Chapter Text
Haered was deep in the forest on patrol when he sensed an ambush. He drew and aimed, finding his target not high in the branches, as he’d expected, but low down: there was a dwarf standing between the trees, not three yards away, raising his hands in surrender. How by all that was green had a dwarf snuck up on him?
“It’s me, Haered, it’s me!”
Haered lowered his bow. “Kili?”
“I’m not armed.” Kili moved a couple of steps out of the thick undergrowth. He was in the same clothes he’d worn at the trial, and carried nothing; no bag, no visible weapons, not even a proper coat for the autumn weather. There was something strange about his face and voice that Haered couldn’t name.
Haered could not understand what his exiled comrade was doing here, far away from the main road. It seemed he had been waiting, or perhaps following, the regular patrol routes, and must have stepped off the path as Haered approached. Haered felt a rush of annoyance at himself for being detected by anyone, even a fellow recruit. He lowered his arrow and gritted his teeth.
“I’m not supposed to talk to you. You’re exiled.”
“I need your help,” Kili cut him off. Haered realised that the strangeness was that the Kili he knew from the Guard was always chatty and cheerful, and now he looked and sounded so cold and grim he was almost unrecognisable. Everything about his expression and bearing had changed from the fellow recruit Haered had spent two years training with.
“You’re a murderer,” said Haered.
Kili took a moment to reply, then he said at last, “My brother’s hurt. No matter what you think of me, you know he’s done nothing wrong. Please, help me, and then we’ll be on our way and no one needs to know.”
Haered slowly put his arrow back in its quiver and stowed his bow. “Show me.”
Kili led him off the path and down a small gully, along a mossy step of rock, sheltered by overhanging roots and leaning trees. A tiny stream trickled past the flat rock, fed by the dripping walls of the gully, and then vanished underground. One of the rare places in the forest where the water was clear and not tinged by the Mirkwood poisons. Even with his elven eyes, there was barely enough moonlight to see a few feet, so Haered found his lamp in his bag and lit it.
Kili was kneeling down to put the back of his hand on his brother’s forehead. Fili lay on his right side, his head pillowed on a rolled up vest. He had his eyes closed and was shivering, but he was not asleep; his hand was gripping tight to his left shoulder, where his clothes were dark with blood. Some torn cloth had been packed around it, but it was soaked through as well. Kili went quickly to the stream, dipping another piece of cleanish cloth. He brought it back to his brother, wringing it out to help and helping him drink.
“What happened?” Haered asked, not yet approaching.
Kili looked up from under his dark brows. “We did everything the praetorians said. They took us up Stargazer Hill and made us wait, no food, no water, no warm clothes. When we tried to leave, they shot at us.”
“Why would they do that? What else happened out there?”
“You wouldn’t believe me if I told you.”
Haered had to admit Kili was right. He didn’t believe this could possibly be the whole story but he also wasn’t willing to trust anything Kili said. He finally knelt down on the mossy rock. Fili opened his eyes and tensed as Haered carefully lifted the bandage from the front of his shoulder. Haered could not stop a sharp intake of breath. It was an elvish arrow, a woodland arrow, identical to those in Haered’s quiver right now. And it was the point that was emerging below Fili’s collarbone; the shaft could be seen on the far side, above the shoulder blade, though it had been expertly snapped off. Haered looked up at Kili with wide eyes.
“They shot him in the back!”
“I told you. We were trying to leave. Look at us, we’re unarmed,” Kili said quietly, as if reciting the rules of grammar in language class. “It’s not just us. This is what they do. That’s why none of the dwarven exiles have ever tried to return,” Kili held his gaze. “They don’t get put on the road to make their way in the world. They die. They all die.”
“You don’t know what you’re talking about. Or you’re lying,” Haered snapped back. "You tried to escape, didn't you?"
He pressed the makeshift bandage back to Fili’s shoulder and Fili gave a small grunt. He finally spoke up, his voice hoarse and his breathing shallow. “Believe him or don’t, but I’d really like to see another sunset.”
