Chapter Text
Thorin is positively fuming. He cannot believe the utter nonsense to which he has lately been subjected. The sheer idea that he might give over some of his treasure, not only to the Men of the Lake, but to the Elves as well? And why? Because the Men begrudged his company a few morsels of food and some ill-fitting clothes? Surely they did this only in the hope that they might someday get their hands on some of Thorin’s gold. And that says nothing of the Elves, who could claim no right to anything in the Mountain even if their intentions were true. It is below the dignity of the King Under the Mountain to be taunted and threatened by the Vassal of Dale, if Bard the Bargeman can be called as much.
“Begone!” Thorin yells through the gap in the wall. “Ere our arrows fly!”
He means that to the core of his being. He will shoot. His aim is not as true as his nephew’s, but he knows that he could do serious damage to that haughty bargeman, if he so chose. He has no love for the apparent leader of the Lake-Men who, only a few days ago, was speaking ill of Thorin in the streets and extorting him for coin as payment for the series of humiliation rituals to which Bard subjected his company. It was perhaps always some great conspiracy, the Elves and the Men putting their wicked heads together and concocting a plan to steal from Thorin. He would not put it past the Elves to be so conniving, nor the Men to be so greedy.
Thorin does not bother to watch as the Man departs on horseback. Instead, he returns to his company, in need of… something. Something that he cannot name. The Arkenstone, perhaps, though he still cannot find it, nor can he sense its presence as once he believed he might upon entry to the Mountain. His One, perhaps.
He is cheered, at least, by the sight of his Hobbit. Bilbo did not follow Thorin to the confrontation with Bard, and why would he? His place is inside the Mountain It would not do for any part of Thorin’s hoard to be seen by outsiders. Better for his One to remain unobserved, alongside the other precious things in Thorin’s keeping. He is pleased that Bilbo seems to understand this.
Thorin sighs in response to a gentle touch on his arm. Bilbo is always so warm, so alive and vibrant, so unlike the gold and jewels. It is a welcome change of pace but slightly dizzying nevertheless, as though Thorin’s body cannot fully adapt to the contrast between the hot, earthy beauty of his One and the cool splendor of his other treasure. “Bilbo,” he breathes, allowing his rage to leave him. Yes, this is much better after all, far preferable to spending any time with Elves and Men.
“Thorin,” Bilbo swallows heavily. Something troubles him. Perhaps the encroachment of Men and Elves upon Dwarven lands, their greed trained on Dwarven treasure. “Are you really going to do this? A war would be devastating for our people, not to mention for the Mountain itself. It would leave us open to attacks from the North. The goblins have been laying in wait since we killed their leader, and Azog’s orcs have been tracking us for even longer. If they should find us already besieged, already half starved—“
“This does not concern you.” Thorin cuts his One off with a gentle smile.
Of course the Hobbit would fret. He knows nothing of war, nothing of the world outside his cozy home. Thorin must protect him from the horrors of battle, from the inevitable confrontation with the Elves and Men. He must lock Bilbo up inside the Mountain where nobody will touch him. He must preserve the sweet innocence that causes Bilbo to believe that greedy creatures like Bard of Esgaroth will keep their word.
“Please, Thorin,” Bilbo tries again. “The Men and Elves are not our enemies. We have to prepare for battle, yes, but not against them.”
“Who, then, ghivashel?” Thorin runs a finger along Bilbo’s jaw, relishing the way his love swallows in response. He watches as Bilbo blatantly fights the urge to allow his eyes to flutter shut. Yes, the Hobbit is talking nonsense, but Thorin enjoys his company nevertheless.
“The orcs,” Bilbo replies, a little agitated now. “I just told you. They’re still tracking us.”
“You think they’re going to attack again?” Kíli asks, sounding genuinely concerned.
Annoyance bubbles up from somewhere deep within Thorin. Bilbo can be excused for expecting an orc attack, for failing to see the danger posed by the Men and Elves. He comes from a land of peace and plenty. He knows nothing of war, nothing of greed. But Kíli has been well educated in the ways of their people. He should know better than to excuse the threat of one war for the specter of another.
“I know they’re going to attack again,” Bilbo persists, “And they’ll bring wargs and goblins with them. Trolls, too, and worm monsters and all sorts of other horrible things. In case you’ve forgotten, Azog survived our last encounter. He seeks to end the line of Durin, does he not? Well, now there are three, four, how many of you?” Bilbo does not pause long enough for Thorin or anyone else to begin explaining their family tree to him, though it will be important for him to be familiar with this information when he is consort. “And all penned up inside a mountain with no clear plan of escape.”
“But that’s only if our enemies can get inside,” Fíli points out. “Couldn’t we hold the Mountain?” A foolish question. Of course they can hold the Mountain. And if they cannot, then better to die here among their treasures than cold and filthy on the field of battle.
“The Men and Elves will weaken our defenses,” Bilbo reasons, “We must do what we can to stop this war. Thorin, if you give them just a little bit of gold, they’ll all be beholden to you forever. If you personally financed the rebuilding of Dale—“
“You worry too much,” Thorin scolds lightly. He is not angry with Bilbo. Of course the Hobbit does not know any better than to fret, though Thorin is none too pleased with his nephews for encouraging this line of thinking. “Go and wait in the treasury. I will come and find you once the preparations have been made.” He does not believe that there will be an orc attack. Such stupid creatures could never break through the fortifications that their company has lately built, let alone the ones forged by Thorin’s ancestors.
“I will not wait anywhere,” Bilbo protests. It is endearing, this desire of his to remain by Thorin’s side. Unfortunately, Thorin would rather see his beloved safe and unhappy than allow him to put himself into danger. The separation, he is sure, would be bearable under such circumstances. “We are running out of food, and there are only fourteen of us. We are weakening ourselves for no reason and wasting time we could be using to prepare!” That, at least, makes sense. Yes, time is being wasted, standing here talking when Thorin should be arming his subjects and instructing them on the best methods to defend the hoard. “What, exactly, do you propose we do?”
“You should never underestimate Durin’s folk,” Thorin assures Bilbo warmly. Well, as warmly as he can manage. It’s difficult to muster too much mirth when the Men and Elves have brought armies to his door, intent on stealing from his hoard. “We have reclaimed Erebor. Now, we defend it.”
“You have sent word to Dáin already, then.” Bilbo sighs heavily. Why is he disheartened by this news?
“I have,” Thorin replies, “He will come with an army and defend the Mountain.”
“That’s all well and good, but the Elves and Men are not our enemies.” Bilbo repeats himself, gripping onto Thorin’s sleeve as though his life depends on it. “Listen, please listen. We are wasting vital time trying to fight each other when we should be doing everything we can to cut the orcs and goblins off! If we only parlay with the Men—“
“I will do no such thing.”
“Even if we survive,” Bilbo argues, “And even if the Mountain really is impassible, which, I’m sorry, no offense to all of you, you’ve done a lovely job, but I highly doubt, considering how quickly the twelve of you were able to put it together with your bare hands—“
“I do not doubt the skill of my people.” Thorin waves him off.
“A day ago you were doubting their loyalty!” Bilbo snaps.
And this is true enough. It is not as though Thorin has forgotten about the Arkenstone, of course. He knows that one of his own people has stolen the stone and is keeping it from him. But he knows, also, that failure to construct a proper barrier would put everyone at risk. “No one would be fool enough to steal the Arkenstone and then throw away his own life leaving the door open to our enemies. Relax, ghivashel. It is none of your concern.”
“Listen, Thorin, please listen.” The king’s Hobbit is clearly very upset, but the desperation in his tone is oddly gratifying. He cares so much about Thorin’s wellbeing that he would be willing to befriend Elves to protect him. Misguided though this logic may be, it’s rather sweet.“You are not yourself right now. When you come to your senses, you’ll be angry and guilty and you’ll regret what you’re doing now! If you still want to fight the Elves and Men later, then by all means, after we’ve dealt with the real threat, you can have your stupid, pointless war! But for now, we should be doing everything in our power to make sure that our people have food. Are you not hungry?”
“You worry too much, my Hobbit,” Thorin decides once more with finality. “Even if the orcs do come, Dáin’s army will dispatch them once the Men and Elves are dealt with. They are the ones who insist upon making war. I did not bring an army to their gate.”
“Yes, I know, it’s all terribly unfair, and Thranduil is being very greedy.” Thorin is pleased to see Bilbo finally coming around. Not that it matters very much what the Hobbit thinks. He does not know enough to have a serious opinion. Soon, he will be educated in the ways of the Ereborean court, and he will understand what it means to be consort to a king. For now, however, he must be kept away from danger at any cost. Even if it means that Thorin must drag Bilbo into the deepest vaults kicking and screaming. “But we must do what we can to prevent needless bloodshed.”
The others look on in silence, clearly waiting to see how Thorin will react to this odd challenge. “Then we are agreed.” They are, aren’t they? “I will not allow those thieves to touch my treasure. Dáin will assist us in defending the mountain, be it from Men or Elves or orcs. I have spoken.”
“You have a funny definition of ‘agree,’” Bilbo grumbles. “Come back to yourself, please, my love. As soon as possible.” He wraps his arms around Thorin, then, and though the words the Hobbit speaks make little sense, Thorin is content to return the embrace.
