Chapter Text
Earth, Dec. 2014
Shortly after The Hobbit 3 came out, Mulder and Scully ended up taking a week off from work so as to digest at leisure the epic conclusion of the beloved tale. The first viewing turned out to be quite unproductive; many tears were shed upon watching the scene of Thorin’s death. The next day they went again, determined to lock their hearts away and watch solely with their brains; they ended up leaving halfway through, after the scene on the ramparts. No amount of comic relief from the great Dain of the Iron Hills could make up for the heartbreak of seeing Thorin and Bilbo’s falling-out. They gave it one more try two days later, and finally managed to watch through the whole thing with a more detached attitude.
“I’ll tell you,” said Scully once they were back in Mulder’s office, “even if they’re just friends, that was really tough to watch.”
“Indeed,” echoed Mulder. “So, are you ready to give it your all in our last Bagginshield match?”
“Oh, I doubt it’s the last,” said Scully. Then she continued in a somber tone. “Bilbo didn’t love him, I know that much. The jury is out on Thorin, but if he was in love, for his sake I hope he was able to reverse the process.”
“Thorin’s behavior is consistent with all I said starting with Hobbit 1,” said Mulder. “I’m happy to see that his feelings endured.”
“Mulder... I said it before, Thorin changes with the weather. But go ahead, let’s see what you’ve got.”
“This is really heavy stuff, Scully. We should probably do a scene-by-scene analysis. Let’s start with the acorn scene. Need I state the obvious, that Thorin looks smitten with Bilbo once he sees that acorn?”
“Hmm. I would say you’re just distracted by the fact that he looks gorgeously handsome,” said Scully. “I think that is bound to cloud the vision of many as to what his real mental states are. He is mad, Mulder. His emotions are unstable and supercharged. First he is overly paranoid, ready to smash something. Then, after he changes 180 degrees, he’s overly endearing, sensitive and even tearful. There is no need for love as an explanation; it’s a classic case of madness, going from one extreme to another.”
“But it’s more than that. He has tears in his eyes when he understands that Bilbo will go back to the Shire. Which, by the way, shows I was right about the book: Thorin did want him to stay.”
“The tears do not prove he wanted Bilbo to stay,” Scully countered. “Thorin is very touched that this hobbit cares so much about an acorn, such a little thing, while he, Thorin, is rattling the coins in his pockets like a madman. In this moment he realizes how bad his sickness is and how wonderful being like Bilbo must be.”
“But that’s just a roundabout way of saying what an amazing creature Bilbo is! And the look he gives Bilbo, Scully! What Thorin shows there is better than any look of love I’ve seen in any romantic flick! It’s more than sadness or being “touched”! Bilbo is the one who got away, or rather, will get away. Thorin missed out on this really beautiful person. He knows it. He knows he has alienated Bilbo with his madness. Bilbo’s statement I’m going to plant it in my garden, in Bag End seals it for him. He becomes lost for words, which is unfortunate, but his love for Bilbo is very obvious.”
“Well, at least you agree that Bilbo is turned off by his madness?” said Scully.
“Yeah. I think that, based on what he got on the last leg of their journey, after Laketown, Bilbo expected the attentions from Thorin to continue once the quest was fulfilled. He is disappointed. This is no longer the Thorin who leads him confidently and securely to a space that feels like home. He understandably would like nothing more than to bolt right out of there.”
“Which, by the way, is also consistent with the book. Wait a second. Are we agreeing for once, Mulder?”
“Well... Bilbo is certainly holding back in this scene. It feels to me like he’s carefully trying to figure out, Can I talk about this Arkenstone business with him? Is he lucid enough? He is walking on a tightrope. Once Thorin relaxes and smiles, Bilbo knows it is safe to bring this up. But all this effort in ascertaining Thorin’s mental state does not allow him to express his own feelings.”
“His feelings, which were invented late in the last movie, based on his awareness of an emotion about another emotion. Very muddled, Mulder. Very messy, this Bilbo business.”
“His feelings are on display, though. Exhibit A: the acorn.”
“What’s the big deal about the acorn? As far as I can see it represents the purity and simplicity of growing things. It is what home means to Bilbo, and everything that the dark, cold Erebor is not,” said Scully with a grimace.
“It’s more than an acorn, though. That’s his love for Thorin he’s holding there, Scully. Acorn? Oak? Hello?...”
“Oh, good Lord!”
“You see, he is torn in this scene. He sees that Thorin has changed. He is terrified that he has lost the Thorin he so much admired. So he doesn’t want to believe that he could love Thorin. But...” Mulder adopted a smug posture, “I want to believe.”
“Let it out, Mulder. Don’t let anything stop you now.”
“So he’s hiding his love. From himself, first of all, and also from us. As a result, we can’t see his love for Thorin.”
“Other than in the acorn,” observed Scully with more amusement.
