Chapter Text
Thorin’s first act after dismissing the Men and Elves is to summon a raven. He sends the bird off in Dáin’s direction with new instructions for the Lord of the Iron Hills: charge forward, show no mercy, recover my consort and return him to me. There was never any chance of negotiation before, but now? Now, Thorin will personally place the heads of his fellow kings on spikes outside the gates of Erebor. That is a Mannish tradition, not a Dwarven one, but in his present mood Thorin sees the appeal of it. To even touch the intended of the king is an unspeakable crime, but to kidnap him, to force him onto a horse and use him as a bargaining chip, is practically a declaration of war.
Since the Men and Elves want carnage, then, Thorin will give it to them gladly. Dáin will plow through their flimsy defenses and liberate Bilbo, who will be returned to Erebor in no time. Thorin does not put it past his Hobbit to start stabbing at his captors once war is properly declared. He would have liked to execute his enemies personally, but he is loath to leave the mountain.
The treasure calls to Thorin, even now. It sings to him with promises of peace and glory, rest and splendor if only he makes his way back down to the vaults. The Arkestone is down there, or if not, it is somewhere else inside the Mountain. Even if some traitor has taken it, Thorin will find it sooner rather than later. He will place it above his throne. No, he will carry it on his person forever more. Until his dying day, he will not be parted from it. Nor will he be parted from Bilbo.
Obviously, things will have to change once the Hobbit is returned to him. Bilbo will not be allowed out of his sight ever again. Thorin is no fool. He knows that the Men and Elves could not have gotten into Erebor without the king knowing, not even if his entire company betrayed him. Bilbo could not have been taken from the mountain against his will. He must have been lured down somehow, with false promises of peace. The Hobbit has spent several days pleading with Thorin to help the Men and Elves, apparently laboring under the naive misapprehension that their enemies will be satisfied with a single fair payment.
A fair payment would consist of nothing at all, because neither the Men nor the Elves did a thing to help Thorin reclaim his kingdom. And now they have manipulated his One with lies and false promises, taking advantage of a gentle soul who knows nothing of war and would not think to question the motives of his captors. More likely than not, the Wizard was involved. Perhaps he regrets giving Bilbo to Thorin in the first place and has elected now to take him back. Fair enough. Tharkûn’s head can join the others on the spikes for all that Thorin cares.
He finds himself at the door to the treasury with no memory of how he got here. Thorin knows that he should not be using his time in this way, that he has a battle to command, his One to rescue, and several executions to plan, assuming that Dáin does not take care of his enemies for him. There is plenty for the King Under the Mountain to do right now, but he seeks comfort from his hoard. He steps inside despite his misgivings and relishes the peace it brings him. Why brood in his throne room when he is so soothed by the sight of all that is his?
Gold. So much gold, and all of it only for Thorin. Enough jewels that he could use them as flooring for the entire mountain and still have plenty left over. Silver cups and fine musical instruments and crowns upon crowns. The wealth of a thousand kingdoms, and all of it reserved for one king. One great king, who will soon have all of his treasure in one place.
“What are you doing down here?” A voice destroys the soothing silence of the treasury.
Paying no attention to what he is doing, Thorin plays with a handful of perfectly shaped silver coins. He closes his eyes, trying to remember the feel of Bilbo’s hand in his. Not like the coins at all. Warmer, softer. But Thorin is beginning to forget what exactly it feels like. He is overcome by a pang of loss, sharp and heavy, a blade to his side. He will kill Bard of Lake-town, personally, slowly, painfully. And then he will do the same to the Woodland King, only more slowly and more painfully. That will teach them to take something of such import from the King Under the Mountain.
“What?” Thorin hisses reflexively, whirling around to face Dwalin. “It is mine and I can do with it what I choose.” Someone stole the Arkenstone from him. Someone stole his One from him. It is as though every being in Middle Earth is after Thorin’s treasure.
“Since when do we forsake our own people?” Dwalin stops in front of his king. “Thorin, they are dying out there. And your own One is with them.”
“Dáin will return what they have taken from me,” Throin growls. He does not wish to leave his hoard. It is the responsibility of his subjects to bring his missing gem back to him, and he does not appreciate the insinuation that Bilbo might die. No. That is not possible. That could not be possible. “There are halls beneath halls within this mountain. Places we can fortify. Shore up, make safe, yes. Yes. That is it. We must move the gold further underground to safety.”
And it will be easy enough to move Bilbo down with it, once he is returned. Yes, the Hobbit may struggle. He will not wish to leave Thorin’s side, and more than likely he will prattle on about food stores and the price of peace, as he has been doing for the past several days. But Thorin does not care what Bilbo thinks. He cares only that every last piece of his treasure is safe. Down to the coin.
“Did you not hear me?” Dwalin demands. “Dáin is surrounded. They’re being slaughtered, Thorin. And our Hobbit is among them, with no way to get back to the Mountain, even if he is alive.”
Thorin waves a hand. Three coins fly out and clatter against a pile of golden necklaces studded with rubies. “Is not this treasure worth a few lives? Is not my One worth a few more? Dáin will die before he fails in the mission I have given him. And Master Baggins will find his way back into the Mountain.”
But Thorin doubts his own words as he says them. After all, Bilbo is not like the coins. He will try his best to return, Thorin knows. The Hobbit has long since proven his desire to stay at Thorin’s side. But the field of battle is vast, and Bilbo is very small and rather fragile, at least compared to an armored orc. He would be much easier to destroy than a necklace or diadem. Can even Dáin be trusted to guarantee his safety? When the Hobbit is returned to Thorin, neither one of them will never leave the treasury.
“You sit here in these vast halls with a crown upon your head and yet you are lesser now than you have ever been,” Dwalin looks to be on the verge of tears. “You would have us stay here, then?”
“Aye.” Thorin is torn between the desire to charge into battle to rescue Bilbo, killing indiscriminately until he reaches his Hobbit, and the desire to stay in Erebor, to ensure that the rest of his treasure is safe. Is not it enough to give the orders? To have Dáin and his warriors rescue the Hobbit? Master Baggins can make himself invisible. He would not be seen by an enemy aiming to kill him. Or by an ally searching for a body.
“And what of Master Baggins?” Dwalin demands. “He followed you here. He faced a dragon for you. He wears your gift even still, and you would leave him to the orcs?”
“How dare you speak to me this way?” Thorin snarls.
Who is Dwalin to question him? Who is Dwalin to use his One to twist Thorin’s thinking, to force him away from his gold? This is what matters. This is most important. When he has his hands on his gold, Thorin can forget what Bilbo’s touch felt like. He can forget the warmth, the gentle care, every other carnal detail of being loved by Bilbo Baggins. The hurt and worry are dulled here.
For a moment, there is something unguarded in Dwalin’s eyes, something Thorin does not understand. “I’ve been speaking to you this way as long as I’ve known you, and you never had a problem with it. Was a time you were glad of it.”
“I am your king,” Thorin reminds him. There is no other option. He is beholden to his hoard. Dwalin has no right to accuse Thorin of mistreating Bilbo! The Hobbit will return. He must. And if he does not, Thorin has his jewels to comfort him. Surely soon the cold touch of the stones will replace the warm touch of his One in his affections. “No longer am I a mere blacksmith, with a cropped beard and not a penny to his name.” He is worthy now. He has his gold now. Is that not what Thorin has been fighting for all these years?
“You were always my king,” Dwalin replies, “You used to know that once. You cannot see what you have become.”
What he has become? What he has become? Thorin has become the King Under the Mountain, the true heir of Durin. Finally, now, he is worthy of the plucky little Hobbit who has steered him to his point.
“Go. Get out,” Thorin mutters. “Before I kill you.”