The only advantage to all of this battle-preparation business is that Bilbo now has more time than ever to himself. It is almost like being back in Bag End, save for the fact that his days, and those of all of his friends, are numbered. And, of course, there is virtually no food remaining. Second breakfast would be laughable to consider now, let alone elevensies, and even luncheon has become a thing of the past. Dinner and supper, already merged into one meal called interchangeably by either name, in keeping with the Dwarven custom, seem also to be on the way out. Really, it is not like Bag End at all, save for the all-encompassing loneliness.
He knows why. He understands perfectly. For anyone other than Thorin to speak to him privately at this juncture would pose a major risk. Bilbo does not know whether Fíli chose to tell the others what happened on the battlements, but surely he has warned them against getting too close to their Hobbit. Some members of the company, however, do not seem to take very well to warnings.
Nori and Kíli approach Bilbo while he is puttering about, ostensibly looking for the Arkenstone while Thorin rants nonsensical battle plans in Dwalin’s general direction. Bilbo does not wish to know the substance of these plans, and it troubles him that Thorin is so drawn in by them as to release his possessive hold for a moment. It seems that whatever he plans to have done to Thranduil is more important to him than Bilbo’s apparent well-being, which would be troubling under the rosiest of circumstances. These most certainly are not those.
“Our king’s gone insane,” Nori observes casually. Nobody else has said it aloud, but he’s right, of course. They all know he’s right. Thorin has gone insane and cannot be trusted to rule his kingdom. He would lead them to war and ruin, if not outright starvation, for the sake of his hoard, just as he did eighty years ago.
“It’s the gold,” Kíli explains when Bilbo makes no comment. Because what can Bilbo say? He can’t very well defend Thorin against accusations that are entirely true. “All this cursed dragon’s gold. That’s what’s making him like this.”
“Mmm,” Bilbo hums noncommittally. He will not make the same mistake twice. Thorin will not hesitate to harm even his own kin if he believes they’re getting too close to Bilbo.
“I’m sorry,” Kíli blurts out. “All of this is my fault.”
“Your highness,” Nori scolds him, delivering the title with his characteristic irreverence, “Shut up. That’s not what we’re here for.”
“No,” Kíli does not take instructions, as a general rule. If he did, no doubt he’d be in the armory with his brother, away from the gold but presumably doing something tangentially related to the security of Erebor. This arrangement seems to suit everyone involved: kept away from the treasure, Fíli and Kíli appear to have remained relatively healthy, and Thorin has no reason to suspect either of his nephews of any treachery of treason. “Bilbo, I’m so sorry. I told you to… in Lake-town, I mean, I said you and Thorin should… I didn’t think he’d get like this. I thought, if you just told him that you didn’t like the… possessiveness, then he’d stop. I should never have— Oh, Mahal, Bilbo, I’m sorry. I’m so sorry.”
Ah. Of course. Kíli encouraged Bilbo to initiate a proper relationship with Thorin, and now, because of that connection, Thorin’s behavior has expanded to unacceptable levels of possessiveness and paternalism. It makes sense that Kíli might blame himself, Bilbo supposes, though it is certainly not the prince’s fault that his uncle has lost his mind.
“Hush, lad, it’s alright.” But Bilbo knows better than to offer any genuine comfort. He won’t touch Kíli. Thorin will view it as threat, and he will retaliate.So Bilbo grips the nearest railing like a vice. Such a coward he has become! “It’s not your fault. You couldn’t possibly have known.” Just as he told Fíli earlier. Just as he will tell Thorin when all of this is over and the king comes back to himself. Bilbo should get used to these words, if he’s chosen to throw his lot in with the Line of Durin.
Bilbo has one goal. Never mind the silent, nonfunctional Ring of Power in his pocket. Never mind the fact that he is living in a dusty old mountain full of dragon dung. Never mind the madness of his king. Never mind the that useless, gaudy, thrice-damned rock.Bilbo needs to keep all of his friends alive, however he can. If that means manufacturing distance and keeping Thorin happy until a better plan can be worked up, then that is what Bilbo will do.
Yes. Alright. He’s been avoiding the company, the princes especially. He has chosen to isolate himself, elected to suffer alone under Thorin’s penetrating gaze. What else can he do? How else can he protect them? The Arkenstone is missing, even if Bilbo were fool enough to think of trying to trade it for assurances of securityagain. Thorin would only grow angry, and he would not be swayed.
Nori pats the prince awkwardly on the shoulder. What is needed is a proper Hobbit hug, un-self-conscious, soft, and warm. But that is not an option right now. Bilbo cannot take that risk, cannot put Kíli in any more danger than he is already in, with an orc host marching toward them and the Men and Elves gathered down below.
“Listen, Bilbo,” Nori begins. “None of us have any sway with Thorin anymore. He’s not even listening to Balin. Never thought I’d see that day, I can tell you. But do you think you could—“
“No,” Bilbo cuts him off. “I couldn’t.”
“You didn’t even let me finish.”
Bilbo closes his eyes. He can imagine the sorts of plans that may have circulated among the company in his and Thorin’s absence. “If you’d like me out of the way so you can mount a coup, I have to decline,” he growls. When did Bilbo Baggins start growling at people? “Thorin won’t hesitate to kill any of you, unless you killed him first. And if any of you did that, I’d never forgive you.”
“We wouldn’t dream of a coup,” Nori assures him, “Besides, Fíli won’t go along with it. I’ve asked.” Strange. Bilbo can’t imagine that happening the last time he did all of this.
“At least someone still has some sense.”
“You think we should let Thorin go to war?” Nori demands. “Let him send us to our deaths? Let him send our brothers to their deaths? When we’re all gone, there won’t be anybody left to unlock whatever chamber he puts you in once the Mountain’s under siege.”
“There must be some way to stop it,” Kíli manages, making a valiant effort to smother his sniffles. The poor lad is blaming himself for all of this, though he has no reason to. Thorin’s condition is nobody’s fault but Bilbo’s, and even he couldn’t have seriously stopped the king from entering the Mountain. “He won’t listen to any of us, but if we could go down and parlay behind his back, maybe—“
“No, no, absolutely not.” Bilbo has done this before, after all. He knows how that story ends. With a convenient Wizard at the last moment, or else with a broken body splayed out on the ground beneath the battlements. “It’s too much of a risk.”
“I’m quick and quiet,” Nori reminds him. “I’ve got noble blood, strictly speaking, if anyone wants to get technical about it. I know how to put on a good face. All you’ve gotta do is distract Thorin, and I’ll make my way down the Mountain and see what I can do.”
“No.” Bilbo says it firmly. “Nori, no. Absolutely not.”
“Someone’s got to do something.”
“Yes, someone has.” That much, Bilbo can agree to. “But Thorin will catch you, and he’ll have you killed. Both of you. Anyone who was involved. Anyone he suspects might have been involved. And then when he gets better, he will hate himself for the rest of his days. Do you understand? Thorin isn’t himself right now. Do you think he’d hesitate? And you can’t parlay behind his back, anyway. Even if you had the Arkenstone, which I sincerely hope you don’t, it wouldn’t work as leverage against Thorin. Trust me when I tell you that he wouldn’t listen. He’d only get angry, and he’d never give over any gold to get the wretched thing back. Short of murder—“
“No,” Kíli protests. “Never. It’s like you said. This isn’t really him. We can’t— For Durin’s sake, we can’t…” He never finishes the sentence, and Bilbo doesn’t blame him.
Bilbo closes his eyes. “Let me think of something. Let me take care of it. I’ve got you out of every mess until now, haven’t I? This shouldn’t be harder than a stroll to Buckland.” The Shire saying sounds out of place here in this Mountain darkened by the twin shadows of a fire-breathing dragon and a mad king.
“Last time you got us out of a mess, you left me with a nasty bruise on the back of my neck.” Apparently, Nori still isn’t over the little incident where a wounded Bilbo toppled into his barrel as they were escaping from the Elves.
“Have Óin put some salve on it, if it’s still bothering you,” Bilbo instructs.He honestly can’t believe that Nori hasn't done anything about the bruise until now. No, the thief is only teasing him, trying to lighten the moment, almost certainly for Kíli’s sake. The lad does not look any better than his brother did the other day. Oh, those poor young princes, gathering up their uncle’s slack as best they can, to no avail. There is nothing any of them can do to force Thorin to give over the gold, at least not in his present state. “I’ll put a stop to this. But in the meantime, none of you should do anything stupid.”
Kíli laughs, if a little weakly. He seems to be bordering on hysteria. “Do you think we could get in touch with Tauriel? Would the Ravens go to her? If only I could get to Ravenhill. Is that not where they roost?”
“No,” Bilbo’s blood is ice in his veins. Ravenhill. Ravenhill, of all places? That is Kíli’s plan? It would be a good one, perhaps, if not for the oncoming orcs. Suddenly, Bilbo’s focus shifts. His sole reason for drawing breath at this time is to keep Kíli from rushing to his death.“No, you’ll not be going to Ravenhill. As I said, I’ll take care of this. You’d better go and look like you’re doing something warlike, both of you, before Thorin notices anything amiss. If Tauriel can be reached, Kíli, then I’ll do my best. But for now, none of you should try to sneak about. You don’t send warriors or thieves do do a Burglar’s job.”
Nori whistles. “Well, the consort has spoken.” He affects a smug expression that fools nobody. The thief may be a quick thinker, and he may have plenty of experience bluffing, but he’s as terrified as any of the rest of them. “That’s that, then.”
Bilbo is not the consort, not technically, at least. But they all know that he’s been fulfilling that role since their arrival in Erebor. And if his friends seeing him that way keeps them from doing anything that might get somebody killed, Bilbo is more than happy to go along with it.“We really should be going,” Kíli decides, gathering himself. “Bilbo’s right. Uncle Thorin is going to notice that we’re gone.” Bilbo can only pray that his advice will be taken.
