Actions

Work Header

Strange Alloys

Chapter 10: The Beacons

Chapter Text

Kili had not said anything since they had been marched out the great hall. Not a single word. They were taken through tunnels under the City, away from the crowds, until they reached one of the smaller gates that led out into the forest. There, the regular Guard had handed them over to the praetorians, to Fili’s surprise. The praetorians were rarely seen outside of the palace, and he didn’t know them by their faces, only their dark uniforms with the king’s sigil emblazoned on the chest.

“Can’t we pack a bag?” Fili asked them. “We’re allowed to take spare clothes and some personal things. I thought that was how this worked.”

“You’ll be provided for,” the captain of the praetorian’s said stiffly. “Follow me, please.”

So at least the praetorians were polite. It was slow and uncomfortable walking through the increasingly root-knotted and uneven forest path with their arms bound. Kili tripped once, but one of the praetorians knelt and helped him up, saying almost kindly, “There you go, Master Dwarf, take more care.”

Slowly their path began to rise. Fili wasn’t familiar with this part of the forest, but it was clear that Kili was, as he made the turns without waiting for the praetorians to direct them and was almost striding ahead by the time the trees began to thin and they crested the ridge. At last Fili realised they were nearly at the top of the Stargazing Hill, the only high point in Mirkwood close to the City. He’d been here once for a summer solstice festival, years earlier. It looked very different when it was empty of tents and hanging ribbons. It was a peaceful place, with a contemplative view across a swathe of forest and over the Long Lake. A grassy meadow lay sheltered between the ring of huge boulders that sat just below the peak, like a crown on a huge, green head.

“Go inside the circle,” the captain pointed towards the ring of boulders.

“Why are we here?” Fili asked. He tried to catch the captain’s eye. “What is going on?”

Kili followed their orders without question, and there was not much Fili could do except stick close to him. Once they were near the centre of the summit, within the circle of stones, the praetorians undid their bonds. The captain took out a small bottle of dark, brown glass. “Have some of this; about half each should be more than enough, but you don’t have to take it all at once.”

“What is it?” Fili asked. He didn’t reach for the bottle.

“It’s a tincture. It will make you calmer, make you not care,” the captain said.

“We’re not taking that,” Fili snapped. The captain held out the bottle to Kili. After a moment Kili shook his head.

“As you wish,” the elf tossed the bottle in the grass. “It’s there if you change your mind. We will be going now, but my archers will be posted around the entire hill. If you try to leave the stone circle, you will be shot. No warnings.”

“Then when can we leave?” Fili asked. It was late in the afternoon, and he did not fancy walking in the dark.

“Everything will become clear,” the captain nodded his head, almost like a salute. He seemed about to go, half turning away. Then he spoke again. “They said you are here only for your brother. You are very brave. I am sorry for you.”

Fili’s throat was dry. “Kili is innocent. Neither of us should be here.”

“Perhaps,” the captain said. “But our stocks are low, and this has to be done.”

As the captain walked away, Kili sat down in the long grass and crossed his arms over his knees, facing the widest gap in the mismatched boulders. Fili sat down beside him. They both looked out across the tree-tops, waves of silver flickering across the leaves as the breeze passed over them. They could see all the way to the far side of the lake. It struck Fili with some awe, after spending most of his life enclosed by trees and buildings. Beyond the water was the tiny, dark arrow of the Lonely Mountain, that long-lost home of their parents and grandparents. Once the praetorians let them go, Fili decided they would head in that direction.

Fili had been to Esgaroth a couple of times, with Thorin, before Thorin ran away. It seemed like that would be the most sensible place to go once they were released onto the road and their exile officially began. They might even find news of their uncle there, or if not, they could carry on towards the Iron Hills, where Fili knew they had some distant cousins. He didn’t know what they’d do for food and money, but surely someone would have work for two young and healthy dwarves. All that mattered was that they stuck together and looked after each other.

“By all that’s green, I’m thirsty,” Fili said, breaking off a few grass stalks and absent-mindedly beginning to plait them, just for something to do. “I haven’t had anything to drink since Ma and I left the house this morning.”

Kili still didn’t say anything. His face looked so empty, Fili wondered if he’d even heard the words.

“At the trial,” Fili said cautiously. “You know you said Thorin was wrongly accused of training child soldiers?”

Still no reply, except perhaps a slight narrowing of Kili’s eyes, but that might just have been against the glare of the late afternoon sun.

“Well, Thorin was trying to train child soldiers. The plans for a Khuzdul school were real, but it was always a front for a secret training camp.”

Kili’s head whipped around, his eyes wide. “What?”

Fili could not stop himself laughing at his brother’s face, which finally looked like Kili again. “Not actually kids, of course not. But young dwarves, school leavers and upwards, everyone born after the weapons prohibition. He wanted us to be ready, in case we had to survive outside the City. So that one day, when we retook Erebor, we could hold it and defend it. He was going to teach us all to fight. Him and a few old warriors he trusted, Dwalin and Oin and some others.”

