Chapter Text
Chapter 7- lavender marriage and all its complications.
Steve left to find Nancy.
Billy knew a conversation was needed, and he understood Steve didn’t want to keep it a secret but watching him walk away made his chest ache, nonetheless. Billy stood at the crossroads, one road leading to his ugly house and the other to the lake. He turned to the lake.
The entire world was still as if holding its breath. He walked the path to the lake, kicking loose stones, body still tingling from the kiss. He didn’t know what he’d done, or what it would change. He didn’t know what Brenner would do now, whether Billy failed the test, whether the target actually was Robin and Steve. He didn’t know a lot of things. It hit him how young he’d been on Earth.
Before he decided what to do, he needed to talk to Heather. Maybe she understood better than he did.
The lake sprawled before him, glittering in the sun, blue and green swirling together. But it was still and quiet. It didn’t lap against the golden sand. There were no winds to create waves. No birds or bugs. Just water and the sun and the boat afloat by the dock. It rocked beneath his feet when he stepped onto it.
Heather peered through the window as he walked the length. The door was open. Heather sat on her couch, a deep blue like the ocean.
“How’d it go?” she asked. She didn’t bother to move so he could sit with her but gestured to a small stool tucked beneath the breakfast bar.
Billy perched on the uncomfortable stool. “Not very well. I think I’ve pissed Brenner off.”
“How?”
“By suggesting this isn’t actually the Good Place?”
Heather’s eyes widened and she slumped dramatically backwards. “Oh, thank god I wasn’t the only one who noticed!”
“You knew?”
“Not specifically, but I’ve been suspicious of this paradise since I got here.” She looked around her boathouse and scowled in exaggerated disgust. “This is not my paradise.”
“And Jonathan?” Billy noticed he wasn’t there. There weren’t a lot of personal touches on the boat, everything seemed stale and stagnant, like a hotel room that got cleaned whenever you went out.
“Not here. And I knew when I saw him the universe was wrong.”
She appraised him, leaning forward with her elbows on her knees, chin perched on her hands. She peered through her lashes, fluttering them as she waited for Billy to ask.
“I knew when I saw Robin,” he said instead.
“I’m a lesbian.”
“I’m gay.”
They both relaxed. Heather moved up the couch, leaving enough space for Billy to fall into it.
“This is much better than mine.”
“Yours is horrendous,” she agreed.
“So,” he nudged her shoulder, “you and Robin?”
She blushed and shoved him back, harder. “Whatever. You and Steve?”
“We kissed,” he admitted. Saying it out loud filled him with joy and shame and pride and sadness, it made his stomach clench and his heart beat faster.
“We’ve kissed as well.”
He tried to decide whether or not it was his business to know. Billy and Robin had known about each other from the beginning, knew about Steve and Heather before the other person even understood what was happening. But still, a small bubble of betrayal tried to escape. He swallowed it back down.
“When?”
Heather understood anyway. “Whilst you were doing your sermon. I went to check on her.”
“How is she?”
“Sad and guilty.”
“About kissing you?”
“Yes and no,” Heather said. “It’s complicated. I think it’s something you need to talk about together.”
It was Billy’s turn to study Heather. Her body held a tension which never fully let up, an engrained fight or flight she was reacting on subconsciously. He wondered how she died, because the neighbourhood seemed disproportionately young.
“What about you and Jonathan?”
“We spoke about it, when we first arrived. Agreed to keep pretending. Honestly, I think he’s been waiting for Nancy and Steve to implode.”
Jonathan and Nancy. Heather and Robin. Billy and Steve.
“That worked out well,” he joked.
She smiled but shrugged. “Depends on what happens now. Because this isn’t the Good Place. Everything has been off, mildly inconvenient or uncomfortable. Something you can’t quite put your finger on until afterwards.”
“Like the houses and shops. Nice enough but definitely don’t cater to me.”
They fall into a comfortable silence, letting their bodies move with the gentle sway of the boat. They could make this place a Good Place, Billy thought. If they did some reshuffling, rearranged certain households (and it was a selfish thought, he could admit that now. Because maybe Billy wanted to be soulmates with Steve. Wanted to have a happy afterlife even if he didn’t deserve it).
“What happens now? Do we just go back to pretending?” Billy asked.
He could say now that he would agree to remain as Robin’s soulmate if it stopped them from going to the Bad Place. But it would change their relationship, the knowledge they both had someone else, they could’ve had someone else, but were together for selfish, self-preserving reasons. He also didn’t know what would happen if Steve asked him not to.
“I don’t think I can keep pretending,” Heather replied and buried her face in her hands.
Footsteps sounded out on the dock and Robin’s face peered through the window. She brightened when she saw them, coming through the door moments later. She paused as she took Billy and Heather in.
“You okay?” She seemed nervous.
“I told Billy,” Heather said.
“Oh.” Robin turned to him, reached for his hands. Billy took them, warm hands in warm hands, looking into her pale, anxious face. “I would’ve asked you first, but it got all emotional and sappy, and I couldn’t help myself.”
“I kissed Steve,” Billy cut her off.
Robin dramatically slumped, “Oh, good. Now I feel less bad.”
Heather shifted along the couch even more and Robin wiggled herself between them. Soft hair tickled Billy’s nose.
“How did the sermon go?”
“Billy might have destroyed the neighbourhood,” Heather said cheerfully.
“Nothing major then,” Robin agreed. “Wait, what?”
“I told everyone we aren’t in the Good Place.”