Time does not render Bilbo any aid in concocting a plan that might return Thorin to his right mind. He spends his days pacing and thinking, trying to work something out, with scant results. Everything he tries has fallen flat, and now the company is being armed for war. They rifle through the armory while Bilbo paces in tight circles outside the door.
“Ghivashel.” Thorin’s voice distracts Bilbo from his mounting anxiety, as it always does. He struggles not to feel comforted by the sheer presence of his lost love. There is some tiny, selfish part of him which is indiscriminately happy to be by Thorin’s side, even when the king is so obviously in such a terrible state. “Come here.”
Bilbo sighs heavily. He could have avoided this, if he really wanted to. He could have done as he was told and waited in the treasury. He could have chosen to do his pacing as far from the armory as possible. He could have secreted himself away and slunk out of the Mountain at the earliest opportunity, though what he would do, he isn’t certain. The ring in Bilbo’s pocket no longer grants him invisibility, but he is still a Hobbit and could easily have hidden from the company if he wished to. He can pretend, he supposes, that he only wants the benefit of armor. He can pretend that this is a tactical maneuver, that his head is focused solely on his goals of saving his friends and destroying the ring. But really, Bilbo is being incredibly weak.
It was a struggle not to close his eyes and melt into Thorin’s embrace when the king was spouting nonsense about the necessity of defending his treasure from thieves. It is a struggle every day for Bilbo not to go completely boneless, to respond as his body wishes to the attention lavished upon him. He has spent eight decades longing for Thorin’s touch, for the love that was ripped away from him upon Ravenhill. His mind and body have cried out, loudly at first, then quieter and quieter as the years progressed, for this person who now seems to crave Bilbo’s company just as openly.
But Thorin is not well. It would not be right for Bilbo to fold, to allow him anything more than a few chaste touches. Not because he doesn’t want it, but because it would be taking advantage. Thorin cannot make sure decisions at this juncture. And it is clear that no matter how gentle his caresses might be, he does not presently regard Bilbo as an independent person but as simply one more piece of treasure in his hoard. He is going to give Bilbo a beautiful gift, one that could very well serve as a symbol of his love, but instead it will be nothing more than an act of possession. And Bilbo will lean into it, because he needs the stupid impenetrable shirt, and he loves Thorin, and he wants it to be no more complicated than any other gesture of affection. It breaks Bilbo’s heart, but he lacks the luxury of time to be heartbroken.
Emotions aside, he needs that mithril mail. There is nothing more to be said on the matter. Bilbo finds himself standing in front of Thorin, just as he did the last time. Only now, he understands so much more about Dwarven customs and the nature of dragon sickness. He’s had his suspicions about this moment, of course, but they have been largely irrelevant until now. What did it matter what Thorin’s intentions were when the king was laying motionless in the crypts beneath the Mountain with the Arkenstone upon his breast?
“You’re going to need this.” Thorin shakes the mithril shirt, and the mail rattles prettily. The way it sparkles in the torchlight is undeniably beautiful as well. “Put it on.” Another command. Bilbo has long wished that he could have shared this moment with a more stable version of Thorin, that his dear friend who hugged him on the Carrock could have been the one to bestow this armor upon him. But not so. And even still, Bilbo does as he is told.
“This vest is made of silver steel,” Thorin explains. “Mithril, it was called by my forbears. No blade can pierce it.”
And Bilbo knows all this, of course. He knows that this mail saved Frodo’s life on more than one occasion when the lad went on his quest to Mordor. He knows that the fate of Middle Earth lays in Thorin’s hands at this moment.Because last time, it may have been Frodo, but this time, Bilbo will be the one to throw that ring in Mount Doom.
He didn’t realize this was his plan until the thought popped so clearly into his head, but now, he knows that it is what he must do. He knows that there is no other choice, no other way to ensure that the ring is fully destroyed. He’ll show it to Gandalf first, of course, and see what the Wizard thinks, but Bilbo was a fool to believe that his quest will be over so easily. If he survives the battle, no matter what happens to any of his friends, Bilbo knows that he will have another long journey ahead of him.
But he does not have time to dwell on it now. There is a war coming, and Bilbo can’t imagine he’ll get to Mount Doom any time soon. He knows that he’ll have to stay and fight, to do everything in his power to protect Thorin and his heirs, before he can worry any more about the ring. Bilbo also knows that he does not look as ridiculous in this getup as he thought he did the last time. What had he said before? I’m not a warrior, I’m a Hobbit.
But Thorin has not dressed him in the vestments of a warrior. That much is plain to see with a single glance into the armory. The others are dressed in heavy armor, complete with plates and helmets. Their bodies are obscured by the blocky metal, which will be difficult to pierce by virtue of its construction. They are the warriors, and Bilbo is dressed like the Consort of Erebor. Precious to the king and fine to look at. A piece of treasure, not a weapon to be deployed upon the battlefield. Yes, Bilbo is going to need armor, but Thorin must intend this only as last line of defense.
“It is a gift,” the king explains. “A token of our love.” The word falls heavily from his lips, laden with meanings that were not so apparent the last time they did this.
And Bilbo is a very weak Hobbit indeed, to swoon and melt as he does at the sound of it. Love. Love. It is not love. Or it is love, of course it is love, but this act is not demonstrative of that. Thorin does not remember what it feels like to love Bilbo. He knows now only what it is to covet, to crave the presence of the Hobbit by his side. He would hurt Bilbo, if he felt betrayed, if he felt justified in doing so.
And yet this is a moment of which Bilbo has dreamed for many years. Receiving a gift from Thorin, being told in no uncertain terms that he is loved, that the feelings blooming in his mind and body are not his alone. That he and Thorin are at a solid, healthy understanding, that they have a future together. That Thorin wants a future with him, when he could have anyone else. Still, Thorin would choose Bilbo. Even when his mind is gone, even when he cannot remember what it is to love or how one should behave toward one’s partner, still, some central part of him would choose Bilbo.
It is a knife in Bilbo’s side. It is a knife and it is twisting and it is worse than bearing the One Ring, worse than learning Frodo’s fate, worse than living for all those years alone in the Shire. But it is not worse than watching Thorin bleed out upon the ice, hearing him beg for forgiveness, knowing that the king went to his grave thinking that he’d ruined things, that Bilbo did not return his feelings. It does not matter what a stronger Hobbit would do. Bilbo asks the question he was too afraid to ask the last time. “Is this a proposal, Thorin?”
Thorin laughs, then, the same way that he did both times on the Carrock. The same way that he does whenever Kíli makes a stupid, well-timed joke, deliberately engineered to catch his uncle off guard. Just like when Dwalin does something uncharacteristically gentle or Balin’s nagging borders on the hyperbolic. This is the same laugh that Thorin hid inside his mug of ale when Bofur danced on the table at Rivendell, the same laugh that bubbled forth one night on the road when Fíli elected to entertain the company with his rather impressive juggling skills. This laugh is the real Thorin Oakenshield, not the King Under the Mountain he was raised to be or the trauma that has toughened him or the dragon sickness that has lately poisoned his great mind.
“It is,” he replies eventually, swallowing his mirth. Bilbo could kiss him. Because this is not the mad monarch, but Thorin Oakenshield, truly, the only one Bilbo has ever loved with such passion, such levity, such intensity. “What say you?”
“Do you really have to ask?” Bilbo can’t help but smile up at Thorin. He stares into those beautiful, gleeful blue eyes. There is so much hope there, so much love. And nerves, too, as if Thorin ever seriously believed that Bilbo would deny him. Bilbo, who has stayed by his side through the worst of the dragon sickness and everything else. The idea of refusing Thorin now is simply laughable. “I say yes, of course. I told you already, I intend to be your consort once this whole mess is sorted out.”
Tell me that you’ll sort it out now, Bilbo pleads inside his head. Tell me that you’ll send a Raven to Bard, that you’ll parlay, that you’ll give them a little gold and turn your focus and your cousin’s army to the Goblins and Orcs. Tell me that you’re sorry. Tell me that you need to go apologize to Fíli for the way you spoke to him the other day. Tell me—
“You are loyal to me, then.” Bilbo watches as the blue flame returns to Thorin’s eyes. “That is hard to come by.” Thorin places a heavily-armored hand on his shoulder and steers him just a little too roughly away from the armory where the rest of the company resides. “I have been blind. But now I begin to see. I am betrayed.”
Bilbo’s heart falls to his stomach as he realizes he has heard these words before. Nothing he does matters, does it? No matter what he tries, Thorin still falls into the same dark patterns that he traced before. “Betrayed?” Bilbo echoes uselessly, just as he probably did the first time.
He keeps falling into this same ridiculous trap. He keeps convincing himself, even momentarily, that he has somehow managed to save Thorin with romance alone. He is no better than the princes on that score, blaming himself for something that is clearly not his fault. Thorin did not die upon Ravenhill because Bilbo failed to communicate his feelings. He died because Azog stabbed him. He died because he was fighting through grief. He died because he was weak and tired and hungry and drained from his sickness. He died because that is what happens in battle: people die. Kings die, and the young die, and Men and Elves and orcs die, and there is nothing Bilbo can do about any of that.
Not unless he prevents the battle. Not unless he stops his friends from marching on Ravenhill. Not unless he secures an impossible alliance. Even if he could cure Thorin’s madness, he tells himself, staring into the king’s hot eyes, the outcome of the battle would not automatically be changed.