“Why didn’t you tell me?”

“We couldn’t,” Fili looked out over the forest. “If we’d been caught and anything was linked back to you, you’d have lost your position in the Guard for sure. After Thorin left, Dwalin and I picked everything up, as best we could. We’ve been running the school in basements around the City ever since.”

Kili stared at him. He jabbed at his chest. “What about me? I thought that was the whole point of me joining the Guard, I thought he wanted more dwarves in the Guard!”

Out of the corner of Fili’s eye, Fili saw movement at the edge of the stone circle. They both looked over to see two praetorians climbing up onto one of the taller, flat-topped boulders. A third praetorian began to pass what looked like long, thick logs of dry wood up to them. Quickly, the elves were constructing some kind of tall, stacked tower of wood. Fili looked around and saw another team constructing something similar on a boulder on the other side.

“I was going to tell you, the morning you were arrested,” Fili tossed his plaited grass-stalks into the wind. “I needed your help. We have three hundred trainees in the school who can swing an old-fashioned sword or a dwarvish warhammer, but don’t know which way up to hold a bow or how to use their off-hand for anything more than scratching their sacks. I wanted you to train them,” he sighed. “I guess it’s Dwalin’s problem, now.”

“Why did I bother going through all this Guard stuff if Thorin was just going to break the law anyway?” Kili muttered.

Fili turned back to his brother. “You think Thorin didn’t have a contingency plan? Thorin was always playing one hand behind the other. Ma acts like Thranduil is the mighty schemer in this City but he had to be, or he’d have lost control to Thorin years ago. Of course Thorin wasn’t expecting the entire reclamation of the Lonely Mountain and rebuilding of Erebor to depend on you surviving your basic training,” Fili laughed again.

“It’s not funny. I worked really hard. I thought he was relying on me,” Kili grumbled. He folded his arms across his knees, buried his face in his forearms and swore, colourfully and a little tearfully. He finished the outburst with, “It isn’t fair.”

Fili touched his arm. “Thorin was proud of you. He will still be proud of you, when we find him. And we’ll all be together, at least.”

Kili raised his head, sniffing and rubbing his eyes with his shoulder. “Except Ma. We’ll never see Ma again.”

Fili looked over at the praetorians who had apparently finished building their two pyres on opposite sides of the stone circle. They were large bonfires, and the elves were now threading some kind of long, dry, leafy branches through the lattice of kindling. The leaves looked a strange, powdery white, like they were covered in some kind of crushed stone or minerals.

“We’ve got time. Things are changing in the City. A lot of people think you’re innocent, and not just the dwarves. Maybe Ori or Balin will be able to clear your name and they’ll let you come back.”

Kili’s face went grim and cold. “I need to go back. I need to find out who really killed Tauriel.”

Fili sighed. “We need to survive in the world outside until then. Let’s focus on that.”

He shuffled closer and reached his arms around Kili’s shoulders. Kili leaned into him, hiding his face in Fili’s hair, and gripped Fili’s shoulder as his body heaved with deep sobs. Fili held him close and mumbled whatever came to mind. “It’s alright. I’ll be with you. We’ll figure it out together.”

Over Kili’s shoulder, he saw that the sun was just starting to brush the tops of the Misty Mountains. On the boulders, one praetorian stood beside each of the newly-built bonfires. As Fili watched, the light began to fade towards dusk. At last, the praetorians handed up a torch to each of their comrades beside the pyre, and the fire was put to the wood. As the stacks began to burn, and the powdered leaves caught, Fili saw that the flames dancing along the leaves were not the colour of the sunset but tinged instead with a bright, green glow.

—

The sun had almost vanished as Bilbo and Thorin came along a quiet forest path to the edge of the City. When Bilbo had come here alone, he had entered via the main road, through the huge cathedral of trees that formed the promenade in front of the main west gate. This time, Thorin led him to a small gate on the north side, not much larger than a double-leafed door in an ordinary house. The daylight was just starting to fade, and the doors to the City were still thrown wide open.

“It looks like we could just walk in,” Bilbo said, taking a step out of the thick trees.

“No!” Thorin grabbed his arms. “There’ll be regular patrols along the walls, even by day. We’ll wait for one to pass, then slip in before the next comes.”

Bilbo huffed. He felt impatient, both from the urgency of Dis’ letter and for his stomach, which was beginning to rumble after a full day travelling from Laketown. Once they were inside, he was hoping they’d first head for Thorin’s sister’s house, and maybe she would feed them while they caught up with the situation and planned what to do next. They probably had days or weeks before Kili’s trial.

Bilbo looked up at the surrounding trees. “I bet I can see over the wall from up there,” he pointed. “Let me have a look for the patrols. When it’s safe, I’ll whistle down, and you go in first. Wait for me inside, I won’t be long.”

