine fare. He has certainly taken care in cutting perfect triangles of toast and artfully arranging the fish and the apples on the plate they’ll both eat from.
“You flatter me,” Thorin informs his beloved between bites of toast. “And you spoil me. How did you get butter?”
Theoretically, the king should be the one making the trade deals that will lead to such unimaginable luxuries. “I told Thranduil where we were going,” Bilbo replies.
“Ah. That explains it, then.” Thorin bites back a dry remark about Thranduil’s evident glee in providing what may turn out to be Thorin’s last meal.
He will defend Bilbo with his life, and he expects the others in their small fellowship to do the same. Surely Gandalf will have imparted this upon the Elven guard and the Mannish warrior. “We really should all be having breakfast together,” Bilbo decides.
“Bard’s Man will not leave his chambers,” Thorin points out flatly. As a general rule, he does not trust Men. He has had far too many bad experiences with them to to believe that they mean him anything but harm, and Bard’s conduct prior to the battle of Five Armies has not disabused him of this notion.
Yes, it is true that Thorin was gold-sick and not in his right mind. Yes, it is true that he succumbed to the poison left by the dragon upon the hoard in conjunction with the curse on Durin’s line. It is also true, however, that Bard held Bilbo against his will overnight, and used the Hobbit as a bargaining chip, as though he were merely a possession of Thorin’s to be ransomed out in exchange for a few gold coins. Thorin will spend the rest of his life repenting for the harm that he did his Hobbit during his days of madness, but what is Bard’s excuse?
“How do you know Bard’s warrior is a fellow?” Bilbo asks, shocking Thorin out of his rumination. “It’s not as though we’ve seen their face. We don’t even know their name.”
Thorin snorts. “Men do not allow their ladies to fight.”
Bilbo looks taken aback. “What?” He comes, after all, from a culture where nobody fights at all. Hobbit lasses probably do not wield weapons any more than do the daughters of Men, but Hobbit lads are no better trained. “But the women of Lake-town have grown up in Smaug’s shadow just the same as their fathers and brothers!”
“Their culture is twisted and backwards,” Thorin announces. “They pick and choose at random who deserves rights and who does not.” He remembers how he was treated in the towns of Men, how plain it was that many of the smiths who talked down to their Dwarven workmates were equally dishonorable in dealing with their wives and daughters.
“I can’t imagine that’s the case with all Men. The Rangers of the North surely do not… Although…” But he trails off, apparently remembering something that contradicts his own argument or else proves Thorin’s point. “Well. I suppose I should’ve known. I’d forgotten all about the White Lady of Rohan, I must say.”
“Rohan?” Thorin is intrigued by this. “I do not know much about the Horse Lords. Have you spent much time in their lands?” He still has much to learn about Bilbo’s other life.
“I haven’t, but a few of my young cousins have,” Bilbo explains, “Or, they will spend time there, I suppose. Or, they would have spent time there, had we not intervened. Goodness, Thorin, I can’t tell you how confusing this whole mess is! Someday, I swear, I’m going to sit down and write it all out, and then you’ll see what a mess I’ve had inside my head all this time!”
“I would read it, if you did,” Thorin purrs.
“I wish I’d been able to bring my book with me,” Bilbo grumbles. For just a moment, Thorin is willing to believe that his Hobbit is very old indeed. “I worked so long and hard on it, too, only for the plot to change and everything else! I suppose it’s for the better, but you know, I was quite proud of how it turned out. And Frodo’s bit at the end was very well done. I think young Sam was hoping to finish it, too, though of course I don’t know how that turned out.”
It is strange, very strange, looking at the lovely young face of his love and knowing that Bilbo is ancient at heart. Bilbo has lived through the painful stretching of his mind on top of the deterioration of his body. From what Thorin understands, that took place rapidly toward the end of Bilbo’s first life. Oh, how he wishes he could have been there to provide comfort for Bilbo in his old age. Thorin, too, would be old by then. But he failed his Hobbit, in the other world. He failed to survive, leaving Bilbo bereft and alone to face untold hardships.
“You can tell me the stories later, if you remember them,” Thorin offers, because he does not know what else to say.
“I do wonder,” Bilbo barrels on as though his king had not spoken, and Thorin is hopelessly endeared. “What happened to my body. Did I just drop dead on the shores of the Grey Havens? I should hope not. Poor Frodo has been through far too much to have to deal with that on top of everything else. But perhaps the world simply dissolved around me, I don’t know. I suppose it depends.”
“Depends?” Thorin echoes, rapt. He loves to watch the working of Bilbo’s mind.
“Have I been sent back in time, or to another world entirely?” Bilbo muses. “Because if I’ve only traveled through time, then I suppose that everything must have.. gone away. Obviously, my being here has changed the future. But if I’ve been taken to another world, then I suppose dear Frodo would be mourning me right now in the undying lands.”
“Poor lad,” Thorin says, entertaining this idea. He would like to know this Frodo someday, though of course, he’ll have to wait for the boy to be born.
“Anyway,” says Bilbo, collecting himself, “I do wish we could all have breakfast together. I suppose we should have invited Gandalf, at least. And Tauriel.”
Thorin does not understand why the Captain of Mirkwood was chosen for this task. Were he in Legolas’s position, he would not send one of his own kin on such an errand. But perhaps it will be good for Thorin to spend more time with Tauriel. She may soon be joining his family, after all, or trying to.
“I believe she is with Kíli now,” Thorin growls. He still does not understand why his nephew is courting an Elf. Especially now that Kíli has proven his valor in battle, he could have his choice among any dam or fellow from any of the great Dwarven kingdoms. But he seems devoted to Tauriel, which makes Thorin wonder. If he himself was forged to love a Hobbit, could not Mahal have crafted Kíli to love an Elf?
“You can’t have expected anything else to happen, seeing them on Ravenhill,” Bilbo points out, “And in the infirmary! I imagine we’ll have a wedding to look forward to in no time.”
“I hope not.” Thorin is aware of how petulant he sounds.
“You still dislike her?”
“What was the Captain of the Guard of Mirkwood doing when the dragon took our home from us?”
“I imagine she was following the orders of her king, who could have her executed for disobedience,” Bilbo retorts. He is always in the mood to argue, for which Thorin is very grateful. He enjoys their verbal sparring matches, though he’d prefer it if his own rhetorical sword were a bit sharper in this instance. “Unlike at the last battle, when she and Legolas risked exile to help us on Ravenhill. There’s a fair chance Kíli wouldn’t be here to get married to anyone if she hadn’t intervened, and I won’t have you dragging her good name through the mud because you don’t like her employer. I expect you to be civil to her on the journey, and I expect you to behave yourself and dance with her at the engagement party.”
“Dance with her?” Thorin is pleased to discover that Bilbo has remembered how he likes his eggs. The yolks have not been broken, and they collect in golden splendor at the bottom of the little bowl. Thorin gladly uses the toast (of which there seems to be no shortage) to mop them up. “You are not familiar with the customs of Dwarven courtship.”
“I am not throwing an engagement party where the two families don’t dance together! And I’ll tell Kíli the same thing if he tries to kick up a fuss about dancing with Thranduil.”
That gets Thorin to laugh out loud, though he does not believe for a moment that Bilbo is anything but serious. In all likelihood, he really will expect poor Kíli to participate in some sort of traditional Hobbit line dance involving the Elven King as the adoptive father of his intended. “Yes, you should tell him about that. He may decide the courtship isn’t worth it after all.” Not that Thorin believes for a moment that Thranduil would indulge Bilbo by agreeing to participate.