“The Arkenstone,” Thorin clarifies. “One of them has taken it. One of them is false.”
Last time they had this conversation, the Arkenstone was in Bilbo’s pocket. Now, he does not know where it is, though of course, he has his suspicions. Balin is still the most likely candidate, but then, Bombur has been particularly reclusive lately, and Bofur has been shooting worried looks in Bilbo’s direction for the past several days. Fíli had his hand in his pocket when Bilbo saw him on the battlements, and Kíli has tried to talk Thorin into helping the people of Lake-town more than once. Dwalin has been oddly quiet, as well, and Dori continues to pace. Ori rarely leaves the library, even for what scant meals the company can manage to scrape together. Nori was prepared to go down and parlay with the Men and Elves, but what could he possibly have to offer, save for the stone? It could be any of them.
“Thorin,” Bilbo begins, “I don’t think—“
“Betrayed by my own kin,” Thorin cuts him off.
“Maybe you just haven’t found it yet.” These words sound hollow and false even to Bilbo. Of course somebody has the Arkenstone. There is not enough gold in Erebor to hide its shine indefinitely. After so many long days with so many of them looking, someone has to have stumbled upon it. “Maybe it will come to you in time.”
“In time?” Thorin echoes. “We do not have time. There is an armed host at our gates.”
“So we should be worried about how we will prevent the oncoming siege,” Bilbo reasons, “Or at least how we will feed ourselves during it.”
“You are wise and noble,” Thorin decides, though Bilbo feels these words are just as empty as his own. If Thorin truly thought Bilbo wise, he’d listen to him, which he clearly does not intend to do. And as for nobility, it means very little to have noble motives when they do not carry any action with them. “A fine consort you will make.”
“Could you not give just a little bit to Bard, just to help his people get back on their feet?” Bilbo asks. “Whatever you would give to me as a wedding gift, give to them instead. They need it far more than I do. I am content just with your company, and the company of our kin. I don’t need any more than that.”
“The treasure does not belong to the people of Lake-town.” Thorin cups Bilbo’s face in his hand. It might be romantic, were he not dressed for battle, were his eyes not blazing with a fire hotter than any burning coals could produce. “This gold… is ours. And ours alone. By my life, I will not part with a single coin. Not one piece of it.” His intensity makes Bilbo shudder. The implication is clear. Bilbo may be the future consort of Erebor, but his betrothed will never grant him the authority to give away any of the treasure.
Bilbo wants to ask Thorin whether he himself is included in that treasure, whether the king would allow Bilbo to leave his sight if the Hobbit so wished. He wants to know what it was that made Thorin’s glare soften, ever so briefly, and what it was that made those haunting flames come back. He wants to say something that will help, something that will make Thorin reconsider his decision to send the company to war. Would a wedding make things better or worse?
But before Bilbo can say anything, he is interrupted by the sound of footsteps. The company marches out of the armory, single-file, dressed for war. The torchlight makes their breastplates gleam. They all bear impressive weapons, most of which Bilbo cannot imagine lifting on his own. He has a distinct memory of the last time this happened. Thorin stepped back, as did Bilbo, and the others marched in between them, an impassible divide. Thorin’s warlike behavior drove a wedge between them, forced apart what might have been a significant pairing.
Now, however, Thorin grabs Bilbo around the waist and drags him out of the way. It is such an easy, fluid motion. Not premeditated at all. Was Thorin restraining himself the first time, then? Has Bilbo, in agreeing to marry him, taken away some of Thorin’s meagre self-restraint? Or did Thorin suspect that Bilbo had taken the Arkenstone? Did he fight with himself, the small part left of the Thorin Bilbo knew assuring the mad monarch that the Hobbit would never betray him? Is that why he became so violent when he learned that he was wrong?
“I know you do not have it,” Thorin murmurs into Bilbo’s ear as Bofur marches past them, a metal helmet balanced oddly atop his favorite hat. “I would have felt it as I held you close.” Yes, he would have. They have been in such proximity lately that Thorin would doubtlessly have noticed if the Arkenstone were on Bilbo’s person. “And since Mahal has bound you to me as my One, you could not betray me if you wished.” That’s not strictly true, but Bilbo is not about to correct Thorin on his misapprehension. “But it could be any of them.”
Bilbo does not know what to say. He does not wish to lie, but he certainly has no desire to put whoever has bravely taken the Arkenstone into any more danger than they are already in. Instead, he speaks the truth. “Everyone here is loyal to you,” he points out, “They all came this way with you, didn’t they? But there is a curse upon this treasure. You may not be the only one affected.”
Everything is going to be fine. Balin must have the Arkenstone, as Bilbo concluded earlier. He would know to take it and destroy it. He probably threw it into some deep mine, or off the side of the mountain, or passed it off to a Raven to drop into Mount Doom. Or something of that nature. Balin, surely, would not hesitate to keep the gem from Thorin. He’d know what to do. Bilbo should not be worrying about the possibility that someone more volatile, someone with more of a claim to the throne, someone less objective about Thorin’s present state, might have claimed the rock.
“There is no curse,” Thorin declares, as if he did not personally drag his grandfather from the treasury during a dragon attack. Thrór was so addled at that time that he was willing to burn to death so long as he did not have to leave his treasure behind. But if Thorin believed in the curse, he’d be aware of his own madness, which would be too much to ask. “None would steal from my hoard but by his own will. I will find the thief and chop off his hand as penance for his crime before I kill him.”
“These people are your kin, Thorin,” Bilbo points out. The company has long since passed them by. They received a few odd glances, a knowing smirk from Bombur and a heavy sigh from Balin, but nobody spoke. Nobody would dare intrude on what appeared to be a very private moment. More likely than not, they thought that Thorin was whispering sweet nothings in Bilbo’s ears, as opposed to paranoid rambling. Or, at least, they prefer to believe the former to the latter, which, considering Thorin’s condition at the moment, must be known to all to be more likely.
“And that makes the betrayal all the worse.”
There is no swaying him, no changing Thorin’s mind once he has set it on something. Bilbo knows this from experience. So he settles for leaning back, resting his head uncomfortably against the king’s metal-clad chest. Neither one of them says anything for a very long while, and nobody makes any move to interrupt them.
The next day or so passes by in a blur. Coaxing Thorin out of the treasury at all is a genuine feat, and getting him to stay out long enough to eat a proper meal or get a full night’s sleep is, apparently, beyond the capacity of a single loving Hobbit. Bilbo does what he can, but as he watches his king frantically sorting gems and coins in a fruitless search for the Arkenstone, apparently unconcerned with the dark circles under his eyes, his rapidly loosening clothes, and the armies waiting at his gate, it is difficult to feel like anything more than a failure.
Rarely does he see the others, for all that Thorin keeps him close. Balin has managed a few visits to the treasury in his capacity as advisor, with a few long looks in Bilbo’s direction when Thorin is distracted. The king seems to welcome his sister-sons to his domain well enough, though Bilbo could not parse the frantic hand-gestures with which they tried to communicate with him behind Thorin’s back. Dwalin once told Thorin directly to ‘let the Hobbit breathe a minute,’ which resulted in his immediate dismissal from the king’s line of sight, coupled with a threat against his life.
Regardless of the obvious fears harbored by his companions, Bilbo, thankfully, is still the same frightfully organized and quick-thinking Hobbit who first set out from Bag End all those years ago. He may be deeply troubled by all that has happened since the company’s arrival at Erebor, but he will not be cowed. He cannot allow his friends to sit inside the mountain waiting for their doom. Bilbo must act, and he must act quickly.
Obviously, his original plan is out of the question. Even if Bilbo had the Arkenstone, which he does not, he knows full well that giving the gem to Bard will solve absolutely nothing. Thorin has proven that he is no more likely to be swayed by logic or honor than he was the last time. The king is not in his right mind, and Bilbo must tread carefully if his aim is to prevent a war.
The best he can hope for, of course, is to resolve the conflict between the three free kingdoms before the confrontation with the orcs. If Bard, Thranduil, and Dáin all send their warriors to meet the oncoming orc host, with perhaps a small contingent left behind to defend Erebor, then the Mountain will be safe enough. Thorin can recover inside, as he did the last time, while his kin and the Eagles take care of the orcs. They’ll be better prepared, with fewer dead and wounded at the start of the battle, and the advantage provided by an ambush. Yes, Thorin and the lads in particular will feel anger and guilt at being left behind inside their stronghold while others fight their battles for them, but they will also be safe.
After all, Azog seeks to destroy the line of Durin, does he not? Bilbo cannot see the sense in allowing the royal family to leave Erebor only to be driven into a trap. The pale orc will be distracted, searching the Dwarven ranks for absent leaders, and Dáin’s folk will take advantage of the confusion to dispatch the evil creature. Right? Doesn’t that make sense? Isn’t that a reasonable solution?
Bilbo wishes he had somebody to ask. But even if Thorin were in any position to have a conversation with him, he couldn’t very well reveal any of his foreknowledge. This is the same wall that he’s been running up against since the very beginning. Bilbo will, once again, have to take care of everything alone and hope that it works out for the best. But how to go about it?
He can’t use the Arkenstone. He could bring Thranduil the white gems that the Elf King so covets, except that Bilbo would have to carry a chest of precious stones down the side of a mountain without being seen by either side. Too difficult, even if he thought it would be effective, which he does not. Thorin would be angry about the loss of any piece of his hoard, and though he might not attempt to have Bilbo executed for it, the Hobbit would probably wind up locked in the treasury for the rest of his very brief life while the company waited for the orcs to come kill them. The long and short of it is that giving away treasure behind Thorin’s back, while it might be the right thing to do in terms of honor and propriety, is not a sound strategy for preventing a war.
