Actions

Work Header

Everything is fine.

Chapter 5: Steve's Perfect Paradise

Chapter Text

Chapter 5 – Steve’s perfect paradise.

Steve’s death was stupid. Because he was stupid. Because Tommy was five drinks deep and Steve was drunk on tequila when Tommy dared him to jump into the Quarry.

“Bet you’ll die,” Tommy said, arm around a giggling Carol who was barely aware of her surroundings.

Steve did another shot of tequila. “Prepare to eat your words.”

Then he leapt into the black, plunging depths of Hawkins Quarry. There was no false body. No Upside Down. No telepathic girl to lift him from the darkness. Just Steve, stupid and dumb, wind in his hair, alcohol in his veins, falling to his death.

At least it didn’t hurt.


Nancy Wheeler was exactly who Steve expected to be his soulmate. The girl his parents had demanded he find in life, who finally came to him death. She was smart and strong, precisely like he predicted. They moved into their eternal home, a mansion bigger than the Harrington household, with a large garden and a fountain and a driveway despite there being no cars.

It was paradise, the life he’d been expected to have, and now he could have it without the annoying life things that destroyed his parents’ marriage, like jobs and money and affairs. If everyone had a soulmate, then no one would be disappointed.

But Nancy didn’t seem to like this life like Steve did. She would walk the halls of the big house, staring at the portraits of her and Steve, together in a way they’d never truly been.

Sure, Steve thought it was weird that they were there when they moved in, but it was a symbol of their love! Proof they were soulmates!

But he inevitably covered them at Nancy’s request, their odd, false faces behind deep, red velvet. A strange secret to keep, in a paradise like this.

And despite their soulmate connection, Nancy did not want to sleep in the same bed.

“I just want to be by myself right now. You understand, don’t you Steve?”

He didn’t but he let her drift away every night to her cozy room by the library, and he walked to the master bedroom where the bed was too big for one person and there was an odd draft that had him shivering through the night.

They spent the days together, doing things Nancy wanted to do. It wasn’t that Steve didn’t want to do them, and he enjoyed spending time with Nancy, but the thought of spending eternity at poetry readings and writing circles didn’t sit right. But it was what Nancy wanted to do, and all Steve wanted was to be with Nancy.

One day, Brenner came by.

“We’ve settled the last resident into his forever home, and I was wondering if you’d like to throw a little neighbourhood party? You know, for some neighbourhood bonding?”

Nancy seemed decidedly uncaring about it, but Steve wanted to talk to some other people. To fill the empty house with more than two people, at least for the night. At his agreement, the mansion itself glowed with delight, the candles lighting themselves and the drapes covering the portraits fell in a smooth down sweep.

Steve wrote the invitations himself, debating whether to sign them with Mr and Mrs Harrington. But something told him Nancy wouldn’t like that, so he scrawled his signature reminiscent of his father and pretended he was happy with what he had.

How selfish of him, to want more from paradise. To want more from soulmates and afterlife and eternity.

(“Why did you and dad stay together for so long?”

“He was comfortable and safe. I knew where I stood.”

“But you weren’t happy?”

“Happiness comes in many forms. It can be difficult to chase pure happiness. I’d settle for comfort, Steve, rather than a fleeting feeling that doesn’t know how to stay.”)

He wondered when his mother swapped comfort for fleeting happiness, when she decided the chase was worth it. When she decided to walk out on him and her life to follow an artist to France. Steve didn’t know if the happiness stayed, if she settled into a familiar complacently like before, or if she left once more, chasing another happiness.

Steve, back when he was alive and bitter, swore he’d never chase those moments, once he had a safe life. The party was in full swing, people laughing and talking, full of a joy only paradise could bring, and Steve stood with a glass of fake alcohol, watching Nancy talk to other people, never once glancing at him.

For a moment, he wondered what it was like for her, to stand so far from him without fearing he would disappear. Because, when Steve looked away from Nancy Wheeler, he dreaded, so fierce and strong, that she wouldn’t be there when he turned back.

Just as he made to cross the room to pull Nancy away from the guy with shaggy hair, a glimpse of blond so blinding sent him stumbling. He scrubbed a hand across his eyes. There across the hall, entering through the large doors was a man with a gorgeous head of blond hair. Even from where Steve stood, he could see the curls, the faint quirk to his lips, the way he pressed his hand gently to the woman’s back (that’s his soulmate Steve, what are you looking at?).

The music swelled and Steve crossed the room, leaving Nancy without a second thought. The man stood in the corner, an awkward hunch to his shoulders as he surveyed the room with a glass in his hand. He startled as Steve made himself known, a faint blush spreading quickly across his cheeks.

Steve found himself enthralled. “I’ve never seen you around.”

The man seemed distinctly unimpressed. “I moved in this morning.”

Made sense, Steve definitely would’ve noticed him around town.

“Of course,” he breathed, eyes still fixed on him.

His eyes were bright and blue.

He asked about his soulmate, trying to gauge how attached the man was to her (what are you doing, Steve? You have a soulmate. You are in paradise.) She was at the banquet table, piling a plate with food beyond what was socially acceptable, and Steve tried to stop his nose wrinkling in disgust.

Yet, the man walked away. Steve made to follow him, but soon, too soon, she returned, staring at Steve with similarly blue eyes, calculating and wary.

Suddenly, the room felt cold and dreary. Steve turned, swallowing something bitter as he tried to find Nancy once again. She was still talking to the shaggy-haired man, face lit up in a delight Steve had never brought out from her.