Thorin made a step from his own hands and heaved Bilbo up into the lowest branches of a tall conifer standing close to the wall. From there, the branches were thick enough that Bilbo could clamber up with only a brief, nervous glance towards the forest floor far below. The light was still good under the canopy, but he didn’t want to delay. The shadows under the trees were growing deeper as dusk wore on, and it would not be so long before darkness would make it difficult to climb back down. He could not imagine trying to survive alone in the branches overnight. He’d probably have to ask Thorin to call the forest Guard to come and rescue him with their keen elven eyes, like a kitten stuck in a tree. He’d rather be taken into the City in shackles than fall to his death in the night.

He climbed as high as he could, until the thin branches near the top were only just supporting his weight. He’d picked a good tree, as the conifer stood a little higher than the canopy surrounding it, and was definitely higher than the wall. He peered out as far as he could dare. Within the City wall, there was still a great deal of trees, but they were sparser and more well-trimmed, and between them were strung long lines of Mithril-lamps that were already glowing in the early dusk. Tucked between the branches were the many curved roofs with their red clay tiles or grey slates, their beams and lintels shaped into swoops or carved patterns like braids and twisted rope. There were a few people walking in the mild evening air, an occasional laugh carrying all the way to where Bilbo watched. It looked beautiful and very peaceful. It was hard to believe this was all built on the blood of sacrifices to a dragon.

The street that followed the line of the wall had been kept clear and open of trees, presumably to stop branches overhanging the wall on either side. Bilbo could see the regimented uniforms of two elves on patrol walking along the inner path, just past the gate.

“I think it’s safe to go in,” he called down.

From below, Thorin’s voice floated back. “Sh!”

As Bilbo tried to establish his route back down through the increasingly shadowed branches, he looked behind him at the wild forest. “Hold on,” He murmured, mostly to himself, and then called down to Thorin. “There are new lights above the forest, to the north.”

“Keep it down, Mr Baggins, elves have keen ears!”

“Two green lights,” Bilbo said to himself, squinting at the two glowing points that were shining above the growing gloom of the forest. Something was nagging at his thoughts. His thoughts strayed to his instruction to Dis, after they’d first met days ago, to put a colourful candle in her window to summon him if she needed him. The huge, starry dome of the sky arched above him, white stars shining between the clouds. Bilbo called down to Thorin again, “Is there a hill, maybe three miles or so to the north of here?”

After a moment Thorin replied, “Yes, that’ll be Stargazer Hill. Can you come down and stop yelling, if you please?”

Bilbo felt all heat drain from the night air. His heart began to race. “Green stars, up the hill,” he whispered. He grabbed for the branches below him and began to swing himself down as fast as he could go, no longer thinking about the drop or getting stuck. He half-climbed and half tumbled off the lowest branches of the tree. Thorin was waiting to catch him but Bilbo gave him no warning and missed him entirely, just barely landing on his feet in the piled leaves. He grabbed Thorin’s arm. “Green stars. They’re called green stars in the records. The praetorians light green beacons for Smaug, and the records said the dwarves are exiled on the hill - they’re talking about Stargazer Hill. Thorin, it’s happening now. Tonight.”

Thorin rasped, “They’re summoning the dragon. Kili is up there.”

“If we hurry can rally dwarves from the City—“

“You go. Find my sister, tell her everything. Maybe she can still stop it,” Thorin’s eyes stared through the trees. “I have to go up there.”

“Up there?” Bilbo frowned at him. “Thorin, what on earth are you going to do? They won’t let you just walk in and take him away! And you certainly can’t fight the dragon on your own!”

Thorin met his eye at last. A spasm of regret crossed his face. “I will not stand here and watch it happen again.”

“Thorin,” Bilbo said, more desperately. “Don’t do what I think you’re going to do. Please. I… I don’t want you to. That’s all I can say.”

Thorin smiled at him, soft and full. He leaned in and kissed him once, quickly, his large hand ghosting briefly over Bilbo’s cheek. And then he was gone, and Bilbo was left in the cold, alone, staring into the shadows of the trees.

--

Dis was in her office off the Tinkerer’s guild, taking a moment to try and gather herself. She had spent the day doing whatever she could to cause trouble in public. She hoped that if she was loud enough and difficult enough, if she convinced enough people that this was worth the fight, it would somehow, somehow, somehow bring them back.

Ori and Berior had arranged a gathering outside the Great Hall, with a rota of dwarves and young elves chanting and handing out papers outlining their case for Kili’s innocence. Dwalin had his own network of young dwarves, who he said were friends of Fili’s. Dwalin had sent them to watch any Guards on patrol around the City, in case there was any sighting or news of her sons. He explained they were all awaiting the signal to mobilise on her command, to try to bring the exiles back by force if they had to. But a fighting force was no good if nobody knew where they were, and even if they had known, Dis was not ready to go down the route of open violence yet. They did not have any supply of weapons, only wooden toys and tools, and despite Dwalin’s confidence, she did not think a horde of ardent young dwarves could possibly take on the elite praetorian Guard. She did not want any other grieving mothers on her conscience.

