Chapter Text
“You have a sharp eye, Mr. Baggins!” Oakenshield exclaimed with feeling, giving Bilbo an approving clap on the shoulder. Bilbo could hardly disagree: he really was observant. But now that very observance frightened him more than a whole pack of orcs.
Thorin was not himself. And, it seemed, he had once again forgotten Bilbo’s name.
Back in Esgaroth, Bilbo had noticed the subtle changes that came over Oakenshield’s face as he stared long at the majestic slopes of Erebor. At times he would stand alone by a window, as if rooted to the spot, gazing at the Mountain when the mist cleared. Then, just as suddenly, he would shake off that stony mask and throw himself into everyday matters with renewed vigor.
At the time, Baggins had chalked up those small oddities in Thorin’s behavior to worry – for the fate of their group (Kili was growing worse by the day) and for the quest itself. But he had been wrong. And the closer and more tangible Erebor and its treasure hoard became, the more clearly he realized it.
Thorin was obsessed – and stubbornly refused to admit it. Bilbo tried to speak to the others in their small company, tried to tell them that something was wrong with Thorin, that he needed help. They refused to see the problem until the very end. All the while, it was rapidly getting worse. Their journey had lasted more than half a year, yet it had taken only a couple of weeks among the glittering trinkets of the kingdom for Oakenshield to go off the rails and become a shadow of himself. Bilbo could no longer tell what had been real: the Thorin he had known before, or that stone mask that had first shown itself back in Esgaroth, which Thorin had simply learned to hide so well.
“You were only ever a means to an end. That coward Oakenshield has weighed the value of your life and found it worth no-thing.” Smaug was dead, but his insinuating voice never left Bilbo’s head for even a moment. The hobbit fought it with the last of his strength. At the thought of the dragon, Baggins felt an unbearable itch in the left pocket of his jacket, where the Arkenstone lay wrapped in the first scrap of cloth he’d found.
Bilbo leaned against the cold wall beside the granite bench where he had sat down not long ago, seeking a moment of silence, and closed his eyes. He was dead tired – drawn and hollow-eyed, unable to sleep, with no appetite at all (something he would never have expected of himself). Baggins gave a bleak little smile. In a way, he and Thorin were alike: the cursed gem was driving them both mad. The difference was that the King under the Mountain wanted only the Arkenstone and nothing else, while Bilbo would have given up every diamond in the world just to have the old Thorin back.
The hobbit opened his eyes and looked at the acorn he held carefully in his hand, untouched by all the hardships of the journey. His nose prickled, and Bilbo dabbed at it with the handkerchief Bofur had given him. From his conversations with Balin, he had a general idea of what was happening to Oakenshield: the same madness that had overtaken Thorin’s grandfather Thrór was awakening in him – obsession taken to its extreme, boundless greed, the infamous Dragon-sickness.
Bilbo had grown attached to Thorin far more than he could have imagined – or cared to admit. He was perceptive in all matters except his own feelings, and he held long emotional soul-searching in quiet contempt. So the realization came late (and only thanks to the extreme circumstances they now found themselves in): the dwarf he had not known at all less than a year ago had become unimaginably dear to him.
Long ago he could have handed over the cursed stone, taken his share, and rushed back to the Shire at full speed, pockets jingling with the gold of Erebor’s hoards. He had helped the dwarves reclaim their home; he could have gone back to his own.
Bilbo bit his lip nervously. Nonsense. Perhaps he could – but warg take it, he didn’t want to. It hurt him physically to see Thorin in this state. And this wasn’t really Thorin anymore, but a greedy, ruthless King under the Mountain.
Bilbo truly was observant, and he had had time to study Oakenshield, who was by no means free of flaws: secretive, not particularly gentle with strangers, calculating, stubborn, and excessively proud. But he had been different, too.