He does not wish to consider the possibility that Bilbo may be slain, that he may already be dead. Thorin does not wish to care as much as he does about the Hobbit. He does not appreciate Dwalin’s reminders. Why can he not be allowed to numb himself? Why must this be his lot in life, to suffer grief upon grief, loss after loss, as Mahal rips every good thing from Thorin’s grip? Not the gold. Thorin will not lose the gold. His mother, his grandfather, his brother, his father, his One. All of these can be taken from him, but the coins will not be. These Thorin will have until he dies.
Until he dies among them, alone and unloved. I am not my grandfather, he reminds himself, his voice more firm inside his head than it has been for days. No, he is not his grandfather. Thrór died with honor in battle at the hands of a formidable enemy, taking on a noble task. How will Thorin die? Here, in his hoard. What will become of the others? No. The mountain is safe. Erebor will protect Thorin and his gold.
Dwalin turns. It takes every ounce of Thorin’s self restraint to keep his word and stay his hand. How dare Dwalin come here, no better than the Men and Elves, holding Thorin’s One hostage in his mind? Master Baggins will make his way back to the Mountain. He is clever, he is crafty, and he will find his way back to Thorin. Even if Dáin is killed. Even if every last warrior on that battlefield is killed, every uppity Elf and foolish Man all the sturdy fighters from the Iron Hills.
The world constricts as the door slams shut behind Dwalin. Thorin is alone in the treasury. Thorin is alone in a dark void, in nothingness, and his hoard is far out of sight. He can feel a great longing, a great need for something that is absent. Hunger? Is this hunger? Is it thirst? Both of these things, yes, but something more. He is inundated with images: his sword, jabbing Bilbo’s chest, the Hobbit looking up at him with cautious eyes. Fíli with his hands raised, backing away from Thorin in terror. Dwalin, shaking his head in disgust, turning his back on the king to whom he has dedicated his life. Thrór’s headless body laying upon a pile of the fallen at Azanulbizar. Half of Frerin’s face frozen in a pained expression, the other half mangled beyond recognition. Gold in Thorin’s halls. Blood on Thorin’s hands.
He hears Fíli’s voice, frightened but unwavering. “You told me it would bring clarity of mind, so that I would always remember the sort of leader the Maker shaped me to be.”
Thorin has lost all honor, drawing his sword on his nephew. And before that, did he not hold his One at sword point? How far would Thorin have gone, had Fíli not interrupted them? Is this how Mahal made Thorin? Would the Great Smith be pleased, now, to see his child sunken so low?
He hears Dwalin’s voice, rough with disbelief and sorrow. “You were always my king. You used to know that once.”
Yes, once, Thorin did know that. Once, he had some idea of who he was. Once, he lived without gold or jewels. He labored in the towns of men, his beard shorn in shame but his honor intact. He risked his life and swallowed his pride for the good of his people. Where would they be, had Thorin not done that? Where would they be, had he been so selfish as this when first the dragon came?
Thorin is assaulted by Bilbo’s voice, a shifting kaleidoscope of love and pain and worry and rage. “Come back to yourself, as soon as possible, please, my love.”
These words made no sense to Thorin, when first they were spoken, but now he understands. Thorin has not been himself. He has been something else, a wicked shadow, contorted by greed. He has been hiding while his people, his kingdom, and his One are in danger. He has sought out comfort when he should seek the rush of battle.
The darkness around Thorin shatters, but still he is alone. All around him, piles of gold gleam in the torchlight, but he does not see them. The Arkenstone is in this Mountain, but he does not bother to search for it. He has no time for such things.
He has abandoned his honor and refused payment to those who have aided him. His cousin is fighting a battle that belongs to Thorin. His company is starving to death in this mountain. His One is out there on the battlefield, unarmed and held hostage by Men. These things he knows with a clarity that has been absent from his thinking since the moment he set foot inside his ancestral home. What has Thorin become, indeed? His have not been the actions of a great king but a great coward.
Thorin does not close the door behind him, let alone lock it, as he exits the treasury. He trips over his feet several times on his way to the front gate, but he only picks himself up and keeps running, ignoring the pain in his knees and the palms of his hands. He is winded when he arrives at the gate where his company have gathered. There is nothing majestic about His Majesty then, as he skids to a halt, panting, with his crown askew. But he does not care. He does not care how he appears, does not care what is proper. Cares only for the lives that are, by right, his to protect.
The members of his company are dressed for battle. But how could twelve defend a mad king and his treasure against three armies? Thorin has been a fool indeed.
“Uncle!” Kíli grabs him by the shoulders, a bold move, but one that Thorin cannot begrudge him. He is shocked that it has taken so long for anyone to try it. How long has he been in such a pitiful state? Days, weeks perhaps, and nobody has thought to grab him and shake him? Perhaps they did think to. Perhaps they decided against it, convinced that Thorin would kill them for it. What would he have done, had Kíli approached him an hour earlier? Would he have laid his hands on his sister-son? Thrown him off the side of the mountain? Forced him into a sword fight? “I will not hide behind a wall of stone while others fight our battles for us! It is not in my blood, Thorin. Erebor is ours, is it not? So we must defend it ourselves, with our own swords, with our own bows, with our own bodies if we must! Bilbo is down there, fighting orcs, though he is no warrior, and here we are, warriors, all, sons of Durin, doing nothing! I will not allow you to—“
“Kíli,” Thorin breathes. He has never been so proud of his sister-son.
“If you refuse to join the battle,” Kíli tells him evenly, apparently not noticing the tears welling in his uncle’s eyes. “Everyone here will support Fíli’s claim to the throne. I will drag you to the dungeons myself and lock you up in them if you continue this cowardice! We will not stand by and allow Dáin and Master Baggins to— oh!”
Thorin has enfolded his nephew in a crushing hug. “You are brave,” he announces, “And you are right.”
Kíli hugs him back, if a little reluctantly. “So you agree?”
“We are sons of Durin,” Thorin replies, “We do not leave our battles for others to fight, and we do not abandon our kin. Nor do we allow mindless despots to rule us. You and Fíli were plotting against me?”
“No,” Fíli speaks up, “Kíli had nothing to do with it. It was my idea from the beginning. I bear it upon my head.” He kneels then in a show of fealty, wholly unnecessary. But then, of course he would. He saw how Thorin reacted to his earlier transgression. Thorin cannot blame his sister-son for his fear, not in the slightest.
“You were right to do so,” Thorin informs his nephews. He hauls Fíli to his feet, wasting not a moment in doing so. “Both of you. I was not fit to rule.”
“And are you now?” Dwalin asks, arms crossed in front of his chest. He is clearly fed up with the king’s nonsense, and Thorin does not blame him.
Before Thorin can respond, there comes a familiar chattering noise from outside, and then a graceless sort of thud. Twenty-six practiced hands fly to weapons and shields. Dori steps in front of Ori, guarding him from whatever threat might be approaching. Kíli knocks an arrow and aims it at the entrance, lately barricaded.
“Thorin Oakenshield!” A voice booms from just outside the company’s makeshift fortification. “Let me in this instant!”
“Tharkûn,” Thorin grumbles. Dwalin’s hand relaxes upon his axe, which is nothing compared to the weapons taken from him by the Woodland Elves. That will be something to sort out later, Thorin decides. He longs for Orcrist.
Kíli does not drop his weapon. “Gandalf was down there with the Men and Elves. He let them kidnap Bilbo! How do we know he does not come here as a foe?”
“Because if he were a foe, he’d have magicked us all to death twice over by now,” Nori suggests. Thorin does not find himself comforted by this thought.
“Nori!” Dori scolds, but the damage is done.
“If you do not move this barricade, I will move it myself!” Tharkûn threatens. “You are not in your right mind, my friend. I will put things right whether you wish me to or not, if only for the sake of our dear Mister Baggins.”
Thorin finds himself rolling his eyes. “I am already well, Wizard,” he replies, “We were just about to move the barricade when you arrived.”
There is shuffling outside. Another chattering noise. “Is that so?”