He is more concerned with what this means for their own future. Will Bilbo refuse to marry Thorin until the entire Line of Durin has shared a dance with the entire Baggins clan? If that’s the case, then arrangements should be made to get them all to the Shire. Best to do that soon, so that Dís and the first caravan from the Blue Mountains can join them on the journey home.
Bilbo huffs. “If the courtship isn’t worth a few moments arm-in-arm with the Woodland King, it’s just infatuation, not love, anyway. I did let Thranduil kidnap me twice for your sake, you know. That never happened on my first adventure.”
“I wasn’t aware that you had any say in the matter of being kidnapped,” Thorin snarls. He still is not pleased with Thranduil and Bard for holding Bilbo against his will.
“I didn’t have to go into the throne room with you in Mirkwood, and I certainly didn’t have to leave the Mountain just before the battle,” Bilbo reasons, “And I’d do both of those things again if I got another chance. Which, Yavanna willing, I will not. Twice is quite enough, I think.”
“It is an honor to be chosen twice by you,” Thorin says. “Were our places reversed, I would choose you a hundredfold.”
“You’re being dramatic again,” Bilbo protests, “Who else would I choose? I keep telling you, you’re the only one for me, Thorin Oakenshield. I decided that a long time ago, and I don’t intend to change my mind now.”
“And how very glad I am of that.” For a moment, Thorin considers leaving it there. He certainly has no right to ask Bilbo for anything more. He would let his One determine the course of their courtship. That is only right, considering all that he has put Bilbo through. But Thorin is greedy, and he has spent the past several months pushing down the desperate wanting that has been clawing at his guts. Deeper-rooted than the fleeting desire to possess a shiny stone, though the need is much less heavy, much less painful. “May I kiss you?”
Bilbo gapes at him. “Of course!” He blurts out. Thorin begins to lean in, clenching his fists in the sheets to hide his trembling fingers, but then Bilbo stops him. “Wait!”
Thorin pauses and watches in wonder as Bilbo transfers the breakfast tray to the bedside table. “Okay, alright. I’m ready now. Go ahead.”
And Thorin cannot help but smile. Yes, this is what he wants. This is better than any treasure hoard, better than any crown, better than anything in the world. “Are you sure you wouldn’t rather wait until after breakfast?”
“You’d better not tease me,” Bilbo scolds, though the fond smile upon his lips rather betrays him.
Thorin knows that he does not deserve such fondness. He certainly does not deserve the second chance that he has apparently been given, unbeknownst to him. No matter what he might do, Thorin is certain that he will never for a moment deserve Bilbo’s love. But it’s plain that he has it, whether he deserves it or not, and he will do everything in his power to become worthy.
“Of course not,” Thorin breathes, cupping Bilbo’s face in his hands.
These hands, which have done so much damage. These hands, which pointed a sword at Bilbo, which clutched at the ghost of the Arkenstone. Which, in another world, were laid upon the Hobbit in anger. These hands which failed to slay Azog the Defiler, leaving the task to Thorin’s sister-sons. These hands which are capable of bringing pain and disappointment can also bring pleasure and comfort. Bilbo leans into the touch, despite what he said about teasing, and meets Thorin’s gaze, unwavering.
Thorin leans in and kisses him softly, gently, sweetly. He kisses Bilbo with reverence, worshipfully. He knows he will never deserve this. But he also knows that this is what Bilbo wants, that this is what makes him happy, that for whatever reason, he continues to return Thorin’s feelings. Perhaps, Thorin thinks, in an unavoidable moment of darkness, it is only the ring that makes Bilbo love Thorin. It is only the foul magic that makes him wish to stay with one who hurt him so? What if the enemy wants Bilbo in Erebor for his own nebulous, but surely nefarious, purposes?
Bilbo deepens the kiss, pulling Thorin impossibly closer, getting his tongue involved. They are both clumsy at this, lacking in practice, and Thorin knows that he was wrong to doubt his Burglar. He would not have minded, knowing that there were others, after him. He would not have understood the impulse, being of a race that loves only once, but he would have understood the principle. He would rather see Bilbo happy than anything else, and after how Thorin apparently treated him in this other world, he knows he would have forfeited any claim he could once have made to the Hobbit’s heart.
But it is plain to Thorin as Bilbo kisses him that the Hobbit never took another lover. When Bilbo finally pulls away, breathless and panting, Thorin finds himself babbling in Khuzdul, saying things he’d never thought to voice. Telling Bilbo that he loves him over and over again, that he is sorry, that he is afraid. That he would not choose this, if given the chance to decide. That he wishes there were anything to do but take his love to Mordor.
Bilbo only sighs, cuddling Thorin close. “It’s alright, darling,” he says, as though he understands the words.
Perhaps he does. He had eighty years to learn Khuzdul, after all, though it seems he spent those years in the Shire, locked away in silent grief. And Thorin cannot blame him. He cannot imagine what it would be like, to watch his boys fall in battle. Though Thorin does not believe himself to be worthy of the same level of grief, he knows what the bond between Ones is like. He does not believe that he could live on without Bilbo. He does not believe that he could do it for eight decades. How strong his Hobbit is, how brave.
“It is alright,” Thorin agrees. He will not err again, not with Bilbo to guide him. He can be vigilant, attentive. He can do everything that must be done.
He cannot take the ring to Mordor. He cannot even look upon it, does not trust himself in the face of the temptation. But Thorin must help Bilbo. That is not even a question.
Bilbo and Thorin spend a lovely morning together, not taking about the quest. They’ve gotten very good at not talking about things over the course of their journey together, after all. They spent several months ignoring their feelings for one another, or refusing to express them, at least. Bilbo does not think that he ever told anybody aloud that he loved Thorin until they were in Mirkwood for the second time, and that probably doesn’t count, because he was far from his right mind. They say it a few times, laying side-by-side in the king’s bed. They share a few chaste kisses, and a few kisses that could not be called chaste by any stretch of the imagination.
And then it is time to set out again. Four Eagles await to bear them to Mount Doom. “I wish I’d remembered how Frodo described it,” Bilbo mutters. “He didn’t give much detail in his account. I think he was half-senseless by the time they got there.”
“But that was a different time,” Thorin murmurs in response. They have not told Tauriel or the unnamed Mannish warrior about Bilbo’s other life or his foreknowledge, which has become admittedly limited in recent days. After all, nothing that he remembers about those weeks of grief following the battle applies very well to the inception of this new quest. “And the ring was stronger than it is now. Has the weight of it changed?”
“No.” This much Bilbo can be sure of.
When he sneaked out of Thorin’s chambers this morning, he did not merely set about preparing breakfast. He also practiced casting the ring into the stove, over and over again, burning his fingers more than once as he picked it out. When Thorin called attention to this, because Bilbo could only distract him for so long with kisses and food, Bilbo only shrugged, reporting that the wounds were superficial, anyway, and therefore it did not really matter how he acquired them. This had not dissuaded Thorin from having him seen to by Óin, who was annoyed, to say the least, at having to take time away from the battle-wounded to look at a ‘wee mark on the sodding consort,’ as the healer put it whilst muttering to himself.
