Chapter Text
Chapter 8- how to ruin paradise in five easy steps.
Step 1- leave on a boat
Heather sprang into action immediately, pulling Jonathan with her. in the slither of window through the floral-patterned curtain, a large crowd was gathering. The sky flared red in regular intervals and with every flash, more and more figures swarmed the hill like flies.
Jonathan, face set in grim determination, unhooked the rope from the dock. The entire boat trembled slightly as the current beneath the water caught it. Billy stared at the floorboards, adrenaline coursing through his veins. The instinct to race up the hill to fight whatever Brenner was sending was immense, but he managed to quell the urge as the figures slowly faded into the distance.
Heather and Jonathan talked in hushed whispers, heads closed together. Billy wondered what they’re agreement was; whether they would’ve agreed to be soulmates for eternity as well. They were never that affectionate in public before, so sometimes it was easy to forget they lived together. But as they communicated in short words and gestures, Billy was struck with a sudden wave of sadness.
If he’d woken up and was soulmates with Steve, would he and Robin be friends? Would Heather and Jonathan, if they were with Robin and Nancy, be able to talk with such familiarity? Would Steve and Nancy be pressed against each other in comfort? Would they be any happier?
The boat drifted and their bodies settled. At intervals they’d peer out the window, announce the sky was still flashing and turn away. No one was trying to plan or discuss what was happening beyond the walls. They instead turned to the next best thing—Monopoly.
It was the only game Heather and Jonathan had, and it was the Easter addition. Billy rolled his dice, moved his rabbit and promptly went bankrupt as he handed a smug Nancy all his money.
Steve was the first out and was sitting on the couch. Billy joined him, pressing their legs together.
“What do you think is going to happen?” Steve asked.
He leaned his head against Billy’s, close enough that he could feel the way his lips moved against his hair.
“I don’t know. I don’t even know if this is a piece of land floating in space, or if it’s connected to anything. But I think I’d like to try and find a new paradise.”
“Any place with you is paradise,” Steve said softly. He pressed a kiss to Billy’s curls. Billy tipped his head upwards and kissed Steve gently on the lips. Steve cradled him close as they took comfort in each other, warmth spreading through them.
Then the boat rocked, tipping dramatically to one side. Billy startled, sprawling backwards as objects fell from cabinets. Monopoly money went flying as the boat groaned in protest. Robin was under the table, spitting stands of hair out of her mouth. Jonathan and Heather were awkwardly lying on each other in an odd embrace, limbs tangled together.
Nancy was the first to stand, brushing herself off and stepping daintily over the mess to look out the window.
“I think we’ve made it to somewhere new.”
Step 2- get lost in the fog
Billy got off the boat first, squinting through the thick mist that seeped around them. The sky was inky black, no stars but a faint glow from a circle struggling to be the moon. But it was quiet, with no alarm blaring.
“I think it’s alright,” he called back.
The others scrambled out, coming to stand by him. The boat beached itself on a bay where the sand grains were fine glass. The cliffs where the mist crawled down were sheer, jagged rocks sticking out at jutting angles.
“There,” Robin said.
Following her finger, in the side of the cliff was a staircase. It seemed unstable and thin, winding up through the rocks and disappearing into the white.
They all looked at each other, shrugged and walked towards it. Glass tinkled beneath their feet as they walked, stopping at points to shake the shards from their shoes.
Calling it a staircase was a kind description; it looked like erosion had tried its best to recreate stairs. They were all different sizes, some were crumbling and they went up and up with no barrier between them and the ground.
“We can’t die again, can we?” Steve asked. He slipped his fingers into Billy’s hand once again.
“No other way to find out,” Heather replied.
She placed one foot on the first step and pressed down, testing them. Then she started to climb. Robin started after her, before she fully vanished into the fog.
Jonathan glanced between them before gesturing to Nancy. She rolled her eyes but brushed her fingers against his cheek gently. Jonathan followed shortly after, hands out in front of him, as if ready to catch her if she fell.
“You go,” Billy whispered. The air was thick, and he feared his voice wouldn’t reach Steve.
Steve looked at him, eyes wide. Billy gave him a shove, letting go of the hand and missing the warmth immediately.
“You’ll be behind me?”
“All the way,” Billy murmured.
Without thought, he pressed a kiss to Steve’s chin. Steve swallowed, turning to the looming steps. With one more look, he made the first step and then didn’t stop.
For a moment, Billy stood in the glass, surrounded by fog winding its way around his legs like a cat. The boat rested on the beach, dark against the horizon. He didn’t know what was up there, didn’t know what he would find, but he took the first step anyway.
