Chapter Text
Thorin was halfway up Stargazer Hill when he saw one of the praetorians. He was not trying to keep quiet - as if it would have done any good, with their keen ears - and in the faint moonlight he saw the archer kneeling in the grass just as they saw him. In a moment, they had an arrow aimed at his throat from thirty feet away. He stopped, his hand on his sword but not drawing it.
“You know me, Bramben,” he said. Before his downfall, Thorin had been part of Thranduil’s inner court for over a hundred years. He knew the king’s most trusted inner ring; their faces, their names, their favourite drink. Sometimes they had even been his friends. “Let me speak to Esgal.”
The elf did not lower the arrow, but he whistled sharply. They had less than a minute to wait before another praetorian appeared around the curve of the hill, and from the crest behind them, at a light jog, came Captain Esgal. The green glow of the pyres shone on his face. These were elves who were old for the most part, who were the sharpest troops in the City and had seen more in their long lives than Thorin could even imagine. But it was still satisfying to see a brief flash of surprise in Esgal’s eyes.
“Thorin, son of Thrain,” Esgal said, with the wary softness bred by the forest’s dangers. “You are a wanted dwarf in these lands. I am charged to bring you home in fetters if I can catch you.”
“Consider me caught. Is my kin up on that hill?” Thorin had no time for banter. Esgal did not answer. Thorin barked. “I know the dragon is coming. Is it Kili? Is that who you’re feeding to the beast tonight? As you gave up my father for a pittance of treasure?”
Esgal drew in a sharp breath, not hiding his shock that Thorin was so well-informed. Then he said, without hiding the pity, “It’s both of your nephews, Thorin. Fili wouldn’t be parted from his brother, even in his exile, and we are under oath to reveal nothing to anyone outside the dragon guard. It’s kinder if they don’t know what’s coming.”
Thorin felt his stomach lurch and his knees weaken. He tightened his hand on his sword. But there were three of them, and he was old and out of practice, and they were all faster with a blade even if they hadn’t had arrows to fill him with holes from a distance. He had only one choice.
“I’ll take their place,” he called. “Let me go up there. The lads will leave if I order them to leave, and they need never know Thranduil’s secret. Let them go and be exiles and I’ll stand in as your payment for the Mithril.”
Esgal looked up at the moon, raising his arm to protect his face as a wind rose and flattened the grass around them. He glanced at Thorin and nodded. “Go, then. Go quickly. He’s coming!” He looked at the other two praetorians. “Spread the word around the hills, let the young ones flee where they will.”
Thorin was already clambering up the last of the slope, wading through thigh-high grass and tussock, stumbling a little in divots and stones in the dark. As he reached the great ring of boulders, the land flattened into a gentle meadow that until now Thorin had always thought of as a place of beauty and tranquility, rising above the shadow of the trees. In the light of the green fires, it was revealed to be an eerie and sickly monument, a place of sacrifice and doom. How many had been traded away here, unwitting until the last moment when the dragon reached out of the darkness and snatched them up, to carry away to its lair, to torment and play with like a mouse under a cat’s paws, to drag out their deaths for who knew how long? He had to save his nephews from that fate. Thorin sprinted past the looming stones that stood like teeth in a mouth and came into the meadow beyond.
Fili and Kili stood in the centre of the ring, very close together, Kili rubbing his eyes as if he’d just woken up. Thorin had not seen them in more than two years, but they had changed little; Fili’s hair was longer, and Kili’s was braided down his back like an elf. Their faces were turned to the east, to the sky, still frowning with confusion rather than fear. Amongst the huge boulders they looked tiny and so, so fragile.
“Run!” Thorin bellowed, not breaking his stride, taking his hand off his sword to wave his arm. “Run, lads!”
Kili turned with a jolt as if someone had slapped him. “Thorin?” he called, and for the briefest moment he smiled.
Thorin wanted only to embrace them, to hold them, to tell them how much he’d missed them and ask them everything he had lost since he had left the City, but there was simply no time.