Twice she had tried to go to the palace to speak to Thranduil directly, and twice she had been turned away at the door. The insult was almost as painful as the failure. This City was supposed to exist upon the dual strands of its two people. It had been a long time since anyone had pretended there were two kings in the City, but she would still have expected some recognition as the heir of Thror. Thorin would not have stood for this treatment, she thought. But what would he have done? Without weapons, without his title, without the political capital granted by his friendship with the elven king, would he have been just as impotent? She had sent her brother the letter to Laketown hoping against hope that it would reach him in time and he would come and magically fix everything - but time was running out.

Ori and Dwalin were bringing her news from their respective efforts when a tall figure could be seen through the stippled glass door of the office. Dis went and pulled it open before they could even knock.

Prince Legolas stood on the other side, in his commander’s uniform and armed. He said quietly, “I need your help.”

“Come in, then,” she said. “If you’re willing to be seen with me. Have you spoken to your father?”

“No, I’ve been from one end of the city to the other all afternoon. I haven’t had a chance.”

“Then I have nothing for you,” she said.

“Your highness, I am afraid it may come to bloodshed if we don’t find some common ground,” Legolas pleaded. “The engineering apprentices are blockading the utilities and threatening a work stoppage. Three times the Guard has dispersed a crowd from the steps of the great hall. The third time they came back with banners.”

“Your father’s secrecy has fed the flames,” Dis picked up a folded wedge of paper from her desk, bound in rough thread, and handed it to him. “The dwarves at the trial have written up their own transcript and copies are being printed and handed out on the street. I have control of the story now, my prince. I will keep pushing this until something breaks. Give me back my sons and we can talk about peace.”

Legolas flicked through the roughly printed tract. “Not very flattering description of me,” he muttered, and dropped it back on the desk. “We may not agree on many things, but neither of us wants to see our City riven and more innocent blood on the streets. We both want to convince my father to at least show his face outside the palace.”

“Then go and convince him–”

“I want you to come with me, Dis,” Legolas cut her off. “Let him hear the pain that is the cause of all this.”

She looked him in the eye. At last she said, “A moment, I’ll just get my coat.”

–-

After they had gone, there was a knock on the door.

“If it’s more elf princes, we’ve had enough for tonight,” growled Dwalin. A small, beardless face peered around the edge of the door, panting as if he had just been sprinting. Dwalin and Ori stared at the face. “Who the blazes are you?” Dwalin asked.

“Uh, my name is Bilbo Baggins. Professional burglar,” Bilbo said, wiping the sweat off his face with his sleeve. “I work for the family, or at least, I did until recently.”

“The family?” Dwalin frowned. “What are you talking about? Where did you even come from?”

“I’m looking for Dis,” Bilbo said. “It’s extremely urgent, is she here?”

Ori shook his head. “She just left. I’m sure she won’t be too long.”

Bilbo sighed heavily. He let himself into the office, despite Dwalin’s warning growl, and threw himself into an empty chair beside the desk. “I’ve been to her house and they sent me here. I’ve run practically all the way from Laketown since this morning and I’ve not had a single proper meal. Can either of you bring me a cup of coffee, at least?”

Dwalin started to bluster a colourfully spoken protest at his brazenness, but Ori said, “Of course!” and went into the side room to fetch a cup. The pot in the little kitchen had some lukewarm and well-brewed tea at the bottom. He added a generous spoonful of honey to balance the bitterness of the over-soaked leaves, brought it back to Bilbo and put it in his free hand. “There you are, Mr Baggins. You can wait here for the princess.”

Bilbo had only one hand free because with the other, he was holding the small, roughly-printed booklet that Dis had shown to Legolas. He had read the first few pages already. He took the cup without looking and sipped it. After a moment he glanced up at Ori, making a pained face.

Ori wrung his hands. “I’m sorry, we only had tea and it is a bit cold, but we’ve all been up to our ears–”

“The tea’s fine. Is this accurate?” Bilbo waved the booklet. “Is this what actually happened at the trial?”

“Oh, yes, I transcribed most of it myself,” Ori said proudly. “Maybe I added a few of the more florid descriptions later, but the spoken words are pretty much all bang on the anvil.”

Bilbo went back to the small booklet, turning the pages with one hand while he drank the tea. He did not take long to finish before he set the cup down on the desk. “I have to go.”

“Do you want us to leave a message for Dis?” Ori asked.

“No, thank you. I think I can solve this murder and clear Kili’s name, but I’ll have to run for it again,” Bilbo bowed quickly. “Thank you for the tea.”

He was out the door before either of them could question him further. Bilbo ran, trying to work out the fastest route to the palace. He’d spent days in this City but it was not an easy place to navigate, as none of the streets ever ran straight for long and there were never any right-angles. But he had to get there before Thorin could do something really stupid.

