Actions

Work Header

Everything is fine.

Chapter 4: Two gays vs the heteronormative agenda.

Chapter Text

Chapter 4 – Two gays vs the heteronormative agenda.

0-

There were quite a few issues with paradise. One being that soulmates all seemed to be romantic. The first (and only) time Billy and Robin suggested their relationship was platonic, the couple beside them had gasped like they’d admitted to murder, and Brenner appeared from the shadows with malicious concern in his gaze.

They’d tried to be less obvious, sat beside each other in public, awkwardly held hands when everyone else did, and tried their best to cuddle during the weekly ‘drive-in movie night’ experience. It wasn’t the best, and the idea of doing this for eternity was their own personal hell, but they’d agreed to stick it out with each other.

“Heather, huh?” Billy asked as they awkwardly laid in the same bed.

Robin’s flinty glare was obvious despite the darkness. “Steve, huh?”

They did not talk about it.

 

1-

Tina, who used to be a marriage counsellor, was the first to notice their awkwardness and offered her services. It was interesting, although Billy would never say it out loud, that paradise had a marriage counsellor. But, if you were stuck with the same person for eternity, no matter how perfect you were for each other, counselling was probably recommended.

Neither Robin or Billy wanted counselling, but Brenner, who still materialised from nowhere at the slightest hint they weren’t doing things the proper way, had stepped up and agreed on their behalf.

So, now they sat on a sofa that was unfortunately reminiscent of their own, knees touching at Tina’s request as she scrutinised them over her desk. There was a photo of her soulmate, Tammy Thompson, on her desk, smiling beguilingly out at them.

When they’d entered, Robin’s eyes had flicked between Tina and Tammy’s photo, jealousy and longing and fear flashing across her face. Billy squashed the familiar pang of guilt and avoided Tina’s gaze as her crystal blue eyes swept across them.

Billy didn’t understand. He’d thought, half-heartedly and in the shadows of night, that Neil was correct, that faggots and dykes and all other queers couldn’t be in heaven. That he was here by mistake, or as punishment, but he couldn’t understand why Robin was here. Or why they were sitting on a sofa facing a woman who had another woman as a soulmate.

“Brenner has told me that you two might be having problems,” Tina’s fingers were laced together as she spoke in a calm, condescending voice.

“That’s none of Brenner’s business,” Robin snapped.

Tammy had thrown her off; she was as confused and scared as Billy. He wondered faintly why she’d let him in so quickly. Why she hadn’t marched straight up to Brenner and told him there was no possible way Billy could be her soulmate.

“Unfortunately, it is,” Tina said serenely. There was an oddness about her, the same oddness that encompassed Brenner. Like she didn’t quite fit right. “You see, as the creator of this neighbourhood, it is his responsibility to maintain the livelihood of the community. To make sure everything functions how it’s supposed to.” Something cold flicked in her eyes but it was gone almost as quickly. “If something goes wrong, the consequences could be catastrophic. Plus,” she softened her entire body, almost on cue, “soulmates can often seem too perfect. We always have to remember; we are ultimately human here.”

“How do you determine soulmates?”

It came out before he could fully understand what he was asking. But he needed to know, for Robin.

Tina smiled like she was waiting for them to ask. A screen emerged behind her, and funky music began to play as the title card ‘So, You’re Soulmate Feels Wrong’ appeared on screen. A petite blonde girl, face sweet like an angel stepped out.

“Hiya, I’m Chrissy and my role in the Good Place institution is to work with neighbourhood architects to determine each residents’ soulmate. Now, what is a soulmate?” Billy felt he was back in school, watching his classmates group projects. “A soulmate,” Chrissy continued, “is the one person on earth specifically meant for you. This might seem improbable, impossible even, but in the grand scheme of the universe, it makes perfect sense.” She seemed proud of herself.

“Now, at the beginning of your time in the Good Place, it can be confusing and disorientating. Maybe you had a partner on earth, maybe a family, someone you thought was the one. And now you’ve woken up with someone new for you and that can be confusing. Just know, there are no mistakes. Your soulmate is your soulmate for a reason, your missing piece, the other half of your soul. And all you need to do is try.”

The screen flicked off, and Tina turned to them once again. “It can be confusing at first, but you’ll soon learn how to live with each other, and then eternity will feel like nothing when you’re with each other.” She stroked a finger along Tammy’s cheek.