A normal ring would come away burning hot from the embers of a stove. The One Ring should be plenty cold after spending time in any fire. As it happens, the ring is somewhere in the middle, warm to the touch, but not as hot as it should be. Bilbo does not know whether the damage done by the dragon fire is permanent, but it seems to be holding at this juncture. Of course, that could all be a clever trick. Wouldn’t it be just perfect to lure Bilbo to Mount Doom, to put him and his fellows in grave danger, and then snatch the rug out from under him? He wouldn’t put it past this tricky little ring. Maybe it’s only taken away the invisibility to punish Bilbo for trying to destroy it. Maybe it’s not calling out to Thorin because it wishes to lull Bilbo into a false sense of security, and in the hour of their greatest need, the ring will awaken and poison Thorin’s mind.
If he tried to kill Bilbo, the Hobbit would not fight back. He would let it happen. He could not harm Thorin, not even for the good of Middle Earth. Anyone else, he thinks he could bring himself to stab, if the fate of the world depended on it. But not Thorin.
Is that Bilbo’s own thinking, or is it the influence of the ring? “It does not call to me,” Thorin assures him. “When I cannot see it, I feel nothing at all.”
“And when you can see it?” Bilbo is not so foolish as to believe that the ring has been completely disarmed. Probably, it knows his plan, and it is saving its depleted energy for the very last moment.
“Then it is like any other piece of gold.” This is a familiar refrain. But Thorin has not explained to Bilbo the depth of feeling gold evokes from him, so the Hobbit cannot possibly understand. All he has to compare it to is his former longing for the ring, which is significantly diminished now that the wretched thing and its wicked master have both been weakened by time and magic.
Significantly, but not entirely. He still feels odd about parting with it, and he cannot help but wonder whether this is truly necessary. After all, it’s not as though the ring is going to trouble anybody any time soon. It was stronger before, and Bilbo lived with it for years before it started to show an effect! And even still, he was able to part with it. Why destroy it now? Why jeopardize the happy life he’s begun to build with Thorin?
But that’s a simple question with a simple answer. For Frodo. Bilbo will do this all, and gladly, for his nephew’s sake.
“We should go,” Tauriel advises, “While we have the daylight.” In truth, Bilbo was so distracted by his worry for Thorin’s ability to truly overcome the dragon sickness (not to mention his own ability to stand up to the influence of the ring) that he altogether forgot about their other three traveling companions. Some ring-bearer he is. Frodo would never have made such an oversight.
“Yes,” Gandalf agrees, “We must make haste, and enjoy the daylight while we have it.”
“It will be dark in Mordor,” Bilbo agrees, suddenly remembering Frodo’s stories of that horrid place. He drifted in and out, when they were told to him, falling asleep or into a daze so many times that his poor nephew had to recite the same harrowing details over and over again.
How much did he leave out, for Bilbo’s sake? How much did he hide, so that his beloved uncle would never know of Frodo’s pain? And how much did he omit for his own wellbeing, so that he did not have to tell the same awful, aching story so many times to a sleeping, aged Hobbit who could barely remember where or when he was, who kept asking for his missing ring?
“Will the Eagles still be able to fly without light?” Tauriel asks. “How will they navigate?”
“These are not the sparrows of the Greenwood,” Gandalf informs her brusquely, “But the Eagles of Manwë, They need no light to navigate, though of course they prefer it.”
The members of the company will not be pleased when they discover that Bilbo and Thorin left without saying goodbye. Kíli will likely be equally upset with Tauriel. But they could not afford delays or further requests to accompany their fellowship, and Bilbo is eager to have this errand done. So he and Thorin climb onto the back of the same Eagle. The others find an Eagle each. Bilbo tries to ask for the bird’s name, more out of politeness than anything else, but he is snubbed. Or, perhaps only the King of the Eagles speaks Westron. That, too, is a possibility. Bilbo allows himself, for just a moment, to be distracted from his terror and guilt by musing about the language of Eagles, of all birds, actually, and whether it might be possible to learn such speech.
The decision to mount the same Eagle was one on which Thorin refused to compromise.He and Bilbo will ride into Mordor together, and they will not be parted, even when logic and reason would dictate that they should be. Besides, as Tauriel pointed out to Bilbo, with steely-eyed practicality, they would be easiest to defend if they were both in the same place. The forces of Mordor would likely aim to attack the King who just defeated their armies in battle just as much as the Ring-bearer. Which, as the Hobbit cannot stop reminding himself, is Frodo’s title, not Bilbo’s.
Still, it grounds Bilbo to be held about the waist, to have Thorin clinging to his back as they sail over unfamiliar lands. Could it really be as easy as all this? “You are distracted,” Thorin observes.
“Yes,” Bilbo admits.
“Will you not tell me what you are thinking about?” In this position, it is ever-so-easy for the king to simply lean over and murmur into Bilbo’s ear. Whether he knows what he is doing or is completely oblivious to the effect that he has on his Hobbit, Bilbo is not certain. That is, perhaps, a conversation to have at a later date, when they are not sailing into mortal peril.
Bilbo considers lying. It would certainly set Thorin’s mind at ease to do so. But he cannot bring himself to that point. If Bilbo is to die, which he may very well be, he will do it with a clean conscious. “What if the ring is only tricking me, only pretending to be weak to force my guard down? What if it tries to make me hurt you, like it did with Frodo? I nearly killed him, Thorin. I would have killed him, if I’d been able to, and I had not carried the ring or even seen it for nearly two decades by then.”
“Tell me about him,” Thorin orders, rather than trying to assure Bilbo that the ring will do no such thing. He must understand that there are no guarantees in that arena. By riding on the back of this Eagle with Bilbo, Thorin is risking being thrown to his death, should his lover turn on him by the malice of the ring. But then, Thorin is strong. His arms are a prison from which Bilbo cannot escape, which feels more comforting than smothering when it means that Bilbo cannot be used as a weapon of the enemy to harm the one he loves. Of course, if the ring gets ahold of Thorin, then he could easily throw Bilbo to his death, but surely one of the others would intervene in that case. “Your nephew.”
Bilbo sighs. “Frodo is a right menace,” he decides, not worrying at all about the proper tense to use when discussing someone yet to be born who manages, despite this, to be an intimate of nearly half a century. “Not… well, not like your boys. He’s much quieter than they are, at least. But he has a way of looking very contrite, especially when he knows he’s done something wrong. I’ll tell you, once, he broke my favorite cookie jar trying to get it off the high shelf in the larder. This was before he came to stay with me, mind, so I didn’t know how easily he could make that face. I thought he was terribly sorry! I ended up baking more cookies just to calm him down, which, of course, is exactly what he wanted. And his mother was no help at all! Primula found it very funny, how easily her lad could manipulate me. Which is hardly fair at all! I did make him sweep up the mess he made, at least. It’s not as though he had me bending to his every whim.”
“He sounds exactly like my boys,” Thorin breathes. “I can imagine the trouble he made for you when he was small. What was he like when he grew up?”
“He’s very skilled with maps, making them and reading them,” Bilbo continues, “Better than I ever was, that’s for certain. Though he’s lucky he’s got Sam, or else I don’t know what he’d do out in the garden. Frodo nearly killed my hydrangeas, the last time I let him do the weeding, but thankfully, Sam stopped him just in time. The lad always meant well, of course, but his eye is better for foraging than for gardening, if you know what I mean.”
“I do not.”
