Chapter Text
Chapter 6 – Here in eternity, damnation looms.
Robin kissed a girl on screen, and nothing made sense anymore. Billy just couldn’t comprehend what was happening, why they were being lied to. To their faces as well.
Beside him, Robin rewound her memories, watching as she lunged across the table in the diner to kiss Vickie. Her eyes were soft and heavy as she watched, shadowed by sadness. It was an odd feeling, to grieve your own death, to not know if you were the only one to do so.
To grieve what you could’ve lived, if only you had more time.
He left her there, rewinding her life over and over. Told himself he was glad he couldn’t do the same (wondered if somewhere, out in the great expanse, was a memory of his mom).
The house seemed cold now, like this revelation broke through a barrier that held up the façade. That all the colours and warmth and joy they felt for a moment were built by the hands of a liar, for a purpose still unknown.
It went to the bathroom and tried to splash his face with water, but it was scalding as it came from the tap. The shower water was freezing cold as he stepped into it, the wooden floorboards now left splinters in his bare feet, the towel kept falling from the hook and the shampoo seemed to run out immediately.
Later, Billy emerged from the shower, trembling like a baby, mind still unclear, to find Brenner standing in the lounge. The screen was dark, and Robin hovered before it, face reminiscent of a child trying not to be caught.
“Ah, Billy,” Brenner said, smiling. There was an obvious fakeness to it now; it didn’t meet the cold in his eyes. It twitched into a sneer before pulling back. “I was hoping to see you.”
“You are in my house,” Billy responded, dry.
“Well,” the other said, “that’s by the by. Let’s talk about your sermon.”
“Let’s not.”
“Well, as I’ve said many times already, the Good Place is here to allow each person to reach their potential, to do the things that will bring them bliss forever more. And I do believe that this is your purpose.”
“And if it’s not?”
Brenner bared his teeth in a vague resemblance of a smile. “You’ll never know if you don’t try.” With a pointed look around the room, he left, calling behind him, “See you Sunday!”
“I don’t even know why we still have weekdays,” Robin said, settling back down on the couch. She patted the space beside her and Billy fell into it, folding in on himself. Her hand brushed his hair in soothing motions as they stared at the black screen.
“I don’t understand what he’s getting from this.” His reflection looked exhausted. Leave it to Billy Hargrove to be drained in heaven. “Do you think we’re being paranoid, or taking all this for granted? I mean, we’re in the Good Place, heaven, paradise, and here we are, complaining it isn’t exactly what we expected.”
“Because paradise was promised to us.”
The house seemed to struggle with what it should be doing, brightening like the sun had risen before dimming in quick succession. It fluctuated between a cozy, loved home and a dreary unrenovated house. Before their eyes, static appeared on the screen before it started to play fake-Billy’s memories, speeding through them faster and faster until it stopped. Rewound. Started to play at a normal speed.
The other him stood in front of an enthralled congregation, shouting about fire and brimstone and other hellish entities. “And if we continue to live a life rich in sin, the heavenly gates before us will not open. There will be no paradise, no eternal reward, for you will not deserve it. All that awaits the sinner is fire and ash and suffering so unfathomable only the devil himself could come up with it.”
“What’s the point of preaching in the afterlife?” he pondered. “The entire point of religion is to try and get to whatever concept of heaven you believe in, whatever eternal reward your God promised. But we’re here now. What’s the incentive? What’s to stop people from sinning now? Unless the Good Place/ Bad Place dynamic isn’t as static as presented.”
“You think if someone does something wrong, they’ll be sent to the Bad Place?”
“Makes sense.” Billy could feel the excitement coursing through him now. “Eternity is a long time for a person to be good in an unchanging place. If the weather remains the same, the seasons, the neighbourhood stuck in a pastoral limbo, what’s to stop someone from pushing at the boundaries. I don’t know about you, but being stuck here forever sounds boring.”
“So, you hate me.” Her laughter was sweet, then she said seriously, “If he’s making you do a sermon anyway, maybe you should talk about that.”
“What else would you say? God and heaven don’t seem to be real, and they seem to be the two big components of religion.”
“Morality and ethics.”
“What everyone loves to think about on a Sunday morning.”
The most pressing moral and ethical question on his mind was fundamentally; could he be attracted to someone who had a soulmate? Was Billy’s presence in the neighbourhood upsetting the balance of other soulmates as well?
Because he could not stop thinking of Steve Harrington. His large, gentle hands. His kind eyes. Even out and about, Billy found himself peering over people in search of Steve and his large hair.
Sometimes they saw each other. Steve would light up if he was alone, arm waving over heads. If Nancy was there, Steve would smile at Billy but always angled his body to face Nancy, like a compass pointing north. Nancy never extended Steve the same grace, always walking ahead, always talking over him, always so sure in herself that it was recognisable from metres away.