“I know the north outpost is less than half a mile along your route. That’s why I was waiting for one of our team,” Kili explained. “There’ll be supplies at the outpost but I can’t risk being seen there. Can you bring me a field surgeon’s kit, and as many clean bandages as you can find, and maybe some rations and a water skin or two? Then you can be on your way and they’ll assume I robbed the place. I’ll take the arrow out and suture it myself, and we’ll head for Laketown as soon as Fili’s able to walk. Tell nobody we came here and we’ll never step foot in the Woodland again, I swear.”
“Please,” Fili added, almost like he was reminding his little brother to be polite.
“Alright,” Haered said. “But only because your brother doesn’t deserve… whatever happened.”
Haered left them at a swift jog. Kili tried to keep Fili drinking water and talking while they waited.
“Why?” Kili kept asking. “If they wanted to execute criminals, why not just line us up against a rock and shoot us full of arrows? Why would Thranduil choose such a horrible way to get rid of us? To keep the dragon content in his ill-gotten hall? So no elf needs to act the executioner themselves? It seems like such a risk of raising the monster’s ire.”
“I don’t know,” rasped Fili. “I think there’s a lot we don’t know.”
“How did Thorin know we were there?”
“I don’t know that either,” Fili closed his eyes. “Can I just sleep, just for a few minutes? You can wake me.”
“No. No, I’ll shake your bad shoulder if you dare. You’ve bled too much.”
Fili grumbled and said, a little petulantly, “Ma and Tauriel were up to something. Maybe they knew about this.”
“What? What do you mean?”
Fili regretted the slip immediately. He wasn’t thinking straight. This was not the right time to talk to Kili about Tauriel. He couldn’t take it back now. “The night before she died, Tauriel was in our house, talking to Ma. I interrupted them when I came home. I thought she was there to talk about you, of course. But I think it was some other secret business, that started after you and Tauriel had separated from each other. Ma thinks she was killed because of it, to keep her silent, I suppose.”
Kili could not speak. He could not believe it was only days since that had happened, three days, but he now felt the ordeals weighing him down in layer after layer as if he was enduring them all anew. Dis had not told him any of this when she’d been granted her one visit to him in the cell, which might have been caution in case she was heard by the elven guards but seemed suddenly like a cruel omission to hide her own responsibility. And Fili had kept this from him, until he was literally on his deathbed? It felt like a conspiracy. They had all been keeping secrets from him, even Tauriel. And Ma would have probably said it was to protect him, their paragon of the dwarvish-elvish union, that he had to be lied to and tricked so that he would be above suspicion. What good had their protection done him? If he’d known what was really going on, perhaps he could have defended himself at the trial. Perhaps he could have proved his innocence when he was arrested, so he needn’t have gone through the misery of that trial at all.
Perhaps if they’d all let him in, he could have protected Tauriel.
Certainly he would have stopped Fili joining him in this fatal exile. Ma must have known; her reaction at the trial, when he’d been sentenced, when Fili had joined him - she had known they being sent to the dragon. And instead of warning Kili, she’d let him walk towards his death with his brother beside him. If she’d only told him, he would have forced Fili to stay in the City at any cost, even if Fili hated him for it.
Before he could recover himself, he heard light footsteps in the forest above their gully. He put his finger to his lips, looking up through the darkness to see if it was Haered, or if their conversation had given them away to another patrol. His heart raced as he heard more than one set of footsteps. He’d piled several good, fist-sized stones from the creek nearby, and now reached silently for one.
“Kili? Are you still here?” a voice called. It wasn’t Haered, but Lieutenant Fainthel. As she climbed down into the gully she lit a lamp with the brief hiss of Mithril-glow. She wasn’t alone; Haered was behind her, and two more of the young Guards from Kili’s unit, older recruits who were several years senior to him and Haered. Kili didn’t let go of the stone, and crouched low in front of Fili.
“Haered!” Kili hissed. “Why would you grass on me?”
Haered looked suitably guilty. Fainthel answered for him, “He turned up at the outpost acting odd and I ordered him to speak. You can thank the gods he did. Let us see your brother.”