“Oh, he’s just much better at remembering different types of wild plants and mushrooms than he is at fussy work in the garden,” Bilbo elaborates, “Just a little quirk, nothing too terrible. Most Hobbits have a little of some, a bit of the other, though I’m not much for foraging. I’d say he got it from the other side of the family, but he’s my cousin on both sides, so it can’t be that. Though those Brandybuck cousins of his were always taking him with them to steal from poor Farmer Maggot, so maybe he just had more practice with the harvesting than the cultivating, I don’t know. It’s formative, what you learn in the garden at a young age.”
“And what did you learn, when you were a pebble?” Thorin’s voice is low and soft, enticing despite the horror of their situation.
It’s obvious what Thorin is doing. He’s trying to draw Bilbo out, to induce the Hobbit to talk and to think about things other than the ring. To prove to him that the ring does not have the power to control Bilbo’s mind. Perhaps, also, to distract him from the changes they are seeing in the landscape below them and the peril toward which they fly.
It’s surprisingly effective. Bilbo talks at length about raised plots and stepping stones, about cleaning up the edges of the walkway and different types of grass. He speaks about perennials and annuals and the nuisance made by rabbits.
The days pass; the Eagles stop on high rocks to rest themselves, and the company eats and sleeps. Tauriel and Gandalf talk amongst themselves, though both seem content to be quiet, and the Mannish warrior retreats, apparently disinterested in making conversation with any other member of the fellowship. Bilbo has his theories about the Man, ranging from muteness to bigotry. But Bilbo and Thorin huddle together, wrapped in conversation, making up for lost time.
Bilbo makes certain to inform Thorin about every detail of the eighty years he spent alone. He talks at length about the Shire fairs, the young Hobbits who hailed him as a great storyteller until they grew up and decided that Bilbo was rather odd, actually, and perhaps no longer worth their time. He speaks of Erebor, his late journey there and all that he learned, of the years he spent in Rivendell amongst the Elves. And Thorin speaks in return, divulging secret years of his life to Bilbo.
Bilbo never hoped to know so much about the exile of the Ereborean. Thorin tells stories of his brother, Frerin, who was killed in battle, and of his father and grandfather when both were sane. He speaks of smithing, of his nephews’ youth, of his own desperate attempts to provide for his people and his family. At night, they push their bedrolls together and hold one another close. Though they do not make a point of ignoring the other members of their party, all seem content to allow Bilbo and Thorin a bit of time and space to themselves.
A heavy feeling of dread begins to surround Bilbo. He worries that it may be caused by the ring itself, and not by the gravity of his task. But then, they have entered Mordor, and to camp here is not safe for anyone. Not even Eagles, not even Elves or Wizards. The Mannish warrior, still quiet, huddles in on himself and trembles in the evenings. Tauriel and Gandalf both sleep with their eyes open. When Bilbo is on watch, he observes Thorin pretending to sleep for the sake of his Hobbit. When Thorin is on watch, Bilbo feigns slumber in turn. That is only polite.
Near the end of their journey, Bilbo tells Thorin about the acorn that he took from Beorn’s garden the first time around, and about how he didn’t bother with that on this trip because he has no intention of returning to the Shire.
“You will stay with me, then, when this is over?” Thorin inquires, pressing his forehead to Bilbo’s shoulder.
“Of course!” Bilbo can’t believe that’s even a question in Thorin’s mind. “Now that I have you, I’m not leaving unless you ask me to.”
“I would never ask that,” Thorin assures him, “But what about Frodo?”
That’s not something Bilbo had considered, truth be told. He’s been so wrapped up in protecting Frodo from the ring that he hadn’t even considered the lad’s more immediate future. “Well, obviously, I’ll warn Drogo and Primula about boating on the Brandywine, though I doubt either of them will listen to me. And if they don’t heed my warning, and things turn out exactly the same, though I ask Yavanna to protect my cousins, of course, then I suppose it will be Frodo’s choice whether to stay in Brandy Hall or come join us in Erebor.”
“He is welcome, if he does choose to join us,” Thorin assures Bilbo, “And of course we can maintain a correspondence if he does not.”
In all honesty, Bilbo has been so preoccupied with repeating his adventure exactly the same way, and then with fixing the battle and destroying the ring, that he hasn’t bothered to think much about what will come after. He can imagine, of course, that he will stay in Erebor with Thorin and become consort, but he has no clue what that might entail. Dáin had no queen when Bilbo visited him before the council of Elrond, and even if he had, it would have been a bit strange to ask her about her daily duties. That would not have occurred to Bilbo, for he would not have thought that he’d ever wind up in this situation.
“I’m sure he’ll get all sorts of odd looks in the Shire,” Bilbo mutters. “Receiving ravens from the Consort of Erebor? The poor lad will be badgered by relatives, day in and day out.”
“Not to mention the letters he’ll be getting from the King of Erebor,” Thorin replies smoothly, pulling Bilbo impossibly closer. As they get closer to their destination, the ring becomes undeniably heavier on the chain around Bilbo’s neck. It’s by no means excruciating, and it’s not as though the ring is speaking to him, but Bilbo wouldn’t describe the sensation as particularly comfortable. For now, however, Thorin’s presence at his back feels grounding, a firm resistance against the other pull he feels. “It is as you said, ghivashel. Frodo is your kin, which makes him mine as well.”
“We’ll have to go to back to the Shire for his birth,” Bilbo muses. “Drogo and Primula will be over the moon! Well, Prim will be over the moon, and Drogo will probably grow a few grey hairs, having you lot all in the dining room, and I don’t blame him, but I already know the lads will want to come, too.”
“Oh, yes,” Thorin agrees. “Are you going to tell them about—“
“Absolutely not.” Bilbo nips that idea in the bud right away. “I’ll not make them mourn when neither of them has any cause to. As far as I’m concerned, it never happened.”
There is a palpable shift in the air as they cross into Mordor. The enemy’s eye may not be capable of watching them or commanding the Nazgul at present, thanks to the ministrations of Lady Galadriel, but that does not mean that their party is safe. Legolas is still running a diversionary campaign to draw off the orcs, and even so, Tauriel takes out a few archers on the cliffs. Not that she needs to, with the Eagles maneuvering so well. The Mannish warrior still has yet to say a word to any of their fellowship and does not seem particularly skilled with the bow, but Gandalf has been very liberal with his use of his staff.
Thorin hums. “Then we won’t tell them,” he says. “We will bring them to the Shire and pretend we don’t know the exact date of your nephew’s birth.”
Bilbo purses his lips. “That’s a difficult secret for me to keep, Your Majesty.” He can only really bring himself to use Thorin’s proper title in jest. “Since Frodo’s birthday is the same as mine.”
“Mahal below, I do not even know when that is.” Thorin sounds so very taken aback that Bilbo cannot help but giggle. He hopes they aren’t bothering their Eagle too much with all this stilted flirtation, but then, the great bird did agree to carry Bilbo and Thorin together. He had to have had some idea of what he was in for.
Bilbo decides to play coy. “I’m sure you’ll figure it out when you wake up to cake and fireworks and me giving you a present.”
“Why would you give me a present on your own birthday?”
“And I’d forgotten about your silly Dwarven birthday customs, too!” Bilbo can’t help but exclaim. “To receive presents on one’s birthday, at one’s very birthday party! I can’t believe that slipped my mind.”
“We will have to have a long discussion when we return to Erebor,” Thorin decides, “About our cultures. To avoid a misunderstanding.”
Bilbo blinks. “You know, the last time, when you gave me the mithril armor, I didn’t know what you were doing.”
“What?”
