Actions

Work Header

Five Simple Steps

Chapter 15: Days of Conversation

Notes:

There's a lot of talking in this chapter, so buckle up. Thanks for all the comments and kudos, as always, and thanks for reading!

Chapter Text

 

Thorin’s body is trembling from head to foot, his thoughts racing and his breath coming quickly in erratic pants. He cannot believe that it is finally over. He has reclaimed Erebor. Azog the Defiler is dead, and his pack of fiends with him. Bilbo Baggins is alive, even after having been slashed across the gut by the orc and thrown several meters in the process. Not that this is a very big surprise, once Thorin is able to think about the matter logically. He knew, after all, that Bilbo was wearing mithril armor. But something at the very core of Thorin was unable to move past the sight of his One flying through the air, landing in a heavy heap upon the icy ground. The battle faded around Thorin and the Hobbit grew brighter, drawing him in with mumbled nonsense that Thorin could not parse. 

Thorin would have died, in that moment, and he would not have cared in the slightest. There would have been no life for him without Bilbo, not anymore. No way for him to go on without his One, the only person who could draw him out of dragon sickness, the only person with the courage to contradict him openly in his most dangerous state. Perhaps the Hobbit simply did not understand the level of threat that Thorin posed. There must not be any similar affliction among his own people. What is there in the Shire to merit such disgusting greed? 

“You’re alright,” Bilbo assures Thorin, reaching up to touch his face with one quaking hand. Bilbo’s fingers are so soft, with not a scar to speak of and only a few callouses in testament to a life spent reading, writing, cooking and gardening. “You’re alive.” 

“Yes.” It takes Thorin a moment to register that Bilbo must have been mourning him already, must have seen Azog approaching while Thorin was senseless with worry. That odd mumbling must have been Bilbo’s attempt to get Thorin to take up his swords and battle the pale orc, but Thorin would not have been able to do so without knowing that Bilbo was safe. “You should not have jumped in front of me.” He grabs Bilbo’s hand and kisses it, pressing his lips to the knuckles one by one. “You should never risk yourself for my sake again.”

“We’ve had this conversation twice before, Thorin,” Bilbo breathes. Then his voice solidifies. “Don’t be ridiculous. If you’re in danger, of course I’m going to protect you. I’m as good as a shield with my mithril on.” To prove his point, the Hobbit tries to sit up. He winces with the effort, abandons the idea, and lays back down. “Though I don’t suppose it protects much against bruising.” 

“There must be some way to re-engineer the design so that it does,” Thorin muses. If he were sensible, he would perhaps not be thinking of designing new armor for Bilbo with the corpse of his greatest enemy laying behind him, but if he were sensible, he would have killed the creature himself for harming his One. 

“The one time you don’t charge into battle, I swear,” Bilbo grumbles, apparently thinking along the same lines. “By the Green Lady, Thorin, you scared me half to death! I don’t know what I would’ve done if… no, it doesn’t matter. We’re both alive. I suppose we have the lads to thank for that.”

And if there were any words to force Thorin back to his senses, Bilbo has just uttered them. It feels as though Thorin spent the past several minutes submerged underwater and has finally just come up for air. The world clarifies around him, and Bilbo is no longer the center of it. There are others here as well. 

“My sister-sons.” They were the ones to slay Azog the Defiler, were they not? They were the ones to save Thorin’s life and, more importantly, Bilbo’s. Thorin has been so preoccupied with his One until now that little else has settled in his mind. 

“You should speak to them,” Bilbo counsels. “I’ll be okay, but…” He trails off.

Thorin looks over his shoulder, attempting to see what has left his Hobbit at such a loss for words. There is Kíli, sitting upon the cold ground. He appears to be engaged in a rather intimate conversation with the Elf Maiden, who sits too close to him, her slender hand braced on his shoulder. It is clear to Thorin that his nephew is wounded, but judging by the grin on the lad’s face, he is less concerned with his injuries than he is with the chance to pass more time with the Woodland guard. Thorin swallows his instinctive distaste and decides that his sister-son is in good hands. At the very least, the Elf will prevent Kíli from straining whatever hurts he has managed to accrue. 

“I’m fine, I swear,” Kíli is telling the Elf, “Just a twisted ankle, that’s all. You must see to Legolas first.” 

“That is not a twisted ankle,” the Elven prince argues, still clutching at his side. His tunic is drenched in blood, and sitting up clearly requires great effort on his part. “You’ve broken something.”

“And you’ve been stabbed,” Kíli retorts rightfully. 

Tauriel rolls her eyes. “Be still, both of you,” she orders, “And be quiet. You know I cannot work with all this chatter.” 

Thorin watches in awe as his beloved nephew actually shuts up. Perhaps this Tauriel is not as bad as he originally thought. She is still an Elf, though, and still too old for Kíli, but Thorin can trouble himself with such things later. 

Next, of course, Thorin sees Azog. The orc is dead. There is no malice left in those cruel eyes, and a large puddle of blood seeps from two rather impressive stab wounds: the first in the side and the second in the chest. It will take three warriors at least to move the pale orc off of Orcrist, upon which Azog fell with his complete weight, and when they do, Thorin thinks he will allow his sister-son to keep the blade. After all, it was Kíli, not Thorin, who used the ancient sword to slay the greatest foe their line has known since Durin’s Bane. Regardless, Thorin has no trouble ripping Bilbo’s little Sting out of the enemy’s corpse. 

“Here you are, Ghivashel.” He hands Bilbo the weapon. 

The Hobbit wrinkles his nose. Adorable, Thorin thinks, but knows better than to say. “Oh, the smell is even worse up close. Could you not have cleaned it first?”

Thorin can’t help but smile. If Bilbo has the energy to complain about cleanliness, he is probably going to be alright, after all. “Next time you kill an Orc Lord, I will be sure to clean your blade for you before I return it to you, yes.”

“I did not kill an Orc Lord,” Bilbo protests, “Fíli and Kíli did.” Which reminds Thorin once again of his initial task. This, apparently, was Bilbo’s intent, as he adds. “At least go and talk to Fíli. He looks terribly worried, and you might set his mind at ease.”

Worried? What does Fíli have to be worried about? Thorin owes him a life debt. Three life debts, actually: without Fíli’s intervention, Azog doubtlessly would have killed Thorin first, and then Kíli, and then Bilbo. Thorin takes responsibility for the lives of all his kin. But then his eyes fall to the Arkenstone, and he is distracted once again.

It is so bright. So beautiful. Sickened as he is at the way he behaved in pursuit of it, Thorin is shamefully drawn to the stone. He wishes the reclaim it, to hide it in his pocket and never allow it to be seen by any other soul. To hold it close forever more, proving once and for all his unequivocal right to rule over Durin’s folk. That is the dragon sickness speaking, or else the same curse from which his grandfather suffered, or both together, muddling his mind. Will it ever truly go away? Will Thorin ever be entirely without this burden, ever be free to trust his own instincts?

The same part of him that sought the Arkenstone sought also to possess Bilbo entirely. To lock him away deep within the vaults of Erebor, along with all the gold and jewels. Would the Hobbit have gone along with it, had Thorin tried it? Would he have gone to his prison willingly? Or would he have struggled? Would he have challenged Thorin, tried to fight him off? He would not have succeeded. Perhaps he might have run away. But fantasizing about imprisoning Bilbo is hardly the worst of Thorin’s crimes. 

Understanding dawns on him, now that he has forced the clouds from his stormy mind. Of course Fíli would be worried. He stole the Arkenstone from the treasury of Erebor, kept it from Thorin for days on end, and ultimately used it recklessly as a weapon in battle. Had his plan failed, had his aim not been true, the stone could have wound up in the hands of the pale orc. But then, had Fíli’s plan failed, the lad would have become king in short order, and the stone would have been his to do with as he wished.

Had he wished to, in fact, he could have allowed Azog to kill Thorin, then attacked the orc from behind. It would have cleared up any disputes about the ownership of the stone. He could have saved Bilbo, too, and perhaps Kíli as well, if he’d managed to stop his brother from fighting. Had Kíli not said that he would support Fíli’s claim to the throne, if it came to that?