There were moments when Billy swore Steve would come to him. Convinced he’d be weaving his way through the crowds to catch Billy in quick conversation, but Steve stayed away. Billy pretended it didn’t bother him.
Sometimes, when he wanted to indulges in his imagination, Billy told himself that him and Robin being soulmates had put everyone into mismatches. That in another paradise, Billy would’ve woken up and been introduced to Steve. Then he would be satisfied.
But those fantasies were locked firmly away. They were not allowed to fester more than they already had. Billy might’ve been a mean person in life, but he wouldn’t be cruel enough to rip someone’s paradise away on a presumption.
(And yet.)
Brenner skulked, sending reminders to Billy everyday leading up to his passion fulfilment day. Someone pasted posters around town, advertising his sermon like it was the answer to everything.
Find bliss in eternal happiness, the slogan read.
People Billy couldn’t remember were coming up with excited grins, grasping his hands and thanking him for the service. “I haven’t done it yet,” he told one woman, who laughed so loudly she startled a bird from a tree.
There was a religious fervour unleashed, crosses appeared on walls like they’d always been there, and the café only played hymns. No one else seemed bothered by it, going on their merry way like it was a normal everyday occurrence.
Robin refused to go to the café. She was twitchier, looking over her shoulder and jumping at shadows. Guilt was a constant companion for Billy when he watched her, contemplating time and time again how he managed to ruin her afterlife in a matter of minutes.
Then, before he knew it, the day had come. It was bright and beautiful, like a filter over a photograph. The birdsong sang sweetly on a looping sound Billy couldn’t unhear.
There was an outfit in his closet, the familiar black gown of a preacher with the white collar and vestments. Billy refused to touch it, spending minutes staring at it, trying to beg his hands to move and yet they didn’t. He couldn’t do it.
Instead, he pulled on the familiar red shirt, unbuttoned the top few buttons enough so his necklace was visible. He pulled on the skinniest jeans imaginable and decided he didn’t quite care anymore. Brenner would have to admit he knew Billy was a mistake in front of everyone if he didn’t want Billy like that.
Pretending didn’t seem as important anymore.
A knock at the door.
Robin made no move from the couch to answer. Billy sauntered over instead, opening the door and finding Steve on the other side. Steve, who couldn’t keep his eyes off Billy’s bare chest.
“Hey,” Billy said, casual as ever.
Steve’s eyes finally moved to meet his. “Hi. Just came to wish you luck for the sermon. But I guess you aren’t ready yet?”
“No, I’m ready.” Billy shrugged and leant against the doorframe with a smirk. Steve’s eyes tried to not look down but didn’t quite make it. Something hummed in Billy like a satisfied cat stretching languidly in the sun. “Want to come with me?”
“What about your soulmate?” Steve said. He tacked on, “Robin,” to prove he knew her name.
“She’s coming later.” He wasn’t sure she was coming at all.
Steve agreed, moved his arm like he was going to hold it out for Billy to take, but took a step back. Billy followed with one last glance at Robin. The air was thick with sweet citrus, and the sun beat down on them like it was the height of summer. Further down the path, where it split off either to Steve’s house, the lake or the town, Heather appeared, walking in the opposite direction.
“Your sermon’s soon, isn’t it?” She cocked an eyebrow and looked him up and down in amusement.
“All ready,” he said, waving a hand at his outfit.
She laughed. It softened the sharper edges of her face. “Brenner won’t like that.”
Confident in what he knew about her, he said, “He shouldn’t have made me do this then.”
Appraising him, Heather’s eyes flicked back to Steve who was hovering at the edge. “Afterwards, you should come round mine. I think we need to talk.”
“I don’t know where you live.”
She pointed at the lake, where a boathouse was tied to the dock. “I live in a boat.” She did not look happy about this.
“It’s a nice boat,” Steve offered.
“How many bedrooms do you have?” Heather asked. She turned back to Billy before Steve could respond. “My house. After. Jonathan won’t be there.” Steve scowled as she winked and continued along the path.
If Billy turned around, he would’ve seen Heather turn on the opposite path to the lake, up his own driveway and through his door. Steve saw and Steve pondered, and Steve decided something that would change everything.
Practically the entire neighbourhood was at the church, a thronging crowd like a mass of ants, scrambling and pushing. Steve stood in front and shoved his way through like he was Billy’s bodyguard, physically bodychecking a woman when she reached out to touch Billy. Like he was something holy.
Brenner was waiting by the large oak doors, a brass key the length of Billy’s palm on his belt. As Billy stepped up the stairs, Steve trailing behind still forcing people back, Brenner clapped Billy on the shoulder like he was his son.
“You ready?”
Billy wanted to smack him.
He took the proffered key. It fit into the lock and opened the door with a heavy thud. Inside, the church was beautiful, like the inside of a storybook. The stained glass shone a myriad kaleidoscopic sunrays on the grey stone floor. The pews were a deep black wood and the pulpit matched.