It was clear from reading Ori’s transcript that nobody at the trial understood what had happened. But if Bilbo could prove who the real killer was, then maybe, maybe, he could force the king, or the praetorians, or anyone else who would listen, to intervene before the dragon arrived.

Bilbo had the advantage of being on the outside, and perhaps the comfort of seeing it all laid out on paper, and also of course, he had direct knowledge of the night in question. Nobody had called him as a witness, but he realised now that he was key to many of the events described in the trial. He and Dis had been the last known people - apart from the killer - to see Tauriel alive. And he had heard some of her final words to Dis, when Dis had asked her not to reveal their newly discovered secret. Tauriel had claimed she was running off in a hurry “just to return these keys.” Bilbo knew that even people trying to hide something tended to speak in half-truths.

Now he was sure he was the only one who could track all of Tauriel’s movements over the night in question, at least until the very end. She had met with Legolas before she caught Bilbo in the praetorian’s quarters. That meant the keys, evidently not hers, almost certainly belonged to Legolas. So when she left Dis’ house, she had been going back to the palace to return them to the prince. Maybe she really had intended just to put the keys back in his rooms - evidently they were not still missing, or Bilbo was sure it would have come out in the trial, and blamed on Kili with everything else - or maybe she had always intended to seek out someone while she was there, and tell them what she had learned. He didn’t know Tauriel well enough to be sure whether she had betrayed Dis or threatened to shout about the dragon in the streets, but he was sure either way that the person she’d met in the palace had silenced her.

After all, she had not been attacked by assassins, who would surely have brought their own weapons. And she would not have spoken of these matters anywhere she would be overheard. So her killer had to be someone she trusted to meet her alone, in the middle of the night, in the palace, who would listen to her story about dragons and dwarves sacrificed for Mithril. Oh, and as Balin had so succinctly determined, it was an elf. So by Bilbo’s estimation, that left an increasingly short list of suspects. He couldn’t know how many trusted friends Tauriel had in the palace, of course, but he knew two for a start.

He reached the gates of the palace only to find, in great despair, that they were shut tight. He glanced up at the stars through a gap in the trees. How long? How long before the dragon was on the wing? Had Thorin already reached the hill? There must still be time, there must be.

Bilbo blew out a frustrated breath, knocked on the doors and slipped on the ring just as he heard hobnail-booted footsteps on the far side. The doors of the palace swung open and a guard looked around in confusion. Unseen, Bilbo slipped under his arm and tried to run as softly as he could.

He had explored this palace thoroughly over the past few days. He would start with the elven king’s rooms. He dodged around a nighttime patrol and under the elbows of a retainer carrying a tray of empty glasses. Up steps and through grand archways and finally, he saw to his relief that the double doors to the king’s private apartments stood open just a crack.

Bilbo squeezed inside. The lamps were lit with a gentle, warm light, but he could not hear and see anybody. He scurried across the polished, wooden floors and began to search. He pulled open drawers and cupboards and lifted up the mattress on the sofa and peeked behind the paintings hanging on the walls. He was just about to leave when he heard a myriad of approaching footsteps.

In his panic and exhaustion, he forgot that he was invisible and dashed to the corner of the room, sliding under the huge desk and tucking himself behind one of its raw wood legs, formed of a natural twist in the ancient oak. From where he was crouching, he saw three pairs of legs walk through the doors, two elves and a dwarf.

Bilbo shook himself. He was perfectly safe with the ring on. None of them would notice if he snuck out. And then, as he prepared to crawl out from under the desk as quietly as he could, he looked across the room to spy the clearest line for the door. From his new perspective low down, his eyes caught sight of a strange shape in the shadows beneath the nearby cabinet.

–

On the top of the hill, Kili was sleeping against Fili’s side, his legs curled up and his head pillowed against his brother’s chest. Fili kept his arm slung around his brother’s shoulders, glad to feel his breath finally grow even and peaceful. Fili didn’t want to sleep, though he was sure he’d wish he had, come the morning. He had no idea what time it was by now. He was really thirsty. He’d have to ask the praetorians for something when they came back to feed the fires. They had periodically returned to add more of the green-burning leaves.

The wind was picking up, the grass shifting around them, rushing over the crest of the hill in a sudden burst like a gale. It was so loud that Kili stirred and raised his head. Something flickered in the moonlight like a handful of falling hail and struck the ground around them. Fili saw one of the glimmers had fallen near him, shining in the grass. His fingers closed around it and he raised it to his face. A silver metal scale, like from a coat of mail armour. Not actually silver, though - it was paler, and as light in the hand as paper.

Fili looked up at the sky and said in a puzzled voice, “It’s raining mithril.”

—

“Father, If you don’t address this now, someone will start a riot,” Legolas was saying.

Dis followed the two of them into the grand reception room in the palace. Thranduil sat down at a large desk carved of a single, curled bough of oak, in a room overlooking the City. The doors to the balcony were wide open and the lamps glittered among the trees and roofs below. He started flicking through the pages of something, and picked up a glass of wine in his other hand. Dis saw, upside down, that the papers were a missive with Tulus’ name signed to each page.

