Actions

Work Header

Everything is fine.

Chapter 3: Hello, neighbour.

Chapter Text

Chapter 3 – Hello, neighbour.

Gentle hands stroked over his forehead, brushing loose curls against warm skin. Eyes, shining with hurt, peered down at him, a blue bruise blooming fresh over tan cheeks.

There was a stinging in his side, a pressure against his chest, a ringing in his ears.

Everything hurt. And then it was dark.


Billy woke up, lying on the hideous couch in his hideous house, head clear but ears ringing. A phantom pain ached across his chest, and he rubbed it until it dissipated. He never thought he’d miss the concept of a hangover, but the post-drink clarity struck him quicker without a headache to sift through.

Snores echoed throughout the sunlit house. He sat up fully and could see through the open bedroom door, Robin sprawled across the double bed, fast asleep. It reminded him of Kali, and the thought of Kali reminded him of his own death.

He wondered, suddenly, how time worked. Whether he was already buried six feet under and a passing memory for people who were still fresh in his mind, or if they were still pulling him from the wreckage as his spirit passed from the mortal world. Did Max miss him? Did Argyle? Would they tell his mom? Would she care?

He laid back down and stared at the strangely patterned ceiling. Brown eyes flashed behind his eyelids. Shame was still a prevalent feeling in heaven, he supposed.


Neil Hargrove was an angry, angry man. It was an anger that bled into everything, even his own son. It was easy to be angry in the Hargrove household, and it dogged Billy like a shadow. It was heavy and heady and encompassing.

It was a shock when Neil passed away. Part of Billy thought Neil would outlive him. Part of Billy thought Neil would kill him. So, when he’d got a call during his shift at the mechanics, Billy almost hadn’t believed it — had to see for himself.

But it had been Neil Hargrove on the cold table, skin pale, eyes closed and body still. The nurse was kind as she explained he’d had a heart attack and took Billy’s shameful relief as grief. He stood there and watched his father’s still chest, his calm face, his knuckles still bruised from the punch he’d thrown the day before.

Susan was grief-stricken when he walked through the door, sitting at the kitchen table with her head bowed, sobs shaking her thin frame. Billy stood in the doorway for a moment, debating whether he should comfort her. Then, she looked up and he remembered the years where she’d sat by and let Neil hurt him.

Susan and Max left shortly after, leaving Billy in a big house with the ghost of his father around every corner.


Robin leant over him, poking his shoulder with the point of her nail. Billy sat up with a start, blinking at the smile that appeared on her face as she leapt out of the way of his swiping hands, laughing all the while.

The sun was clearly up now, hanging in the sky with small, fluffy clouds passing by. Were the skies planned? Was there a generator somewhere that dictated the amount of blue? Or the cloud coverage?

“There’s a brunch happening in the centre of town and everyone is invited!” Robin said, dragging him from the ugly couch with unnecessary enthusiasm.

He barely had time to rearrange some of his curls before she was dragging him out the door, the sun shining down on them. It was strange how bright everything seemed, like someone turned up the saturation of the greens and blues. It hurt Billy’s eyes.

As they rounded a corner, the chatter of the brunch event burst forth, like there'd been something covering it and they broke through. It was the type of event Billy wouldn’t have attended when he was alive, too suburban and domestic and soft. But when he caught Harrington’s large head of hair above the crowd, he decided the food was a good starting point.

Robin already piled her plate high with meat and bread and a pastry that was oozing melted chocolate. Billy scooped a portion of scrambled eggs from where the little sign read ‘cooked to your standards!’. The bread was toasted exactly how he liked, and the bacon was slightly crispy. The jam was ‘your favourite’ and the coffee was ‘as you like it’.

They sat at an empty table near the outskirts, watching as the residents of their utopian afterlife mingled with one another. Billy sipped at his sweetened coffee with a slight smile, which dropped as soon as he saw were making their ways over.

Steve Harrington, with a plate predominantly piled with pastries, followed by Nancy Wheeler and two other people. Billy took an angry swig, practically draining his entire cup, as Steve loomed over them, asking in a genial voice, “You mind if we join you?”