Billy and Robin made eye contact when she was distracted, confusion and grief on Robin’s face presumably mirrored on Billy’s own.

Whatever mistake had brought him here had truly replaced Robin’s soulmate. Maybe a conglomerate of bad listings had replaced someone with him and implemented someone else’s life as his. Maybe Robin’s soulmate was a sexy lesbian being tortured for eternity due to a clerical error. Maybe Billy should tell Robin that, but the fear that she’d hand him over, the fear of darkness and fire and pain and Neil Hargrove kept him quiet.

Robin turned back to Tina like she already knew. “What about platonic soulmates?”

“Platonic?” It fell from Tina’s mouth like a slur.

“Soulmates who aren’t romantically involved,” Robin prompted.

Tina stared, and stared, and stared, like she couldn’t even comprehend what was being asked. “Why would you not be in love with your soulmate?”

“I said platonic. You can still be in love with your soulmate, without romantic feelings.”

Tina’s face turned an alarming shade of red and her voice cracked like a whip in the cool silence of the room. “Platonic soulmates do not exist. The universe does not make mistakes.”

They didn’t mention platonic soulmates for the rest of the session. Tina ended by asking them not to come back again.

 

2-

They received a booklet for free couple massages in their post-box, which didn’t make much sense, considering that the economy was non-existent. Robin flipped through it like a mystery book, oddly fascinated by the heterosexual erotic displays.

“She’s secretly gay,” she said, showing him a double-page spread of a man and a woman in a steamy room, the woman’s head seemingly looking anywhere but at her partner’s naked body.

“He has a foot fetish,” Billy contributed, pointing to another page, where a man was getting a foot massage from his partner, neck rolling back in ecstasy.

Once the glee wore off, they tossed the booklet down the side of the couch and forgot about it until Heather and Jonathan came to visit. Robin and Heather sat side by side on the ugly couch, knees and heads pressed together, talking in low voices like they were the only people in the universe.

Billy and Jonathan hovered on the fringes, and Billy startled when Jonathan nodded at Heather and Robin with a knowing glance. The other man was quiet, an intensity to him that melted into an odd casualness. Like he knew too much and couldn’t be bothered by the implications.

Before Billy could ask, Jonathan suddenly bent down and picked up the discarded booklet. He flipped through it, face blank except a faint eyebrow twitch that could mean a myriad of things. But it was Heather who plucked it from his hands and held it out to Robin.

“We got one of these,” she said.

“Oh, um, I – uh…” Robin stammered in response.

“We should do it.” Heather then turned to Billy and Jonathan. “We should all go.”

Billy and Robin exchanged looks and there was something pleading in her eyes. Reluctantly, he agreed.

As expected, it was incredibly awkward and practically unbearable. There was a ‘double trouble’ package which resulted in Billy and Jonathan, shirtless, hands sticky with oil, rubbing Robin and Heather’s backs as they continued to gaze at each other like they were alone in the universe.

At one point, when Billy was trying to get a knot out in the centre of Robin’s back, Steve and Nancy passed by. Steve looked in and when they looked eyes, an odd sense of shame flashed through him.

“Keep going,” Robin mumbled, eyes lidded. “I can do you next.”

“That’s alright.” When he looked up, Steve was gone. Heather stared though, something like relief shining up at him.

 

3-

“Welcome to the first annual Soulmate Showdown!” Brenner stood on stage, black suit specked with faint, translucent sparkles, microphone in hand. “The chosen couples will answer a series of questions to see which soulmate duo know each other best!”

It sounded like they had an option to sign up. Billy and Robin did not. Brenner was at their door that morning, presenting them with ‘invitations’ and not-so-subtly hinting they were participating whether they liked it or not.

So, when the time came, they dawned their fancy clothes once more, the same ones they wore to Steve’s party the week before. Robin kept fluffing her hair in the mirror, the action uncharacteristic for her. Billy waited impatiently behind her, also wanting to fluff his hair.

“What kind of questions do you think they’ll ask?” Robin asked, looking at him through the mirror’s reflection.

“Probably things about our lives on earth,” Billy said after a moment of thought, nudging her out the way so he could do his hair. There was a curl that wouldn’t lie flat. He tried to flatten it, and it sprung out again, coiled like a spring.

