Actions

Work Header

I see (you in) fire

Chapter 7: Traditions

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“By my mother’s beard, Thorin, I’ve got no idea what you mean.”

Dwarves were conservative folk and fiercely proud of their traditions and customs. From generation to generation they were carefully preserved within each clan. The clan of the Sigin-tarâg – the Longbeards, from which all of Thorin’s company hailed – once the most respected and numerous among the Dwarves of Middle-earth, was no exception. Tradition shaped every part of their lives, from the stages of an individual dwarf’s coming of age to the structure of their society as a whole. It governed marriage as well.[27]

That matter was approached rationally and pragmatically. A household was founded by dwarves who had completed their apprenticeship and come into maturity – between forty and fifty years of age – on a solid footing of craft mastery, steady means, and a warm, safe place to live. And it was taken very seriously. Dwarves were monogamous; divorce did not exist in their society, and even when separated by distance, the pairs remained tied by strong, unbreakable bonds.

Their people were not known for romance, yet almost every marriage was preceded by a long – sometimes years-long – period of courtship, with its own rules and customs, likewise grounded in practical, material concerns. “Tokens of regard” included displays of strength, skill at one’s craft, and prosperity. The latter found expression in gifts:[28] what mattered was their value, their uniqueness, and how personal they were. Most were made by the dwarf himself, though purchased items were not unheard of.

Thorin was unwed and had never initiated courtship. At the time of Smaug’s attack on Erebor he was only twenty-four, and his parents had not yet given thought to finding him a suitable match. In the years of wandering that followed, and during their brief stay in Dunland, such thoughts were pointless: all attention was bent toward survival and helping one’s kin. Soon came a fresh chain of tragedies – the murder of Thrór, the bloody war with the Orcs that cut down their already weakened clan even further, and another stretch of wandering, until at last they managed to settle in the mines of the Blue Mountains.

At first the workings brought little profit, having been nearly exhausted. This gnawed at Thorin’s father, Thráin: the hunger for gold gave him no peace, and he vanished without a trace after hastily setting out for Erebor in 2841. By then Thorin had only recently crossed into full maturity, and at ninety-five he inherited a heavy burden – the care of his younger sister and a whole blood-drained clan, meagre means, and an all-consuming thirst for vengeance. Hardly the foundation for a home of his own.

In time, matters improved. The clan prospered in its own way, and Dís founded a household of her own, where Thorin’s nephews, Fili and Kili, were soon born. The crushing weight borne by the King gradually lifted, and Thorin could finally have thought of his own future – but he… simply did not want to. He lacked neither attention nor interest from the few dwarf-women of the Blue Mountains, yet none stirred his heart. He did not think about heirs: first, without Erebor there was nothing to inherit, and talk of its return was not yet on the table; second, Fili and Kili were enough for him – he loved them as his own sons. If he were to die, there would be someone to take his place as King. Thorin withdrew into himself, and in that light, solitude felt fitting. He had found something to whichhe could devote his strength and his thoughts, and he had a small family nonetheless. He desired no more.

So it was that in Esgaroth, in Bard’s house, the point of their leader’s question did not dawn on Bofur at once. Thorin himself grasped the meaning of their exchange even later. At the time of the quest, only Glóin among the company had a household of his own – and children to boot. That was why Oakenshield grew wary when Bofur, for no apparent reason, presented Bilbo with a peculiar gift. He liked the hobbit’s reaction even less: it was plain the thing pleased him. Once Thorin learned that the kerchief was just a kerchief, with no hidden meaning or subtext, he relaxed. And then tensed again as another question crept in: why had it mattered to him at all? But pressing concerns soon claimed his full attention, and he pushed the thought aside.

Now the King under the Mountain was once more pacing slowly across the hills of jewels in Erebor’s treasury, taking fierce pleasure in the sight of every object there. He longed to gather it all into his arms, to become one with it, and never, ever let it go again. Of course, none of the hoard could compare to the Arkenstone, yet that did not make it any less precious or necessary to Thorin. Everything here was his – his by right, and his alone. And he would guard his treasures at any cost.

As he rounded one of the pillars, his eye caught a white gleam from within a chest. For a heartbeat he thought it might be the coveted gem, but drawing closer, Thorin saw it was no stone at all, but a coat of mail. He bent and lifted it. Mithril. True-silver. A metal of incredible beauty, rarity, and worth – light as a raven’s feather and strong as a dragon’s scale. Thorin stared absently at the armour set with white gems, whose value was second only to the priceless Arkenstone. Something troubled him. The mail was small, likely meant for someone young – or of slighter build.

Oakenshield studied the piece again, more closely now, more thoughtfully. To protect the treasure. That was the thought circling at the edge of his mind.

“Almost perfect…” Thorin folded the mail and slipped it beneath his cloak. He needed to find Bilbo.

☜ ☞

Baggins would never forget Smaug’s piercing eyes. Each of them alone had been larger than the hobbit himself – but that wasn’t even the worst of it (well, not only that). It was the way they looked. In the home library of Bag End, Bilbo had always loved illustrated books best. Not that he lacked imagination, but pictures set it alight all the more. The dragon’s burning amber eyes had reminded him of an illustration of waking volcanoes from one such book – their fiercely churning mouths both alluring and deadly. Paired with that cloying, sing-song, insinuating voice, the effect had been unforgettable and terrifying. That gaze you want to surrender – and to run as fast and as far away as you could.