“We would’ve moved the barricade even if Thorin wasn’t well,” Fíli admits. Good. Thorin is glad to hear that his heir was swayed neither by the treasure nor by sycophantic devotion to his mad uncle. “Bilbo’s worth committing treason over.”
“That is fair news,” Tharkûn decides, “But I fear it may have come too late. We must do what we can to find Bilbo and defend Erebor from the threat she faces.”
“Yes, that had occurred to me,” Thorin bites out. Who is this Wizard to order Thorin to rescue his own One? “Can you destroy the barricade by magic?”
“He’s a Wizard,” Glóin points out, “Of course he can.”
“Stand back, if you please,” Tharkûn orders, and suddenly, his transgressions are forgiven.
Dori grabs Ori now, and drags him as far away from the potential blast zone as is physically possible at such short notice. The rest of them merely treat this as a mining explosion, stepping back with practiced nonchalance.
We will find the Burglar, Bifur signs. His custom helmet, lately forged to accommodate the axe in his forehead, makes him look more polished than Thorin has ever thought of him before. He is not fooled. Bifur is formidable in battle. And we will defend our Mountain. We are strong. Death to all orcs!
There is a loud explosion, and then Tharkûn stands before them, a giant Eagle perched upon the battlements behind him. So that is how he got up here so quickly. In the distance, Thorin can see more of the great birds swooping down upon the oncoming orcs, though there are not enough of them to destroy the enemy’s ranks completely. “Quite right, Bifur,” the Wizard says.
“He can read Iglishmêk through solid rock,” Ori observes, dazed.
“I’d like to learn that trick,” Bofur muses, “Might come in handy in the mines.”
“You’re not a wizard,” Bombur points out. “And we have a Hobbit to save.”
Thorin does not even think about the heaps of gold which they will leave behind in the Mountain when he begins to shout orders to his company. “Your priority is finding Bilbo,” he declares, “Don’t bother trying to get him out of the action. He will make himself invisible and slip away to join the fight again.”
“It’s impossible to find him when you can’t see him,” Kíli speaks from experience.
“If you reach him, guard him,” Thorin continues, “And send word to me however you can. The ravens await our signal, and the thrushes understand the common tongue. Not to mention our friends the Eagles. This is our fight. Now, let us win it, or we shalldie trying!” Some deep-seated part of Thorin utters now the battle cry that he learned at his grandfather’s knee. It is echoed by his company as they charge through the whole where once their barricade stood. “Baruk Khazâd! Khazâd ai-mênu!”
Bard spirits Bilbo away, back in the direction of Dale. The Elven King went off to command his armies, shouting orders at the Lord of Men to keep the Hobbit close. No doubt he knows that the moment Bilbo is free to move at his leisure, he will run back to Erebor. To Thorin. To the Company.
Bilbo wonders how a Man from a town on a Lake learned to ride a horse so well, but he supposes that Bard has lived a scrappy and varied life, despite his noble lineage. And besides, if the Shire were in danger, Bilbo imagines that he, too, would suddenly become a very fast rider. “The Dwarves will march on Dale,” Bard alleges. He is wrong about his enemy, of course, but correct that Dale will soon be under attack. “We must make haste!”
“Oh, please wait, will you!” Bilbo tries to stop the horse somehow, though his efforts are ineffective. He doesn’t want to spur it on with the wrong sort of kick, and though he tries, he can reach neither its reins nor its mane.
“I cannot wait. I must—“
“Let me off here,” Bilbo commands.
“In the middle of a battle?” Bard does not seem to like this plan very much. “You will be killed.”
“Maybe,” Bilbo concedes. They aren’t really in the middle of a battle, per se. The orc host has not yet arrived, and Dáin is presently delivering some sort of speech to the Men and Elves, rather than fighting them. But they certainly will be in the thick of things soon. Within a few minutes, there will be carnage at this spot, beyond a doubt. “But there will be a battle soon in Dale, will there not? The danger will find us all, whether we run from it or toward it.”
“And you wish to run toward it?”
“I wish to run toward Thorin,” Bilbo replies evenly. “I cannot leave him to be killed.”
“Then you will die with him,” Bard argues, “Or perhaps before him. One Hobbit, running through a raging battle? And unarmed at that?”
“Then give me back my sword.” Bilbo will not be deterred. “Or I will leap off this horse and die that way.” He doesn’t think Bard will actually allow things to get to that point. The Man is reasonable, after all, and he was always reluctant to enact Thranduil’s harebrained hostage scheme. “The gold that Thorin owes you is no longer a priority. We must do what we can against the orcs. Please.”
“He does not deserve the faith you put in him,” Bard decrees, “Nor the love you give him.”
Bilbo bristles at this. “Well, you don’t know him, do you? And he may have been friendlier to you if you’d done anything other than doubt him and hinder him. Anyway, does any of that really matter if we’re all about to die?”
“I fear you will not reach him.”
“I must try,” Bilbo pleads, “Besides, I’ve done it before.” That was an extraordinarily stupid thing to say, but Bilbo is desperate. He will not allow Thorin to be killed again.
He knows exactly what will happen, of course: Dwalin will speak to the king and shatter the dragon sickness. Thorin will lead his company into battle and then he’ll take his nephews and his best soldier up to Ravenhill. Bilbo will be too late if is forced to accompany Bard to Dale and escape from his clutches. A head start is his only hope.
“Your king is a fool, let that be known.” But Bard has dismounted and is rummaging through the saddle bag in which he has stowed away Bilbo’s things. A sword, a handkerchief, and a pouch of useless pipeweed. Bilbo never did remember to pick out a replacement pipe in Erebor. At least Bard and Thranduil let him keep the mithril shirt. They clearly do not want him dead, whatever else they may desire. “I sincerely hope that, whatever happens this day, one of his nephews ends up on the throne.” He then helps Bilbo down from the horse and hands Sting back to the Hobbit.
“You shouldn’t speak ill of my intended when you’ve just put a sword in my hand,” Bilbo advises. “I’ll see you after the battle, and I’ll make sure you get what you are owed.”
“Go, then.” Bard does not sound optimistic about the issue of the treasure, but then, why would he? He knows nothing of dragon sickness and he has made it clear how little he thinks of Thorin. But he must have been telling the truth when he said that he harbored a great respect for Bilbo, or else he would not have allowed the Hobbit to enter the fray. If no one else does, Bard of Esgaroth and Dale trusts Bilbo to make his own decisions.
By the time Bilbo gets free of Bard and makes his way over to the fighting, the orcs have arrived. Naturally, getting through the battle is much more difficult now than it was the first time around. For one thing, the ring Bilbo carries is functionally useless and does not make him invisible. His enemies can see him, at least theoretically, though he is pleasantly surprised to discover that very few of them appear to be looking down, and therefore he escapes the notice of many an orc. It took an awfully long time to negotiate his escape from Bard, but Bilbo is not deterred. He must reach Thorin.
The main problem with that, of course, is that he has no idea where Thorin is. Last time, they met on Ravenhill, but Bilbo is now several hours ahead of that event. Thorin won’t attempt to climb Ravenhill until he knows that Azog and Bolg are there. He could be anywhere in the battle, as could every member of the company. There are only thirteen of them, after all, and Dáin, of course, who might have been given Bilbo’s description and be able to direct him to Thorin.
And then there is the horror of being here again, amidst the sounds and smells and sights of battle. Bilbo tries, he truly tries, to breathe only through his mouth, to plug his ears, to avoid focusing overmuch on anything that he might see. But of course, this is impossible. If he wishes to survive, and if he wishes to find Thorin, he must remain present. He was too late, the last time. He was too late, too distracted, too appalled by all that came to pass around him. He was disgusted, shocked, horrified, and Thorin died for it. Fíli and Kíli died for it. The sharp smell of blood hits Bilbo’s nostrils, and suddenly, he is there again, upon Ravenhill, holding Thorin in his arms and watching his only love bleed out upon the ice.