Behind him, the crowd surged, barrelling over Steve like a wave. He fell into Billy, sending them both stumbling. Billy hit his chin on a pew, but the pain faded quickly. When he stood, everyone was seated, facing forward with passive faces.
Steve stood, shaking his head in disbelief. Brenner was at the pulpit already, beckoning Billy forward. Suddenly, Billy was deeply, deeply afraid. Without thinking, he reached behind him, grasping for Steve’s hand. He felt Steve’s fingers slip between his and squeezed gratefully.
In his dreams, Billy was in a church like this, in a suit and tie. Max was there, hair glowing red in the candlelight and his mom walked him down the aisle, light haloing her like an angel. Steve was waiting for him at the end, hair brushed and beaming so brightly that Billy can’t look at anything else. In his dreams, Billy took Steve’s hands, turned to the priest and woke up.
This was nothing like Billy’s dreams. He felt like he was walking to his doom. The candles flickered as he passed, but no one turned to face him. Their placid faces didn’t move; empty smiles plastered on their faces.
As he stepped up to the lectern, where the Bible waited for him, Billy swallowed down rising vomit and turned to face the congregation, still holding hands with Steve. They stared up at him with blank eyes, and in one movement, they all opened their bibles.
Amen. Amen. Amen. Amen.
It echoed and echoed, crawling over his skin, slipping into his bloodstream. Billy placed a trembling hand on the book, tracing the words he vaguely remembered from a life that now seemed so long ago.
“Don’t,” Steve muttered, grip tight.
“I have to,” Billy said. He felt like crying.
Because he never told Robin the letter Brenner sent him. The letter with the word Vickie in thick, black marker. Names were written and then erased but when he held it up to the light, he could make out the scrawled words. Steve and Heather and Nancy and Jonathan.
When he read it, he believed it was a test, maybe the final test, but one none the less. And if he failed, Billy wouldn’t go to the Bad Place, but those four names, written so faintly, would. But the hours he’d spent pacing, a slow, slinking realisation settled in his bones.
He never managed to put it to words before.
He tried to say quietly, so only Steve could hear, “I don’t think this is the Good Place.”
Steve tried to let go of his hand, but Billy clung on. The people before him, Tina and Tammy and Andy and Jason and Edith and all the others that Billy realised were not real, waited.
“When do we stop sinning?” he asked, voice ringing loud. “When have we earned our place in heaven? Does it end with our time on Earth?”
Amen. Amen. Amen.
“What makes heaven, heaven? What makes hell, hell? How are neighbourhoods created? How are points calculated?” He was asking all the questions that had built within him over the last days (Weeks? Months?). “Do they stop? Or are they still going? If they’ve stopped, what’s to stop us from doing bad things?”
Unable to help himself, he turned to Brenner. “I don’t think we’re in the Good Place.”
“Where are you then?” The man asked coldly.
“Purgatory.”
Amen. Amen. Amen.
Brenner’s smile was pleased. It didn’t make Billy feel better. He pulled Steve close and inhaled, letting the faint scent of oranges soothe him.
The congregation rose as one, hands open in prayer, but the words they said were garbled. The candles went out, one by one, until they were standing in darkness. The stretch of colours from the windows formed a figure and Billy wondered when Jesus began to look like the devil.
“Thank you for today, Billy. I’ve learnt a lot.”
“If you send them to the Bad Place, you’ll have to send me too. I’ll commit as many sins as needed to get there.”
“Go home, Billy.” Brenner said.
Steve pulled him from the building, arm around Billy’s trembling waist. The world seemed stifling.
“You’re crying,” Steve said. He pulled to a stop and turned Billy to him, cupping his face and wiping the tears away with his thumbs. “I don’t understand what really happened in there, but I think I got enough. This isn’t the Good Place?”
“No…” Billy sobbed and lunged into Steve’s arms. The tears weren’t stopping, and he didn’t know what to do.
“How did you know?”
“Because I’m here.”
“And I’m here.”
Billy looked at him through the tears. “What’s that supposed to mean?”
“I don’t think I’m a great person, either,” Steve smiled sheepishly.
“I was so mean to my sister,” Billy said.
“I was a bully,” Steve responded.
“I was so angry at my dad and she was there,” Billy continued.
“I was an insecure little shit, and I needed other people to feel that way too.”
“I slashed his tires once.”
“I used to steal money from my parents.”
“Sometimes, I hate my mom.”
“So do I.”
“I was such an asshole to all my friends.”
“I was a brat.”
“My dad beat me.”
Steve kissed him then, quick and desperate and so warm. Billy pulled him closer, hands gripping the thick locks that had been taunting him for ages. It was slick and hungry and everything he wanted, everything he hoped and dreamed.
Maybe he was wrong. Maybe this was the Good Place after all.