Without looking up, Thranduil said in a flat voice, “We don’t need to discuss this tonight. I’m sure this morning was very distressing for both of you. Go to bed and rest.”

Legolas gritted his teeth. “The City will not rest tonight. Everywhere, people are talking in the streets of this matter. Everybody has an opinion, and some of them are getting very loud.”

“The old dwarves from Erebor have always been obnoxious. Give it a hundred years and we won’t have to worry about them any more.”

“The old dwarves are on your side, from the ones I spoke to,” Dis said. “They say the rule of law is sacrosanct and must be respected. It’s the young ones who are angry.”

Legolas stepped in beside her. “And not just the dwarves. We had to bring off-duty forest guards into the city to help the constables. Fifty of the forest recruits are claiming they are sick and cannot serve, to avoid going against the civilian agitators. Several more are asking me to implement a curfew for all dwarves and begin mass arrests. Everyone, everywhere is divided.”

Thranduil raised one eyebrow. “So you have a handful of partisans in a thousand? Relieve both sides of their duties. The rest of them will fall into place.”

“Father,” Legolas said, “You should have handled this with more delicacy. The boy was very popular.”

“So was his uncle, and nobody talks about him anymore,” Thranduil drawled, tidying up the pages of Tulus’ report and leaning back in his chair.

Legolas let out a slow breath. “He was your friend.”

“I barely knew the boy.”

“I mean Thorin,” Legolas said firmly. “I remember when there was no one else you listened to above him. No one else you called for when our two peoples struggled, suffered together. What really happened to him?”

“He dug his own grave, is what happened,” Thranduil took a sip of wine and gave Legolas a scandalised look. “He was causing trouble, and he didn’t like the consequences.”

“Did you have Thorin framed?” Dis asked quietly.

Thranduil held her gaze. He said nothing. He ran his finger around the rim of the glass.

Legolas said, “I was certain that Kili was the one who killed her. But I think I made a mistake. When we arrested him, I saw the guilt in his face. He never defended himself. I thought it was his outrage that we had caught him so quickly. But now I wonder if it was grief, only grief. I don’t think he knew she was dead until that moment.”

Thranduil met this soliloquy with a heavy sigh. He pushed himself out of his chair and walked to the balcony with his wine. “Then it is well for our city that the law does not base its decisions on your sentiments, but on proof and prudence.”

“Father, if there is someone else who could be responsible, I want them punished,” Legolas felt his voice grow sharp as a sword-edge. The uncertain fear that the killer might still be in the City, free and unknown, felt like a ligature around his throat. He could not bear the not-knowing. He would not be able to wash Tauriel’s bloodless, dead face from his thoughts until he was sure they had suffered even a fraction of what she had suffered.

“The culprit has been punished and exiled. This matter is closed.”

“There is still time to put another in their place,” Dis took a half step forward. “Let me go instead of them.”

Thranduil turned slowly to face her, his eyes locked in hers with a new and dangerous glare. “So, you have secrets of your own, Princess,” he tilted his head. “And you did not even tell your own sons? You did not warn them?”

Dis felt the barb plunge deep and could not make any reply. And in her ear, in that moment of silence, she heard a voice - not unfamiliar - whisper the strangest thing: “The cabinet, Dis. It’s under the cabinet.”

She shook her head as if brushing off a fly. She must be losing her mind.

Legolas picked up the argument. “You need to consider a retrial. The praetorians can recall the exiles, imprison them for now. But show our people and the dwarves that you can be fair and listen to their unease, and you will have their loyalty stronger than ever before.”

Dis said, desperate now. “Call them back. I’ll never reveal what I know, if it saves their lives tonight.”

Again came what sounded to Dis like Bilbo’s voice. “Look! Under! The! Cabinet! The one with the silver things in it.”

Dis turned her head a little. It was definitely Bilbo’s voice. But she could not see the hobbit anywhere. Was this some clever trick his people had, some magic? And why, in the middle of this critical conversation, was he trying to tell her about cabinets?

Thranduil shook his head, sipping the wine. He said quietly, “It is too late, Princess. The beacons are already lit.”

Dis shivered. She had nothing else left to play. She turned to Legolas and she pointed. “There’s something under the cabinet. Over there.”

“What?” Legolas looked as baffled as she felt. “What’s that got to do with anything?”

Thranduil had turned back to look at them both. He looked confused as well, but also wary, as if this sudden change in the wind was tacking towards a place he didn’t want to go. He didn’t attempt to silence Dis as she repeated, “Look under the cabinet. I saw something as we came in, from across the room. I don’t know what, but I think it’s important. Please, I’m not going mad.”

Legolas glanced at his father, and then crossed the room and knelt elegantly. He reached one long-fingered hand under the display cabinet, took a moment to feel around, and then froze. He drew out a short sword, the handle embossed with the sigil of the Guard and the rank of Captain.