What other options does Bilbo have? He could beg Bard and Thranduil to leave, though he doubts that would be effective, either. Would they believe him if he told them about the orcs? They would probably assume that Thorin had sent him to drive them off, especially if he arrived empty-handed. Thranduil is power-hungry and Bard has lived a very rough life; both of them have made suspicious by their circumstances.
Is there nobody down in that camp who will listen to reason? Yes, Bilbo realizes with sudden surety, there is. Of course! Gandalf could help! Didn’t the Wizard come to warn Bard and Thranduil about the orcs in the first place? That failed, obviously, or the battle would have turned out differently. But perhaps… maybe if Bilbo could find Gandalf and explain Thorin’s symptoms, the Wizard could do something to help! Bard and Thranduil do not want a war. Would they not allow Gandalf to parlay with the King Under the Mountain? It would only be the logical thing to do, especially if it might lead to Bard being given his share of the treasure. Bilbo cannot help Thorin on his own, but Gandalf has power beyond his comprehension. Could he not set things right?
It isn’t as though Bilbo has any other choice. The food stores are running low enough that even if, by some miracle, Erebor withstands the siege, the entire company will starve to death inside before the Battle is even through. He makes up his mind, slinking out of the treasure hoard while Thorin is distracted by his latest handful of gleaming coins. Bilbo refuses to allow himself any meditation on his feelings about this, the fact that his beloved is more interested in gold than he is in Bilbo. That was always going to be the case, after all. Bilbo doesn’t get to be surprised.
He sneaks through the halls of Erebor which he has come to know so well and makes his way up the battlements. Even after all these years, he does not like them. The memory does not sit well in his stomach. He doesn’t blame Thorin, of course, but it isn’t exactly a pleasant experience to be dangled over a great height by one’s neck, staring into the flaming eyes of one’s mad love. But that is only one more thing about which Bilbo does not have time to think. He is in the process of attaching a rope to the wall for easy climbing when he is interrupted by footsteps.
“You should be inside. Out of the wind.”
Of course it is Bofur. Who else would it be? This happened last time, too. Bilbo lied about it in his book, fabricated a conversation with Bombur which never took place. He doesn’t know quite why he did it. Perhaps because the whole affair takes on a different meaning when the story is told accurately. If Bilbo hoodwinked poor old Bombur, took advantage of his exhaustion with a false act of kindness, then the tale is a simple one of utilitarian necessity. But if Bofur allowed Bilbo to go, knowing exactly what it meant, with full understanding of what Thorin’s words and deeds meant, what the king planned to do to the Hobbit should he stay? That would make it into a tale of deep, perhaps improper, friendship and love. Too many questions would be raised in the minds of the Hobbit children listening to the tale.
“I was just…“ Bilbo trails off. What’s the point? Whether he lies or tells the truth or remains silent, Bofur will know exactly what he’s planning to do.
Bofur moves to stand by Bilbo on the battlements, staring out at the long drop below. He pointedly refuses to look at Bilbo’s very obvious rope. “The Elves have been moving their archers into position. The battle will be over by tomorrow’s eve, though I doubt we will live to see it. You’ve been in the treasury with Thorin for a few hours now, haven’t you?”
“Yes.” Bilbo has, frankly, lost track of time. Lately he and Thorin have fallen into an odd rhythm wherein the king meanders through his hoard, searching in vain for the absent Arkenstone, and the Burglar paces in tight circles, trying to think of a way to get out of this mess.
“He’ll be looking for you soon, then.” Bofur does not qualify this statement with any further explanation. But that isn’t necessary. Bilbo knows full well what he’s talking about. “No one could blame a soul for wishing themselves elsewhere.”
Thorin will notice Bilbo’s absence in a matter of minutes, and he will hunt him down and bring him back to the treasury posthaste. Bilbo knows frightfully little about Dwarven Ones, and even less about how that sort of bond can be affected by dragon sickness. Clearly, since he accepted Thorin’s proposal, something significant has changed. While before Thorin seemed to crave Bilbo’s presence at all times, he now seems to become greatly unsettled by Bilbo’s absence, once he becomes aware of it. It’s all very confusing, but then, Bilbo can hardly expect somebody to think rationally when he isn’t in his right mind.
“He will be,” Bilbo agrees. He ignores the second half of Bofur’s utterance, just as he did the last time he heard it. Bilbo does not wish for his friends to think him a coward, to believe that he would abandon them, would abandon Thorin, in a moment of obvious need.
There is a long silence while he waits for Bofur to offer the same kind farewell that he gave him the last time, the same cryptic resolution to look the other way while Bilbo escaped. But Bofur clears his throat and says something altogether unexpected.
“I had a long talk with Fíli this morning,” Bofur announces.
“Did you?” For a moment, Bilbo doesn’t understand. He’s been so caught up in everything else that he’d nearly forgotten about the incident with Thorin and Fíli and the sword. Well, both incidents with Thorin and Fíli and the sword. “What did he say?”
“He says,” Bofur begins, clearly uncomfortable with this line of discussion. “That Thorin threatened you during the fight with the dragon.”
Bilbo bites his lip. Yes, technically, that happened. “Thorin isn’t in his right mind,” is all he can offer. He’s been saying it over and over ever since they got to Erebor, as though it might be news to any of the company. But Bilbo is truly at a loss for anything else. “We can’t— well, of course we can hold him accountable, but we can’t…” Bilbo huffs. “He wouldn’t have done that, if he were himself. I do not fear him.”
“The lad told me true, then.” Bofur looks down over the battlements at the desolation, as though contemplating an escape. Probably, he is contemplating Bilbo’s escape and wondering how it will go for the poor Hobbit alone in the wilderness, outside the protection of the Mountain. “I had hoped… I had hoped that perhaps he misunderstood what he was seeing. Jumped to conclusions, maybe.”
Bilbo does not mention the part of the story that Fíli left out, the very relevant detail where Thorin threatened the crown prince for no good reason. Maybe he should say something. After all, if Thorin discovers the two of them here together, he might be less forgiving with Bofur than he was with Fíli. “You should go back inside,” Bilbo advises, “And find Bombur. He’s next, isn’t he? Your watch is over, and you need your sleep.”
“Ah,” Bofur gives Bilbo an appraising look. “It’ll take a bit to wake him."
Bilbo swallows. “I’m not running away from Thorin.” He needs to make this clear. “I’m not giving up on him. I’m going to get him some help. I’ll be back. I’ll be right back! I’ll see you in the morning.”
Bofur may be very skilled at hiding his true emotions, but even he cannot conceal the doubt and grief in his bright eyes. Even if he does believe that Bilbo will be back, he very likely struggles with the idea that there is anything that can help Thorin now. But Gandalf was able to heal Thorin on the Carrock, when all hope seemed to be lost, and according to Merry Brandybuck, the Wizard once used a spell to shake King Theodin of Rohan from a similar madness to the one from which Thorin suffers. Where there’s life, there’s hope, Bilbo reminds himself, and where there’s a Wizard, there’s even more of it.
“Goodbye, Bilbo,” Bofur says with a gentle hand on the Hobbit’s shoulder. Strange. The last time, when he said that, he was already on his way back inside the mountain. But it does not take much pondering to figure out the reason for this change. It is obvious why Bofur would be more worried now that he was before.
“I’ll see you in the morning, Bofur.” Bilbo looks up into his friend’s eyes with steely determination. This is not a matter of debate. Bilbo will be back here with the Wizard in no time, and Gandalf will use his magic to put some sense into Thorin, and all will be resolved. Well, except for the two armies of Orcs presently plotting an ambush on Ravenhill, but that is a bridge that Bilbo will have to cross when he gets to it.
It takes much less time for Bilbo to be captured and taken to Bard and Thranduil than it did the on the first go. Obviously, since he can no longer become invisible, Bilbo’s only choice is to present himself to the guards with his arms raised. He considered leaving Sting on the battlements and coming unarmed to prove his peaceful intentions, but that seems ill-advised. What if something happens on the way to the camp and Bilbo must fight? He’d rather not be entirely unarmed.
So he raises his arms, throws down his sword, and allows the guard to take him and the blade to the tent where Bard and Thranduil await. Bilbo does not know precisely how to go about this conversation, but he has to try for Thorin’s sake and the sake of the company. “Good evening,” he addresses both kings with an awkward little bow.
“Mister Baggins,” Bard greets him, straight-faced as ever. “What brings you away from your king and his treasure hoard?”
“Ah, yes, well, about that.” Bilbo glances meaningfully at the guard who is currently gripping his arm with an unnecessary level of force. It is not as amusing as one might assume to know that the guard must stoop slightly to reach Bilbo at all. The Elf who’s holding him is about three times his size and heavily armed, while Bilbo has given up his sword and carries only a useless ring. He does still have his mithril mail on underneath his clothes, but it’s not as though anybody else is aware of that fact. “I thought we might talk in private. With the Wizard, too, if he’s here.”
“The Wizard?” Bard asks.
“He is here.” Thranduil waves his hand and dismisses the guard, presumably to fetch Gandalf. Bilbo is only pleased to have his arm released from that iron grip. He shudders to think of what Thorin would do to the Elf that dared to leave a bruise on Bilbo, because he doubtless will be bruised, even through the mithril. “Though I am more interested in why you have come, Halfling.”