Thorin knew how to listen – and how to hear. He was sensible and clever (for a dwarf; for at times Bilbo suspected that the only proper brain cell in the whole company – aside from his own – belonged to Balin, and that Thorin merely borrowed it now and then). He could look at you with such warmth that it felt as though he’d gladly give you his last crumb of food and was genuinely glad to see you of all people. He was caring, and he would fight to the death for those he loved and for what mattered to him. That was the Thorin Bilbo had seen, the Thorin he had come to know, the Thorin he had grown attached to – and the Thorin he was now losing at a frightening pace.
Baggins remembered the old dwarf-tales his mother had told him: according to legend, one of the Ainur (the Valar), the smith Aulë (or Mahal in Khuzdul), had carved the first dwarves from stone and made the fruits of their own craft the purpose of their lives. Poor dwarves – along with their skill, astonishing endurance, and strength – had been given an incredible greed, pride, and hard-headedness (both literal and figurative). Of course, they were not the only ones who could fall prey to the Sickness: men, elves – anyone could. But the flaws unintentionally woven into the dwarves, alongside their useful and admirable traits, made them the most vulnerable to it. And yet Bilbo still stubbornly refused to believe that Thorin was the same. It seemed the hobbit could give dwarves a run for their money when it came to obstinacy: once he made up his mind, it stayed made.
He didn’t know what to do. Balin had told him about the Arkenstone’s sacred and political importance to the dwarves of Middle-earth. This stone – stunning beyond measure, yet still only a stone – could, all by itself, unite scattered groups into a single mighty people. Bilbo could not – simply could not – decide its fate alone. But the price of that unity would be Thorin’s sanity, and a senseless war with the Wood-elves and the Men of Esgaroth, a war the King under the Mountain was ready to start just to protect his riches.
As if anyone were trying to take them from him.
Bilbo clenched and unclenched the hand holding the acorn. The weight beneath his eyes felt like lead, and he knew that a little more and he would simply lie down here from sheer exhaustion. For ever. In Erebor, there was no one he could turn to. He feared – with good reason – that the dwarves would not understand him (though even they had recently begun to worry about their king’s state of mind) if he told them that the Arkenstone could not remain in the kingdom. Bilbo was left alone with his torment – and the cursed gem.
“What is that you’re holding?”
Ah yes. And with a mad King under the Mountain.
☜ ☞
Thorin searched in vain. He prowled feverishly through the web of stairways and halls of Erebor, but the Burglar was nowhere to be found – not around any corner, not in any passage. Passing yet another empty corridor, the dwarf finally spotted a familiar silhouette in an archway: Baggins was sitting hunched on a bench, nervously turning something over in his hands.
He has found the Arkenstone. At that thought, the dull, painful itch that had been tormenting Thorin flared at once. He was swallowed by the sensation; it felt as though muscles and nerves, drawn tight as strings, were about to snap from the strain.
Oakenshield closed the distance between himself and the hobbit in a few long strides. The pounding roar in his head was deafening. He did not even hear his own question; all his attention narrowed to a single desire – to feel the weight of the diamond in his hands at once.
The Arkenstone. His Arkenstone. The greatest treasure of Erebor, whose beauty recalled the legendary Silmaril set in the Nauglamír.[25] A symbol of boundless power. It alone was worth any sacrifice, any blood spilled, any tears shed. Thorin had to claim it; he had endured too much not to. The gem was his by right.
Oakenshield stared without blinking at the hobbit’s hands, held behind his back. Impatience swelled, yet Thorin did not move. He savored the aching tension that wracked his body in anticipation. Any moment now, his face would be lit by that dazzling white glow, shimmering with every color of the rainbow.
Thorin was ready for this meeting. It seemed he had been yearning for it for a very long time indeed. But he was not ready for what he finally saw.
An acorn?
Thorin faltered. Why an acorn?
“…in Beorn’s garden.” The ringing in his ears gave way to a crushing silence. Thorin forgot what he had been thinking about before. Had he been thinking at all? He remembered wanting something fiercely. What was it he wanted? Despair welled up inside him. He shifted his gaze from the acorn to the speaker.