Bilbo is covered in blood again, running down the stairs again to tell Kíli the horrible news. He has pulled himself together again, forced himself away from Thorin in the name of his duty to the next king. The next king, who Bilbo might have called nephew, in a kinder world. Only to find him laying in a pool of his own blood, his body covered by Tauriel’s shaking, sobbing form. Yes. Bilbo remembers this moment well.
It was this very wind, whipping mercilessly against his wet face. It was this very stench that coated every inch of the battlefield, unwashed orc and blood and shit and other things more horrible. This stench which Bilbo has always associated with loss and horror and terror. This is the stench of Bilbo’s failure, his inability to protect the ones he loves.
He is nearly decapitated by the clumsy swing of an untrained man, wielding a rusted blade which looks to be as old as Dale itself. That brings Bilbo back to his senses. No, he is not upon Ravenhill. His face may be wet, and the world may smell just as it did when Bilbo pried his face off of Thorin’s bloody chest, but he has not yet failed. There is still time, and Bilbo must try. He cannot surrender to his memories, even ones so powerful and so horrific as these.
So he fights his way through, blindly, forcing himself to remember happier times. He is in Beorn’s garden with Thorin, sipping berry-water and talking about golden pipes. He is in Lake-town, the first time around, drinking with his friends. He is in Bag End, enjoying a proper Hobbit party with the least-proper and least-Hobbity folk he knows. He is wandering the Shire with Frodo on one of their long walks, deep in conversation, marveling at the lad’s bright wit and clever smile. He is watching Gandalf’s fireworks. Thorin is alive.
Are the Valar protecting Bilbo yet again? He still has yet to destroy the ring completely, weak though it may be, so he supposes that wouldn’t be too far-fetched an idea. Still, he has work to do. He is kicked once, distracted by the thought of his grandmother’s butterscotch biscuits, but he recovers quickly. He catches a stray arrow that leaves a hole in his tunic but cannot pierce his mithril armor. He is in Rivendell, and Frodo is there, alive after giving everybody such a shock. Beaming, despite his pallor, at the news that he is in the House of Elrond at long last. Eagles swoop and dive overhead, which fills Bilbo with true hope, none of this flimsy stuff that he’s been manufacturing thus far. The great birds have come early. Even if the worst happens, perhaps… perhaps there might still be some chance.
He presses on with renewed vigor. He must find Thorin. Bilbo’s arms are exhausted, after being stretched around Bard’s body and then from wielding Sting. He is panting from his long run and soaked in sweat, spattered once again with the blood of Elves and Men and orcs. But he is alive, and he can see Thorin now, and every fiber of his being is calling him toward his love.
Thorin is fighting with a heavy Dwarven broadsword. Of course, Orcrist is still in Legolas’s clutches, probably being put to great use in this very battle. Bilbo watches as the king dispatches orc after orc with his glorious weapon, narrowly dodging decapitation on several occasions over the course of only a few moments. Kíli is beside him, sword in hand and bow strapped across his back. They are both still alive, then. Bilbo has not failed. Not yet, at least.
Kíli spots Bilbo before Thorin does, but he knows better than to distract his uncle in the middle of a fight. His eyes widen in understanding and Bilbo nods a quick salute before making his way over to his love. Bilbo takes the liberty of sticking his sword into the latest orc’s back. That’ll teach him to threaten Thorin Oakenshield, Bilbo thinks.
As the orc falls, Thorin meets Bilbo’s eyes, and Bilbo is pleased to see no fire whatsoever. Thorin has come back to himself at long last, and not a moment too soon. “Ghivashel,” the king breathes.
“There’s no time to talk!” Bilbo pulls Thorin into what he means to be a very quick hug, not able to take his eyes off the battle around them. Kíli moves into a protective stance, apparently intent on covering the couple during their brief reunion. “You must listen to me, Thorin.”
“I am sorry.” Obviously, Thorin is not listening at all as he pulls the Hobbit close, so that he might mutter into Bilbo’s hair, “I am sorry.”
“I know,” Bilbo replies. Now is not the time for this conversation. They’re in the middle of a battlefield. “And you’re forgiven. Of course you’re forgiven.”
“Oh, thank Mahal.” Fíli has apparently joined them. Bilbo watches out of the corner of his eye as the prince, with swords drawn, establishes himself on the other side of Bilbo and Thorin. “I thought they’d taken him back to Dale.”
“Tell me you got a few hits in on that Elven King before you slipped away.” And Dwalin, too, is here, surrounding the third side of the embrace. Bilbo and Thorin are almost entirely defended, and it’s a good thing, too, because Thorin does not show any signs of releasing Bilbo. He may no longer be suffering from dragon sickness, but clearly, he’s being driven out of his mind by guilt and shame.
“So, this is the Hobbit.” Is that Dáin, as well? Oh, this won’t do at all! Two Ereborean princes, the greatest warrior among Durin’s folk, and the Lord of the Iron Hills, all defending Bilbo and Thorin so they can indulge in a simple hug? Bilbo loves Thorin, but this is a little excessive. They’ve got to put an end to this before somebody gets killed. No, not thinking about that. Bilbo’s got to keep his wits about him.“Not how I thought I’d meet my cousin’s intended, I have to say, but a happy meeting nevertheless.”
“I will never treat you so dishonorably again,” Thorin murmurs, “I will never restrain you in any capacity again. I will never—“
“That’s enough, Thorin.” Bilbo says firmly.
Immediately, Thorin releases Bilbo and steps back, as though the Hobbit were made of hot coals. “Have I hurt you?”
“I’m not so fragile that you could crush me with a single hug,” Bilbo protests, “But we’re in the middle of a battle, and I’ve already forgiven you, so there’s no need to keep apologizing and making promises and all that. Besides, if you say everything now, what will be left for the wedding?” He must force himself to keep his tone light. He does not wish to scare Thorin, to make him suffer when the king has already endured so much.
The dragon sickness has melted away. Bilbo knows neither how nor why, but he cares only for the fact that Thorin is well again. That is all. That is the only thing.
Dáin guffaws at this. “You’ve met your match, Thorin. Mahal be with you.”
“You are right, of course,” Thorin decides, though it’s unclear whether he is agreeing with Dáin or with Bilbo. “Our Maker has been merciful this day, helping you to find me amidst all this, returning you to me hale and hardy.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “And here I was thanking Yavanna for delivering you to me before you could get yourself chopped in half.”
“Chopped in half?”
“You should thank Kíli; he saved your life about three times that I just saw.” Don’t think about it. Don’t think about it. Don’t think about it. “Anyway, you’ve distracted me with your sweet nothings, and we are in the midst of battle, after all. You have to listen.”
“I am listening,” Thorin assures him. “Of course.” There’s a small scratch on his face, just below his eye, but he looks otherwise unharmed.
“There’s another orc army coming from the North,” Bilbo explains, “They’re going to set a trap for you on Ravenhill. Bolg and Azog are both there, and they expect that you’ll take your best warriors, Fíli, Kíli, and Dwalin, that is, and there you will be overwhelmed. They aim to separate you and kill you one by one.”
“How come you by this knowledge?” Thorin asks.
Bilbo tells as much of the truth as he can get away with without raising more questions than he is equipped to answer. “The Elven Prince and his Captain went to Gundabad and saw the hosts departing.” Hopefully, Tauriel will elect, as she did last time, to go up and help, and Legolas will follow her, just as he did before. “You need to have Dáin turn his army North and ambush our would-be ambushers. While they’re doing that, I say you and Dwalin and I take Ravenhill. Azog and Bolg will be caught off guard; they’ll be expecting to have an army at their backs and they won’t.”
“Tauriel is well, then?” Kíli asks.
Bilbo certainly hopes so. “Well enough,” he says vaguely. In truth, he hasn’t seen her since she saved his life in Lake-town. But he’s already committed to his story, and there’s no need to worry Kíli during such a vital moment. Tauriel will be fine. “We’ve got to get that army moving. It’ll take a while to extricate them, won’t it?”