“Right! You’re really with it this time, Scully! But his love right now is tiny as a seed. Oh, that reminds me. This is too good. Remember we bought An Unexpected Journey on Blu-Ray? There are valuable clues in the scenes with Bilbo at the beginning. I’m sure we’ve already gone over the fact that young Bilbo wears a vest with acorn buttons; coincidence? I think not! Old Bilbo, though? He wears a vest with tree buttons!”
“Huh?!”
“Yes!! You can only see them if you seriously zoom in, and you absolutely need the high resolution provided by the Blu-Ray edition, but there are trees on his buttons! Undoubtedly a sign that his love for Thorin does grow later.”
“You’ve lost it, Mulder.” Scully turned to his desk and began examining a random newspaper clipping. “Bigfoot spotted in Australia,” she muttered. “This conversation makes me miss those days.”
“Let’s move on to the mithril scene,” said Mulder, suddenly in a hurry. “Once again, Thorin’s feelings are clear in the way he looks at Bilbo while he helps him put on the armor and as he inspects him right after. There is also much emotion in his voice.”
“Yes, but keep in mind he is still mad.”
“Now, now, Scully. This madness can only explain so many moments. Also, we can agree that his madness doesn’t account for the fact that he gifts him the mithril, so why use it to explain the love in this gesture?”
“But if he loves Bilbo, why does he say the mithril is a token of our friendship?”
“You’ve answered your own question earlier, Scully. His madness is to blame.”
“In other words when it’s convenient for you, let’s use his madness. That’s weak, Mulder.”
“All right, all right. One explanation is that he doesn’t have any hope that his feelings will be returned, since Bilbo made it clear earlier he plans to go back to the Shire. The other explanation is Thorin doesn’t know where Bilbo is at with his feelings, and doesn’t want to scare him away. He can refer to friendship as a familiar place; in his mind, though, this gift means more.”
“Bilbo doesn’t seem to rise to the occasion,” observed Scully.
“True. Bilbo is holding back once again. He is very reserved and apprehensive, and clearly turned off. He doesn’t recognize the Thorin he likes, and is more and more worried that that Thorin is not coming back.”
“More than holding back, Mulder. By the end of this scene, when he hears Thorin say I will not part with a single coin, he is done with him.”
“Yeah... Remember when I said that Tolkien did not intend for Bilbo and Thorin to fall in love? I think what happened is, while Thorin fell in love and just went with it, oblivious to the process and without questioning it, Bilbo at some point realized what was happening. He’s the machine that becomes aware of its own processes and begins making its own decisions. He wised up about the glitch in Tolkien’s writing and decided he would not have any of this love stuff. I believe that, while in the acorn scene Bilbo was still torn and still open to love, in this mithril scene he makes the decision to halt the process of falling in love with Thorin.”
“Great, then there’s hope yet for them to be just friends,” laughed Scully. “No doubt he is put out that Thorin is placing the gold above those loyal to him?”
“That’s correct; obviously, he doesn’t know the value of the mithril. But even if he did, Thorin’s failure to keep his word to the people of Laketown would be enough to make Bilbo run for the hills.”
“So then Bilbo is not really in love.”
“I think in everything, his pattern has been to follow Thorin’s lead. Thorin is not leading anywhere good right now, so Bilbo wants out, even though he was falling in love. However, when Thorin charges out of the Mountain ready for battle, Bilbo realizes halting this process was a mistake. His expression there is very telling: he didn’t expect - he didn’t trust - that Thorin would snap out of madness; he now sees he has been wrong in his estimation. He can no longer fight his own feelings, and regrets that he has not embraced them fully. The Thorin he knows is back, and he is eager to follow him once more.”
“So now he wants to love Thorin?”
“I believe so. But he doesn’t have time to expand on his feelings, to bring them to completion, because there is a battle going on. By the way, Scully, the look he gives in this scene when he hears Bombur sound the horn and sees that giant bell is the closest look of love I’ve seen on Bilbo. It’s all in that moment, his realization, that he was not wrong to be falling in love with this person. Thorin to him is even more amazing now that he pretty much managed the impossible - to squash the madness that plagued his line and infused the Mountain! I don’t think the regret Bilbo feels here is so much that he betrayed Thorin, as it is that he betrayed his own heart by sabotaging his own feelings.”
Scully sighed. “Oh, Mulder, here we go again. I grant you he didn’t expect that the Thorin he liked would return. But his look could be one of admiration, and amazement, both at his own misjudgment and at the fact that Thorin somehow managed to conquer that awful sickness.”
“It is those, Scully. But it’s also more. What he did - putting his feelings on hold - is costing him. That is what his expression is all about. Sadly, I think Bilbo remains stuck in an emotional limbo,” said Mulder gravely. He waited for Scully to counter; yet she was listening with an intrigued look, so he continued comfortably.
“We see it in Thorin’s death scene. Once again, Thorin is wide open with his emotions. It is plain as daylight he loves Bilbo and is full of regret that he didn’t treat him as deserved. As for Bilbo, however, it’s too late now to allow himself to be in love. Thorin is dying, and since the adventure is over, Bilbo’s story will soon be over.”