But Fíli chose to part with the Arkenstone and save his uncle’s life rather than ascend to the throne. Would Thorin have done the same, had their positions been reversed? He tries to tell himself that of course he would; he’d do anything for his sister-sons. But he nearly murdered his heir on the battlements, when Thorin walked in on Fíli embracing Bilbo. In his madness, Thorin could not see the innocent gesture as anything other than a threat to his authority, an attempt to steal from him, as though Bilbo were nothing more than a possession. Thorin was weak in the face of his own twisted desires, bending like a blade of grass to his worst impulses. 

Thorin could never be so strong as his sister-son. Not in all his life. If he’d had the Arkenstone in his hands, he would have become his grandfather. He would have retreated into the treasury and probably starved to death there. Or he would have become a burden to all those close to him, leaving Bilbo to care for him and his sister-sons to rule his kingdom while he whiled away the days staring at a pretty rock. 

Yet none of these things happened. Thorin did not lose himself to the dragon sickness, and he did not die in battle, all for the bravery of his sister-son. When he thinks of it like that, there is really only one possible course of action. Thorin takes a few quick, decisive strides in the direction of his heir. 

Fíli holds up his hands in a gesture of peace, dropping his heavy heirloom blade upon the ground. “I am sorry, Uncle,” he blurts out before Thorin can reach him, “You should know that I acted alone. Kíli did not know that I had taken the stone. Do not blame him. What he said about my claim was—“ 

But he cuts himself off when Thorin falls to his knees. By Mahal, could there be one more suited to the throne of Erebor than Fíli, son of Dís? Even now, when he thinks he is going to face charges for treason, his first instinct is to defend his brother.

Something foul settles in Thorin’s stomach. For a moment, he is glad that Frerin is dead, that he could not have come on this terrible journey. That at least he never had to watch his beloved brother devolve into monstrosity. Is that why Mahal has reclaimed so many of Thorin’s loved ones, then? So that his father, his mother, his grandparents, his brother, and his brother-in-law would be spared the sight of his egregious behavior?

“What are you doing?” Fíli demands, dropping his outstretched hands in confusion. “Get up.” 

“When we return to Erebor,” Thorin begins, “We will hold your coronation ceremony immediately. The King’s Chambers are yours if you want them. The Arkenstone, as well, to place upon your throne, if you think it wise.” 

“I don’t understand.” The lad sounds genuinely perplexed. 

“You have proven your worth a hundredfold this day, my sister-son,” says Thorin. He cannot look his nephew in the eyes, cannot bear the disgust that he knows he will find there. “None of our line have ever willingly parted with the Arkenstone before. You could have kept it for yourself and fled, but you chose instead to save my life at the cost of your own.” They both know what Fíli risked, after all, when he made it known that he took the Arkenstone. Legally, Thorin would be well within his rights to have the lad executed. But legally, Thorin was well within his rights to start a war with the Men and Elves, and see how that turned out! “I swear fealty to you, Fíli, son of Dís, true King of Erebor.” 

“Uncle, please, get up,” Fíli urges once more, holding out his hand. “You don’t mean that.” 

“I mean it well enough. You have acted as a true king would. Where I was a coward, you were—“ 

“I was protecting my king.” When Thorin does not get up on his own, Fíli hunches down and hauls his uncle to his feet. When did he grow strong enough to do that? “As I will continue to do as Crown Prince of Erebor. Crown Prince, and nothing more.” 

“You are entitled—“ 

“I’m not letting you abdicate,” Fíli informs him flatly. “You know Mum would kill you.”

But Dís will kill him anyway. When Thorin tells her that he threatened her son, that he put the entire company at risk with his foolish, pointless war over nothing, against the better judgment of all of his advisors, she will charge at him with her axe raised. And she will be right to do so. “You have proven—“

“Do you think I planned to… to throw the Arkenstone?” Fíli gestures at the stone where it lays upon the ground. “I would have kept it. I would have challenged you for the throne. Had you not threatened me, and shown me that our treasure could cause madness, I would have acted rashly. I would have done what I could not take back, just as you would. I am not yet ready to be king, Thorin. I see the burden that you bear, and I would not yet take it from you. Durin’s folk look to you as their leader.” Fíli kneels before Thorin, a gesture which the king feels he does not deserve. “I swear fealty to you, Thorin, son of Thráin, son of Thrór, King Under the Mountain.” 

“I—“ Thorin may cry. He does not deserve this level of loyalty. To have Bilbo forgive him is a miracle enough, but for Fíli to kneel when he is the one who just saved the kingdom would be far too much even had Thorin not spent the last moments of the battle sitting idle and without sense. 

“Honestly,” Fíli continues, “If slaying Azog is what makes someone king, then we should be crowning Kíli. He wouldn’t do a bad job at it, either.” This must be some sort of joke, intended to relieve the tension or lighten Thorin’s mood. 

“He owes you his life as well.” Thorin tries, truly, not to make the comparison that blooms so easily in his chest. Where he could not protect Frerin, Fíli was able to buy Kíli the time that he needed. Did he keep track of Kíli’s whereabouts through the fighting? Was he aware the entire time of his brother’s location? 

Thorin never was. At Azanulbizar, he was distracted, first with his own opponents and then with avenging his grandfather. He could not keep track of Frerin, could not keep track of Thráin, could do nothing but charge forward and fight. He lost himself to it, and he earned himself a new name, but he was left bereft and grieving for his negligence. 

“I’m not keeping score,” Fíli says firmly, “All of us are still alive. We have Erebor back, and you are… back to normal. Aren’t you?” 

“Yes,” Thorin says roughly, because it is easier than explaining that he will never be back to normal again. That he may always be tempted by the gold, always pulled to lock himself away with it, to take his One with him and hide from the horrors of the world. He may always long to pluck the Arkenstone up off the ground and cradle it close to his chest. 

“If we’re done swearing fealty,” Dwalin makes his eavesdropping apparent, “And figuring out that the fellow with the crown on his head is the king—“ 

“I’m not wearing a crown.” The words bubble to Thorin’s lips before he can stop them. 

Dwalin rolls his eyes and flicks at the king’s braid in Thorin’s hair. It is the sort of gesture that a brother would make, something too intimate for any but the closest of kin. Dwalin will not say that he loves Thorin, will never put voice to the terror he must have felt during the battle, watching what he believed to be his king’s last moments. He will never speak of what transpired in the treasury, will never say that he forgives Thorin, will never ask the king to beg for absolution. No. With a single motion of his fingers, Dwalin makes it clear that everything is as it was. 

And then he speaks.  “If you’re finished taking a blunt axe to the line of succession—“ 

“Fíli will make a great king.” This much, Thorin knows for certain. “And he would have done today.” 

“You are blind, still, Uncle,” Fíli laughs, having risen to his feet while Thorin was distracted. “If you truly believe that. Must I swear fealty again?”

“Please, no.” Thorin doesn’t think he can take that. He is suddenly very tired, and though he would never admit it, his wounded arm stings more now that there is no combat to distract him. The handkerchief tied around it has become sodden with blood, and Thorin would very much like to get Kíli and Bilbo to a serious healer. He still does not trust the Elves. 

“Let’s collect our wounded and go home, then,” Fíli decides, “Though Kíli seems to have glued himself to his Elf maiden. And… the Elven prince? Mahal below, that’ll be a lot to sort out, won’t it?” 

“Do not remind me.” That is a mess that Thorin is not prepared to start cleaning up. One Elf lingering around his sister-son was bad enough. It brings him no joy to see Kíli sandwiched between two of them. 

“You’re courting a Hobbit,” Fíli points out. 

“Bilbo is not an Elf.” 

“He’s elf-adjacent,” Fíli teases, “Pointy ears. I do love him, but it’s true.” 

Thorin growls. “If you call my intended Elf-adjacent ever again, I will make Dáin my heir and have done with it.” 

“And I will help him plan your funeral when Mum murders you,” Fíli assures him with a pat on the shoulder. “You should go to Master Baggins now, before he tries to walk back to Erebor on his own. I’ll deal with Kíli.” 