Bilbo shivered and squirmed on the jacket spread beneath him on the cold stone floor. There came a soft chime of mithril rings. According to Thorin, the impossibly strong armour was almost weightless, yet to Baggins it felt as though he could not move at all. The mail bound him, pressed on him, nearly choked him.

He could feel a gaze fixed upon him. During their journey he had grown used to Thorin watching him constantly, and had stopped feeling awkward or trying to explain such excessive attention – but now that look spread a nasty, sticky fear through his insides. Bilbo was unhappy with the mail not only because it implied taking part in battle, but also because it had not been Thorin who gave it to him.

He had begun to regard Oakenshield with unease, though stubbornly refusing to avoid him, hoping to glimpse the old Thorin again and pull him back from the grip of madness. Baggins’s heart had skipped a beat when, to his amazement, he succeeded. Thorin remembered Beorn’s garden, remembered the oak grove. And then it dropped through the floor hours later, when Bilbo saw the King again. A dragon. Thorin looked and spoke like Smaug. (The dragon is dead – long live the dragon, indeed) That was when the hobbit grew truly uneasy.

The gaze was hard, commanding, greedy – frighteningly cold and empty. Bilbo did not need to turn his head to know that this was how Thorin was looking at him now. As Baggins tried on the mail under the “watchful” eye of the newly crowned Smaug, the other dwarves nearby in the armoury exchanged sly smiles and nodded approvingly. Then they visibly wilted and frowned when they caught their King’s eye. Oh – so it had reached them at last. Dwarf-level mpaths, may the Valar bless them.

Bilbo’s despair found a whole new low when that seemed impossible already. He was shaking with panic and anger – at himself, for being unable to decide anything; at the dwarves, who were no help at all; and at that stupid, useless bauble bearing the lofty name the Heart of the Mountain.

Lost in his turmoil, Baggins failed to notice the rest of the company drifting into the far hall of the armoury – where he sat with the ghost of Smaug, Glóin, Óin, and Balin – carrying plates of whatever they had managed to scrounge up for supper. The sight of the mushroom stew Bombur handed him made Bilbo feel sick. He had no appetite whatsoever.

He poked the food gloomily with his spoon but could not force himself to eat even a mouthful, staring dully instead at the fire burning in the hearth. Its light, along with that of the torches lining the walls, flickered over the faces of the dwarves as they ate. Bilbo chewed his lip, thinking feverishly. He had wasted a great deal of time on these thoughts and come no closer to an answer. Meanwhile, December had come outside Erebor – nearly a month had passed since they had settled within the Mountain. The patience of elves and men was wearing thin, and the cold breath of war felt ever closer.

The clatter of spoons faded, and the dwarves sank into contented warmth by the fire. In all the bustle, Bilbo forgot entirely about his strange visions. The last time he had seen anything of the sort had been in the Misty Mountains, and much water had flowed since then. He thought that at least on that front he could finally relax – and was sorely mistaken. He had no idea why such “grace” had descended upon him, but the dwarves, it seemed, were determined to help the hobbit stay on edge at all costs.

Bofur was no kin of Durin’s royal line – just a working dwarf, simple, open, not especially sharp, but kind and understanding. Bilbo liked him very much, but sometimes… Baggins’s head was slowly turning toward the dwarf who, settling comfortably on a makeshift pallet of jacket and cap, suddenly began to sing. Sometimes he wanted to throttle him – and the others along with him, too. The already impressive list in Bilbo’s head titled “Would I ever have thought, half a year ago, that…” had just gained a new entry: “…that I would so desperately want to kill someone?”

The thought had barely formed when others joined Bofur, and the song spilled through the hall, at the far end of which sat Thorin, “breathing fire”. I need to leave. Bilbo was exhausted, and thinking now came as hard to him as it did to his dwarf-friends, so he hesitated. And when the fire in the hearth slid into his line of sight – he realized it was far too late.

Daladbundûn dushkadahan
The King has come into his hall!
kuth agnân hûl
tragû ’ugrul
And ever so his foes shall fall.
[29]

Was it just Bilbo – or had time stopped, the darkness around him turning almost solid?

The sword is sharp, the spear is long,
The arrow swift, the Gate is strong;
The heart is bold
that looks on gold;
The dwarves no more shall suffer wrong.

Was he imagining it, or had he stood up without noticing?

Now call we over mountains cold,
'Come hack unto the caverns old'!
Here at the Gates
the king awaits,
His hands are rich with gems and gold.

Right. The fire. It needs to be put out. With what – what do you put out a fire with?

The king is come unto his hall
Under the Mountain dark and tall.
The Worm of Dread
is slain and dead,
And ever so our foes shall fall!

“Bilbo!”

Notes:

[27]The depiction of Dwarven culture here was largely inspired by this source (translation needed): https://enir.in/viewtopic.php?id=7210&p=32 [return to text]

[28]For aspects of Dwarven courtship customs, the following post was particularly helpful: https://www.tumblr.com/luna-redamancy/182566737978/dwarves-are-private-very-secretive-but-caring[return to text]

[29]The lines in Khuzdul are taken from the quatrain “ Under the Mountain dark and tall <…> His foe is dead, the Worm of Dread,…” — from the song “Under the Mountain dark and tall.” The Khuzdul translation is by A. Bazarov and can be found here: http://khuzdul.su/blog/pesnja_korol_zakonnyj_zanjal_tron_under_the_mountain_dark_and_tall_na_kkhuzdule/2019-09-23-25 [return to text]