Bilbo ignores the rude term. It’s not as though he expected Thranduil to be polite, especially considering that they are technically standing on opposing sides of a war at the moment. “Right, well, that has to do with Gandalf, and I’d really rather explain only once,” Bilbo explains. “So I’ll wait for him, if you don’t mind.”
Bilbo doesn’t really have the bargaining power here to be making such demands, but he doesn’t particularly care. He’s sick and tired of all this kingly nonsense. Yes, absolutely, Thorin is in the debt of the Men of the Lake and should repay them for their kindness, but he owes nothing to Thranduil, and no promise is worth the lives of so many worthy Men and Elves, not to mention how many of Dáin’s warriors will fall on the battlefield if things unfold the way Bilbo expects them to.
“Very well.” Thranduil studies Bilbo in a way he does not quite enjoy. “Though I suspect that you are responsible for the miraculous escape that Thorin and company managed from my dungeons.”
“I am,” Bilbo admits, stalling for time so he doesn’t have to sit in awkward silence waiting for the Wizard, “Though your friend Bard had a hand in it as well.”
Bard’s habitual grimace tightens. “At that time, Thorin, son of Thráin was in the habit of honoring his word and paying those who gave him aid.”
“I have received not a cent for the food I provided,” Thranduil drawls.
Oddly, the desire for vengeance which dogged Bilbo’s thoughts in the Elven dungeons has abandoned him now. He still seethes, of course, but he is less inclined to clobber Thranduil and more inclined to snipe at the Elf King with a biting remark, as any Hobbit worth his salt would do. “Perhaps you could consider the bruise your guard left on my king as your payment.”
Thranduil snorts. “You are an odd servant, Master Hobbit, and loyal beyond what Thorin Oakenshield deserves.”
“But Master Baggins is not a servant,” Bard points out. Both kings are studying Bilbo with far too much intensity for his tastes.
Thankfully, before Thranduil and Bard can get into a conversation about the nature of Bilbo’s relationship with Thorin, Gandalf barges into the tent. “Bilbo Baggins!” He bellows, embracing the Hobbit. If Gandalf is at all surprised to feel the mithril mail beneath Bilbo’s clothes, he does not betray this shock. “I’m glad to see that you are all in once piece after your meeting with the dragon!”
Bilbo hugs him back gratefully. “It’s good to see you, Gandalf,” he replies, “But now that you’re here, I think we should go ahead with it. We’re all very busy people, after all.” Bilbo knows that it is a risk to be gone from the Mountain for too long. Thorin will not take his absence well.
“Yes, I agree,” Thranduil drawls. “I am looking forward to hearing why Thorin Oakenshield has sent you in his stead. Why not one of his heirs?”
“Well, he hasn’t sent me exactly,” Bilbo explains.
“He has not sent you?” Bard repeats. “Please, tell us why you have come once more to speak with me against your king’s wishes.”
That reminds Bilbo of their earlier conversation. “Did you heed my advice before, King Bard? Did you wait for the dragon in the watchtower?”
“Aye, I did. Though that could not prevent the beast from wreaking havoc, especially considering the recent orc attack.” So Bilbo’s warning was marginally effective, but the company still led a party of orcs to Bard’s home.
“Are your children well?” Bilbo inquires. He knows he should get down to the business of his visit, but now that he’s been reminded, he needs to confirm that Bain, Tilda, and Sigrid are alright.
“All alive,” Bard reports. “Though none of the Men of the Lake are particularly well at the moment. We are sleeping in tents and preparing for battle, in case you had not noticed, Mister Baggins.”
“Right.” Bilbo swallows. That’s as good a segue as any. “Bard, Thranduil. You should know that there’s an army of orcs marching on the Mountain right now.”
“Yes, the Wizard told us,” Thranduil replies, sounding bored. “I did not believe it then, and I do not believe it now.”
Bilbo ignores him. “And there is another army coming from the North. They intend to stage a trap on Ravenhill.”
“A trap for whom?”
Well. Bilbo may as well say it. “For Thorin and his heirs. Azog the Pale Orc intends to wipe out the line of Durin once and for all.”
“I’m not quite sure I care.” At least Thranduil is honest. “They have refused us what we are owed. If they wish to die atop Ravenhill—“
“Thorin is not well,” Bilbo blurts out. He does not need to think about his friends dying right now. He cannot handle the flood of images, the bombardment of memories that will no doubt come of this. But he must. He must handle it, he must pull himself together, he must make use of his famous silver tongue and talk his friends out of this predicament. Bilbo has been strong for Thorin and Company before, too many times to count, and now he need only repeat that common feat. “He suffers from dragon sickness. There is a curse upon that treasure, as you well know, Your Majesty.” He directs a vague bow in Bard’s general direction. “And Thorin has succumbed to it, through no fault of his own.”
“He chose to enter the Mountain against all warnings,” Bard points out.
“Yes, yes, he did,” Bilbo concedes, “But the fact stands that he fully intended to give you what you were owed upon entry to the Mountain. He had no way of knowing that he’d fall ill. None of the rest of the company have succumbed.”
“Then why not remove him from the throne and have done with it?” Thranduil asks. “He has two heirs with him, does he not? Choose the sanest of them, if there is one that can be called sane, and name him the King Under the Mountain.”
“And if you fall sick, should Prince Legolas then claim your throne?” Bilbo snaps. “I’m sure he would rule fairly and justly. I doubt he would imprison starving travelers or allow orcs to pass unhindered through his lands.”
Thranduil’s eyes are icy. “Careful, little one. You should not speak of that which you do not understand.”
“And nor should you, Your Majesty.” Bilbo is not afraid of Thranduil, and he is angry, angrier than he has ever been in all his life. “I have come to request that Gandalf the Grey be allowed to speak with King Thorin.”
“Why should the Wizard succeed where we have not?” Bard asks. “I would have peace over war, Mister Baggins, but I doubt that there is any way around a battle if Thorin Oakenshield is truly as unwell as you claim.”
“I believe that Gandalf can cure him,” Bilbo reasons, “If he is only allowed inside the Mountain—“
“This is an obvious trick,” Thranduil declares, “Do not think we are so naive as to fall for it. Thorin Oakenshield is not ill but mad with power, and that cannot be cured. His greed poisoned him from the outset. You wish to send the Wizard into the Mountain merely to aid you in the battle to come.”
“Mister Baggins speaks true,” Gandalf protests, “Thorin has contracted dragon sickness, but it is likely I could find a cure if given enough time.”
“We do not have time,” Bard protests. “My people are starving now.”
“And my people will starve in a few days if no aid comes,” Bilbo replies evenly. “Surely Greenwood the Great has provisions enough for all of us on hand.” If he must appeal to Thranduil’s vanity to keep the company and the Lake-town refugees fed, then so be it.
“Your people?” Thranduil’s sharp eyes catch on the neckline of Bilbo’s tunic. Perhaps any but an elf would miss the hint of mithril peeking through, but Thranduil has keen eyes and the advantage made by deep suspicion. “He has laid claim upon you.” Clearly, the Elf king understands the significance of such a fine gift being bestowed upon a commoner by a Dwarven monarch.
“There is no food inside the Mountain,” Bilbo persists, “Or barely any, anyway. We don’t want a war any more than you do. There is a chance that Gandalf could talk to Thorin and make him see reason—“
“The Wizard has already tried to trick us with an army of imaginary orcs,” Thranduil alleges.
“No, he hasn’t! There really are two armies—“
“And how come you by this knowledge?”
It occurs to Bilbo that perhaps he should not have gone out of his way to provoke Thranduil as he has done. It would have been more prudent to play to the king’s impressive ego from the start. But what’s done is done. “Does that matter? Hundreds of your people will die.”
“I do not believe that Thorin Oakenshield suffers from any affliction which can be cured,” Thranduil replies, “Nor do I believe that the Wizard is without his own motives. No, we will not allow anyone to approach the Mountain until we are assured of our treasure, whether by the king’s consent or as we move to take what we are owed.”
“Gandalf.” Bilbo is desperate now. “Can you get past them?”
“They have two armies under their command, Bilbo,” Gandalf points out, “No, I cannot. And I am not convinced that Thorin would let me pass into the Mountain unhindered even if these good kings would allow it.”
Bilbo winces. That is wise enough counsel, but he isn’t pleased to hear it. “Please.” He is not above begging. “My plan is our best chance to avoid war.”
“But you claim that there will be war regardless,” Thranduil points out, “And I do not trust the word of Thorin Oakenshield’s intended.”
“You are to marry him?” Bard’s eyes narrow, “Even though you claim he is unwell?”
Bilbo swallows. He sees the situation through Bard’s eyes clear enough: if Thorin is mentally unstable, why would Bilbo agree to marry him? If Bilbo was held against his will in the Mountain, he would not be aching to get back to it. The logical conclusion is that Bilbo is either suffering from his own madness, in which case his word cannot be trusted, or he, Gandalf, and Thorin have concocted some sort of trap for Bard and Thranduil.
“I think it will be much more effective to offer a trade,” Thranduil decides, “Thorin Oakenshield has many things that we want, but we have that which he covets above all else, save the Arkenstone. You do not carry that along with the mithril mail, do you, Halfling?” The Elven king confirms Bilbo’s suspicions about his very good eyesight.
Bilbo tries to be sympathetic. He really does. Thranduil has every right to be suspicious, Bilbo supposes, but hitherto, the king’s behavior has been petty and childish. “That will not work,” he tries to explain, “Thorin will kill you. He nearly killed his own nephew for letting me hug him, and you think that you can prevent a war by holding me hostage?”