Robin nodded whilst Billy remained quiet, glaring at the meager liquid left in his cup. He lurched when Steve sat beside him, knee practically pressing against his own.

“I’m going to get another cup,” Billy said, standing quickly, not even pretending that he wasn’t running away.

Steve stood as well. “I need a refill.” Then he looked Billy in the eyes and drained the rest of his drink.


Billy would like to say handled his father’s death and Susan’s subsequent departure well, but it seemed to bring back his fear of abandonment.

Sure, he was relieved that Neil was dead, but also he was upset. His therapist, if he had one, would’ve said that Neil died before Billy felt he’d proved himself to him. That Neil passed away before Billy figured out how to make his dad love him.

Billy didn’t have a therapist, so he drank instead.

Argyle was there, because he was Argyle and he cared. Billy was cruel to Argyle during those moments. Becoming dangerously close to the spectre of Neil that followed him like a shadow.

If he’d lived longer, Billy thought he would’ve pulled himself together. Stopped drinking for Argyle and for Max, went back to work and bought a new house. Maybe he would’ve liked himself enough to get a boyfriend, then a husband. And then he might’ve died of old age.

Instead, he got behind the wheel, bottle of whisky between his knees and he kept going faster and faster down the highway. He’d turned, just for a moment, to take another swig from the bottle, and before he even realised, his Camaro crashed directly into a tree.


Billy tried to ignore Steve’s hovering, as he poured himself another cup. Across the yard, Brenner stood with an odd, analytical look on his face, but he waved his hand in greeting when Billy caught his gaze.

When Billy put his arm down, Steve coughed, apparently tired of being ignored.

“What?” Billy snapped.

“How was the rest of your night?” Steve asked, leaning close. There was a rising scent of oranges and hairspray that tickled Billy’s nose.

“I was asleep for most of it,” Billy replied dryly.

Steve grinned. “Dreaming good dreams, I hope.” He took Billy’s cup from his hands, took a sip and winked. He handed it back. “Surprisingly sweet, just like you.”

“Shut up.” Then, “What do you want?”

He shrugged, smile coy and eyes glinting with interest under the artificial sun. “I think you’re interesting.”

“Why?” Billy peered over Steve’s shoulder, feeling slightly put out about the other man being taller. Robin wasn’t even looking at him, too busy leaning over and laughing at whatever the new woman was saying. Nancy was engaged in conversation with the other guy.

Billy looked back to Steve, whose eyes crinkled in amusement. A hand came to rest on Billy’s shoulder, then Steve’s thumb started to stroke the fabric of the red shirt. “This is a good colour on you.”

Heat rose to his cheeks immediately and Billy tried to lift a hand to cover it, but Steve caught it in his hand (with a bigger palm and longer fingers, which felt nice against his shoulder blade and might also feel nice if it slipped further down to rest in the small of his back). He opened his mouth to say something, maybe about Brenner watching across the crowd, or Nancy sitting at the table three feet away still talking to another man, or the fact that Billy now thought everyone was watching.

“I think you’re interesting,” Steve said first, “because you don’t seem to fit in.” Billy lurched back in offence, but Steve pulled him back. “When I first saw you at the party, you looked angry and uncomfortable, despite being in literal heaven with a beautiful lady on your arm.”

“This isn’t heaven,” Billy replied, slightly helpless against Steve’s intense gaze. “It’s called the Good Place.”

Steve smiled again, “See. You just don’t want to be here, and I want to know why. Who you were then, and who you are now. I think you might be the only real person here, Billy.”

It should’ve been comforting, to know someone watched Billy stumble and decided they wanted to continue to know him, but the sense of dread that was hanging over his shoulders dropped until the inching horror crawled over him. Steve had seen him and decided he didn’t belong.

Billy took a step back. “Don’t say that.”

Steve rolled his eyes. “It was a compliment.”

“That I don’t belong here?”

“That you’re real.” Steve was reaching out again, but Billy could see Brenner, and he could not let this man before him tear down the only afterlife Billy had. It may not be right, and it may feel empty, but Billy was as happy as he could be, and he wanted to keep hold of that feeling as long as he could.