Bilbo.
Bilbo looked embarrassed, yet he met Thorin’s eyes directly and openly – without a trace of fear or reproach, the kind that sometimes flickered in the looks of others. He smiled at Thorin warmly, and in his eyes burned… hope? The hobbit hesitated, then carefully slipped the acorn into his pocket. Like a treasure, a thought flashed through Oakenshield’s mind.
“…I’ll remember everything: the good, the…”
Another realization began to stir. Thorin forced the cogs of thought into motion; their grinding sent a sharp lance of pain through his temples. The haze before his eyes slowly thinned. Click. In his chest, a tightly wound spring snapped open with a powerful jolt. Mahal. That tiny fruit of an oak from the grove by the skin-changer’s garden – carried by Bilbo all the way through this journey like a priceless trophy – was his reminder of Thorin.
Heat washed over the dwarf. Warmth flooded his insides like molten gold and spilled outward in one of the brightest, most sincere smiles he had ever worn. Memories of Thorin were Bilbo’s treasure? Oakenshield recalled that he had not seen the hobbit among the others in Erebor’s gem-filled grotto. The immeasurable riches of the Lonely Mountain – and his rightful one fourteenth share of them – had not interested him?
Bilbo had long since finished speaking, but Thorin did not notice the silence hanging in the corridor. All that held him was a pair of amber eyes, glowing with a gentle light and looking at him with boundless devotion – and something more. He had seen that look before, in his nephews’ eyes, and in Dís’s.
Thorin held his breath. A sharp, nervous chill ran over his skin.
Oakenshield remembered how he had doubted Bilbo, how he had dismissed him. He had not intended to answer for the life of some clumsy, cowardly hobbit and could not understand why Thârkun[26] so stubbornly insisted on taking him along. “He will surprise you yet.” Thorin had not believed the wizard, but his persistence – and Thorin’s own curiosity – had prevailed. When the Burglar collapsed into yet another faint in the Misty Mountains, Thorin rolled his eyes and recalled Gandalf’s words. Well, no one said the surprise would be a pleasant one. When the hobbit, with a fervor not found in every dwarf, vowed to help them reclaim Erebor, Thorin found himself oddly unsettled. Could the wizard have been right after all? Was the hobbit not so simple as he appeared?
At his age, Oakenshield was rarely surprised, astonished even less so, and truly shaken only a handful of times in his life. But when the hobbit – who until then had cut little more than bread – stabbed an orc far stronger and taller than himself with fierce desperation, and did not leave Thorin’s side as (this time) he lay senseless (what an irony), even when they were surrounded, Oakenshield had been shaken to his core. From that moment on, he never doubted Bilbo again.
Thorin found it fascinating to watch their Burglar. In the grumbling, stubborn, and at times desperate hobbit, he sometimes glimpsed a reflection of himself. He did not know how to repay Baggins for all he had done for him and for their company. He had nothing to offer but a dubious, deadly quest. Even a share of the treasure he could not truly guarantee. And yet Bilbo – who had first heard of the King under the Mountain barely half a year ago – remained at his side, stubbornly believing in their mad undertaking, believing in Thorin. And the dwarf did not notice the moment when, in so short a time, the hobbit became an important, inseparable part of his life.
Oakenshield was a dwarf to the marrow: he was used to crafting treasures and possessing them. Yet it seemed that for the first time, he himself had become such a treasure – for someone outside his family.
He had always known what he wanted. But now he needed something more. Before that thought could fully take shape, the sound of footsteps tore Thorin from his reverie.
“Thorin, survivors are streaming into Dale,” Dwalin’s voice echoed down the corridor. Oakenshield’s gaze hardened instantly. Dwalin went on speaking, but the King under the Mountain no longer heard him.
The Arkenstone. He needed his Arkenstone.