Gandalf looks deeply troubled by this news. “What?”
Perhaps Bilbo has shared too much. But the darkest aspects of Thorin’s madness will not stay secret much longer, and it is paramount that he impress upon these people the gravity of the mistake that they are making. Thorin will not take this well. He may lose what little sense the dragon sickness has left to him and act even more rashly than he did when it was the Arkenstone being kept away from him. After all, there was no threat of the stone being destroyed by Bard and Thranduil. If Thrór’s best craftspeople could not cut it, then surely no Man or Elf could do so.
“Yes, I do think that,” Thranduil declares, ignoring Bilbo’s panic. “What say you, Bard?”
Bard’s lips form a tight line. “I say,” he replies eventually, “That a trade is our safest option. Even if the Hobbit and the Wizard mean well, I do not trust that they will be safe upon return to the mountain. It is better to offer a deal and see how Thorin Oakenshield responds.”
“This is a terrible plan,” Bilbo moans as cold fear overtakes him. He can guess how Thorin will respond, and he can’t imagine that it will be very pretty.
Bilbo clings, as best as he is able, to Bard, his hands barely clasping as his arms strain around the Man’s middle. The Hobbit has spent the whole ride huffing and puffing, partly as a result of traveling on horseback for the first time in his life and partly in response to the utter indignity of being lifted onto the back of the beast. He can be thankful, at least, that he is not riding with Thranduil. The thought of Thorin’s reaction to that particular confrontation makes Bilbo shudder.
“It is not much father, Master Baggins,” Bard assures him, gazing forward with resolve. “You will be in the presence of your intended again very soon.”
Bilbo cannot determine whether he is being mocked or whether Bard is harboring some secret optimism hitherto concealed rather masterfully. “Thorin will kill you for this,” he tries to explain, for what must be the fiftieth time this morning. “That’s not a threat, you know. In fact, I really wish he wouldn’t, but when he sees that you’re holding me against my will…”
“Why do you chain yourself to one who would treat his friends that way?” Bard asks. It is not a demand but a gentle question, one that a teacher might pose for a student.
Bilbo swallows, considering dishonesty. But what dishonest answer would satisfy Bard? He is clearly already disappointed with Bilbo for even giving Thorin the time of day. “I am not chained,” Bilbo replies instead. “You saw how easily I left the Mountain. If I did not wish to be with Thorin, then I would leave him. I would never have accepted his proposal if I didn’t want to marry him.”
“And how do you think he would have taken that?”
Bilbo does not answer. He has long since learned that he doesn’t know what Thorin is capable of, but it is better not to underestimate his king. Bilbo’s arms and thighs ache from the uncomfortable position he’s been forced into. Drat this blasted horse! Could he not been given a pony of his own? One of Bard’s or Thranduil’s guards could have led it to prevent Bilbo’s escape, could they not? But nobody seems to have thought of that. Once Bard and Thranduil made their plan, it was a matter of waiting for the sun to rise so that they could approach the mountain and confront Thorin.
Bilbo releases another heavy sigh as he is brought before the slopes of Erebor. Having never before been on this side of a military parlay, he is somewhat taken aback by the moments of quiet waiting that take place upon the party’s arrival. He glances over at Gandalf in silent question. Can you get into the Mountain while we have the kings distracted? And the Wizard shakes his head. No, of course not.
Gandalf may be strong and powerful, but Bilbo doubts that his friend is impervious to arrows. It would be a suicide mission to try and sneak into the Mountain now; he would be fleeing a betrayed Thranduil to confront a gold sick and furious Thorin, and that is assuming that he would be able to break through the Mountain’s defenses at all. Besides, there is a chance that this might work.
Bilbo chews on his bottom lip. What if Thorin is willing to make a trade? It didn’t work with the Arkenstone, of course, but surely Thorin cares more about Bilbo than he does about some stupid rock. Ah, yes, that’s the lesson that Bilbo should take away from his initial adventure! When faced with a decision between a Hobbit and a gem, Thorin Oakenshield will always choose the Hobbit! That’s why he threatened to throw the Arkenstone over the battlements for Bilbo’s sake, left bruises on the Arkenstone’s neck because it threatened Bilbo, banished the Arkenstone from his Kingdom because he could not bear to be without Bilbo!
At the sound of Bilbo’s hysterical laughter, Bard turns around. “It will not be long now. They cannot see you from where they are looking.”
“Can’t they?” Bilbo feels shaky and vague, as though he were sketched upon Bard’s horse in light and frantic lines.
“I hate to do this, Mister Baggins,” Bard sighs.
“Nobody’s forcing you,” is Bilbo’s snippy retort. Honestly, Bard and Thranduil could have led their forces to meet the oncoming orc army twice over by now. They could draw the enemy away from the Mountain, away from Dale, and eliminate the orcs that have lately troubled the Woodland Realm. Bilbo and Gandalf could return to Erebor, where Gandalf would cure Thorin, and the King Under the Mountain would see the error of his ways and direct Dáin’s forces to join the ambush far away. Thorin and the lads would live, as would the people of Dale, and perhaps many fair Elves who would otherwise be caught off guard in the battle of the Five Armies.
But not so. Thranduil and Bard have made their decision. Holding Bilbo overnight against his will and forcing him to ride on the back of Bard’s horse is as good as torturing him, in Thorin’s eyes. The king will not see the matter clearly. There is no turning back now that they are here, and Bilbo expects to bear witness to some rather unpleasant things.
“Regardless of what I may say to your intended—“ the scoff in Bard’s tone is rather unnecessary, Bilbo thinks— “I have a great respect for you.”
“Well, thank you for that.” A great respect indeed, treating Bilbo the same way that he would have treated the Arkenstone, had it come into his possession.
Thorin makes an imposing figure, standing there in his crown overlooking the desolation and the small party gathered there. He is too far away for Bilbo to make out the expression on his face, especially since that would require leaning around Bard and, in all likelihood, falling off his horse. Bilbo is confident that if he fell to his death at the hands of the soon-to-be King of Dale, his friends would suddenly become very amenable to Thorin’s plan of outright war. Best to stay in place, then.
The Men and Elves all watch in silence as Thorin knocks an arrow and fires it at the hooves of Thranduil’s mount. “I will put the next one between your eyes,” the king declares. And he does not even know yet that Thranduil and Bard have kidnapped his intended. This isn’t going to end well at all, is it? And poor Bilbo is now trapped in the middle.
He adjusts his grip on Bard while his friends taunt the approaching host in half-hearted Khuzdul. They all look more anxious than intimidating, however. It is clear to Bilbo that most of them are participating only because they fear Thorin in his present state and will do nothing to displease him if they can help it. On the one hand, Bilbo is glad that his friends have the self-preservation instincts to get them through this ordeal despite their qualms. On the other hand, he worries that they may apply this same logic to Thorin’s less-savory ideas, which will only lead to disastrous results.
Naturally, the Mirkwood Elves raise their bows in unison, producing a mechanical sound as each and everyone one of them aims in Thorin’s direction. Thranduil urges his mount forward in an elegant movement that feels choreographed. Bilbo wonders absently how many hours the king has passed training the animal to respond to him so gracefully. “We have come to see if you will reconsider your refusal to offer payment for your debt.” The Elven king smirks, clearly very pleased with himself and his foolhardy plan.
Bilbo cannot see Thorin’s eyes at this distance, but he can imagine the blue fire that must be blazing there. “My mind does not change with the rising and setting of a few suns,” Thorin declares in an imperious snarl. “I will give you nothing. You will have nothing.”
Bilbo’s arms feel as though they are going to fall off, and he feels as if his legs are being tugged in opposite directions by the sturdy body of the horse beneath him. Bard rides without a saddle, which is all well and good for somebody of his size, somebody accustomed to long journeys on horseback, but for Bilbo, it is decidedly uncomfortable. He’ll have bruises on his thighs, for sure. For just one moment, he allows himself to focus more on that and less on the impending carnage.
“Give us the gold that you have promised us,” Bard cuts immediately to the chase. Unlike Thranduil, he does not seem to enjoy this in the slightest. “And we will give you back your Hobbit.” Bard moves aside slightly, allowing Bilbo to peer out from behind his broad back.
For a moment, nobody says a word. Thorin stares at Bilbo, and Bilbo stares at Thorin. The rest of the company looks from Bard to Thranduil to Bilbo to their leader as the pieces of the puzzle begin to fall into place. Doubtlessly, they were all aware that Bilbo was not with them. Probably, they thought he was hiding in the treasury from the impending battle, as Thorin would have directed him to do.
“They kidnapped Master Baggins!” Kíli announces, as if this was in any way unclear. “How? How did you get to him? You have made a grave mistake, setting your hands on the king’s intended!”
“The king may have him.” Bard moves again to obscure Bilbo from the company’s view. Bilbo shudders at the similarity to the words Bard used to offer a trade of the Arkenstone all those years ago. Is he really no different from any of the other baubles in Thorin’s collection? Clearly, Bard does not believe that Thorin will think so. “With our goodwill. But first, he must honor his word.”
“Bilbo!” Thorin calls, and despite himself, Bilbo feels his heart swell. Thorin is calling out for him, not going along with Thranduil’s plot to use Bilbo as a negotiating device the way Bard did so readily. “What harm have they done you?”