“When did you become a general, men ghivashel?” Thorin asks, his eyes shining. Under any other circumstances, Bilbo would kiss him, but that would perhaps be inappropriate at the moment.
“Around the time I betrothed myself to a warrior king,” Bilbo replies. “Now, enough talk, and let’s get going. We must not waste time.”
“Very well,” Thorin acquiesces. Perhaps he’s still not thinking clearly, because it’s very unlike him to just go along with one of Bilbo’s plots without intervening. Perhaps because this plan involves killing Azog, Thorin is willing to do things that he would otherwise consider inadvisable and foolhardy. Or perhaps Bilbo’s plan just happens to be consistent with what Thorin would have done anyway.“Dáin, send your forces to the North and intercept the orc army there. The Men and Elves will have to hold this side of the Mountain along with my company. Dwalin, you will accompany us to Ravenhill. Defend Bilbo with your life.”
Bilbo glares at Dwalin. “Don’t you dare listen to him. Prioritize Thorin’s safety above mine.”
“I would have done anyway,” Dwalin promises. At least Bilbo isn’t the only one here with any sense.
“You are being ridiculous,” Thorin complains.
“No, you are,” is Bilbo’s clever retort. “I’m wearing mithril armor, Thorin. I’ll be fine. You, on the other hand—“
“Mithril?” Dáin seems to find this so amusing that he stops in the middle of killing an orc to laugh at it. Fíli has to finish the kill and keep Dáin from meeting his end mid-guffaw. “Mahal below, Thorin, you really are in love!”
“What are our orders, Uncle?” The situation must be dire indeed, if Kíli is the one to steer it back on track.
“Defend the mountain,” Thorin’s smile melts. “Return to it if necessary.”
“What?” Kíli doesn’t seem to like this very much. “You can’t be serious! You’re going to face Azog and Bolg alone?”
“Not alone,” Bilbo cuts in, “I’ll be with him, and Dwalin, too.”
“You would leave your two best warriors behind?” Fíli asks incredulously.
“He’s taking me with him,” Dwalin points out. “And we are the two best warriors in the company.”
“That’s preposterous,” Kíli protests, “Fíli and I are going with you.”
“Very—“
Before Thorin can finish allowing this, Bilbo puts his hairy foot down. “No. No, absolutely not. I’m not leading you two lads into a trap.”
Something tugs at his stomach. They would fare better with more warriors, and he is already taking Thorin back to Ravenhill against his better judgment. Besides, they will have the protection of Dáin’s entire army. Thorin must be there to kill Azog. Nobody else could do it, and Bilbo is dimly aware that it would be an insult to Thorin’s honor were anyone else to steal what he views as his kill. But there is no reason for Fíli and Kíli to risk themselves.
“We are sons of Durin,” Kíli points out, “And this is our battle to fight.”
“If the trap is intended for us, then we should be the ones to spring it,” Fíli reasons, “All three of us.”
“And Tauriel will be there, won’t she?” Kíli adds. “She’s been tracking those orcs. She won’t flee from them now. I would be honored to fight by her side.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “Does no one in this family have any self-preservation instincts to speak of?”
But he does, reluctantly, see the point. The lads would consider it dishonorable not to join the fight, and, now that Bilbo thinks about it, there’s no guarantee that the party will reach Ravenhill without the help of Fíli and Kíli. Besides, they will need an archer to cover them, and though the most logical move would be to protect the heir to the throne, even Bilbo is not naive enough to believe that the brothers would willingly be separated. Regardless, they are wasting time standing around and arguing. Bilbo can only hope that he has influenced things enough to keep the lads safe on Ravenhill. “Fine. Let’s get going, then. We don’t have time to lose.”
They set out for Ravenhill, the five of them, at a pace that Bilbo can barely match. “Dwalin will carry you,” Thorin decides, and it is difficult to determine who is most upset about this prospect.
“You can’t be serious!” Dwalin protests. “How am I supposed to swing an axe with a Hobbit on my back?”
“I hardly need to be carried,” Bilbo grumbles. “I can run perfectly fine. The lads have seen it.”
“He outran us once,” Kíli pipes in helpfully. “Which is practically unheard of.” He takes a moment to shoot his final arrow at a lunging goblin. He curses in Khuzdul. “Keep an eye out for arrows, will you?”
“Aye,” Fíli seems to understand what his brother is talking about, at least.
Bilbo may vomit. His legs are sore, but he can’t stop running, regardless of where he happens to be running to. His guts are swimming. They are running to Ravenhill, the very place where Thorin, Fíli, and Kíli were slain. Bilbo is leading them to their graves, but he sees no other choice. Bolg and Azog must be slain, and none of Bilbo’s stubborn friends would listen if he tries to persuade them to return to their Mountain and be safe.
“Thorin,” Bilbo pants, “Please tell me that your plan is not to run up Ravenhill on foot!”
“My plan was for Dwalin to carry you up Ravenhill,” Thorin grumbles. “Since I know you would not be parted from me even to save your own life.” It’s clear he disapproves of this, and would rather see Bilbo safe inside the Mountain, as well.
“You are not going to sulk at me in the middle of a battle, Thorin Oakenshield!” Bilbo scolds, watching with appreciation as Thorin takes out three orcs at once with that impressive sword of his.
“So you are allowed to be as contrary as you wish, but I must bend to your whims?”
“Contrary? Next time, perhaps I’ll keep my information to myself and see how you fare.” That’s a much lower blow than Thorin knows, but in Bilbo’s defense, he is near the point of losing consciousness from physical exertion and the cocktail of emotions brewing in his guts.
“Thank you for your input, General. When we have Erebor restored, I will be sure to make you my chief guard.” Thorin pauses to allow Bilbo to slash the legs of an oncoming orc before continuing. “Apologies to Dwalin; you are obviously better suited to the post.”
Before they can continue bickering, all further discussion is prevented by a loud whistle. Bilbo whips his head around and sees that Balin has commandeered some sort of goat-drawn cart from some of Dáin’s forces. Why they brought a cart into a battle, Bilbo has no idea, but he is glad of it now. “Oh, brilliant,” he breathes. He grabs Thorin’s hand and begins dragging the king in the direction of the cart.
Halfway there, he hears Thorin cry out, and when Bilbo looks back he sees that his beloved has an arrow sticking out of his arm. Despite the fact that all the blood in Bilbo’s veins has turned to jelly, he manages to keep running and help Thorin onto the cart. Dwalin joins them quickly, and the princes clamber up after him. Bilbo notes that Kíli’s quiver is mysteriously full of arrows again, though some of them appear to have seen better days. But Bilbo is too concerned about Thorin’s obvious injury to spend too long imagining the lads picking through the carnage for arrows to re-use.
“Right,” he says to Balin, “First things first, let’s find Óin. Second, we go to Ravenhill.”
Dwalin snorts. “We don’t need Óin for this, laddie. It barely broke the skin.”
“I am not injured,” Thorin declares, as if he does not have an arrow sticking out of his arm.
“I’ll be the judge of that,” says Bilbo, leaning over to examine the wound. “You’re bleeding.”
The cart begins to move, but Thorin pays it no mind. “That tends to happen when one is shot with an arrow.”
“So you admit that you are injured. Good. That’s progress. Let’s find somewhere safe for you to recover, and then the lads and Dwalin and I—“
“I will not sit this battle out,” Thorin growls. “You would have to saw off my legs, and even then, I would crawl forth trailing blood to challenge Azog.”
“There’s nowhere safe to put him, anyway,” Balin yells over the din of the battle.
Bilbo exhales heavily before taking his last remaining handkerchief out of his pocket. Thank Yavanna he had the sense to wash it when he was being held hostage. Thank Yavanna that Bard was generous enough to allow Bilbo to do so.