That, Thorin realizes, is a very good point. “If ever you would like to be King—“ 

“Oh, for the Maker’s sake,” Dwalin grumbles. “Our burglar’s getting up now, and if you don’t stop him from trying to make the trek on his own with all those bruises, I’ll go do it myself.” 

That, as it happens, is enough to get Thorin moving in the right direction. 

 

Unfortunately, Bilbo is not able to convince Thorin to let him walk back to Erebor. Fortunately, the poor Hobbit is so exhausted by the battle and the nerves and everything else that he somehow manages to fall asleep in the arms of his intended while crossing a battlefield. He wakes just as they reach Erebor’s gates. “Not a word,” Bilbo hisses. 

“Of course not.” Thorin looks amused, but does not tease Bilbo. 

“Where are you taking me?” This is the first serious question that occurs to Bilbo. Obviously, Thorin is bringing him somewhere specific, but Bilbo has no clue where that might be. 

“The infirmary.” After a slight pause, the king adds, “Do not argue.”

“Argue? Why would I argue?” Bilbo asks sweetly, enjoying Thorin’s pleased expression. He’d like to make his king smile like that much more in the future. Every day, if possible. Because they have plenty of days left to them now, Bilbo realizes. The battle is over, and Thorin yet lives. And their nephews, too! What Bilbo set out to do has been done, and now he can enjoy a long and peaceful life with Thorin. “You need to have your arm seen to, after all.”

“My arm is not a concern,” Thorin alleges, “You have been bruised and battered by a foe six times your size.”

“Four times,” Bilbo argues, though Thorin is probably right. “Anyway, I expect we’ll all be spending a lot of our time in the infirmary from here on out. Tauriel says Kíli broke his foot.” 

“How did he manage that?” Thorin asks. Probably, he would rub his temples, were he not carrying Bilbo in his arms. 

“No idea,” Bilbo replies, “But you and he can keep one another company while you recover from your wounds. And it seems Legolas will be there, too, with that nasty stab wound. I don’t know how much Tauriel could do for him. I still don’t understand that Elven healing magic, to tell you the truth. Someday, I do expect you to tell me every detail of what it was like to watch the process.” Bilbo considers this for a moment. “And then after you’ve spouted your anti-Elven propaganda, I’ll consult with Fíli and Bifur and find out what it was actually like.” 

“I am not wounded,” Thorin lies. He still very clearly does not want to address whatever situation is occurring between Kíli and Tauriel, especially not now that Legolas seems to have involved himself as well. Still, there are other matters to attend to. Bilbo can’t wait to see the look on Thorin’s face when Óin tells him that he is, in fact, injured. “You are.” 

In the end, the healer makes it clear enough that Thorin and Bilbo are both wounded, although, annoyingly, Thorin is allowed to leave the infirmary after a salve is administered and a proper bandage is applied. Not that he does leave, however. Thorin spends the next two days in the infirmary, pacing between the bedside of his nephew and that of his intended. 

 

 

Bilbo recovers quickly from the Battle of the Five Armies. Perhaps this is because he barely had anything to recover from in the first place. Yes, he was knocked around a bit, but it wasn’t half so bad as the blow to the head that he look the last time. Really, once Óin has verified that Bilbo’s bruising is limited to a few nasty purple patches on his back and belly and does not extend to any internal organs (nothing short of a miracle, that, but then again, he was wearing mithril armor), he is cleared to leave the infirmary as well. 

But Óin had to know when he gave the order that this was never actually going to happen.Bilbo stays until Kíli is permitted to start hobbling around on crutches, which seems a very quick thing to Bilbo but is obviously an excruciating interval for the typically active lad. Fíli and Thorin are generally present in the infirmary as well, as anybody would expect, and the days pass quickly between the four of them and the other members of their company, who all visit regularly. 

Tauriel is another constant fixture, and though she sometimes lingers by Legolas’s bedside, as soon as the Elven Prince’s safety is secured, the Captain seems to spend progressively more of her time with Kíli. Thorin, for his part, does not lash out physically, and he waits until his nephew is sleeping to throw the worst accusations at Tauriel. This shows great improvement, though it is clear that the Elf struggles to be patient with him. 

There is a party in the throne room when Kíli is released. “Oh, how lovely,” Bilbo exclaims upon entry, marveling at the redecoration that has taken place since the battle.

There is no gold whatsoever in this room, and the Arkenstone is nowhere to be found. He does not ask Fíli what happened to the gem, though he suspects that the prince is responsible for its disposal. Thorin made it clear that the stone was Fíli’s to do with what he would, and Bilbo honestly wouldn’t be surprised to learn that the lad had taken it outside the Mountain and blasted it to bits with explosives used for clearing mines. If, indeed, that would have any impact on the Arkenstone, which is harder than diamonds and cursed with some sick magic. Honestly, though, Bilbo has no desire to know any more than he already does. He’d be perfectly content to put the Arkenstone out of his mind altogether.

There is wine and ale aplenty, and a fair amount of food, compared to what they have been eating. Legolas leans against a wall near that particular table, looking pleased with himself indeed. His battle wounds have healed up nicely, and though he has not yet been permitted to embark upon the journey back to Mirkwood, that announcement is almost certainly in the making. It’s not difficult to put two and two together and conclude that the Elves had a hand in this feast, though they could’ve sent over more meat and fewer greens. Thranduil is in attendance as well, unfortunately, as is Bard, who looks about as comfortable with the festivities as Bilbo feels. 

It was not easy to avoid thinking of the ring in the infirmary. First, Bilbo was focused on Thorin’s injured arm, which healed at an impressive speed, but he also dwelt on the possibility that the ring might wake at any time and taunt him further. Then, he was concerned with his own recovery, which by all accounts went swimmingly, all the while pondering the route of his upcoming journey to Mount Doom. For the next several days, Bilbo busied himself with helping Kíli, which was an all-consuming task, particularly when the novelty of being waited on wore off and the lad started itching for something more stimulating than staring at a wall. Bilbo told him stories, read him poetry, and snapped at him when he attempted to sneak out of bed and put weight on his wounded foot. And he tried to convince himself that no harrowing journey would be necessary after all, that the ring may no longer be a danger in its present state, half-destroyed as it is. 

But now? Now, with Thorin steering him around by the arm, and hundreds of pairs of eyes staring at them with varying degrees of curiosity and mirth, with people thrusting goblets of wine (no, thank you), legs of mutton (not right now, if you don’t mind) and lovely little cakes (oh, yes, please) into Bilbo’s hands, he can think of nothing else. 

Bilbo’s quest is not over. He has only completed the first four steps of his initial plan. The ring is still very much intact, and though it seems much weaker than it was before its encounter with dragon fire, the fact remains that it is still a danger. From Sam’s description, when the ring was destroyed in Mount Doom, it disintegrated shortly after poor Gollum did, and then the fire mountain began to bubble, and Frodo needed to be dragged away, and they nearly didn’t make it, and… No. Not thinking about that now, because it isn’t going to happen. Because Bilbo is going to destroy the ring before Frodo is even born, to ensure that such a burden, even in a weakened form, never passes to his beloved nephew. 

He will not see Frodo suffer. He will take that all away, he will fix it, he will make things better. He will reshape the world so that it is ready when Frodo comes into it, so that the lad never knows hardship. So that he never knows war. So that he never feels the need to leave Middle Earth before his time, so that he is happy in Bag End for all his life. Bilbo will give Frodo that simplicity, will take on the boy’s burden and bear it gladly, as he should have done the first time. If Bilbo’s life is the price for this, then so be it. He has saved Thorin and Fíli and Kíli, and now, he must do what he can for little Frodo, who is a son to him in all but blood. 

“You do not look happy, ghivashel,” Thorin observes in a low tone that nearly sends Bilbo’s scattered thoughts careening in a more pleasant but much less seemly direction. Nearly.

Bilbo considers lying to him. It would be easy enough to let Thorin have this night, this first evening of the rest of his reign. To allow the king to visit with his subjects and celebrate his nephew’s fine recovery. There have been festivities every night since the battle ended, with Dáin’s folk filling the halls of Erebor and making merry over feasts of barley meal and enough ale to make the poor and scant food feel fair and plenty. Thorin has missed all of these fretting over Bilbo and Kíli. Would it not be kind to let him enjoy himself?