The first few were fine, wide enough to fit his whole foot. He squinted into the thick fog, staring at Steve’s back further up. But it was getting further away. Billy started to climb faster, heart thumping in his throat as Steve seemed to move further and further away.
A wind picked up, whipping around him. Billy stopped. Looked down. Nothing but white. Nothing but white all around. He looked back up but Steve was gone. The stairs were gone. He felt weightless, suspended, and so, so alone. He leant forward like he did as a child and used his hands to find the next step, pulling himself up.
“Steve!” he called, but the wind stole the fear from him.
Hands grabbed him, voices frantic as they pulled and pulled. Then Billy could breathe, inhaling lungfuls of air, thick with brine and soil. Steve was curled around him, frantically whispering, “Billy. Billy. Billy.”
“I’m here,” he repeated. “I’m here.”
Step 3 – trust a stranger
“Well, there,” a voice said, amusement potent, “you look like you’ve been through hell.” Then the man laughed like it was a hilarious joke.
Billy tried to sit up, but Steve clung to him, so he ended in a strange half-up pose. The fog was gone, and they seemed to be in a field after it was tilled. The earth was dry and crumbling beneath them. A man, with thick, wavy hair smiled at them, hand waving.
“Hiya, I’m Eddie.”
“Fuck off,” Heather said. Robin seemed to be trying to curl into her lap, face wet with tears.
“Look, y’all just climbed the misery steps, and it’s my responsibility to provide a semblance of care.”
“That’s what that was?” Nancy snapped. Her hair was ruined, buffered by the wind and caked with dirt. Jonathan was beside her, head buried in his hands.
“Uh, duh?” Eddie chuckled again, hands spreading wide. “You’re in the Bad Place, after all.”
This was not what they wanted to hear. The mild theory Heather presented on the boat felt like months ago, and they took comfort in the fact it might not be true. But it was. They were in hell, miserable, terrifying hell.
Billy held Steve’s hand.
It’s fine. Steve is here. He is paradise. He is here.
This did not comfort him.
“I told Brenner it wouldn’t work,” Eddie continued, seeming to smile wider at their obvious despair. “He said, ‘I’ll just tell them they’re in paradise and make it wrong for them’ and I said, 'that’s dumb and stupid and they’ll figure it out quick.’ I was right, of course, but I thought it would take you longer.”
As he spoke, they drew closer and closer together. Huddling close like dogs in the winter, trembling, frightened and ready to bite.
“Hmm,” Eddie tapped his chin. His movements were always exaggerated, like someone trying their best to be a person but not quite doing it. “Now, what kind of demon would I be if I didn’t go against the regime? Tell you what, I’ll help ya out!”
“Why?” Heather whispered.
“The Good Place. The Bad Place.” Eddie tipped his hands like weighing scales. “Both serve the same function. Judge, judge, judge. Only good. Only bad. Only black. Only white. Forced conformity, the afterlife’s favourite pastime.”
He looked at them expectantly. They all nodded.
“Well, me and a couple of buddies decided to pull a Satan and diverge from the rules set in place by our cold and angry universe. We thought to ourselves, because us demons have that advantage, and decided, why not have a Medium Place. Not for extraordinarily good, not for exceptionally bad. But for humans like you, who just lived lives.”
“Is that why you’re here?” Billy asked. Steve relented in his grip for a moment, allowing Billy to fall further into his warmth. “To take us to this Medium Place?”
“Yup! If ya want,” Eddie chirped, hair bouncing like the ears of a very fluffy, very excited dog.
“Of course we want that,” Heather said. She stood up, pulling Robin with her. Jonathan and Nancy slowly got up as well. Billy struggled, but he slowly stood with Steve still attached like a limpet.
“Great,” Eddie said, gesture wide and sweeping once more, “if you’ll follow me.”
Step 4 – realise it’s all broken
The Medium Place was a trailer park on the edge of the woods. It was large, the trailers looked spacey and welcoming and there was an atmosphere of joy that hadn’t been there in the fake Good Place at all.
They weren’t the first humans to arrive; Eddie had told them as he led them through the brass iron gates. There were symbols on the iron, protection from the two oppressive fractions (Eddie’s words) which prevented them from being found.
There was an elderly couple tending a fire, faces youthful despite their age, like the vitality of life was still coursing through their veins.
“Got sent to the Bad Place because they never had kids,” Eddie said as they walked by. “Minus two hundred points for each unborn child you could’ve had.” He mouthed ‘unprotected sex’ with wiggling eyebrows.
A small boy throwing a basketball. “Died before he told his parents he was the one to break the vase. Minus fifty points.”
A teenage girl strumming a guitar. “Killed herself. Minus three thousand.”
Two men, both sitting in deckchairs and reading books. “Gay. Minus ten points for every gay thought.”