“Nancy’s real.” It came out like a whipcrack, and it struck. Steve flinched and stepped back, hip banging against the table. The teacups rattled and the milk jug toppled over.

There was a hand on his elbow and he turned, catching the fiery glint of Robin’s hair before his fear consumed him completely.

“You okay?” Her voice was soft, gentle, pulling above the surface into the sun.

I wish I was in love with you, he wanted to say, I wish you could make me happy.

From the look in her eyes and the way she’d been leaning into the woman at the table, he guessed that Robin thought the same. She squeezed his elbow gently. “Do you want to leave?”

Desperately. But he couldn’t, not again. Couldn’t spend eternity running from Steve Harrington whenever the man so much as breathed near him.

“No, it’s fine. I just want to finish my breakfast.” Robin nodded and released his elbow. Steve was still watching as they walked over to the table. He trailed after them, eyes still fixed on Billy.

Nancy’s eyes were wide as they sat down. She asked in her sweet, gentle voice if Billy was okay. He nodded and focused intently on inhaling the food before him, trying to ignore Steve’s presence as the man sat opposite.

“I don’t think you’ve met,” Robin said, voice high-pitched as she tried to break the tension. “Billy, this is Jonathan.” The awkward looking man beside Nancy waved but remained silent. “And this is… Heather.” There was a pause there, Robin smiled brightly as the woman, Heather, leaned against her and reached out to shake Billy’s hand.

“Billy.” He took her hand but couldn’t stop looking at the glint on Robin’s eye.

The guilt he’d been trying to ignore settled like rock in his stomach. Robin shouldn’t be stuck with him.

“So,” Heather leaned back, angling her body more towards Robin than Jonathan, “how are you enjoying paradise?”

Robin went beet red immediately, wiping her hands on her shorts even though you couldn’t nervous sweat in the Good Place.

“Oh,” she stammered, “it’s good. We’re good. Everything is good and normal.” She laughed awkwardly and her eyes flicked to Billy’s, panic obvious.

“It’s good,” he agreed. Steve snorted across the table.

Heather turned to him fully. “You have a familiar accent. You from Cali as well?”

“Oh, yeah.” Billy sat up straighter, smile more genuine as Heather launched into a play-by-play of her life, asking at points if Billy also experienced those things. When he admitted he also surfed, Steve also leaned in closer. But it didn’t matter.

The sun shone brighter, the air was sweeter, and Billy could finally talk about himself without the burden of another life looming over his shoulder. He wondered (briefly, insignificantly) if Heather was hiding something, like Robin was, like Billy was. The way she leant closer to Robin, the way she spoke about her life, the way Jonathan didn’t even seem to register to her despite him being her soulmate.

As Billy started to launch into a story from his freshman year, footsteps grew louder behind him and Heather’s smile slid from her face.

“Ah,” Brenner said, smile etched like a plastic doll. “I see you’re all enjoying yourself.” They all murmured an agreement. “Billy? May I speak to you?”

Robin opened her mouth, but Billy stood before any noise came out. “Sure.”

Brenner didn’t seem to fit quite right, anymore. The way he stood in his black suit against the greens and blues like a spectre or shadow. The pursed lips, the cool glint to his eyes, the way he seemed to barely resist reaching out and taking.

“I hate to speak ill of any residents,” Brenner said, in his strange, calm voice, “but I recommended staying away from Heather Holloway and Jonathan Byers.”

Suddenly, it was Neil before him, warning him away from Argyle, Max away from Lucas. Spitting words of vitriol. Warping it into caring, like they were so dangerous the only way to be safe was to avoid, avoid, avoid. It had taken Billy a shamefully long time to learn he was wrong.

“Why? I thought only good people were in the Good Place.”

Brenner’s eyes sharpened and a tinge of fear shot up his spine. “Yes. But sometimes we make mistakes. If residents stop getting along, or there are problems, positions can be redistributed.”

“To another Good Place?”

“Sure.” Brenner’s smile was reminiscent of bared teeth. A dog baying for blood.

Billy turned then, desperate to get away.

“Oh, and Billy?” Brenner called after him. “People are looking forward to your first sermon!”