No, it wouldn’t. It would be very cruel indeed to keep something of such magnitude from Thorin. He could not have said anything on the journey, of course. Bilbo was resolved to keep Thorin safe, to get him to Erebor, at the very least, and begin changing things from there. If he’d explained it all at the start, nobody would have believed him. If he’d waited until he’d gained the company’s trust, if he actually managed to convince Thorin that he was telling the truth, then he would have changed things irreparably. Thorin may have found a novel and creative way to get himself killed. Better to let him act as Bilbo expected him to and to take advantage of his foreknowledge to set things right. 

But Bilbo cannot explain about the ring without explaining about his time travel. The story would not make any sense without a description of Frodo’s actions at Mount Doom, the context of Sam’s devotion and the Fellowship’s meddling. His knowledge would seem too expansive, and Thorin would be able to tell that Bilbo was keeping something from him. And besides, hasn’t Bilbo been saying this whole time that he refuses to build a relationship upon a foundation of lies? He must tell Thorin the truth. Nothing else will suffice. 

Thorin will not take this story well. He will stew in it and ruminate, even now that it is done with. He will obsess over how easily his madness could’ve induced him to harm Bilbo, if he is not doing so already. He will have to contend with his own mortality, how close he came to dying. And that is not to mention the betrayal of knowing that all this time, Bilbo has kept something so monumental from Thorin. Bilbo has had foreknowledge and used it to his own advantage, in terms of the quest, yes, but also in a personal context. He lied to Thorin, and not exclusively during the dragon sickness, either. 

They have been given a second chance, and Bilbo will do everything in his power to protect it. It’s new for him, having someone he can confide in, can truly be himself around. After his last adventure, Bilbo returned to Hobbiton and endured years of isolation before Frodo came into his care. Then, he cherished his role as uncle and surrogate father. But that was not comparable to having a partner, an equal for whom he was not responsible, to whom he could show his heart of hearts.

At the moment, Bilbo’s heart is heavy, and Thorin deserves to know why. Some awful, selfish part of Bilbo would avoid this altogether, would sneak off to Mordor with the ring on his finger and pray to come back and talk things over later, if at all. He could take care of it himself or die trying, and he would never have to witness Thorin’s grief in the later case. But Bilbo is really not so terrible as all that. 

“Can we talk?” He asks in a strangled voice.

Thorin seems alarmed by this. “Of course. We’ll go to our chambers.”

Our chambers, so easy, just like that. Something Bilbo never could have dreamed of, not in his wildest imaginings, not even when he and Thorin were together for the first time. Maybe they would have a warm friendship, maybe Bilbo would be able to admire the king from a very close distance, but to share chambers, to share a bed? He would not have allowed himself the fantasy. And now the reality is his. 

Thorin leads him through the halls of Erebor to what is ostensibly the Royal Wing. Bilbo has never been here. He did not stay with Dáin and his family on his last visit to the Lonely Mountain, not wanting to impose. And of course, this time around, Bilbo and Thorin have spent the days since the battle staying in chambers close to the infirmary, much to Kíli’s horror. He made it perfectly clear that he did not need them hovering, but Thorin insisted upon chaperoning all of the lad’s interactions with Tauriel, and Bilbo insisted upon chaperoning Thorin’s chaperoning to ensure that no blood was spilled. 

The room to which Thorin eventually brings Bilbo is modest, not what one would expect from the bedroom of a king. It is certainly large, but it’s clear that the bedclothes have been sitting in a cupboard somewhere for over a century, and the same can be said of the rug. It has been dusted and swept; the floors and walls have been washed, and the dresser and vanity look well-made. The bedside table has seen better days, however; it will need repainting. There are no adornments whatsoever. 

Bilbo looks around, and Thorin shuts the door. “I thought we could bring in some of your things from the Shire, if you want to decorate,” the king explains. 

“What about you?” Bilbo knows well enough that Thorin has not truly had a room to call his own since Erebor fell. Yes, he had his quarters in Ered Luin, and Bilbo is certain they were very nice, but he knows his intended well. Thorin would not have decorated, would not have indulged at all in the maintenance of a space that he’d have seen as temporary at best, for the same reason that he insisted on shearing his beard short and refusing the braids that would have been culturally appropriate for a king. “You are the king, and these are the king’s chambers. Surely we should decorate them to suit your tastes as much as mine.” 

Thorin has spent more than a century depriving himself, and Bilbo intends to change that. The king sighs, sitting down on the edge of the great bed. “Perhaps you and Fíli might go down to the vaults later. You could surprise me with whatever you think I might like.”  He doesn’t say that he is terrified to go down there himself, that he is terrified to let any set foot in the treasury but those who have proven already beyond a shadow of a doubt that they are not affected by the dragon’s curse. He doesn’t need to say it. 

No matter how many times Bilbo and the lads reassure Thorin that they have no way to know what he’d have done if his and Fíli’s positions were reversed, Thorin maintains that he could never be as strong as his heir, could never relinquish the Arkenstone willingly, even to save the life of another. He has insisted since Ravenhill that Fíli is uniquely suited to the throne for this very reason, his ability to prioritize his family and the well-being of his kingdom over any treasure that said kingdom might contain.

This, in Bilbo’s opinion, is hogwash. According to Óin, many traits that run in families are not passed intuitively from parent to child, and it is difficult to trace the patterns of inheritance associated with mental instability. Fíli’s apparent resistance to dragon sickness may come from his father. Or, it may very well be something that he shares with Thorin. After all, the king was able to pull himself out of his illness eventually, unlike his grandfather. And there is no telling how Fíli might have reacted had he not seen Thorin’s madness before laying hands upon the Arkenstone. It is not a matter of strength or weakness but rather a combination of circumstances. 

Bilbo wants to comfort Thorin, to assure him that the gold sickness will not come back. But in truth, he doesn’t know that. Perhaps the illness will return. Perhaps it will be an uphill battle for Thorin his entire life, and he will truly have to avoid the treasury for as long as he lives. At least he does live. That is better than Bilbo could have asked for a year ago, well and truly beyond his wildest dreams. And he knows that he is stalling, avoiding a conversation that he doesn’t know how to have. He grabs Thorin’s hand, seeking strength and comfort as much as he offers it. 

“Will you not tell me what is the problem, ghivashel?”

“Thorin,” Bilbo begins. “I—“ Well, that won’t do. “Have you perhaps noticed…” Oh, bloody brilliant, Mister Baggins. Really great start to the story. The Old Took would be very proud indeed of his floundering grandson. You spent eighty years telling this tale, and yet you clam up now? “Well. Throughout the journey—“ 

“Do you not wish to marry me after all?” Thorin blurts out, stopping Bilbo short. 

“What?” 

“Is that what is so difficult for you to say? Because if it is, of course, I understand. When you accepted my gift, I was… I had already threatened you.” The words pour out of Thorin. It becomes painfully clear that he was just as distracted by these thoughts as Bilbo has been by his own. “I was not in my right mind. You would not have been misguided if you’d agreed only to… placate me. I did not even explain things to you. My behavior was shameful.”

“You already apologized for all that,” Bilbo waves him off. “And if I recall, I accepted your apology the first time.” 

“I threatened you, and my own sister-son as well.”

“You didn’t hurt either of us. You can hardly blame yourself for things you didn’t do.”

“I would have.” Thorin seems very sure of this, indeed. “I would have.”

“But you did not,” Bilbo shakes his head. “You cannot hold yourself accountable for thoughts you never followed through on. I know you’re already torturing yourself about the things you actually did, Thorin. Please don’t add in made-up nonsense to feel guilty about as well. Fíli and I have both already forgiven you several times! Of course I want to be with you! If I didn’t, I never would have said yes, whether or not you were ill. You see, Thorin, I respect you a great deal, and I would never patronize you with a false acceptance of courtship, even if I thought that it would anger you. I accepted your gift because I love you, and that is that. If you’re going to doubt my feelings or accuse me of lying—“ 

“I would never,” Thorin breathes. 