Bilbo ignores every instruction Thranduil and Bard have given him about keeping quiet. “I’m a little sore from riding here on horseback, but I don’t think any serious damage has been done!” Bilbo calls. “Please don’t kill anyone, Thorin! I’m unharmed!”
“You would lay your hands on such a kind and gentle creature,” Thorin snarls at Bard. “You would kidnap one who has already forgiven you when you still hold him against his will?”
“We did not wish to take a hostage,” Thranduil lies, “But you left us no choice.”
“I told them it was a stupid plan!” Bilbo hopes against hope that he will get through to Thorin somehow, though he doesn’t know why he thinks that will suddenly be an effective strategy when it has been so ineffective all this time. “They wouldn’t listen!”
“You have encroached upon my lands,” Thorin ignores Bilbo altogether, which is as bad a sign as Bilbo can imagine. “And stolen my One from me. And you expect me to parlay?” My One. It should not surprise Bilbo in the slightest to be referred to as such. After all, Thorin said it before, when he was fitting Bilbo with the mithril shirt. But it is one thing to say such things in private, during a fairly intimate moment, and quite another for Thorin to make such an announcement during a formal negotiation in his capacity as King Under the Mountain.
“I told you that this wouldn’t work,” Bilbo reiterates to Bard, who, like Thorin, seems content to ignore him.
“We will return Master Baggins to you unharmed in exchange for the promised gold,” Bard announces.
Bilbo leans around Bard to stare up at Thorin, ignoring the valiant protest made by the muscles in his thighs as he grips onto the horse. He has seen such rage only once before. This is exactly how Thorin looked when he learned that Bilbo had given away the Arkenstone. It is a struggle to push away the vibrant images of Thorin’s hands around Bilbo’s neck, the feeling of empty space below him as Bilbo prepared for his impending death. Gandalf saved him then, but where is the Wizard now?
Conspicuously missing all of a sudden. Bilbo knows not what to make of this development. Perhaps Gandalf has decided to try and sneak into the mountain after all, or perhaps he has formulated his own scheme for dispatching the orc and goblin hosts. Maybe Gandalf has realized that Thorin will not give in without bloodshed.
Bilbo looks around as best he can from his position behind Bard and catches sight of familiar grey robes. Gandalf is holed up in a corner, under the shelter of the Mountain, muttering. For a moment, Bilbo thinks that the Wizard is working some sort of magic, perhaps a spell that will help Thorin to come to his senses. Perhaps he can be healed after all, and at a distance, too! But then Gandalf opens his cupped palms, and an oversized moth flies out of them. He was speaking to the little creature, though for what reason, Bilbo does not know. It’s certainly a good thing that the Wizard has his priorities straight, making friends with local insects in the middle of Bilbo’s hostage negotiation. When Bilbo looks again, Gandalf and the moth have disappeared. Typical. Once again, it’s down the Bilbo to save himself and his friends from whatever awful fate they’re lurching toward.
“You will return my One to me unharmed in exchange for your lives,” Thorin roars. “Or I will come down and kill you myself.”
“By all means,” Thranduil drawls, “See how your company of fourteen… or, thirteen now, I suppose… fares against our armies.”
Bilbo stares at the Elven king in utter shock. “I’m sorry, are you trying for an arrow between your eyes?” Bilbo demands of the king.
Thorin laughs at that, though whether he finds Bilbo’s comment funny or whether he is fantasizing about doing exactly as the Hobbit suggests remains to be seen. Either way, he is not stable. Even from this great distance, Bilbo can see that Thorin is shaking with rage as he raises his bow. He knocks an arrow and aims at the Elven king.
Once more, the Elven army makes a great show of raising their own weapons all at once. Every single one of them is aiming for Thorin, but the King Under the Mountain does not seem deterred. Thankfully, others in the company have a bit more sense. Balin rushes to Thorin’s side and whispers something in his ear. Fíli, too, has a few emphatic words to say in Khuzdul. His hand hovers over Thorin’s for a moment, but, perhaps remembering the incident on the battlements, he does not dare place it there. Instead, his tone becomes conciliatory, and he makes no move to physically bar his uncle from committing an act that cannot be retracted.
“I will not stand by and allow these…” Thorin then makes use of his own choice words in Khuzdul. Bilbo has no idea what Thorin is saying, but it is enough to make Dori reach instinctively for Ori, as though he seriously intends to cover his brother’s ears in the middle of a rather nasty confrontation. “To put their hands on what is mine.”
Fíli says something else, and Dwalin seems to agree with him. Bilbo cannot make out the words from here, but he trusts his friends to make sound and reasonable arguments. Unfortunately, he does not trust his intended to heed any warnings that he is presently being given. This day will likely end with one of Thorin’s arrows stuck somewhere on Thranduil’s person, and about a million arrows fired upon Thorin and Company.
“Thorin!” Bilbo yells again. “Please don’t shoot! Even these—“ Here, he attempts to repeat the Khuzdul words he just heard, “— Will not be so stupid as to kill me while they still want something from you! I’m perfectly safe, I assure you. The Wizard is around here somewhere, and you can imagine how he might react should anyone attempt to murder me. If I am not worth my weight in gold to you, then that’s… perfectly understandable, just please, don’t start the battle this way!”
“You are worth everything to me,” Thorin declares. “They know this and have forced you from my side. They must pay in blood.” So much for reasoning with him, then. Bilbo really needs to stop thinking that will work.
“Your Hobbit is wiser than you are, Thorin Oakenshield.” Thranduil seems to believe that he’s being very helpful. He is, however, only making things worse.
“Oh, please shut up,” Bilbo snaps. “Your smug nonsense isn’t helping.”
Bard’s body shakes slightly in what Bilbo takes as a silent laugh. Bilbo feels as though all the bones and muscles in his body have turned to jelly. He has already failed once to prevent this battle, and now it seems that he has made the same mistake a second time. Not only is he unable to protect Thorin and the lads from Azog the Defiler, but he has somehow managed to bring a completely new threat to the company’s door. Just brilliant work, Master Burglar.
But Thranduil seems to take it in stride. Clearly, he is confident that Thorin will simply trade the gold for Bilbo. He does not truly believe in the curse or in dragon sickness and seems to be laboring under the misapprehension that Thorin is simply greedy. Why the Elven king believes this after taking counsel from Gandalf, Bilbo doesn’t know, but it hardly matters now, does it?
“As I said,” Thranduil smiles placidly, “He is very wise. Perhaps I should have him instruct me in the ingenious method that he used to smuggle you out of my realm.”
At the insinuation that Thranduil wishes to take Bilbo back to his own kingdom, there is a sound of snapping wood. Bilbo peers around Bard to see that Thorin has broken the arrow that he was about to shoot at Thranduil. Well, better than assassinating a foreign king, Bilbo supposes, but still not very pleasant.
“Uncle, please.” Fíli’s voice carries faintly down to the party gathered before Erebor’s gates. “Who knows what they will do to Master Baggins if you ignore their demands? We cannot allow them to keep Bilbo a moment longer. We must do whatever it takes to get him to safety.” These are brave words indeed. Perhaps Bilbo and Fíli are the only ones who know for sure how Thorin might react to them.
The king, thankfully, is too busy glaring at Thranduil to accuse his nephew of treason. “They will do nothing to him,” Thorin snarls, tossing his bow aside. Thank the Valar. “Because I will come and claim him.”
“Good,” Thranduil continues to look smug. Bilbo preferred it when Bard was doing the talking. “Please bring enough gold to satisfy your debts to the Men of the Lake and the Elves of the Woodland realm, and we will return your… Burglar to you in one piece.”
“You are still not helping,” Bilbo groans. It’s as though Thranduil really is trying to get himself shot.
“Kíli,” Thorin orders, loud enough to be overheard, “Aim for the Elven Lord. If he makes any move against me, or against Master Baggins, you are encouraged to shoot.”
“You are not really going down there,” Balin protests, “All you need to do is agree to their demands, and they’ll let Bilbo up to join us.” But before anyone can answer, speech is momentarily precluded by a sound like a herd of Oliphaunts marching through the waste.
Bilbo closes his eyes. “So much for negotiation,” he hums, “I hope you are prepared for war.” Dáin’s host has arrived.
“I will not parlay with you,” Thorin declares, just as Bilbo expected. He’s probably planning to rush down and liberate Bilbo himself, or, even worse, to try and divert Dáin’s entire army to the foolish goal of rescuing one Hobbit who is barely even in any danger. Though Bilbo doesn’t particularly trust or like Thranduil, he does not believe that the Elven King is hostile to him, and he knows for a fact that Bard has no interest in maiming or killing him. “If you will not give back what is mine—“ Bilbo winces at this phrasing, “Then you will face the wrath of Durin’s folk.”
“Please, can I just go back up there?” Bilbo asks. “It’d save us all a lot of trouble. If we can find the Wizard, there may yet be a chance—“
Bard opens his mouth as though to speak. Perhaps he intends to take pity on Bilbo and allow him back into the mountain, or to deliver a paternalistic edict about how it might be safer for Bilbo to stay by his side. In that case, Bilbo is perfectly prepared to sneak out of Dale just as he did the last time. But unfortunately, Thranduil beats him to the punch.
“Very well,” Thranduil replies, “If you and your Hobbit both survive, perhaps you will be reunited after the battle.”
“This is a waste of time,” Bilbo groans, “There are orcs approaching.”
But Thranduil has already turned his strange, antlered mount around, and Thorin has left the battlements to go do Yavanna-knows-what, and Bard is spurring his horse. There will be no parlay, there will be no alliance, and there will be no peace.