“Stay away from us,” Kili raised the stone, bringing it back behind his ear ready to throw. “I mean it, I’ll fight all of you. Try knocking me over, I know you can’t, I know how you all fight.”
Fainthel’s eyes glinted in the lamplight, but her face was half-shadowed and hard to read. “Kili, I want to help. You can trust me.”
“Why?” Kili’s voice rose, cracking at the end. “I can’t trust anyone. I did everything you all asked of me, every one of you, everyone at home. I served the king with everything I had, I was loyal to him, I was loyal to my folk, I walked that sword-edge every day and I never slipped up. I even gave up Tauriel so no one would question my loyalties. I loved her and I was the one who pushed her away. And this is how I’ve been repaid,” Kili drew back the stone as Fainthel stepped closer with slow, careful movements, her gaze locked on his face. “I mean it, Lieutenant, leave us alone, I don’t want your help!”
“Kili,” Fainthel raised her hands slowly, half crouched so she was not leaning over him, gently reaching to put her hands on his shoulders. “I believe you. You didn’t kill Tauriel.”
Kili drew his lips back from his teeth, and he didn’t drop the stone, but he didn’t hurl it at her, either. His shoulders sagged. “Why did they do this to us? It can’t be because of me, because I’m a dwarf stepping out of line. Nobody hates anybody that much.”
“We all heard the noises tonight. They probably heard it as far as Rivendell,” Fainthel held his eye. “I helped the dwarves escape Erebor as it burned, even if the rest of you were too young. I know what the dragon sounds like. Did you see Smaug? Here, in the Woodland? Is that what you were running from when the praetorians shot at you?”
Kili nodded. Fainthel patted the side of his neck. “We can talk about it later, son. I want to look at your brother. Can you put the rock down?”
Kili lowered his arm at last, though he couldn’t bring himself to drop the stone. Fainthel knelt down and inspected Fili quickly. She glanced up at Kili. “We have to take him back to the outpost.”
“Can’t you treat him here?” Kili asked weakly, kneeling down beside her.
“In the dirt, with that brackish water to wash the wound? Even the strongest dwarf constitution will risk blood poisoning.”
Kili looked at his brother. Fili nodded at him. Fainthel called over the rest of the young Guard and they started talking about the best way to move Fili without causing him too much distress. Kili stepped back, feeling bitter and furious with himself for not holding his ground. He was losing control of the situation, and it was going to end with them being taken back to the City. And he had a very, very bad feeling about that.
—
Legolas left the palace with Dis. She said ‘thank you’ as he ushered her through the main gates and ‘really, I should be getting back to my house anyway,’ when he asked if he’d like her to fetch someone to be with her. Her voice sounded polite and distant, as if she was reading from a script without knowing the rest of the play. As they passed the fountain just beyond the palace bridge, she sat down on the edge of the stone balustrade and looked down the quiet street. It was past midnight and the paved path was empty and dark except where the intermittent lamps hung from the branches above. A small animal, a cat or a fox, darted out of the shadows and sauntered away from them.
“I’ll just sit here a moment,” she said softly. “Thank you, Legolas, but there’s nothing more for us to do. And I want you to know that I don’t blame you. This began long before Tauriel died. It is not your doing that led us here.”
There was a pair of guards approaching, eyes on their commander. Legolas wanted to delay whatever new crisis they had for him. He could not stop the thoughts darting in a circle like dancers around the solstice fire: he had loved Tauriel, and Tauriel had fallen in love, but not with him, and his rage against her death may have led to the death of the dwarf she loved, and now wherever she was Tauriel must despise him, and he still loved her, and round and round it went. He had to do something to make this right, even in the smallest way.
“Princess Dis, my father is not himself. Some strange mood has possessed him. I will keep searching for your sons, you have my word.”
“There will be nothing to find,” she answered, still gazing at the long, deep shadows of the street. Her voice finally became more like her usual imperious tone. “Leave me, please.”
The guards reached his side and bowed. “Commander, there are reports that a dragon has been heard north of the City. The praetorians have been waylaid by a mob of dwarves and cannot attend. And one of the forest patrols is overdue, one of the patrols on the north circuit near where the roars were heard. We need you.”