Bilbo shoots him an incredulous look. “And what, exactly, do you think you’re doing right now? Asking if I no longer wish to marry you! Do you really think me so fickle as that? I won’t hear it. If we’re to spend our lives together, then you must trust me when I tell you that I love you very much.” 

“Alright.” Thorin does not sound entirely convinced, but he is clearly making an effort to trust Bilbo. This is a major feat, Bilbo knows, when Thorin cannot even trust himself. “But if that is true, then what is bothering you? Why can you not look me in the eyes?”

Bilbo sighs. He has to say this sooner or later. His relationship with Thorin cannot progress on a foundation of misapprehension, especially not after the speech Bilbo just delivered about the importance of trust. “Have you noticed,” he begins, “That over the course of our journey, I have always seemed to be a step ahead? To have a plan, to know what was coming? As though I had foreknowledge.”

“Yes.” Thorin does not hesitate, nor does he elaborate. 

“Right, then.” This may be easier than Bilbo thought. At least he will not have to give examples or provide proof. “That’s because I’ve done this all before.”

“I do not understand.” Thorin studies Bilbo with narrowed eyes, as though he is a complicated piece of metalwork. “What have you done before?”

“This entire adventure.” Bilbo swallows. “From the very beginning to the very end. I lived it one time already. This is my second go.”

“And that is how you knew who I was when I arrived at your home,” Thorin breathes. “That is how you knew the bowman’s name before we spoke to him. How you seemed prepared each time it rained. That is why you treated my sister-sons as kin, even at the start.”

“It is.” At least Thorin understands. 

“I still do not understand.” Never mind. “Why would endure so much suffering a second time? We have our Mountain back. You are here, and you are safe. Why would you feel the need to do it again?” 

Naturally, there is one clear explanation, the only true one, and probably one that Thorin does not want to hear. He must know, of course. He is not stupid. He must be hoping that Bilbo will tell him that he does not know why he had to do his adventure over, that it was just some magical accident, that he had no choice and no reason but necessity to embark upon such a massive undertaking. 

But Bilbo cannot give him the comfort of that story. He is sick and tired of making up lies, of telling tales much smaller and simpler and sweeter than the ones he’s carried coiled up inside his guts for eighty years. So he tells the truth. 

“The first time,” Bilbo grips Thorin’s hand tightly, “The battle did not end so well.”

“What happened?” 

There is no other way to say this. “You died.” Once those words come, the others fly out unbridled. “You died in my arms, Thorin. I… well, after you killed Azog, that is, I found you, and we spoke a little, we forgave each other, but then y—“

“Forgave each other,” Thorin echoes slowly, cutting Bilbo off mid-word, “What did we have to forgive each other for, ghivashel?” 

Bilbo bites his lip. He doesn’t want to get into this whole Arkenstone business. “The first time, I stole the Arkenstone and gave it to the Lake-Men. I thought that if they had it, you would give them the gold they wanted and just… I thought that I could prevent a war, if only… if only you would have seen reason.” 

“But I would not have seen reason.” This, Thorin knows to the core of his being. It is all over his face. 

“You were furious.” That’s an understatement. 

“I can imagine.” Thorin does not elaborate, does not tell Bilbo what he is imagining. Does not compare it to whatever thoughts must have raced through his head during the worst of the dragon sickness. It must be as painful for him to have this discussion as it is for Bilbo, and he does not even know what is coming. “Did I hurt you?”

Bilbo sucks in a breath and settles on the best answer he can muster. “You did not hurt me, no. This was a completely different world, as far as I’m concerned, and I refuse to allow you to hold yourself accountable for actions that you would have taken under different circumstances. We just had this conversation, Thorin, I—“

“How?” 

Bilbo closes his eyes. “Does it matter?” 

“Yes. How did I hurt you, in this other world of yours?” 

Thorin wants to know. He is asking, and it would be unfair of Bilbo to withhold the information, wouldn’t it? Even though he knows that Thorin will only use the knowledge to torture himself, Bilbo cannot carry this secret around for the rest of his life. Someone has to know, and it would be far worse to tell somebody other than Thorin and guard the knowledge from the king.

“You first commanded the company to kill me, but they all refused.” 

“As they should have.” 

“Then, you tried to force Fíli in particular to do it, but he would not.” This is the easy part. Let Thorin be proud of his sister-son.

Bilbo cannot see Thorin with his eyes closed as they are, but he can hear the king’s slow, steadying inhale. “Of course he wouldn’t.” 

“Then,” Bilbo pauses for a moment, trying to find the best way to describe this. “You attempted to… take matters into your own hands.” 

“I tried to murder you?” Thorin’s voice sounds gutted, hollow. “My own intended?”

“No, Thorin, no,” Bilbo has to put a stop to this. “We were not… listen. Please listen. I was rude to you for most of the trip. I constantly pushed you away, and every time you were a little cold to me, I took it as evidence that… that you hated me, I don’t know. And I didn’t try to… to push through or anything, I just went along with it, and… and even on the Carrock, I thought… I thought that we would never be anything more than friends, so…” Bilbo trails off. He does not know why he is making excuses for Thorin’s behavior on the first adventure. 

Perhaps because it does not seem fair that the matter should be drudged up again when it was already put to rest. Bilbo would not be pursuing a romantic relationship with Thorin now if he truly believed that the king would harm him when in his right mind, or if he truly believed that Thorin would fall once more to dragon sickness. In another world, the version of Thorin who threatened Bilbo’s life apologized for it, and Bilbo forgave him. Now, the present version of Thorin, who did nothing so horrible as all that, has taken it upon himself to feel guilty for things never even had a hand in. 

“But that does not matter,” Thorin reasons, “I put my hands on the one that I love. You would be entitled to cast me out of Erebor, to cut off my braids and send me away in shame. How could you have forgiven me for something like that?”

“Once again,” Bilbo says sharply, “It wasn’t you. You were not there. And even… the other Thorin, I suppose, the one on my first timeline, he… the dragon sickness. I gave away the Arkenstone. I betrayed the person I loved. We were both at fault.”

“No. Nothing could justify that.” Thorin is silent for a moment before he asks. “Surely the company would have acted. I was not fit to rule. The throne should have passed to Fíli.” 

“That’s not what happened, I’m afraid.” Bilbo will have to give more details than he already has, more details than he has any interest in giving. “They were shocked, I think. You must remember that I had stolen the Arkenstone and given it to an Elf. Perhaps they didn’t want me thrown over the battlements, but I’m sure some of them were perfectly comfortable with my being exiled. Gandalf put a stop to things, of course, but naturally, I was banished. He took me to Dale. The Elves, Legolas and Tauriel, that is, came and told us about the Gundabad orcs, and I’d seen you climbing Ravenhill, so… of course, I went to you. And I found you, I spoke to you, but you charged off to…” Bilbo decides to omit the relevant details in the middle. He will not make Thorin carry the weight of his sister-sons’ lives, not when all of it happened in another world. “You charged off to challenge Azog, and Dwalin and I were left with… well, with hundreds of orcs, really, and one of them knocked me out, and when I woke up, I followed you, and I found you, and as I said, we forgave each other, and then…” 

“Ah.” Thorin is silent for another long moment. “What was Fíli like as king, then?” 

Bilbo squeezes his eyes as tight as they will go. Of course Thorin would ask that. Of course he would want to know. Of course he would not conceive of the horrors that Bilbo witnessed, the awful memories that he and Dwalin would carry in silence for decades on end. But all that Bilbo can manage by way of explanation is a single word. “Dáin,” he says, choked and awful.

Thorin seems to understand because he sobs aloud, then, and Bilbo cannot bear this any longer. He opens his eyes and throws his arms around his king, his love, his intended. They both weep, and neither seems very much for words at the moment. For so long, Bilbo has been alone in his grief. His horrible, terrible grief. He was alone in the loss of his family, the only Hobbit in the Lonely Mountain until he went back to the Shire. And there he wrote a silly little story, told the tale wrong so many times that he could nearly convince himself of the plot that he constructed.