Fili had not taken his eyes from the night sky. He raised his hand and pointed. For the briefest moment he looked over at Thorin, but his face wasn’t smiling; his expression was curdling into fear. Thorin was yards away now. He could hear the deep, howling pulse of huge, batlike wings.
“Run!,” he roared, and Fili bolted like a hunting dog at a whistle. He grabbed Kili’s shoulder and spun him, shoved him and ran, dragging his brother by the upper arm.
Thorin turned to see Smaug sink out of the sky and settle on two of the huge boulders, perched like an owl above a nest. His scales shone green in the light of the pyres. There came a low, rumbling laugh that Thorin could feel in the earth, through his boots and the soles of his feet. “So,” the dragon said. “The leaf-clad king was feeling generous today, and has given me three toys.”
Thorin found himself looking up into two huge, foul-breathed nostrils. He couldn’t make himself step any closer, but he raised his arms away from his body to look as willing as possible, to try and get the dragon’s attention. He wondered what his father had thought, standing perhaps in this same spot on this same hill, knowing how terribly he had been betrayed by the elven host he had trusted. Thorin focused on his own rage and grief, to suppress the terror at the sight of teeth as long as his arm and the broiling chemical scent from deep in the dragon’s belly.
“I’m the trade, your impotent lizard,” Thorin bellowed. “Don’t let your gluttony give you a stomach ache. One dwarf for the king’s regular pocket money, isn’t that the agreement?”
He didn’t dare look away until the dragon’s wing reached right over the stone circle, arching over Thorin like the bough of a huge yew, and slammed down on the far side. Then he glanced back to see the clawed fingers digging into the soft earth between two of the huge stones, blocking Fili and Kili’s escape. The great tail curled around the outside of the stones. There was no way out.
“My bargain is not with you, dwarf, and you cannot edit the terms in your favour,” Smaug chuckled.
Before Thorin could react, Smaug’s other wing-hand reached out and gripped him, enclosing him from ankles to shoulders. Before the claws tightened completely, he managed to draw the sword and free one of his arms above the dragon’s scaled joint. He felt himself lifted off the ground, and groaned as the pressure pushed the air from his lungs. Smaug began to spread his wings to rise, reaching out towards his nephews to sweep all three of them up together.
Thorin had to do something or Smaug would have them all and he would have given his life for nothing. The dragon’s scales, Thorin knew, were impenetrable, but he saw suddenly that where the claw met the finger-like bone, there was a connection that looked like softer skin. Thorin raised his sword and jammed it as deep as he could into that thin crescent of soft tissue at the base of the claw.
Smaug gave a scream that rippled through Thorin’s bones and deafened him completely. Its toys from the Woodland had always been disarmed before today; it was probably a very long time since it had been hurt. The scream made the trees tremble and flattened the leaves in every direction. The stacked, burning pyres cracked and fell outwards in a shower of sparks. In the City, the scream hummed in the tree trunks and wooden posts of the homes and halls, waking a few old dwarves from dark dreams. In Laketown, the water rippled like in a breeze and old fishermen late on their boats looked up at the sky without knowing why.
Smaug sprang into the air and flew straight up, and for the briefest moment Thorin was able to look down and saw his nephews standing far below on the solid ground, their faces lit by the clashing lights of the dragon’s red glow and the last of the green fire. So they were safe. He had done that much. Thorin gritted his teeth, feeling his ribs and the joints of his body bending in the dragon’s grip, and dug the sword in deeper, twisting it as hard as he could. Smaug howled again and in his pain his claws opened as he flew upwards like an arrow, releasing Thorin into the empty night air.
Thorin felt his breath rush into his lungs at last, and then he began to fall.
—
As the dragon rose away from them and the gaps between the stones opened once more, Fili grabbed his brother and tried to run. Kili’s feet wouldn’t move. He was leaning away from Fili, neck craned back to where the dragon’s wingbeat had lifted the beast higher than the tallest roof in the city. Fili hauled on him until he stumbled backwards, and Fili heard the dragon’s howl of pain ring out a second time.