He does not bother asking Balin where the wounded are kept, because he has his own wounded to deal with. Thorin has already yanked the arrow out, and the fact that the blood is oozing rather than spurting is a promising sign that the wound is shallow. The cloth of Thorin’s tunic is torn, and it seems the arrow managed to pierce through a gap in his armor, but was stopped from puncturing the flesh any deeper by the hard metal.
“I wish I had something proper to clean it with,” Bilbo complains. Then he remembers the last of his handkerchiefs, which, thankfully, he had washed in Lake-town and then entirely forgotten about in all of the hubbub surrounding the Arkenstone and the hostage negotiation. Bilbo withdraws the little square of cloth from his pocket and uses it to bind Thorin’s wound.
“Your last handkerchief?” Thorin asks, incredulous for reasons which escape Bilbo entirely.
“Yes,” Bilbo confirms, “Now, hold still.”
Dwalin examines the arrow for a moment before tossing it aside and redirecting his focus to the weapon he has lately acquired. The cart they have stolen (perhaps not stolen; it is of Dwarven make, after all, and was likely handed over to Balin by its original drivers, assuming they’ve survived) is equipped to shoot bolts from two small canons mounted on either side.“Could be worse. Goblin make; no poison.”
“You see? I am not poisoned.” Thorin latches onto this news immediately. He tries to stand, as though he thinks that Bilbo will allow him to hang out the side of the cart, slashing at orcs with that ridiculous oversized sword. “I am fine and will continue fighting.”
Of course, things can never be simple for this company. They plow through rows of orcs. Dwalin and the boys fire bolts from either side of the cart while Bilbo tends to his king. It takes no small degree of glaring and muttering on all sides, but Thorin does eventually acquiesce to the gentle treatment.
Bilbo binds Thorin’s wound to his satisfaction and is pleased to see that there is little serious damage. Still, his heartbeat has yet to return to normal. He is uncomfortably aware that Thorin may very well die in a matter of minutes, that Bilbo’s intervention may not have been enough. At least this time, Bilbo will die with him. Rather than spend the next eight decades braving social isolation and ridicule in the Shire, for all his lonesome happiness, Bilbo will pass the time in the afterlife, atoning for his failure to resolve matters. Not that Thorin will expect much penance.
“Here, Uncle, you’ll make that worse,” Fíli uses one of his two swords to gesture at Thorin’s injury, “Trying to swing that great big sword around. Trade?” He removes the other sword from its scabbard and holds them both out to his uncle.
“Fine,” Thorin concedes. Bilbo does not know whether to be pleased that Thorin has acknowledged his injury or horrified that Thorin plans to rush into battle with a wound that is apparently so great as to necessitate a switch to a lighter weapon. “But do not damage the blade. That sword is a relic from Khazâd-dum and very precious to our family.”
Typical. Bilbo shakes his head. Before he can make some snide comment about the utter ridiculousness of worrying about the impressive history of one’s weapon in the midst of battle, a great troll lumbers into their path. Bilbo squeezes Thorin’s hand, more to stop his lover from attempting to challenge the beast one-handed than to comfort himself, and braces himself as Balin steers the cart roughly onto a frozen river. Yes, because the wisest course of action is to test the ice with the weight of a cave troll, adapted by some occult means to the daylight.
Kíli and Dwalin yell for a moment about how to kill the troll. Bilbo does not know if this happened before. He hopes that it did, and that his friends survived it the last time, but of course, he cannot very well ask them. He knows that his presence has thrown things off balance. Even if Thorin took an arrow to the shoulder before, Bilbo knows for certain that he is the only thing stopping His Majesty from hopping onto one of the goats and attempting to fight the blasted troll on his own.
“Hang on lads, I’m coming!” Is that Bofur’s voice?
Yes. It is. Bilbo does not know how Bofur has managed to commandeer the reigns of yet another troll, but he sits atop its head, pulling at the chains that apparently relate to the movement of the monster’s limbs. Bilbo watches as his friend manipulates his troll into attacking the other, knocking it out of play.
“Bofur, you beauty!” Fíli screams at the top of his lungs, before the cart turns a corner and their friend is out of sight. Bilbo must physically restrain Thorin from trying to help as Dwalin takes out another troll with his bolts and Balin steers the cart over the monster’s corpse.
“I think they have it well in hand,” Bilbo murmurs.
“I should be helping,” Thorin grumbles, “I will not sit here and do nothing while my kin fight my battles for me.”
“You are healing,” Bilbo protests, “And besides, you’re in no position to fight.”
“Let us guard you for a few moments more, uncle,” Fíli agrees, winking at Bilbo.
“Like Mister Boggins says, we have it well in hand.” Kíli is very good at feigning confidence, apparently, joking around in the midst of battle.
Their path is blocked by wargs. Bilbo winces as the beasts take out a few of their goats. He squeezes Thorin’s hand a little too tightly as the animals bleat in pain. Thorin mutters something in Khuzdul, though it is difficult to tell from his tone whether he is comforting Bilbo or cursing the Hobbit for keeping him from the fight.
“We’re pulling too much weight,” Dwalin says to his brother. Ah. Yet one more problem that is entirely Bilbo’s fault. Perhaps this happened the last time, but they were able to make it past this point because the Hobbit was absent. But now he has added weight to the cart, prevented Thorin from fighting, and mucked everything up, if only in a novel way.
“Cut the tracers,” Balin says. “Ride them to Ravenhill.”
“No, Balin.”
“My goat riding days are over,” Balin smiles. “Durin be with you, brother.”
“If only I could say my goat-riding days were over as well,” Bilbo grumbles, but he doesn’t have much say in the matter. His head spins trying to follow the swordplay taking place. In all honesty, Bilbo’s heart stops in his chest for a moment, watching Fíli walk across the ropes that bind the goats to the cart, swinging his sword as he goes. Bilbo knows that this is a battle, and that the lad is a trained warrior, but that does not make Bilbo any more comfortable with the sight.
Still, the prince eventually settles onto the back of a goat, and his brother follows suit. Dwalin joins them, and before Bilbo can protest, Thorin is tossing him onto the back of another goat (that can’t be good for his shoulder) before jumping on behind him and cutting the tracer that tethers the goat to the cart. Bilbo offers a sympathetic pat to the animal that must now carry their combined weight through a battle, but he knows better than to try and argue with Thorin about it at this juncture.
Once they get higher than the wargs can climb, things become much simpler. No orcs hinder them, because why would they? This is a trap deliberately set to give Azog the satisfaction of wiping out the line of Durin. Although, Dáin yet lives as he commands his troops below, but perhaps Azog expected him to come rushing forth as well. Or, perhaps the pale orc lives only for carnage and does not care who springs the trap that he has set.
Regardless, they make it up the hill without any further injury. Or, at least, nothing serious. They’re all a bit scratched-up, and Bilbo suspects that there are more than a few bruises lurking underneath all that terrible armor. “I need you to know that I love you,” Bilbo tells Thorin just as they reach the top. He doesn’t know why he says it now. “In case things go badly…”
“Things will not go badly,” Thorin assures him. For a moment, Bilbo thinks he’s lying to himself and everyone else yet again, but the king continues. “If we are killed, we will be reunited in the service of Mahal, where we will work together for eternity. Though, of course, I love you more than ever I had thought to love another being.”
“Are we certain that Mahal lets Hobbits in?” Bilbo asks as the goat bearing them slows to a stop. No orcs are yet visible.
“Perhaps not all Hobbits, but you were made as my companion, and I was made as yours,” Thorin explains in a low tone into Bilbo’s ear. “We will be together in the next life, as in this one. The Maker and his Lady would never be so cruel as to keep us apart.”