Robin sighed and said worriedly, “But what if it’s questions about your fake life?”

“Then I guess we lose.”

Turned out neither Billy nor Robin liked to lose. Especially when Steve and Nancy stood on one side of the podium, Tammy and Tina beside them.

“Robin, which church did Billy frequent as a child?”

Robin stared. “Um…” She glanced at Billy who was no help because he didn’t even know the name of the church he actually used to go to. “The Catholic one?”

Brenner laughed heartily like she’d made a terrific joke. “I’ll give you a half-point for the correct denomination. The correct answer was St Mary’s Catholic Church for the Disadvantaged.”

“Oh, of course.” Robin replied.

“Of course,” Billy echoed, trying to sound like he knew that all along.

Brenner looked at him then, and Billy had the sudden thought that the man (Deity? God? Unknowable entity?) already knew. That now he was trying to catch Billy and Robin out, to see how far the charade would go.

“Nancy,” Brenner turned away, “what was the Harrington net worth?”

As Nancy answered with unwavering confidence, Billy watched Steve flinch at the question. It made him ponder, for a moment, the nature of the Good Place. Steve’s family seemed to have a large fortune, and it seemed like they didn’t do much with it. Why was Steve in the Good Place?

Why was Robin? Nancy? Tina?

“Billy,” Brenner said, cutting off his thoughts, “what was the name of Robin’s first boyfriend?”

Robin went rigid beside him and Billy clenched his hands beneath the podium to stop himself from vaulting over and attacking Brenner. He had to think, wondered how deep this odd sexuality coverup went. They never looked at Robin’s memories of earth, finding it a violation, especially when his were all fake.

“Vick,” he announced, nails digging into the flesh of his palms. “His name was Vick.”

Her name was Vickie; she had been Robin’s first and only girlfriend. They’d been on a break when Robin was killed by a man on a motorbike. It wasn’t clear if it was an accident or a malicious attack, but Robin had closed her eyes on the cold, wet sidewalk and opened them in the Good Place. She missed Vickie, of course, but there was no way she’d ever see her again. Vickie had a lot more life left to live.

“Correct.”

It seemed to hurt him to get the word out. Maybe Brenner expected Billy to trip up or hesitate so he could poke and prod and expose his own mistake.

But that also meant that Brenner did know that Billy and Robin couldn’t be soulmates. If Vick was Robin’s first boyfriend, there was a record somewhere.

“We might need to watch some of your memories after this,” he murmured, watching as Tina and Tammy laughed in exaggerated joy at their win.

“Sure.”

Steve and Nancy walked over as the audience in the clearing below dispersed.

“That was intense, huh?” Steve said, running a hand through his perfectly coiffed hair. “I’m surprised we did that well.” Nancy scoffed and Steve glared at her.

“Yeah,” Billy agreed, eyes drawn to the stray strand of hair that was now blowing in the faint breeze, “but Tina and Tammy were on another level.”

“At least you both got a question right,” Nancy spat, turning on her feet and storming away. Jonathan slipped from the sparse audience and trailed after her.

Steve didn’t turn to watch her, staring at Billy’s face. “You have freckles,” he said, a finger tracing the bridge of Billy’s nose. “I’ve never noticed before.”

“Neither have I.” Robin’s voice was dry, and she too walked away, with a smug smile tugging at her lips.

Steve’s thumb stroked across Billy’s cheek, a gentle swipe which sank beneath the skin, settled against the bones. Then Steve blinked and came back to himself, taking a quick step back and clearing his throat.

“I’m surprised you got every question wrong,” Billy told him before Steve could say anything.

A frown crossed his lips. Billy resisted the urge to lean forward and kiss it away. “We don’t really talk much about before.”

“At all?”

Steve shrugged self-consciously, “Nancy wants to focus on the now, I guess?”

“But she’s still upset?”

Smiling wryly, Steve leant forward and mock-whispered, “She said soulmates should just know this stuff.”

His eyes were bright up close, light reflecting like the moon in a deep night sky. “I don’t think that’s true,” he whispered, leaning close.

Steve’s eyes crinkled, eyelashes fanning against his cheeks. “I think the universe works in mysterious ways.”

Billy was beginning to think so too.