There was no sound in Dis’ ears except the thudding of her own heart. She looked at Thranduil. His face was a mask of shock and fury. It seemed he had not realised the sword was there, perhaps had not realised the significance of its absence and so had not looked for it. He made no attempt to disavow any knowledge of it. There was surely nothing he could have said to explain how it had ended up in his private room.

Legolas stumbled backwards as he stood up, cradling the sword on his open palms. He stared at it for a long time. His breath came in small, pained hitches, as if he had been punched in the gut.

At last he snatched a silk scarf from the back of the nearby settee and wrapped up the sword as if it was something delicate and precious. He cradled it in one elbow and put his right hand to his own sword, on his hip. He still had not looked at his father. Then he seemed to change his mind and did not draw his own sword. He turned to Dis.

“We’re going. Now.”

Dis looked between the two elves. Thranduil had put his wine down on the railing of the balcony. He had no weapon, but he looked as if he was preparing for a fight.

“Where?” Dis asked.

“To the praetorians,” Legolas said. “I am taking command of them as of this moment. The king is not capable. I will order them to recall your sons with all haste.”

There came a rending scream from far, far away, yet loud enough and deep enough to make the floor beneath their feet tremble and the wine in the glass ripple. Dis and Legolas flinched and turned to look at the sky through the open doors of the balcony. They had all been present at the burning of Erebor and knew that sound in their bones. After a moment, it came a second time, not so loud or so deep but unmistakable.

“There,” Thranduil said gently, as the last tail of the scream faded. “He has come for them. It is done. Will you let it rest, now?”

–

Three days earlier, Tauriel went straight from Princess Dis’ house to the palace.

She had listened to Dis’ warning. She had considered it. And then she had gone to Thranduil and told him she knew what really happened to the dwarves who were exiled from the city. She did not say how she knew or who she had discussed it with.

“Tell me there is another explanation, my king,” Tauriel said. “I cannot believe it. I will not. Do not let me believe it.”

Thranduil looked at her and turned away, staring out the open balcony at the city beyond. The eternal lights glowed like the stars come to earth, the canals trickled beneath the paths and filled the air with the scent of cool water under the woven ceiling of living branches far above. The most beautiful city in the world, more beautiful than Doriath at its peak, as clever in its workings and fierce in its defenses as the ancient realms of Numenor and Eregion. Nothing compared to their City, to his City.

Thranduil turned back to her. He said, “How many of those old dwarves would have died, if I had not welcomed them to my realm?” He tilted his head. “How many would have perished from their wounds, starved on the road, frozen when that first winter rolled over them?” He touched his chest. “I had to protect them. And once I did, I could not take back my hospitality. They were my responsibility. But they were too many, Tauriel. They grew and they bred, like animals. And still I loved them and wanted to keep them and shelter them. But the woodland palace could not hold us all. The Mithril which powered our early experiments had run out. There was not enough water in the wells. Not enough fuel for the fires. Families were sleeping on the streets or crushed in the halls living in darkness, because we could not build or light the homes they needed. It was an impossible situation,” Thranduil took a long breath through his nose. “And I only gave him criminals, in the beginning. I offered him troubled and despised dwarves who would have been banished by their own kin and died in the wilderness.”

“King Thrain was not a criminal. He was not despised.”

“He was an antiquated obstacle to the progress of his own people,” Thranduil shrugged. “No one even looked for him after he disappeared.”

“You sacrificed them,” Tauriel whispered. “Didn’t you? Like some old worship of Morgoth and the primeval powers, in ancient times.”

“Don’t be dramatic. It was never a gift, I never gave Smaug anything for free,” Thranduil leaned back against the edge of his desk and folded his arms. “The dragon had spoken to me, after I risked my life to buy time for the dwarves to escape the mountain. As we fled from him, he said he liked the sport of chasing us. So when we were in dire need, I went to the mountain and I offered him sport, in exchange for mithril. He prizes it below the gold and gems on which he sleeps, he picks it out of his hoard like a child pushing vegetables to the side of their plate. He was willing to part with a little mithril, a few tiny trinkets, which was all we needed. And in exchange for so few,” Thranduil leaned into the last words, almost hissing them. “It was one dwarf every seven years, give or take. Those few lives bought us so much. Walk through my streets, Tauriel. Tell me how many children you see, elf and dwarf, playing together, growing together in peace and endless delights. Would you rather they lived in war and famine? How many of them would have died before they saw their first birthday, or never have been conceived at all, if we did not live in a city of such safety and plenty?”

Tauriel shook her head, feeling a numb ice flowing through her limbs. “You are a monster. You have poisoned what was good in this place.”

“I have created life from blood and bone, which any good gardener can tell you makes the richest soil,” Thranduil intoned. “Even the uppity little guard that Legolas tells me you have grown too close to. Would he have been born if I had not taken on this burden? If I had not acted as a king should, and protected my people? All my people.”