In Bilbo’s book, Thorin did not die upon Ravenhill. He was seen to by healers, laid upon furs in the most comfortable tent that could be had, as he would have deserved. He was surrounded by loved ones, and he was at peace. In Bilbo’s book, Fíli and Kíli were killed as an afterthought, painlessly, with no detail. He pretended not to know, when faunts asked him how their favorite characters were slain. He pretended to have been unconscious for it all, and that became his truth. 

He has never told a soul. Never mentioned it, not even to the other members of the company. He has never talked it through, not even with Dwalin, who was there for all of it. Bilbo never said a word to Tauriel, only left her sobbing over Kíli. He does not know what happened to her after, does not know whether she lived on in her grief, sailed to the Undying Lands, or perished of sorrow, as some Elves do. 

Now, Thorin joins him in his grief. It is not the cool state funeral, with organized chanting and weaving around the stone slabs where the bodies have been placed. Thorin is warm, so warm, so vital, so alive. He is here, and he is breathing, and if Bilbo lets his focus drift a little, he can hear the faint sounds of Kíli’s laughter from the party downstairs. There is a loud clomping sound, and Bilbo imagines that Fíli is marching across yet another table. They have changed, both of them, but some things will remain forever the same.

All three of them live. The knife that has been twisting in Bilbo’s gut for several months now comes free and clatters to the floor, leaving him to bleed out his sorrow in Thorin’s strong arms. It takes a while, but eventually, Thorin is the first to speak again.

“You came back to save my sister-sons,” he concludes, voice quivering. “Somehow, through some Hobbit magic, you returned. You risked everything for my boys. I thank you.“

“For all three of you,” Bilbo nips that in the bud as quickly as he can. “But it was not Hobbit magic.”

“Tell me.” 

This is the easy part. “Well, I lived a very long life, and at the end of it, Lady Arwen of Rivendell offered me her place on an Elven ship sailing West, to the Undying lands.”

“What?” That, clearly, was not what Thorin expected at all. 

“She was to marry the King of Gondor, a lovely lad called Aragon, a friend of mine, actually,” Bilbo explains. “But, of course, when I arrived to board the ship with my nephew and Gandalf, there was Lady Galadriel. She really cornered me, now that I think about it. She showed me a vision, I suppose, of you and the lads looking healthy, and I… well, you see, I may have misunderstood. I thought I was being sent to join you in Mahal’s realm, which seemed… odd, I have to admit, especially considering that I wasn’t exactly dead yet, mind you, but it made much more sense than what actually did happen, so I don’t suppose anyone with sense could hold it against me for jumping to conclusions.”

Thorin clenches his fists. “The Elf lied to you and tricked you into putting your own life in danger.” Of course that is what he would make of Bilbo’s story.

“No, she didn’t lie!” Bilbo protests, “There was no trickery. I misunderstood. But even had I known the truth, of course I would have come.” 

“I do not understand why an Elf would care for the lives of three sons of Durin,” Thorin replies after some consideration. “Though I can easily believe that one would send you back through time for sport.”

“Yes, well,” Bilbo heaves yet another sigh. “I may have come here for another purpose. But that is a very long tale, and a complicated one, and a rather sad one, I’m afraid.” 

“I will hear it.” Thorin sets his jaw the way he always does when he looks forward to getting his way. And he is right, of course. Thorin needs to know. He asked what was bothering Bilbo, and he will hear of it soon. 

“You remember the tale of the Rings of Power,” Bilbo begins. Thorin merely nods, entreating him to continue. 

And continue Bilbo does. He recounts the entire tale of the War of the Ring, beginning to end, adding Gollum in for context, and concluding with the damage that was done to Frodo even after the ring was destroyed. For another long moment, Thorin is silent. 

Then, he brings his free hand, the one not locked in Bilbo’s iron grip, to his temple. “You knew that you carried the One Ring,” Thorin recounts, “And yet you put it on your finger multiple times. You wore it for several days in the Elven prisons. You understood, and yet you put yourself at risk.”

“I had no other choice!” Bilbo protests, “I didn’t want to change anything too much, and I knew it wouldn’t hurt me, because it didn’t the first time. I had to get the company to Erebor, and frankly, I don’t think I could’ve done it at all without ever going invisible!” But does Bilbo truly not think this? Or has the ring convinced him of it over the years, warped his mind into believing that he is incapable of acting on his own, powerless unless that awful little bauble deigns to grant him some of its power? 

“It sounds as though it hurt you very much the first time.”

“Alright, yes, fine, but not during the adventure. And if I’d done anything differently, we may not have gotten to Erebor, and then what would have happened?” Bilbo asks. “If I hadn’t worn the ring, we would both be in Thranduil’s dungeons right now.”

“You should have stayed in Bag End and left me to my fate,” Thorin resolves, stubborn as usual. 

“And the boys as well?” Bilbo clinches the argument tightly and neatly. “No. I should not have. None but a Hobbit can carry the ring, as I just explained. And anyway, it’s weakened now. I had Smaug blow on it, to knock it out, you know. I’d hoped it would destroy the thing, but it still seems intact, even if it doesn’t work anymore.” 

Thorin exhales heavily. “Yes. It would be. The One Ring can only be destroyed in the fires that forged it. Is this not common knowledge?” 

“Perhaps for Dwarven princes it may be,” Bilbo retorts testily. “In case you had forgotten, I was very old when I learned the true nature of the ring, and my mind was not what it once had been. But either way, I have it now, and it must be destroyed. I’m going to speak to Gandalf, and then I’m leaving for Mordor.” 

 

Unsurprisingly, Thorin is not at all pleasedwith Bilbo’s plan. After several hours of emotional argumentation, they eventually arrive at three important conclusions. First, the ring must be destroyed, and the only way to destroy the ring is to return it to the fires whence it was forged, which necessitates lugging the thing to Mordor and tossing it into Mount Doom. Only a Hobbit can be trusted to carry the ring without being irreparably corrupted (though Bilbo doesn’t like to use Thorin’s battle with dragon sickness against him, he does here, at length), and it would be stupid and irresponsible to turn around, march back to the Shire or Bree, and find some other Hobbit to take on the task when Bilbo is already right here. Therefore, Bilbo must be the one to carry the ring to Mordor. 

Second, Thorin will accompany Bilbo on his journey, through whatever peril it may lead. That is only fair, considering their bond and the pain that the separation will cause for Thorin. Bilbo, too, dislikes the idea of spending any meaningful amount of time away from Thorin, if only because he truly struggles to believe that his intervention at the battle was successful and the King Under the Mountain is, in fact, alive. Also, Bilbo followed Thorin on his quest, so it’s only fair that Thorin plays a part in Bilbo’s greatest errand. Though Bilbo does not want to put Thorin in danger, the king is stubborn, and he makes sound points. Since neither of them wishes to send the other to Mordor, the best compromise seems to be for both of them to go together.

Third, they must inform the rest of the company. Not about Bilbo’s time travel, not about his decades of grief, and not about the fact that the Lady Galadriel can apparently manipulate the strands of the universe to send Hobbits eighty years into the past. But at the very least, as Thorin’s heir, Fíli will need to be told why he’s being appointed as the regent of Erebor, and he will tell Kíli everything, anyway, so the other prince may as well be included in the discussion. 

Of course, the lads will need Balin to guide them and Dwalin to protect them, and as their resident scribe, Ori, too, should be kept in the loop. It would be a shame to let him start writing about their adventures without knowing about the ring and its integral role in the whole business. And Óin should know in advance in case somebody gets hurt and must return to Erebor for emergency medical treatment, though Bilbo can’t help but worry that there will not be an opportunity, where they’re going, for such hasty transportation. That’s half the company already, so they may as well just tell everybody. And obviously, Gandalf must be kept informed.

They elect to tell the Wizard everything first. Thankfully, despite the fact that it is now the middle of the night, Gandalf is wide awake and receiving visitors. At the very least, the opens his chamber doors for them, and does not inquire about their presence here at such a late hour. He says very little as he listens to Bilbo’s tale, though his eyes twinkle with characteristic menace each time Bilbo brings up Aragorn. Probably, Gandalf is already plotting the restoration of the monarchy in Gondor.

“May I see it?” Gandalf asks, once everything is out in the open. 