“I didn’t know it was a courtship gift,” Bilbo explains. “I thought it was just a pretty shirt. I had no idea it was worth so much money, either, or I probably never would’ve worn it. And I guess it just seemed so obvious to everyone else that they never bothered to explain it to me. All those years, it was sitting in the Mathom House down in Michel-Delving when it could easily have purchased the whole Shire. Apparently, Gimli was absolutely beside himself when Frodo showed it to him in Moria, and no wonder, finding out his king had proposed marriage to a Hobbit and nobody had ever bothered to tell the lad.”
Thorin breathes out a laugh, and it is the most beautiful sound that has ever reached Bilbo’s ears. This moment is worth the trip to Mordor, worth all the hardships of both of Bilbo’s journeys and maybe even worth the time he spent stretched thin by the influence of the Ring. Bilbo decides that he’d endure all those trials over again, harrowing as they may be, just to listen to that lovely laugh. Which is very stupid of him, but he’s besotted, so he’s got to cut himself some slack.
They spend one night camped in Mordor. Bilbo thought, before the journey began, that it would be the worst evening of his life. He believed, naively, that nothing could be worse than bedding down in the shadow of Mount Doom, with orcs on all sides. “The Eagles grow weary,” Gandalf explains simply, confirming Bilbo’s suspicion that he can communicate somehow with the great birds.
“This is dangerous,” Thorin complains, as though it had just now occurred to him.
“Of course it’s dangerous,” Bilbo snaps, “We’re in Mordor. But we’d better not tire out our birds before we get to the main event. They may need to make a quick extraction.”
The Mannish warrior, in his ill-fitting armor, curls in on himself as always, trembling from head to toe. Tauriel strokes the feathers on her Eagle’s neck and murmurs to the bird in quiet Sindarin, too low for any of the others to hear. Gandalf takes out his pipe and chews on the end of it, not bothering to pack or light it. They do not dare to make a fire.
“The enemy’s forces are few, surely,” Bilbo says, leaning back against the warmth of Thorin, all around him. “Lady Galadriel has driven him back, and Dáin’s people took out most of the Gundabad orcs.”
“There have been archers on the cliffs,” Tauriel points out, “Legolas will do what he can to draw out those forces which remain, but we must remain vigilant.”
Bilbo does not think that he has ever seen an Elf in such distress. Tauriel does not require proper sleep, yet her cloudy eyes suggest a lack of it. Her hands do not tremble, but they twitch periodically. Her brilliant red hair is uncombed, and she looks somewhat disheveled. Bilbo never learned what happened to her, at the end of his first adventure. He was not close with her, then, and he was selfish in his grief, retreating into himself rather than offering comfort to anyone else.
“You’re right,” Bilbo tells her.
They are tired, all of them, and haggard. Bilbo feels Thorin’s shuddering breath against his back as the king manages his terror. He does not like to see Bilbo in danger, and this is the greatest danger of all. This entire trip, Thorin has offered security to Bilbo. Now, he falters. Because he is not the great king of legend, after all, not one of the Dwarven monarchs carved from Erebor’s green marble, but a living, breathing being, vital, inhaling the smog of Mordor and the glory of a second chance. Bilbo squeezes his hand.
There is no merry-making, no song and little talk. They eat rations, and they sip their water sparingly. At their last camp, there was a little stream from which drinking water could be taken, and Bilbo drank greedily. Here, though, there is nothing. No drinking water, no game for Tauriel to hunt, and no sound but the menacing wind.
And yet this is not the worst night of Bilbo’s life, not by a long shot. The worst nights of Bilbo’s life came in Rivendell, when he was foggy and hazy and exhausted yet unable to sleep. The worst nights of Bilbo’s life came in quick succession, one after another, each day blending into the next as Frodo walked across Arda with Bilbo’s burden strung around his neck. Poor lad. Poor, poor, lad. Being here is not half as bad as knowing that Frodo was here, thin and wan and pained. Not knowing whether his nephew even lived, or his cousins, or dear Sam.
Nothing could be worse than that. Death, Bilbo thinks, is better than uncertainty. He knows how to mourn his dead, and he has done it before. He knows how to push those feelings away, to soothe himself with poetry and maps and food. He knows how to turn his grief into fine stories, fine songs. But he has never known what to do with uncertainty.
“Mister Baggins,” Tauriel says, “You are not well.”
And Bilbo wishes to scream at her, to tell her that of course he isn’t well! How could he ever be well, knowing that this dreadful, harrowing journey is not half as terrible as the one that Frodo went on? How could he ever be well, leaning against the warm, healthy body of his lover, knowing that Frodo and Sam each had to watch while the other slowly starved? Knowing that they drank dirty water and evaded orcs at every turn and battled an arachnid far worse than any Mirkwood spider? Knowing that they were pursued by Gollum all the while, because Bilbo was so stupid, so trusting, so arrogant as to give the fiend his name?
How could Bilbo ever be well, knowing that he was personally responsible for every moment of Frodo’s suffering? He returned to Rivendell thin and frail. So thin and so frail, in fact, that Bilbo was not told of his arrival, was not allowed to see him for days in case the lad should die, for fear that the shock would do Bilbo in as well.
“I’m alright, lass,” he says, instead of all that. “Or, I will be, once this business with the ring is taken care of.”
Nobody sleeps. They stay awake, all five of them, and the ring makes Bilbo’s back hurt. They do not even put out bedrolls. Bilbo and Thorin lean against one another, aware that this might be their last night together in this life but aware just as keenly that their surroundings prevent them from doing anything about it. Still, Bilbo reasons, they both knew what they were signing up for.
The next day, they approach Mount Doom. It is horrible, imposing even against the perpetual dark of Mordor. “The Eagles will leave us here,” Gandalf reports as they swoop down to land. “They will circle above to retrieve us, of course, but they cannot go inside.”
“Of course not,” Bilbo grumbles. “That would be too easy.”
Perhaps he’s not entitled to his complaints. After all, this entire journey has been remarkably easy, and Bilbo knows precisely why: his trademark luck is not luck after all but the deliberate hand of the Valar. He was sent here on purpose, and here specifically, as well. There is something unique about this precise time, just after the Battle of the Five Armies, just after Lady Galadriel has driven the enemy out of Dol Goldur, just after Bilbo has doused the One Ring with dragon fire. It will not be a stroll in the garden, by any means, but it will be easier for Bilbo than it was for Frodo. Or so he tells himself, at least.
The Eagles set them down at the entrance to the mountain. “It would’ve been much more convenient if he’d built an opening at the top,” Bilbo complains. He’s decided that he is, actually, entitled to do so by virtue of the fact that he’s presently in the process of saving the world.
“And make his forge vulnerable to the weather?” Thorin asks dryly. “Any smith could tell you what a bad idea that would be.”
“It’s all just very inconvenient,” Bilbo protests, but he sees Thorin’s wisdom.
Gandalf is delivered to the mountain next, and then Tauriel. However, a gust of wind overtakes the Eagle carrying the Mannish warrior, who is deposited shakily, falling sideways onto the ground with a rather loud curse.
That does not sound like the voice of a great warrior. In fact, it is almost certainly the voice of a very young person, and what’s worse, it sounds familiar. Bilbo is amazed, in fact, that this voice has been hitherto unheard. But then, it isn’t so surprising. Bilbo and Thorin have spent the entire journey wrapped up in one another, and Gandalf and Tauriel have been muttering amongst themselves, when not sleeping or on watch. What time they do not spend resting, they spend flying into the wind. It would be easy to miss the sound of a voice in all of that.