Tauriel felt the ice in her chest turn molten. “The dwarves do not owe their children to you! You do not own them! And if you think you can distract me with such jibes, don’t bother. I am rid of my affection for the dwarf. It was a passing dream.”

Thranduil raised one sharp brow. “Good. So you have retained some sense,” he turned a little, hands clasped behind his back, looking into the rich blue lake stitched into the tapestry that hung on the wall. “You have spared yourself the grief of watching him change. watching him grow old and ugly. They are impossible to love forever. All mortals transform with time, they wilt like a fallen fruit or grow too hard and dry, and soon enough you can see the bones in them waiting for the worms to bring out. I know,” he said, and met her eye again. “I have made the same mistake. I have been drawn to the glow of their youth, but it is a corpse-light. Love them too much and it will be the death of you, as the elves of old gave up their bodies and freed their spirits when their husbands fell in battle.”

Tauriel held his gaze. “You must stop these… offerings to Smaug.” She said firmly. “We will find another way to feed the City.”

He shook his head. “It does not do to rescind a bargain with a dragon. I would bring the wyrm down on us if I denied him his occasional pleasures.”

“Then we will kill it!” Tauriel pleaded. “We are not helpless prey!”

Again, he simply shook his head. “Let it sit in your heart for a while, Tauriel, and you will come to understand. This is the only way.”

Thranduil had taken her in when she had no family left to shelter her or teach her. She of all his children should understand the danger that the world posed. He had given her a place and a purpose in his realm. He was sure she would understand.

“No,” Tauriel pointed at him. “You will confess. Tell Dis Thrainsdaughter what you have done, and she will summon the greatest of her artificers and make a weapon that can kill the dragon. Then we can be rid of its threat and the City be cleansed of your sins.”

Thranduil gave a small peal of laughter. “You would shatter us as a people. If they learn the truth now, the dwarves will leave and return to the road, or their kin in the miserable halls of distant mountains. The City will be made destitute. I will tell them, in time, once they are ready - not yet, but in two generations, or three, once the City is the only home they know. Once they no longer remember how to live underground.”

“They are free to go where they will,” Tauriel answered. “Let them choose.”

Thranduil did not reply, and she realised she was wrong. They were not free. He was closing the gilded cage around them, slowly, slowly, by offering them over a hundred years of comfort and seclusion, he was bending the bars into place without them even knowing it. He did not want to let them go. They had been guests, but they had become profitable assets.

“You will tell them now, tonight. Come with me and tell Dis,” Tauriel said in a low voice. “Or I will go and explain everything to my lord Legolas. I will ask him to summon your court and rescind your mandate as king. You are not fit to rule and your throne can be usurped for the good of all.”

“Do not threaten me,” he snarled.

“You have until dawn to decide,” she said, and turned to go. As she reached the top of the steps, she felt a hand stronger than steel lock around her elbow. She spun, instinctively reaching for her swords. “Release me!”

“If you speak of this to a soul, you will be stripped of all titles and cast out of my Woodland,” Thranduil hissed. “Daughter you were to me, but I will name you outcast and traitor.”

“Then I will go gladly, and all will know the truth as I walk away!” She tried to pull out his grasp again, but he held firm. With her left hand, Tauriel drew the short sword at her hip. “I recant any vows of service to you, now and forever!”

Thranduil let go of her arm, but in the same movement he grabbed for her sword on her other hip and drew it from its sheath. He turned her blade aside like it was a twig over his path, and seized her around the throat with his free hand. “You will leave when I command it.”

Tauriel tried to strike the sword out of his hand, but they were locked close and both were clumsy. She knocked his arm away and he raised it high to avoid her, but the tip of her blade nicked a few strands of his hair, and scraped the tiniest line of blood across his face, high on his cheekbone, almost at his temple. His lips drew back from his teeth and she saw for a moment that he was overwhelmed by instinct, some memory of wars long passed, taking him over like programmed clockwork.

He drove the blade down in an arc and into her left breast, through the delicately woven brocade, through the silk undershirt, through skin and the filament of muscle between her ribs and skimmed the edge of a lung and in further. All of it happened in a heartbeat, and that was one of her last heartbeats.

She felt her fingers open and the sword in her hand tumbled away with a ringing like a bell, skidding to rest under the cabinet nearby. Tauriel felt herself falling. Thranduil caught her, and cradled her, and she saw the shock and horror in his face. “My daughter, my daughter, forgive me,” he whispered. “Hold strong, I will try to slow the bleeding.” She felt his palm on her chest.

She put her hand over his, and then stretched her fingers to the buttons of her outer vest, looking for the little silk pocket inside. Her fingers touched the soft, braided circle of hair with its silver clasp. She managed to draw it out, clutching it close to her failing heart. She gripped it tight and tried to speak as felt herself being dragged beneath the shadows growing at the edges of her vision, “Tell him, tell him…”

But that was all she managed to say before the darkness took her.