“Thorin!” Kili screamed, and it was a howl of pure, helpless horror; and then out of the corner of his eye Fili saw and heard something hit the ground near the very peak of the hill.
“Come on!” Fili kept dragging him until Kili’s feet were forced to run or he’d fall over. Fili could not think about what was happening, he could only think about one thing, and that was to get him and his brother away from here. Nothing could be worse than remaining in this exposed circle. This trap they had let themselves walk into.
He got Kili moving and pushed him ahead. They half-fell, half-ran past the circle of stones and down the hill, feet snagging in the grass.
Fili saw a shape rising, twenty feet to his right. He grabbed Kili’s shoulders and pushed him down. There was, very faintly, beneath the dying echoes of the dragon’s wingbeats, the twang of a bow.
Fili felt as if someone had punched him in the back with a closed fist. He stumbled and they both fell. Kili twisted as they went down and caught him around the chest. They ended up in the grass, tangled together with Fili on top. That’s when the pain hit and he made a noise that would have been embarrassing if his mind wasn’t overwhelmed with a black, burning agony radiating from his left shoulder. Kili put his hand over Fili’s mouth and tried to hush him, his head turning towards where the praetorian’s shape was cut out against the stars on the curve of the hill. Fili’s breath came in short, sharp gasps through his nose as he tried to stay quiet.
They heard the captain’s voice from further away. “Hold! Hold your arrows! My orders were to let the young dwarves go!”
There was a surprised reply from the nearby archer, though Fili couldn’t quite make out the Sindarin words. He couldn’t really see or hear much around the pain. At the sound of the praetorian’s exchange, Kili hauled Fili up and stood on Fili’s right side, slipping his arm around Fili’s back, under his shoulders. He hissed, “We have to get into the forest. They won’t find us there.”
“Thorin,” Fili whispered. “Did the dragon get Thorin?”
“No,” Kili said, barely louder than a breath. “It flew away and Thorin fell. From very high.”
Fili made his feet move as Kili half-carried and half-dragged him down the slope and into the trees, keeping their pace as swift as Fili could manage. The shadows closed over them until it was nearly pitch black. Fili had only ever left the city at night for feasts or festive rituals or, very occasionally, youthful outings with friends on a dare; but they had always brought torches with them. He had never been in the forest after dark without lamp-lined paths, or open clearings with strings of little lights like a glimmering mosaic of colour. He had heard all the stories of spiders and orcs and darker things lurking under these trees. Roots and rocks tripped his feet and the branches tugged at his clothes. But Kili moved through it without hesitation, as if he knew every tree, as if he was navigating in broad daylight. This was his forest, his daily duty. He clearly knew where he was going.
“Leave me. Just get out of here,” Fili tried to say, though it came out as mostly a mumble.
Kili must have figured out the gist, though, because he replied. “No. Not even if they kill me. I’m not losing you, too. Stay awake. I’ll bloody kill you if you die on me, Fili. I mean it.”
Deeper into the forest they went, leaving the Stargazer Hill and its sacrificial altar behind.
--
At the top of the hill, Captain Esgal and several of the praetorians entered the ring of stones from all sides, approaching the small, dark shape that lay near the centre of the grassy circle. A few glinting scales of mithril, torn from some ancient, dwarvish armour, lay in the grass around the motionless body. Esgal stepped in close and knelt beside Thorin, laying his hand on the dwarf’s chest in a silent prayer to speed his spirit onwards to the halls of rest. After a moment, he raised his head sharply to look at his troops.
“He’s alive. By the gods, I don’t believe it.”
“Sir, what do we do?” Bramden asked. “The bargain is broken. What if the dragon is aggrieved? Do we leave Master Thorin here, for it to return and claim him?”
“Smaug doesn’t want enfeebled prey,” Esgal shook his head. “It’s too late. Even if we could catch the exiles, I don’t think the dragon is the sort to gracefully accept apologies. Make a litter, we’ll take Master Thorin back to the City. Bramden, run ahead as fast as you can and alert the king of all that has happened.”