Legolas nodded. “Very well, we’ll go searching for the missing patrol at once and let us only hope we do not meet anything else along the route.”
He took a dozen guards into the forest, two lieutenants with their most senior recruits. He hoped against hope that the patrol was delayed by a twisted ankle or sidetracked by an investigation of new spiderwebs, but they could take no chances. With the unrest in the streets and now the roar of a dragon in the sky, he did not want to be surprised by some new disaster.
“We’ll start by searching the northern circuit from both ends,” he said as they marched away from the lights of the City and the shadows of the tree closed over them. Legolas indicated a path that would have been nearly impossible to see even by daylight and sent one of his lieutenants in that direction. “You lot, go that way round the loop. The rest of you, we’ll go the other way and meet them on the route.”
The seven of them moved on swift feet in a single line. By caution of the unlit forest at night, they said nothing and kept their ears always alert. Less than an hour later, they did not need to be listening too hard when they heard the scream. Legolas raised his hand. After a pause he gave a sign for weapons to be at the ready but not yet drawn and they should follow him at speed.
He was sure of the direction. There was a small outpost nearby, built to hold supplies and provide a little shelter and rest on long nights on duty. In a few minutes Legolas and his guards were at the foot of the small, stone outcrop that supported the outpost, built just high enough that in daylight it stood above a thinner patch of trees and could see at least a short distance into the forest. The windows were lit up with more lamps than were usually allowed in the forest at this time of night; light could draw spiders or fouler things. As they arrayed themselves, there came another, shorter wail from inside. Legolas motioned the guards to draw their weapons now, and then ran silently up the stone steps to the door. With his elves in perfect step behind him, he drew one sword, seized the doorhandle and burst into the room.
He had to keep moving to let the rest of the guards follow, but he took in the scene as he did so and felt himself draw back in surprise. The main room of the outpost was barely big enough to hold the people already in it, let alone seven more elves with bows and shortswords in their hands. Legolas made eye contact with Fainthel, who stood over the dining table that had been dragged into the centre of the small room. Her arms were bloody to the wrists and she was pressing down with two hands and wads of fresh bandages on either side of the shoulder of a dwarf. Three of her unit were in various states of assistance, one holding the dwarf in place, one dipping a pair of pliers into a bowling pot on the stove, and the other handing Fainthel a bowl with some crushed, fresh herb. The dwarf’s face was a bloodless, disheveled mess, but Legolas recognised him from the trial. Even if he hadn’t, he had enough of a clue who he was from Kili standing by his head, clutching his brother’s good arm.
Fainthel stared at Legolas and her eyes flickered across the entire troop that had just burst into her surgeon’s chamber. “Commander!” she cried, “Can you get out, please? I need to focus!”
Legolas opened his mouth and then, turning to the armed guards behind him, said “Outside, make a perimeter, no one enters or leaves here until I say.”
As they did as he ordered, he turned back in time to see Fainthel’s hand withdraw something through the front of Fili’s shoulder with a precise, swift tug. An arrow shaft, Legolas saw at once, coated in blood but still recognisably a City-made arrowhead from the Guard’s armory. Fainthel dropped it onto the table nearby, quickly returning to press the cloth to the entrance and exit wounds. Fili did not make a sound this time, his eyes tightly closed and his breathing growing fainter.
“It’s out, it’s done,” Kili pressed his face to his brother’s hair. “Hold on a bit longer.”
“Haedred, does his shirt look intact?” Fainthel barked. “Could there be any cloth inside the wound?”
The elf who had been leaning on Fili’s chest to hold him down replied, “It looks like it’s all here, Sir.”
“Good. Thread and suture needle,” she ordered. The recruit by the stove handed them over, still steaming from the boiling water, and Fainthel began stitching the entrance wound one-handed.
“Let me help,” Legolas walked towards a bowl of clean water that smelled of lime-powder and began to wash his hands thoroughly. “He’s lost enough blood, we need to move fast.”
Fainthel glanced at him and nodded. In a few minutes, they had finished their work. Fainthel bandaged their patient and let him finally lie on his back, slightly propped to avoid pressure on the entrance wound. Kili was inches away the entire time, holding his brother's head and staring at Legolas with an ugly expression.