“No,” says Thorin. “Bilbo does not have it with him. Of course it is somewhere safe.” 

Bilbo bites his lip. “I think you overestimate me, my love,” he admits, pulling the ring out of his waistcoat pocket and setting it on Gandalf’s desk. Somehow, the surface is already cluttered with paper, though where the Wizard procured all of this, Bilbo does not know. “But I could not leave it be stolen. Even in its weakened state.”

Thorin turns away. “I will not look upon it.” 

“That is wise,” Gandalf observes. His fingers hover above the ring, but he does not dare to pick it up. “Does it call to you?” 

“Not more than any other piece of gold,” Thorin replies. His voice sounds ragged, but the news makes Bilbo smile. 

“That’s good to hear,” the Hobbit reports, “I think it would have done, the way it was before. Most of the journey, it was speaking to me, I suppose, telling me things I knew weren’t true. It tried to convince me that you were going to take it from me, though of course, I knew that was rubbish. You didn’t the first time, after all.” 

“It is weakened,” Gandalf confirms, “Greatly weakened. Dragon fire may not be enough to destroy the One, but in conjunction with the blows that we of the White Council have just dealt to its master, I believe its battle with Smaug was enough to dilute the power of the ring, as you say. Though I do not know how you will fare, bringing it to Mordor.” 

“That’s to be expected,” Bilbo concedes, reaching out and squeezing Thorin’s hand. True to his word, the king is very pointedly looking away from the apparently harmless bauble on the table. He seems to think himself very weak indeed, very heavily affected by the magic of the ring. He doesn’t know half of what the ring is capable of, or would once have been capable of, or will be capable of should Bilbo fail to destroy it. “We both know the risks. But we must go, Gandalf.” 

“Both of you?” The Wizard smiles, though it doesn’t reach his eyes. 

“I will not abandon Bilbo to carry such a burden alone,” Thorin replies decisively. “Even if I cannot look upon the ring, I will not leave him to its mercy.”

“I do not like this,” Gandalf admits, “I would rather send another of the company as Bilbo’s escort.” 

“I’m sorry, but that’s not your decision.” Bilbo puts the ring back into his pocket. There’s no point leaving it on the table, now that Gandalf has seen it. Its presence is only torturing poor Thorin. “It took enough arguing to get us to this point, and I don’t particularly fancy starting again. Thorin and I are going to Mordor, and that’s final. We wanted to let you know before we met with the rest of the company about it, but we’ve made up our minds.” 

“Very well,” Gandalf says gravely. “Assemble the company, then. In the meantime, I will arrange for your transportation.”

Bilbo doesn’t even bother to ask what he is talking about. He has learned enough, over the course of his long life, about dealing with Wizards to understand that such a gesture would be perfectly pointless. 

 

 

The next evening, the company assembles in the Second Royal Meeting Hall. It’s a very nice room, all things considered. The walls are plated with silver, and there are some lovely stone statues standing in all four corners, depicting famous kings of the Line of Durin, none of whom Bilbo is able to identify on sight. They cannot use the First Royal Meeting Hall because the walls are covered in gold leaf and the throne at the head of the gold-plated table is made of solid gold. Quite gaudy, in Bilbo’s opinion, but he supposes that Thrór might have thought the same of Bilbo’s own home, had he ever gotten the chance to visit Bag End. When Bilbo and Thorin enter the room (hand in hand, as they always are, nowadays), they walk into a heated discussion about battle names.

It makes sense. After all, Fíli and Kíli both fought valiantly during the Battle of the Five Armies, and they did take down Azog the Defiler. They have more than earned the traditional privilege. It simply has never occurred to Bilbo before that perhaps not every act of heroism lends itself to name so intuitive and powerful as Oakenshield.

“Hush and listen to what I’ve got so far,” Ori orders, consulting a leaf of paper on the table in front of him. “Fíli of the Arkenstone.”

“No,” Fíli shakes his head, “Absolutely not.” 

“Fíli Gem-wielder,” Ori suggests. 

The crown prince cringes. “That’s not much better. Can’t I just be… Stone-thrower?”

Kíli laughs at that. “That does have a nice ring to it, brother. Imagine this: King Fíli the First, Rock-hurler.” 

Fíli shoves his brother in the side. Apparently, Kíli has now recovered enough for roughhousing, which must be wonderful news indeed for the young prince. “I’m not taking suggestions from you, Kíli Dropped-sword.”

It seems that the brothers have recovered from the horror of battle enough to mock one another for their admittedly unconventional orc-slaying methods. Bilbo supposes that this is a positive development, all things considered. 

Thorin seems to disagree. He pinches the bridge of his nose and closes his eyes. “I patiently await the day that Dís arrives to deal with her sons.” 

Bilbo is so fond of his new family that he can hardly contain himself. How the Valar have blessed him, allowing him a chance to keep everyone alive. Even if their quest is unsuccessful, at least Bilbo can take comfort in the knowledge that the lads are safe. He may not be able to shake Thorin as he undertakes his perilous mission, but Fíli and Kíli will stay in Erebor, where they will live long and happy lives. 

“Alright, enough of this!” Bilbo takes the list from Ori and searches for appellations which are to his liking and suitable for the boys. He knows that this discussion could go on forever if the princes are expected to select their own titles. “Fíli Mountainheart and…Kíli Elfblade. We called this meeting for a reason, you know, and it’s very rude to ignore your hosts. Not to mention your king.” 

Bofur elbows Dwalin in the ribs. “You’re going to be out of a job soon, now that Thorin’s using Bilbo for an enforcer.” 

Dwalin grunts. “I don’t mind the thought of retiring.” Balin snorts at this, aware as everyone else is of the blatant untruth in his brother’s words, but does not intervene. 

“I like those,” Kíli gives his verdict on the titles. “Although I still think Rock-hurler is better.” 

“Did Bilbo not just say ‘enough?’” Thorin demands. He does not dispute the Elfblade title for Kíli, which feels like a significant win. “You will heed him or you will be sent from this room and back to the infirmary.”

“Now, that hardly seems fair,” Óin grumbles. The poor healer has been dealing with Kíli’s restlessness for some time and has just gotten free of the incessant pestering. “Can’t you send him somewhere else?” 

“I’d be happy to go on a diplomatic expedition to the Woodland Realm,” Kíli suggests, grinning broadly.

“Yeah, you would be,” Nori grins and shoves Kíli so hard that the lad nearly falls out of his chair. 

“You be careful with the prince,” Bilbo orders, “He has a broken foot, in case you had forgotten.”

Kíli rolls his eyes. “Óin said it wasn’t broken anymore.”

“I did not,” Óin counters. Wisely, he’s had his trumpet close to his ear this entire time. “I said you could put a little weight on it without making the damage any worse. But if I catch you trying to run again before I give the word, Mahal help me, you won’t see a thing outside of my infirmary until your beard reaches your knees!” 

“You’re not helping,” Kíli grumbles.

“Please let Bilbo speak,” Dori orders, having taken notice of the conversation between the Burglar and the king. “I wonder if this isn’t very important.”

“It is.” Bilbo offers him a grateful nod. “I don’t exactly know where to begin, so I guess I should just come out and say it. The Wizard should be here any minute, and he knows the story better than I do, mind, but…” Bilbo exhales heavily. “You may recall that I was briefly separated from the group in the goblin tunnels during our adventure.”

“Yes, but you turned invisible and got away,” Nori recounts. 

“And then you sneaked past my lookout,” Balin smiles at Bilbo, “The first creature ever to do it, too.”

“Yes, well.” Bilbo can’t return the smile. “As it happens, I can’t turn invisible on my own, which you would’ve known already, if you knew anything about Hobbits. In fact, I’m gobsmacked that any of you believed that in the first place. But, regardless. In the goblin tunnels, I picked up a magic ring, which at the time I believed to be nothing more than a helpful, shiny bauble. But I’ve come to understand that it’s a bit more than that.” 

“Bilbo has a Ring of Power in his possession,” Thorin explains. “He has carried it this far and tricked Smaug into breathing fire onto it.”

“As he should’ve done!” Glóin cheers. “That’d be the only way to destroy it.”