Nobody says anything about how Thorin appears to be making up lore as he goes along. It’s not as though there’s any precedent, and even if there were, Thorin would not know how the couple fared in the afterlife. He is alive now, and for that, Bilbo is infinitely grateful. “Well, I suppose it doesn’t matter.” For the second time today, Bilbo is lifted off of an animal’s back and set with ceremony on the ground. “We’re not going to find out.”
“I thought you said there would be orcs here.” Kíli looks around, apparently finding no threats.
“There are,” Bilbo gestures toward the large rock structure at the crest of the hill. “In that tower, no doubt, waiting for us. Didn’t you see them on our ride?” But of course he didn’t. Kíli was at bit busy defending Bilbo and Thorin while the Hobbit saw to the king’s wound. He would not have been paying attention to what was happening upon Ravenhill.
“Of course,” Thorin agrees, “They expect us to send one or two to check the structure over.”
“Mhm,” Fíli hums thoughtfully, “And if Dáin had not intercepted their army, they would send troops to distract those left outside. Then they would isolate whoever went inside the watchtower. Probably make a big show of the execution.”
“It doesn’t matter what they would do.” If Fíli knows all that, then why did he go into the tower in the first place? Oh. Because his king ordered him to do it. Because had he not gone, had he not been the one to forge ahead and spring the trap, it could just as easily have been Kíli. Bilbo keeps hearing the sound of Fíli’s bones breaking, over and over again, the lad’s pained scream echoing in his mind. That will not happen again. Bilbo will die before he lets it happen again. “Nobody is going in there. Agreed?”
“If they want us, they’ll have to fight us on our terms,” Kíli declares.
“And they will not win easily.” Dwalin is ready with his axe.
The five of them stand in a circle. Thorin, annoyingly, keeps trying to shove Bilbo behind him. “Please don’t be ridiculous,” Bilbo warns. “I’m armed and I’m fighting beside you. That’s that, so we’ll hear no more about it.”
“I will not allow you to be killed on my account.”
Bilbo rolls his eyes. “I’m wearing mithril armor, Thorin. If anything, I should be shielding you.” But he reaches out to squeeze the hand of his beloved. There is no point in arguing, but if it becomes necessary, then it goes without saying that Bilbo will put himself between Thorin and any approaching threat.
Everything will be fine. Bilbo’s head feels packed with cotton and his guts have turned to water and he keeps having to look beside him to make sure that Thorin is still alive, but other than that, everything is going to be perfectly alright. And if not, Bilbo will find Lady Galadriel and beg her to send him back again. He would fight the trolls a hundred times, riddle with Gollum over and over, and spend a thousand years imprisoned by Wood Elves if it means keeping his family safe.
A scraping sound behind Bilbo causes him to jump, but before he can react properly, Kíli exclaims, “Tauriel!” Oh. Good. The Elves are here, then.
“Thank the Valar we are not too late.” Bilbo turns to see Tauriel rushing to Kíli’s side. Fíli makes room in the circle for her to slide between the two princes. “Legolas and I came as fast as we could when we learned what the orcs were plotting.” As promised, the Elven prince climbs onto the hill after her.
“Why would you come?” Thorin demands, not even turning to look at her. “Why do you care? This is not your fight.”
“I would not see a friend slaughtered,” Tauriel cuts him off. “Nor would I allow any orc to triumph in battle if I could help it. We have been tracking this pack for weeks, Your Majesty. Did you really think we’d let up now, just because you got here first?”
“We’ll take the extra swords,” Dwalin decides. “You four can sort out the courtship later on.”
“I intend to save my sword for that, as well,” Legolas snipes. He has a bit more trouble shoving into the circle, but eventually finds his place between Bilbo and Kíli. It is probably for the best that Thorin cannot reach him, as Bilbo does not put it past the king to lash out. Especially considering that Legolas is currently wielding Orcrist, which glows the same faint blue as Sting.
“Less talking of courtship, and more killing of orcs, if you please!” Bilbo is perhaps the only one who understands the gravity of this situation.
“There are no orcs to kill,” Fíli reminds him. “Or none that I can see.”
“They’ll come,” Bilbo is certain of this.
In fact, they do come, after only a few moments of waiting. Apparently, Azog gets sick of waiting for Thorin to send scouts into the watchtower and sends a few of his own soldiers out. They are joined by stragglers from the orc host that Dáin’s forces have engaged. Their numbers are not as great as before, but they still occupy the seven fighters well enough. Their circle falls to pieces in no time, but Bilbo sticks close to Thorin. He knows that his absence would become a distraction, and anyway, Tauriel can defend the princes if it comes to that.
Bilbo is too distracted slashing at orcs to pay much attention to anybody else’s fighting. Flashes of auburn inform him of Tauriel’s quick movements, and he is dimly aware when Legolas leaves his side. The circle is broken quickly, which is likely what their enemies wish to happen. Still, aside from Bilbo, everyone here is a trained warrior, well accustomed to fighting in or out of a prescribed formation.
He is perpetually aware of Thorin’s position, and he watches his intended destroy orc after orc in quick succession, even with a wounded arm. Thorin fights with both of Fíli’s swords, but he favors his left arm slightly. Bilbo, then, establishes himself on Thorin’s left and does his best to compensate for any weakness there. This is how the battle passes until Bolg and Azog arrive.
“Oakenshield,” Azog greets Thorin, paying no mind to any of the rest of them. “Have you come to be slaughtered? Your filthy bloodline shall end today.”
Thorin laughs darkly at this. “A hundred years hence, my heirs will spit upon this ground as a place forever tainted by your blood, and that of your fell kin.”
Bilbo refuses to think about why this quick comment did not come to Thorin the last time. He refuses to remember the horror of watching Fíli fall. Of knowing that he was too late to prevent the trap from being sprung, that his young friend would never again laugh beside a campfire or stomp across anybody’s dinner table.
He finds himself glancing away, just for a moment, just to make certain that the princes still live. Kíli has climbed atop a boulder and takes advantage of the added height, firing arrow after arrow at their enemies. Tauriel flits around, engaging orcs with her twin knives. Fíli swings his massive sword around, and Bilbo hopes that the lad is not at a disadvantage for his lack of practice with the blade. Dwalin stands close by, making it clear that he has practice aplenty with that axe. Bilbo searches frantically for Legolas, but cannot find him.
“Your heirs will die first,” Azog decides, reclaiming Bilbo’s attention. “And then your…” he utters a word in his own tongue which Bilbo does not understand, but assumes is probably some slur against Hobbits, or else some rude reference to Bilbo in particular. Regardless, he is the intended target. “And then, once you have watched them all suffer, I will slay you slowly.”
He waves his sword arm, and Bolg steps toward Fíli. But Legolas is already there, leaping down from the side of the watch tower and moving in front of the prince to engage the great orc. It would, perhaps, be better if he did so with any weapon other than Orcrist, but that shall be a conversation to have after the battle.
“You’re not stealing our kill,” Kíli protests, knocking an arrow and aiming at Bolg. He is distracted by another orc approaching his boulder. He redirects the arrow and shoots the enemy at close range between the eyes.
Legolas mutters something that Bilbo does not catch. Fíli pivots, slashing at another approaching orc with his heirloom blade, and suddenly, it seems, the fight has begun anew. Bilbo catches sight of Tauriel leaping up to kick Bolg in the back of the head before he turns to focus on his own fight. The fight that has been brewing inside him for eighty years, the fight that has haunted his nightmares and dogged his every step since the first Battle of the Five Armies.
Azog advances toward Thorin, and Bilbo sees red once more. He is not aware of his own actions as he steps in front of the king. “Stay back,” he warns, as if Azog will be deterred by a single Hobbit wielding a short blade. “Do not touch him.”
This sentiment is not new, but all Bilbo can see is Thorin’s lifeless body on that stone slab, blood on the ice, the poor lads, Dwalin’s shaky hands, Tauriel’s tears, the Eagles’ descent a moment too late, blue eyes staring at nothing. This will not happen again. Bilbo will not allow it to happen again. He will drive Sting into Azog’s gut and watch with as the foul creature dies painfully. He will saw off the head and stomp on the face and spit on the corpse to avenge those he loves, those who have been murdered by this foul beast.