“We aren’t?” She looked between Heather and Billy. They didn’t have to wait long before she slumped. “I knew something was off.”
Heather stood, bent down and pressed a kiss to Robin’s hair. “I think the two of you need to talk.”
Alone, Billy and Robin turned to each other. Robin pulled him into a hug, tucking her head into his neck.
“Are you doing okay?” he whispered into her hair.
“I am now,” she whispered. “It was hard for a while.”
“Why?” he asked gently.
“Because I was quick to reassure you I was okay with all of this. But I wanted a soulmate and when it was you, a part of me was crushed. And you were in the same place as me and were willing to stick it out for a semblance of happiness. I thought I could do it too.”
“And then Heather?” Billy prompted, resting his chin on her head.
“And then Heather,” she agreed. “And I tried so hard, but Heather saw the way you looked at Steve and Steve looked at you, so I thought maybe there was a chance of having both.”
“You can have both, once we figure it out.”
“Okay,” she whispered. “Okay.”
It was Nancy who found him next.
He gave Robin and Heather their space and walked down the strange beach with sand that seemed to get everywhere. The sun was trying to set as he settled on a rock, skipping rocks across the still water.
Someone sat beside him, and from his peripheral vision, he could see Nancy. She tucked her skirt around her legs and rested her hands on her knees.
“Steve’s in love with you,” she said, staring at the horizon.
“I didn’t know,” he said. There was a warmth in his chest though. He smiled at his reflection in the water.
“He said he kissed you.”
“That I did know.” He could feel her glaring and skipped another stone. “What are you actually annoyed about? The fact that he doesn’t want to be with a fake soulmate who didn’t care about him in the same way, or that he didn’t ask your permission first?”
“He’s sweet and kind of a dope,” she said quietly. “If I was alive, I would’ve been happy with him as my boyfriend. But this is eternity we’re talking about. Truthfully, I was disappointed.”
Because she was Nancy, Billy wanted to goad her, but he couldn’t lie to her. “We all were. I think that was the point.”
“You were?”
“I’m gay,” he said simply.
She hummed. They fell silent, watching Billy skip stones. “I am not mad at you or Steve. I was just hurt that he didn’t think he could come to me with his problems.”
Billy didn’t know what to say. He knew Steve probably would’ve tried with Nancy, if she was willing too. But Billy wasn’t as willing to let Steve go now.
“What’s happening with Jonathan?”
She went bright red. “He’s interesting.”
“I think he’s interested in you.”
“He is,” she admitted. “He told me a few days ago.”
“And?”
“I told him I would think about it.”
As he went to speak, the pale orange sky suddenly flared red. A siren blared, exploding the landscape with a cacophony of noise. Both Billy and Nancy covered their ears as the sound rattled their bones.
WARNING! WARNING! SIX HUMANS HAVE BEEN COMPROMISED! WARNING! WARNING! SIX HUMANS HAVE BEEN COMPROMISED! WARNING! WARNING!
The message repeated over and over, the dead, robotic voice echoing across the horizon. Robin and Heather emerged from the boat to stare at the sky, and two figures raced down the hill towards them.
Billy pulled Nancy up with him and they ran back towards the boat. Billy didn’t know why the boat felt safer than anywhere else, he was sure if he really wanted to, Brenner could find them. Drain the lake, land-lock them.
They reached it at the same time as Steve and Jonathan, both panting and wild-eyed. Steve shoved them all in, sending the three of them stumbling down the stairs. Heather and Robin helped stabilise them as Steve slammed the door behind them.
Heather and Jonathan closed all the curtains bar a slither of glass that showed the path to town. The noise was muffled in the boat, but the sky still flashed the warning red.
“So, definitely not the Good Place,” Heather panted, collapsing back on the couch.
“It still could be,” Nancy pointed out. “It could be they made a mistake, and we aren’t supposed to be here.”
“All six of us?” Jonathan asked.
“They called us humans,” Steve said. He leant against Billy, tugging him close. If it was anyone else, the gesture would’ve been constraining, but because it was Steve, Billy folded himself further into his side.
“What did you say to them?” Heather asked Billy. The joking tone in her voice was completely gone from earlier. She meant business now. “The exact words.”
“I said it was a test I needed to pass to get into the Good Place and implied we were still stuck in purgatory. Brenner seemed pleased.”
Jonathan frowned from his shadowed corner. “Why would they not just tell us it’s purgatory?”
“Why are there only six of us,” Robin also asked.
That gave them all pause. Why did Brenner form a purgatory for six humans and fill it with over a hundred entities, most who they most likely have never met? Why not just gather one hundred people and say, ‘hey, you’re in purgatory, good luck getting out!’?
“Tina,” Robin said, sitting up suddenly. They turned to her and Billy gestured for her to elaborate. “Tina was specifically trying to get us to stay in a horrendous romantic relationship whilst flaunting her own sapphic relationship in our faces.”
“So, people have been actively hindering us?” Nancy asked. “Like, Jason.” Here, Steve’s eyes lit up in a revelation.
“I don’t think this is purgatory either,” Heather said. “I think purgatory would be neutral. This place has been actively working against us. I think this might be the Bad Place!”
That… made sense. A horrifying, dreadful amount of sense.
(Of course, Billy Hargrove wouldn’t even make it to purgatory.)
“What do we do?” Robin whispered.
“I don’t know,” Billy said.
Outside, the siren blared and Brenner’s eye searched for them using the moon and stars.