“So does he or does he not love Thorin by the end?”
“I think...” said Mulder, “I think he is stuck in an “almost”. Which would not be so bad; the issue is that he can’t turn it into anything more. To him it feels that it’s too late for that.”
“Hmm. Stuck in an “almost” could mean that he just values Thorin as a friend.”
“That’s what he’ll tell himself, perhaps,” said Mulder. “He was my friend. He could have been more, but I’m never going to find out; there is no way for me to explore my feelings for him now. To make them grow somehow. Unless...”
“Unless?”
“Unless his - their - story is not over, and maybe they did meet later in their afterlife or what not. It’s something we’ll never find out, Scully, how it ended for them,” he closed with great sadness.
“But the characters are not real, Mulder. They’re the product of someone’s imagination!” Scully exclaimed in exasperation. “Also, why does it have to be love in order for you to get so invested? Why can’t it be just a great friendship? It is not less than love, you know? I am just as sad as you over their parting, and I only view them as friends!”
“It’s the romantic in me, Scully,” said Mulder with a wink. “What I like about their love is that it’s hidden. In these movies love is a puzzle waiting to be solved. It’s not given to you. The more meaning you uncover the more you glean that you haven’t uncovered. It’s like an upward spiral, much like our love was, in its initial stages. Though these guys... I’d say they take love to a new level.”
“Perhaps you’d have liked to go for one of them? Now you feel like you may have missed the boat?”
“Ah, but as you say, they’re not real,” Mulder replied with some satisfaction. “And I have a distinct feeling they’re both taken, anyway. As am I.” He moved closer to her and began kissing her gently, while still trying to get a point in. “Maybe there is a Bilbo and a Thorin somewhere. I wonder if we can communicate with them...” he pondered, evidently enjoying to see Scully make what he thought was an adorable attempt at multitasking.
Mahal’s Halls, same time
“Whoa...” Fili and Kili went as they witnessed the above exchange from their watching spot in Mahal’s Halls.
“We’re here!” shouted Kili. “You can talk to us!”
“Be quiet,” said Fili, knocking an elbow into him. “Can’t you see they’re having a private moment? Plus, they don’t want to talk to us! They’re just interested in Uncle and the hobbit.”
“Right,” said Kili with great disappointment. “It’s not like we can clue them in on the truth, either. Is it just me or did they for once agree on something? Scully didn’t oppose the theory that Uncle loved Bilbo.”
“I don’t know who could oppose it,” said Fili. “He gifted Bilbo the mithril while in gold madness. We never understood the gifting part before, but the movie makes it clear. Therefore, case closed. It takes a dwarf to easily make that call, though.”
“And when Thorin died... It’s so obvious how much he loved him. In that scene all he cares about is to part as friends and to encourage Bilbo to live a happy life.”
“Though I’ll say,” added Fili uneasily, “it wouldn’t have hurt to confess his love to Bilbo there at the end. Saying I wish to part in friendship doesn’t help if the person on the other end is so uncertain as poor Bilbo seems to be.”
“That’s part of why I think Thorin loved him, Fili, because he didn’t confess it,” said Kili with tears in his eyes. “He didn’t count himself worthy. It just shows how highly he thought of Bilbo. But oh, if only he had said something, we’d have a much happier Uncle to deal with on a day-to-day basis!”
“I’m not so sure about that. It’s not clear that Bilbo would have loved him back, Kili. I think Mulder is right. Bilbo was falling in love with Thorin but paused the process, or even canceled it, who knows? Uncle hoarding the treasure must have been a huge turn-off.”
Kili sighed with hopelessness. “I guess that makes Thorin the one more in touch with his emotions. You'll have no trouble estimating the success of their love story just based on that.”
“Y...yeah. This has disaster written all over it. Poor Uncle.”
Mahal’s Halls, same day, a few hours earlier
“Were you in love with him?”
After watching the acorn scene and easily spotting a sappy-looking Thorin with unmistakable awe and tears in his eyes at hearing Bilbo was still planning to go back home, Balin had interrupted his viewing of The Battle of The Five Armies. He stood up in alarm and rushed to Thorin’s room, determined to get to the bottom of this.
“Does it matter?” said Thorin, turning slightly away from his wall to face Balin.
“Of course it matters.”
“Nothing can come of such a love now.”
“Nothing, unless the love is still alive in your heart.”
“He is far away from me,” said Thorin. “To hope that I will meet him when the world is remade...”
“It’s a good hope to have.”
“He never wanted me.”
“He never wanted anyone else, either. Trust me. If there’s one thing I saw after you died, it’s that there was no one. Thorin... maybe you can reach out to him. If you truly love him, you might have the power to change something. You have to try.”
“I don’t know how to try,” Thorin murmured.
“I’m going back to watching. The battle is soon to begin. Enjoy the rest of the evening, laddie,” said Balin with much compassion in his voice. He got up and left Thorin to his world of choice, forsaking another attempt at breaking the walls around him.