“You are full of surprises indeed, Princess Sigrid of Dale,” Gandalf proclaims, as if he is not disturbed in the slightest by the fact that Bard’s eldest daughter managed to slip unnoticed into their fellowship and thereby into Mordor.
Thorin and Tauriel, thankfully, seem to have more sense. “This is no place for a child,” Thorin proclaims. “You should not have come.”
He is clenching his fists so tightly that his nails will surely leave marks on his palms. No doubt he is reliving the harrowing ordeal of talking his nephews out of accompanying him on this particular quest. Bilbo is in a similar position, forcibly reminding himself that this is worse than Frodo’s situation, because although the Ring-Bearer will always be Bilbo’s baby, he was, in fact, a fully grown Hobbit of a very respectable age when he undertook this quest.
“You must return to Dale at once,” Tauriel agrees, “Your father will be worried about you.”
“I am no child!” Sigrid protests, springing to her feet as only the young can do after such a tumble and removing her helmet. She certainly looks like a child, with her cheeks flushed and her eyes round.
“How many winters have you seen?” Thorin inquires gently.
“Sixteen, Your Majesty,” Sigrid holds her ground.
“Then you are a child,” Tauriel informs her, tight and clipped as every Woodland Guard should be. “You have no training that would help us here. You are only putting yourself in danger. I would not have you guard the gate as planned when you cannot have spent more than a fortnight with that sword.”
“But none of my people have spent more than a fortnight with their swords,” Sigrid protests, “I am just as good as any other fighter from Lake-town.” This implies that she fought in the Battle, which Bilbo hopes is untrue. He does not like the thought of one so young taking up a blade.
“The Elf speaks true.” The fact that these words have left Thorin’s lips is a testament to the dire situation. He whirls on Gandalf next. “Did you know about this?”
“I did not,” Gandalf replies, though who knows whether he’s telling the truth?
Bilbo closes his eyes and opens them again. “How did we not figure this out sooner?”
Sigrid shrugs. “I don’t know, but here I am.”
“Were you not asked to find a warrior from among your people to accompany us on our quest?” Thorin demands. That had all sounded like a very good idea when Kíli proposed it, but at the moment, Bilbo can’t see the point. Better to have only the four of them and leave this child safe at home.
“There are no warriors among my people,” Sigrid replies, “And my father would not have risked any if there were. If I’d told my brother, he’d have felt it was his duty to come as the future King of Dale, and he has yet to see his fourteenth birthday. I had no choice.”
“You mean to say that your father does not even know where you are?” Bilbo demands, hands on hips. “He must be worried sick! Gandalf, we can’t have this!” He does not bother to mention that the fire mountain is probably going to erupt when he throws the ring inside. After all, the Wizard knows this.
But perhaps the Valar have smiled upon Bilbo again this day. It does give him an opening for a rather ingenious plan. “You may yet need me,” Gandalf informs the Hobbit. Clearly he has made the same calculations. “I cannot leave, not even to deliver Sigrid safe to her father.”
“It’s not as though he thinks I’m missing,” Sigrid replies. Her voice does not waver. Of course, it wouldn’t. She has spent her entire life under the threat of Smaug, under the oppressive regime of the Master of Lake-town. She has battled orcs, apparently, and seen her home destroyed by dragon fire, just as Thorin has. She does not fear kings or Wizards or any other source of authority. Bard, Bilbo thinks, will be proud, once the steam stops coming out of his ears. “I’m supposed to be getting lessons in diplomacy from Prince Kíli.”
“Lessons in—“ Bilbo stammers, “From— oh, by the Lady, lass, that’s preposterous! And your father believed that?”
“She could find a worse teacher,” Tauriel muses.
“Yes, I suppose that’s true,” Bilbo concedes. Though, truly, if Sigrid wants lessons in diplomacy, she’d be better off asking her own father. “But if she was going to lie to Bard, she may as well have made up something believable!”
“All sound ideas that I’m sure young Sigrid will consider for next time,” Gandalf muses. He may be trying to sound lighthearted, but he has subtly positioned himself behind Sigrid, as though to be certain that nothing will attack her from the back.
She is brave, yes, and clever, and in her time, Bilbo has no doubt that she will be great at this sort of thing. Perhaps she’ll serve as general and advisor to her brother the king. Truthfully, Bilbo doesn’t understand why Sigrid herself won’t ascend to the throne, but then, he won’t pretend to have spent much time studying Mannish lines of succession. Either way, Sigrid is yet a child, and this is no place for her now.
“Tauriel should take the Princess home,” Thorin decides.
“No.” The ring is the heaviest burden Bilbo has ever carried. It was not so bad on the journey. His trials have not been half of what Frodo had to go through. But now, just as he suspected, the ring is pulling out all the stops. It is making one last ditch effort, from what little power remains to it, to keep itself safe. Who knows what will happen when Bilbo tries to throw it into the fire? Well, aside from the eruption that he knows is coming. “You should go, Thorin.”
“What?” Thorin demands. “No. I should not. My place is by your side, and—“
Bilbo cuts him off with a shaky exhale. “If Bard finds out what has happened, he’ll already be in Erebor, harassing poor Fíli.”
“My nephew can handle himself,” Thorin protests, “I would not have made him my regent if he couldn’t.”
“We’ve just had a war, and I don’t want another,” Bilbo reasons, “And there’s more to it than that.” He doesn’t want to use this argument, but he will if it means getting Thorin away from the Mountain. Away from the ring, and what it might turn Bilbo into. In truth, Bilbo cannot forget the moment when he lashed out at Frodo, the feeling of utter rage engendered by the ring. He would have killed his own nephew. What will he do if Thorin tries to prod him into casting off the ring?
Bilbo is prepared for the possibility that he will need to be pushed into the fire. He is prepared for the possibility that he will fall to the faint influence of the ring, that he will not be able to part with it. But he is not prepared to take Thorin down with him. Oh, yes, he knows that his king would rather die by Bilbo’s side, and that he is being entirely selfish by sending him away. But then, Bilbo also knows that Thorin would not push him into the fire, even for the good of Middle Earth. He would not allow Tauriel or Gandalf to do so either.
“What more is there?” Thorin asks. “When my only place is by your side, what more is there?”
“Thorin,” Bilbo breathes, “You are only just recovered from Dragon sickness. You say that the ring calls to you no more than any other piece of gold, but you will know as well as I do that it has gotten stronger in its native land. It is tugging on me like a weight, even now. It does not want to be destroyed, and it will fight. Can you resist its pull? Could you resist a thousand Arkenstones?”
Bilbo is being deeply unfair. “You are stronger than I am, ghivashel.” Thorin brushes his thumb over Bilbo’s cheek, tender and soft. They will not call this goodbye. Perhaps Thorin does not know that it may be. Bilbo doubts that he’d be able to get his love to leave him here if he thought that Bilbo’s death was a legitimate possibility. After all, Bilbo has neglected to mention the bit about the eruption and the bit where he may need to be pushed into the fire.
It might be easier to return to Erebor with Thorin now. They could rule together and be happy and the ring would not be a problem for eighty years. And after eighty years together with Thorin, Bilbo would have lived a better life than he could ever have imagined. Would it really be so bad to just give the ring over to its master, then, after such a long and comfortable peace? It could prolong Bilbo’s life, so that Thorin would not have to watch him die. They could go together into the afterlife, as Bilbo had wanted to do all along. Middle Earth would be no concern of theirs, after they had left it.