At last, Fainthel and Legolas washed the blood off their hands and took a step away to speak to each other, though there was nowhere private in this small, cosy outpost. Legolas said darkly, “I hope you have an explanation for this, Lieutenant.”
Fainthel reached back and picked up the arrowhead, using a spare cloth so she didn’t dirty her newly-cleaned hands. “The Dwarves were hiding in the tractless forest, with this in Fili’s back. They say the praetorians took them away from the City and shot them when they tried to leave. Do you have an explanation for that, sir?” she put the arrow back down swiftly but carefully, as if it burned.
Legolas said after a moment. “Perhaps exile was not enough to hide the truth. There are only three people who we can be sure know whether Kili is a murderer, and one of them is already dead. Perhaps somebody wanted to silence the second.”
He glanced at Kili and twitched his head towards the only other door in the outpost, which led to a small bunkroom. “Come with me.”
“I don’t take your orders,” Kili spat. “You’re not my commander anymore.”
Legolas let out a slow breath. “Come with me, please.”
Kili patted his brother's good shoulder. “You alright?”
“Terrible,” Fili croaked. “But I’m not sure what more you can do about that.”
Kili left him and followed Legolas into the bunk room. Legolas took one of the lamps from the main room and hung it above the small window. There was only a narrow aisle between two rows of bunks of bare wood. The thin, rag-stuffed mattresses were rolled and stowed under oilcloth, each bed a double wide so that up to eight elves could sleep in this tiny room. This was far from the luxuries of the City. They were outside its protection and its overbearing eye. Legolas felt uncomfortable looming over Kili with the lamp behind him, so after a moment he sat on the edge of one of the bunks.
“I need to apologise to you,” he said, folding his arms over his knees. “I know you didn’t kill her.”
Kili leaned back against the post of the bunk but didn’t sit. “How long have you known?”
“Only a couple of hours. I thought I was seeking justice when I spoke against you at the trial,” Legolas said. “But I should have seen it sooner. Fainthel tried to tell me you had an alibi, and I didn’t listen,” he closed his eyes, not sure if he was speaking out of contrition or trying to make excuses for himself. “You were such an easy target for my grief.”
“What changed tonight?”
Legolas wasn’t sure he should speak more, but how could he keep quiet with the truth when he’d been so effusive in spreading the lie? He reached into the bag slung over his back and took out the sword, opening the silk cloth he’d wrapped it in. “I found this, with your mother’s help.”
Kili’s eyes widened and he took half a step forward. “Tauriel’s missing sword.” He looked at Legolas. “Where was it?”
“In my father’s rooms,” Legolas said numbly.
The silence that felt between them was as loud as a rolling drumbeat. Kili’s brow tightened, his mouth opened a little. Anger began to grow on his face. “So either he ordered it, or he did it himself.”
“I don’t know,” Legolas wrapped the sword up again but held it resting on his palms, like the stem of a flower. “But I know you couldn’t have put it there. Here, take it. She’d want you to have it.”
“I’m not sodding touching it,” Kili backed up so fast he bumped into the bunk behind him. “Is that your plan to protect the king? If I’m seen with it, I’ll never clear my name.”
“It’s not a trick. You need something to protect yourself,” Legolas held the sword out further. “It’s clearly not safe for you to return to the City. As soon as your brother is able to walk, I’ll have Fainthel and a unit of guards escort you both to Laketown. I will tell your mother you are alive but no one else - at least until I can figure out what happened and what to do about my father. He is not fit to be king. Tauriel was like a daughter to him. He must be mad. He couldn’t have done this from a place of right thinking.”
“He’s perfectly clear headed. He’s covering up something worse,” Kili shook his head. “You don’t know, do you?”
Legolas frowned. “Know what?”
“Fili and I saw the dragon tonight. Here, in the Woodland. The praetorians summoned him, like he was their trained bear. Your father has some kind of bargain with Smaug. He feeds dwarves to him. He would have taken us too, but my uncle saved us, gave his life for us. Tauriel died because she learned about it all. I’m sure of it.”