“What are you doing?” Thorin demands, trying to step around Bilbo. “Get behind me!”
But the Hobbit blocks him. Bilbo screams and charges at the orc, who only watches, in shock or amusement or some combination thereof. Bilbo gets one good stab in, but perhaps it’s in the wrong place, because Azog is still standing, and Bilbo cannot pull his sword out. The orc probably knew that there was no point in fighting off the little Hobbit. Or perhaps he did not believe that Bilbo would actually attack him. Perhaps the orc is simply too slow to process events, though he more than makes up for that shortcoming with his bulk.
There is a scream in the distance, one Bilbo has heard before, in Lake-town, on the first adventure. His blood chills. Kíli. Just for a moment, he glances away again, and sees the prince laying upon the ground, his sword tossed out of his reach and his empty quiver thrown even farther. His bow is broken, and an orc stands over him, curved blade raised. Kíli’s chest heaves with ragged breaths, which means that he is yet alive. From the looks of it, he was thrown from the boulder and is now too injured to flee or seek out his weapons.
Legolas bounds over and tackles the orc, saving Kíli. Good. Bilbo turns to face his opponent again, having lost any advantage he may have had in the element of surprise. Azog is aware of Bilbo’s weakness, his momentary distraction, and he has gathered himself. He is no longer shocked at the sight of a Hobbit charging toward him, and why would he be, when he has seen it once before? And Bilbo has given him long enough to ascertain that Sting will not kill him. Azog does not even bother to pluck the blade from his side.
Before Bilbo can scramble out of the way, Azog hits him across the stomach with the blade arm and enough force to send the Hobbit flying. He hits the stone wall of the watchtower and groans, but evidently, he is still alive. He may not be able to get up quite yet, but if he were dead, he would surely not be in so very much pain. His head, thank Yavanna, has not taken any impact. Bilbo is propped up against the wall, just enough to get a good look at the fighting behind him.
“Bilbo!” To hear the way that Thorin screams his name, though, Bilbo may as well have just been killed.
“Mithril,” he manages to say, “Wearing mithril.” Bilbo will not die today. He cannot. If this mithril shirt could protect Frodo from a similar attack by a cave troll twice Azog’s size, then it stands to reason, too, that Bilbo will recover in good time.
But Thorin does not seem to hear him, does not seem aware of the advancing orc at all. Azog walks slowly, apparently relishing in the sight of Thorin’s devastation. The other orcs do not touch him. Those not distracted by the fight with the rest of their company have clearly been ordered to leave Thorin to Azog, which is both a blessing and a curse in this terrible moment. The king rushes to Bilbo’s side, turning his back on his enemy.
“What are you thinking?” Bilbo demands. “Turn around. Turn around and fight.”
Disjointed footsteps sound, and he can see Kíli approaching over the king’s shoulder, ready to attack Azog. He must have heaved himself up somehow. No, he did not heave himself up; someone helped him. It is not hard to see who, based on the blade in his hand. Legolas has given him Orcrist.
Why would Legolas give up Orcrist? Something is wrong with Kíli’s run, his gait thrown askew, and his face is twisted in a grimace of pain. His injury is plainly slowing him down. He will not reach them in time. Tauriel and Dwalin are distracted fighting Bolg, though they appear to be winning. Fíli takes care of the other orc soldiers. Even if Kíli gets there before Azog kills Thorin, he will only be a momentary distraction. He is not as skilled with the sword as the orc is, and he is wounded already. There is nobody near enough to help him, save for Thorin.
“Thorin, please!” Bilbo begs. “You must fight. Turn around and fight!”
But Thorin is busy checking him over for injuries, pressing against Bilbo’s sides with trembling hands as though to staunch some imaginary bleeding. He is breathing heavily, as senseless as he was in Erebor. And he will die for it.
The orc that Fíli has been fighting collapses to the ground, and the lad meets Bilbo’s eyes across the battle. He cannot possibly get there quickly enough, cannot use his cumbersome blade to intercept the pale orc. Does he have throwing knives left? Bilbo doubts it. Plenty of these were used on the way to the Mountain, and anyway, he does not think that Fíli is in any position to rummage around in his boots for a spare blade.
This is a terrible predicament to be in. Thorin is entirely without sense, hovering over Bilbo. Azog is approaching. Kíli, one of the best archers among them, will be forced to fight the pale orc at close range, if he gets there in time. He lost a sword fight to Bolg the last time even with Tauriel’s help, and Azog is larger and more skilled, and Kíli is alone, or he will be, and Fíli is too far away to help, while the others cannot extricate themselves from their own fights. Azog raises his blade.
“Thorin,” Bilbo breathes, “Thorin, please. You must—“
Something comes flying through the air. For a moment, Bilbo thinks it is a burst of light, some magic, perhaps conjured by the Wizard. Yes, Gandalf should be here to clean up the mess that he made by sending them all on this adventure in the first place. He has seen this before, he remembers dimly, in the visions given to him by the Lady Galadriel. Not that this helps Bilbo any in determining what the sight before him means.
But then the ball of light hits Azog in the head, proving its own solidity with a resounding thud, like an uncuttable stone, like the heart of a mountain. The orc absorbs the force of the hit, the sort of force produced by a strong Dwarven arm. Bilbo is dimly aware of a harsh, determined battle cry, a wordless yell and the sound of disjointed footsteps pounding against the cold ground. Azog sways for a moment, apparently dizzy, and swoons, stumbling backwards right onto Kíli’s sword.
If the orc wasn’t dead when the stone hit him, the prince makes sure of it by releasing the weapon, stepping to the side and allowing Azog’s great weight to do the work of burying the blade. Even the pale orc cannot survive two swords boring into him, one in the side and one in the back. And all of this after what must have been a major head injury by what is probably the hardest stone to ever exist. Well. That’s step four out of the way, then. If Azog is dead, he won’t be bothering Thorin or the lads any time soon.
Kíli collapses with apparent exhaustion the moment his enemy is slain. His brother rushes to his side, sword raised. Bilbo can rest easy knowing that Fíli is there to protect them all from those few surviving orcs. Thorin still seems unaware of his surroundings, and Bilbo is not any more likely to rouse himself to rejoin the fighting than Kíli is, at this point.
“By the Valar,” Legolas cries. He is slumped against the boulder, clutching at his side where a knife has been lodged. Oh. That is why he gave up Orcrist, why he did not take on Azog himself. The run may very well have killed him. There are only five or six enemies left, of which Tauriel and Dwalin make quick work. It seems that Dáin has done his part, after all, because no more orcs appear to be forthcoming. “I would not have thought that possible. I would not believe it, had not I seen it with my own eyes.” He murmurs something else in shocked Sindarin, Westron apparently failing him in his pain and shock.
“What happened?” Thorin asks, eyes wide with confusion and awe. He brushes Bilbo’s face with a gentle hand, as though he cannot believe that the Hobbit is breathing. In his frantic, overprotective state, he must have forgotten all about the mithril. Silly. So silly.
Besides, it is obvious what just happened. All of the pieces have fallen into place for Bilbo, and he is beyond proud. Yes, Kíli just killed Azog the Defiler, which would be a cause for celebration under any circumstances. But this would not be possible had Fíli not made the greatest sacrifice that any Son of Durin could make. Legolas’s awe is perfectly explicable; Bilbo feels it too, and he knows that Thorin will be equally gobsmacked when he hears what has taken place.
Bilbo does not have the presence of mind to say anything very elaborate. He is tired, and he is bruised, and he has barely recovered from the knowledge that his beloved was about to die in his arms for the second time. He can be forgiven if he is not so eloquent as he would be on any other day. “Your heir just used the Arkenstone as a projectile weapon.”