“It is trying to manipulate me even now,” Bilbo admits. “It would use you against me. It would bend both of us to its will and we would each be weaker for the threat to the other. The ring knows how painful it is for us to be parted, and it will take advantage of that if it can. You must return to Erebor with Princess Sigrid and ease her father’s fears.”
“How can I leave you in this place?” Thorin asks softly.
Bilbo is fighting tears. Every fibre of his being wants so desperately to go with Thorin now. The bond between them is so great. Could they not share the power of the ring? And it is so weak now, anyway. So very harmless. Why risk himself? Why die, why devastate Thorin, when they could just as easily go home? The home that Bilbo has fought for all this time. The life that Bilbo was promised by the meddling Lady of Lorien.
“I came back to you once,” Bilbo points out, “Across time and against all odds.”
“More than once,” Thorin reminds him. “Did you forget about the battle?”
Bilbo’s laugh is soggy and tearful. “I will come back to you again.” Even if only in the afterlife. Middle Earth must be saved. Frodo must be saved. That is more important than a lifetime of joy for Bilbo and Thorin. These few days together were enough, and even if his mind slips away from him when he walks through that door, Bilbo will take comfort now in the knowledge that Thorin will be safe.
Bilbo leans up and plants a gentle kiss on Thorin’s lips. If it is to be their last kiss, then it will be a sweet one. Soft and loving. A promise of more to come, whether anything is forthcoming or not. “For the road,” Bilbo explains, in response to Thorin’s stunned expression when he pulls away. “I love you.”
“And I love you,” Thorin replies, pressing his forehead to Bilbo’s. They stay like that for an eternity that lasts only a few seconds. At least if Bilbo dies, Thorin will know that he is loved. “Which is why I cannot leave you.”
“Thorin—“
“Did you not follow me on my quest?” Thorin inquires, ignoring Bilbo’s protests and smoothing a hand over the back of his messy hair. Bilbo has been resting on the ground for days now, and he did not exactly bring a comb along. “When all hope was lost, did you not stay by my side? When I became a monster—“
“You were never a monster,” Bilbo argues. “But that is different. This—“
“I will not leave you.” Thorin speaks firmly. “Let the Wizard go with the princess. He will see her safe to Dale and handle the fallout with her father.”
“No,” Bilbo argues in vain. “Absolutely not. I won’t let you do this.” He is aware that he is throwing a tantrum, and aware, despite the painful tugging of the ring, that they have an audience for this conversation. No doubt the others are studiously looking away, ignoring Bilbo’s ridiculous display at the gates of Mount Doom. “I just saved your life, Thorin. I’m not letting you die.”
“There is no life for me without you, ghivashel.”
“That’s a very silly thing to say! You have your Kingdom, your nephews, the rest of the company—“
“I will not abandon you to this fate. If you wanted a quiet, gentle lover who would roll over and allow this madness, you should not have chosen to wed a Son of Durin.” That, Bilbo cannot argue with. He did know that Thorin was very stubborn when agreeing to court him.
“Thorin,” Bilbo tries one last argument. “I may not be able to cast the ring off. I may die. I may need— I may need to be pushed.”
“No.” Thorin grits his teeth. “It will not come to that.”
Bilbo glances in Tauriel’s direction. Of course she is listening to their conversation. Even if Elves did not have some of the keenest ears in Middle Earth, Bilbo and Thorin are yelling so loudly that they have probably woken every fell beast in Mordor. No doubt the Nazgul will not need their master to command them when they have only to follow the sound of shouting to find their quarry. Which is precisely what the ring wants.
The Elf nods, and they arrive at a silent agreement. Thorin will not push Bilbo into the fires of Mount Doom. Not unless his mind is so twisted that he seeks to take the ring for himself, in which case they will have other problems on their hands. But Tauriel will act as needed. She will push Bilbo if it is the only way to see the ring destroyed. Bilbo raises his eyebrows, in what he hopes is an instruction to protect Thorin at all costs. Though he is not sure if the Captain understands.
“The mountain will erupt when the ring meets the fires,” Bilbo warns, “It will be dangerous.”
“My body was made to withstand heat,” Thorin points out, “I might shield you. And then the Eagles will bear us away.”
It occurs to Bilbo that he has no choice but to allow this. He has to let Thorin come with him, or they will die of exposure, arguing on the face of this mountain. He should have known better than to believe that Thorin would ever leave him to his fate. “I love you,” he says again, “Even if I tell you otherwise in there.”
“I am the other half of your soul,” the king reminds him. “I would know your true heart no matter how the enemy spoke through you. But it will not come to that. You are stronger than this ring.”
Bilbo cannot help but laugh. “Oh, don’t tell me that you actually believe that! Stronger than the ring? No wonder you want to put a throne under me, if that’s what you think!”
Gandalf clears his throat. “I think it best if Princess Sigrid and I be going now,” the Wizard decides. Apparently, the decision was never in Bilbo’s hands to begin with.
“Farewell,” Thorin murmurs. But he does not even look at the Wizard as he reaches for Bilbo’s hand. “Let us get this over with.”
“Ah, easy for you to say,” Bilbo grumbles. “Goodbye Gandalf. Goodbye Sigrid.”
The Princess shakes her head at Bilbo. “Do not say it like that, Mister Baggins. You will be back in Erebor soon.”
“And I imagine you will be stuck in Dale for the foreseeable future,” Bilbo replies. He can imagine how he would have reacted if Frodo had attempted to sneak out on a dangerous quest while still a tween, and it does not bode well for the Princess. Bard will be furious.
“Probably,” Sigrid admits, head held high. “I will bring my father news of your safe arrival. And I will speak to your nephew as well, Your Majesty.”
“Very well,” Thorin says, though Bilbo can hear a note of wry amusement in his voice. Even in this moment of terror, knowing what he’s about to walk into, Thorin is clearly not sure how to feel about the idea of Sigrid conspiring in any way with such seasoned schemers as Fíli and Kíli. The three of them will get on like a smial on fire.
“Farewell,” Gandalf says, placing a heavy, meaningful hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. This is much better than the alternative, and Bilbo can see that in the Wizard’s eyes. He looks troubled, yes, but not terrified.
Perhaps Bilbo may die. But unlike Frodo, he understood the magnitude of the risk from the beginning, and it was his decision to make. Frodo was forced to bear the ring by circumstances beyond his control. Someone had to do it, and Frodo was the one who had inherited that burden. But Bilbo could have chosen not to do this. He and Thorin and Tauriel and even young Sigrid knew what peril awaited them when they left Erebor. And still they chose to come, for the sake of Middle Earth. Even if the very worst happens, it will not be for nothing. Bilbo will die sooner than fail, and his death, he knows, will almost certainly result in his success.
Tauriel moves to stand beside Bilbo and Thorin. The three of them watch as the Princess and the Wizard depart. “Let us go,” she decides. “We must make haste. I do not like this place.”
“Oh, don’t you?” Bilbo snaps, but he sees her point. The ring is heavy around his neck indeed, and Thorin’s grip on his hand does not do much to ease the burden. Bilbo is not confident in his ability to do this, and he would really prefer it if at least he could be certain in the knowledge that Thorin was safe. But that, it seems, is not to be.
“Whatever happens,” Thorin mutters, “We will be together in the Maker’s Halls.”