“Sorry,” Nancy said at some point after being told a five-year-old boy lost ten points because he told a teacher his dad hurt him, “what is this point system? How do you even get into the Good Place?”
“You don’t,” Eddie said bluntly. “No one’s got in for over one hundred years. But none of the higher ups want to admit something’s wrong. So, they just blame the humans.”
“They can’t do that!” Robin protested.
Eddie shrugged. “We’re not actually human. So theoretically the point system is unbiased and fair.”
“It lacks nuance,” Billy said.
“Sure,” Eddie agreed. “Human life is complicated. Every action has a chain reaction. Rejecting a girl in middle school leads her to believe she’s ugly which gives her self-confidence issues which makes her suicidal and then she kills herself. Not only is that negative points for her, but for you as well.”
“I’m guessing there’s always more bad reactions than good,” Jonathan said quietly, still staring at the little boy who was excitedly telling a black woman (filed a complaint against her boss for harassment, minus thirty-five points) a story.
“There’s a threshold for the Good Place. Essentially, you can only get in if you haven’t lost any points.”
“And that’s impossible.” Heather’s face warred between disbelief and grief. “We had no chance.”
“You have one now.” The soft voice was oddly familiar. When Billy turned, a tiny blonde girl emerged from a trailer, holding files.
“Chrissy!” Eddie lit up and scampered over to her, hugging her enthusiastically.
“You haven’t been gone that long,” she laughed, hugging him back.
“Are soulmates real?” Billy asked.
Her face softened into something sympathetic when she saw him. “Yes and no. There are hundreds of potential matches spanning hundreds of years, but humans are fickle and stubborn. Any attempt at a soulmate initiative failed. You lot like to choose.”
“I choose you.” Steve’s voice was quiet, like a breath that wasn’t meant to be heard.
“I choose you too,” Billy said, squeezing his hand. “For as long as you’ll have me.”
Step 5- make a heaven out of hell
Billy and Steve’s trailer was at the edge of the park. From their kitchen window, they could see the pond where the kids liked to feed the ducks and catch tadpoles. From their bedroom was the forest, the Medium Place’s defence. It lit up with orange in the morning, light kissing them gently in farewell at night.
Pathways led into these woods, where they led to other trailer parks. The Medium Place was expanding at a rapid pace, filling with more and more people, fresh to the afterlife and those who’d been there for centuries, finally pulled from eternal punishment into something more deserving.
The Medium Place wasn’t perfect by any means. People from varying walks of life, in varying shades of grey, lived together. Arguments broke out, enemies were made, crimes were committed. But the Medium Place never loomed with the threat of the Bad Place. Crimes were dealt with in house and punishments dealt accordingly, namely a place worse than torture called ‘a therapist’.
Billy was never sure what agreement Eddie and Chrissy managed to wrangle from the figures up high, but the Medium Place was medium. The water was always lukewarm, television played adverts (mainly local ventures like the new café opening down the street which only opened for three hours during the week and never on the weekend), the sky was always overcast, and every crime novel was written by James Patterson.
But it was perfect for Billy because Steve was there, in the bed, in the kitchen, in the lounge, smiling his dopey smile, spraying his hair with thick hairspray and singing in the shower despite the water pressure being middle road.
They would curl up on their couch, no longer an ugly maroon but a soft lavender. Billy took up knitting, he wasn’t very good, but he had all of eternity to improve. Steve admitted through tears that he wasn’t dyslexic anymore and was now reading all the books he couldn’t before. He and Nancy had formed a book club.
Jonathan and Nancy ran the local newspaper, a chirpy reporter called Ben joining their team after a few months. Robin and Heather were ‘backpacking’ whatever the Medium Place equivalent was, probably camping in the woods, but every time Billy saw them they seemed more and more in love.
He wondered at times, when it was too dark out and the shadows stretched into something sinister, whether his mom was here. Whether Max would arrive soon. Where Neil was.
Eddie offered to show him Neil’s point total once. Billy declined. He didn’t want to see his life in a series of tally marks. Didn’t want to see how little Neil lost in comparison to Billy.
Steve reunited with Tommy and Carol, who made it to their fifties before dying in a car crash. They lived three trailers down and were often round for wine and game night (the wine being the cheapest Store-brand and the game being character-themed Monopoly or Ticket To Ride).
One night, as Steve kissed down his throat, hand spread across Billy’s chest, Billy found the courage to ask, “Would you choose me if you were still alive?”
Steve tweaked his nipple. “I’d choose you in every universe.”
“That’s gay, Steve.”
“I love you.”
“I love you too.”
Outside it started to rain and the lights flickered before going out completely. But they still had the candlelight and each other for company as they made it through another night.