An ugly, vicious emotion welled from his chest, slipping across his face as he came up to them. The other man’s eyes widened, he took a step back with a stammered, “Nice to meet you, Nancy,” and slipped back into the crowd, hopefully to find his soulmate.

“Steve.” Nancy crossed her arms and raised an eyebrow. “You interrupted an important conversation.”

“Couldn’t have been that important,” Steve mumbled, staring back across the room, eyes drawn like a moth to a flame to the blond hair through the crowd. “He didn’t seem very interesting.”

“I thought he was interesting.”

“That man,” he pointed at the blond, “you know his name?”

She appraised him with her cool brown eyes. They softened at times, when they looked at him. But they’d never lit up with joy or laughter or lust when they were on him, just a look you’d give a child when they played pretend.

“Billy Hargrove,” she answered, turning away. “He moved into the neighbourhood this morning. He’s Robin’s soulmate.”

“Billy,” Steve said to himself. The name sounded right on his tongue. “Billy.”

The music switched to something slower. People gestured to soulmates and soon the dancefloor was full of waltzing partners, enthralled with each other, like they were in a paradise. From the corner of his eye, Steve saw Nancy slip away, wondering faintly if she’d left before he could ask her to dance.

Billy’s soulmate, Robin, was twirled onto the dance floor by an unknown woman. Steve crossed the space without a second thought, sidling up to Billy once again.

“Can I have this dance?” he whispered, scared all at once of this strange forwardness.

Billy turned in surprise, face so close to Steve’s that he could see his own reflection in those blue eyes. Everything was warm, blooming like a summer’s day.

“What?” Billy asked.

Steve laughed.

“Can I have this dance?”

Billy’s waist was warm beneath his hands, soft with flesh and a solid backing of muscle. He never wanted to let go, wanted Billy closer and closer until they were entwined.

(What is happening to you Steve? Where is this nonsense coming from?)

“What about your wife?” Billy’s lips were shining from his drink, tinged pink and moving distractingly.

Steve stopped himself from looking for her then, afraid of being caught. Doing what, he wasn’t sure, but a gut feeling told him Nancy wouldn’t be happy with any answer.

“Nancy?”

“Yes. Your soulmate.”

Steve smiled, finding the frustrated pout oddly cute. “She’s around.”

He took the pause to start swaying with the music, pulling Billy with him. The other man didn’t seem to notice as the music swelled once more, and the crowd began to move.

“How long have you been here?”

“Like, four days,” Steve replied.

A stray curl fell against Billy’s forehead, dancing softly as they moved. Nancy never liked it when Steve tried to do anything gentle with her, always batting him away with ‘I can do it myself!’. If he tucked the curl behind Billy’s ear, would everything come crumbling back down.

“Your soulmate,” Steve whispered in his ear. “Where is she?”

Was Billy like him? With someone who might be wrong for him?  

Billy snorted against his shoulder. His breath was warm and moist. Steve shivered, told himself it was the heat.

“Dancing. What’s it to you?”

“Just can’t believe she’d leave you by yourself.”

She’d been stuck to his side since they walked through the door, and yet, when the most romantic aspect of the evening started, she disappeared.

If you were my soulmate, he wanted to say, I would never let you go.

They turned in time to the beat, turning and turning with a melody like a whisper brushing against their ears. He saw Nancy, for a moment, back in her corner, still talking, not a hint of bother at where Steve was. If he kissed Billy right now, would she even care?

Then Billy ripped himself from his grasp. The room went cold, quiet, a faint ringing in Steve’s ears that muffled everything but Billy as he said, “I literally don’t know you. I know her. I trust her. Leave me out of whatever this weird regency roleplay you and your soulmate have going on.”

“No,” Steve murmured. Told himself Billy was wrong. But Nancy still hadn’t looked his way, and the music changed to something faster and Robin spun into their conversation, flushed and vibrant.

And Billy no longer looked at him, eyes fixed firmly on his soulmate. They started to leave; Billy’s arm wrapped around Robin’s waist like it belonged there. Steve remained where he was, couples spinning around him like puppets on oblivious strings.

Soon after, the party dispersed. Steve had downed four drinks in that time. Now he was slumped over the empty glasses, where if he was self-aware, in a position reminiscent of his own father. Nancy fluttered around the room bidding farewell, lingering by the man from earlier and his soulmate, who seemed to have appeared from nowhere.

“You can’t pull a face like that when your own party is ending,” she told him, plucking the drink from his hand and placing it on the table, where it vanished instantaneously.

“I can if I didn’t have fun.”

Nancy quirked an unimpressed eyebrow. “Didn’t seem like that to me. You seemed to enjoy dancing with that man.”

“So, you did notice.” He scowled at his hands.

“Did I notice my soulmate spending the entire night following another man around the room? Of course I did, Steve.”

“You didn’t do anything.”

She rolled her eyes. “Why should I? It didn’t bother me.”

“Why?”

How was she okay with that, when the sight of her talking to someone else had sent Steve into a spiral?

“Because you’re my soulmate,” Nancy replied simply. “I know at the end of the day, it will be you and me.”

Steve wasn’t sure if he believed her. There was a routine to their lives, despite the few days they’d spent together. They woke up in their own beds, safe in the knowledge the other was down the hall, safe in the knowledge they had a soulmate.

Maybe it wasn’t the paradise, maybe it wasn’t soulmates or Nancy. Maybe the problem was Steve. Maybe paradise couldn’t be handed to you and expected to stay the same. (When he blinked, Billy was there, behind his eyes, blond and blinding and real.)

Maybe Steve was exactly like his mother, because there was a taste on his tongue sweet, like happiness, and he wanted to chase it into eternity.