“But Thorin says Bilbo still has it,” Ori points out. 

The color drains from Bofur’s face. “You can’t mean…”

“No.” Bombur shakes his head in utter disbelief. “Bilbo doesn’t have… he couldn’t have The One. That thing tears people up inside, doesn’t it? Makes them go insane. But Bilbo’s as stable as they come.”

“True,” Balin agrees, “He was the only one of us quick enough to think of any kind of plan when….” But he trails off, not wanting to refer to Thorin’s dragon sickness. Out of politeness, Bilbo neglects to mention that Fíli, Kíli, and Nori each came up with plans as well, though admittedly, enacting any of them would have resulted in an unprecedented disaster. 

“Bofur is right,” Thorin explains, grabbing Bilbo’s hand under the table. “Bilbo has the One Ring in his possession.” 

“It was not destroyed by Smaug,” Bilbo explains, “Though Gandalf and I can agree that it was weakened. It no longer grants me any invisibility, even when I put it on, and it no longer speaks to me as it once did. Thorin says that it calls to him no more than any other piece of gold. I trust that none of you can hear its voice now?”

“I wasn’t aware that a ring could have a voice,” Bofur is gripping the edge of the table with white knuckles. “But then, all the things that ring can do, why wouldn’t it be able to talk as well?”

Bifur says something in Khuzdul, and Bombur nods. “Amad told that story often, and she never mentioned the ring having a voice. But then, how would she know?” 

“So, you have the One Ring in your waistcoat pocket,” Dwalin summarizes the situation with his typical bluntness. “What next?”

“Right.” Bilbo is truly grateful for the assistance with staying on track. “Well. Thorin and I are going to take the ring to Mordor, where we will destroy it in the fires of Mount Doom.”

“Have you lost your minds?” Glóin demands. “The King Under the Mountain can’t just march into Mordor!”

“It’s the only way,” Bilbo retorts smoothly. “I wanted to go alone, but you can imagine how well that went over.”

“Aye,” Óin nods. “I suppose Thorin threatened to lock you in his chambers while he went in your stead.”

“Yes, that’s exactly what happened,” Bilbo agrees, “Though he apologized after.” 

“I still do not wish you to go,” Thorin admits, “I would find another Hobbit, if it is indeed true that none but a Hobbit can bear the ring.” 

“None but a Hobbit?” Ori echoes, flipping the list of names over and taking up his pen. 

“That is what the Wizard says,” Thorin explains, “Any other creature would easily become corrupted by its influence.”

“But that was before Bilbo weakened it,” Kíli points out, “He threw it into dragon fire, didn’t he? How are we to know whether the rule about Hobbits is still true?”

“It’s certainly weaker now than it was when I picked it up,” Bilbo confirms, “And it might be that the ring is no longer strong enough to have that sort of pull on any creature. But I’d rather not take the risk. It’s not nice to think about, but Thorin is very powerful indeed even when… well, even when he’s in his right mind. I don’t need to tell any of you about what happened with the dragon sickness, and forgive me, but I’d rather not let my intended take that kind of risk, simply for his own sake, if not for the sake of Middle Earth.” 

“But if that’s the case, does anyone need to go at all?” Fíli asks. “The ring is already weak, and the one who made it isn’t a serious threat. Why risk a journey into Mordor?” 

“Because it may yet grow stronger over time,” Bilbo points out, “In fact, I don’t see any way around that. We’re lucky right now. The enemy has been driven back a bit, and we’ve taken care of a good chunk of his forces. This is the best time to mount an attack, with the ring in its current state. I’d hate to wait for it to get worse and try to deal with it then.”

“You know more than you’re letting on,” Nori observes. “Last I heard, Sauron was destroyed centuries ago.”

“Yes,” Thorin admits, “But we will not tell you any more. It is dangerous enough sharing as much as we have.” 

“We trust all of you,” Bilbo explains. “But we would not put any of you in unnecessary peril by telling you more than you need to know.” 

The door to the meeting room opens, admitting Gandalf. The Wizard does not sit down but lingers in the doorway.

“Then you should let someone go with you,” Ori suggests. “Thorin is a great warrior, but only two of you against all the orcs of Mordor?” 

“Fíli and I killed Azog the Defiler,” Kíli recounts, “We could be of some help to you, I’m sure.”

“You are still wounded, brother,” Fíli points out gently, “But I will go.” 

“You most certainly will not!” Bilbo yelps. “There’s a fair chance we may all die on this journey, you know, even with the ring as weak as it is. As I’m sure you know, there are still the orcs to deal with. If I could talk Thorin out of it, I would.”

“But you cannot, ghivashel, any more than I can talk you out of it,” Thorin assures Bilbo. 

“Yes, well, be that as it may,” Bilbo tries not to be affected by the pet name at this juncture. “The fact stands that we’re going, and you are all staying, and now you all know.”

“But you really shouldn’t go alone,” Kíli protests. 

“They won’t take your brother when he’s hale enough,” Glóin reminds him, “They’re not going to bring you and your broken foot. You’ll hinder more than you’ll help, I’d say.”

“No, I’m not talking about me,” Kíli shakes his head. “I just don’t think Bilbo and Thorin should try to do this alone. They should bring an Elf—“

“You would think that,” Nori mutters teasingly. 

“Come on, Nori, think of another joke,” Fíli quips, flying to his brother’s defense. “We’ve heard that one before.” 

Nori only shrugs. “It’ll stay funny as long as he’s mooning over one of Thranduil’s guards.” 

“No, listen, I’m serious!” Kíli continues, “They should bring an Elf and a Man as well. Isn’t it better to have the whole set? We’ve just learned there’s a lot that Hobbits can do but we can’t. Bilbo has to be the one to bear the ring, and Thorin can protect him better than anyone. But Elves have good eyes and better aim, and Men must have good qualities, too. Do you know if Beorn is available?” 

“I am not dragging Beorn to Mordor,” Bilbo puts his foot down. “He has too many responsibilities to the animals under his care, and he’s a good ally to have on the Borders of Mirkwood. Besides, he’s a peaceful sort. It was bad enough we led him into one battle; I’ll not bring him to another one.” 

“Ah. More wisdom from General Baggins,” Balin observes. Bilbo truly hopes that nickname doesn’t stick. 

“Fine, not Beorn, then. What about Bard?” Kíli suggests. “I just don’t think it would hurt to have an even mix.”

“That is well spoken, Kíli Elfblade,” Gandalf agrees. Bilbo had quite forgotten about him, but apparently, the Wizard has been eavesdropping for longer than anyone would suspect, if he’s aware of Kíli’s new title. “I, of course, will be coming along, but it would be wise to reach out to Bard and Thranduil and ask them each to send a warrior.”

“I’ll head for Dale in the morning,” Dori offers, “And speak to Princess Sigrid. We’ve been working on a trade deal since she returned from the Woodland realm.”

“I like the lass,” Glóin decides, “She’s got a good head on her shoulders. She’ll be able to help her father pick a worthy warrior.”

“Did you not see the Men of Dale in battle?” Bofur asks. “I’m not sure they’ve got many warriors, excepting Bard.” 

Dwalin snorts. “I’d not trust my king’s safety to any of them.” 

“We should still extend the offer,” Bilbo concedes. He can’t really argue with Kíli’s logic. After all, that was what Frodo did, and having Men and Elves around saved his nephew’s life on more than one occasion. Though in the end, it was only Sam who followed the lad to Mordor.

“I’ll send a Raven to Tauriel,” Kíli resolves, “Most of them already know where to find her. Shouldn’t be too much trouble.” 

“We will speak about this when Bilbo and I return,” Thorin warns, clearly allowing himself to be distracted by the matter of Kíli and Tauriel. 

This, too, is progress. If Thorin finds sport in courtship negotiations, clearly he is coming around on the idea of his nephew loving an Elf. Perhaps after their journey, Bilbo can advocate for the young couple and help his intended see reason. 

“And if you do not return?” Balin asks. Of course he would be the one to think of that. 

“Then we will speak of it in the Maker’s halls,” Thorin says gravely. At least he understands the level of danger inherent to their present quest.