“The Valar will not begrudge us that for saving Middle Earth, I suppose,” says Bilbo. “I hope they let Tauriel in as well.”
The Elf snorts. “I do not think even Lord Aulë would allow such a thing.”
Bilbo takes a decisive step toward the entrance to the mountain. “We will not be finding out,” he lies. Thorin, at least, has the decency not to argue with this.
Bilbo and Thorin walk into the mountain on the narrow path, with Tauriel following behind. It is every bit as horrible as Sam and Frodo told him it would be, a thin strip of stone over a rushing river of fire. The ring is like an oliphaunt around his neck. He should have stayed in Erebor. He should have taken his crown. He should go back and do that now. He could use the ring. He could— no. The ring is useless. Bilbo made it useless. He took away its power when he cast it off before.
The ring is weak. The ring is nothing. The ring is just a shiny bauble. No more than any other piece of gold, as Thorin said, and he was absolutely correct. The ring is nothing.
The ring is everything. Its power will return, if Bilbo only gives it time. Bilbo will be forgiven for his mistake. See, it is already getting stronger. It could not have spoken to him this way a week ago. If he only waits, he can use the ring to his advantage. He can make the entire world bow to him. Nobody will be locking Bilbo in any treasury now, that’s for sure. Nobody will be calling him Mad Baggins now, not if he’s got the ring on. Nobody will be hurting Frodo now.
But nobody ever hurt young Frodo worse than the ring did. This ridiculous, evil piece of metal did irreparable damage to Bilbo’s beloved nephew. It twisted his mind and took advantage of his every fear, his every thought. It tortured him for months on end and made him want to end his life. Bilbo is overcome with rage. How dare the ring try to sweet-talk him, try to use Frodo for its own salvation once again?
Bilbo Baggins has cast off this ring twice before, and both times it was much stronger than it is now. He was able to give it up, to give it to another, and to let the other live. He lashed out at Frodo, yes, but that was only once, and afterwards, Bilbo was able to keep himself in check. Oh, he longed for the precious, yes, how he longed for the precious, but his love for his nephew was greater than his longing. Drogo and Primula died when Frodo was very young. Bilbo was his father from that point forward. Nobody ever used that word, of course, but Frodo was Bilbo’s adopted heir. Even before Frodo came to live in Bag End, Bilbo was at Brandy Hall at least two nights a week while the lad was recovering. Bilbo was the one who bandaged Frodo’s bruises and scrapes, the one who sang to him when he woke up screaming in the middle of the night. Bilbo was the one who told Frodo stories of loss, who proved to him that a person could recover from having one’s entire world torn away.
Bilbo has a responsibility. Not just to Middle Earth, but to Frodo. To his child. That’s what this is, isn’t it? The last time, Bilbo failed.
He failed as a friend, and Fíli and Kíli were killed upon Ravenhill. He failed as a partner, and Thorin died not knowing how loved he was. Bilbo failed as a resident of the Shire, and his homeland was invaded because of his carelessness in dealing with Gollum. But most of all, Bilbo failed as a parent. He failed to protect Frodo. He allowed his child to travel to Mordor with the One Ring around his neck, to be traumatized, to nearly die, because Bilbo himself was too foolish to realize what he had in his possession. He trusted others too much to make his decisions for him, to know better than he did, to have a plan better than his own. And it cost Frodo his happiness, and nearly his life.
Before, Bilbo could be forgiven. He had not understood, had not known. He could not have gotten to Ravenhill five minutes faster. He was running as fast as he could, pushing his body beyond its limits. Fíli and Kíli should never have split up inside the watchtower, and they should both have known that. Indeed, Fíli chose to forge on alone, likely aware that he would die but hoping that perhaps his brother might live. His miscalculation and Kíli’s decision to avenge him do not truly rest on Bilbo’s shoulders. They were not children, after all, but trained warriors defending their reclaimed home.
Thorin never should have sent his nephews to scout alone, and he never should have rushed off to challenge Azog with no support. He was careless, angry, grieving. His thoughts were scattered, his mind still recovering from the weight of dragon sickness and his body much depleted from weeks of scant food and little sleep. He was overcome with battle rage, and Bilbo knows now that had he been awake and present, he could not have prevented Thorin from fighting Azog.
Frodo could have been selfish and refused the Ring. It could have been any of them, Sam or Merry or Pippin, and the story would have been the same. But it was Frodo, brave Frodo, who would never have turned down his duty, would never have allowed another to suffer on his behalf. Brave, kind, selfless Frodo, who tried to go to Mordor alone, and would have done, if not for Sam.
All these people Bilbo loves made their own choices, and all of them suffered for it while Bilbo watched, helpless. But now, he is not helpless. Bilbo has cast the ring off twice before. He can do it again.
Weak, the ring hisses. But it may as well be taking about itself. It has not managed a single word until now. Oh, certainly, it may get stronger, but now? Right now, the ring is barely more than a bauble. A bauble that harmed little Frodo. Sweet, funny, adventurous little Frodo, who once stared up at Bilbo with shining eyes, seeking comfort and protection. Who will one day look again to Bilbo the same way.
“You will not harm my nephew,” Bilbo informs the ring as he throws it into the fire.
Thorin has to stop him from jumping in after it, though Bilbo doesn’t know why. He doesn’t want the ring. How could he want such a thing, with strong Dwarven arms wrapped around him and a scratchy beard pressed into his neck? The contact is steadying. Bilbo wonders if Frodo would have experienced something similar, if perhaps Sam would have been the one to drag him back from the precipice. “You have done it, ghivashel,” Thorin murmurs, “You have done it.”
But Bilbo cannot take credit for this. After all, even in his first life, Bilbo Baggins was the only creature ever to cast off the One Ring. It was no great feat for him, not so much to withstand. If he could get rid of it at its full power, even in the Shire, it does make a certain level of sense that he could toss it away here in Mordor when it is so weak. He had good friends at his back to help him, anyway.
The only reason Bilbo couldn’t have done this before was his own ignorance, his own cowardice, his own refusal to trust others with such sensitive information. It occurs to him, belatedly, that never, in all his life, has he been as plainly truthful with anyone as he was with Thorin when he opened up about his other life. That was all it took for Bilbo. But Thorin has only just recovered from dragon sickness. Who knows what he’d have done a week ago, in the presence of the ring?
“You have done it,” Bilbo breathes, “You have withstood—“
“We have withstood,” Thorin takes Bilbo’s correction one step further. “We have withstood the ultimate temptation.Nothing could be worse, but we have done it. We are… we are worthy now of Erebor’s throne.”
He may be saying we, but Bilbo knows what Thorin means. Ever since he watched Fíli cast off the Arkenstone, Thorin has questioned his own right to rule. He has not believed himself deserving of the crown. Now that he has watched the One Ring fall, has stopped Bilbo from falling along with it, Thorin is finally confident that he can rule Erebor as well as his nephew could.
“We do not have time for this,” Tauriel announces, ushering the couple out of the mountain as the first spurts of fire begin to come up.
They run, then, the three of them, until they are outside and there is nowhere left to go to and the fire of the mountain is lapping at their heels.The weight that is lifted from Bilbo feels significantly lighter than the one that he remembers losing the last time the ring was destroyed. But Bilbo was so much older then, and more frail by any estimation. Now he is young and healthy and he registers it very little before the events of the day catch up to him and all he can do is lay there on the Eagle’s back. That’s step five taken care of, then. Bilbo has done everything that he set out to do.