Legolas took a moment to process this. Then he thrust the sword at Kili. “Take it. Protect yourself. Tauriel would never forgive me if I let you come to further harm.”
—
Thranduil stood on the balcony looking over his City. From here, he could see it laid out beneath him like a quilt. From a distance, especially at night, one would never believe it was infested with dissidents and ungrateful rabble-rousers. He watched the tiny figures of his son and the dwarven princess leave the palace by the main bridge and walk across the square beyond, pausing to speak at the fountain.
He had been foolish to take such a bold move against the children and grandchildren of Thrain, so openly scapegoating them. If he’d been patient, they would surely have diminished into irrelevance in a few years. Any memory of royalty would soon be no more than an old scrap of family lore. No matter what mortal kings and queens would like their subjects to believe, thrones and crowns were not carried in the blood, the gods did not distill any divine essence into a pedigree. There were hundreds of dwarves in this city alone who could abstractly or sometimes even directly trace at least one ancestor to Durin the Deathless; were they all special, did all deserve the title of prince or princess? Of course not. The only ones who got those titles were the ones who claimed it, by right of power, by killing their rivals or slaying dragons and stealing land, and who kept it by the brutal and constant battle of ruling. Thrain’s family had failed to hold their claim to kingship and so would have disappeared into the mists of history within the span it took an oak sapling to become a spreading tree. Especially if Thranduil had continued to force them subtly into obscurity.
It wasn’t rivalry for the kingship that had spurred him to frame the boy for Tauriel’s death. It wasn’t personal. It was simply that Thranduil had hated to think of Tauriel’s spirit alone, in those unreachable lands beyond the veil of this earth. The dwarf’s life meant nothing. He would have died anyway, sooner or later. Kili’s spirit might as well reunite with Tauriel while he still looked handsome. Thranduil did not pray, as he did not expect the gods to be listening, but he certainly hoped in his secret thoughts that the gods would allow her to receive this one offering of a companion, a gift from her king, a comfort to her as she waited in the halls of the dead. One last kindness he could do for his foster daughter. With luck, the exchange had gone as expected and the dragon was sated with fresh meat, the City resupplied with Mithril, and soon Tauriel would not be alone. He could only hope.
From the balcony he could see bands of the starry sky between the thin, high branches at the tops of the trees. And what he glimpsed up there made him uneasy. He was sure he had seen a shadow up there, between the shifting clouds.
He was beginning to suspect that something had gone wrong at the top of the hill.
He left his watch point and summoned a retainer to follow him into a windowless room deeper in his apartment. Here, the lamps were dimmed above shelves of bottles, folded twists of paper and jars of dried herbs and powders. He found a locked cage at the back of the tallest shelf, filled with thin, narrow bottles sealed with glass stoppers and black wax. The servant held open a crate packed with dried grass and Thranduil carefully placed a dozen bottles inside, arranged them to his satisfaction, and closed the lid.
“Not wine, I suppose, sire?” The retainer asked with a wry smile.
Thranduil chuckled. “No. A tonic for an uninvited guest. I have expected a visit from him for many years and prepared accordingly.”
He hurried down towards the praetorian’s quarters in the lower levels of the palace with the retainer behind him, carrying the box. Only half his elite elven guard were there, the rest having not yet returned from the hill. Many of them had been roused from sleep when the roars of the dragon woke their watchmen, and were still in the process of dressing and eating a little food.
“What do we do, sire?” Their captain asked. “The dragon’s never made his presence known, before. He’s always been quiet as an owl.”
“Arm yourselves. Longspears and good, heavy armour, though you must still be able to climb in it,” Thranduil told them, and opened the crate with the bottles sealed with black wax. “Take one of these each, but be careful not to spill a drop. When he is close, break the seal and coat the blades of your weapons in it. And carry as much of that strong, spider-silk rope as you have in your stores. We will be setting an ambush. Go and tell the stables to prepare a horse as well. Just the one.”
The captain glanced at the elf next to him and then back to the king. “For yourself, my lord?”
“Of course,” said Thranduil. “As the bait.”
